Loading..
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges

    EDELWEISS ASSET RECONSTRUCTION COMPANY LIMITED v. M/S W B ENGGSINTERNATIONAL PVT LTD

    Presented on : 18.11.2011 Registered on : 16.12.2011 Decided on : 20.04.2023 Duration : Y M D

    11 5 2

    IN THE DEBTS RECOVERY TRIBUNAL AT PUNE

    (Before Shri Dilip G Murumkar, Presiding Officer) ORIGINAL APPLICATION No.308/2011

    Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd.

    [Bank of Maharashtra - Original lender who has assigned the loan to the present applicant under Assignment Agreement dated 28thMarch, 2014] A Company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956 and registered as Securitization and Reconstruction Company, having its Registered Office at Edelweiss House, Off. C.S.T. Road, Kalina, Mumbai-400 098. … Applicant

    Versus

    1. M/s. W.B. Engineers International Pvt. Ltd.

    C 21/22, Liberty Society, North Main Road, Koregaon Park, Pune-411 001 Through the Managing Director

    2. Ms. Marietta Barnetto, C 21/22, Liberty Society, North Main Road, Koregaon Park, Pune-411 001.

    … Defendants

    APPEARANCES

    For the Applicant ARC Mr. Pradeep Yadav - Advocate For Defendants Mr. S.S. Panchpor - Advocate

    1

    TOTAL CLAIM AMOUNT - Rs.14,54,23,706.58Ps.

    JUDGMENT

    (Delivered on 20th April, 2023)

    1. The Applicant Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd. (for short `ARC') has filed the present application for recovery of aggregate Rs.14,54,23,706.58Ps. The details of which are as given below:

    Sr. No. Amount Type of Loan Rate of Interest
    1. Rs.4,16,51,976.58Ps. Term Loan-I Account No. 20000725915 @16.95% p.a. with monthly rests
    2. Rs.84,70,817/- Term Loan-II Account No. 20000726066 @16.95% p.a. with monthly rests
    3. Rs.3,23,54,846/- Term Loan-III Account No. 60000015805 @16.95% p.a. with monthly rests
    4. Rs.4,03,06,691/- Term Loan-IV Account No.60028435456 @16.95% p.a. with monthly rests
    5. Rs.1,01,23,535/- Term Loan-V Account No.60052582230 @16.95% p.a. with monthly rests
    6. Rs.69,12,930/- Term Loan-VI Account No.60055822544 @16.95% p.a. with monthly rests
    7. Rs.4,16,51,976.58Ps. Cash Credit Account No.20000721580 @16.70% p.a. with monthly rests

    thereon from 18thNovember, 2011 till full

    2

    repayment/realization of entire dues from defendant Nos.1 and 2 and enforcement of securities.

    2. The facts mentioned in the Application could be summarized as under:-

    The applicant ARC contended that defendant No.1 borrower was at the relevant time carrying on the business of sale and renting of heavy earthmoving equipments for mining infrastructure and cement industry who was banking with Bank of Maharashtra, erstwhile applicant Bank, which has assigned debt of the borrower under the Assignment Agreement dated 28thMarch, 2014 to present applicant ARC.

    The applicant ARC further contended that in the year 2006, defendant No.1 approached the erstwhile applicant Bank i.e. Bank of Maharashtra for financial assistance by way of Term Loan of Rs.1,74,00,000/- and Import/Inland LC of Rs.443 Lakhs for business purpose. Defendant No.2 agreed to be guarantor for the repayment of the said amounts with interest and charges and undertook personal liability for the same.

    On 02ndMarch, 2006 the erstwhile Bank of

    3

    Maharashtra granted the said credit facilities with interest @11.25% p.a. (floating).

    The applicant ARC further contended that on 03rd August, 2006 another Import/Inland LC of Rs.5,57,00,000/- was granted to defendant No.1.

    On 16thJanuary, 2007 on the request of defendant No.1, the erstwhile Bank of Maharashtra again sanctioned Term Loan of Rs.7,35,00,000/- with interest @15% p.a. for business. Defendant No.2 stood as guarantor. In the meantime, on 16thMay, 2009 the defendants admitted and confirmed outstanding in the various loan accounts as per Memorandum Cum Deed of Modification vide which defendants agreed to pay interest @14.50% p.a. with monthly rests.

