Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 5 LIMITATION ACT
  • SECTION 14 LIMITATION ACT
  • Order IX Rule 13 CPC.
  • Order IX Rule 13 of C.P.C.,
  • Section 96(2) r/w Order XLI Rule 1 of CPC
  • Section Order XLI Rule 3-A read with Section 151 of C.P.C.
  • rule 2 of Order XXIII of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908), the provisions of sub-section (1)
  • Section 96(2) read with Order XLI Rule 1 of CPC. 11.The
  • Order IX Rule 13 of C.P.C. read with Section 5 of the Limitation Act
  • Section 96 r/w Order XLI Rule 1 of C.P.C.
  • Section 14 of the Limitation Act. Section 14 of 7 the Limitation Act,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 5 LIMITATION ACT
  • SECTION 14 LIMITATION ACT
  • Order IX Rule 13 CPC.
  • Order IX Rule 13 of C.P.C.,
  • Section 96(2) r/w Order XLI Rule 1 of CPC
  • Section Order XLI Rule 3-A read with Section 151 of C.P.C.
  • rule 2 of Order XXIII of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908), the provisions of sub-section (1)
  • Section 96(2) read with Order XLI Rule 1 of CPC. 11.The
  • Order IX Rule 13 of C.P.C. read with Section 5 of the Limitation Act
  • Section 96 r/w Order XLI Rule 1 of C.P.C.
  • Section 14 of the Limitation Act. Section 14 of 7 the Limitation Act,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners, defendants in O.S.No.110 of 2015 before the Sub Court, Paramakudi, were sued by the respondent for specific performance based on a sale agreement dated 17.08.2015. The first petitioner had failed to execute the sale deed pursuant to this agreement, prompting the respondent to file the suit on 22.09.2015. During the pendency of the suit, the first petitioner executed a sale deed in favor of the second petitioner, after which the petitioners appeared and filed a written statement but failed to cross-examine the respondent's witness. Consequently, the petitioners were set ex-parte on 07.02.2017, and the suit was decreed in favor of the respondent. Execution proceedings followed, resulting in a sale deed executed in favor of the respondent. The petitioners subsequently filed applications for condoning delay in setting aside the ex-parte order, which were initially allowed by the trial court but later reversed by this Court. Special Leave Petitions filed by the petitioners were dismissed by the Supreme Court. The petitioners then filed the present application seeking condonation of delay of 1116 days in filing an appeal before the Principal District and Sessions Judge, Ramanathapuram, which was dismissed by the learned Principal District and Sessions Judge.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the delay of 1116 days in filing the appeal under Section 96(2) read with Order XLI Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Code can be condoned in light of prior dismissed applications for condonation of delay under Order IX Rule 13 and Section 5 of the Limitation Act.
  2. Whether the principle under Section 14 of the Limitation Act regarding exclusion of time spent in bona fide prosecution of proceedings in a court without jurisdiction applies to the facts of this case.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The learned counsel contended that the remedy available under Order IX Rule 13 of CPC read with Section 5 of the Limitation Act differs from the appellate remedy under Section 96(2) read with Order XLI Rule 1 of CPC.
  • They relied on the Supreme Court decision in N.Mohan Vs. R.Nadhu (2020 1 CTC 343), which involved a similar second round of litigation where delay was condoned in filing the appeal despite earlier refusal to condone delay in setting aside the ex-parte decree.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The learned counsel submitted that the impugned order is well reasoned and requires no interference.
  • No satisfactory explanation was provided for the delay in the first round of proceedings under Section 5 of the Limitation Act to condone delay under Order IX Rule 13 CPC.
  • The delay caused in filing the appeal can only be condoned under Section 14 of the Limitation Act, and the prior delays that were already disallowed cannot be condoned again.
  • The Supreme Court decision relied upon by the petitioners does not lay down a binding ratio and was based on the bona fide conduct of parties, which is not applicable here.
  • The petitioners were negligent in not filing the appeal in time, and the delay remains unexplained.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
N.Mohan Vs. R.Nadhu (2020 1 CTC 343) Condonation of delay in filing appeal after earlier refusal to condone delay in setting aside ex-parte decree; application of Section 14 of Limitation Act for exclusion of time spent prosecuting proceedings in court without jurisdiction. The Court followed the approach in this precedent, noting that delay already condoned and reversed in the first round cannot be condoned again in the second round. However, delay due to pursuing remedy before wrong forum may be condoned under Section 14 of the Limitation Act.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the history of the litigation, noting the initial ex-parte decree and subsequent attempts by the petitioners to condone delay in setting aside that decree. The trial court had condoned delay in two applications, but this Court reversed those orders, a decision affirmed by the Supreme Court. The Court emphasized that the period for which delay was condoned and then reversed cannot be condoned again in the appeal stage. The Court analyzed Section 14 of the Limitation Act, which excludes time spent prosecuting bona fide proceedings in a court without jurisdiction from the limitation period. The Court held that only the delay attributable to pursuing remedy before the wrong forum can be condoned under this provision.

