Loading..
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts

    Ms Tashi Delek Gaming Solutions and Another v. Union Of India and Another

    rr,<' IN THE HIGli cOuFiT OF slitlaM AT GANGTOK WRIT PETITION (C) No. 21 0F 2009 M/s Tashi Delek Gaming Solutions Pvt. Ltd., 135, Continental Building, Dr. A.B. Road, Worli,

    Mumbai.

    Amit Goenka

    135, Cont:inental Building,

    Dr. A.B. Road, WorEL ,,

    Mumbai.

    -versus-

    Union of India, I

    Through its Secretary,

    Ministry of Finance,

    Department of Revenue,

    North Block,

    New Delhi.

    ...Petit:ioners.

    2. The superintendent of central Excise, C/o Commissioner of 'Service Tax, Gangtok Range,

    Jeewan Theeing Marg,

    Development Area,

    Gangtok, East Sikkim.

    Stat:e of Sikkim

    Represented by the Principal Secretary, Finance, Expenditurei & Revenue Deptt., GovernmentofsikkiTJ

    Gangtok.

    1

    -a- The Director of State Lotteries, State of Sikkim,

    Balwakhani,

    Gangtok-737101.

    For the Petitioners

    ...Respondents.

    = Mr. Indranil Nandi, Mr. Debashish Kundu, Mr. Satyakam Chakraborty and Ms. Manita Pradhan, Advocat:es.

    Forthe Respondents = Mr. A. Moulik, Sr. Advocate with Ms. K.D. Bhutia, Advocate for Union of

    India/respondents No. 1 & 2.

    Mr. Karma Thinlay Namgyal, Govt.

    Advocate and Mr. S.K. Chettri, Asstt.

    Govt. Advocat:e for the State-

    respondents.

    WRIT PETITION (C) No. 30 0F 2009

    M/s Sugal & Damani Enterprises Pvt. Ltd.

    A Company registered under

    The Companies Act, 1956

    Having its Head` Office at

    6/35 W.E.A. Karol Bagh,

    New Delhi-110005

    Through Mr. Naresh Mangal,

    Director,

    M/s Sugal & Damani Enterprises Pvt. Ltd.

    ...Petit:ioner

    -versus-

    Union of India,

    Through its Secretary,

    Ministry of Finance,

    Department of Revenue,

    Nort:h BIock,

    New Delhi.

    2

    di. The Superintendent Of Central Excise, Gangt:ok Range,

    Near Community Hal||

    Development Area,

    P.O & P.S Gangtok, East Sikkjm. State of Sikkim

    Through the Secretary,

    Finance, Revenue & Expenditure Deptt., Government of Sikkim,

    Tashiling Secretariat,

    Gangtok, East Sikkim.

    State Lotteries,

    Government of Sikki,'m,

    Balwakhani, I

    Gangtok, East Sikkim-737101 Through Director, State Lotteries ...Respondent:s.

    For the petitioner : ,lil Xsrhj=.RchhKeu#a:'ndMfar.ABE:rbGaarTg:w#; Advocates.

    Forthe Respondents : Mr. A. Moulik, Sr. Advocate with Ms. K.D. Bhutia, Advocate for Union of

    I India/respondents No. 1 & 2.

    '' Mr. Karma Thinlay Namgyal, Govt.

    Advocate and Mr. S.K. Chettri, Asstt.

    „ Govt. Advocate for the State-

    respondents.

    WRIT PETITION (C) No. 36 0F 2009

    M/s Future Gaming Soliitions India

    Privat:e Limited,

    (A Private Limited Company registered

    under the Companies Act, 1956)

    Having its Registered Office at

    355-359, Daisy Plaza,

    3

    6th Street, G Coimbatore And branch office at '1 Samdrupling Bujldjng, Kazi Road, Gangtok, East Sjkkim

    I

    Through Mr. P. Ravichandran, Manager, M/s Future Gaming Solutions India Private Limited,

    -versus-

    ...Pet:itioner

    Union of India,

    Through its Secretary,

    Ministry of Finance,

    Department of Revenue,

    North Block, New Delhi.

