Loading..
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Acts
  • SECTION 18 LIMITATION ACT
  • SECTION 7 INSOLVENCY AND BANKRUPTCY CODE 2016
  • SECTION 128 CONTRACT ACT
  • SECTION 134 CONTRACT ACT
  • SECTION 60 INSOLVENCY AND BANKRUPTCY CODE 2016
  • SECTION 135 CONTRACT ACT
  • SECTION 25 CONTRACT ACT
  • COMPANIES ACT 1956
  • Section 238 of IBC, the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code
  • Article 57 of the schedule to the Limitation Act, 1908. Limitation,
  • 11 IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022 Date of Order : 14.09.2023 of Limitation Act, Section 29 of the Limitation Act
  • Section 15(1) of Sick Industrial Companies Act (SICA)
  • 19 IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022 Date of Order : 14.09.2023 under Section 18 of the Limitation Act
  • II IA(IBC) No.58 of 2023 in CP(IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022 [Section 95 IBC, 2016 r/w Section 232 read withRule 7(2)
  • Contract Act (between Sections 130 to 141). Section 141
  • Section 3 (1) and Article 55 of the Limitation Act and Section 238 (A) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code read with Rule 11
  • Section 15(1) of 7 IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022 Date of Order : 14.09.2023 the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 (SICA)
  • section 41 of the SARFAESI Act, 2002.
  • Section 15(1) of Sick Industrial Company Act (SICA)
  • Sections 14 & 18 of the Limitation Act,
  • section 7, 9 and 10 of the Code.
  • Article 115 of the schedule to the Limitation Act, 1908.
  • Section 4 of the SICA (Repeal) Act
  • Section 15(1) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provision) Act.
  • section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act, 2002
  • Section 19 of the Recovery of Debts due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 and under Section 15(1) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985,
  • Code (Second Amendment) Act, 2018]. Another reference to Limitation Act
  • Article 55 of the Limitation Act
  • Article 55 of Limitation Act and Section 238 (A) of the IBC read with Rule 11 of NCLT Rules
  • Article 137 of the Limitation Act
  • Section 7 of the Code,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Acts
  • SECTION 18 LIMITATION ACT
  • SECTION 7 INSOLVENCY AND BANKRUPTCY CODE 2016
  • SECTION 128 CONTRACT ACT
  • SECTION 134 CONTRACT ACT
  • SECTION 60 INSOLVENCY AND BANKRUPTCY CODE 2016
  • SECTION 135 CONTRACT ACT
  • SECTION 25 CONTRACT ACT
  • COMPANIES ACT 1956
  • Section 238 of IBC, the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code
  • Article 57 of the schedule to the Limitation Act, 1908. Limitation,
  • 11 IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022 Date of Order : 14.09.2023 of Limitation Act, Section 29 of the Limitation Act
  • Section 15(1) of Sick Industrial Companies Act (SICA)
  • 19 IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022 Date of Order : 14.09.2023 under Section 18 of the Limitation Act
  • II IA(IBC) No.58 of 2023 in CP(IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022 [Section 95 IBC, 2016 r/w Section 232 read withRule 7(2)
  • Contract Act (between Sections 130 to 141). Section 141
  • Section 3 (1) and Article 55 of the Limitation Act and Section 238 (A) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code read with Rule 11
  • Section 15(1) of 7 IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022 Date of Order : 14.09.2023 the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 (SICA)
  • section 41 of the SARFAESI Act, 2002.
  • Section 15(1) of Sick Industrial Company Act (SICA)
  • Sections 14 & 18 of the Limitation Act,
  • section 7, 9 and 10 of the Code.
  • Article 115 of the schedule to the Limitation Act, 1908.
  • Section 4 of the SICA (Repeal) Act
  • Section 15(1) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provision) Act.
  • section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act, 2002
  • Section 19 of the Recovery of Debts due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 and under Section 15(1) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985,
  • Code (Second Amendment) Act, 2018]. Another reference to Limitation Act
  • Article 55 of the Limitation Act
  • Article 55 of Limitation Act and Section 238 (A) of the IBC read with Rule 11 of NCLT Rules
  • Article 137 of the Limitation Act
  • Section 7 of the Code,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Financial Creditor, M/s Stressed Assets Stabilization Fund (SASF), a trust established by the Government of India, filed Company Petition No.314/2022 under Section 95(2) read with Section 60(2) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) and Rule 7(2) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy (Application to Adjudicating Authority for Insolvency Resolution Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtors) Rules, 2019. The petition sought initiation of Insolvency Resolution Process against Mr. D. Srinivas Rao, the Personal Guarantor of M/s Priyaranjani Fibres Limited (Corporate Debtor), for default on a loan of Rs. 990 lakhs taken on 15.09.1994.

The Personal Guarantor challenged the maintainability of the Company Petition by filing IA No.58/2023, contending that the petition was barred by limitation under Article 55 of the Limitation Act and Section 238A of the IBC read with Rule 11 of the NCLT Rules. The default was admitted to have occurred on 01.04.1997, and the guarantor argued that notices issued in 2021 and 2022 were not legally valid to revive limitation.

Prior proceedings included recovery applications before the Debts Recovery Tribunal (DRT), Chennai, where a Recovery Certificate was issued in 2009. The Corporate Debtor was declared a sick company by the Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (BIFR) in 2004, with subsequent appeals and proceedings continuing until the repeal of SICA in 2016. The Financial Creditor issued multiple Demand Notices and One Time Settlement (OTS) proposals were made by the applicant and others over the years. The Company Petition was filed on 21.09.2022. The Tribunal heard arguments primarily focused on the question of limitation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Company Petition under Section 95 of the IBC has been filed within the prescribed limitation period.
  2. Whether the limitation period was extended or revived by acknowledgments such as OTS proposals or proceedings before DRT, BIFR, and AIFR.
  3. The applicability of provisions of the Limitation Act, 1963, including Section 18, and Section 238A of the IBC to the present case.
  4. The effect of the continuing guarantee and the date from which limitation runs against the personal guarantor.
  5. Whether the proceedings under SICA and pending litigations exclude or suspend limitation.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The default occurred on 01.04.1997, and the Company Petition filed in 2022 is therefore barred by limitation of 3 years under Article 55 of the Limitation Act.
  • No valid acknowledgment of debt was made within 3 years from the date of default; hence Section 18 of the Limitation Act does not apply.
  • The demand notices issued in 2021 and 2022 are not legally valid to revive limitation.
  • Proceedings before DRT, BIFR, and appeals do not extend the limitation period.
  • Renewal of contract under OTS was with the Corporate Debtor and not with the applicant, discharging the applicant under Section 135 of the Contract Act.
  • Reliance on Supreme Court and NCLAT decisions including Kotak Mahindra Bank v. A. Balakrishnan, Bimal Kumar v. BOI, Deepak Vegpro v. Srihari Agro, and others to support limitation bar.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Invocation of guarantee deed was on 30.12.1999 and subsequent Recovery Certificate dated 19.11.2009 revived the cause of action.
  • Proceedings before DRT, BIFR, and AIFR were pending within limitation and suspension under SICA applies to exclude limitation period.
  • OTS proposals and payments made by the applicant and associates constitute valid acknowledgment under Section 18 of the Limitation Act, extending limitation.
  • The liability of the personal guarantor is co-extensive and continuous with that of the Corporate Debtor as per the guarantee deed clauses.
  • Reliance on Supreme Court decisions including Dena Bank v. C. Shivakumar Reddy, Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd. v. Hotel Poonja International Pvt. Ltd., and others to support the petition's maintainability.
  • The applicant attempted to delay the CIRP process by filing the IA challenging limitation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited versus A. Balakrishnan, AIR 2022 SC 2652 Applicability of Section 18 of the Limitation Act to IBC proceedings and limitation period for insolvency petitions. Supported the view that limitation applies and that no acknowledgment was made within limitation period to extend it.
Dena Bank (Now Bank of Baroda) versus C. Shivakumar Reddy, (2021) 10 SCC 330 One Time Settlement proposals can constitute acknowledgment of debt under Section 18 of Limitation Act. Held that OTS offers made within limitation extend limitation period; relied upon to find limitation not barred.
Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd. versus Hotel Poonja International Pvt. Ltd., (2021) 7 SCC 352 Judgment/decree or certificate of recovery gives rise to fresh cause of action for filing insolvency petition within 3 years. Applied to hold that Recovery Certificate issued in 2009 gave fresh cause of action for petition filed within 3 years of IBC enforcement.
B.K. Educational Services (P) Ltd. versus Parag Gupta & Associates, AIR 2018 SC 560 Cause of action accrues and limitation starts from date of default. Reaffirmed that limitation period for insolvency petitions starts on date of default.
K. Shashidhar versus Indian Overseas Bank, (2019) 12 SCC 150 Restatement of principles that right to sue under IBC accrues on date of default. Confirmed that if default occurred more than 3 years prior to filing, petition is barred.
Ansal Engineering Projects Ltd. versus Tehri Hydro Development Corporation Ltd., 1996 (5) SCC 450 Bank guarantee is independent contract; liability of guarantor is continuous unless discharged. Used to explain continuing guarantee and liability of guarantor running from invocation date.
State Bank of India versus Index Port, (1992) 3 SCC 159 Guarantor may be sued without suing principal debtor; liabilities are separate though arising from same transaction. Clarified that guarantor's liability is separate and limitation runs from demand on guarantor.
Jignesh Shah and Another versus Union of India and Another, (2019) 10 SCC 750 Limitation period once begun can only be extended as prescribed by Limitation Act. Emphasized that procedural remedies barred by limitation do not extinguish debt; extension must be as per Limitation Act.
Sesh Nath Singh and Ors. versus Baidyabati Sheoraphuli Co-operative Bank Ltd. and Ors., (2021) 7 SCC 313 Period during which remedy is suspended under SICA is excluded from limitation computation. Applied to exclude period of suspension due to SICA proceedings from limitation period.
Margaret Lalita Samuel versus The Indo Commercial Bank Ltd., AIR 1979 SC 102 Continuing guarantee means limitation runs from breach/refusal to perform obligation. Supported reasoning on continuing guarantee and limitation running from date of breach.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal examined the facts and submissions regarding limitation. It noted that the default occurred on 01.04.1997, but the petition was filed only in 2022, about 25 years later. The applicant contended this was barred by limitation, relying on admitted default and absence of acknowledgment within 3 years.

