O R D E R
(Delivered on 18/10/ 2012 ) Per M.C. Garg, J. :
Present petition has been filed by the petitioner under section 482 of Cr.P.C with a prayer that the investigation of FIR no. 06/2009 dated 12thFebruary, 2009 registered at EOW, ( Indore Branch ) be transferred to the Central Bureau of
2
Investigation ( In short ' C.B.I. ')
2 The aforesaid FIR was registered by the Indore Office of EOW Cell after carrying out preliminary investigation on the complaint filed by the petitioner alleging irregularity in granting sanction to construct a commercial building at plot no. 11, M.G. Road, Indore completely in violation of the then prevailing master plan, which provided the use of the plot only for residential purpose with 1.5 FAR. According to the petitioner, in this case, the permission was granted for constructing commercial building with 2.5 FAR contrary to the then prevailing master plan as also contrary to section 23(A) of Nagar Tatha Gram Nivesh Adhiniyam, 1973 under the active connivance and instructions of influential persons namely the then Chief Minister, the then Chief Secretary, the then Minister, the then Chairman of M.P. Housing Board and other senior officers who were responsible for the conspiracy to get Kalani brothers benefited with crores of rupees and to cause huge loss to state government.
3 The petitioner filed a complaint before EOW, Bhopal, which was registered as complaint no. 262/2008 at Indore Office of EOW, Cell. It was investigated by Mr. Arun Jain, the then Dy.S.P. During preliminary investigation, a prima facie case was found to have been made out against the accused persons namely Manish Kalani, Prem Kalani, Padma Kalani, Ashwin Janwade, Rakesh Sharma, V.P. Kulshrestha, Chandraprabhash Shekhar, U. K. Samal, D.P. Tiwari, as also against Mr. A.V. Singh, the then Chief Secretary, M.P. Govt. Rakesh Chaturvedi, the then minister of environment as well as
3
Mr. Digvijay Singh, the then Chief Minister of the State of M.P. under section 13(1)(d) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act read with section 420, 467, 468, 471 and 120-B of IPC. Accordingly, FIR bearing no. 06/2009 was registered. All the aforesaid persons have been arrayed as respondent nos 5 to 16 in this petition requesting for transfer of further investigation of the case to Central Bureau of Investigation.
4 Conclusion drawn by Mr. Arun Kumar Jain finds mention in the FIR, which are as follows. :
Jh izse dkWykuh fuoklh 11 ,e0 th0 jksM bankSj ds vkoklh; Hkw[kaM dks okf.kT;dh; mi;ksx gsrq mikarj dh dk;Zokgh esa rRdkyhu e0iz0 'kklu ds ofj"B inkf/kdkjh] x`g fuekZ.k eaMy ds v/;{k uxj rFkk xzke fuos'k ,oa uxj fuxe bankSj ds lacaf/kr vf/kdkfj;ksa us bankSj fodkl ;kstuk ds Lohd`r ekLVj Iyku ds foijhr vkoklh; Hkw[k.M dks okf.kfT;d mi;ksx esa fu;e ,oa izko/kku ds foijhr dk;Zokgh dhA bl ;kstuk dk fooj.k bl izdkj gS fd& ,e0th0 jksM bankSj jhxy Vkdht ls iykfl;k pkSjkgk rd banksj uxj ds ekLVj Iyku esa vkoklh; {ks= gS] mDr jksM ij Hkou dzekad&11 rqdksxat esujksM bankSj Jh izse dkyksuh ds Hkou dk mi;ksx bankSj uxj ds ekLVj Iyku 1975&1991 ds vuqlkj vkoklh; gS vkSj ,Q0,0vkj0 dsoy 1-5 fu/kkZfjr gS] mDr Hkwfe ij dkyksuh cznlZ dh esllZ baVjVsuesaV oYMZ MsOgyilZ fyfeVsM bankSj ds }kjk e/;izns'k x`g fuekZ.k eaMy ds lkFk la;qDr midze gsrq vkoklh; ifjlj ,dhd`r vkeksn izeksn dasnz] ikfjokfjd euksjatu dsanz] eYVhIysDl ,oa 'kkWfiax eky dh ,d ;kstuk gsrq vkosnu rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h Jh fnfXot; flag ds le{k izLrqr fd;k ftUgksaus fnukaWd 11-9-02 esa vius gLrk{kj ls Jh euh"k dkWykuh ds fjQszUl ,oa eq[;
4
lfpo dks ß Iyht ,Dtkfeu fnl ,.M fMLdl ß dk uksV vius gLrk{kj ntZ dj uhps HkstkA bl i= ij dksM oMZ ,Dl&299 ntZ gSA rRi'pkr rRdkyhu eq[; lfpo ds dk;kZy; ls i=kpkj lacaf/kr foHkkxksa esa fd;k x;k vkSj le; ij Vhi izkIr ugha gksus ij muds }kjk izeq[k lfpo vkokl ,oa i;kZoj.k foHkkx dks dk;Zokgh gsrq uksV'khV o rRi'pkr Lej.k i= HkstsA mijksDr dk;Zokgh ds rkjrE; esa e0iz0 x̀g fuekZ.k eaMy ds v/;{k Jh panzizHkk"k 'ks[kj }kjk fnukaWd 2-6-03 dks vius gLrk{kj ls dkyksuh cznlZ dh mDr tehu dk Hkw&mi;ksx ifjorZu dh dk;Zokgh fd;s tkus dh uksV'khV vk;qDr ,oa izeq[k lfpo vkokl ,oa i;kZoj.k foHkkx dks HksthA
fnukaWd 21-5-03 dks e/;izns'k x`g fuekZ.k eaMy e0iz0 esllZ baVjVsuesaV oYMZ MsOgyilZ fyfeVsM bankSj ds Mk;jsDVj rFkk Jh euh"k dkWykuh vkfn ds chp ,e0vks0;w0 lEikfnr fd;k x;k ftlesa e0iz0 x`g fuekZ.k eaMy dks 52 izfr'kr 'ks;lZ fn;s tkus dk ys[k fd;k x;kA ;g ;kstuk tc e0iz0 x̀g fuekZ.k eaMy ds lkFk la;qDr midze ds :i esa gqbZ rks 'kklu Lrj ij bl ;kstuk ds Hkw&mi;ksx mikarj.k dh dk;Zokgh vkfn dh tkdj ;kstuk ds lQy fdz;kUo;u esa vkbZ leLr oS/kkfud :dkoVksa dks nwj djrs gq, ;kstuk iw.kZ gqbZ] ftlesa 'kklu dh Hkkxhnkjh ds fcuk ;g fdz;kUo;u laHko ugha FkkA 'kklu esa ekStwn vf/kdkfj;ksa ds }kjk Hkw mikarj.k ,oa lajpuk gsrq uD'ks vkfn esa Hkkjh voS/kkfud dke Hkh fd;s x;s bankSj uxj fuxe }kjk mBkbZ xbZ oS/kkfud xaHkhj vkifRr;ksa dks utj vankt fd;k x;k vkSj izk:i uxj fodkl ;kstuk bankSj dh dwVjfpr vkM+ ysdj Hkwfe ds mi;ksx dks 30 ehVj xgjkbZ rFkk O;olkf;d fd;s tkus ds vkns'k Jh ;w0ds0 lkey us ikfjr dj rRdkyhu ea=h vkokl ,oa i;kZoj.k] eq[; lfpo o rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h dh Lohd`fr yh tcfd
5
,salh dksbZ uxj fodkl ;kstuk dk izk:i vfLrRo esa gh ugha Fkh Fkk ijUrq jkti= dh vf/klwpuk dwVjfpr ,oa vlR; cukdj iwjs Hkw[kaM ,d yk[k oxZQhV dk Hkw mi;ksx okf.kfT;d djus dh foKfIr izdkf'kr dh xbZ ckn esa fuekZ.k vuqKk Hkh ,Q0,0vkj0 1-5 ds ctk; 2-5 dh ns nhA tc ;g ;kstuk iw.kZ gksdj 'kklu dks ykHk nsus dh fLFkfr esa vk xbZ rks vpkud e0iz0 x̀0fu0eaMy ds v/;{k Jh panzizHkk"k 'ks[kj Lo;a ds }kjk vius gLRkk{kj ls uksV'khV fnukWad 25-11-03 fy[k dj la;qDr midze dh daiuh ls e0iz0 x`0fu0eaMy dks vyx djus dk i= fnukaWd 25-11-03 fy[kk x;kA
mijksDrkuqlkj fnukaWd 25-11-03 dks tc e0iz0 x`g fuekZ.k eaMy ds v/;{k Jh panzizHkk"k 'ks[kj }kjk ,e0vks0;w0 fujLr djus dh uksV'khDV fy[kdj i= tkjh dj fn;k mlds i'pkr fnukaWd 2-12-03 dh vf/klwpuk tkjh gksuk laHko ugha Fkk ;g vius vki esa Li"V gS fd mijksDr fnukaWd 25-11-03 dks dh xbZ dk;Zokgh ckn ds fnukaWdksa esa dh tkdj fjdkMZ ij iqjkuh rkjh[k esa ntZ n'kkZdj vk;qDr e0iz0 x̀g fuekZ.k eaMy dks Hksth xbZ] ftl ij vk;qDr Jh jk?kopanzk us fnukaWd 8-12-03 dks mijksDr izLrko ij dh oS/kkfudrk] eaMy fgr bR;kfn dh tkudkjh ds laca/k esa viuh Vhi ys[k dh xbZA
mijksDr tkap esa vk;s nLrkosth lk{; ds vk/kkj ij vkjksihx.k 1& euh"k dkWykuh] 11 ,eth jksM bankSj 2 izse dkykuh] 11 ,eth jksM bankSj 3 Jhefr inek dkykuh 4 vf'ou tuons rRdk0 lgk;d ;a=h
uxjikfyd fuxe bankSj 5 jkds'k 'kekZ rRdk0 lgk;d ;a=h uxjikfyd fuxe bankSj 5 Ogh0ih0 dqyJs"B rRdk0 la;qDr lapkyd uxj rFkk xzke fuos'k bankSj 7 panzizHkk"k 'ks[kj rRdk0 v/;{k e0iz0 x̀g fuekZ.k eaMy Hkksiky 8 ;w0ds0 lkey rRdk0 izeq[k lfpo e0iz0 'kklu vkokl ,oa i;kZokl 9 Mh0ih0 frokjh lfpo
6
vkokl ,oa i;kZokl rRdk0 vk;qDr lg lapkyd uxj rFkk xzke fuos'k Hkksiky 10 ,0Ogh0flag rRdk0 eq[; lfpo e0iz0 'kklu 11 Jh jkds'k prqosZnh rRdk0 i;kZoj.k ea=h e0iz0 'kklu Hkksiky 12 Jh fnfXot; flag rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h e0iz0 'kklu Hkksiky ds fo:) vijk/k /kkjk 420] 467] 468] 471] 120ch Hkk0 na0 fo0 ,oa 13 ¼1½ ¼Mh½] 13 ¼2½ Hkz"Vkpkj fuokj.k vf/kfu;e 1988 ds ik;s tkus ls vkjksihx.k ds fo:) vijk/k lnj iathc) dj foospuk esa fy;k x;kA
5 The FIR show that permission to construct commercial building on plot no. 11, M.G. Road Indore was contrary to the then prevailing master plan, 1975 - 1991, which provide user of the property only for residential purposes with FAR of 1.5 and also in violation of 23(A) of M.P. Nagar Tarha Gram Nivesh Adhiniyam, 1973 which reads as under :
23-A. Modification of Development plan or Zoning plan by State Government in certain circumstances- (1) (a) The State Government may, on its own motion or on the request of a Town and Country Development Authority, make modification in the development plan or the zoning plan for any proposed project of the Government of India or the State Government and its enterprises or for any proposed project related to development of the State or for implementing a scheme of a Town and Country Development Authority and the modification so made in the
7
development plan or zoning plan shall be an integral part of the revised development plan or zoning plan.