    I

    Commissioner of Service Tax, Si[iguri, C.R. Building, Harendra Mukherjee' Road, Hakimpara Siliguri, HO, District:: Darjeeling. ,t

    I

    The Superintendent,of Central Excise, C/o Commissioner of Service Tax, Gangt:ok Range,

    Jeewan Theeing Marg,

    Development Area,

    Gangtok, East Sikkim.

    I

    ...Respondents. Forthepetitioner : ,I,'Mr. A.R. Madhav Rao, Mrs. L. Chakraborty, Mr. A. Krishna Rao and

    [' Mrs. Manju Raj, Advocates.

    b

    4

    Forthe Respondents : Mr. A. Moulik, Sr. Advocate with Ms. K.D. Bhutia, Advocat:e for Union of

    India/respondents No. 1, 2 & 3.

    BEFORE : HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE BARIN GHOSH,

    CHIEF JUSTICE.

    Dates of Hearing .. 27.07.2010 &

    28.07.2010

    Date of Judgement = Ghosh, CJ.

    C20 .o7.2010.

    JUDGEMENT

    `In a notice dated 30th April, 2007 issued to Mart:in Lottery Agencies Ltd., it was held out by the Central Revenue t:hat the nat:ure of the transactions between the State Governm.ent and Distributors in relation to lottery tickets is not in the nature of sale, but the activity of the Distributors are that of promotion or marketing of lottery tickets for their client i.e. the State Government, and as such, the Board of Revenue has decided that the service of Dist:.ributors falls under the category of ``Business Auxiliary Service" and therefore, are chargeable to Service Tax. The

    5

    said notice was challenged by Martin Lottery Agencies Ltd. in a writ petition filed in this Court, registered as W.P. (C) No. 19 of 2007. Central Revenue, despite opport:unity given, did not file counter to the writ petition. On 18th September, 2007 this Court noticing the judgment of the Constitution Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court rendered in Sunrt-se Assocliaites vs. Government of NCT of Delhir reported .in (2006) 5 SCC 603, where it was held that lottery tickets are actionable claims, held that lottery ticket:s would not be goods within the meaning of the definition clause in the Sale of Goods Act and if lottery tickets are not goods, writ:

    petitioner, i.e, Martin Lottery Agencies Ltd., cannot said to be rendering any service in relation to the promotion of their client's goods, or market:ing of their client's goods, or sale of their client:'s goods.

    There is no dispute that liability to pay tax if any of Martin Lottery Agencies Ltd. accrued by a reason of

    I

    Finance Act, 1994. At the t:ime when the aforementioned writ petition was decided, clauses (i) and (ii) of sub-Section 19 of Section 65 of the said Act: was as follows: - `` ``business auxiliary service" means any

    service in relation to,-

    6

    rth (i) promotion or marketing or sale of goods produced or provided by or belonging to the client; or

    (ii) promotion or market:ing of service provided by the client; or"

    It is thus apparent that: while this Court dealt with the writ petition, it concluded the same by noticing clause (i) of sub-Section 19 of Section 65 of the Act and did not take notice of clause (ii) of sub-Section 19 of Section 65 of the Act.