    On 03rdJune, 2009, the erstwhile Bank of Maharashtra again sanctioned and disbursed Term Loan of Rs.4,11,00,000/-, with interest payable @14.50% p.a. Thereafter, in the year 2010, as per the request of defendant No.1, Cash Credit facility of Rs.1,50,00,000/- was enhanced to Rs.3,00,00,000/- and two additional loans of Rs.1,00,00,000/- each were sanctioned and disbursed.

    4

    Defendant No.2 stood as guarantor for the said facilities. In order to secure repayment, defendant No.1 mortgaged immovable property being Office/Flat Nos.21 & 22 at Koregaon Park, Pune, as mentioned in paragraph No.5(F) of the Original Application.

    On 23rdSeptember, 2010 defendant No.1 executed Hypothecation Deed for Rs.5,00,00,000/- and Guarantee Bond by defendant No.2 for Rs.5,00,00,000/- each. The applicant ARC contended that the charge created over the properties of defendant No.1 has been duly registered with the Registrar of Companies. The applicant ARC further contended that defendants have confirmed the balances in various accounts and confirmed the securities created by signing and delivering the Balance and Security Letter on 16thMay, 2009. The applicant ARC further contended that defendant No.1 did not operate the accounts satisfactorily and therefore, the accounts of defendant No.1 became Non- Performing Asset as per Reserve Bank of India guidelines. Thereafter, the applicant ARC through its Advocate issued Demand Notice on 7thFebruary, 2011, under

    5

    SARFAESI Act. The defendant challenged the action under SARFAESI Act by filing Securitization Application No.111/2011 which was dismissed by this Tribunal. The applicant ARC further contended that during the pendency of Original Application, the erstwhile Bank of Maharashtra has conducted E-auction on 18thJanuary, 2013 in respect of two properties i.e. Office No.21 admeasuring about 1100 sq. ft. and Office No.22 admeasuring about 1100 sq. ft. both situated on the second floor in the building C of the complex known as `Liberty (II)' and within `Liberty Co- operative Housing Society' on land situate and bearing F.P. NO.323 (part), TPS Sangamwadi, out of S.No.31/1A- 31/1B/3 of Village Ghorpadi, North Main Road, Koregaon Park, Pune for an amount of Rs.1,40,35,000/-. In the said E- auction Mr. Rajesh Vaishnave is successful bidder who has paid Rs.1,40,35,000/-. The said sale is challenged vide Securitization Application No.5/2013 before DRT, Pune which is disposed off. Hence, the amount of sale proceeds is required to be reduced from final determination amounts of the Original Application while claiming remaining amount for recovery, as contended in Additional Claim Affidavit

    6

    (Exhibit-32) filed by the applicant ARC. Hence this application is filed.

    3. Initially, the defendant Nos.1 and 2 did not file Written Statement and therefore, `No WS' Order was passed against them on 04thJune, 2012.

    However, thereafter, on 19thJuly, 2012 the defendant Nos.1 & 2 were allowed to file Written Statement. Accordingly, they filed Written Statement (Exhibit-20) whereby they have opposed the Original Application filed by the applicant ARC. Defendant Nos. 1 and 2 contended that although the loan of Rs.617 Lakhs was sanctioned, the defendant No.2 has never agreed to remain as guarantor and therefore, the defendant No.2 is not liable to pay jointly and severally with defendant No.1. The defendants also contended that the erstwhile applicant Bank never communicated any rate of interest for Letter of Credit facility of Rs.557 Lakhs. Defendants have disputed Deed of Hypothecation for absence of description of movable properties. Defendants further contended that instead of giving opportunity for OTS, the erstwhile applicant Bank has forcibly made them to enter into Memorandum of

    7

    Modification dated 16thMay, 2009 which is illegal and fresh loan documents shown to have executed by erstwhile applicant Bank for the loan facility of Rs.411 Lakhs are doubtful. Further, the contents of Deed of Mortgage are disputed by defendants. Defendants have also disputed the particulars of claim of each and every loan account. Defendants further disputed that various amounts were debited to the loan accounts and shown to have recovered the said amount by appropriating to respective accounts. Defendants further contended that the erstwhile applicant Bank has invoked the provisions of SARFAESI Act in respect of alleged immovable property of defendant No.2 by issuing the Notice u/s 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act. The defendants contended that erstwhile applicant Bank is not providing them OTS as per RBI norms.