(b) The State Government may, on an application from any person or an association of persons for modification of development plan or zoning plan for the purpose of undertaking an activity or scheme which is considered by the State Government or the Director, on the advice of the Committee constituted by the State Government for this purpose, to be beneficial to the society, make such modification in the development plan or zoning plan as may be deemed necessary in the circumstances of the case and the modification so made in the development plan or zoning plan shall be an integral part of the revised development plan or zoning plan.
(2) The State Government shall publish the draft of modified plan together with a notice of the preparation of the draft modified plan and the place or places where the copies may be inspected, continuously for two days in such two daily newspapers which are in the approved list of Government for advertisement purpose having circulation in the area to which it relates and a copy thereof shall be affixed in a conspicuous place
8
in the office of the Collector, inviting objections and suggestions in writing from any person with respect thereto within fifteen days from the date of publication of such notice.
After considering all the
objections and suggestions as may be received within the period specified in the notice and shall, after giving reasonable opportunity to all persons affected thereby or being heard, the State Government shall confirm the modified plan.
(3) The provisions of Sections 18,19 and 22 shall not apply for modification made by the State Government.
6 Perusal of this provision clearly establishes that the development of the master plan / zoning plan could have been done for the purpose of converting the user of the residential plot to commercial building, only if it was a proposal of the State or some development authority or at the request of any development authority that also for " public purpose" which as per the definition given in the explanation is for the purpose of creation or development and maintenance of human settlement or any part thereof.
7. According to the petitioner, in this case there was no proposal to either construct any residential building or any proposal for maintenance of human settlement as the plot in
9
question was a vacant plot and which could have been used only for residential purpose as per the then prevailing master plan.
8. It has been submitted that the permission to construct commercial building in this case has not been granted either to the State or any Development Agency, but has been to individuals i.e. Kalani Brothers for constructing commercial building contrary to the then existing master plan that also FAR
2.5 which was not applicable in the area in which the building was constituted. It is apparent that the entire land belongs to Kalani brothers. The joint venture which was entered into, later on also came to an end, soon after the permission was granted. The proposal to grant such permission was forwarded by the then Chief Minister. It was thereafter, a joint venture was entered into between Kalani Brothers, later through M/s Entertainment World Developers Pvt. Ltd with M.P. Housing Board was just camouflage because neither the condition mentioned in MOU such as granting 29 years lease of the land to M.P. Housing Board by the owners of the land was made, rather soon after the permission was granted, the M.P. Housing Board in hurry withdrew itself from the joint venture. Thus, the proposal was of Kalani brothers whose family owns the land in question and in fact, it was they who have constructed the building, in as much as M.P. Housing Board is not more a partner of the joint venture as stated above.
9. It is also submitted that granting FAR 2.5 to the building on the pretext that the land in question was located on commercial road, on which proposed master plan, 2011 would have been applicable, was a misnomer as the land in question
10
did not fall in the stretch, for which this FAR 2.5 was permitted, in as much as the FAR 2.5 was proposed for the commercial road starting from Gandhi Hall to Subhash Statute whereas the plot, where the mall has been constructed, is located in the way from High Court to Palasiya Square.
10. It has been submitted that in the preliminary investigation, respondent nos. 5 to 16 were prima facie found guilty for commission of the offence under sections 13(1)(d) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, as also under section 420, 467, 468, 471 and 120-B of IPC
11 It has been submitted that the permission granted in this case to Kalani Brothers was basically to benefit them with crores of rupees, in as much as conversion of residential plot to commercial plot in this area must have fetched more than Rs. 10 crores to Kalani Brothers without any benefit to the State in view of the withdrawal of the M.P. Housing Board from the alleged joint venture. It is submitted that despite this, the investigating Agency has not investigated the role of all the concerned officials in having permitted such construction which was blatantly in the teeth of M.P. Nagar Tatha Gram Nivesh Adhiniyam as well as the provision of Indore Municipal Corporation.
12 It is a matter of record that soon after the FIR was registered, the investigation was taken over by respondent no.
17. The progress of the investigation was not satisfactory. There was no attempt to collect evidence against the accused persons, who have been arrayed as respondent nos. 5 to 8 as they are influential persons since one of them was the Minister; other
11
was the Chief Secretary and third one was the then Chief Minister. However, this aspect has simply been given during the course of the investigation.
13 The petitioner approached Special Judge, Indore by filing an application under section 156(3) of Cr.P.C with request to supervise investigation of the case continuously. Direction was also sought against Mr. Mahendra Singh Sikarwal respondent no. 17 to file a report of investigation. A request was also made that the investigation be transferred to C.B.I. However, the said application was dismissed by the Special Judge, Indore vide order dated 09thof March, 2009 holding that at that juncture, it could not have been said that the investigation had not progressed as per law.
14 The petitioner, then filed a petition before this Court under section 482 of Cr.P.C vide M.Cr.C. no. 3593/2009. The said petition was disposed of by this Court by passing the following order on 19thof August, 2009.
"Shri M.Dalal, counsel for the petitioner.
Shri Manoj Dwivedi, Dy. Advocate General for respondents alongwith Shri A.S.Mandloi, D.S.P Investigating Officer, presently posted in the office of SP, EOW, Indore.
By filing this petition under Section 482 of Cr.P.C., the petitioner has made a prayer to change the Investigating Officer, Mr. M.S.Sikarwar and transfer the case to C.B.I. for investigation because influential persons Respondents no.5,6,7 and 8 involved in the case. Referring various dates, it is also alleged that investigation is being delayed on account of involvement of political persons of high level as well as high officials, therefore, investigating officer ought to have been changed and the matter may be relegated to CBI. On the other hand, Shri Manoj
12
Dwivedi, Dy. Advocate General submits that some time, there was a dispute on the point of handling over the charge to Mr. Arun Jain to Mr.Sikharwar, but after handing over charge and thereafter two months one Mr.Soni was appointed to investigate the matter. Now with effect from June 2009 Shri A.S.Mandloi is performing the investigation. It is stated and ensured by Shri Manoj Dwivedi, Dy.Advocate General to the Court that investigation be done in accordance with law without influencing by any person. It is also contended that no allegation overwhelming available to transfer the matter for investigation to C.B.I. particularly when the investigation is on preliminary stage, the complete file and record could not have been seized. In that view of the matter, it is said that this petition is filed on the basis of presumption, however it may be dismissed.
After having heard the learned counsel for the parties, it appears that the petitioner has come at an early stage and by way of subsequent event, now Investigating Officer has been changed and Mr. A.S.Mandloi, D.S.P has been assigned the work of
investigation. As per the statements of Dy. Advocate General and assurance given to the Court that the investigation be done in accordance with law, however, I do not find any ground to interfere in the matter at this stage. Hence, this petition is dismissed."
15 Bare perusal of this order reveals that the order was passed on the statement made by Dy. Advocate General who gave assurance to the court that the investigation will go in accordance with law and would be conducted expeditiously. According to the petitioner, this assurance was not complied with. The petitioner not being satisfied with the pace of investigation and also looking to the conduct of respondent no.
17 Mr. M.S. Sikarwal, who was trying to save respondent nos. 5 to 8, filed the present petition for directing the investigation to
13
be transferred to the C.B.I.
16 Some averments made in the aforesaid petition in support of the prayer are reproduced hereunder :
**2- izfrikFkhZ dzekad&17 us mDr
vijk/k dzekad 6@2008 dk vuqla/kku ewy vuqla/kku vf/kdkjh Jh v:.k tSu ls pktZ esa izkIr fd;k vkSj U;k;ky; izFke vij l= U;k;k/kh'k ,oa fo'ks"k U;k;k/kh'k egksn;] ds U;k;ky; esa na-iz-la- dh /kkjk 156 ¼3½ ds varxZr fnukad 06-03-2009 dks izLrqr fd;k x;k rks Mh ,l ih Jh lksuh dks vuqla/kku vf/kdkjh fu;qDr dj fn;k] ijUrq vkosnu v/khuLFk U;k;ky; }kjk fujLr dj fn;s tkus ds ckn Mh ,l ih Jh lksuh ls Jh egsUnzflag fldjokj izfrikFkhZ dzekad&17 us iqu% mDr vijk/k dzekad 6@2008 dk vuqla/kku Lo;a ys fy;kA tc izkFkhZ us ekuuh; mPp U;k;ky; ds le{k felysfu;l fdzfeuy dsl dzekad 3593@2009 fnukad 15-05-2009 dks izLrqr fd;k] rks twu 2009 esa vuqla/kku vf/kdkjh Mh ,l ih Jh , ,l e.Mksr dks ns fn;kA izfrikFkhZ dzekad&3 ,oa 4 }kjk vuqla/kku vf/kdkjh ds :i esa vijkf/k;ksa dks laj{k.k nsus gsrq fuEukafdr voS/k ,oa {ks=kf/kdkj ckg~; dk;Z fd;s x;s gSa&
d izfrikFkhZ dzekad&17 us fnukad
25-02-2009 dks mDr vijk/k dzekad 6@2009 ds tkap izfrosnu ds vuqla/kku vf/kdkjh Jh v:.k tSu ls e/;izns'k 'kklu ds vkokl ,oa i;kZoj.k foHkkx ea=ky; dh nLrkosth lk{; dh uLrh dh Nk;kizfr izkIr dh vkSj mDr
izfrfyih ls Nk;kizfr djokdj vijkf/kd
lk{; u"V djus ds "kM+;a= gsrq izHkko'kkyh vijkf/k;ksa dks nh gS] ftuesa izfrizkFkhZ dzekad&14 Hkh izkIrdrkZvksa esa lfEefyr gSA [k& eq[; vijk/kh Jh euh"k dkykuh
ls izdj.k ds laca/k esa ckEcs gkfLiVy ds ih- vkj-vks- Jh ijk'kj ds d{k esa blds iwoZ izfrizkFkhZ vqual/kku vf/kdkjh us cSBd dh vkSj mlds ckn nks ckj vius dk;kZy; esa mlls fopkj foe'kZ fd;kA mDr rF; dks e/;izns'k jkT; vkfFkZd vijk/k vUos"k.k C;wjks ds egkfujh{kd Jh vt; 'kekZ ds le{k izfrizkFkhZ dzekad&17 us fn- 06-03-2009 dks Lohdkj fd;k gS vkSj dsoy ,d ckj eq[; vkjksih Jh euh"k dkykuh ls lkStU; HksaV djuk Lohdkj fd;k gSA
x& Jh euh"k dkykuh ds Vªstj
vkbys.M eq[; lqj{kk vf/kdkjh Jh ih-ds- flag vijkf/k;ksa ds fgr lk/ku gsrq izfrizkFkhZ
14
dzekad&17 ls vk;s fnu HksaV djrs jgs gSaA ?k& vuqla/kku vf/kdkjh ds :i esa izfrizkFkhZ dzekad&17 ds }kjk mDr vijk/k dzekad 6@2009 ds nLrkosth lk{;ksa dks u"V djus vFkok VsEij djus dh nqHkkZouk ls iqfyl Fkkuk ,e vkbZ th bUnkSj esa iwoZ vuqla/kku vf/kdkjh Jh v:.k tSu ds fo:) mDr vijk/k ds nLrkosth lk{; ,oa ,Q-vkbZ-vkj- dk vk/kkj tkap izfrosnu ?kj ys tkus dh ,Q- vkbZ-vkj- ntZ djus gsrq Hksth gS] ftldk mn~ns'; nLrkosth lk{; u"V gksus dk vijkf/kd nkf;R; tkap vf/kdkjh Jh v:.k tSu orZeku vfrfjDr iqfyl v/kh{kd ukjdksfVDl bUnkSj dk cryk;k tk ldsA p- ekuuh; mPp U;k;ky; ds
