Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2017 PHHC 108996
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Acts
  • Order 39 Rule 2(a) of the CPC.
  • Order 6 Rule 17 of the CPC
  • Order 39 Rule 2(a)
  • Order 9, Rule 4; Order 9, Rule 7; Order 9, Rule 9; and Order 9 Rule 13 of the Code.
  • section 35-B of the Code, section 151 of the Code
  • Section 35-B,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2017 PHHC 108996
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Acts
  • Order 39 Rule 2(a) of the CPC.
  • Order 6 Rule 17 of the CPC
  • Order 39 Rule 2(a)
  • Order 9, Rule 4; Order 9, Rule 7; Order 9, Rule 9; and Order 9 Rule 13 of the Code.
  • section 35-B of the Code, section 151 of the Code
  • Section 35-B,
Smart Summary

High Court of Punjab and Haryana — CR No.7254 of 2017 (Darshan Singh & Others v. Gurmeet Singh)

Factual and Procedural Background

This revision petition challenges two orders of the learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), Ludhiana in Civil Suit No. CS-4133-2016 (titled Gurmeet Singh v. Darshan Singh & others):

  • Order dated 17.05.2017 (Annexure P-11) striking off the defence of the defendants-petitioners for failure to file written statement and for non-payment of costs; and
  • Order dated 14.09.2017 (Annexure P-17) dismissing the defendants-petitioners' review petition against the 17.05.2017 order.

Key factual sequence as recorded in the opinion:

  • On 22.03.2017, new counsel for the defendants filed a power of attorney in the trial Court. On that date an application under Order 39 Rule 2(a) was also listed; the newly engaged counsel, while superseding the former counsel, placed his power in the matter but was not aware of separate proceedings/listing in the main suit.
  • Because of this lack of notice and confusion, the defendants' counsel noted an adjournment date (10.05.2017) pertaining to the Order 39 Rule 2(a) matter and did not notice the civil suit's adjournments. The civil suit had been adjourned to 24.04.2017 (with costs imposed) and subsequently to 17.05.2017 with costs of Rs.1,000/-. The defendants were unrepresented on 24.04.2017 and also on 17.05.2017.
  • On 17.05.2017 the trial Court struck off the defence (Annexure P-11). The defendants' counsel discovered the listing on 06.07.2017 while appearing in another case and filed a memo of appearance on that date (Annexure P-12).
  • The defendants filed Civil Revision No.4860 of 2017 in this Court which was dismissed as withdrawn on 27.07.2017 with liberty to approach the trial Court; a review petition before the trial Court was dismissed on 14.09.2017 (Annexure P-17).
  • Thereafter the present revision petition was filed in this Court seeking recall of the order striking off the defence and one opportunity to file the written statement on the ground that non-appearance and non-payment of costs were due to circumstances beyond the defendants' control (a bona fide mistake), not mala fide conduct.
  • The respondent-plaintiff did not appear before this Court and the matter proceeded ex parte against him.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the impugned order dated 17.05.2017 striking off the defence, and the subsequent order dated 14.09.2017 dismissing the review, were liable to be set aside where non-appearance/non-payment of costs was asserted to be the result of a bona fide error.
  2. Whether a court should recall an order striking off defence for failure to deposit costs where sufficient cause is shown (including circumstances beyond the control of the defaulting party) and whether inherent jurisdiction/Section 148 of the CPC can be invoked for that purpose.
  3. Whether the doctrine of implied waiver (i.e., where no objection is taken on the crucial date and the case is allowed to proceed further) operates to bar a party from seeking recall of an order striking off defence for non-payment of costs.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' (Defendants') Arguments

