Loading..
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This Appeal arises from an Order dated 18th April 2023 passed by the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Cuttack Bench, in IA(IB) No. 14/CB/2023 connected to CP(IB) No. 1174/KB/2018. The Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) was initiated against Jagannath Sponge Private Limited on 20th April 2019 under Section 7 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016.

A Resolution Plan submitted by M/s Omkara Asset Reconstruction Company was approved by the Adjudicating Authority on 6th August 2021. The Appellant was informed of this approval on 19th July 2022 and had earlier challenged the approval in an appeal which was subsequently withdrawn on 25th November 2022.

Subsequently, the Respondent requested electricity supply with a connected load of 550 KVA. The Appellant demanded payment of outstanding electricity dues amounting to Rs. 13,46,19,931/-. The Respondent filed an application before the Adjudicating Authority seeking directions to the Appellant to provide electricity connection and to set aside the demand for arrears. The Adjudicating Authority framed two issues for consideration: the validity of the demand for dues and entitlement to the electricity connection.

The Adjudicating Authority held that the approved Resolution Plan was binding and the claim of arrears by the Appellant was not valid as they had not filed a claim during the CIRP. The Authority directed that the arrears demand was unenforceable and ordered the Appellant to consider the electricity connection application without insisting on payment of past dues prior to 6th August 2021. The Appellant challenged this order in the present Appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the demand of Rs. 13,46,19,931/- by the Appellant against the Respondent is valid and enforceable post approval of the Resolution Plan?
  2. Whether the Respondent is entitled to be granted electricity service connection without payment of the alleged arrears?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Electricity dues must be paid before electricity connection can be granted to the Respondent.
  • Electricity supply to the Corporate Debtor was disconnected in 2013 and power supply agreements were terminated in 2013 and 2015 respectively.
  • The total arrears claimed amount to Rs. 13,56,19,931/- which remain payable.
  • The Resolution Professional did not properly publish the claims process, preventing the Appellant from filing its claim during CIRP.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Appellant did not file any claim for dues during the CIRP, thus pre-CIRP dues stand extinguished.
  • The Resolution Plan expressly directs that the electricity distribution company shall not raise any demand for past dues.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ghanashyam Mishra and Sons Pvt. Ltd. through Authorized Signatory vs. Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction Company Limited through the Director & Ors., (2021 SCC OnLine SC 313) Extinguishment of all dues, including statutory dues, not part of the approved Resolution Plan prior to approval date under Section 31 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code. The Court relied on paragraph 102.3 of the judgment to hold that pre-CIRP dues not included in the Resolution Plan stand extinguished and cannot be enforced against the corporate debtor or the successful resolution applicant.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the facts in light of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code and the approved Resolution Plan. It noted that the Appellant did not file any claim for its pre-CIRP electricity dues during the insolvency resolution process, which is a prerequisite for enforcing such claims post-approval. The Court emphasized the binding nature of the approved Resolution Plan and the specific waiver contained therein, directing electricity distribution companies not to raise demands for past dues.

The Court referred to the Supreme Court judgment in Ghanashyam Mishra and Sons Pvt. Ltd. vs. Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd., which clarified that all dues not included in the Resolution Plan stand extinguished upon approval. The Court found no merit in the Appellant's contention regarding lack of proper publication by the Resolution Professional, as the Adjudicating Authority had already considered and rejected this argument. Furthermore, the Appellant had previously withdrawn its appeal challenging the Resolution Plan approval, precluding reconsideration of that issue.

Accordingly, the Court upheld the Adjudicating Authority's direction that the Appellant must consider the Respondent’s electricity connection application without insisting on payment of pre-approval arrears.

Holding and Implications

The Appeal is dismissed.

The Court confirmed the binding effect of the approved Resolution Plan under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, holding that pre-CIRP dues not claimed during the insolvency process are extinguished and cannot be enforced against the corporate debtor or the successful resolution applicant. The direct consequence is that the Appellant must provide electricity connection to the Respondent without demanding payment of the alleged arrears prior to the date of plan approval. No new precedent was established beyond the application of existing law and prior Supreme Court authority.