le{k izkFkhZ }kjk felysfu;l fdzfeuy dsl dzekad 2274@2009 izLrqr fd;s tkus ij izfrizkFkhZ dzekad&17 us vijk/k dzekad 6@2009 ds vuqla/kku dk dk;Z mi iqfyl v/ kh{kd Jh fnyhi lksuh dks ekSf[kd :i ls nsdj izdj.k ekuuh; mPp U;k;ky; }kjk fujkd`r dj fn;s tkus ij vijkf/k;ksa ls izHkkfor gksdj mudh okaNk vuqlkj Jh fnyhi lksuh dks vuqla/kku vf/kdkjh dks iznRr vuqla/ kku okil ysdj izfrizkFkhZ dzekae&17 Lo;a us j[k fy;k gSA blds ckn izkFkhZ }kjk ekuuh; mPp U;k;ky; ds le{k fnukad 15-05-2009 dks felysfu;l fdzfeuy dsl dzekad 3593@2009 izLrqr fd;s tkus ij izfrizkFkhZ dzekad&17 us vuqla/kku dk dk;Z Mh ,l ih Jh , ,l e.MyksbZ dks ns fn;k gSA N- izfrizkFkhZ dzekad&2 us vijk/k dzekad 6@2009 dk vk/kkj f'kdk;r dzekad 262@2008 ds tkap izfrosnu esa ls vijk/khx.k rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h Jh fnfXot; flag] rRdkyhu eq[; lfpo Jh vkj-oh- flag] rRdkyhu vkokl ,oa Ik;kZoj.k ea=h Jh jkds'k flag vkSj rRdkyhu e/;izns'k x`g fuekZ.k e.My ds v/;{k Jh pUnzizHkk"k 'ks[kj ds fo:) Li"V izek.k o lk{; ugha gksus ds fu"d"kZ ikfjr dj izfrikFkhZ dzekad&17 dks i= fnukad 16-12-2008 dks QsDl ls Hkstk gS] ftldh Nk;kizfr layXu izn'kZ&3 izLrqr gSA t- izfrizkFkhZ dzekad&3 dks izfrizkFkhZ dzekad&17 vijk/k dzekad 6@2009 dk vijkf/k;ksa ds fgrlk/ku gsrq vkSj mUgsa laj{k.k nsus gsrq vuqla/kku djus dk fn[kkok ek= fd;k tk jgk gS vkSj ekuuh; mPp U;k;ky; }kjk felysfu;l fdzfeuy dsl dzekad
15
3593@2009 esa ikfjr vkns'k fnukad 19-08-2009 esa ikfjr U;k; fu"d"kksZa dk ikyu ugha fd;k tk jgk gSA ekuuh; mPp U;k;ky; }kjk ikfjr vkns'k fnukad 19-08-2009 dh izfrfyfi layXu izn'kZ&4 izLrqr gSA >- vijk/k dzekad 6@2009 fnukad
12-02-2009 dks izfrizkFkhZ dzekad&2 us ntZ djok;k gS] ijUrq fdlh Hkh vuqla/kku vf/kdkjh us izkFkhZ@ifjoknh ds dFku rd ugha fy;s gSaA**
17 It is the submission of the petitioner that the sequence of events as followed reflects upon the conduct of the respondent no. 17 as also other officers connected with the investigation in taking more care qua interest of respondent nos. 5 to 8 instead of investigating the crime effectively and expeditiously.
18 During the pendency of this petition, this Court also gave specific directions to the Investigating Agency to file written report about progressive investigation within four months vide order dated 27thof September, 2010. The said order is reproduced hereunder:
"It has been alleged by the applicant that five Investigating Officers have been changed and nothing is being done in the matter. The case remains at the same stage after filing of the FIR. In the view of the matter, four months time is granted to the Investigating Officer to file his written report. In case of his failure to do so an adverse conclusion shall be drawn against the investigating officer and this Court shall be constrained to treat this case a a public interest litigation. Till then it is directed that let a written report by the Investigating Officer be filed within four months i.e. on or before the
16
27thof January, 2011".
19 Directions were again given on 24thof April, 2011 as also, on 16thof September, 2011 to complete investigation expeditiously. It was reported that charge sheet was filed against respondent nos. 7,9,10 &14 namely Mr. Chahdraprabhash Shekhar, Mr. U.K. Samal, Mr. D.P. Tiwari and Mr. Manish Kalani. Later on, this was informed that as against the other accused persons, a closure report has been filed by the Investigating Agency on the pretext that no evidence was available against them.
20 Against the closure report, a protest petition has been filed by the petitioner which is pending before the Special Judge. Despite that, it is the submission of the petitioner that the manner in which the investigation has been conducted by the Investigating Agency shows that the Investigating Agency was not interested in bringing out the real culprit to the books and in fact they have simply ignored the evidence which was available in their records about the role of the other accused persons including the respondent nos. 5 to 8 and thus has requested this Court to direct further investigation of the matter by the Central Bureau of Investigation as arrayed as respondent no. 4 in this case. Reliance has been placed on the judgment delivered by Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case Sakiri Vasu Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and others reported in (2008) 2 SCC 409 to support his prayer that in such cases, this court may give direction to further investigation by the Central Bureau of Investigation.
17
21 Request has been opposed by the respondents on the pretext that once a final report has been filed, jurisdiction now to take further action is that of the Special Judge , before whom the investigation report has been filed. It is submitted that it is not appropriate for this Court to intervene in the matter at this juncture.
22 We have considered the submissions on behalf of the parties. We have also gone through the records of the case including the case diary submitted by the Investigating Agency under the directions of this Court. We have also perused the legal advice rendered by the Additional Advocate General to State of M.P. at the relevant time whereby it has been opined that prima facie case exists against all the accused persons arrayed as respondent nos. 5 to 16 in this case before us.
23 Now, the question which arises for consideration is as to whether the investigation can be transferred to CBI Authorities after the charge sheet has already been filed against some of the accused in Court. Both the sides relied upon the judgment delivered by the Apex Court in the case of Sakiri Vasu Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and others reported in (2008) 2 SCC 409, which hold that while this court may direct investigation of the criminal case by Central Bureau of Investigation in appropriate cases; also makes an exception to such a prayer being granted. Relevant observations made in that judgment are reproduced hereunder :
10 It has been held by this Court in CBI & another vs. Rajesh Gandhi and another 1997 Cr.L.J 63 (vide para 8) that no one can insist that an offence be investigated by a
18
particular agency. We fully agree with the view in the aforesaid decision. An aggrieved person can only claim that the offence he alleges be investigated properly, but he has no right to claim that it be investigated by any particular agency of his choice.
24 A reading of the aforesaid judgment goes to show that this Court certainly has power to direct investigation of criminal case by the Central Bureau of Investigation, of course, in appropriate cases. In this regard, we can also rely upon the judgment delivered by the Apex Court in the case of Inder Singh Vs. State of Punjab & Ors [ 1994 (6) SCC 275], as also the judgment delivered in the case of M.J. Cherian & ors Vs. Union of India [ 1992 (1) SCC 397 ].
25 In the case of Inder Singh ( supra ), when seven persons were abducted by a gang of police officers with direct support received by police officials abducting near relations of the petitioner, after directing filing of an affidavit to explain their positions by the senior police officials including the I.G ( crime ), the Apex Court made following observations.
16. It will be remembered that the petition sets out the various police stations in which the said 7 persons were from time to time lodged until 28th December, 1991, and that there is no denial thereto. We cannot but wonder whether Station House Officers of police stations in Punjab are not alert to the fact that there are strangers in their lock-ups and do not feel it necessary to find out how these strangers come to be there. There is not a word in the affidavits filed on behalf of the State of Punjab and by the 2nd respondent.
19
which states that any investigation has been made into the conduct of those in- charge of these named police stations and other police officers and policemen therein. They were obviously also involved in illegally detaining the said 7 persons within the precincts of the police stations. We are, therefore, unimpressed by the assertion of the 2nd respondent in his affidavit that
"incidents of the kind men tioned in the petition are deviant behavior and an aberration on the part of individual member of the force".
17. For the reasons that we have already set out we are unwilling to entrust the investigation of the abduction and presumable liquidation of the said 7 persons to the Punjab Police. We are satisfied that an independent investigation at a very high level is called for. The investigation shall cover:
(a) the circumstances of the abduction of said 7 persons; (b) their present whereabouts or the date and circumstances of their liquidation; (c) how it was that the inquiry into the complaint was delayed from 25th January, 1992, when it was received by the office of the 2nd respondent, till 23rd March, 1994, when the case was registered; (d) whether it is in conformity with good police administration that a complaint of abduction of 7 citizens by a high ranking police officer should not be required to be brought to the attention of the officer in command of the police force even after the allegations made in the complaint had been found to be correct
20
on inquiry by a specially designated officer; (e) whether there has been an attempt to cover-up the misdoings of police officers and policemen involved in the abduction of the said 7 persons and their subsequent incarceration or liquidation; and (f) if so, who was involved therein.
18. The inquiry shall be conducted personally by the Director of the Central Bureau of Investigation and he shall make a report to us within 4 weeks from today. For the purposes of recording statements and such other purposes, the Director shall be free to utilise the services of officers of the rank of Deputy Director, CBI, and above. The report shall be submitted in a sealed envelope to the Registrar-General of the Supreme Court and it shall be opened by us.
19. We direct the State of Punjab to ensure all assistance to the CBI for the purposes of the inquiry ordered as aforesaid in view of the observations made by us.
It may be simply observed that in this case also the direction to further investigate was given after filing of the charge-sheet in the peculiar facts of that case, which are not required to be reproduced by us.
26 In the case of M.J. Cherian & ors (supra), the Apex Court directed further investigation by C.B.I by making following observations :
10. We, therefore, direct the CBI to take up the investigation of the case immediately. We further direct the
21
Senior Superintendent Police, Moradabad and the Station House Officer, Gajraula Police Station to assist the CBI in conducting the investigation. The State of Uttar Pradesh through its Chief Secretary and the Home Secretary is further directed to provide all assistance to the CBI in this respect.
27 We would also like to make a reference to a judgment delivered by the Apex Court in the case of Rajender Singh Pathania and others Vs. state ( NCT of Delhi ) and others reported in (2011) 13 S.CC 329. In that judgment which has been recently given , the Apex Court has been pleased to observe as under :
14. This very Bench recently in Disha v. State of Gujarat while relying upon the earlier judgments of this Court in Ashok Kumar Todi v. Kishwar Jahan and Narmada Bai v. State of Gujarat came to the conclusion that for directing CBI to hold the investigation the Court must be satisfied that the opposite parties are very powerful and influential persons or the State authorities like top police officials are involved and the investigation has not been proceeded with in a proper direction or it has been biased. In such an eventuality, in order to do complete justice a direction to CBI to investigate the case can be issued.
