Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order IX, Rule 13 of the Code
  • Order IX, Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order XLIII, Rule 1(d) of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • Order IX Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908,
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 13,
  • sub-rule (1),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order IX, Rule 13 of the Code
  • Order IX, Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order XLIII, Rule 1(d) of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • Order IX Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908,
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 13,
  • sub-rule (1),
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of Opinion — High Court of Kerala (Anil K. Narendran & P.G. Ajithkumar, JJ.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from O.S. No. 190 of 2012 filed in the Sub Court, Ottapalam by the respondent (plaintiff) claiming damages of Rs.5,00,000. On 24.11.2015, when the suit was listed for trial, the appellant (defendant) informed his counsel had no instructions and the defendant was set ex parte; an ex parte decree in O.S. No. 190 of 2012 was entered by order dated 24.11.2015. The appellant filed I.A. No. 2528 of 2015 under Order IX Rule 13 CPC seeking to set aside the ex parte decree, supported by an affidavit and a medical certificate (marked Ext.A1) which stated the appellant was suffering acute back pain and advised rest from 21.11.2015. The respondent opposed the application, alleging lack of bona fides, fabrication of the medical certificate and that the defendant was present in court premises on 24.11.2015. The trial court examined the appellant as PW1, marked Ext.A1, and dismissed I.A. No. 2528 by order dated 18.02.2016 on the ground that the evidence showed the medical certificate was fabricated and the appellant had been present in the court premises and wilfully failed to appear. The appellant challenged that interlocutory order before this Court by an appeal under Order XLIII Rule 1(d) CPC (FAO No. 83 of 2016). On admission, notice was issued and the matter was heard by this Division Bench on 15.06.2023.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Sub Court erred in dismissing I.A. No. 2528 of 2015 under Order IX Rule 13 CPC and refusing to set aside the ex parte decree passed in O.S. No. 190 of 2012.
  2. Whether the appellant had shown "sufficient cause" within the meaning of Order IX Rule 13 CPC for his non-appearance on the date the suit was taken up for trial (24.11.2015).
  3. If interference with the impugned order is warranted, what conditional relief (if any) is appropriate in the circumstances of the case (for example, costs or other terms)?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The application under Order IX Rule 13 CPC (I.A. No. 2528 of 2015) was filed within the period of limitation and therefore the Sub Court should have allowed it.
  • In support of the application the appellant produced a medical certificate and an affidavit asserting he was suffering from acute back pain from 21.11.2015 and was advised rest, which prevented him from giving instructions to his counsel.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent contended that the appellant failed to show sufficient cause for his absence on the date fixed for trial.
  • The respondent alleged lack of bona fides, that the medical certificate (Ext.A1) was not genuine, and that the defendant was available in the court premises on 24.11.2015 — indeed that the defendant consulted his lawyer outside court that day.
  • The respondent further pointed out that this was the second occasion on which the appellant had been set ex parte, and relied on that fact to oppose relief.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
G.P. Srivastava v. R.K. Raizada, (2000) 3 SCC 54 The phrase "was prevented by any sufficient cause from appearing" in Order IX Rule 13 CPC must be liberally construed; "sufficient cause" is an elastic expression; courts have wide discretion; "sufficient cause" refers to the date on which the absence was made a ground for proceeding ex parte and cannot be stretched to anterior circumstances. The bench relied on these principles to affirm that when an Order IX Rule 13 application is within the statutory period, discretion should normally be exercised in favour of the defendant (subject to absence not being mala fide or intentional) and that costs can compensate the plaintiff for inconvenience.
Peeves Enterprises v. Muhammed Ashraf, 2015 (3) KHC 981 (Division Bench of Kerala High Court) Applying G.P. Srivastava, the court held that the trial court must determine whether the erring party has made out sufficient cause; where no negligence or inaction is imputable and absence was not mala fide, and the application is within time, discretion should favour the defendant; plaintiff can be compensated by costs. This decision was cited to support the proposition that appellate interference is warranted where the application under Order IX Rule 13 is within time and the legal test for "sufficient cause" favours the defendant, subject to reasonable costs.
Shivananda M. v. M. Susheela, 2021 (5) KHC 357 Reiterated the principle that "sufficient cause" refers to the date on which absence was made a ground for ex parte, that prior negligence cannot be stretched forward to defeat a timely application, and that when application is filed promptly discretion normally favours the defendant unless absence was mala fide. The bench relied on this reiteration to apply the established approach and guidelines when deciding whether to set aside an ex parte decree where an application under Order IX Rule 13 is within time.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in the following steps, as reflected in the text of the judgment:

  1. Statutory framework: The Court set out the text and purpose of Order IX Rule 13 CPC — which permits a defendant against whom an ex parte decree has been passed to apply to set it aside if he satisfies the court that summons were not duly served or that he was prevented by sufficient cause from appearing. The rule also contains provisos limiting relief where a party had notice and sufficient time to appear and an Explanation precluding a fresh application where an appeal was already disposed of on certain grounds.
  2. Survey of governing precedent: The Court summarized the principles from G.P. Srivastava and subsequent Kerala High Court decisions (Peeves Enterprises and Shivananda) that (a) "sufficient cause" is to be liberally construed and is an elastic concept, (b) the relevant "sufficient cause" is to be judged with reference to the date on which absence produced ex parte proceedings (and not stretched to prior conduct), and (c) where an application under Order IX Rule 13 is within the statutory period and the absence was not mala fide, discretion is normally exercised in favour of setting aside the ex parte decree, subject to reasonable terms such as costs.
  3. Application to the facts: The Court noted the trial court's findings — including the trial court's view that the medical certificate (Ext.A1) appeared fabricated and the appellant's admission that he had been present in the court premises and had consulted his lawyer outside court on 24.11.2015 — and that the trial court therefore dismissed the application. Notwithstanding those factual findings recorded by the trial court, the Division Bench examined the case in the light of the cited authorities and the fact that the application under Order IX Rule 13 had been filed within the period of limitation.
  4. Discretion and balancing: Applying the legal principles, the Court concluded that the discretion exercised by the Sub Court in dismissing the application required interference. The Bench qualified its interference by imposing a cost condition — reflecting a balancing exercise: interference with the order was warranted (consistent with the precedent favouring defendants who file within time), but because the appellant had earlier been set ex parte on a prior occasion, the Court required payment of costs as a term for relief.
  5. Remedial direction: The Court specified the practical consequences and directions to give effect to its view: payment of costs within two weeks would lead to setting aside of the impugned interlocutory order and thereafter the ex parte decree would be set aside; the Sub Court was directed to proceed with the suit and dispose it expeditiously (within four months), and the Court fixed a date for appearance before the Sub Court.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal was allowed and the impugned order dated 18.02.2016 of the Sub Court, Ottapalam (dismissing I.A. No. 2528 of 2015) was set aside subject to a condition. The Court's core ruling is emphasized below:

Core Ruling: THE APPEAL IS ALLOWED AND THE IMPUGNED ORDER DATED 18.02.2016 IS SET ASIDE ON PAYMENT OF COSTS OF RS. 5,000/- BY THE APPELLANT/DEFENDANT.

Direct consequences and procedural directions:

  • The appellant-defendant must pay Rs. 5,000 to the respondent-plaintiff within two weeks of receipt of a certified copy of this judgment. Upon such payment being made, the impugned order dated 18.02.2016 will stand set aside and, consequently, the ex parte decree passed in O.S. No. 190 of 2012 will stand set aside.
  • After the ex parte decree is set aside, the Sub Court, Ottapalam shall proceed with the suit and dispose of it as expeditiously as possible, in any event within four months (the suit being of the year 2012).
  • Both parties were directed to appear before the Sub Court, Ottapalam on 04.07.2023.