  • The failure to appear and the non-payment of costs on the adjourned dates were the result of a bona fide mistake caused by confusion between the main suit listing and an application under Order 39 Rule 2(a); the newly engaged counsel had not received notice of the main suit listing/adjournment and had inadvertently noted the date for the interlocutory application instead.
  • The defendants promptly acted upon discovering the omission: a memo of appearance was filed on 06.07.2017 and the defendants sought relief through a revision and then a review petition in the trial Court.
  • Counsel relied on precedent to contend that (a) the Full Bench decision in Shri Anand Prakash v. Bharat Bhushan Rai (1981 PLR 555) requires disallowing prosecution/defence where costs are not paid on the adjourned date, but (b) a subsequent Full Bench in Prem Sagar v. Phul Chand (1983 PLR 797) held that if the question of payment of costs was not raised on the crucial date and the case was allowed to proceed then that conduct amounts to an implied waiver of the right to bar further prosecution — hence, the plaintiff's right to bar the defence was impliedly waived; and
  • Counsel also relied on Municipal Committee, Kharkhoda v. Bhim Singh (1987 (1) PLR 435) to submit that recall of an order striking off defence for non-deposit of costs is maintainable where the Court is satisfied that sufficient cause is shown, invoking inherent jurisdiction/Section 148 where appropriate.
  • The petitioners offered to pay the costs already ordered and additional costs to demonstrate bona fides and sought one opportunity to file the written statement.

Respondent's (Plaintiff's) Position

The respondent-plaintiff did not appear before this Court; the proceedings before this Court therefore proceeded ex parte against the respondent. The opinion does not contain any detailed account of arguments advanced on behalf of the respondent.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shri Anand Prakash v. Bharat Bhushan Rai, 1981 PLR 555 (Full Bench) Held that in the absence of a party paying costs for adjournment on the adjourned date it was mandatory for the Court to disallow further prosecution of the suit or defence. The decision was cited by petitioners' counsel in support of legal propositions about striking off for non-payment of costs. The Court considered the submissions but did not base its order solely on this authority; instead the Court found a bona fide error and, to avoid a technical approach at an early stage of the suit, set aside the impugned orders and granted an opportunity to file the written statement.
Prem Sagar v. Phul Chand, 1983 PLR 797 (Full Bench) Held that if the question of payment of costs was not raised on the crucial date and the case was allowed to proceed further then this amounts to an implied waiver by the party having the right to seek bar to further prosecution of the suit or defence. Counsel relied on paragraph 16 of this decision to argue implied waiver by the plaintiff. The Court noted the submission, but its ultimate decision rested on a finding of bona fide error and the interest of justice rather than on application of this precedent as the dispositive ground.
Municipal Committee, Kharkhoda v. Bhim Singh, 1987 (1) PLR 435 (Single Bench) Recognised that an application to recall an order striking off defence for non-deposit of costs is maintainable; where sufficient cause is shown the Court may exercise its inherent jurisdiction (section 151) and/or enlarge time under section 148 of the CPC to recall such orders. Relied upon by petitioners' counsel to argue that the trial Court could recall the order striking off defence if sufficient cause was shown. The High Court considered this principle in the submissions and concluded that sufficient cause (a bona fide error) had been demonstrated, leading to the setting aside of the impugned orders and grant of one opportunity to file the written statement (subject to payment of costs).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's reasoning, as recorded orally by Hon'ble Mr. Justice B.S. Walia, followed these steps:

  1. The Court considered the factual matrix and the submissions of learned counsel for the defendants-petitioners that a bona fide error had occurred because the newly engaged counsel filed his power in respect of an interlocutory application (Order 39 Rule 2(a)) and was unaware of the main suit's adjournments and costs directions. This led to inadvertent non-appearance on the relevant dates in the main suit.
  2. The Court observed objective indicia of bona fides: counsel for the defendants filed a memo of appearance promptly on 06.07.2017 upon noticing the matter while in Court for another case (Annexure P-12 was placed on record).
  3. The Court noted that petitioners had pursued remedies (a High Court revision application that was withdrawn with liberty, and a review petition before the trial Court) and that the trial Court's review dismissal had been cryptic and non-speaking (a point advanced by petitioners' counsel).
  4. The Court weighed the competing considerations: the technical strictness of striking off defence for non-appearance/non-deposit of costs versus the interest of justice, particularly given that the civil suit was at an initial stage and an application under Order 6 Rule 17 for amendment of the plaint was also on file.
  5. The Court explicitly adopted an approach to "avoid a technical approach" in the circumstances described. On this basis, and having accepted that a bona fide error had occurred rather than mala fide conduct, the Court found it appropriate to set aside the impugned orders and to permit the defendants one opportunity to file the written statement.
  6. As a condition for relief and to balance interests, the Court made the grant of opportunity subject to payment of costs of Rs.10,000/- to the respondent.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Revision petition allowed. The High Court set aside the trial Court's order dated 17.05.2017 (Annexure P-11) striking off the defence and the order dated 14.09.2017 (Annexure P-17) dismissing the review. The defendants-petitioners were granted one opportunity to file their written statement, subject to payment of Rs.10,000/- as costs to the respondent.