    However, the Roznama dated 25thJanuary, 2016 reveals that despite having granted opportunities, defendants have not filed CAOD. Hence, the case of filing CAOD of defendants was closed on 25thJanuary, 2016.

    4. The Officer of applicant ARC Miss Sukanya Sahani, Authorized Signatory of Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction

    8

    Company Limited has filed Affidavit of Evidence (Exhibit-

    30) and she reiterated facts in the said Affidavit as elucidated in the pleadings.

    The applicant ARC also relied on loan transaction and security documents (Exhibit-31) in evidence (AW-1-1 to AW-1-45) which corroborates the case of the applicant Bank.

    5. The defendant Nos.1 and 2 failed to lead evidence. Therefore, contentions raised in the Written Statement (Exhibit-20) are devoid of consideration as observed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Iswar Bhai C. Patel alias Bachu Bhai Patel Vs. Harihar Behara and Anr. reported in AIR 1999 SC 1341 in respect of non-filing of the evidence affidavit.

    Consequently, I hold that the evidence of Miss Sukanya Sahani, witness of the applicant ARC in the form of Claim Affidavit and documentary evidence produced on record is conceivable. Therefore, application deserves to be allowed. Also, the applicant ARC has filed Additional Claim Affidavit (Exhibit-32) thereby contending mainly that the entire amount of Rs.1,40,35,000/- paid by successful bidder Mr. Rajesh Vaishnave may kindly be reduced from final

    9

    determination amount.

    6. The applicant ARC has charged Penal Interest in various loan accounts which cannot be granted and these amounts are deducted from the respective total claim amounts. Thus, the aggregate claim amount is reduced from Rs.14,54,23,707/- to Rs.14,44,92,657/-.

    Further, after adjusting the amount of Rs.1,40,35,000/- towards sale proceeds received through E-auction, the aggregate claim amount works out as under:

    Total claim amount (after deducting Penal Interest) Rs.14,44,92,657/-
    Less: Sale proceeds received through E- Auction Rs. 1,40,35,000/-
    Aggregate claim amount Rs.13,04,57,657/-

    7. I mention here that the future interest is claimed by the applicant ARC @16.70% with monthly rests for Cash Credit loan account and @16.95% p.a. with monthly rests for other loan accounts. However, considering the facts of the case, I am of the opinion that if future interest is granted @9% per annum (simple) for all loan accounts, it would be just and

    10

    reasonable rate of interest.

    8. Hence, I pass the following order:-

    ORDER

    (A) Or iginal Application No.308/2011 is allowed with costs.

    (B) De fendant nos.1 and 2 shall either jointly or severally pay to the applicant ARC the aggregate sum of Rs.13,04,57,657/- (Rupees Thirteen Crores Four Lakhs Fifty-Seven Thousand Six Hundred and Fifty-Seven only) with future interest @9% per annum from the date of filing of the Original Application i.e. 18thNovember, 2011 till full payment/realization of the amount mentioned in this operative order.

    (C) Th e aforesaid adjudicated amount is secured by hypothecation of movable assets i.e. (I) Present and future movable Plants, Machineries, goods, Stock of Raw Materials, Items, inventories, stocks in process, semi finished and finished goods, stores and spares (consumable stores and spares), stock in trade, goods in process, movable in

    11

    transit and present and future tangible and intangible assets, vehicle, goodwill, trademark etc; (II) Mining Machineries like - Jaw Crusher and Cone Crusher and (III) Mining Machineries just like - Finlay Jaw Crusher (1 No.), Pegson Cone Crusher with onboard screen (1 No.), Power plus 938 wheel Loader-3 Ton (2 Nos.), Power Plus

    966 Wheel Loder-5 Ton (1 No.), Finlay 683 Screener (1 No.) Finlay 683 Screener (1 No.), Finlay Jaw Crusher (1 No.), as mentioned in Deed of Hypothecation.

    (D) Th e applicant ARC is entitled to sell the hypothecated assets to recover its dues.

    (E) Iss ue Recovery Certificate.

    (F) The Registrar is directed to send the copy of Judgment and Recovery Certificate to the applicant ARC and defendants.

    Sd/-

    (Dilip G Murumkar) Place : Pune Presiding Officer Date : 20.04.2023 Debts Recovery Tribunal, Pune

    12

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    EDELWEISS ASSET RECONSTRUCTION COMPANY LIMITED v. M/S W B ENGGSINTERNATIONAL PVT LTD
    (Apr 20, 2023)