28 In the case in hand, the above expressions of the Apex Court are fully applicable, in as much as the persons against whom, investigation is sought by the petitioner independently are the persons of influence, in as much as they
22
had been Chief Minister, Chief Secretary and the Minister for Environment of the State of M.P at the relevant time.
29 Another judgment of which notice is required to be taken is a judgment delivered in the case of T.C. Thangarai Vs.
V. Engammal and others reported in (2011) 12 SCC 328.
9. The decision of the two-Judge Bench of this Court in Ramesh Kumari
v. State (NCT of Delhi)will have to be now read in the light of the principles laid down by the Constitution Bench of this Court in State of W.B. v. Committee for Protection of Democratic Rights. The Constitution Bench has considered at length the power of the High Court to direct investigation by CBI into a cognizable offence alleged to have been committed within the territorial jurisdiction of a State and while taking the view that the High Court has wide powers under Article 226 of the Constitution cautioned that the courts must bear in mind certain self-imposed limitations.
10. Para 70 of the opinion of the Constitution Bench in State of W.B. v. Committee for Protection of Democratic Rights is extracted hereinbelow: (SCC p. 602)
"70. Before parting with the case, we deem it necessary to emphasise that despite wide powers conferred by Articles 32 and 226 of the Constitution, while passing any order, the courts must bear in mind certain self-imposed limitations on the exercise of these constitutional powers. The very plenitude of the
23
power under the said articles requires great caution in its exercise. Insofar as the question of issuing a direction to CBI to conduct investigation in a case is concerned, although no inflexible guidelines can be laid down to decide whether or not such power should be exercised but time and again it has been reiterated that such an order is not to be passed as a matter of routine or merely because a party has levelled some allegations against the local police. This extraordinary power must be exercised sparingly, cautiously and in exceptional situations where it becomes necessary to provide
credibility and instil confidence in investigations or where the incident may have national and international ramifications or where such an order may be necessary for doing complete justice and enforcing the fundamental rights. Otherwise CBI would be flooded with a large number of cases and with limited resources, may find it difficult to properly investigate even serious cases and in the process lose its credibility and purpose with
unsatisfactory investigations."
(emphasis supplied)
It will be clear from the opinion of the Constitution Bench quoted above that the power of the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution to direct investigation by CBI is to be exercised only sparingly, cautiously and in exceptional situations and an order directing CBI (sic to conduct investigation) is not to be passed as a matter of routine or merely because a
24
party has levelled some allegations against the local police.
30 Another judgment which can be looked into is the judgment delivered by the Apex Court in the case of High Court Bar Association Vs. State of Punjab &; amp' Ors [ AIR 1994 SC 1023 ]. In all these cases, charge sheet was submitted in Court. The court while passing the order for transfer observed that :
" The High Court was wholly unjustified in closing its eyes and ears to the controversy which had shocked the lawyer fraternity in the region. For the reasons best known to it, the High Court became wholly oblivious to the patent facts on the record and failed to perform the duty entrusted to it under the Constitution. After giving our thoughtful consideration to the facts and circumstances of this case, we are of the view that the least the High Court could have done in this case was to have directed an independent
investigation/enquiry into the mysterious and most tragic abduction and alleged murder of Kulwant Singh, Advocate and his family. We are conscious that the investigation having been completed by the police and charge-sheet submitted to the court, it is not for this Court, ordinarily, to reopen the investigation. Nevertheless, in the facts and circumstances of the present case, to do compete justice in the matter and to instill confidence in the public mind it is necessary, in our view, to have fresh investigation in this case through a specialized agency like the Central Bureau of Investigation ( CBI) "
31 In the case of State of Punjab Vs. Central Bureau of
25
Investigation & Ors reported in AIR 2011 SC 2962, while considering the question of directing fresh investigation or re- investigation after filing of charge sheet by police, the apex Court observed that inherent powers of High Court are not limited or affected by section 173(8) of Cr.P.C and the court in its inherent powers vested under section 482 of Cr.P.C has the powers to direct further investigation in the matter by Central Bureau of Investigation under section 173(8) of Cr.P.C even in a case where charge sheet has been filed. The relevant paras reads as under:
13. Sub-section (1) of Section 173 of the Cr.P.C. provides that every investigation by the police shall be completed without unnecessary delay and sub-section (2) of Section 173 provides that as soon as such investigation is completed, the officer in charge of the police station shall forward to a Magistrate empowered to take cognizance of the offence on a police report, a report in the form prescribed by the State Government. Under sub-section (2) of Section 173, a police report (charge sheet or challan) is filed by the police after investigation is complete. Sub-section
(8) of Section 173 states that nothing in the Section shall be deemed to preclude any further investigation in respect of an offence after a report under sub-section (2) has been forwarded to the Magistrate. Thus, even where charge sheet or challan has been filed by the police under sub- section (2) of Section 173, the police
26
can undertake further investigation but not fresh investigation or re- investigation in respect of an offence under sub-section (8) of Section 173 of the Cr.P.C.
14. Section 482 of the Cr.P.C., however, states that nothing in the Cr.P.C. shall be deemed to limit or affect the inherent powers of the High Court to make such orders as is necessary to give effect to any order under the Cr.P.C. or to prevent the abuse of the process of any Court or otherwise to secure the ends of justice. Thus, the provisions of the Cr.P.C. do not limit or affect the inherent powers of the High Court to make such orders as may be necessary to give effect to any order under the Court or to prevent the abuse of any process of the Court or otherwise to secure the ends of justice. The language of sub-section
(8) of Section 173 of the Cr.P.C., therefore, cannot limit or affect the inherent powers of the High Court to pass an order under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. for fresh investigation or re-investigation if the High Court is satisfied that such fresh investigation or re-investigation is necessary to secure the ends of justice.
15. We find support for this conclusion in the following observations of this Court in Mithabhai Pashabhai Patel v. State of Gujarat (supra) cited by Mr. Dhawan:
27
" 13. It is, however, beyond any cavil that "further investigation and reinvestigation " stand on different footing. It may be that in a given situation a superior court in exercise of its constitutional power, namely, under Articles 226 and 32 of the Constitution of India could direct a "
State" to get an offence investigated and/or further investigated by a different agency. Direction of a reinvestigation, however, being forbidden in law, no superior court would ordinarily issue such a direction. Pasayat, J. in
Ramachandran v. R. Udhayakumar [(2008) 5 SCC 413] opined as under:
(SCC p. 415, para 7)
" 7. At this juncture it would be necessary to take note of Section 173 of the Code. From a plain reading of the above section it is evident that even after completion of investigation under sub-section (2) of Section 173 of the Code, the police has right to further investigate under sub-section (8), but not fresh investigation or reinvestigation
A distinction, therefore, exists between a reinvestigation and further investigation
"15. The investigating agency and/or a court exercise their jurisdiction conferred on them only in terms of the provisions of the Code. The Courts subordinate to the High Court even do not have any inherent power under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure or otherwise.
28
The pre-cognizance jurisdiction to remand vested in the subordinate courts, therefore, must be exercised within the four corners of the Code."