Implications:

  • Direct consequence for the parties: the defence is reinstated for the defendants-petitioners and they are permitted one opportunity to file their written statement upon payment of the specified costs. The trial Court's prior orders striking off the defence and dismissing the review have been set aside.
  • Scope and precedent: the Court's decision is fact-specific and grounded on a finding of bona fide error and the stage of proceedings; the opinion does not purport to lay down a new general rule beyond applying established principles (as discussed in the cited authorities) to the facts of this case. The opinion expressly frames the result as an exercise to avoid a technical approach in the circumstances recorded.

Neutral Citation No.: 2017:PHHC:108996 — Judgment pronounced on November 07, 2017 (B.S. Walia, J.).

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    DARSHAN SINGH & ORS v. GURMEET SINGH

    CR No.7254 of 2017 -1-

    271

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA

    AT CHANDIGARH

    CR No.7254 of 2017 Date of Decision : 07.11.2017

    DARSHAN SINGH AND OTHERS

    ....PETITIONERS

    VERSUS

    GURMEET SINGH

    ....RESPONDENT

    CORAM : HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B.S. WALIA

    Present: Mr. Atul Goyal, Advocate for the petitioners. ------

    B.S. WALIA, JUDGE (ORAL)

    [1] Petitioners have challenged order dated 17.05.2017 (Annexure P-11), passed by the Civil Judge (Jr. Divn.), Ludhiana in suit bearing No.CS-4133-2016, whereby the defence of the defendants- petitioners was struck off as also order dated 14.09.2017 (Annexure P-17), whereby review filed by the defendants-petitioners against the order striking off defence was also dismissed.

    [2] Brief facts of the case leading to the filing of the instant revision petition are that on 22.03.2017, counsel engaged by the defendants-petitioners in supersession of their former counsel filed his power of attorney in the case listed before the Court of the learned Civil Judge (Jr. Divn.), Ludhiana. Learned counsel contends that on the said date, apart from the main suit, application under Order 39 Rule 2(a) was also listed. However, defendants-petitioners counsel who was filing power of attorney by superseding the former counsel was not aware of the

    1 of 9

    aforementioned position nor had any notice been received by the defendants-petitioners or their former counsel with regard to the application under Order 39 Rule 2(a) of the CPC. In the circumstances, the power of attorney came to be placed in the matter pertaining to the application under Order 39 Rule 2(a) of the CPC and adjournment of the same to 10.05.2017 was noted as the date in the civil suit by the counsel for the defendants-petitioners while adjournment of the civil suit on the said date to 24.04.2017 along with imposition of costs of Rs.500/- did not come to the notice of the counsel before the learned trial Court. Consequently on 24.04.2017, none was present in the civil suit on behalf of the defendants-petitioners.

    [3] Learned counsel further contends that although new counsel had been engaged in the matter, yet the presence of the former counsel was marked in routine in the zimni order on 24.04.2017 and on the said date, the suit was adjourned to 17.05.2017 with costs of Rs.1000/-. Learned counsel contends that unaware of the listing of the civil suit on 24.04.2017 or for that matter of the same having been adjourned to 17.05.2017, counsel for the defendants-petitioners appeared in the case under Order 39 Rule 2(a) of the CPC on 10.05.2017 assuming it to be the main civil suit. However, on 10.05.2017 the application under Order 39 Rule 2(a) was adjourned to 10.07.2017.

    [4] As has been noted above, the civil suit had been adjourned on 24.04.2017 to 17.05.2017, subject to payment of cost of Rs.1000/-. However, on account of being unaware of the position in the background of events as noted above, counsel engaged on behalf of the defendants-

    2 of 9

    petitioners could not put in appearance before the Court of the learned Civil Judge (Jr. Divn.), Ludhiana in Civil Suit No.CS-2133-2016 titled as 'Gurmeet Singh versus Darshan Singh and others' on 17.05.2017. Consequently, impugned order dated 17.05.2017 i.e. Annexure P-11 was passed, striking off the defence of the defendants-petitioners on account of their failure to file the written statement as well as to pay the costs.