The Court analyzed the guarantee deed, which provided a continuing guarantee with liability co-extensive and continuous with the principal debtor. The limitation against the guarantor starts from the date the guarantee is invoked and the guarantor refuses or fails to comply, here on 30.12.1999.

The Court considered the effect of OTS proposals and payments, finding that these constituted valid acknowledgments under Section 18 of the Limitation Act, thereby extending the limitation period. The applicant made several OTS offers and payments both individually and as Vice-Chairman of the Corporate Debtor, acknowledging liability repeatedly.

Proceedings before the Debts Recovery Tribunal, BIFR, and AIFR were ongoing within limitation, and the period of suspension under SICA was excluded from limitation computation. The Court noted the repeal of SICA in 2016 and the consequent accrual of cause of action under the IBC.

The Court relied on binding Supreme Court precedents to affirm that limitation applies to insolvency proceedings but can be extended by acknowledgment or suspension of proceedings as per law. It held that the cause of action accrued afresh on issuance of the Recovery Certificate in 2009 and was not barred by limitation when filed under the IBC after 2016.

Accordingly, the Court found that the Company Petition was within limitation and dismissed the IA challenging maintainability on limitation grounds.

Holding and Implications

The Tribunal DISMISSED IA(IBC) No.58/2023 filed by the Personal Guarantor challenging the limitation of Company Petition No.314/2022.

The holding confirms that the limitation period for insolvency petitions against personal guarantors runs from the date of invocation of the guarantee and refusal to pay, and can be extended by acknowledgments such as OTS proposals or by suspension of proceedings under laws like SICA. The period during which proceedings before other authorities like BIFR and DRT were pending and the SICA suspension period are excluded from limitation computation.

This decision directly affects the parties by upholding the maintainability of the insolvency petition filed by SASF against the personal guarantor. No new precedent is set beyond application of established legal principles and Supreme Court precedents.

    D. SRINIVAS RAOS/o.ShriSimhabaludu the personal guarantor of M/s. PriyaranjanFibres Limited. D.No. 7-1-79/C Plot No.601 Street No. 11DharamKaram Road Ameerpet Hyderabad-500016 v. M/s. STRESSED ASSETS STABILIZATION FUND SASF

    SL. No.4

    NATIONAL COMPANY LAW TRIBUNAL

    HYDERABAD BENCH

    COURT HALL NO: II

    PHYSICAL HEARING

    CORAM: SHRI. RAJEEV BHARDWAJ - HON'BLE MEMBER (J)

    CORAM: SHRI. SANJAY PURI - HON'BLE MEMBER (T)

    ATTENDANCE-CUM-ORDER SHEET OF THE HEARING OF NATIONAL COMPANY LAW TRIBUNAL, HYDERABAD BENCH, HELD ON 14.09.2023, At 10:30 AM

    TRANSFER PETITION NO.
    COMPANY PETITION/APPLICATION NO. IA(IBC) 58/2023 IN Company Petition IB/314/2022
    NAME OF THE COMPANY
    NAME OF THE PETITIONER(S) Stressed Assets Stabilisation Fund (SASF)
    NAME OF THE RESPONDENT(S) Mr. D. Srinivas Rao
    UNDER SECTION 95 of IBC

    ORDER

    IA(IBC) 58/2023 Present: Ld. Counsel Mr. Dishit Battacharjee for the Applicant. Orders pronounced, recorded vide separate sheets. In the result, this application is dismissed.

    Company Petition IB/314/2022

    For hearing, call on 09.11.2023.

    Sd/- Sd/-

    MEMBER (T) MEMBER (J)

    Vamsi

    1

    IN THE NATIONAL COMPANY LAW TRIBUNAL

    HYDERABAD BENCH - II

    IA(IBC) No.58 of 2023 in

    CP(IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    [Section 95 IBC, 2016 r/w Section 232 read withRule 7(2) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy (Application to Adjudicating Authority for Insolvency Resolution Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtor) Rules, 2019]

    In the matter of Mr.D.Srinivas Rao (Personal Guarantor to M/s.Priyaranjani Fibres Limited)

    BETWEEN

    D.Srinivas Rao, S/o.Sri Simhabaludu, the Personal Guarantor of

    M/s.PriyaranjanFibres Limited, D.No.7-1-79/C, Plot No.601,

    Street No.11, Dharamkaram Road, Ameerpet, Hyderabad - 500 016. ….Applicant/Personal Guarantor

    AND

    M/s.STRESSED ASSETS STABILIZATION FUND (SASF), having its Registered Office at:

    3rd Floor, IDBI Tower,

    WTC Complex, Cuffe Parade,

    MUMBAI - 400 005.

    Represented by Santosh V.Shinde, Deputy General Manager.

    …. Respondent/Financial Creditor

    Coram:

    Hon'ble Rajeev Bhardwaj, Member (Judicial) Hon'ble Sanjay Puri, Member (Technical)

    Counsel/Parties present:

    For the Petitioner : Mr.D.Srinivas Rao, Personal Guarantor. For the Respondent : Mr.Dishit Bhattacharjee, Advocate

    2

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023

    O R D E R

    Date of Order: 14.09.2023

    The Financial Creditor, M/S Stressed Assets Stabilization Fund has filed petition under Section 95(2) Section 60(2) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code 2016 (herein-after-referred to as the IBC) read with Rule 7(2) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy (Application to Adjudicating Authority for Insolvency Resolution Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtors) Rules, 2019 to initiate Insolvency Resolution Process against the Personal Guarantor (herein-after- referred to as the Applicant) of the Corporate Debtor i.e., M/S Priyaranjan Fibres Limited. The Applicant instead of filing counter to the petition, filed the IA No.58/2003, challenging the maintainability of CP No.314/95/HDB/2022 on the ground of limitation under Article 55 of Limitation Act and Section 238 (A) of the IBC read with Rule 11 of NCLT Rules .

    1. The brief facts necessary to dispose of the present application, as stated, are that:

    1.1 M/S Stressed Assets Stabilization Fund (SASF) (hereinafter referred to as the Respondent) was incorporated as a Trust established by the Government of India on 24thSeptember, 2004 and entrusted to acquire and absorb stressed assets transferred to it by the erstwhile IDBI, filed the Company Petition No.314/2022 to initiate Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) against the Personal Guarantor of Corporate Debtor, M/S Priyaranjani Fibres Limited.

    1.2 It is averred that the Corporate Debtor secured a term loan of Rs.990 lakhs on 15.09.1994 and for repayment of the said amount, the personal guarantor alongwith Sri V.Raman and Sri K.Jawaharlal Reddy stood guarantors and executed Guarantee Deed dated 15thSeptember, 1994.

