AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2023 DHC 7379
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2023 DHC 7379
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition was filed by the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner (RPFC), Gurgaon East, challenging an order dated 23.03.2023 passed by the Presiding Officer of the Central Government Industrial Tribunal cum Labour Court-II (CGIT), Rouse Avenue, Delhi. The CGIT had set aside the original order passed by the RPFC. The RPFC contended jurisdiction before this Court on the basis that the impugned order was passed by the CGIT located in Delhi.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Delhi High Court has territorial jurisdiction to entertain the writ petition challenging an order passed by the CGIT, Delhi, when both the petitioner and respondent establishments are situated outside Delhi.
  2. Whether the principle of forum non-conveniens should be applied to decline jurisdiction despite a fraction of cause of action arising within the territorial limits of this Court.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The RPFC argued that since the appellate authority (CGIT) that passed the impugned order is situated in Delhi, this Court has jurisdiction to entertain the petition.

The respondent did not appear or file arguments before this Court.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kusum Ingots & Alloys Ltd. v. Union of India, (2004) 6 SCC 254 Even if a small part of the cause of action arises within a High Court's jurisdiction, it is not determinative for entertaining a writ petition. Supported the principle that territorial jurisdiction cannot be claimed solely because the appellate authority is located within the Court's jurisdiction.
Ambica Industries v. CCE, (2007) 6 SCC 769 Reinforcement of the principle limiting jurisdiction based on cause of action location. Reinforced the discretionary exercise of writ jurisdiction and application of forum non-conveniens.
State of Goa v. Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd., (2023) 7 SCC 791 Clarified the limitations of jurisdiction despite a part of cause of action arising within a court's territorial limits. Further supported the principle that territorial location of the tribunal alone does not confer jurisdiction.
Sterling Agro Industries Ltd. vs. Union of India & Ors., 2011 SCC OnLine Del 3162 Established that the situs of tribunal or appellate authority is not the sole foundation for jurisdiction; forum non-conveniens must be considered. Applied to hold that Delhi High Court was not a convenient forum for the petition despite the appellate authority being located in Delhi.
Chinteshwar Steel Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India, 2012 SCC OnLine Del 5264 The mere location of statutory authorities within a court’s jurisdiction is insufficient to establish a material cause of action. Used to emphasize that the situs of tribunal is not determinative of jurisdiction and to prevent potential misuse of writ jurisdiction.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the territorial jurisdiction issue by noting that both the petitioner (RPFC) and the respondent establishment are situated in Gurgaon, Haryana, outside Delhi. Although the appellate authority (CGIT) is located in Delhi, the Court emphasized that the writ jurisdiction is discretionary and must be exercised in consonance with the principle of forum non-conveniens. Relying on binding Supreme Court precedents and a Full Bench decision of this Court, the Court held that the mere presence of the tribunal within the Court's territorial jurisdiction does not automatically confer jurisdiction. The Court reasoned that entertaining the petition in Delhi would not be convenient, especially since the cause of action and parties are primarily located outside Delhi. The Court also highlighted the risk of conflicting orders and potential misuse if jurisdiction were solely based on the tribunal's location.

Holding and Implications

The petition is dismissed.

The Court declined to exercise jurisdiction over the writ petition on grounds of forum non-conveniens, holding that the Delhi High Court is not the appropriate forum despite the appellate authority being located in Delhi. The petitioner was granted liberty to approach the appropriate forum for redressal. No new precedent was set; the decision reaffirms existing principles limiting territorial jurisdiction based merely on the location of the tribunal or appellate authority.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    REGIONAL PROVIDENT FUND COMMISSIONER GURGAON EAST  v. M/S BSC- C AND C JV

    2023:DHC:7379

    $~38

    * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

    + W.P.(C) 12888/2023 and CM APPL.50775/2023 & 50776/2023

    Date of Decision: 03.10.2023

    IN THE MATTER OF:

    REGIONAL PROVIDENT FUND COMMISSIONER

    (GURGAON EAST)

    PLOT NO. 43, SECTOR 44

    GURGAON - 122002 .... PETITIONER Through: Mr.Sandeep Mishra, SC EPC, Ms.Nandika Vyas, Mr.Ashish Choudhary and Mr,.Shurbhit Nandan, Advocates. versus

    M/S BSC- C AND C JV

    PLOT NO. 70, INDUSTRIAL SECTOR 32

    GURGAON-122002 ..... RESPONDENT Through: Counsel through VC (Appearance not given).

    HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV

    O R D E R

    PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV, J. (ORAL)

    1. The present petition has been filed by the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, Gurgaon East (hereinafter 'RPFC') challenging the order dated 23.03.2023, passed in appeal by the Presiding Officer, Central Government Industrial Tribunal cum Labour Court-II, Rouse Avenue, Delhi (hereinafter 'CGIT'), whereby the order in original passed by the RPFC was

    1

    -2-

    set aside.

    2. When questioned about the aspect of territorial jurisdiction, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the RPFC submits that since the impugned order has been passed by the CGIT situated in Delhi, therefore, this court has the jurisdiction to entertain the instant petition.

    3. I have heard learned counsel for the petitioner.

    4. The facts of the case show that the concerned RPFC is situated in Gurgaon, East, Haryana. The respondent-Establishment is also situated in Gurgaon, Haryana. It is also to be noted that it is only the appellate authority i.e. CGIT, Delhi that is situated within the territorial jurisdiction of this court.

    5. Undoubtedly, a fraction of cause of action does arise within this court's jurisdiction as the appellate authority is situated in Delhi. However, it is well settled that the writ jurisdiction of this court is discretionary and has to be exercised in consonance with the principle of forum non-conveniens.

    6. The Hon'ble Supreme Court, in the cases of Kusum Ingots & Alloys Ltd. v. Union of India 1, Ambica Industries v. CCE 2 and State of Goa v. Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd.,3 has unequivocally held that even if a small part of the cause of action arises within the territorial jurisdiction of a High Court, the same alone cannot be a determinative factor for courts to entertain a writ petition.

    7. The principle of forum non-conveniens has also been fleshed out

    1 (2004) 6 SCC 254

    2 (2 007) 6 SCC 769

    3 (2023 ) 7 SCC 791

    -3-

    through a decision of the Full Bench of five Hon'ble judges of this court in

    Sterling Agro Industries Ltd. vs. Union of India & Ors.4, wherein it was held that the whole foundation of the cause of action cannot be the situs of the tribunal/ appellate authority/ revisional authority while excluding the concept of forum non-conveniens. This view has been subsequently followed in a plethora of cases including the case of Chinteshwar Steel Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India5, where the court has held that the mere fact that the statutory authorities are located within the jurisdiction of the court is not sufficient to constitute a material cause of action. This court has pithily made the following observations in paragraph 27 of the order:

    "27. The enunciation of legal principles in the aforementioned judgments would show that in case of pan India Tribunals, or Tribunals/statutory authorities having jurisdiction over several States, the situs of the Tribunal would not necessarily be the marker for identifying the jurisdictional High Court. If the submission of the petitioner is accepted, it would potentially lead to conflict of orders and possible misuse by the litigants. In nutshell, applying the ratio of the judgment of the Full Bench of this Court in Sterling Agro-industries, in particular observations made in paragraphs 33(a), (c) and (d), as explained by various judgments of this Court, I am of the view that this Court would not be a convenient forum for the following reasons: the order impugned in the present writ petition is not only of the Revisional Authority but also of the respondent no. 2/State of Maharashtra. There are several applicants, as noticed above, who are potentially aggrieved by the decision of the respondent No. 2/State Government of Maharashtra. The petitioner, the State Government of Maharashtra and respondent No. 3 and other respondents except the Revisional Authority, are located outside the jurisdiction of this Court. At the stage at which, challenge has been laid before the Revisional Authority, the Central Government has little or no role to play."

    [Emphasis supplied]

    8. In the present case, both the parties are situated within the territorial

    -4-

    jurisdiction of another High Court. The sole fact that the appellate authority is incidentally located in Delhi is not a compelling ground to entertain the instant petition.

    9. In view of the aforesaid, this court is not inclined to entertain the instant petition and therefore, the same is accordingly, dismissed alongwith the pending applications.

    10. The petitioner would, however, be at liberty to approach the appropriate forum to seek redressal of its grievance, in accordance with law.

    PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV, J

    OCTOBER 3, 2023/MJ/rg

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    REGIONAL PROVIDENT FUND COMMISSIONER GURGAON EAST  v. M/S BSC- C AND C JV
    (Oct 3, 2023)