    [5] Learned counsel contends that the counsel for the defendants- petitioners conducting the case before the learned trial Court came to know about the situation on 06.07.2017 when he noticed the civil suit reflected in the cause list while appearing in another case in the said Court. On coming to know of the aforementioned position, defendants- petitioners counsel filed memo of appearance in the civil suit on 06.07.2017. Thereafter the defendant petitioner filed Civil Revision No.4860 of 2017 but the same was dismissed as withdrawn by this Court vide order dated 27.07.2017, with liberty to approach the learned trial Court by moving an appropriate application. Thereafter, the defendants- petitioners filed a review petition before the learned Civil Judge (Jr. Divn.), Ludhiana, praying for recall of order dated 17.05.2017 i.e. Annexure P-11, whereby the defence of the defendants-petitioners was struck off. However, the review petition was dismissed by the learned Civil Judge (Jr. Divn.), Ludhiana vide order dated 14.09.2017, i.e. Annexure P-17, by observing that order dated 17.05.2017 was passed after taking all factual aspects of the matter into account and there was no legal defect in order dated 17.05.2017. In the aforementioned background, instant revision petition has been filed praying for grant of

    3 of 9

    one opportunity for filing of written statement on the ground that non- appearance before the learned trial Court leading to passing of impugned order dated 17.05.2017 i.e. Annexure P-11 was on account of circumstances beyond the control of the defendants-petitioners and not on account of any ulterior motive or mala fide consideration.

    [6] Despite notice having been served on the respondent, none has put in appearance. Consequently, the respondent is proceeded against ex parte. Learned counsel for the defendants-petitioners further contends that the proceedings are listed before the trial Court for today itself.

    [7] I have considered the submissions made by learned counsel for the defendants-petitioners. Learned counsel contends that since the defendants-petitioners counsel was not able to appear in the civil suit due to a bona fide mistake, therefore, the impugned order was liable to be recalled and the defendants-petitioners granted one opportunity to file the written statement. Learned counsel contends that despite the entire factual position as has been referred to above having been brought to the notice of the learned Civil Judge (Jr. Divn.), Ludhiana, by way of review petition, the petition for review was dismissed by a cryptic and non speaking order by recording that the impugned order dated 17.05.2017 i.e. Annexure P-11 had been passed after taking all factual aspects of the case into account and there was no legal defect in order dated 17.05.2017. Learned counsel contended that the defendants-petitioners were willing to pay costs as had been ordered by the learned trial Court besides any further costs in addition thereto in order to show their bona fide for being granted one opportunity to file the written statement by setting aside the

    4 of 9

    impugned order particularly in view of the fact that non appearance was solely due to absence of knowledge on account of the mistake as referred to above.

    [8] Learned counsel contended that no doubt in view of the decision of the Hon'ble Full Bench in 'Shri Anand Prakash versus Shri Bharat Bhushan Rai and another', 1981 PLR 555, in the absence of a party paying costs for adjournment on the adjourned date, it was mandatory for the Court to disallow prosecution of the suit or defence as the case may be but the aforementioned decision had been considered by a subsequent Full Bench of this Court in 'Prem Sagar versus Phul Chand', 1983 PLR 797 wherein it was held that if the question of payment of costs was not raised on the crucial date fixed for the payment of the same and the case was allowed to proceed further then the same would amount to implied waiver by the party having the right to seek bar to the further prosecution of the suit or defence. On the basis of the same, learned counsel contended that since no objection had been raised by the respondent-plaintiff on the adjourned date and the suit had been allowed to proceed further on account of adjournment from 22.03.2017 to 24.04.2017 and thereafter from 24.04.2017 to 17.05.2017, the right to bar further prosecution of defence was impliedly waived by the respondent-plaintiff. Learned counsel relied upon paragraph No. 16 of the aforementioned. The same is reproduced as under:-

    "To conclude, both on principle and precedent, as also on the language of Section 35-B, the answer to the question posed at the very outset is rendered in the

    5 of 9

    negative. It is held that the party defaulting in the payment of costs on the date fixed for the payment thereof (on which date this issue is not at all raised) cannot on subsequent date or dates be barred afresh from further prosecuting the suit or the defence, as the case may be."

