Loading..
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • INCOME TAX ACT 1961
  • Acts (Gujarat Industrial Development Act, 1962 and the Karnataka Industrial Areas Development Act, 1966)
  • Section 10(23C) and by Section 11
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • INCOME TAX ACT 1961
  • Acts (Gujarat Industrial Development Act, 1962 and the Karnataka Industrial Areas Development Act, 1966)
  • Section 10(23C) and by Section 11

    COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (EXEMPTIONS) v. AHMEDABAD URBAN DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY

    C/TAXAP/74/2021 ORDER DATED: 11/09/2023

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD

    R/TAX APPEAL NO. 74 of 2021

    ==========================================================

    COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (EXEMPTIONS)

    Versus

    AHMEDABAD URBAN DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY

    ========================================================== Appearance:

    MS MAITHILI D MEHTA(3206) for the Appellant(s) No. 1 for the Opponent(s) No. 1

    MR. B.S.SOPARKAR, ADVOCATE for the Respondent(s) ==========================================================

    CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BIREN VAISHNAV

    and

    HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BHARGAV D. KARIA

    Date : 11/09/2023

    ORAL ORDER

    (PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BIREN VAISHNAV)

    1 Heard Ms.Maithili Mehta, learned counsel appearing for the appellant and Mr.B.S.Soparkar, learned counsel for the respondent. Mr.Soparkar, learned counsel, is permitted to file his appearance.

    2 Following substantial question of law arises for consideration of this Court:

    "[A] Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Appellate Tribunal was justified in holding that the assessee is eligible to claim exemptions u/s.11 and 12 of the Act as the provisos to section 2(15) are not applicable to the assessee

    Page 1 of 12

    without appreciating the fact that the assessee is involved in widespread commercial activities in nature of business and the activity of the assessee is covered under proviso to section 2(15) of the Act?

    [B] Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Appellate Tribunal is justified in upholding the order of CIT(A) thereby allowing the benefit of exemptions u/s.11 without considering the fact that the assessee is covered by the first and second proviso to section 2(15) of the Act?

    [C] Whether on the facts and in circumstances of the case and in law, the Appellate Tribunal is justified in allowing benefit of section 11 of the Act relying on the decisions of this Hon'ble Court in the case of Ahmedabad Urban Development Authority Vs ACIT (Exemption) in TA No. 423 to 425 of 2016 and CIT Vs Gujarat Industrial Development Corporation reported in (2017) 83 taxmann.com 366 (Gujarat) which are subject matter of further appeal pending before the Hon'ble Supreme Court?

    [D] Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Appellate Tribunal has erred in allowing the claim of the assessee for carry forward of capital expenditure, ignoring the fact that there is no express provisions in the Income Tax Act, 1961 allowing such claim, and without appreciating the fact that this would have the effect of granting double benefit to the assessee, first as accumulation of income u/s.11(1)(a) or Corpus donation u/s.11(1)

    (d) in earlier/current year, or exempt income u/s.10(34), and then as application of income u/s.11(1)(a) in subsequent years which is legally not permissible?

    [E] Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Hon.ITAT is justified in allowing

    Page 2 of 12

    benefit of exemption u/s.11 & 12 of the Act without appreciating that in quantum appeal the decision of the Hon.High Court in T.A. 301 of 2018 which has not been accepted and further SLP has been preferred before the Hon.Supreme Court, which is pending?"

    3 It is not in dispute that the issue has now been settled before the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 21762 of 2017 in the case of Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax (Exemptions) Vs. Ahmedabad Urban Development Authority. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in paras 185 to 190 has held as under:

    "185. As far as boards and corporations which are tasked with development of industrial areas, by statute, the judgments of this court, in Shri Ramtanu Cooperative Housing Society (supra) and Gujarat Industrial Development Corporation (supra) have declared that these bodies are involved in 'development' and are not essentially engaged in trading. In Shri Ramtanu Cooperative Housing Society (supra) this court, by a five judge bench, held that the Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation is not a trading concern, and observed as follows:

    "These features of transfer of land, or borrowing of moneys or receipt of rents and profits will by themselves neither be the indicia nor the decisive attributes of the trading character of the Corporation. Ordinarily, a

    Page 3 of 12

    Corporation is established by shareholders with their capital. The shareholders have their Directors for the regulation and management of the Corporation Such a Corporation set up by the shareholders carries on business and is intended for making profits. When profits are earned by such a Corporation they are distributed to shareholders by way of dividends or kept in reserve funds. In the present case, these attributes of a trading Corporation are absent. The Corporation is established by the Act for carrying out the purposes of the Act. The purposes of the Act are development of industries in the State. The Corporation consists of nominees of the State Government, State Electricity Board and the Housing Board. The functions and powers of the Corporation indicate that the Corporation is acting as a wing of the State Government in establishing industrial estates and developing industrial areas, acquiring property for those purposes, constructing buildings, allotting buildings, factory sheds to industrialists or industrial undertakings. It is obvious that the Corporation will receive moneys for disposal of land, buildings and other properties and also that the Corporation would receive rents and profits in appropriate cases. Receipts of these moneys arise not out of any business or trade but out of sole purpose of establishment, growth and development of industries.