It is clear from the aforesaid observations of this Court that the investigating agency or the Court subordinate to the High Court exercising powers under Cr.P.C. have to exercise the powers within the four corners of the Cr.P.C. and this would mean that the
investigating agency may undertake further investigation and the subordinate court may direct further investigation into the case where charge sheet has been filed under sub-section (2) of Section 173 of the Cr.P.C. and such further investigation will not mean fresh investigation or re-investigation. But these limitations in sub-section (8) of Section 173 of the Cr.P.C. in a case where charge sheet has been filed will not apply to the exercise of inherent powers of the High Court under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. for securing the ends of justice.
32 Now coming to the facts of this case, we may observe that conclusion drawn by the Investigating Agency prior to registration of the FIR were referred for advice to the law officer of the State of M.P vide letter dated 03rdof April, 2003 by EOW cell ( Indore Branch ). A perusal of the aforesaid letter goes to show that specifics about the role of each and every individual accused was specified in that case, the evidence collected bythe
29
Investigating was also discussed. It was in the light of the aforesaid submissions where Additional Advocate General gave his opinion in equivocal words there was material to proceed against Mr. Digvijay Singh, the then Chief Minister of State of Madhya Pradesh and Mr. A.V. Singh, the then Chief Secretary of State of Madhya Pradesh in the opinion given to the Superintendent of Police, EOW, Indore Branch in the context of the enquiry made by the said Cell is reproduced hereunder :
vkids }kjk layXu vuqla/kku izxfr
fjiksVZ ds vuqlkj rRle; vkjksih euh"k dkykuh }kjk fnukaWd 11@09@2002 dks ,d vkosnu rRdkyhu
eq[;ea=h ds le{k izLrqr fd;k x;kA mDr vkosnu i= esa bankSj ds Hkou dzekad&11] rqdksxat] bankSj ds Hkwfe mi;ksx ifjorZu djus ,oa e0iz0 gkmflax cksMZ ds la;qDr Hkkxhnkj esa ,d midze cuk;k tkdj Hkw[k.M dks
'kkfiax&de&eYVhQ~ysDl esa ifjorZu djus ckcn~ Lohd`fr pkgh xbZ FkhA vkosnu dks rRdkyhu vf/kdkjh ,oa rRdkyhu ea=h] rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h }kjk mDr euh"k dkykuh dks fu;eksa ds foijhr tkdj voS/k :i ls ykHk igqaWpkus gsrq Lohdkj fd;k tkdj] vkxs dk;Zokgh djus ds fy, ;ksX; ik;k x;k ,oa mDr vkjksih dks voS/k ykHk igqWapkus mn~ns'; ls rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h }kjk vkosnu esa ;g Vhi yxkrs gq, fd] ßIyht ,Dtkfeu fnl ,.M fMLdlAß rFkk dksM ,Dl&299 ntZ dj rRdkyhu izeq[k lfpo dks Hkstk x;kA mDr vkosnu ij ls gh vkxs pydj rRle; izo`Rr 'kklu }kjk fu;eksa ds foijhr tkdj] Hkw[k.M mikarj.k dh dk;Zokgh dh xbZ] tks fd fu;eksa ds foijhr Fkk rFkk rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h }kjk iz;qDr dksM izdj.k dks izkFkfedrk fn, tkus ds fy, rRle; mi;ksx fd;k tkrk gS vFkkZr~ Hkwfe ds mikarj.k dh dk;Zokgh esas rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h dh fo'ks"k :fp dks vuns[kk ugha fd;k tk ldrk ,oa mDr vkosnu ij ls rRdkyhu izeq[k lfpo ;w0ds0 lkey }kjk 30]000 ¼rhl gtkj½ oxZQqV Hkwfe dk mi;ksx ifjorZu vkoklh; ls okf.kfT;d djus dh vf/klwpuk izLokfor dh xbZ] ftls fd rRdkyhu izeq[k lfpo us rRdkyhu ea=h dks izsf"kr fd;k] ftl ij rRdkyhu izeq[k lfpo us rRdkyhu ea=h dks izsf"kr fd;k] ftl ij rRdkyhu ea=h }kjk fy[kk x;k]
ßekuuh; eq[;ea=hth }kjk bl izdj.k ds laca/k esa iwoZ esa funsZf'kr fd;k Fkk] vr% izeq[k lfpo dh Vhi dk voyksdu djuk pkgsaxsAß ftl ij rRdkyhu eq[; lfpo ,oa eq[;ea=h }kjk vuqeksnu fd;k x;kA izdj.k ds vuqla/kku ds nkSjku vkids }kjk Jh jkts'k Tosy] Jhefr la/;k 'kekZ] Jh xq:n;ky lqrkj] Jh
30
lquhy tks'kh] Jh panzizHkk"k 'ks[kj] Jh vuwi xks;y] Jh lh0ch0iMokj] Jh ,0ds0'kqDyk] egs'k xxZ] Jh txnh'k Mwxkodj] jk?kopanz] galdqekj tSu] ';ke 'kekZ] gjHktuflag] 'kjn egktu vkSj Jh f'kokuan nqcs vkfn ds dFku ntZ fd;s x;s FksA izdj.k esa Jh lh0ch0iMokj ,oa ,0ds0'kqDyk ds dFku voyksduh; gS] ftuds dFkuksa ls ntZ izdj.k dh iqf"V gksrh gSA
bl izdj.k esa ;g Hkh mYys[kuh; gS fd izdj.k esa tks f'kdk;r izkIr gqbZ Fkh] ml f'kdk;r dks eq[;ky; dks izsf"kr fd;k x;k Fkk vkSj eq[;ky; ls vuqeksnu; izkIr gksus ij izkFkfed tkaWp mijkar izFke lwpuk fjiksVZ vkjksihx.k ds fo:) ntZ fd;k x;k FkkA
izdj.k esa ftu vkjksihx.k ds fo:) vfHk;ksx i= izLrqr fd;k x;k] mlesa vkids }kjk ;g vk/kkj fy;k x;k gS fd euh"k dkykuh }kjk esllZ baVjVsaesaV oYMZ MsoyilZ izk0fy0 bankSj QeZ cukdj e/;izns'k x`g fuekZ.k eaMy ds lkFk ,d la;qDr midze cuk;k rFkk nksuksa ds e/; l'krZ ,d ,e0vks0;w0 fu"ikfnr gqvk] ftlesa e0iz0x`g fuekZ.k eaMy dks 51 izfr'kr 'ks;j fn, tkus dk r;k gqvk Fkk rFkk mDr ,e0vks0;w0 dh otg ls mDr Hkw[;.M dk Hkw&mi;ksx vUrxZr /kkjk&23¼d½ uxj rFkk xzke fuos'k vf/kfu;e] 1973 ds vUrxZr vkoklh; ls okf.kfT;;d fd;k x;kA izdj.k esa uxj fuxe }kjk mBkbZ xbZ oS/kkfud xaHkhj vkifRr;ksa dks utjvankt fd;k x;k ,oa vkokl ,oa i;kZoj.k foHkkx] }kjk O;kolkf;d Hkw&mi;ksx 30 ehVj xgjkbZ rd ekU; fd, tkus ds foijhr 'kklu }kjk ,d yk[k oxZ QhV dk Hkw&mikarj.k dh vf/klwpuk tkjh gqbZA ,e0vks0;w0 ds vuqlkj e0iz0x`g fuekZ.k eaMy dks ;kstuk ls 225 yk[k :i;s izkIr gksdj ykHk izkIr gksuk Fkk] fdUrq eaMy ds v/;{k }kjk vukf/kdkj ,e0vks0;w0 fujLr dj fn;k x;k vkSj ;kstuk fujLrh dk vkns'k tkjh djus ds mijkar fnukaWd 2&12&2003 dks jkti= esa vf/klwpuk tkjh ugha gksuk pkfg, Fkh \ bl izdkj la;qDr midze fujLr gksus ls 'kklu dks :i;s&225 yk[k dh gkfu rRdkyhu inklhu vf/kdkjhx.k] rRdkyhu vkokl ,oa i;kZoj.k ea=h rFkk rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h e0iz0'kklu vkfn us in dk nq:i;ksx] /kks[k/kM+h ,oa vkijkf/kd "kM;a= dj Lo;a ykHkkfUor dj 'kklu dks izkIr gksus okyh jktLo :i;s&225 yk[k dh vkfFkZd {kfr dkfjr dj euh"k dkykuh oxSjg dks Pecuniary advantage ,d lkft'k jpdj igaqW;k;k x;k gSA
izdj.k esa mYys[kuh; gS fd C;wjks ds vuqla/kku izfrosnu vuqlkj ,e0vks0;w0 ij gLrk{kj ds fy, euh"k dkykuh dks vf/kd̀r fd;kA mldh daiuh ds Mk;jsDVj Jhefr inek dkykuh ,oa izse dkykuh Hkh 'kkfey FksA ;fn mDr izdj.k esa ;fn daiuh dks ykHk gksrk gS rks gLrk{kj
31
djus gsrq fdlh ,d O;fDr dks vf/kd`r fd;k x;k gks rks daiuh dks ;fn vuqfpr ykHk izkIr gksrk gS rks daiuh ds leLr Mk;jsDVj mDr vijk/k dh ifjf/k esa vk;saxsA vr% esjs er esa izdj.k esa euh"k dkykuh ds lkFk izse dkykuh ,oa Jhefr in~ek dkykuh dks Hkh vfHk;ksftr fd;k tkuk pkfg,A
izdj.k esa ;g Hkh mYys[kuh; gS fd izdj.k esa tks loZizFke vkosnu mDr QeZ ds Mk;jsDVj }kjk rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h egksn; dks izsf"kr fd;k x;k Fkk mDr vkosnu ds izLrqr gksrs gh izdj.k esa conspiracy fn[kkbZ nsrh gS] D;ksafd mDr vkosnu ij rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h egksn; ds le{k izLrqr fd;k x;k] ftlesa Vhi yxkbZ xbZ] ftlesa fy[kk gS fd] ßIyht ,Dtkfeu fnl ,.M fMLdlß rFkk ,d dksM oMZ&299 vafdr fd;k x;kA
izdj.k dh uLrh ì"B dzekad&13 esa ;g vafdr fd;k x;k fd ekuuh; eq[;ea=hth eq[; lfpo ls ppkZ djuk pkgrs gSa ,oa Vhi 24&9&2002 rd pkgh xbZ gSA bl otg ls izdj.k dh uLrh rhoz xfr ls lapkfyr dh xbZA
izdj.k dh uLrh&16 esa ;g Hkh mYys[k vk;k gS fd izdj.k ls lacaf/kr ewy uLrh mPp Lrj ij izLrqr gksdj] izeq[k lfpo dks voyksduh; gSA ì"B dzekad&21 dh uLrh esa mPp Lrj ij izLrqr gksdj] izeq[k lfpo dks voyksduh; gSA i`"B dzekad&21 dh uLrh esa mPp Lrj ij izLrqr fd;k tkuk mYysf[kr gS] D;ksafd izdj.k 'kq:vkr ls mPp Lrj ij py jgk FkkA mlh vk/kkj ij x`g fuekZ.k eaMy ds rRdkyhu v/;{k ds izfrosnu ij ls izdj.k esa Hkw&varj.k dk vkosnu izLrqr fd;kA euh"k dkykuh ds }kjk izLrqr vkosnu i= /kkjk&23¼d½ uxj rFkk xzke fuos'k vf/kfu;e ds rgr Hkw&mikarj.k dh dk;Zokgh izkjaHk gqbZA mDr le; e0iz0uxj rFkk xzke fuos'k vf/kfu;e dh /kkjk&23¼d½ dk izko/kku fuEukuqlkj Fkk %&
ß 23&d dfri; ifjfLFkfr;ksa es jkT; ljdkj }kjk fodkl ;kstuk ;k ifj{ksf=d ;kstuk dk mikUrj.k& ¼1½ jkT; ljdkj] Loizsj.kk ls ;k fodkl izkf/kdj.k ds fuosnu ij vR;ko';d yksd iz;kstu ds fy,] fodkl ;kstuk ;k ifj{ksf=d ;kstuk esa mikarj.k dj ldsxhA fodkl ;kstuk ;k ifj{ksf=d ;kstuk esa bl izdkj fd;k x;k mikarj.k iqujhf{kr fodkl ;kstuk ;k ifj{ksf=d ;kstuk dk ,dhd̀r Hkkx gksxkA
¼2½ jkT; ljdkj mikarfjr ;kstuk ds izk:i dks mikarfjr ;kstuk izk:i ds rS;kj fd, tkus dh rFkk ml
32
LFkku ;k mu LFkkuksa dh] tgkaW mldh izfr;ksa dk fujh{k.k fd;k tk ldsxk] lwpuk ml {ks= esa] ftlls og ;kstuk lacaf/kr gS] ifjpkfyr ,sals nks nSfud lekpkj i=ksa esa tks fd foKkiu ds iz;kstu ds fy, jkT; ljdkj dh vuqeksfnr lwph esa gks] yxkrkj nks fnu rd izdkf'kr djk,xh vkSj mldh ,d izfr dysDVj ds dk;kZy; ds lwpuk iV~V ij fdlh lgt ǹ'; LFkku ij fpidkbZ tk;sxh] ftlesa fdlh Hkh O;fDr ls ,salh lwpuk ds izdk'ku dh rkjh[k ls iUnzg fnu ds Hkhrj mlds laca/k esa fyf[kr vkifRr;kaW rFkk lq>ko vkeaf=r fd;s tk;saxsA lwpuk esa fofufnZ"V dkykof/k ds Hkhrj leLr vkifRr;ksa rFkk lq>koksa ij fopkj djus ds i'pkr vkSj mlls izHkkfor leLr O;fDr;ksa dks lquokbZ dk ;qfDr;qDr volj nsus ds i'pkr jkT; ljdkj mikUrfjr ;kstuk dh iqf"V djsxhA
¼3½ /kkjk 18]19 rFkk 22 ds micU/k jkT; ljdkj }kjk fd;s x;s mikUrj.k ij ykxw ugha gksaxsA ß