    2

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023

    1.3 When the Corporate Debtor committed default in paying the loan amount, the Financial Creditor filed an application before the Debts Recovery Tribunal, Chennai, wherein the personal guarantor and Corporate Debtor were asked to repay the loan amount and accordingly on the basis of the Recovery Certificate No.106/2009, notice dated 20thNovember, 2009 was issued demanding the payment of the amount. Despite this, the Corporate Debtor and personal guarantor committed default in paying the amount.

    1.4 After coming into force of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy (Application to Adjudicating Authority for Insolvency Resolution Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtors) Rules, 2019, the respondent issued Demand Notices dated 13.09.2021 and 22.04.2022 to the Applicant. When the Applicant failed to make the payment of the loan amount, the respondent approached this Authority by filing the Company Petition No.314/2022.

    2. The Applicant by filing the present application under Section 3 (1) and Article 55 of the Limitation Act and Section 238 (A) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code read with Rule 11 of the NCLT Rules claimed that the Company Petition No.314/2022 is hopelessly barred by limitation.

    2.1 It has been explained that the default in paying the debt took place on 01.04.1997 which has been admitted by the respondent by filing affidavit in the proceedings before the Debts Recovery Tribunal. Hence, the respondent has wrongly claimed that the demand notices were issued on 13.09.2021 and 22.04.2022 are legally valid.

    3

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023

    2.2 Further, the Corporate Debtor vide reference No.266/2001 under Section 15(1) of Sick Industrial Companies Act (SICA) prayed to declare the Corporate Debtor as sick company. It is claimed that the proceedings before the Debts Recovery Tribunal in OA 373/2007 and the Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (BIFR) in reference No.366 of 2021 would also not save the limitation period to file the CP against the applicant.

    2.3 It is averred that the Corporate Debtor entered into a fresh contract with the respondent under the OTS scheme for payment of Rs.376 lakhs vide letter dated 22.11.2008 and acceptance letter dated 17.12.2008. As contract was renewed by the respondent with the Corporate Debtor and not with the applicant, the latter was discharged from any liability under Section 135 of the Contract Act.

    3. The respondent has filed a counter to the aforesaid IA by submitting that the recovery notice was issued to the Corporate Debtor on 23-12-1999 and the guarantee deed was invoked by letter dated 30.12.1999. When the payment was not received, the respondent filed OA No.222/2000 before the Debts Recovery Tribunal, Chennai. This OA was subsequently transferred to Debts Recovery Tribunal II, Chennai and renumbered as OA No.373/2007. Finally, the Corporate Debtor and the Applicant were directed to pay a sum of Rs.49,77,88,997.79 and accordingly the Recovery Officer issued demand notice on 20.11.2009 as per Recovery Certificate No.116 of 2009. This Recovery Certificate was amended on 02.03.2021 in MA 146/2000 in OA No.373/2007.

    3.1 The respondent has specifically made reference of declaration of the account of the Corporate Debtor as NPA on 01.02.2000, making a reference No.366/2001 by the applicant to the Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (BIFR) under Section 15(1) of Sick Industrial Company Act (SICA) to declare the

    4

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023 Corporate Debtor a sick industry and pendency of proceedings before the BIFR and Appellate Authority for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (AAIFR) and recovery proceedings before the DRT II, Chennai to claim that the CP has been filed within the period of limitation. In this regard, the respondent has also relied upon OTS proposals made by the Applicant on 02.04.2019, 20.04.2013,

    08.08.2015, 03.07.2017, 08.09.2017, 13.10.2017, 15.11.2017, 17.02.2018,

    06.04.2019, 17.09.2019, 14.01.2020, 20.02.2021 and 20.02.2022.

    3.2 Thus, the applicant is liable to pay the outstanding amount to the respondent in accordance with the guarantee agreement in view of clause 3, clause 4, clause 5, clause 6, clause 10, clause 15, clause 16, clause 17 and clause 18.

    3.3 In these circumstances, it is submitted that the applicant wanted to delay the CIRP process by filing the present IA.

    4. On the basis of the pleadings and discussions, the following points arise for determination.

    Whether the CP has been filed within the limitation period.

    5. We have gone through the entire record and heard the Ld. Counsels for both the parties.

    6. The Corporate Debtor is engaged in the business of manufacturing carded as well as combed cotton yarn with installed capacity of 24,960 spindles at Ibrahimpatnam, Rangareddy district, Andhra Pradesh. The Corporate Debtor availed a loan of Rs. 990 lakhs on 15.09.1994 from erstwhile Industrial Development Bank of India. The Central Government created a trust by the name 'Stressed Assets Stabilization Fund' (hereinafter named as "SASF"), the present Financial Creditor, vide Trust Deed dated 24.09.2004 for acquiring non-

    5

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023 performance assets and consequently the IDBI transferred and released to SASF all the loan/facilities sanctioned by the IDBI to the Corporate Debtor.

    7. Both the parties have not disputed the following facts:

    General

     Execution of the Loan Agreement Annexure-1 dated 15.09.2004 in CP between M/S Priyaaranjan Fibres Limited, Corporate Debtor, and Industrial Development Bank of India, Lender, for the advancement of loan of Rs. 990 lakhs.

     Hypothecation Deed Annexure-3 in CPfor the hypothecation of assets of the borrower to the lender was executed on 15.09.1994.

     Sh. D. Srinivas Rao, the applicant, Sri V.Raman and Sri K.Jawaharlal Reddystood guarantors for the repayment of the said loan. Guarantee Agreement dated 15.09.1994 Annexure-4 inCPwasexecuted between both the parties.

     At the request of the Corporate Debtor, the respondent granted reschedulement in repayment of the loan disbursed, to repay the principal amount in 32 quarterly installments commencing from Oct 1, 1999 to July 1, 2007 vide letter dated 23.04.1998 [Para No. 12 of OA 222 of 2000

    Enclosure 1 of the Counter to the report filed by the RP and order10.08.2009passed by the DRT in OA No.O 373 0f 2007. [Enclosure 3

    of the Counter to the report filed by the RP]  Default in making the payment of the loan amount on01.04.1997 as per para No.-iv and page 5 of the affidavit filed by the Financial Creditor in O.A. 222/2000 before the D.R.T.Chennai and which is further recorded in its order [Para No. 14 of OA 222 of 2000 as Annexure 1 in IA]

    6

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023  On account of default, the loan amount was recalled vide letter dated

    27.12.1999

     Invocation of the guarantee deed vide letter dt. 30.12.1999 Annexure5 [Para No. 5 of the Counter to IA and para No. 15 of OA 222 of 2000 as

    Annexure 1 in IA]  The Corporate Debtor, Priyaranjani Fibres Limited has been admitted in Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process under Section 7 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 vide order dated 24.03.2023 in CP (IB) No. 574/7/HDB/2019, titled Stressed Assets Stabilisation Fund versus Priyaranjani Fibers Ltd.

     The Company Petition No.314/95/HDB/2022 was filed on 21.09.2022

    B. Proceedings before the Debts Recovery Tribunal, Chennai

     The Financial Creditor on 01.02.2000 filed O.A. No. 222 of 2000 for the recovery Rs. 1778. 78 lakhs against the Corporate Debtor and applicant before the DRT, Chennai which was subsequently transferred to DRT-II at Chennai and renumbered as O.A. No. 373 of 2007.

     The Recovery Certificate at page no. 60 to 64 of Counter to IAwas issued on dated 19.11.2009 to pay a total sum of Rs. 49,77,88,997.79 comprising of Rs 1178.78 lakhs as principal and Rs. 31,97,60,997.79 as interest and Rs. 1,50,000 as costs. The Recovery Certificate was amended vide Annexure 10 dt 22.3.2021.

    C. Proceedings before BIFR & AIFR

     The applicant made a reference No. 366 of 2001 dated 18.08.2001

    Annexure - 4 (page No.61 of Preliminary Counter) under Section 15(1) of

    7

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023 the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 (SICA) to the BIFR to declare the Corporate Debtor as a Sick Industry.  On 17.09.2009, the BIFR appointed IDBI as the operating agency under section 16(20) of the SICA to conduct an SIA into the accounts of the Company.

     In the proceedings dt. 27.12.2004 (Page 21 of the Counter to the IA), show cause notice was issued to the applicant.