Relying on the Supreme Court decision in N.Mohan Vs. R.Nadhu, the Court noted that while the Supreme Court condoned delay in a similar factual matrix, that decision was based on the bona fide conduct of the parties and was not a strict legal principle applicable universally. The Court found that the petitioners had not sufficiently explained the delay, and their negligence justified refusal to condone the delay without conditions.

However, considering the respondent had incurred inconvenience and deposited the balance sale consideration and registration charges, the Court was inclined to intervene in favor of the petitioners subject to the payment of Rs.1 lakh to the respondent as compensation. Upon such payment, the delay in filing the appeal would be condoned and the appeal would be numbered and disposed of expeditiously.

Holding and Implications

The Civil Revision Petition is disposed of with the direction that the petitioners shall pay Rs.1 lakh to the respondent by 07.06.2023. Subject to this payment, the application to condone delay in filing the appeal is allowed. The Principal District and Sessions Judge, Ramanathapuram, is directed to number the appeal and dispose it on merits preferably within nine months.

The direct effect of the decision is to permit the petitioners to file the delayed appeal upon payment of compensation to the respondent. No new precedent is set; the Court adheres to established principles regarding condonation of delay and the application of Section 14 of the Limitation Act.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Lingeswaran v. Thirunagalingam

    C.R.P(MD)No.1113 of 2023

    BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT

    DATED: 25.04.2023

    CORAM

    THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE C.SARAVANAN C.R.P(MD).No.1113 of 2023 and

    CMP(MD)No.5363 of 2023

    1.Lingeswaran 2.Tamilarasi ... Petitioners/Petitioners/Appellant Vs.

    Thirunagalingam ... Respondent/Respondent/Respondent

    PRAYER:- This Civil Revision Petition has been filed under Article 115 of the Constitution of India, to allow the Civil Revision Petition and set aside the fair and decreetal order dated 08.02.2023 made in I.A.No.1 of 2022 in UN Numbered A.S.No...... of 2022 on the file of Principal District and Sessions Judge, Ramanathapuram.

    For Petitioners : Mr.PT.S.Narendravasan

    For Respondent : Mr.S.Srinivasa Raghavan

    ORDER

    This petition has been filed to set aside the fair and decreetal order dated 08.02.2023, made in I.A.No.1 of 2022 in unumbered A.S.No...... of 2022 on the file of Principal District and Sessions Judge, Ramanathapuram.

    1

    2.The learned Principal District and Sessions Judge, Ramanathapuram, has dismissed the application filed by the petitioners by the impugned order dated 08.02.2023 with the following observations:-

    "19.On perusal of the averments contend in the present petition seeking for condone of delay on 1116 days, it reveals that the petitioners have assigned the same reason to condone the delay as averred in I.A.Nos. 462/2018 and 119/2019 which was already dismissed by this Court.

    20.Though the learned counsel for the petitioners relied upon three judgments cited supra however the facts and circumstances of the case in hand, and the facts and circumstances of the cases referred by the learned Counsel for the petitioners are different and hence those judgments will not improve the case of the petitioner." 3.The petitioners are the defendants in O.S.No.110 of 2015 before the Sub Court, Paramakudi. The said suit was filed by the respondent for specific performance based on the sale agreement dated 17.08.2015, entered between the first petitioner and the respondent. Since the first petitioner failed to execute the sale deed pursuant to the sale agreement dated 17.08.2015, the respondent herein filed the said suit before the Sub Court, Paramakudi, on 22.09.2015.