    4. Against the judgment rendered by this Court in the aforementioned writ petition, the Central Revenue took the matter before the Hon'ble Supreme Court. The Hon'ble Supreme Court by rendering its judgment in the case of union of India & Otl.ers vs. Martin Lottery Agencies ffd. reported in (2009) 12 SCC 209 dealt wit:h the same. While the matter was pending before the Hon'ble Supreme Court, by the Finance Act, 2008, which came into force on or about 16th May, 2008, an explanation to the effect as follows was inserted after clause (ii) of sub-Section 19 of Section 65 of the Finance Act, 1994:

    ``Explanation.- For the removal of doubts, it is hereby dec:Iared that for the purpose of this sub-clause, "service in relation to promotion

    7

    or marketing of service provided by the client" includes any service provided- in relation to promotion or marketing of games of chance, organized conducted or promoted by the client, in whatever form or by whatever name called, whether or not:

    conducted,, online, including lottery, Iotto, bingo;"

    It was contended before the Hon'ble Supreme Court .iT\ union Of India vs. Martin Lottery Agencies Ltd. (supra) that where the State Government involves itself in an illegal activity it cannot render a service, as dealing in lottery is illegal being res extra commercium, no services can be rendered. The Hon'ble Supreme Court expressly held i:hat it does not intend to go into the said issue. It, however, observed that: the said issue is a complex one and that the Hon'ble Suprenie Court at that sage was primarily required to consider t:he effect:`of the said explanation. It held that while the State raises its revenue by controlling dealing in liquor and/or by transferring it:s privilege to manufacture, distribute, sale, etc. as envisaged under Entry 8 of List 11 of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution of India, thereby it does n¢F render any service to the society.

    I

    It also held that servid'e tax purports to impose tax on Service on two grounds (1) service provided to a consumer,

    8

    and (2) service provided i:o a service provider and service provided in respect of the matters envisaged under sub- section 19 of Section 65 of the Act must be construed strictly and before tax is found to be leviable, it must come within the domain of legitimate business and/or trade. Hon'ble Supreme Court ultimately proceeded to declare that the above explanation thus inserted brought: about a change effectively in the existing law and thereby introduced a substantive law and the liability if any accrued thereon would accrue with effect from May, 2008 and not with retrospective effect. Hon'ble Supreme Court did not go into the question of constitutional validity of the said explanation and expressly left the same to be decided and ultimately upheld the judgment of this Court, though for different reasons.

    While this Court held that Martin Lottery Agencies Ltd. has no liability under clause (i) of sub-Section 19 of Section 65 of the Act, the Hon'ble Supreme Court did not hold that Martin Lottery Agencies Ltd. incurred any liability under clause (.ii) of sub-Section 19 of Section 65 of the Act. It declared, sub]-ect t:o the const:itutionality of the Act, in

    9

    10

    view of the explanation appended, service tax, if any, would be payable only with effect from May, 2008 and not with retrospective effect:. At the same time, it did not uphold the constitutional validity of the said explanation. In the present writ petition validity of the said explanation has been challenged. It was urged that the Constitution Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court: in Sunr/-se `Associ.ates case (supra.) has held actionable claim as goods, but the same was excluded from the meaning of ``goods" dealt with in the Sale of Goods Act, 1930 and the State taxation laws considered in the said judgement and that lottery ticket is a kind of actionable claim. It was submitted that if lottery is goods, then it cannot be service. In terms of sub-Section 50 of Section 65 of the Act ``goods", in relation to the Act, has the same meaning assigned to it:

    in the Sale of Goods Act, 1930. Therefore, in terms of the said Act, actionable claim including lottery ticket is excluded from the meaning of ``goods".

    It was submitted that sub-Section 105 of Section 65 of the Act defines ``taxable services". It was contended that although sub-Section 105 of Section 65 of the Act

    S

    11

    categorizes different kinds of activities as service provided, but it has not been provided there that dealing with actionable claims or organizing lottery is a service provided and that would be a taxable service. It was contended that if the activity of organizing lottery is service provided then having regard to the fact that the State Government is organizing lotteries should be held to be liable to pay service tax, but no provision has been made in the Act in that regard. It was stated that until date no State Government has been asked to pay service tax on lotteries. It was submitted that in terms of, clause (zzb) of sub-Section 105 of Section 65 of the Act, service provided to a client by any person in relation to business auxiliary service would be deemed to be taxable service and at the same time in terms of clause (ii) of sub-Secti'on 19 of Section 65 of the Act any service in relation to promotion or marketing of service provided by the client would be deemed to be business auxiliary service. Therefore, it: is the client: who has to

    11

    render service and in relation to such service if any service is provided to promote or market the same, the later service would come within the meaning of business auxiliary

    I

    service. It was contended that if the client is not providing i)

    de.

