Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2023 PHHC 72571
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 21 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Section 438 Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 438 Cr.P.C., 1973
  • Section 437 or 439 of the Code
  • Section 438 of the Cr.P.C.
  • Section 438(1) of Cr.P.C.,
  • "Section 438(1) of the Code
  • provisions of Section 438 Cr.P.C., 1973,
  • 7 of 10 Section 438(1),
  • sub-Section 1 of Section 438
  • Sections 438 and 439 Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 438 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2023 PHHC 72571
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 21 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Section 438 Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 438 Cr.P.C., 1973
  • Section 437 or 439 of the Code
  • Section 438 of the Cr.P.C.
  • Section 438(1) of Cr.P.C.,
  • "Section 438(1) of the Code
  • provisions of Section 438 Cr.P.C., 1973,
  • 7 of 10 Section 438(1),
  • sub-Section 1 of Section 438
  • Sections 438 and 439 Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 438 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner sought second anticipatory bail under Section 438 Cr.P.C. in respect of FIR No. 274 dated 16.09.2022 (Sections 406 and 420 IPC) at Police Station Saha, District Ambala. The FIR alleges that the accused, in connivance, caused a loss of Rs.19,40,400/- to the complainant by dishonestly diverting sale proceeds received through portals and transferring the amounts into their own accounts instead of paying the complainant. An earlier anticipatory bail petition (CRM-M-237-2023) was filed by the petitioner and withdrawn on 06.01.2023 after the Court indicated it was not inclined to grant the relief. The present petition was filed about two months later by different counsel seeking anticipatory bail again.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a second or subsequent anticipatory bail application under Section 438 Cr.P.C., 1973 is maintainable.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • There were simple money transactions between the petitioner and the complainant; no specific allegations against the petitioner in the FIR.
  • The money was received by the petitioner's father.
  • The case is an abuse of process and a counter blast to complaints earlier filed by the petitioner and his family.
  • Principle of res judicata should not operate to bar a fresh anticipatory bail application, particularly where the earlier petition was withdrawn (relying on Rani Dudeja vs. State of Haryana).

Respondent's (State) Arguments

  • The second anticipatory bail petition is not maintainable.
  • On merits, the petitioner connived with others to cheat the complainant and caused wrongful loss of Rs.19,40,400/-.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Rani Dudeja vs. State of Haryana, 2017 Vol. 13, SCC 555 The principle that res judicata could not operate in an application for anticipatory bail where an earlier petition had been withdrawn; on change of circumstances a fresh Section 438 application should be considered on merits (paras 3 & 4 cited). Petitioner's counsel relied on this to argue withdrawal of earlier petition did not bar re-agitation; the Court considered the principle but found no change of circumstances here and proceeded to dismiss the second application.
Gurubaksh Singh Sibbia vs. State of Punjab, ((1980)2 SCC 565) Sets out principles for exercise of discretion under Section 438 (e.g., "reason to believe" must be founded on reasonable grounds; no blanket orders; anticipatory bail can be granted even after FIR filed if not arrested; need for court to apply its own mind; conditions and time-limits). The Court relied on these principles to assess the discretionary exercise under Section 438, emphasizing objective grounds for apprehension, the need to balance personal liberty and investigational rights, and that subsequent applications are permissible only upon change in facts or law.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first identified and addressed the preliminary procedural question of whether a second anticipatory bail application under Section 438 Cr.P.C. is maintainable. It reviewed the history and purpose of anticipatory bail, including Law Commission recommendations and legislative enactment as Section 438. The Court summarized principles from Gurubaksh Singh Sibbia regarding the exercise of discretion under Section 438 (noting requirements such as "reason to believe" founded on reasonable grounds, avoidance of blanket orders, and that courts must apply their own mind).

The Court examined the facts of the present matter and the earlier proceedings: the prior anticipatory bail petition was argued and then withdrawn on 06.01.2023 after the Court indicated reluctance to grant relief. The present petition was filed about two months later by different counsel. The Court found no subsequent event, change of circumstance, or substantial change in fact or law was pointed out or averred in the present petition.

Applying the legal principles, the Court held that a subsequent application under Section 438 is permissible only where there is a change in the fact-situation or law that justifies revisiting the earlier view. Because no such change was shown here, and the earlier petition had been withdrawn to avoid an adverse order, the Court concluded the present second anticipatory bail petition must fail.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED

Direct effect: The petition for second anticipatory bail is dismissed on the ground that a second application is not maintainable in the absence of any change in facts or law since the earlier (withdrawn) petition. The Court expressly stated that anything stated in the order shall not be construed as an expression of opinion on the merits of the case.