Broader implications:

The Court applied established precedents concerning the liberal construction of "sufficient cause" under Order IX Rule 13 CPC and directed that, where an application to set aside an ex parte decree is filed within the period of limitation, the discretion is normally exercised in favour of the defendant unless absence was mala fide. In this case the Court did not purport to lay down a new legal principle; it applied existing authorities and remitted the matter to the Sub Court subject to the specified condition of costs. No novel precedent was announced.


End of summary. This summary is confined to the material and findings expressly stated in the provided opinion of the High Court of Kerala in FAO No. 83 of 2016 (dated 15.06.2023).

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    N.BASHEER v. SIVASANKARA MENON

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

    PRESENT

    THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL K. NARENDRAN

    &

    THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P.G. AJITHKUMAR

    THURSDAY, THE 15TH DAY OF JUNE 2023 / 25TH JYAISHTA, 1945

    FAO NO. 83 OF 2016

    AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 18.02.2016 IN I.A.NO.2528 OF 2015 IN

    O.S.NO.190 OF 2012 OF SUB COURT, OTTAPPALAM

    APPELLANT/PETITIONER/DEFENDANT:

    N.BASHEER, AGED 41 YEARS

    S/O. NEDIYEDATH KUNJHAMMU HAJI, KURUVATTOR AMSOM DESOM, OTTAPALAM TALUK, PIN-679335.

    BY ADV SRI.DINESH MATHEW J.MURICKEN

    RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT/PLAINTIFF:

    SIVASANKARA MENON

    S/O. K. RUGMINI AMMA, RESIDING AT "SIVASAKTHI".

    VANIYAMKULAM AMSOM, PULACHITHRA DESOM, OTTAPALAM

    TALUK, PIN-679522.

    BY ADVS.SRI.ARUN MATHEW VADAKKAN

    SRI.SANTHEEP ANKARATH

    THIS FIRST APPEAL FROM ORDERS HAVING COME UP FOR

    ADMISSION ON 15.06.2023, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED

    THE FOLLOWING:

    1

    2

    JUDGMENT

    Anil K. Narendran, J. The appellant is the defendant in O.S.No.190 of 2012 on the file of the Sub Court, Ottapalam, which was one filed by the respondent herein-plaintiff claiming damages to the tune of Rs.5,00,000/-. On 24.11.2015, when the case was listed for trial, the learned counsel for the appellant-defendant reported no instructions and therefore, the defendant was set ex pate. By the order dated 24.11.2015, O.S.No.190 of 2012 decreed ex parte. The appellant filed I.A.No.2528 of 2015 in O.S.No.190 of 2012, an application under Order IX Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, seeking an order to set aside that ex parte decree. In the affidavit filed in support of that application, it was stated that the appellant was suffering from acute back pain from 21.11.2015 and he was advised to take rest. Therefore, he could not give necessary instructions to his counsel. The respondent-plaintiff filed counter opposing the reliefs sought for in that interlocutory application by contending that the application is without any bona fides; the medical certificate produced by the defendant is not genuine; the defendant was available outside the court on 24.11.2015; on an earlier occasion, the ex parte decree passed against the defendant was set aside. The appellant-defendant was

    3

    examined as PW1 and Ext.A1 medical certificate was marked on his side. After considering the rival contentions, the court below dismissed I.A.No.2528 of 2015 by the order dated 18.02.2016. The reasoning of the court below, as contained in paragraph 7 of the order, reads thus;