    2

    4.During the pendency of the said suit, even before the suit summons were issued by the Court, the first petitioner executed a sale deed in favour of the second petitioner on 26.11.2015. Thereafter, the petitioners herein also entered appearance and filed their written statement. The respondent witness (P.W.1) was also examined. However, the petitioners failed to cross-examine the respondent witness. 5.Under these circumstances, both the petitioners were set ex-parte on 07.02.2017. On the same day, the suit in O.S.No.110 of 2015 was also decreed by the Sub Court, Paramakudi. Pursuant to the ex-parte decree passed on 07.02.2017, the respondent also filed E.P.No.10 of 2017 and it was allowed and the sale deed was also executed in favour of the respondent.

    6.It appears that on the date of the sale agreement dated 17.08.2015, the first petitioner had received a sum of Rs.40,000/- and thus, the respondent was allowed to pay the differential amount of Rs.2,60,000/- apart from the requisite stamp duty for registering the sale deed. The sale deed was also executed by the Court in favour of the respondent.

    3

    7.The second petitioner/2nddefendant herein had filed I.A.No.462 of 2018 and first petitioner/1stdefendant had filed I.A.No.119 of 2019 for condoning the delay of 462 days and 712 days in setting aside the ex- parte order passed in O.S.No.110 of 2015, dated 07.02.2017. 8.The learned Sub Judge, Paramakudi, has allowed both the applications filed by the petitioners herein by order dated 19.08.2019. Therefore, the respondent has filed CRP(MD)Nos.1688 & 1689 of 2019 before this Court, which were allowed by this Court, vide order dated

    09.11.2021.

    9.Aggrieved by the same, the petitioners had also preferred S.L.P.Nos.2054 & 2055 of 2022 before the Hon'ble Supreme Court. The said Special Leave Petitions came to be dismissed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, by its order dated 25.02.2022. The petitioners, thereafter, filed I.A.No.1 of 2022 to condone the delay of 1116 days in filing the appeal under Section Order XLI Rule 3-A read with Section 151 of C.P.C. before the Principal District and Sessions Judge, Ramanathapuram.

    4

    10.The learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the learned Principal District and Sessions Judge, Ramanathapuram, has committed a grave error in rejecting the application filed for condoning the delay of 1116 days in filing the appeal. It is submitted that the remedy that was available under Order IX Rule 13 of C.P.C. read with Section 5 of the Limitation Act is different from the Appellate remedy under Section 96(2) read with Order XLI Rule 1 of CPC.

    11.The learned counsel for the petitioners has relied upon a decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in N.Mohan Vs. R.Nadhu

    reported in 2020 1 CTC 343. It is submitted that the said decision deals with a case under similar circumstances as in the present case. It also deals with second round of litigation as in the present case. In the first round, the Court had declined to condone delay in filing the application under Order IX Rule 13 of C.P.C., as in the present case. In the second round, to condone the delay in filing the appeal, the delay was condoned. It is submitted that the same reasoning has to be applied to the facts of the case.

    5

    12.Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondent, on the other hand, would submit that the order is well reasoned and requires no interference. It is submitted that no clear explanation is forthcoming for the delay that was caused in the first round while filing application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, to condone the delay under Order IX Rule 13 of C.P.C.

    13.It is submitted that the delay caused in filing the appeal under Section 96(2) r/w Order XLI Rule 1 of CPC alone can be excluded by applying the principle in Section 14 of the Limitation Act. The delay of 467 days and 712 days that was caused after the petitioners were set ex- parte, has been found to be unsatisfactory by this Court in earlier CRP(MD)Nos.1688 & 1689 of 2019, vide order dated 09.11.2021, which has been affirmed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court while dismissing the Special Leave Petitions of the petitioners in S.L.P.Nos.2054 and 2055 of

    2022.

    14.It is submitted that the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court cannot be applied to the facts of the case. That apart, it is submitted that the Court has not laid down any ratio to be followed in the above case

    6

    relied on by the learned counsel for the petitioners. It is further submitted that the Court has taken note of the bona fide conduct of the parties (the defendants therein) and condoned the delay and that the said order was not based on any legal principle. It is further submitted that this Court need not interfere with the impugned order, as the petitioners have been negligent in not filing the appeal in time and the delay has not been properly explained.