    TATA POWER WESTERN ODISHA DISTRIBUTION LIMITED (TPWODL) AND ANOTHER v. JAGANNATH SPONGE PVT. LTD.

    NATIONAL COMPANY LAW APPELLATE TRIBUNAL

    PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI

    Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) No. 777 of 2023

    [Arising out of Order dated 18.04.2023 passed by the Adjudicating Authority (National Company Law Tribunal), Cuttack Bench, in IA(IB) No. 14/CB/2023 arising out of CP(IB) No. 1174/KB/2018 in TP No. 34/CTB/2019]

    IN THE MATTER OF:

    1. TATA POWER WESTERN ODISHA DISTRIBUTION

    LIMITED (TPWODL)

    Through Chief Executive Officer Electrical Division, Rajgangpur, Dist. Sundergarh Odisha - 770017

    Telephone:

    Email: tpwodl@tpwesternodisha.com

    2. THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER TATA POWER

    WESTERN ODISHA DISTRIBUTION LIMITED

    (TPWODL)

    Having its Registered Office at: Burla, Dist. SAMBALPUR

    Odisha - 768017

    Telephone : 0663-2431984

    Email: tpwodl@tpwesternodisha.com …Appellants Versus

    1. JAGANNATH SPONGE PRVIATE LIMITED,

    Through its director Sh. Arun Kumar Gaindhar, Having its Registered Office at; Panda Colony, Bisra Dahar Road,

    Rourkela, Dist. Sundergarh, Odisha - 770017 Email: jagannathspongepvtltd@gmail.com …Respondents

    Cont'd…/

    1

    -2-

    Present:

    For Appellant: Mr. Anupam Lal Das, Sr. Advocate, Mr. Hasan Murtaza, Ms. Nikita Thapar, Advocates

    For Respondents: Ms. Ankita Patnaik, Advocate

    J U D G M E N T

    ASHOK BHUSHAN, J.

    1. This Appeal has been filed against the Order dated 18thApril, 2023 passed by National Company Law Tribunal, Cuttack Bench, Cuttack (hereinafter referred to as "The Adjudicating Authority") in IA(IB) No. 14/CB/2023 arising out of CP(IB) No. 1174/KB/2018.

    2. Brief facts of the case necessary to be noticed for deciding this Appeal are:-

    i. On an application filed under Section 7 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (hereinafter referred to as "The Code") against the Jagannath Sponge Private Limited, Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP in short) was initiated vide Order dated 20thApril, 2019 of the Adjudicating Authority.

    ii. The Resolution Plan was submitted in the CIRP of the Corporate Debtor by one M/s Omkara Asset Reconstruction Company which plan was approved by the Adjudicating Authority vide Order dated 06thAugust, 2021. The Appellant vide Letter dated 19thJuly, 2022 was informed that Resolution Plan has been

    -3-

    approved by the Adjudicating Authority. The Appellant filed C.A.(AT) Insolvency No. 1404 of 2022 challenging the Order dated 06thAugust, 2021 which Appeal was withdrawn by the Appellant on 25thNovember, 2022.

    iii. The Respondent vide Letter dated 05thAugust, 2022 requested the Appellant to supply electricity with CD 550KVA to its units. The Appellant informed the Respondent of outstanding arrears of Electricity dues amounting to Rs. 13,46,19,931/-. The Respondent filed an Application before the Adjudicating Authority I.A.(IB) 14/2023 seeking direction to Appellant to provide electricity connection to the two units and set aside the demand of arrears of electricity dues. The Adjudicating Authority heard the parties and framed following two points for consideration:

    "1. Whether letter dated 08.12.2022 of 2nd respondent demanding Rs. 13,46,19,931/- against the applicant is valid?

    2. Whether the applicant is entitled for service connection?"

    iv. The Adjudicating Authority took the view that Resolution Plan having been approved which is binding, the claim of Appellant against the Successful Resolution Applicant of arrears is not valid. The Adjudicating Authority noted that the Appellant did not file any claim in the Insolvency Resolution Process of the Corporate Debtor. Adjudicating Authority by the Impugned Order issued following directions:

    -4-

    "1. It is hereby declared that the amount of Rs. 13,46,19,931/- claimed by the respondents in their impugned letter dated 08.12.2022 addressed to applicant is not valid and not enforceable as against the corporate debtor/successful resolution applicant.