    [9] On the basis of the same, it is contended that inadvertent and unknowing default by the defendants-petitioners to pay the costs on 24.04.2017 and 17.05.2017 did not debar them from further prosecuting the defence.

    [10] Learned counsel also relied upon the decision of a Single Bench of this Court in 'Municipal Committee, Kharkhoda versus Bhim Singh, 1987 (1) PLR 435 to contend that an application for recall of order striking off defence for non deposit of costs was maintainable and the said order could be recalled if the Court was satisfied about sufficiency of the cause shown. Learned counsel refers to paragraph No.4 of the aforementioned decision. The same is reproduced as under:-

    "For the aforesaid view I draw analogy from Order 9, Rule 4; Order 9, Rule 7; Order 9, Rule 9; and Order 9 Rule 13 of the Code. It is true that in all these rules specific provision is made permitting the defaulting party to move the Court for recalling or modifying the order. Since there is no specific provision under section 35-B of the Code, section 151 of the Code would be attracted under its inherent jurisdiction, if

    6 of 9

    the Court is satisfied that there was a sufficient cause for the defaulting party for not paying the costs on the date fixed, the Court can enlarge the time under section 148 of the Code. That is why there are certain observations in the Full Bench judgment of this Court, reported as Shri Anand Parkash v. Shri Bharat Bhushan Rai, 1982(1) R.C.R. (Rent) 1 : 1981 P.L.R. 555 which are to the following effect:-

    ".......However, where the costs are not paid as result of the circumstances beyond the control of the defaulting party, then the Court will be well within its jurisdiction to exercise its power under section 148 of the Code in favour of the defaulting party if a strong case is made out for the exercise of such jurisdiction."

    [11] On the basis of the same, learned counsel contended that sufficient cause having been made out by showing the circumstances in which the impugned order dated 17.05.2017 came to be passed, it would have been in the interest of justice and upholding of the majesty of law if the learned trial Court had reviewed the order dated 17.05.2017 but the application for review of order striking off defence was dismissed by the learned Civil Judge (Jr. Divn.) by passing a cryptic and non-speaking order. Learned counsel contends that in view of sufficiency of cause having been shown by the defendants-petitioners for non appearance on the date fixed for filing written statement as well as for non payment of

    7 of 9

    costs, order dated 17.05.2017 i.e. Annexure P-11 striking off the defence of the defendants-petitioners as well as order dated 14.09.2017 i.e. Annexure P-17, whereby review filed by the defendants-petitioners against the order dated 17.05.2017 had been dismissed are liable to be set aside and the defendants-petitioners granted one opportunity to file the written statement.

    [12] I have considered the submissions made by learned counsel and am of the considered view that in view of the position as has been noted above, it is apparent that bona fide error occurred in the matter, as a result of which the defendants-petitioners went unrepresented in the main suit. The bona fide of the defendants-petitioners is evident from the fact that their counsel filed a memo of appearance on 06.07.2017 in the civil suit on noticing the same having been listed while appearing in another case in the same Court. Copy of order recording the filing of memo of appearance by the counsel for the defendants-petitioners on 06.07.2017 has been placed on record as Annexure P-12.

    [13] In the circumstances, in order to avoid a technical approach, particularly in view of the civil suit being at the initial stage besides application having been moved under Order 6 Rule 17 of the CPC for amendment of the plaint, the revision petition is allowed, impugned order dated 17.05.2017, i.e. Annexure P-11, striking off the defence of the defendants-petitioners is set aside as is the order dated 14.09.2017, i.e. Annexure P-17, whereby review filed by the defendants-petitioners against order dated 17.05.2017, i.e. Annexure P-11, was dismissed. As a consequence of the setting aside of the impugned orders, the defendants-

    8 of 9

    petitioners are granted one opportunity for filing written statement, subject to payment of Rs.10,000/- as costs to the respondent.

    [14] Revision petition allowed in aforementioned terms.

    ( B.S. WALIA )

    JUDGE

    November 07, 2017

    rajneesh Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No Whether reportable: Yes/No

    Neutral Citation No:=2017:PHHC:108996

    9 of 9

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    DARSHAN SINGH & ORS v. GURMEET SINGH
    (Nov 7, 2017)