    Of

    12

    any service there is no question of rendering any service in relation thereto. It was also contended that the true meaning of the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the c:Else Of union of Indial vs. Malrtin Lottery Agencies [*d. (supra) is that no service is provided by the State in relation to lottery and accordingly providing any service in relation to promotion or marking of the same does not. arise. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of t:he Central Revenue expressly submitted that service is rendered by organizing lottery. It was submitted that: lottery amuses or entertains the ultimate buyer of lottery tickets and in relation thereto service is rendered by organizing lottery. If that be so the explanation does not effect:ively change the existing law. In such event it should be deemed that what was there in clause (ii) of sub-Section 19 of Section 65 was merely clarified in the explanation. However, it has been held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case Of union of India vs. Martin Lottery Agencies ££dL (supra) that the same was not the situation. The logical conclusion, therefore, would be t:hat a game of chance organized, conducted or promoted by the client is

    12

    13

    Er in not service provided by the client as mentioned in clause (ii) of sub-Section 19 of Section 65 of the Act.

    10. Further in the case of B.R. EnterpH-se ws. Sfare of u.P. & offlers reported in (1999) 9 SCC 700, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, has in no uncertain terms, held that

    I

    lottery is gambling. It is a vice. The excitement of a lottery ticket holder after purchase of lottery ticket until the draw

    I

    may amuse or entertain the holder, but such excitement being in connection with a vice cannot be taken in a civilized society either as amusement or as entertainment:. Accordingly, an activity in organizing such an excitement cannot be treated as service. Amongst various observations made .in union of India vs. Martin Lottery Agencies Ltd. (supra), there is an observation that activity that of lottery may be brought within the purview of ``entertainment" or

    "amusement". This observation was made taking note of certain portion of UN-CPC. It was not brought to the notice '1

    of the Hon'ble Supreme Court that the said part of UN-CPC was not accepted by ,I,ithis Country, documentary proof t:hereof is on the record bf these cases.

    11. In the circumstances, the explanation must be deemed to be a substantive law introduced thereby and that is also the conclusion oft t:he Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case Of union of India\rys. Malrtin Lottery Agencies Lld. (supra). In other wor#s, the explanation should not be looked at in connection with service provided by the client as mentioned in clause (ii)||of sub-Section 19 of Section 65 of the Act.

    12- would be appropriate to

    \

    remember that Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Union

    I

    of India vs. Mart:in Lott.ery Agencies Ltd. has held that the~E=

    I

    I

    expression like ``for the removal of doubts" are hot

    I

    conclusive. In other Words, the explanation which has

    )

    effectively changed the existing law may be read as a

    I

    I

    substantive law withoJF reading the expression ``for the

    (

    ' removal of doubts". In (the explanation it has been declared

    "service in relation to promotion or marketing of service

    1

    provided by the c]ient| includes any service provided in

    I

    I relation to promotion r marketing of games of chance, organized, conducted or promoted by the client ................... "

    .,I

    In other words, games|iof chance, organized, conducted or

    11

    15

    promoted by the client ihas not been declared as service. What has been declared as service is any service provided in relation to promotion or''marketing thereof. The concept of service in the explanation is totally alien to the concept of service in clause (ii) of sub-Section 19 of Section 65 of the Act:. In ot:her words;, while t:he service rendered in promotion or marketing ,of service provided by the client is business auxiliary serviqe in terms of clause (ii) of sub- section 19 of Sect:ion 65 of the Act and is accordingly taxable service providedito the client in relation to business auxiliary service in terms of clause (zzb) of sub-Section 105 of Section 65 of the Act; service provided in relation to promotion, or marketing of games of chance, organized, conducted or promoted :by the client is business auxiliary service and accordingly is taxable service in terms of clause (zzb) of sub-Section 105 of Section 65 of the Act. Therefore, although the ¢lient is not providing any service by organizing or conducting)or promoting games of chance, any service provided in relation to promotion or marketing of the same would become taxable service.

    in

    16 tr

    13. It was urged that: organizing or conducting or promoting games of chance is res extra commercium and accordingly the same is illegal.