     In the meeting dated 27.12.2004, the BIFR declared the Corporate Debtor as sick industry under 3(1)(0) of the SICA.

     On 22.11.2011 (Page 81 of the Counter to the IA), the BIFR in case No.368 of 2001 directed that Reddy Group to continue to manage the affairs of the company.

     Against the order dated 22.11.2011 in Case No. 366 of 2001, the Corporate Debtor has preferred an appeal No. 31 of 2012 before the Appellate Authority for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction and vide order dated 22.11.2011 (Page No.100 of the Counter to the IA) stayed further proceedings before the BIFR including the impugned direction given vide dt.22.11.2011.

     On 01.12.2016, the SICA was repealed.

     The proceedings before the AIFR stood abated in February, 2017 in terms of Section 4 of the SICA (Repeal) Act which has come into force w.e.f.

    16.12.2016.

    8. Within the aforesaid admitted position, learned counsel for both the parties confined their arguments on the question of limitation.

    8

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023

    9. Ld Counsel for applicant has argued that the default in repaying the loan amount took place on 01.04.1997 and accordingly the CP should have been filed within the next 3 years, but the respondent took about 25 years to approach this Forum. The default of debt has been admitted by the respondent in para 4 of the affidavit filed before the Debts Recovery Tribunal, Chennai and this fact has also been recorded in the letter of the Tribunal in para Nos.2.5 and 2.7 of their letter dated 10.08.2009. The respondent is also not saved under Section 18 of the Limitation Act because no acknowledgement of the debt was made either by the Corporate Debtor or applicant within 3 years from the date of default. In this regard, he has placed reliance on the decision of the Apex Court in Kotak Mahindra versus A. Bala Krishnan AIR 2022 SC 2652 and Kotak Mahindra versus A.Balakrishnan AIR 2022 SC 2652 and decision of Hon'ble NCLAT in

    Bimal Kumar versus BOI decided 05.03.2020 and Deepak Vegpro versus Srihari Agro decided on 11.10.2022 by the NCLAT.

    9.2 In another case, the NCLT Amarvathi Bench in SBI versus .M/s. N.Madhavi filed U/s 95 of the IBC, dismissed the petition on 22.12.2022 on limitation, while holding:

    "It was held that Section 18 of the Limitation Act, applies to the proceedings under IBC is too well settled that it is applicable".

    9.3 On the question as which Article is applicable to file petition under section 95 of the IBC, Ld Counsel has referred to Article 55 of the Limitation Act which states that the limitation will start from the date of execution of the guarantee deed on 15.09.1994. Even, in the proceedings under the IBC Act, it would not be of any benefit to the respondent. He has also relied upon the decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in M/S Reliance Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd. and M/S Hotle Poonja International Pvt. Ltd, Civil Appeal No. 4221 of 2020 and further of three

    9

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023 Members Bench of Hon'ble NCLAT, decided on dated 05.03.2020 in Bhimal Kumar Manu Bhai versus Bank of India which has held in paragraph -9;

    "9 .. .. We are of the view that the SARFAESI and DRT proceeding will not extend the period of limitation since those proceedings are independent and as per Section 238 of IBC, the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code is a complete Code and will have overriding effect on other laws. Therefore, the proceedings initiated or pending in DRT, either initiated or pending in DRT, either initiated under SARFAESI or under debts and due to Banks and Financial Institutions cannot be taken into account for the purposes of limitation.

    OTS was not accepted by the 1st Respondent/the Financial Creditor, therefore, the same cannot be treated as an acknowledgement in view of Section 18 of the Limitation Act, 1963.

    9.4 Regarding the OTS proposals/offers, it is submitted that these were made after 3 years of committing default and further by the Corporate Debtor and not the applicant. So there was no acknowledgement, w.e.f., 21.04.2012 to 03.07.2017 and further the unauthorized letter dated 08.08.2015 issued by one Sri K.Sivananda Reddy has been placed on record only for the purpose of misleading and in order to prove his point of view, Ld Counsel for the applicant has relied upon the judgments in Deena Bank versus Siva Kumar Reddy (2022)10 SCC 330 and Amaravathi Bench in SBI versus N.Madhavi decided on 22.12.2012.

    9.5 Ld Counsel for the personal guarantor has also submitted that section 22(5) of SICA Act is also not attracted to exclude the limitation period and in this context he has relied on the decision of the Hon'ble NCLAT in the matter of

    M/s.Invent Assets Securitization versus M/s.Girnar Fibers Ltd decided on 18.11.2021 and the said order of the NCLAT was upheld by Hon'ble Supreme Court (2022) Live Law (SC) 423) on 25.04.2022 while dismissing the application as time barred vide para 10 of its order held thus;

    "Section 22(5) of SICA, 1968 is not attracted to the present case since the period of limitation i.e., 3 years had already expired before the BIFR reference was made by the Corporate Debtor.

    10

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023 Any reference before the BIFR is abated, if secured creditors have taken measures under section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act, 2002 as provided for under section 41 of the SARFAESI Act, 2002. The period between 25.04.2006 when the corporate debtor was declared sick by BIFR under SICA and 04.05.2016 when the reference was dismissed cannot be excluded from computing the limitation period."

    10. On the question of OTS, the applicant has referred to various letters and claimed that no such letter was sent from 21.04.2013 to 02.07.2017. Whatever payment has been made, it was towards upfront fees for consideration of OTS and moreover the OTS offer letter dated 20.02.2019 was rejected by the respondent in addition to letters dated 07.05.2018, 16.09.2019, 30.08.2021, 18.10.2021 and 20.07.2022. Hence, there was no concrete agreement between the applicant and the respondent.

    11. The focus of Ld. Counsel for the respondent was centered around the fact that the limitation against the Personal Guarantor is co-extensive and co-terminus with the Corporate Debtor and in this regard he has made reference to para 11 (Page 98 of the counter to IA) of the Guarantee Deed, that the applicant cannot escape from the liability by saying that whatever proposals for OTS were given originated from the Corporate Debtor and not from the applicant. He has also specifically referred to the pendency of litigation before the DRT, BIFR and AIFR, which is still continuing to make point that such period is to be excluded to determine the limitation period for filing the petition under Section 95 of the IBC Code. He has also relied upon the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited versus Kew Precision Parts Private Limited and others (2022)9 Supreme Court Cases 364.

    12. Now it is the settled law that the statute of limitation only bars the remedy but does not extinguish the debt. Whenever procedural actions are barred, the rights themselves are not extinguished. While the IBC is silent on the applicability

    11

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023 of Limitation Act, Section 29 of the Limitation Act states that every legislative enactment, be it central or state legislation, is guided by the Limitation Act unless such enactment "expressly excludes" itself. Thus, the term "expressly excludes"

    can be interpreted that if the intent of the legislature is to make the special statute free from limitation, express exclusion is not necessary. In case of IBC, the provisions of the Limitation Act were expressly made applicable by introduction of Section 238A of the IBC [inserted by way of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Second Amendment) Act, 2018]. Another reference to Limitation Act in IBC is under Section 60(6) which only limits the applicability of the Act for the period of the moratorium, thus, the same doesn't bar its application to initiation under section 7, 9 and 10 of the Code.

    13. The period of limitation for filing applications for initiation of insolvency proceedings would be three years from the date of default under Article 137 of the Limitation Act [See B.K. Educational Services (P) Ltd. versus Parag Gupta & Associates AIR 2018 SC 560]. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Trustee's Port Bombay versus. The Premier Automobile 1981 AIR 1982 held that the starting point of limitation is the accrual of the cause of action. In K. Shashidhar versus Indian Overseas Bank (2019) 12 SCC 150, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court undoubtedly restated principles laid down in B.K. Educational Services supra and reaffirmed that the right to sue under the Code accrues on the date when default occurs and if the default occurred 3 years prior to the date of filing of the Application, the same would not amount to debt due and payable under the Code.

    14. For filing petition under section 54 of the IBC, the limitation period is three years from the date of arising of cause of action. As per the applicant such date is 01.04.1997 when the Corporate Debtor defaulted in making the payment of loan

    12

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023 amount and this fact has also been admitted by the respondent inpara No.-iv and page 5 of the affidavit filed in O.A. 222/2000 before the D.R.T. Chennai and further recorded in its order. [Para No. 14 of OA 222 of 2000 as Annexure 1 in

    IA].