Li"Vhdj.k& bl /kkjk ds iz;kstu ds fy, ßyksd iz;kstuß ds vUrxZr vkrk gS ekuo O;oLFkkiu ;k mlds fdlh Hkkx dk l`tu] fodkl rFkk mldk cuk;s j[kk tkuk
mDr vf/kfu;e dh /kkjk&23¼d½ esa ;g Li"V izko/ kkfur gS fd jkT; ljdkj] Loizsj.kk ls ;k fodkl izkf/kdj.k ds fuosnu ij vR;ko';d yksd iz;kstu ds fy,] fodkl ;kstuk ;k ifj{ksf=d ;kstuk esa mikarj.k dj ldsxh vFkkZr~ ;fn /kkjk&23¼d½ esa mikarj.k fd;k tkuk pkfg, Fkk rks fdlh futh O;fDr ds fuosnu ij mikarj.k dh dk;Zokgh ugha gks ldrhA jkT; 'kklu Loizsj.kk ls ;k fodkl izkf/kdj.k ds fuosnu ij vR;ko';d yksd iz;kstu ds fy, Hkw mikarj.k dj ldrk FkkA vR;ko';d yksd iz;kstu dh Hkh O;k[;k dh xbZ gSA ekuo O;oLFkkiu ;k mlds fdlh Hkkx dk l̀tu fy[kk x;k gS vFkkZr~ mDr izdj.k esa tks /kkjk&23¼d½ dh dk;Zokgh dh xbZ] og mDr vf/kfu;e dh /kkjk ds izko/kkuksa ds foijhr gksdj ek= fdlh O;fDr fo'ks"k dks vuqfpr ykHk igqaWpkus gsrq dh xbZ dk;Zokgh izrhr gksrh gSA
izdj.k esa mikarj.k dh dk;Zokgh rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h@eq[; lfpo ,oa ea=h ds funsZ'k ij tkjh dh xbZA esjs er esa ;fn dk;Zokgh izko/kkuksa ds foijhr Fkh] rks izkjaHk fd, tkus ;ksX; gh ugha FkhA ;g rF; vius ofj"B vf/kdkfj;ksa dks voyksdu djkbZ tkuk Fkh] fdUrq rRdkyhu vf/kdkfj;ksa }kjk mPp Lrj ds izHkko esa mDr Hkw&mikarj.k dh dk;Zokgh voS/kkfud :i ls dh xbZ gSA mDr dk;Zokgh ds nkSjku 'kklu }kjk /kkjk&23¼d½ ds izko/kku ds rgr tks vkifRr;kaW vkeaf=r dh xbZ Fkh] muesa vkifRrdrkZ txnh'k lsu] 'kadjyky uSuok] jkts'k Tosy] jkts'k lksyadh ,oa eukst frokjh us viuh vkifRr;kaW izLrqr dhA ckn esa mDr vkifRrdrkZvksa dh
33
vkifRr;ksa ds mijkar euh"k dkykuh }kjk ,d i= izLrqr fd;s tkus ij fujLr eku fy;k x;kA mlh nkSjku uxj fuxe }kjk Hkw&mikarj.k dh dk;Zokgh ds fo:) vkifRr izLrqr dh xbZ] ftls rRdkyhu lfpo] vkokl ,oa i;kZoj.k foHkkx] }kjk tkucw>dj utjvankt fd;k x;k Fkk ,oa ;g vk/kkj fy;k x;k gS fd izk:i fodkl ;kstuk o"kZ&2011 esa iz'uk/khu Hkwfe okf.kfT;d ekxZ ?kksf"kr gS ,oa mDr ekxZ dh izLrkfor pkSaM+kbZ 30 ehVj xgjkbZ esa okf.kfT;d mi;ksx ekU; gSA vr% mDr izLrkfor izk:i fodkl ;kstuk vuqlkj Hkw&mikarj.k gks ldrk gS] tks fd 20 ehVj xgjkbZ rd gh ekU; fd;k tk ldrk FkkA
uLrh ds i`"B dzekad&37&38 ij uxj fuxe dh vkifRr dks vfHker djkj nsrs gq,] ;g dfFkr fd;k x;k gS fd izLrkfor fodkl ;kstuk dks /;ku esa j[krs gq, 30 ehVj xgjkbZ rd okf.kfT;d mi;ksx gsrq Hkwfe mikarj.k fd;k tkuk mfpr gksxkA mDr uksV'khV ij rRdkyhu vkokl ,oa i;kZoj.k ea=h jkds'k pkS/kjh dh ;g Vhi mYysf[kr gS fd ekuuh; eq[;ea=h }kjk bl izdj.k ds laca/k esa iwoZ esa funsZf'kr fd;k Fkk] vr% izeq[k lfpo dh Vhi dk voyksdu djuk pkgsaxsA
mDr Hkw&mikUrj.k 30 ehVj xgjkbZ ds LFkku ij ,d yk[k oxZQhV fdl vk/kkj ij gks x;k] bl ckcn laiw.kZ uLrh esa dgha Hkh dksbZ mYys[k ugha gSA tks fd mDr mikarj.k dh dk;Zokgh dks u dsoy voS/kkfud] cfYd ,d ;kstukc) lkft'k dk ifj.kke iznf'kZr dj lafnX/k cukrk gSA
mDr vk/kkj ij 30 ehVj ds LFkku ij ,d yk[k oxZQhV vkoklh; Hkwfe dks okf.kfT;d Hkwfe esa mikarj.k dj fn;k x;kA
izdj.k dh uLrh esa ;g mYys[k gS fd vij lfpo lh0ch0iM+okj }kjk ;g dFku fd;k gS fd mDr uLrh esa rRdkyhu ekuuh; eq[;ea=h egksn; }kjk voyksdu fd;k x;kA rnqijkar ,d yk[k oxZQhV dh vafre vf/klwpuk tkjh dh xbZ gSA
mDr leLr rF;ksa dks ns[krs gq, izdj.k esa dh xbZ foospuk ls ;g; izdV gksrk gS fd izdj.k esa rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h ds le{k izdj.k ds vkjksih euh"k dkykuh ds }kjk tks vkosnu izLrqr fd;k Fkk] mDr vkosnu ij rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h }kjk fo'ks"k :fp yh tkdj] vius v/khuLFk vf/kdkfj;ksa ls mDr vkosnu ds vuqlkj dk;Zokgh djus gsrq funsZf'kr fd;k x;kA e0iz0uxj rFkk xzke fuos'k vf/kfu;e dh /kkjk&23¼d½ ds rgr Hkw&mi;ksx ifjorZu gsrq l{ke vf/kdkjh Jh jkds'k pkS/kjh] rRdkyhu vkokl ,oa i;kZoj.k ea=h dks izsf"kr fd;k x;k] fdUrq rRdkyhu l{ke vf/kdkjh }kjk dksbZ vkns'k ugha nsrs gq,] viuh fVIi.kh fy[kh ,oa Vhi ij rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h ,oa eq[; lfpo dks vuqeksnu
34
gsrq HkstkA ftl ij vuqeksnu rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h ,oa eq[; lfpo }kjk fd;k x;k] ftlls Li"V gS fd izdj.k ij dh tkus okyh dk;Zokgh gsrq rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h ls Li"V funsZ'k izkIr FksA ftl funsZ'k dh iwfrZ gsrq mDr uLrh rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h ,oa lfpo dks HksthA izdj.k ds laca/k esa rRdkyhu eq[; lfpo dh le;≤ ij dh xbZ fVIi.kh bl rF; dh iqf"V djrh gS fd izdj.k esa rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h dh fo'ks"k :fp jgh gSA izdj.k esa ;g Hkh mYys[kuh; gS fd izk:i fodkl ;kstuk o"kZ&2011 vfLrRo esa vk;k gh ugha vkSj vkus ds iwoZ gh fujLr gks x;k Fkk rFkk mDr ifjdfYir ;kstuk ds vk/kkj ij dksbZ fu.kZ; fdl vk/kkj ij fd;k tk ldrk gSA mDrk izdj.k esa leLr dk;Zokgh izLrkfor izk:i fodkl ;kstuk ds vk/kkj ij dh xbZ] tcfd mDr izLrkfor izk:i fodkl ;kstuk vfLrRo esa vkbZ ugha A vkids }kjk izsf"kr i= ds ì"B dzekad&2 ds iSjk&3 esa mYysf[kr gS fd &
¼,½ mijksDrkuqlkj fnukaWd 25&11&03 dks tc e0iz0x`g fu0eaMy ds v/;{k Jh panzizHkk"k 'ks[kj }kjk ,e0vks0;w0 fujLr djus dh uksV'khV fy[kdj i= tkjh dj fn;kA mlds i'pkr fnukaWd 2&12&03 dh vf/klwpuk tkjh gksuk laHko ugha FkkA ;g vius vkiesa Li"V gS fd mijksDr fnukaWd 25&11&03 dks dh xbZ dk;Zokgh ckn ds fnukaWdksa esa dh tkdj fjdkMZ ij iqjkuh rkjh[k esa ntZ n'kkZdj vk;qDr] e0iz0x̀0fu0ea0 dks Hksth xbZ] ftl ij vk;qDr Jh jk?kopanzk us fnukaWd 8&12&03 dks mijksDr izLokr ij dh oS/kkfudrk] eaMy fgr bR;kfn dh tkudkjh ds laca/k esa viuh Vhi ys[k dh xbZA ftlds vuqlkj fnukaWd 6&12&2003 dks izns'k esa ubZ ljdkj dk xBu gks tkus ls rRdkyhu x̀g fuekZ.k eaMy ds v/;{k }kjk tYnckth esa rFkk fiNyh rkjh[kksa ij uksV'khV fy[kh xbZA vr% mDr dk;Zokgh vkuu&Qkuu esa ek= vkjksih dks ykHk igqaWpkus ds mn~ns'; ls dh xbZA izdj.k esa n`"V;k /kkjk&23¼d½ ds izko/kku esa Hkw&mikarj.k gks gh ugha ldrk Fkk] D;kasfd Hkw&mikarj.k fdlh futh O;fDr ds fuosnu ij fd;k x;k FkkA mDr; mikarj.k dh dk;Zokgh ij fofHkUu Lrj ij ;g Kkr gksrk gS fd mDr mikarj.k esa mPp Lrj ij n[ky FkkA mPp Lrj ij rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h@eq[; lfpo ;k ea=h dh Vhi ls Li"V gks tkrk gS rFkk mikarj.k dk;Zokgh dk vuqeksnu Hkh rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h@eq[; lfpo }kjk fd;k x;k gSA
vr% esjs er esa mDr lHkh fcUnqvksa ls vkijkf/kd lkft'k fl) djus dh i;kZIr lk{; vfHkys[k ij gS] vr% mijksDr vuqla/kku ds rgr ladfyr lk{; ds vk/kkj ij rRdkyhu ea=h Jh jkds'k pkS/kjh] rRdkyhu eq[;ea=h Jh fnfXot;flag
35
rFkk rRdkyhu eq[; lfpo Jh ,0Ogh0flag ds fo:) vfHk;kstu dh dk;Zokgh dh tkuk pkfg,A
33 The opinion given by the Additional Advocate General prima facia that the proposal to convert the plot no. 11, Tukoganj, Indore which as per the existing master plan could have been used only for residential purpose, in commercial multiplex as per the request of Kalani Brothers, was forwarded to the the Chief Secretary by the then Chief Minister using following remark :
Reference Manish Kalani
CS
Please examine this and discuss X- 299
34 As per Mr. C.B. Padwar, whose statement has been record under section 161 of Cr.P.C during the preliminary investigation, it means, give priority to the proposal and shows more than normal interest of the Chief Minister in the project.
35 Perusal of section 23(A) of the Nagar Tatha Gram Nivesh Adhiniyam, 1973 shows that such proposal could not have been accepted until and unless it was the proposal by the State itself or by development authority in accordance with section 23(A) of the Nagar Tatha Gram Nivesh Adhiniyam, 1973. As per this existing master plan, even if such proposal was to be accepted, it could have been for construction of building 30 meters deep i.e. FAR 1.5 and not FAR 2.5. In any event as per the then existing master plan or even the proposed master plan, 2011, the land in question could not have been permitted to have been used for commercial purpose and that also with FAR 2.5. It is apparent that only to make a proposal of the State, M.P.
36
Housing Board entered into the joint venture with Kalani Brothers, but later on, soon after the permission was granted, they withdrew from the joint venture.
36 It is also a matter of record that after objections were invited, certain objections were filed not only by Indore Municipal Corporation but also by Jagdish Sen, Shankarlal Nainwa, Rajesh Jwel, Rajesh Solanki and Manoj Tiwari to the proposed conversion. All these objections were stated to have been withdrawn on the basis of the letters brought to the concerned authority by Manish Kalani himself. As far as the objections of Indore Municipal Corporation are concerned, they were ignored by just treating it as opinion. The manner in which the proposal proceeded and accepted not only by hurrying it, even by fabricated documents, but also the withdrawal of M.P. Housing Board from the joint venture, also reflects upon some kind of conspiracy between the higher officials and the Kalani brothers for illegal gains of crores of rupees by converting the user of the residential plot to commercial building.