    "7. The argument by the learned counsel for the respondent that the evidence of PW1 alone is sufficient to belie the case of the petitioner is well founded. The evidence of PW1 himself would go to show that Ext.A1 medical certificate is false. A perusal of Ext.A1 would go to show that it is dated 21.11.2015 and the doctor had advised rest for one week from 21.11.2015. According to the petitioner, he had consulted the doctor on 12.01.2016 and the doctor had advised rest for one week. He would further say that rest for one week started from 12.01.2016. PW1 also would say that he had consulted the doctor only once. Therefore, it is evident that the medical certificate produced along with the petition, i.e., Ext.A1 has nothing to do with the illness of the petitioner. It is evident that it is a fabricated document. It is further made clear by the admission of PW1 that during November 2015 he had come to the court 4-5 occasions. It is specifically admitted by him that on 24.11.2015 he had consulted his lawyer outside the court. Even according to the petitioner, the suit had come up in the list for trial on 24.11.2015. The evidence of PW1 would go to show that he was available in the court premises on that day. This evidence of PW1 would prove that the contention by the respondent is true. It is contended by the respondent that on 24.11.2015, the petitioner was in the court premises and

    4

    he did not appear before the court wilfully. This contention by the respondent stands admitted by PW1. So, the evidence of PW1 would go to show that the petitioner has come up with a false affidavit and medical certificate and that it is also evident that he did not appear before the court wilfully when the matter had come up in the list for trial. It is evident that there is absolutely no bona fides in the petition and the petition is liable to be dismissed."

    Feeling aggrieved by the aforesaid order, the appellant-defendant is before this Court in this appeal, invoking the provisions under Order XLIII, Rule 1(d) of the Code of Civil Procedure.

    2. On 17.03.2016, when this appeal came up for admission, this Court issued notice to the respondent in both the appeal and the interlocutory application.

    3. Heard the learned counsel for the appellant-defendant and also the learned counsel for the respondent-plaintiff.

    4. The learned counsel for the appellant-defendant would submit that I.A.No.2528 of 2015 in O.S.No.190 of 2012, the application under Order IX Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure, was one filed within the period of limitation. Therefore, the Sub Court ought to have allowed that application.

    5. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent-plaintiff would contend that the appellant failed to show sufficient cause for his absence. The learned counsel would

    5

    point out that it is for the second time that the appellant- defendant was set ex parte and therefore, the Sub Court cannot be found fault with in dismissing the interlocutory application, by the impugned order dated 18.02.2016.

    6. Order IX, Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure provides for setting aside of ex parte decree against defendant. As per sub-rule (1) of Rule 13, in any case in which a decree is passed ex parte against a defendant, he may apply to the court which the decree was passed for an order to set it aside; and if he satisfies the court that the summons was not duly served, or that he was prevented by any sufficient cause from appearing when the suit was called on for hearing, the court shall make an order setting aside the decree as against him upon such terms as to costs, payment into Court or otherwise as it thinks fit, and shall appoint a day for proceeding with the suit. As per the first proviso to sub-rule (1), where the decree is of such a nature that it cannot be set aside as against such defendant only it may be set aside as against all or any of the other defendants also. As per the second proviso to sub-rule (1), no court shall set aside a decree passed ex parte merely on the ground that there has been an irregularity in the service of summons, if it is satisfied that the defendant had notice of the date of hearing and had sufficient

    6

    time to appear and answer the plaintiff's claim. As per the Explanation, where there has been an appeal against a decree passed ex parte under this rule, and the appeal has been disposed of on any ground other than the ground that the appellant has withdrawn the appeal, no application shall lie under this rule for setting aside that ex parte decree.

    7. In G.P. Srivastava v. R.K. Raizada [(2000) 3 SCC

    54] in the context of an application filed under Order IX, Rule 13 of the Code, for setting aside an ex parte decree, the Apex Court held that, the word 'was prevented by any sufficient cause from appearing' occurring in Order IX, Rule 13 of the Code must be liberally construed to enable the court to do complete justice between the parties, particularly when no negligence or inaction is imputable to the erring party. Sufficient cause for the purpose of Order IX, Rule 13 of the Code has to be construed as an elastic expression for which no hard and fast guidelines can be prescribed. The courts have wide discretion in deciding the sufficient cause keeping in view the peculiar facts and circumstances of each case.