    14. The word "extra commercium" means beyond commerce, i.e. which cannot be bought or sold, such as public roads, rivers, titles of honour, etc. There is no dispute that an action of organizing or conduct:ing or promoting games of chance as that of lottery by a State Government is also res extra commercium. While by doing so the State Government also does not render any service to any one, except to itself by generating revenue, but it cannot be contended that the act:ion is illegal, particularly, having regard to law applicable to the Indian society guided by the Constitution of India, inasmuch as Entry 40 of List I

    I

    of Seventh Schedule of lthe Constitution of India specifically empowers the Parliament to make laws pertaining tor lotteries organized by the Government of India or the Government of a State. Organization of lotteries by a State is, thus, a permissible activity of the State. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners also accept

    16

    17

    that organizing or conducting or promoting games of chance as that of lottery by the State Government is not illegal.

    15. It was submitt:ed by placing reliance on t:he judgement of the Hon'bleli Supreme Court rendered i'n the case Of All India Fedn. of Tax Practitioners vs. union of Jndl/-a reported in 2007 '{7) SIR 625 (SC) that service which can be said to be a taxable service must add value to the product or the service. To that there cannot be any dispute. However, I thin f, if the explanation is read, as it should be read, independently then the value addition, if

    11

    any, by rendering service to the action of the client in organizing or conducting or promoting games of chance as that of lottery would be taxable service. It was contended that tickets are priced byli State Government at Rs.1/-each, which are purchased by the petitioner at Rs.0.70. It was submitt:ed that the price of the activity is paid at: the discounted rate and accordingly there is no question of value

    I

    addition. The fact remains that lottery tickets are purchased not for their consumption but for the purpose of marketing the same. ,In order to market lottery tickets

    11

    petitioner is required, in )t:erms of the agreement it has with ?

    18

    the State Government, toi put up and the petitioner in fact puts up advertisements. It thereby ent:ices the ultimate buyer of lottery tickets to purchase the same. It thus promotes the actMty of its client, the State Government, in organizing lottery. In the matter of enabling its client to sale a lottery ticket worth Rs.1/- at Rs.1/-to the ultimate buyer of lottery tickets pet:itioner renders service thus. The value of lottery tickets without the promotional and marketing activity of the petitioner is 70 paise, which by reason of marketing and promotional activity of the petitioner becomes Rs.1/- when the same reaches the

    I

    ultimate purchaser of lottery tickets. Petitioner thus makes a value addit:ion to the activity of organizing or conducting or promoting games of chance as that: of lottery by the State Government from 70 paise to Rs.1/-by providing marketing and promot:ional service thereto by its activit:ies as above.

    I

    There is thus value addit'ion by the petitioner in relation to game of chance, organized, conducted or promoted by the client of the petitioner namely, t:he State Government.

    16. It was not urged that the residuary clause contained in List I of the Seventh Schedule of the

    19

    Constitution of India on Entry 92C thereto does not authorize levy of service tax on service provided in relation to an activity which though may not be service or which may be res extra commercium, but a legal and permissible activity.

    17. The word petitioner used above should mean all the three writ petitioners.

    18. I, accordingly, the writ petit:ions.

    19. Stay prayed jk/

    Conc lude the mat:ter and dismiss for is refused.

    CHIEF JUSTICE

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ms Tashi Delek Gaming Solutions and Another v. Union Of India and Another
    (Jul 30, 2010)