    17. The Corporation has to provide amenities and facilities in industrial estates and industrial areas. Amenities of road, electricity, sewerage and other facilities in industrial estates and industrial areas are within the programme of work of the Corporation. The found of the Corporation consists of moneys received from the State Government, all fees, costs and

    Page 4 of 12

    charges received by the Corporation, all moneys received by the Corporation from the disposal of lands, buildings and other properties and all moneys received by the Corporation by way of rents and profits or in any other manner. The Corporation shall have the authority to spend such sums out of the general funds of the Corporation or from reserve and other funds. The Corporation is to make provision for reserve and other specially denominated funds as the State Government may direct. The Corporation accepts deposits from persons, authorities or institutions to whom allotment or sale of land, buildings, or sheds is made or is likely to be made in furtherance of the object of the Act. A budget is prepared showing the estimated receipts and expenditure. The accounts of the Corporation are audited by an auditor appointed by the State Government. These provisions in regard to the finance of the Corporation indicate the real role of the Corporation viz. the agency of the Government in carrying out the purpose and object of the Act which is the development of industries. If in the ultimate analysis there is excess of income over expenditure that will not establish the trading character of the Corporation. There are various departments of the Government which may have excess of income over expenditure.

    ************** ******** *********

    20. The underlying concept of a trading Corporation is buying and selling. There is no aspect of buying or selling by the Corporation in the present case. The Corporation carries out the purposes of the Act, namely, development of industries in this State. The construction of buildings, the establishment of

    Page 5 of 12

    industries by letting buildings on hire or sale, the acquisition and transfer of land in relation to establishment of industrial estate or development of industrial areas and of setting up of industries cannot be said to be dealing in land or buildings for the obvious reason that the State is carrying out the objects of the Act with the Corporation as an agent in setting up industries in the State. The Act aims at building an industrial town and the Corporation carries out the objects of the Act. The hard core of a trading Corporation is its commercial character. Commerce connotes transactions of purchase and sale of commodities, dealing in goods. The forms of business transactions may be varied but the real character is buying and selling. The true character of the Corporation in the present case is to act as an architectural agent of the development and growth of industrial towns by establishing and developing industrial estates and industrial areas. We are of opinion that the Corporation is not a trading one."

    186. In Shri Ramtanu Cooperative Housing Society (supra) no doubt, this court did not have to decide whether the Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation was entitled to tax exemption. However, it examined the provisions of the Act, and the ratio, that such industrial development corporations are not engaged in trading, is binding. Like in that case, here too, the concerned state Acts (Gujarat Industrial Development Act, 1962 and the Karnataka Industrial Areas Development Act, 1966) tasked the boards with planning and development of industrial areas. Their personnel are appointed under the enactments and are deemed to be public servants. The state government is empowered to acquire land, in exercise of eminent domain power, for their purposes; their audits are by the Accountant

    Page 6 of 12

    General of the concerned state, or auditors appointed by the state. They are authorized by law, to levy rates and charges, for the services they provide, on pre-determined basis. In the light of these provisions, clearly, these boards and authorities perform objects of general public utility; and they are not driven by profit motive.

    187. There is a two-fold distinction between the now-deleted Section 10(20A) and the newly added Section 10(46) (w.e.f. 01.06.2011). Firstly, that the erstwhile Section 10(20A) applied to a limited class of undertaking i.e., the bodies, or corporations, constituted by or under any law-confined to the planning and development of housing infrastructure. However, the newly added Section 10(46) is wider in comparison and the activities of any body or authority or board constituted by or under any central or State Act with "the object of regulating or administering any activity for the benefit of the general public", has broader import. In a sense, the newly added Section 10(46), resembles a GPU category charity classified under Section 2(15). The second distinction is that Section 10(20A) did not bar any board, or corporations, etc. from indulging in commercial activities. However, sub-clause (b) of Section 10(46) imposes such a bar, and the concerned body cannot claim tax exemption if it engages in commercial activity.

    188. The manner in which GPU charities has been dealt with under the definition clause, i.e., Section 2(15), indicates that even though trading or commercial activity or service in relation to trade, commerce or business appears to be barred - nevertheless the ban is lifted somewhat by the proviso which enables such activities to be carried out if they are intrinsically part of the activity of achieving the object of general public utility. Furthermore, in the case of GPU charities there is a

    Page 7 of 12

    quantified limit of the overall receipts, which is permissible from such commercial activity. In the case of local authorities and corporations covered by Section 10(46) no such activities are seemingly permitted.

    189. As was observed in the earlier part of this judgment - while considering whether for the period 01.0.2003 - 31.05.2011, statutory boards, corporations, etc. could have lawfully claimed to be GPU charities, this court has observed that the nature of such corporations is not to generate profit but to make available goods and other services for the benefit of public weal. If such corporations (falling within the description of Section 10(46)) applied to the Central Government for exemption, the treatment of their receipts, should be no different than how such receipts can and should have been treated for the purposes of determining whether they are GPU charities, during the period when Section 10(46) was not in existence. Furthermore, this court is of the opinion that having regard to the observations in Gujarat Maritime Board case (supra), the denial of exemption under one category cannot debar such corporations from claiming income exempt status under another category.