    15. As far as the guarantor is concerned, Section 128 of the Contract says that the liability of the surety is co-extensive with that of the principal debtor, unless it is otherwise provided by the contract. The Guarantee Agreement provides that the guarantee is not only co-extensive but also continuous. Relevant clauses of the Guarantee Deed Annexure-4 are:

    5) The Guarantors hereby agree that without the concurrence of the Guarantors, the Borrower and the Lenders shall be at liberty to vary, alter or modify the terms and conditions of the Loan Agreement and of the security created and of the security documents executed by the Borrower in favour of the Lenders and in particular to defer, postpone or revise the repayment of the Loans and/ or payment of interest and other moneys payable by the Borrower to the Lenders on such terms and conditions as may be considered necessary by the Lead Institution including any increase in the rate of interest. The Lenders shall also be at liberty to absolutely dispense with or release all or any of the security/securities furnished or required to be furnished by the Borrower to the Lenders to secure the Loans. The Guarantors agree that the liability under this Guarantee shall in no manner be affected by any such variations, alterations, modifications, waiver, dispensation with or release of security, and that no further consent of the Guarantor is required for giving effect to any such variation, alteration, modification, dispensation with, or release of security. waiver, dispensation with, or release of security.

    6) The Lenders shall have full liberty, without notice to the Guarantors and without in any way affecting this guarantee, to exercise at any time and in any manner any power or powers reserved to the Lenders under the Loan Agreement, to enforce or forbear to enforce payment ofhe Loans/ Bridge Loans or any part thereof or interest or other monies due to the Lenders from the Borrower or any of the remedies or securities available to the Lenders, to enter into any composition or compound with or to grant time or any other indulgence or facility to the Borrower and the Guarantors shall not be released by the exercise by the Lenders of their liberty in regard to the matters referred to above or by any act or omission on the part of the Lenders or by any other matter or thing whatsoever or which under the law relating to sureties would but for this provision have the effect of so releasing the Guarantors and the Guarantors hereby waive in favour of the Lenders so far as may be necessary to give effect to any of the provisions of this Guarantee, all the surety- ship and other rights which the Guarantors might other- wise be entitled to enforce.

    13

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023

    11) To give effect to this Guarantee, the Lenders may act as though the Guarantors were the principal debtor to the Lenders.

    15) This Guarantee shall not be wholly or partially satisfied or exhausted by any payments made to or settled with the Lenders by the Borrower and shall be valid and binding on the Guarantors and operative until repayment in full of all monies due to the Lenders under the Loan Agreement.

    16. Here we also rely upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Ansal Engineering Projects Limited versus Tehri Hydro Development Corporation Limited and Another 1996 (5) SCC 450, wherein it was held:-

    4. It is settled law that bank guarantee is an independent and distinct contract between the bank and the beneficiary and is not qualified by the underlying transaction and the validity of the primary contract between the person at whose instance the bank guarantee was given and the beneficiary. Unless fraud or special equity exists, is pleaded and prime facie established by strong evidence as a triable issue, the beneficiary cannot be restrained from encashing the bank guarantee even if dispute between the beneficiary and the person at whose instance the bank guarantee was given by the Bank, had arisen in performance of the contract or execution of the Works undertaken in furtherance thereof. The Bank unconditionally and irrevocably promised to pay, on demand, the amount of liability undertaken in the guarantee without any demur or dispute in terms of the bank guarantee. The object behind is to inculcate respect for free flow of commerce and trade and faith in the commercial banking transactions unhedged by pending disputes between the beneficiary and the contractor.

    17. Thus, an agreement between the guarantor and creditor is separate and collateral contract distinct from the contract of debt between the principal debtor and creditor. When the demand is made against the guarantor, if the claim is a live claim against the principal debtor, limitation in respect of the guarantor will run from the date of such demand and refusal/non-compliance. As long as the account is live, the guarantor is liable as the said account has not been discharged by payment or by other arrangement.

    18. No doubt, the obligation of the guarantor is coextensive and coterminous with that of the principal borrower to defray the debit, as explained in Section 128 of the Contract Act, but the liability of the principal debtor and surety are separate

    14

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023 although arising out of the same transaction and even the liability of surety does not also, in all cases, arise simultaneously. Here we may profitably refer to the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in State Bank of India versus. Index port Registered and Ors(1992) 3 SCC 159, wherein it was held:

    16. "In Halsbury's Laws of England Forth Edition paragraph 159 at page 87 it has been observed that "it is not necessary for the creditor, before proceeding against the surety, to request the principal debtor to pay, or to sue him, although solvent, unless this is expressly stipulated for."

    17. In Hukamchand Insurance Co Ltd. Versus Bank of Baroda, AIR (1977) Kant 204, a Division Bench of the High Court of Karnataka had an occasion to consider the question of liability of the surety vis-à-vis the principal debtor. Venkatachaliah, J. (as His Lordship then was) observed:-

    "The question as to the liability of the surety, its extent and the manner of its enforcement have to be decided on first principles as to the nature and incidents of suretyship. The liability of a principal debtor and the liability of a surety which is co-extensive with that of the former are really separate liabilities, although arising out of the same transaction.Notwithstanding the fact that they may stem from the same transaction, the two liabilities are distinct. The liability of the surety does not also, in all cases, arise simultaneously."

    18. It will be noticed that the guarantor alone could have been sued, without even suing the principal debtor, so long as the creditor satisfies the court that the principal debtor is in default."

    19. On the same issue, Hon'ble Supreme Court in Industrial Finance Corporation of India Ltd. versus Cannanore Spinning and Weaving Mills and others (2002) 5 SCC 54 has observed:-

    33. "Adverting to the contract of guarantee be it noted that though it is not a contract regarding a primary transaction : but it is an independent transaction containing independent and reciprocal obligations. It is on principal to principal basis and by reason wherefore the Statute has provided both the creditor and the guarantor some relief as specified in this Chapter of Contract Act (between Sections 130 to 141). Section 141 thus involves an issue of a deliberate action on the part of the creditor and not a mere fortuitous situation beyond the control of the creditor. It is in this context strong reliance was placed on a decision of the Privy Council in China and South Sea Bank Ltd. v. Tan (1989 (3) All ER 839), wherein Lord Templeman speaking for the Council stated the law as below:- (All ER p. 842 c-h)

    "In the present case the security was neither surrendered nor lost nor imperfect nor altered in condition by reason of what was done by creditor. The creditor had three sources of repayment. The creditor could sue the debtor, sell the mortgage securities or sue the surety. All these

    15

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023 remedies could be exercised at any time or times simultaneously or contemporaneously or successively or not at all. If the creditor chose to sue the surety and not pursue any other remedy, the creditor on being paid in full was bound to assign the mortgage securities to the surety. If the creditor chose to exercise his power of sale over the mortgage security he must sellfor the current market value but the creditor must decide in his own interest if and when he should sell. The creditor does not become a trustee of the mortgaged securities and the power of sale for the surety unless and until the creditor is paid in full and the surety, having paid the whole of the debt is entitled to a transfer of the mortgaged securities to procure recovery of the whole or part of the sum he has paid to the creditor. The creditor is not obliged to do anything. If the creditor does nothing and the debtor declines into bankruptcy the mortgaged securities become valueless and if the surety decamps abroad the creditor loses his money. If disaster strikes the debtor and the mortgaged securities but the surety remains capable of repaying the debt then the creditor loses nothing. The surety contracts to pay if the debtor does not pay and the surety is bound by his contract. If the surety, perhaps less indolent or less well protected than the creditor, is worried that the mortgaged securities may decline in value then the surety may request the creditor to sell and if the creditor remains idle then the surety may bustle about, pay off the debt, take over the benefit of the securities and sell them. No creditor could carry on the business of lending if he could become liable to a mortgagee and to a surety or to either of them for a decline in value of mortgaged property, unless the creditor was personally responsible for the decline. Applying the rule as specified by Pollock CB in Watts v. Shuttleworth (1860) 5 H&N 235 at 247-248 : 157 ER 1171 at 1176, it appears to their Lordships that in the present case the creditor did not act injurious to the surety, did not act inconsistent with the rights of the surety and the creditor did not omit any act which his duty enjoined him to do. The creditor was not under a duty to exercise his power of sale over the mortgaged securities at any particular time or at all."