37 It has been submitted that i ) The conversion of plot no. 11, M.G. Road, Indore to commercial complex was contrary to the provision of Nagar Tatha Gram Nivesh Adhiniyam.
ii ) The proposal was not for public purpose.
iii) The proposal was accepted only because the proposal was forwarded to with code word X-299 by the then Chief Minister.
Iv ) The proposal was also contrary to the provision and Rules applicable for development of the city by the Municipal
37
Corporation.
38 The petitioner in his submissions has reiterated that the land in question is measuring to 250 sq ft x 400 sq. ft = 1,00,000 sq.ft Out of that, 29516 sq.ft belongs to Padma Kalani and 70484 sq ft belongs to Prem Kalani who are the mother and father of Manish Kalani. This proposal has been floated by Manish Kalani posing himself as the owner of the property that in conspiracy to give financial benefit to Kalani brothers. Directions were given by the then Chief Minister by using code word X-299 to accept the proposal and it was at the instance of the Chief Minister , a joint venture agreement dated 21stMay, 2003 was entered into between M/s Entertainment World Developers Pvt. Ltd belonging to Kalani Brothers with M.P. Greh Nirman Mandal with 51% shares. The joint venture shows that the land was to be given on 29 years lease to M.P. Greh Nirman Mandal. Later on, once clearance was granted, joint venture itself was cancelled. It is also submitted that by entering into such joint venture, Kalani brothers could procure all clearance from Government of M.P. and any additional State Government guarantees, besides exemptions and incentives, to which the project is entitled and clearance of permissions such as change in land use from residential to commercial, approval of plants etc.
39 It has also been submitted that the proposal of Housing Board was accepted on 02ndof June, 2003 and was sent to Mr. U.K. Samal who later put up that proposal to Rakesh Singh Choudhary, the then Environment Minister who invited objections vide two newspapers on 08th- 09thAugust, 2003
38
namely Vishwabhraman and Dainik Nav Bharat which has a very limited circulation, so as to avoid notice to general public.
40 That the Development Guidelines, 2011; on the basis of which, FAR 2.5 and permission to convert the residential property into commercial property was granted; never come into existence. Moreover, those guidelines were not applicable to the plot in question. It is also submitted that after 27thof September, 2003, Mr. U.K. Samal despite objections, permitted construction of this property for commercial purpose.
41 In accordance with Rules of Business, Mr. Rakesh Singh Choudhary, the then Minister for Environment himself was competent to grant such permission, instead of granting the permission himself took approval from the the Chief Minister through the then Chief Secretary as per the noting available on record dated 21stof October, 2003 and 2ndof November, 2003 with a view to financially help to Kalani brothers. It is submitted that the proposal was finally put up by A.V. Singh to the then Chief Minister though Mr. U.K. Samal and approved by the then Chief Minster on 02ndof November, 2003.
Relevant noting reads under :
21-10-2003 eq[; lfpo Jh ,0oh0flag us
ea=h Jh jkds'kflag pkS/kjh ds vkns'k vuqlkj
izeq[k lfpo Jh mekdkUr lkey ds ek/;e ls
uLrh iqf"V gsrq eq[;ea=h Jh fnfXot;flag dks
fnukad 22-10-2003 dks izLrqr dhA
02-11-2003 eq[;ea=h Jh fnfXot;flag us
uLrh ij laKku lwpd gLrk{kj fd;sA
42 The petitioner has brought to the notice of this Court the sequence of events on that basis submitted that the
39
permission to convert the residential plot to commercial building was granted only with active connivance of respondent nos. 5 to 8 and thus each one of them was responsible and guilty of the offence alleged against them in the preliminary investigation. This sequence of events for the sake of reference which find mentioned in the written objections / submissions by the petitioner are reproduced hereunder :
11-09-2002 Jh fnfXot; }kjk euh"k dkykuh ds vkosnu ij eq[k lfpo dks iznRr vkns'k izkFkfedrk ls fujkdj.k ds dksMoMZ lfgrA
11-09-2002 Jh euh"k dkykuh }kjk muds vkosnu ij Jh fnfXot; flag ds vkns'k ds eq[kì"B dh Nk;kizfr lfgr vkosnu eq[; lfpo Jh ,0ch0flag dks izLrqr dj eq[;ea=h ds vkns'k ds ikyu dk fuosnuA
21-05-2003 Jh euh"k dkykuh }kjk TokbUV osUpj
bUVjVsuesUV oYZM MsoyilZ izk-fy- e/;izns'k x̀g fuekZ.k e.My ds lkFk fd;s tkus dk ,e0vks0;w0 ftlesa 51 izfr'kr 'ks;j gksfYMax e/;izns'k x̀g fuekZ.k e.My dh j[kh xbZ vkSj cnys esa Hkwfe dk mi;ksx vkoklh; ls okf.kfT;d djokus rFkk foRr laLFkkvksa ls dtZ fnyokus e/;izns'k 'kklu ds vko';d vukifRr;ka fnyokus vkSj vko';drkuqlkj gqMdks dks e/;izns'k 'kklu dh vfrfjDr X;kj.Vh fnyokus vkfn dk nkf;Ro fn;k x;k gSA
21-05-2003 e/;izns'k x`g fuekZ.k e.My ls ,e0vks0;w0 fu"ikfnr djus ds iwoZ Hkw[k.M Lokeh in~ek gkse izk- fy- o dkykuh cznlZ bUnkSj izk-fy- ls 29 o"kZ dh yht ij Hkw[k.M TokbUV osUpj bUVjVsuesUV oYMZ MsoyilZ ds fgr esa izkIr djus dk nLrkost fu"ikfnr fd;k x;k] ijUrq lk{; ds :i esa mi;ksx esa vuqla/kku vf/kdkjh }kjk ugha fy;k x;k gSA
40
02-06-2003 e/;izns'k uxj ,oa xzke fuos'k vf/kfu;e dh /kkjk 23&, ds varxZr ,e0th0jksM jhxy VkWdht ls iykfl;k pkSjkgk@fryd LVsP;w rd bUnkSj ds ekLVjIyku esa vkoklh; gksus ls mldk mi;ksx okf.kfT;d tufgr esa 'kklu vFkok 'kkldh; midze }kjk gh djok;s tk ldus dh vfuok;Z fof/kd iwfrZ gsrq e/;izns'k x`g fuekZ.k e.My dh vksj ls mlds v/;{k vkjksih pUnzizHkk"k 'ks[kj us Hkw[k.M dzekad 11 ,e0th0jksM bUnkSj dk Hkwfe dk mi;ksx vkoklh; ls okf.kfT;d mikUrfjr djus gsrq vkns'k i=koyh mDr fnukad 02-06-2003fy[kdj vk;qDr vkokl ,oa i;kZoj.k dks Hksth xbZA
06-08-2003 vkoklh ,oa i;kZoj.k ea=h Jh jkds'kflag pkS/kjh Hkwfe dk mi;ksx vkoklh; ls okf.kfT;d djus ds Jh pUnzizHkk"k 'ks[kj ds izLokr fnukad 02-03-2003 dks Lohdkj dj Hkwfe dk mi;ksx vkoklh; ls okf.kfT;d djus gsrq vkifRr;ka vkeaf=r fd;s tkus dh vf/klwpuk izdkf'kr djus ds vkns'k ds ikyu esa vf/klwpuk tkjh dh] tks 08 o 09 vxLr 2003 ds nSfud fo'oHkze.k o nSfud uoHkkjr lekpkj i=ksa esa izdkf'kr gqbZ gSA
27-09-2003 vkifRrdrkZx.k }kjk vkifRr;ka okil fy;s tkus ds QyLo:i vkxkeh dk;Zokgh gsrq Hkwfe ds bankSj uxj ds ekLVjIyku esa fu/kkZfjr mi;ksx dh tkudkjh izLrqr djus ds vkns'k Jh ;q0ds0lkey us vius v/khuLFk mi lfpo dks fn;sA
29-09-2003 mi lfpo }kjk fu%'ks"k gks pqdh o fujLr izLrkfor bankSj fodkl ;kstuk 2011 esa ,e0th0jksM ij fLFkr iz'uk/khu Hkw[k.M dk ekxZ okf.kfT;d ?kksf"kr gS rFkk bl ekxZ dh izLrkfor pkSaM+kbZ 30 ehVj gksus rFkk okf.kfT;d ekxZ ij izk:i fodkl ;kstuk 2011 ds pj.k&6%33%2 vuqlkj ekxZ dh pkSaM+kbZ ls Ms<+ xquk xbjkbZ rd vFkok vf/kdre 30 ehVj xgjkbZ esa okf.kfT;d mi;ksx ekU; gksus dh tkudkjh vkns'k i=koyh esa fy[kh xbZ gSA mDr
41
izLokfor fodkl ;kstuk ds vk/kkj ij mYysf[kr tkudkjh bankSj uxj ds izHkkoh ekLVjIyku ds izdk'k esa voS/k] {ks=kf/kdkj ckg~; ,oa 'kwU; gSA ,e0th0jksM ij iz'uk/khu Hkw[k.M ds vykok fdlh Hkh Hkw[k.M dks bl vk/kkj ij Hkwfe dk mi;ksx vkoklh; ls okf.kfT;d fd;s tkus dh vuqefr e/;izns'k 'kklu us ugha nh gSA
30-09-2003 vkjksih mekdkUr lkey izeq[k lfpo us Hkw[k.M dzekad 11 ,e0th0jksM dk 30 ehVj dh xgjkbZ rd mi;ksx vkoklh; ls okf.kfT;d djus ds vkns'k ikfjr fd;s] vkSj iqf"V gsrq vkokl ,oa i;kZoj.k ea=h Jh jkds'kflag pkS/kjh dks vkns'k i=koyh HksthA
30-10-2003 Jh jkds'kflag pkS/kjh us izdj.k ds laca/k esa eq[;ea=hth }kjk funsZf'kr fd;k x;k gksus ds dkj.k Vhi dk voyksdu eq[;ea=hth ls djokus ds vkns'k nsdj uLrh eq[; lfpo Jh ,0oh0flag dks HksthA
21-10-2003 eq[; lfpo Jh ,0oh0flag us ea=h Jh jkds'kflag pkS/kjh ds vkns'k vuqlkj izeq[k lfpo Jh mekdkUr lkey ds ek/;e ls uLrh iqf"V gsrq eq[;ea=h Jh fnfXot;flag dks fnukad 22-10-2003 dks izLrqr dhA 02-11-2003 eq[;ea=h Jh fnfXot;flag us uLrh ij laKku lwpd gLrk{kj fd;sA
29-11-2003 vf/klwpuk dk izk:i vk;qDr&lg&lapkyd uxj ,oa xzke fuos'k dks Hkstdj miyC/k djok;s tkus ds vkns'k iznku fd;s x;sA
02-12-2003 vk;qDr&lg&lapkyd Mh0ih0frokjh us 'kklu }kjk fn;s x;s vuqeksnu vuqlkj vafre vf/klwpuk dk izk:i layXu dj uLrh iqu% mi lfpo vkokl ,oa i;kZoj.k foHkkx dks HksthA
42