    15.I have considered the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the petitioners and the learned counsel for the respondent. 16.The delay in filing application under Order IX Rule 13 of C.P.C. was not sufficiently explained. The delay was condoned by the Trial Court in I.A.No.462 of 2018 and I.A.No.119 of 2019. However, the decision of the Trial Court was reversed by this Court in C.R.P. (MD)Nos.1688 and 1689 of 2019. Therefore, for the period for which the delay was condoned and reversed cannot be condoned in the second round under Section 96 r/w Order XLI Rule 1 of C.P.C. At best, the appeal time taken in pursuing the remedy before a wrong forum alone can be condoned under Section 14 of the Limitation Act. Section 14 of

    7

    the Limitation Act, reads as under:-

    14. Exclusion of time of proceeding bona fide in court without jurisdiction. —

    (1) In computing the period of limitation for any suit the time during which the plaintiff has been prosecuting with due diligence another civil proceeding, whether in a court of first instance or of appeal or revision, against the defendant shall be excluded, where the proceeding relates to the same matter in issue and is prosecuted in good faith in a court which, from defect of jurisdiction or other cause of a like nature, is unable to entertain it.

    (2) In computing the period of limitation for any application, the time during which the applicant has been prosecuting with due diligence another civil proceeding, whether in a court of first instance or of appeal or revision, against the same party for the same relief shall be excluded, where such proceeding is prosecuted in good faith in a court which, from defect of jurisdiction or other cause of a like nature, is unable to entertain it.

    (3) Notwithstanding anything contained in rule 2 of Order XXIII of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908), the provisions of sub-section (1) shall apply in relation to a fresh suit instituted on permission granted by the court under rule 1 of that Order where such permission is granted on the ground that the first suit must fail by reason of a defect in the jurisdiction of the court or other cause of a like nature.

    Explanation.— For the purposes of this section,—

    (a) in excluding the time during which a former civil proceeding was pending, the day on which that proceeding was instituted and the day on which it ended shall both be counted;

    (b) a plaintiff or an applicant resisting an appeal shall be deemed to be prosecuting a proceeding;

    (c) misjoinder of parties or of causes of action shall be deemed to be a cause of a like nature with defect of jurisdiction.

    8

    17.The Hon'ble Supreme Court had intervened under similar circumstances in N.Mohan Vs. R.Madhu reported in 2020 (1) CTS 343.

    Paragraphs 17, 18, 19 & 20 from the said decision are extracted below:-

    ''17.In the present case, the respondent has filed the Money Suit being OS No.76 of 2015 for recovery of Rs. 46,98,500/- together with interest and the said suit was decreed ex-parte on 09.10.2015. Execution petition being EP No.95 of 2016 was also filed for execution of the decree. As pointed out earlier, the appellant has filed application being IA No.327 of 2016 to condone the delay of 276 days in filing the application to set aside the ex-parte decree. In the said application, the appellant has stated that he has been residing at Chennai; whereas the notice was served at Trichy and therefore, he did not have knowledge about the filing of the said suit in OS No.76 of 2015 before the ADJ Court at Tiruchirappalli and the ex- parte decree was passed on 09.10.2015. The appellant has further averred that he came to know about the ex-parte decree and the execution petition only at the time when he appeared in CC No.240 of 2016 at Karur on 29.07.2016. As discussed earlier, the said application filed by the appellant seeking condonation of delay of 276 days in filing the application to set aside the ex-parte decree was dismissed by the order dated 04.01.2017. The revision and the SLP preferred by the appellant also came to be dismissed.

    18.Thereafter, the appellant has preferred the first appeal with the application to condone the delay of 546 days in filing the first appeal. As pointed out earlier, there was a delay of 276 days in filing the application to set aside the ex-parte decree. Pursuing the proceedings in the application filed under Order IX Rule 13 CPC has caused further delay of 270 days. Thus, there has been a total delay of about 546 days in filing the first appeal. In the application for condonation of delay, of course, the appellant has raised the very same ground which was taken in the application filed under Section 5 of the Limitation Act to set aside the ex-parte decree which was not accepted in the earlier proceedings.