This opinion does not set out broader implications beyond the direct effect on the petition; no novel precedent was announced in the judgment.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    JATINDER RANA v. STATE OF HARYANA

    CRM-M-11210-2023 -1-

    2023:PHHC:072571

    103

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA

    AT CHANDIGARH

    CRM-M-11210-2023

    DECIDED ON:14.03.2023

    JATINDER RANA

    ....PETITONER

    VERSUS

    STATE OF HARYANA

    ....RESPONDENT

    CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANDEEP MOUDGIL

    Present: Mr. Shobit Phutela, Advocate for the petitioner

    Mr. Gagandeep Singh Chhina, AAG, Haryana.

    SANDEEP MOUDGIL, J

    1. The jurisdiction of this court under Section 438 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 has been invoked for the grant of second anticipatory bail to the petitioner in FIR No. 274, dated 16.09.2022, under Sections 406 and 420 IPC, registered at Police Station Saha, District Ambala.

    2. The factual matrix of the present case are that a complaint was lodged against the accused persons on the allegations that they in connivance with each other, with dishonest intention caused a huge financial loss to the tune of Rs.19,40,400/- to the complainant, who is a commission agent. Specific allegations against the accused-persons are that they dishonestly provided the portals (through which agricultural produce (crop) etc. is sold), of their relatives for selling the crops of third parties whose crops were lying with the complainant, but the same could not be sold

    1 of 10

    because of some government restrictions/policy etc., and after the sale proceeds came in the account of the portal holders, applicants/accused persons instead of providing the said amount to the complainant, so that complainant may give the said amount to the farmers whose crops were sold, committed breach of trust in respect of that amount, by getting the said amount transferred in their own account. On these facts and on the basis of certain other ancillary facts, present FIR came into existence.

    3. Mr. Shobit Phutela, learned counsel for the petitioner has contended that there were simple money transaction between the petitioner and the complainant. He further contends that there are no specific allegations against the petitioner in the present FIR. From a bare perusal of the FIR, it is evident that the money was received by the father of the petitioner. It is submitted by learned counsel for the petitioner that the instant case is an abuse of process of law and is a counter blast case, owing to the complaints already filed by the petitioner and his family against the complainant. .

    4. Learned State counsel Mr. Gagandeep Singh Chhina, AAG, Haryana has vehemently opposed the present petition primarily on its maintainability urging that second anticipatory bail application is not maintainable. On merits, he contends that the petitioner in connivance with other co-accused cheated the complainant and caused wrongful loss to the tune of Rs.19,40,400/-

    5. Be that as it may, before going to the merits of the case, this Court, would prefer to adjudicate on the preliminary objection raised by the learned State counsel i.e., whether second anticipatory bail application

    2 of 10

    under Section 438 Cr.P.C., 1973 is maintainable.

    6. From the perusal of record, it is an admitted fact by the the counsel for the petitioner that earlier also a petition bearing No. CRM-M- 237-2023 was filed seeking anticipatory bail, but the same was dismissed as withdrawn vide order dated 06.01.2023 (Annexure P-15) after arguing for some time, since the Court was not inclined to accept the said prayer.

    7. Learned counsel for the petitioner has argued that the principle of res judicata could not operate in an application for bail particularly in the light of the fact that the earlier petition had been withdrawn. The counsel has further asserted that wherein the petition was rejected on that ground would not mean that he cannot be allowed to re-agitate the matter on merits, while referring to judgment of the Supreme Court in Rani Dudeja vs. State of Haryana, 2017 Vol. 13, SCC 555 referring to para 3 & 4 thereof, which reads as under:

    "3. The appellant approached the High Court with a petition under Section 438 of the Cr.P.C. By the impugned order daetd 07.03.2017, the petition was rejected on the ground that the appellant had filed a petition earlier and the same had been withdrawn and, therefore, the appellant cannot be allowed to re-agitate the matter on merits.

    4. We are afraid, the stand taken by the High Court cannot be appreciated. The petition was for anticipatory bail and the one which had been filed earlier might have been withdrawn in a given situation, without inviting the Court to consider the same on merits. On change of circumstances, when another application under Section 438 Cr.P.C., was filed, the High Court should have considered the same on merits. The principle of res judicata could not have operated in an

    3 of 10

    application for bail."

    8. Heard learned counsel for the respective parties.

    9. To examine the issue and answer the question, I deem it just and fair to begin with noticing the provisions of anticipatory bail as introduced in the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 for the first time, since there was no such provision under the old Code of 1898. Earlier there had been conflicting views holding that bail could be granted to a person against whom a report of an offence was made even though, he was neither arrested nor detained and even in a case, where a person was suspected of an offence for which he might be arrested by a Police Officer but majority of view also held that even the High Court did not have inherent power to grant anticipatory bail by invoking Section 561A of the old Code, thereafter law Commission in its 41streport advocated the grant of power to superior Courts for the purpose of anticipatory bail, which was also endorsed in the 48threport of the Commission and incorporated Clause 447 of the Code of Criminal Procedure Bill, 1970 for the first time, which reads as under:-

    "31. The Bill introduces a provision for the grant of anticipatory bail. This is substantially in accordance with the recommendation made by the previous Commission (41st report). We agree that this would be a useful addition, though we must add that it is in very exceptional cases that such a power should be exercised.