02-12-2003 mi lfpo f'kokuUn nqcs us vkjksih Mh0ih0frokjh }kjk Hksts x;s izk:i esa lEiw.kZ Hkw[k.M 11 ,e0th0jksM bankSj {ks=Qy 1 yk[k oxZQhV dk mi;ksx vkoklh; ls okf.kfT;d mikarfjr djus dh vf/klwpuk Hksth tkus ij fyf[kr vkifRr izLrqr dh gSA iz'kkldh; vuqeksnu vuqlkj mDr Hkw[k.M dk mi;ksx 30 ehVj xgjkbZ rd mikarfjr fd;s tkus ds vkns'k ds izdk'k esa iqu% vuqeksnu iznku djus dk fuosnu lfpo Mh0ih0frokjh dks izLrqr fd;k] ftlesa mlh fnu vkns'k fn;k fd izk:i izdk'ku gsrq Hkstdj iqf"V gsrq izeq[k lfpo dks izLrqr fd;k tk;sA 05-12-2003 e/;izns'k jkti= esa izdkf'kr mDr vlR; ,oa dwVjfpr vf/klwpuk fnukad 02-12-2003 dks voyksdukFkZ mi lfpo Jh f'kokuUn nqcs us lfpo Jh Mh-ih- frokjh dks izLrqr fd;k] ftlus blh fnu izeq[k lfpo Jh ;q-ds- lkey dks uLrh lfgr izLrqr fd;kA bl izdkj 30 ehVj xgjkbZ rd okf.kfT;d mi;ksx ds LFkku ij lEiw.kZ 1 yk[k oxZQhV ds Hkw[k.M 250 QhV ck; 400 QhV dk mi;ksx Ny o tkylkthiwoZd okf.kfT;d dj fn;k x;k gSA 05-03-2004 gkbjkbt desVh us Jh lh-ch-flag dh v/; {krk dh cSBd esa cgqeaftys 'kkWfiax ekWy gsrq vuqefr iznku dj ,Q-,-vkj- 2-5 Lohdkj fd;k gSA
10-03-2004 e/;izns'k x̀g fuekZ.k e.My }kjk dysDVj bUnkSj] vk;qDr bUnkSj uxj ikfyd fuxe bUnkSj rFkk la;qDr lapkyd uxj ,oa xzke fuos'k bUnkSj dks i= dzekad ts-Mh- @b-MCY;w-ch-ih-,y-@1034&1036 ls iz'uk/khu Hkw[k.M dzekad 11 ds la;qDr midze esa e/;izns'k x`g fuekZ.k e.My dh iwoZ lgefr izkIr djus ds ckn Hkh okafNr Lohd̀fr;ka fn;s tkus dk fuosnu fd;k x;k gS] ijUrq mi rhuksa inksa ij inklhu ihBklhu vf/kdkfj;ksa us Jh euh"k dkykuh ds fgrlk/ku gsrq mDr i= dk laKku rd ugha fy;k gSA 18-03-2004 Hkou vf/kdkjh jkds'k 'kekZ] lgk;d ;a=h Jh
43
lqHkk"kflag pkSgku ,oa mi;a=h Jh fnus'k 'kekZ us Hkw[k.M dzekad 11 ij Hkou fuekZ.k vuqKk 9308-60 oxZehVj ij ,Q , vkj 2-5 dh okf.kfT;d gsrq 1 yk[k oxZQhV ds iz'uk/khu Hkw[k.M gsrq iznku dh gSA Hkou fuekZ.k dk vk/kkj e/;izns'k jkti= esa izdkf'kr vf/klwpuk fnukad 05-12-2003 dks cryk;k x;k gSA rRi'pkr~ fnukad 22-02-2005 dks Hkou vf/ kdkjh Jh vuwi xks;y] lgk;d ;a=h Jh lqHkk"kflag pkSgku ,oa mi;a=h Jh fnus'k 'kekZ us la'kksf/kr Hkou fuekZ.k vuqKk iz'uk/khu Hkw[k.M dzekad 11 ij iznku dh gSA 20-07-2004 e/;izns'k x`g fuekZ.k e.My }kjk vius iwoZ i= dzekad 1034&1036 fnukad 10-03-2004 dk lanHkZ nsrs gq, TokbaV osapj ls lacaf/kr iz'uk/khu Hkw[k.M gsrq fDy;jsal@ijfe'ku@,u-vks-lh- iznku ugha fd;s tkus dk fuosnu fd;k x;k] ijUrq mDr i= dk Hkh laKku fy;s cxSj cgqeaftyk lfefr us Hkou fuekZ.k dh vuqefr nsdj ,Q-,- vkj- 1-5 ds LFkku ij ,Q-,-vkj- 2-5 fn;s tkus dh vuq'kalk dh] ftlds vk/kkj ij bUnkSj uxj fuxe ds Hkou vf/kdkjh us 'kkWfiax ekWy cukus dh fuekZ.k vuqKk iznku dh gSA 21-03-2006 e/;izns'k x`g fuekZ.k e.My }kjk iz'uk/khu 'kkWfiax ekWy de eYVhIysDl dks dk;Z iw.kZrk izek.k i= tkjh ugha djus dk i= Hkou vf/kdkjh N=ifr f'kokth tksu dzekad&7 uxj ikfyd fuxe] bUnkSj dks Hkstk gS] ijUrq mDr i= dh mis{kk dj voS/k ykHk Jh euh"k dkykuh o muds firk Jh izse dkykuh ,oa ekrk Jhefr in~ek dkykuh dks voS/k ykHk nsus gsrq voS/k ,oa {ks=kf/kdkj ckg~; mi;ksfxrk izek.k i= bUnkSj uxj fuxe us fn;s gSaA tcfd ,l-th-,l-vkbZ-Vh-,l- ds eki ds vuqlkj 2-5 ,Q-,-vkj- ds eku ls 2401-1 oxZehVj vf/kd fuekZ.k gksus rFkk Vsjsl ¶yksj cxSj Lohd̀fr ds 2187-85 oxZehVj cuk;s tkus ij dqy voS/k fuekZ.k 4588-45 oxZehVj vf/kd gqvk gSA
44
e/;izns'k 'kklu ds yksd fuekZ.k foHkkx }kjk fd;s x;s HkkSfrd eki vuqlkj Lohd̀r 2-5 ,Q-,-vkj- vuqlkj 1482-84 oxZehVj rFkk voS/k cus Vsjsl ¶yksj dk fuekZ.k 2187-25 oxZehVj gSA
mi;qZDr nksuksa eki rFkk e/;izns'k x`g fuekZ.k e.My ds mi;ksfxrk izek.k i= ugha fn;s tkus ds fuosnu ds ckn Hkh iz'uk/khu 'kkWfiax eky ds mi;ksx gsrq bUnkSj uxj fuxe us izek.k i= nsdj djksM+ksa :i;s izfro"kZ dk voS/k ykHk Jh euh"k dkykuh] Jhefr in~ek dkykuh o Jh izse dkykuh dks fn;k gSA
bUnkSj uxj fuxe ds rRdkyhu vk;qDr Jh fouksn 'kekZ us vlR; ,oa dwVjfpr nLrkost cukdj iz'uk/khu Hkou dzekad 11] ,e-th-jksM] bUnkSj esa voS/k fuekZ.k 10 izfr'kr ls de gksdj dsoy 361-54 oxZehVj ek= gksus dk mYys[k dj e/;izns'k E;qfufliy dkiksZjs'ku ,DV dh /kkjk 308&, ds varxZr voS/k fuekZ.k dk dEikmfUMax dj /kujkf'k :i;s 81]34]650@& bUnkSj uxj fuxe esa tek djokbZ gSA 05-02-2010 yksd fuekZ.k foHkkx eq[;ky; bUnkSj laHkkx dzekad&2] bUnkSj us iz'uk/khu 'kkWfiax ekWy dk fuekZ.k dk HkkSfrd lR;kiu dj 17595-85 oxZehVj vf/kd fuekZ.k gksus dk izfrosnu e/;izns'k jkT; vkfFkZd vijk/k vUos"k.k C;wjks dks izLrqr fd;k gSA
10-12-2010 bUnkSj uxj fuxe ds flVh bathfu;j Jh ,u-,l- rksej us iz'uk/khu 'kkWfiax ekWy Lohd̀r ekufp+= vuqlkj ugha gksus dh tkudkjh e/;izns'k jkT; vkfFkZd vijk/k vUos"k.k C;wjks dk iznku dh gSA
43 It has been further submitted that there has been conscious attempt on the part of the investigating agency to save real culprit, in as much as the investigating agency simply shut
45
its eyes regarding the role played by the then Chief Minister and the then Chief Secretary and the then Minister for Environment who initiated the proposal for conversion of the residential plot to commercial building and in fact granted permission, even though it has come on record that M.P. Housing Board withdrew from the proposal. It is submitted that the investigating agency while filing of the closure report have simply shut its eyes on the important questions whereby the Investigating Agency has not filed any challan against other accused persons except respondent nos. 7,9,10 &14.
44 It has been submitted that no investigation has been conducted about the user of code word X-299.
45 It is submitted that the stand of the Investigating Agency that no case is made out against Ms. Padma Kalani by making reference to resolution passed by the Board of Directors of M/s Entertainment World Developers Pvt. Ltd. which has authorized one of the director of the company to execute lease of the land in question for 29 years in favour of the M.P. Housing Board just because Ms. Padma Kalani was not present in the meeting, again requires independent investigation.
46 It is also surprising that the investigating Agency has not found any wrong in granting FAR 2.5 by taking a plea that the plot in question was situated at a place of M.G.Road where
2.5 FAR was permitted as per the plan for the year 2011. despite the fact that, the plot no. 11 on which the construction has been carried out is not located on the road for which FAR 2.5 was permitted in as much as 2.5 FAR was permitted only between M.G. Road to Subhash Statute whereas the present plot is not a
46
part of that area.
47 Thus, we are satisfied that it is a fit case where, further investigation is required to be made in the matter by any independent investigating agency and for that reason as per the prayer made by the petitioner, the Central Bureau of Investigation to look into the following aspects. i ) What is the significance
of using of code word X-299 in the
proposal forwarded by the then
Chief Minister to the then Chief
Secretory ?.
ii ) If the meaning of X-299
is positive direction, then what is
the role of Senior Officials, the then
Chief Minister, the then Chief
Secretary and the then Minister for
Environment ?
iii ) Whether the plot in
question was located on the road for
which FAR 2.5 could have been
permitted ?
iv ) Was the permission
granted for public purpose as
provided under section 23(A) of the
Nagar Tatha Gram Nivesh
Adhiniyam, 1973.
v ) Whether the proposal
was of the State or any development
authority ? Even if for the sake of
argument, it is presumed that the
proposal was of M.P. Housing Board
with 51% shares in the joint
venture, then what was the status of
the project, after the M.P. Housing
Board withdrew from the proposal ?.
47
48 We are conscious of the fact that a protest petition filed by petitioner is before Special Judge. We are of the considered view that the role to be performed by Special Judge is independent role for the purpose of deciding the protest petition in accordance with the provision contained in the Code of Criminal Procedure. This will not affect the power of the Investigating Agency to further investigate in the matter. We clarify that nothing stated would affect the disposal of the protest petition by the Special Judge, where the protest petition is pending. The said petition may be disposed of by Special Judge in accordance with law and uninfluenced by anything stated by us in this order.
49 With these observations, present petition is disposed of. The Central Bureau of Investigation will carry out the further investigation in the matter and for that purpose, the Investigating Agency of the State of M.P would render all the relevant records as may be required by the Central Bureau of Investigation. However, such investigation shall be carried out within a period of six months from the date which starts the investigation, which of course, must be initiated within two weeks after the receipt of this order.
( P.K.JAISWAL J. ) ( M.C. GARG, J. )
amol
48