    9

    19.The learned counsel for the appellant-defendant has submitted that a huge amount of Rs.45,00,000/- is said to have been paid by cash which according to the learned counsel raises serious doubts about the genuineness of such transaction. Per contra, the learned Senior counsel for the respondent-plaintiff has submitted that lending of Rs.45,00,000/- as hand loan is substantiated by issuance of two post-dated cheques in favour of the respondent by the appellant - one for the sum of Rs. 25,00,000/- and another for the sum of Rs.20,00,000/-. We are not inclined to go into the merits of the contention of the parties. All that is to be pointed out is that the appellant would have been well advised that if he had filed the first appeal simultaneously along with the application under Order IX Rule

    13 CPC. The appellant has however shown his bona fide by depositing Rs.25,00,000/- in compliance with the orders of this Court dated 13.08.2018. The said amount of Rs.25,00,000/- was permitted to be withdrawn by the respondent-plaintiff. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case and in the interest of justice, in our view, the appellant deserves an opportunity to put forth his defence in the suit for recovery of money. But to avail this opportunity, he must deposit the balance amount of Rs.20,00,000/- as a condition precedent for condonation of delay. In these terms, the impugned judgment is accordingly liable to be set aside.

    20. The delay of 546 days in filing the first appeal shall therefore be condoned with condition that the appellant should deposit Rs.20,00,000/- before the trial court-Principal District Judge, Tiruchirappalli, to the credit of OS No.76 of 2015 on or before 28.02.2020, failing which, the application for condonation of delay shall stand dismissed. On such deposit of Rs.20,00,000/- the same shall be invested in a nationalised bank for a period of six months with the provision of auto-renewal. The deposit of Rs.20,00,000/- and also the earlier deposit of Rs. 25,00,000/- would be subject to the outcome of the appeal. On deposit of Rs.20,00,000/-, the impugned judgment passed by the Madurai Bench of Madras High Court in CMP(MD) No.6566 of 2017 in AS(MD) SR No. 27805 of 2017 is set aside and this appeal is allowed. The delay in filing the appeal is condoned. The appeal shall be taken on file and the High Court shall

    10

    proceed with the same in accordance with law. We make it clear that we have not expressed any opinion on the merits of the matter. It is also made clear that the criminal complaints filed under Section 138 of NI Act be proceeded on its own merits without being influenced by any of the views expressed by this Court or by the High Court."

    18.I am therefore bound by the approach adopted by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in N.Mohan Vs. R.Madhu. In the present case, it appears that a sale agreement dated 17.08.2015 was signed between the first petitioner and the respondent for a sum of Rs.2,60,000/-. The petitioners appear to have received a sum of Rs.40,000/- as advance. Thereafter, the first petitioner has executed a sale deed in favour of the second petitioner in violation of the alleged rights of the respondent under the aforesaid sale agreement dated 17.08.2015. Pursuant to the ex- parte decree, the respondent has also deposited the differential amount of Rs.2,40,000/- and invested a further sum of Rs.23,400/- towards stamp duty and registration charges.

    19.Considering the fact that the respondent has been put to inconvenience by the petitioners and since the respondent has deposited the balance sale consideration and also invested the balance amount together with the stamp duty, I am inclined to intervene in favour of the

    11

    petitioners by directing the petitioners to pay a sum of Rs.1 lakh to the respondent. This amount shall be paid directly to the respondent on or before 07.06.2023. Subject to such payment, the application filed by the petitioners in I.A.No.1 of 2022 to condone the delay before the Principal District and Sessions Court, Ramanathapuram, shall stand allowed. The learned Principal District and Sessions Judge, Ramanathapuram, shall number the appeal and dispose it on merits as expeditiously as possible, preferably, within a period of nine months in accordance with law. The petitioners shall report compliance by filing a suitable memo before the learned Principal District and Sessions Judge, Ramanathapuram. 20.With the above directions, this Civil Revision Petition stands disposed of. No costs. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petition is closed.

    25.04.2023

    NCC : Yes / No Index : Yes / No Internet : Yes / No dss

    Note : Issue order copy on 27.04.2023

    12

    To The Principal District and Sessions Judge, Ramanathapuram.

    13

    C.SARAVANAN, J.

    dss

    C.R.P(MD).No.1113 of 2023 and

    CMP(MD)No.5363 of 2023

    25.04.2023

    14

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Lingeswaran v. Thirunagalingam
    (Apr 25, 2023)