    We are further of the view that in order to ensure that the provision is not put to abuse at the instance of unscrupulous petitioners, the final order should be made only after notice to the public prosecutor. The initial order should only be an interim one. Further the relevant section should make it clear that the direction can be issued only for reasons to be recorded,

    4 of 10

    and if the court is satisfied that such a direction is necessary in the interest of justice......"

    10. The said Clause was enacted as Section 438 in the existing Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. Thereafter, the Hon'ble five Judges of Supreme Court tested the judicial discretion envisaged under Section 438 Cr.P.C., alongwith other factors connected with the said provision in case

    Gurubaksh Singh Sibbia vs. State of Punjab, ((1980)2 SCC 565) and prompted certain principles which may be summarised as under:

    " (i) The use of the expression 'reason to believe' in Section 438(1) shows that the belief that the applicant may be so arrested must be founded on reasonable grounds. Mere 'fear' is not 'belief. A belief can be said to be founded on reasonable grounds only if there is something tangible to go by on the basis of which it can be said that the applicant's apprehension that he may be arrested is genuine. Such belief must be capable of being examined by the court objectively, because it is then alone that the court can determine whether the applicant has reason to believe that he may be arrested. Specific events and facts must be disclosed by the applicant in order to enable the court to judge of the reasonableness of his belief. (Paras 35, 40 and 41). A blanket order i.e. an order which serves as a blanket to cover or protect any and every kind of allegedly unlawful activity, in fact any eventuality,

    likely or unlikely regarding which, no concrete information can possibly be had should not generally be passed. Such a blanket order-is bound to cause serious interference with the functions of the police. (Paras 40 and 41)

    (ii)If an application for anticipatory bail is made to the High Court or the Court of Session it must apply its own mind to the question and decide whether a case has been made out for

    5 of 10

    granting such relief. It cannot leave the question for the decision of the Magistrate concerned under Section 437 of the Code, as and when an occasion arises. (Para 36). (iii)The filing of an FIR is not a condition precedent to the exercise of the power under Section 438. (Para 37) (iv)Anticipatory bail can be granted even after an FIR is filed, so long as the applicant has not been arrested. (Para 38).

    (v) The provisions of Section 438 cannot be invoked after the arrest of the accused. (Para 39)

    (vi)An order of bail can be passed under Section 438(1) without notice to the Public Prosecutor or the Government advocate forthwith and the question of bail should be re-examined in the light of the respective contentions of the parties. The ad interim order too must conform to the requirements of the section and suitable conditions should be imposed on the applicant even at that stage (Para 42)

    (vii)Regarding time-limit, if any, for anticipatory bail the court may, if there are reasons for doing so, limit the operation of the order to a short period until after the filing of an FIR in respect of the matter covered by the order. The applicant may in such cases be directed to obtain an order of bail under Section 437 or 439 of the Code within a reasonably short period after the filing of the FIR as aforesaid. But this need not be followed as an invariable rule. The normal rule should be not to limit the operation of the order in relation to a period of time. (Para 42)"

    11. In the light of aforesaid judicial pronouncements and the provisions of Section 438 Cr.P.C., 1973, it is crystal clear that the Court must be satisfied that a fit case had been made out for exercise of such discretion. This Court has to make an effort to strike a balance between the individuals right to personal freedom and the investigational rights of the

    6 of 10

    police. This provision is not to be applied mechanically especially in the light of phraseology "if it thinks fit" as envisaged therein with Sub Section(2) is indicative enough that such order on the face of it must show the reasons for granting anticipatory bail.

    12. The insertion of word "or" in sub-Section 1 of Section 438 has invested this Court with concurrent jurisdiction. Evidently the discretionary power to the Court does not flow from Article 21 of the Constitution of India for grant of anticipatory bail but conferred by the Statute enacted by the Parliament, wherein a distinction from the language of Sections 438 and

    439 Cr.P.C., is quite evident that the provisions contained in Section 439 flow from Article 21 of the Constitution of India.

    13. The constitutional Bench of the Apex Court has interpreted Section 438(1) of Cr.P.C., in the case of Gurubaksh's Singh (supra), which indicated:-

    "Section 438(1) of the Code lays down a condition which has to be satisfied before anticipatory bail can be granted. The application must show that he has "reason to believe" that he may be arrested for a non-bailable offence. The use of the expression "reason to believe" shows that the belief that the applicant may be arrested must be founded on reasonable grounds. Mere 'fear' is not belief for which reason it is not enough for the applicant to show that he has some sort of a vague apprehension that some one is going to make an accusation against him, in pursuance of which he may be arrested. The grounds on which the belief of the applicant is based that he may be arrested for a non-bailable offence, must be capable of being examined by the court objectively, because it is then alone that the court can determine whether the applicant has reason to believe that he may be arrested.