    (b)Summary in relation to statutory authorities/ corporations

    190. In light of the above discussion, this court is of the opinion that:

    (i) The fact that bodies which carry on statutory functions whose income was eligible to be considered for exemption under Section 10(20A) ceased to enjoy that benefit after deletion of that provision w.e.f. 01.04.2003, does not ipso facto preclude their claim for consideration for benefit as GPU category charities, under Section 11 read with Section 2(15) of the Act.

    Page 8 of 12

    (ii) Statutory Corporations, Boards, Authorities, Commissions, etc. (by whatsoever names called) in the housing development, town planning, industrial development sectors are involved in the advancement of objects of general public utility, therefore are entitled to be considered as charities in the GPU categories.

    (iii) Such statutory corporations, boards, trusts authorities, etc. may be involved in promoting public objects and also in the course of their pursuing their objects, involved or engaged in activities in the nature of trade, commerce or business.

    (iv) The determinative tests to consider when determining whether such statutory bodies, boards, authorities, corporations, autonomous or selfgoverning government sponsored bodies, are GPU category charities:

    (a) Does the state or central law, or the memorandum of association, constitution, etc. advance any GPU object, such as development of housing, town planning, development of industrial areas, or regulation of any activity in the general public interest, supply of essential goods or services - such as water supply, sewage service, distributing medicines, of food grains (PDS entities), etc.;

    (b) While carrying on of such activities to achieve such objects (which are to be discerned from the objects and policy of the enactment; or in terms of the controlling instrument, such as memorandum of association etc.), the purpose for which such public GPU charity, is set-up - whether for furthering the development or a charitable object or for carrying on trade, business or commerce or service in relation to such trade, etc.;

    (c) Rendition of service or providing any article or goods, by such boards, authority, corporation, etc., on cost or nominal mark-up basis would ipso facto not be activities in the

    Page 9 of 12

    nature of business, trade or commerce or service in relation to such business, trade or commerce;

    (d)where the controlling instrument, particularly a statute imposes certain responsibilities or duties upon the concerned body, such as fixation of rates on pre- determined statutory basis, or based on formulae regulated by law, or rules having the force of law, setting apart amenities for the purposes of development, charging fixed rates towards supply of water, providing sewage services, providing food-grains, medicines, and/ or retaining monies in deposits or government securities and drawing interest therefrom or charging lease rent, ground rent, etc., per se, recovery of such charges, fee, interest, etc. cannot be characterized as "fee, cess or other consideration" for engaging in activities in the nature of trade, commerce, or business, or for providing service in relation in relation thereto;

    (e) Does the statute or controlling instrument set out the policy or scheme, for how the goods and services are to be distributed; in what proportion the surpluses, or profits, can be permissively garnered; are there are limits within which plots, rates or costs are to be worked out; whether the function in which the body is engaged in, is normally something a government or state is expected to engage in, having regard to provisions of the Constitution and the enacted laws, and the observations of this court in NDMC; whether in case surplus or gains accrue, the corporation, body or authority is permitted to distribute it, and if so, only to the government or state; the extent to which the state or its instrumentalities have control over the corporation or its bodies, and whether it is subject to directions by the concerned government, etc.;

    Page 10 of 12

    (f) As long as the concerned statutory body, corporation, authority, etc. while actually furthering a GPU object, carries out activities that entail some trade, commerce or business, which generates profit (i.e., amounts that are significantly higher than the cost), and the quantum of such receipts are within the prescribed limit (20% as mandated by the second proviso to Section 2(15)) - the concerned statutory or government organisations can be characterized as GPU charities. It goes without saying that the other conditions imposed by the seventh proviso to Section 10(23C) and by Section 11 have to necessarily be fulfilled.

    (v) As a consequence, it is necessary in each case, having regard to the first proviso and seventeenth proviso (the latter introduced in 2012, w.r.e.f 01.04.2009) to Section 10(23C), that the authority considering granting exemption, takes into account the objects of the enactment or instrument concerned, its underlying policy, and the nature of the functions, and activities, of the entity claiming to be a GPU charity. If in the course of its functioning it collects fees, or any consideration that merely cover its expenditure (including administrative and other costs plus a small proportion for provision) - such amounts are not consideration towards trade, commerce or business, or service in relation thereto. However, amounts which are significantly higher than recovery of costs, have to be treated as receipts from trade, commerce or business. It is for those amounts, that the quantitative limit in proviso (ii) to Section 2(15) applies, and for which separate books of account will have to be maintained under other provisions of the IT Act."

    4 Reading the aforesaid paras would indicate that it is

    Page 11 of 12

    now concluded that the respondent is an authority involved in the advancement of objects of general public utility, and therefore, is not precluded from claiming exemption. The appeal is, accordingly, dismissed.

    (BIREN VAISHNAV, J)

    (BHARGAV D. KARIA, J)

    BIMAL

    Page 12 of 12

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (EXEMPTIONS) v. AHMEDABAD URBAN DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
    (Sep 11, 2023)