    2. The 2nd Respondents is directed to consider the service connection application of the applicant submitted by the successful resolution applicant or any other person on its behalf, in accordance with the code/regulation without insisting to make any payment/arrears in whatever nature payable by the corporate debtor prior to 06.08.2021."

    v. Aggrieved by the said order, the Appellant has come up in the Appeal.

    3. Learned Counsel for the Appellant in support of Appeal contends that electricity dues of the Appellant required to be paid before Electricity Connection can be given to the Respondent. It is submitted that electricity was disconnected of the Corporate Debtor in the year 2013 and the two related power supply agreements were terminated with effect from 03.10.2013 and with effect from 01.02.2015. The total arrears of electricity against the Corporate Debtor were Rs. 13,56,19,931/- which is required to be paid. It is submitted that there being no proper publication by the Resolution Professional, Appellant could not file its claim in the CIRP Process.

    4. Learned Counsel for the Respondent refuting the submission of the Appellant contends that Appellant having not filed its claim, its pre-CIRP

    -5-

    dues has been extinguished and in the Resolution Plan the Adjudicating Authority has already issued direction that electricity distribution company shall not raise any demand for reference to the past dues.

    5. We have considered the submissions of Learned Counsel for the parties and have perused the record.

    6. The Adjudicating Authority in several paragraphs while dealing with point no. 1 and 2 has extracted the part of the Resolution Plan under the waivers, reliefs and exemptions, Sl. No., which refers as follows:

    Sl No. Waivers, Reliefs and Exemptions sought from NCLT Orders thereon
    The Hon’ble NCLT be pleased to give or issue necessary directions, instructions to the relevant electricity board to give the exemption to the Corporate Debtor from making payment towards reconnection charges of power. The electricity distribution companies shall not raise any demand with reference to the past dues. They shall, however, treat the application that shall be filed by the corporate debtor, as a new connection and collect charges as applicable for a new connection, without any coercion or precondition to pay the past dues.

    7. There is no dispute to the fact that Appellant did not file any claim of its Pre-CIRP dues of Rs. 13,46,19,931/-. The Adjudicating Authority has rightly relied on Judgment of "Ghanashyam Mishra and Sons Pvt.

    -6-

    Ltd. through the Authorized Signatory vs. Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction Company Limited through the Director & Ors.", (2021 SCC OnLine SC 313). Paragraph 102.3 of the Supreme Court Judgment is as follows:

    "102.3 Consequently all the dues including the statutory dues owed to the Central Government, any State Government or any local authority, if not part of the resolution plan, shall stand extinguished and no proceedings in respect of such dues for the period prior to the date on which the Adjudicating Authority grants its approval under Section 31 could be continued."

    8. The submission of the Appellant that there was no proper publication of the announcement made by the Resolution Professional has been dealt by the Adjudicating Authority in paragraph 8 of the Order. The Adjudicating Authority has noted the provisions of Regulation and has returned a finding that on the above submission of the Appellant plan approval cannot be held to be vitiated. It is also to be noted that against the plan approval order, Appellant filed an Appeal which was withdrawn by the Appellant themselves. No contention by the Appellant challenging the plan approval can be considered. The Adjudicating Authority while approving the Plan having already issued directions that Electricity Distribution Companies shall not raise any demand with reference to the past dues, we see no error in the direction issued by the Adjudicating Authority by the Impugned Order directing the Appellant to consider the service connection application of the Applicant in accordance with the Code/Regulation without insisting on making any payment of arrears

    -7-

    prior to date of plan approval. No grounds have been made out to interfere with the Impugned Order passed by the Adjudicating Authority. There is no merit in the Appeal, the Appeal is dismissed.

    [Justice Ashok Bhushan] Chairperson

    [Barun Mitra]

    Member (Technical)

    NEW DELHI

    08th August , 2023

    Basant B.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    TATA POWER WESTERN ODISHA DISTRIBUTION LIMITED (TPWODL) AND ANOTHER v. JAGANNATH SPONGE PVT. LTD.
    (Aug 8, 2023)