    7 of 10

    Section 438(1), therefore, cannot be invoked on the basis of vague and general allegations, as if to arm oneself in perpetuity against a possible arrest. Otherwise, the number of applicants for anticipatory bail will be, as large as, at any rate, the adult populace. Anticipatory bail is a device "to secure the individual's liberty". it is neither a passport to the commission of crime nor a shield against any and all kinds of accusations, likely or unlikely."

    14. Apart from that, the question "can a formula be devised conferring the power of granting anticipatory bail in straight jacket?" was answered in the negative observing that while laying down cast iron rules in a matter like granting anticipatory bail, it is apt to be overlooked that even Judges can have but an imperfect awareness of the needs of new situation. Judges have to decide cases as they come before them, mindful of the need to keep passions and prejudices out of their decisions and it will be strange, if, by employing judicial artifices and techniques, discretion conferred upon the Courts is cut down by devising a straight jacket formula. Going further, I noticed that the Hon'ble Constitution Bench narrated the situation and contingencies for invoking power under Section 438 indicating in para 8 of the judgment of Gurubaksh Singh Sibbia vs. State of Punjab (supra), which reads as under:

    "No one can accuse the police of possessing a healing touch nor indeed does anyone have misgiving in regard to constraints consequent upon confinement in police custody. But, society has come to accept and acquiesce in all that follows upon a police arrest with a certain amount of sangfroid, in so far as the ordinary rule of criminal investigation is concerned. It is the normal day-to-day business of the police to investigate into charges brought before them and broadly and generally, they

    8 of 10

    have nothing to gain, not favours at any rate, by subjecting ordinary criminals to needless harassment. But the crimes, the criminals and even the complainants can occasionally possess extraordinary features. When the even flow of the life becomes turbid, the police can be called upon to inquire into charges arising out of political antagonism. The powerful processes of criminal law can then be perverted for achieving extraneous ends. Attendant upon such investigations, when the police are not free agents within their sphere of duty, is a great amount of inconvenience, harassment and humiliation. That can even take the form of the parading of a respectable person in hand cuffs, apparently on way to a court of justice. The foul deed is done when an adversary is exposed to social ridicule and obloquy, no matter when and whether a conviction is secured or is at all possible. It is in order to meet such situations, though not limited to these contingencies, that the power to grant anticipatory bail was introduced into the Code of 1973".

    15. Having discussed the factual and legal chronology, this Court convincingly able to observe that while exercising powers under Section

    438 Cr.P.C., the Court is duty bound to strike a balance between the individuals right to personal freedom and the investigational right of the police, therefore, the provisions of anticipatory bail cannot be allowed to put to abuse at the instance of unscrupulous petitioners.

    16. Accordingly, the second or subsequent bail application under Section 438 Cr.P.C., can be filed, if there is a change in the fact-situation or in law, which requires the earlier view being interfered with or where the earlier finding has become obsolete. An accused, who has been denied the bail earlier can move a subsequent application only on in that limited area. If the issue, which had been canvassed earlier, would not be permitted to be

    9 of 10

    re-agitated on the same grounds, as it would lead to a speculation and uncertainty in the administration of justice and may lead to forum hunting.

    17. Perusal of the order dated 06.01.2023 (Annexure P-15) would show that the matter was argued and when this Court opined that it was not inclined to interfere in the matter, learned counsel for the petitioner, who had filed the first anticipatory bail, in order to avoid a detailed adverse order on merits, sought the permission of this Court to withdraw the said petition. After a period of 2 months from the passing of the said order, the present petition has been filed by another counsel, except change of the counsel, there is no subsequent event or change in circumstance, much less substantial change in circumstance has been pointed out by learned counsel for the petitioner or averred in the present petition.

    18. This Court is, therefore, of the considered view after having examined the submissions made by the counsel for the petitioner and the ambit of Section 438 Cr.P.C., this petition fails.

    19. Hence, holding that second anticipatory bail in such circumstances is not maintainable, the petition is ordered to be dismissed.

    20. However, it is made clear that anything stated hereinabove shall not be construed as an expression of opinion on the merits of the case.

    (SANDEEP MOUDGIL)

    14.03.2023 JUDGE

    sham Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No Whether Reportable Yes/No

    Neutral Citation No:=2023:PHHC:072571

    10 of 10

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    JATINDER RANA v. STATE OF HARYANA
    (Mar 14, 2023)