    8. In G.P. Srivastava [(2000) 3 SCC 54], the Apex Court held further that, 'sufficient cause' for non-appearance refers to the date on which the absence was made a ground for

    7

    proceeding ex parte and cannot be stretched to rely upon other circumstances anterior in time. If 'sufficient cause' is made out for non-appearance of the defendant on the date fixed for hearing when ex parte proceedings initiated against him, he cannot be penalised for his previous negligence which had been overlooked and thereby condoned earlier. In a case where defendant approaches the court immediately and within the statutory time specified, the discretion is normally exercised in his favour, provided the absence was not mala fide or intentional. For the absence of a party in the case the other side can be compensated by adequate costs and the lis decided on merits.

    9. In Peeves Enterprises v. Muhammed Ashraf [2015

    (3) KHC 981], relying on the law laid down by the Apex Court in

    G.P. Srivastava [(2000) 3 SCC 54], a Division Bench of this Court held that, on an application filed under Order IX, Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the court has to find out whether the erring party has made out sufficient cause for setting aside the ex parte decree. When no negligence or inaction is imputable to the erring party and the absence was not mala fide or intentional, the discretion has to be exercised in his favour, especially when the application is within the statutory time limit. In appropriate cases, the plaintiff can be compensated by adequate costs for the loss of

    8

    time and the inconvenience caused to him. But any such condition shall not be too onerous.

    10. The principle laid down in Peeves Enterprises [2015

    (3) KHC 981] was reiterated in Shivananda M. v. M. Susheela [2021 (5) KHC 357]. It was held that 'sufficient cause' for non- appearance refers to the date on which the absence was made a ground for proceeding ex parte and cannot be stretched to rely upon other circumstances anterior in time. If 'sufficient cause' is made out for the non-appearance of the defendant on the date fixed for hearing when ex parte proceedings were initiated against him, he cannot be penalised for his previous negligence which had been overlooked and thereby condoned earlier. In a case where a defendant approaches the Court immediately and within the statutory time specified, the discretion is normally exercised in his favour, provided the absence was not mala fide or intentional. For the absence of a party in the case the other side can be compensated by adequate costs and the lis decided on merits.

    11. In view of the law laid down in the decisions referred to supra, when the application under Order IX, Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure is one filed within the period of limitation, the discretion has to be exercised in favour of the defendant, when no negligence or inaction is imputable to the defendant and his

    9

    absence was not mala fide or intentional. For the absence of the defendant, the plaintiff can be compensated by adequate costs and the lis decided on merits.

    12. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, in the light of the law laid down in the decisions referred to supra, we find that the order dated 18.02.2016 of the Sub Court, Ottapalam in I.A.No.2528 of 2015 in O.S.No.190 of 2012 requires interference; however on payment of costs, since the appellant- defendant was set ex parte on an earlier occasion as well.

    13. In the result, this appeal is allowed and the impugned order dated 18.02.2016 of the Sub Court, Ottapalam in I.A.No.2528 of 2015 in O.S.No.190 of 2012 is set aside on payment of a cost of Rs.5,000/- (Rupees Five thousand only) payable by the appellant-defendant to the respondent-plaintiff, within two weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this judgment. On such payment being made, the impugned order dated 18.02.2016 of the Sub Court, Ottapalam in I.A.No.2528 of 2015 in O.S.No.190 of 2012 will stand set aside and consequently, the ex parte decree passed in O.S.No.190 of 2012 will stand set aside. Thereafter, the Sub Court shall proceed with the suit and dispose of the same, as expeditiously as possible, at any rate, within a period of four months, since the suit is of the year 2012.

    10

    Both parties shall appear before the Sub Court, Ottapalam,

    on 04.07.2023. Sd/-

    ANIL K. NARENDRAN, JUDGE

    Sd/-

    P.G. AJITHKUMAR, JUDGE

    AV/17/6

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    N.BASHEER v. SIVASANKARA MENON
    (Jun 15, 2023)