    20. This question was also answered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Margaret Lalita Samuel versus The Indo Commercial Bank Ltd. AIR 1979 SC 102 in the following words:

    We may first consider the question of limitation. As already mentioned by us, the submission of Shri Bal was that every item of an overdraft account was an independent loan, limitation for the recovery of which was determined by Article 57 of the schedule to the Limitation Act, 1908. Limitation, according to the learned Counsel, started to run from the date of each loan. He relied on Basante Kumar Mitra v. Chota Nagpur Banking Association Ltd: AIR 1948 Pat 18 , Brajendra Kishore Ray Chowdhury v. Hindustan Cooperative Insurance Society Ltd. I.L.R.44 Cal. 979 National and Grindlays Bank Ltd. v. Tikam Chand Daga and Anr. AIR1964Cal358 , and Uma Shankar Prasad v. Bank of Bihar Ltd. and Anr. A.I.R. 1942 Patna 201. In our view it is unnecessary for the purposes of the present case to go into the question of the nature of an overdraft account. The present suit is in substance and truth one to enforce the guarantee bond executed by the defendant. In order to ascertain the nature of the liability of the defendant it is necessary to refer to the precise terms of the guarantee bond rather than embark into an enquiry as to the nature of an overdraft account. Exhibit 57 is the guarantee bond executed by the

    16

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023 defendant and her husband on 23rd October, 1944. It is addressed to the Indo-Commercial Bank Ltd., Madras, and is in the following terms :

    Dear Sirs,

    In consideration of your having agreed to allow overdraft accommodation upto Rs. 10,00,000/- (Rupees Ten Lakhs only) to the Modern Hindustan Food Products Ltd., Poona, we, C.B. Samuel and M.L. Samuel, the undersigned do hereby jointly and severally guarantee to you, the Indo-Commercial Bank Limited the repayment of all money, which shall at any time be due to you from the said Modern Hindustan Food Products Ltd., on the general balance of their accounts with you or on any account whatever (such balances to include all interest, charges, commission and other expenses which you may charge as bankers) and also the due payment at maturity of any promissory note or other negotiable instrument on the security or in respect of which any credit or advance shall be made.

    And we hereby declare that this guarantee shall be a continuing guarantee to the extent at any one time for Rs. 10,00,000/- (Rupees Ten Lakhs only) and shall not be considered wholly or partially satisfied by the payment at any one tune or at different times of any sums of money due on such general balance of account but shall extend and cover and be a security for every and all further sums at any time due to you thereon. And we further declare that you may grant to the Modern Hindustan Food Products Ltd., any indulgence without discharging our liability. The guarantee is seen to be a continuing guarantee and the undertaking by the defendant is to pay any amount that may be due by the company at the foot of the general balance of its account or any other account whatever. In the case of such a continuing guarantee, so long as the account is a live account in the sense that it is not settled and there is no refusal on the part of the guarantor to carry out the obligation, we do not see how the period of limitation could be said to have commenced running. Limitation would only run from the date of breach, under Article 115 of the schedule to the Limitation Act, 1908. When the Bombay High Court considered the matter in the first instance and held that the suit was not barred by limitation, J.C. Shah, J., speaking for the Court said :

    On the plain words of the letters of guarantee it is clear that the defendant undertook to pay any amount which may be due by the Company at the foot of the general balance of its account or any other account whatever....We are not concerned in this case with the period of limitation for the amount repayable by the Company to the bank. We are concerned with the period of limitation for enforcing the liability of the defendant under the surety bond....We hold that the suit to enforce the liability is governed by Article 115 and the cause of action arises when the contract of continuing guarantee is broken, and in the present case we are of the view that so long as the account remained a live account, and there was no refusal on the part of defendant to carry out her obligation, the period of limitation did not commence to run.

    We agree with the view expressed by Shah, J. The intention and effect of a continuing guarantee such as the one with which we are concerned in this case was considered by the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in Wright and Anr. v. New Zealand Farmers Co-operative

    17

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023 Association of Canterbury Ltd. [1939] A.C. 439. The second clause of the guarantee bond in that case was in the following terms :

    "This guarantee shall be a continuing guarantee and shall apply to the balance that is now or may at any time hereafter be owing to you by the William Nosworthy and Robert Nosworthy on their current account with you for goods supplied and advances made by you as aforesaid and interest and other charges as aforesaid"

    21. Hence, in a case of a continuing guarantee, the period of limitation would start to run from the date the cause of action would arise with the breaking of the contract for continuing guarantor which would be the date of refusal on the part of the party to carry out the obligation under the agreement. Thus, the cause of action against the guarantor will start to run when the guarantee deed was invoked and the guarantor commits breach by not complying with the demand i.e. 30.12.1999.

    22. The repayment of the loan was rescheduled at the instance of the Corporate Debtor in 32 quarterly installments commencing from Oct 1, 1999 to July 1, 2007 vide letter dated 23.04.1998 and this is clear from Para No. 12 of OA 222 of 2000 as Annexure 1 of the IA and order10.08.2009 Annexure-3 in IA passed by the DRT in OA No. 373 0f 2007. On this point, learned counsel for the applicant has submitted that the applicant is not liable for any modifications of the contract unless his assent is taken. In this regard, Section 134 of the Contract Act is relevant, which says:

    134. Discharge of surety by release or discharge of principal debtor-The surety is discharged by any contract between the creditor and the principal debtor, by which the principal debtor is released, or by any act or omission of the creditor, the legal consequence of which is the discharge of the principal debtor.

    23. This provision makes it clear that any variance in the contract without the surety's consent, discharges the surety as to transactions subsequent to the variance. This provision is applicable when the principal debtor is discharged or when natural consequences of the act or omission of the creditor amounts to

    18

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023 discharge of the principal debtor. However, the creditor has not done any act which may discharge the Corporate Debtor. The renewal in the payment schedule was done when the debt was live and the Corporate Debtor was competent to do so in view of the terms and conditions of the guarantee deed and further the date of invocation of the guarantee deed was after the reschedulement of loan payment. Moreover, there is also admission of the applicant in letter dated 14.01.2020 (Page 199 of the counter to the IA) that he as personal guarantor is accountable and responsible for the loan amount. Therefore, the decisions in Ramaswaroop and anr versus State of Bikaner & Jaipur 2002(3) WLN 430 and SBI versus P.Rajarao CP(B) No. 78/95/AMR/2022 which are relied upon by the learned counsel for the applicant are not applicable and the limitation will start to run against the applicant w.e.f. 30.12.1999.

    24. Once limitation starts, it can be extended only under the Limitation Act. In

    Jignesh Shah And Another versus Union of India And Another (2019) 10 SCC 750, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that "when time begin to run, it can only be extended in the manner prescribed in the Limitation Act". The Law declared by the Hon'ble Supreme Court is explained clearly in Para 21 of the said judgment which read as follows:-

    "Para 21. The aforesaid judgments correctly hold that a suit for recovery based upon a cause of action that is within limitation cannot in any manner impact the separate and independent remedy of a winding-up proceeding. In law, when time begins to run. It can only be extended in the manner provided in the Limitation Act. For example, an acknowledgement of liability under section 18 of the Limitation Act would certainly extend the limitation period, but a suit for recovery, which is a separate and independent proceeding distinct from the remedy of winding up would, in no manner, impact the limitation within which the winding-up proceeding is to be filed, by somehow keeping the debt alive for the purpose of the winding-up proceeding".

    25. As such, when the cause of action has started on30.12.1999, the Financial Creditor was to file the case within next 3 years unless time was extended

    19

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023 under Section 18 of the Limitation Act or there was promise to pay time barred debt under Section 25(3) of the Contract Act

    26. The applicant made various OTS proposals to the respondent in personal capacity as well as on behalf of the Corporate Debtor. The letters of OTS constitute acknowledgment of debt in terms of Section 18 of the Limitation Act and even it can be termed as promise to pay time barred debt. This is no more res itegra that acknowledgement of debt through OTS during the live debt is covered under Section 18 of the Limitation Act. Here we may profitably refer to the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Dena Bank verses C. Shivakumar Reddy and Ors. (2021)10 SCC 330, wherein it was held:

    139. Section 18 of the Limitation Act cannot also be construed with pedantic rigidity in relation to proceedings under the IBC. This Court sees no reason why an offer of One Time Settlement of a live claim, made within the period of limitation, should not also be construed as an acknowledgment to attract Section 18 of the Limitation Act. In Gaurav Hargovindbhai Dave (supra) cited by Mr. Shivshankar, this Court had no occasion to consider any proposal for one time settlement. Be that as it may, the Balance Sheets and Financial Statements of the Corporate Debtor for 2016-2017, as observed above, constitute acknowledgement of liability which extended the limitation by three years, apart from the fact that a Certificate of Recovery was issued in favour of the Appellant Bank in May 2017. The NCLT rightly admitted the application by its order dated 21st March, 2019.

    27. The applicant from time to time has admitted the liability towards the Financial Creditor by making many OTS proposals, which are given below:

    Annexure with date Page No OTS proposals Remarks
    05.12.2005 39 OTS of Rs.350 lakhs for all the Secured Creditors including IDBI, IFCI, SBI & Allahabad Bank. IDBI for submitting an exclusive concrete proposal for settlement of IBDI/SASF dues.
    16.01.2006 42 OTS of Rs.188 lakhs to SASF in full and final discharge of all obligations Proposed offer for settlement was found low and which as per the Creditor requires further discussions.
    08.02.2006 45 OTS of Rs.190 lakhs to IDBI

    20

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023

    24.07.2006 46 OTS with SASF for Rs.190 lakhs
    26.10.2006 48 OTS of Rs.200 lakhs
    27.06.2007 49 OTS of Rs.247 lakhs to be paid in six installments.
    26.12.2008 51 Rs.76 lakhs on approval and Balance Rs.300 lakhs in 8 quarterly instalments with 13% interest p.a. after 6 months from the date of approval Remitted Rs.21 lakhs on this day. Total Rs.76 lakhs (Rs.19.00+16.00+20.00+21.00) being 20% of the OTS of Rs.376 lakhs.
    27.12.2008 Acceptance of the OTS of 376 lakhs 76 lakhs to be paid on approval and Rs. 300 lakhs in 8 quarterly instalments. Proposal approved as is clear from letter dt. 30.06.2010 (Page 65)
    24.08.2009 OTS of 376 lakhs
    12.09.2019 146 OTS granted in 2008 was rejected
    21.09.2012 102 OTS for an amount of Rs.376 lakhs, Rs.76 lakhs payable at the time of approval and Rs.300 lakhs in 8 quarterly instalment with an interest of 13% after 6 months from the date of approval.
    15.11.2012 104 OTS offer increased from Rs.247 lakhs to Rs.400 lakhs. Details given on page 105
    02.04.2013 141 Total 401 lakhs, Rs.113 lakhs already paid. Balance Rs.288 lakhs, monthly 18 instalment @ Rs.15 lakhs OTS Rejected. Substan- tially improved proposal to be sent for consideration
    20.04.2013 110 Rs,10 lakhs by two cheques of Rs.5 lakhs each Amount to be deposited in SASF Account
    08.08.2015 120 Assign the debt of SASF to nominee on payment of Rs.337.50lakhs (Being 376+25 +25+25 minus payment made Rs,113.50 lakhs Dues of PriyaranjaniFibres Ltd for Rs.376 lakhs
    03.07.2017 137 One time settlement amount Rs.113 lakhs already paid. Balance Rs.288 lakhs, monthly 18 instalment @ Rs.15 lakhs Orders dated 15.05.2017 (delivered on 23.06.2017) by NCLT, Chennai
    08.09.2017 143 Rs.401 lakhs + 25 lakhs sanctioned earlier while deducting the amounts already paid by the compony. OTS Rejected. Substantially improved proposal to be sent for consideration
    13.10.2017 148 Rs.401 lakhs + 25 lakhs within Proposal to pay Rs. 500 lakhs has

    21

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023

    this months in addition to Rs.25lakhs already paid sanctioned earlier paid by the company. been rejected vide letter dt. 10.11.2017 (Page 152)
    15.11.2017 156 Rs.20 lakhs in addition to Rs.25 lakhs already paid by the company
    17.02.2018 160 Rs.20 lakhs in addition to Rs.25 lakhs already paid by the company. Another Offer of Rs.5 crores was made.
    28.04.2018 168 Praying to make payment as per the earlier OTS
    06.04.2019 178 Rs.9 crores minus amount already paid towards OTS and minus upfront fee towards OTS.
    26.08.2019 185 Request to accept the earlier offer
    17.09.2019 193 Rs.9 crores minus amount already paid towards OTS and minus upfront fee towards OTS.
    11.10.2019 196 Request to accept the earlier offer
    14.01.2020 199 Request to accept the earlier offer
    20.02.2021 208 Rs.95 lakhs already deposited. Rs.3 crores within 3 months from the date of approval of OTS and balance Rs.505 lakhs will be paid in accordance with SASF Recovery policy.
    20.02.2022 224 Agree to pay Rs.9 crores towards OTS. Rs.95 lakhs already paid towards upfront fee. Paid Rs.2.08 crores towards part payment of OTS amount. Sufficient time for payment of balance amount.

    28. Tone and tenor of the letters of OTS make it clear that the applicant has made the offers in his individual capacity as well as the Vice-Chairman and Managing Director of the Corporate Debtor. It has later been clarified by the applicant in letter dated 14.01.2020 (Page 199) that the applicant being the only surviving

    22

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023 guarantor is solely responsible and accountable to the respondent for clearing the OTS. OTS offers were also made by the Reddy Group (K.Shivananda Reddy) with whom the applicant remained in litigation for a number of years. In the letter dated 06.09.2022 (page 189 of the counter to IA), it is mentioned that the dispute between the applicant and the promoter Sri K.Shivananda Reddy was still pending in the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India and this group continuously managed the Corporate Debtor since 2003 by filing even audited financial statements and annual returns. The applicant in his letter dated 01.02.2002 (page 206 of the counter to IA) addressed to the respondent has clarified that now K.Shivananda Reddy and associates were neither Shareholders nor Directors as the litigation has come to an end because of the dismissal of Civil Suit as well as proceedings pending before the Hon'ble NCLAT and Hon'ble Supreme Court of India. This plea has also been taken by the applicant in letter dated 14.01.2020 (page 199 of the counter to IA). However, it is found that K.Shivananda Reddy and associates continued to remain in the management in one way or the other w.e.f., 2003 at least upto 2012. During this period, K.Shivananda Reddy and associates also made various OTS proposals and even paid some amount. Therefore, the applicant cannot approbate and reprobate at the same time and say that K.Shivananda Reddy and associates were not the authorized representatives of the Corporate Debtor.

    29. The applicant has made number of offers and some of his offers were rejected by the respondent. In letter dated 20thDecember, 2008 (page 51 of the counter to IA), there is admission that Rs.76 lakhs of the OTS amount has been sent to the Financial Creditor. In the letter dated 30.01.2010 (page 65 of counter), it is admitted that Rs.37.50 lakhs has been remitted to the respondent. As per the letter dated 11.11.2020, there is admission by Mr.K.Shivananda Reddy of payment of

    23

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023 Rs.1.35 crores. In the letter dated 02.04.2013 (page 141 of the counter to IA), it is admitted that Rs.50 lakhs has been sent to the Financial Creditor and further Rs.10 lakhs is stated to have been sent vide letter dated 20.04.2013 (page 110 of counter). Similarly, Rs.20 lakhs were sent by the applicant to the respondent through cheque by letter dated 22-10.2017 and there is reference of sending Rs.25 lakhs through cheque. In the letter dated 28.04.2019 (page 171 of the counter), the applicant has admitted that Rs.50 lakhs has already been paid and he has mentioned specific dates on which the amount was paid. He has also written letter dated 06.04.2019 (page 178 of counter) stating that Mr.K.Shivananda Reddy had paid Rs.113 lakhs and subsequently failed to pay the balance amount. In the letters dated 02.03.2021 (page 208 of the counter), 02.10.2021 (page 221 of counter) and 15.06.2022 (page 224 of counter), the applicant has acknowledged the payment of Rs.95 lakhs to the financial creditor. Thus, the applicant cannot deny that he was not having any role in making the OTS proposals and in paying substantial amount to the Financial Creditor. The latest OTS proposal has been made vide letter dated 15.06.2022 (Page 224 of counter) for an amount of Rs.376 lakhs.

    30. Apart from making the OTS proposals on various dates, the respondent was continuously pursuing the remedies available under Law to recover the debt. The Financial Creditor on 01.02.2000 filed O.A. No. 222 of 2000 for the recovery of debt from the Corporate Debtor and others. The Recovery Certificate Annexure 11

    was issued on dated 19.11.2009. This certificate was amended for correcting the party's name and the amended Recovery Certificate is Annexure 10 dt 22.3.2021. Besides, in the year 2001, the Corporate Debtor approached BIFR vide Case No. 366 of 2001 for declaring the industry as a sick unit under Section 15(1) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provision) Act. Against the order dated 22.11.2011 in Case No. 366 of 2001, the Corporate Debtor has preferred an appeal

    24

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023 No. 31 of 2012 before the Appellate Authority for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (AIFR) and vide order dated 21.02.2012 (Page No. 100 of the Counter to the IA) stayed further proceedings before the BIFR including the impugned direction given vide order dt 22.11.2011. The recovery proceedings before the DRT Chennai are still pending.

    31. The proceedings before the DRT Chennai and BIFR/AIFR were started before the expiry of the limitation period. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Dena Bank (Now Bank of Baroda)' versus 'C. Shivakumar Reddy & Anr. (2021) 10 SCC 330 while discussing at length Sections 14 & 18 of the Limitation Act, it was held that the Judgment and/or decree for money in favour of the 'Financial Creditor', passed by DRT, or any other Tribunal or Court, or the issuance of a certificate of recovery in favour of the 'Financial Creditor', would gave rise to a fresh cause of action for the 'Financial Creditor', to initiate proceedings under Section 7 of the Code, if the dues of the 'Corporate Debtor' under the Judgment/decree or any part thereof remained unpaid. The relevant para is reproduced as hereunder:

    "141. Moreover, a judgment and/or decree for money in favour of the financial creditor, passed by the DRT, or any other tribunal or court, or the issuance of a certificate of recovery in favour of the financial creditor, would give rise to a fresh cause of action for the financial creditor, to initiate proceedings under Section 7 IBC for initiation of the corporate insolvency resolution process, within three years from the date of the judgment and/or decree or within three years form the date of issuance of the certificate of recovery, if the dues of the corporate debtor to the financial debtor, under the judgment and/or decree and/or in terms of the certificate of recovery, or any part thereof remained unpaid."

    32. On the similar lines, there is also decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in

    Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd. versus. Hotel Poonja International Pvt. Ltd. (2021)7 SCC 352. In view of the decision in Dena Bank (Now Bank of Baroda)' and Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd supra, the date of issuance of certificate

    25

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023 would give rise to a fresh cause of action for the Financial Creditor, to initiate proceedings under the IBC. The Recovery Certificate was issued on dated 19.11.2009. On the basis of this certificate, the respondent was required to approach this forum before 19.11.2012. The IBC came into force in 2016, therefore the cause of action to approach this Authority will arise on the enforcement of the IBC on the strength of the Recovery Certificate.

    33. As far as proceedings before the BIFR and AIFR are concerned, the embargo of Section 22 of the SICA was lifted with the repeal of SICAw.e.f. 01.12.2016. In this regard, it would be relevant to refer to Section 22 of the SICA which read as under:-

    22. Suspension of legal proceedings, contracts, etc.--(1) Where in respect of an industrial company, an inquiry under section 16 is pending or any scheme referred to under section 17 is under preparation or consideration or a sanctioned scheme is under implementation or where an appeal under section 25 relating to an industrial company is pending, then, notwithstanding anything contained in the Companies Act, 1956 (1 of 1956) or any other law or the memorandum and articles of association of the industrial company or any other instrument having effect under the said Act or other law, no proceedings for the winding up of the industrial company or for execution, distress or the like against any of the properties of the industrial company or for the appointment of a receiver in respect thereof 3 [and no suit for the recovery of money or for the enforcement of any security against the industrial company or of any guarantee in respect of any loans or advance granted to the industrial company] shall lie or be proceeded with further, except with the consent of the Board or, as the case may be, the Appellate Authority.

    (2) Where the management of the sick industrial company is taken over or changed 3 [in pursuance of any scheme sanctioned under section 18], notwithstanding anything contained in the Companies Act, 1956 (1 of 1956) or any other law or in the memorandum and articles of association of such company or any instrument having effect under the said Act or other law--(a) it shall not be lawful for the shareholders of such company or any other person to nominate or appoint any person to be a director of the company; (b) no resolution passed at any meeting of the shareholders of such company shall be given effect to unless approved by the Board. (3)Where an inquiry under section 16 is pending or any scheme referred to in section 17 is under preparation or during the period] of consideration of any scheme under section 18 or where any such scheme is sanctioned thereunder, for due implementation of the scheme, the Board may by order declare with respect to the sick industrial company concerned that the operation of all or any of the contracts, assurances of property, agreements, settlements, awards, standing orders or

    26

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023 other instruments in force, to which such sick industrial company is a party or which may be applicable to such sick industrial company immediately before the date of such order, shall remain suspended or that all or any of the rights, privileges, obligations and liabilities accruing or arising thereunder before the said date, shall remain suspended or shall be enforceable with such adaptations and in such manner as may be specified by the Board: Provided that such declaration shall not be made for a period exceeding two years which may be extended by one year at a time so, however, that the total period shall not exceed seven years in the aggregate.

    (4) Any declaration made under sub-section (3) with respect to a sick industrial company shall have effect notwithstanding anything contained in the Companies Act, 1956 (1 of 1956) or any other law, the memorandum and articles of association of the company or any instrument having effect under the said Act or other law or any agreement or any decree or order of a court, tribunal, officer or other authority or of any submission, settlement or standing order and accordingly,--

    (a) any remedy for the enforcement of any right, privilege, obligation and liability suspended or modified by such declaration, and all proceedings relating thereto pending before any court, tribunal, officer or other authority shall remain stayed or be continued subject to such declaration; and

    (b) on the declaration ceasing to have effect--

    (i) any right, privilege, obligation or liability so remaining suspended or modified, shall become revived and enforceable as if the declaration had never been made; and

    (ii) any proceeding so remaining stayed shall be proceeded with, subject to the provisions of any law which may then be in force, from the stage which had been reached when the proceedings became stayed.

    (5) In computing the period of limitation for the enforcement of any right, privilege, obligation or liability, the period during which it or the remedy for the enforcement thereof remains suspended under this section shall be excluded.

    33. The period spent in proceedings under SICA is liable to be excluded. On this point, reference can be made to the decision in Sesh Nath Singh and Ors. Versus .Baidyabati Sheoraphuli Co-operative Bank Ltd. and Ors. (2021)7 SCC

    313. The relevant paras are hereunder:

    86. In the instant case, even if it is assumed that the right to sue accrued on 31.3.2013 when the account of Corporate Debtor was declared NPA, the financial creditor initiated proceedings under SARFAESI Act on 18th January 2014, that is the date on which notice Under Section 13(2) was issued, proceeded with the same, and even took possession of the assets, until the entire proceedings were stayed by the High Court by its order dated 24th July 2017. The proceedings Under Section 7 of the IBC were initiated on 10th July 2018.

    27

    IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP (IB) No.314/95/HDB/2022

    Date of Order : 14.09.2023

    87. In our view, since the proceedings in the High Court were still pending on the date of filing of the application Under Section 7 of the IBC in the NCLT, the entire period after the initiation of proceedings under the SARFAESI Act could be excluded. If the period from the date of institution of the proceedings under the SARFAESI Act till the date of filing of the application Under Section 7 of the IBC in the NCLT is excluded, the application in the NCLT is well within the limitation of three years. Even if the period between the date of the notice Under Section 13(2) and date of the interim order of the High Court staying the proceedings under the SARFAESI Act, on the prima facie ground of want of jurisdiction is excluded, the proceedings Under Section 7 of IBC are still within limitation of three years.

    34. In view of the facts and circumstances, right to apply under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 IBC accrued after the SICA was repealed on 01.12.2016 and consequently when the IBC came into force. The proceedings pending before the BIFR/AIFR would also give cause of action to approach this Authority on the coming into force of the IBC.

    35. As a result, we are of the opinion that at no point of time, the debt was barred by limitation. Initially, when the proceedings were started under Section 19 of the Recovery of Debts due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 and under Section 15(1) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985, the debt was legally enforceable. It has given cause of action to approach this Authority on the enforcement of the IBC. Even the applicant in his individual capacity and being the Vice-Chairman of the M/s Priyaranjan Fibres Limited, Corporate Debtor acknowledged the debt many times starting from 2005 which continued before the filing of the present petition, thereby making it clear that the present petition is within limitation period.

    Therefore, this present Petition is within Limitation and accordingly this IA(IBC)/58/2023 in CP(IB)/314/2022 is dismissed.

    Sd/- Sd/- Sanjay Puri Rajeev Bhardwaj Member (Technical) Member (Judicial)

    Vinod

    28

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    D. SRINIVAS RAOS/o.S... v. M/s. STRESSED ASSETS...
    (Sep 14, 2023)