Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • sub-section (4) of Section 33,
  • Bihar Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017,
  • Section 107 of the BGST Act. Sub-section (8) of Section 107
  • sub-section (11) and (12) of Section 107,
  • sub-section (11) of Section 107. Sub-section (12),
  • Sections 33 (4) and 66 of the Income Tax Act 1922 and Rule 24 of the Appellate Tribunal Rules, 1946. Rule 24
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • sub-section (4) of Section 33,
  • Bihar Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017,
  • Section 107 of the BGST Act. Sub-section (8) of Section 107
  • sub-section (11) and (12) of Section 107,
  • sub-section (11) of Section 107. Sub-section (12),
  • Sections 33 (4) and 66 of the Income Tax Act 1922 and Rule 24 of the Appellate Tribunal Rules, 1946. Rule 24
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is Purushottam Stores, a proprietary concern represented by its proprietor, Deenanath Gami. The petitioner, an assessee under the Bihar Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (BGST Act), challenged an appellate order dated 15.02.2023 passed by the 3rd Respondent (the Appellate Authority) under Section 74 of the Act. The petition contested that the Appellate Authority dismissed the appeal for non-prosecution / absence of the appellant instead of deciding the appeal on merits, as the petitioner contended the statute required.

The impugned appellate order was in an appeal filed against an order dated 01.11.2021 (referred to as Annexure-9). The petitioner relied on a Supreme Court decision (Commissioner of Income Tax, Madras vs. S. Chenniappa Mudaliar (1969)1 SCC 591) to support the contention that the Appellate Authority was obliged to decide the appeal on merits even in the appellant's absence. The Government Pleader defended the impugned order on the ground that the appellant repeatedly failed to appear and that the Assessing Officer's findings had been reiterated by the Appellate Authority. The State also pointed out that a further appeal lies to the GST Tribunal, which has not yet been constituted.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Appellate Authority under the BGST Act could legitimately dismiss an appeal for non-prosecution or the appellant's absence without deciding the appeal on merits, given the statutory scheme (notably Section 107 sub-sections (8) to (12)).
  2. Whether invocation of Article 226 of the Constitution was appropriate in the circumstances where the statutory appellate tribunal (GST Tribunal) is not yet constituted and hence an efficacious alternate remedy may not be available.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The Appellate Authority erred in dismissing the appeal for non-prosecution/absence instead of disposing of it on merits, as required by the statutory scheme.
  • Counsel relied on the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Commissioner of Income Tax, Madras vs. S. Chenniappa Mudaliar ((1969) 1 SCC 591) to support the proposition that an appellate body must decide appeals on merits notwithstanding absence of the appellant.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The grounds raised by the appellant had been considered by the Assessing Officer and reiterated by the Appellate Authority in the impugned order (Annexure-9).
  • The appellant consistently failed to appear before the Appellate Authority; this non-appearance was noted by the Authority and formed a basis to reject the appeal.
  • The State pointed to an available appeal to the GST Tribunal (although the Tribunal had not been constituted) and submitted that this Court need not exercise extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226; in similar matters the Court grants liberty to approach the Tribunal once constituted and keeps recovery in abeyance on deposit of 20% of the disputed tax amount.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Commissioner of Income Tax, Madras vs. S. Chenniappa Mudaliar; (1969) 1 SCC 591 This decision dealt with Sections 33(4) and 66 of the Income Tax Act, 1922 and Rule 24 of the Appellate Tribunal Rules, 1946, and held that the Appellate Tribunal is required to dispose of appeals on the merits and not merely dismiss them for non-appearance. The Court read this decision and used its principle to interpret Section 107 of the BGST Act, affirming that the Appellate Authority must inquire further as necessary and decide appeals on merits rather than summarily dismissing them for absence.
Hukumchand Mills Ltd. v. CIT; 63 ITR 232 Noted as authority supporting the proposition that the appellate forum has a statutory mandate to dispose of appeals on merits. Referenced by the Court as part of the line of authorities confirming that appeals must be decided on merits and cannot be disposed of merely because the appellant is absent.
CIT v. Mtt. Ar. S. Ar. Arunachalam Chettiar; 23 ITR 180 Another authority recognizing the statutory obligation of the appellate forum to decide appeals on merits. Considered by the Court among other authorities to support the interpretation that the Appellate Authority under the BGST Act must decide the appeal on merits.
CIT v. Scindia Steam Navigation Co. Ltd.; 42 ITR 589 Also cited as holding that there is a statutory mandate requiring the appellate body to dispose of appeals on merits. Used by the Court as part of the jurisprudential foundation for reading Section 107 to require merits-based disposal rather than dismissal for non-prosecution.
State of H.P. & Ors. v. Gujarat Ambuja Cement Limited & Anr.; (2005) 6 SCC 499 Established that invocation of Article 226 is permissible in exceptional circumstances (for example, clear abuse of process) despite the existence of an alternate efficacious remedy. The Court relied on this authority to justify entertaining the writ petition under Article 226 because the GST Tribunal (the alternate remedy) had not been constituted, and because the Appellate Authority had failed to follow the statutory mandate to decide on merits.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a stepwise manner:

  1. It first examined the controlling authorities relied upon by the petitioner, especially the Supreme Court decision in Commissioner of Income Tax, Madras vs. S. Chenniappa Mudaliar, which addressed analogous provisions in the Income Tax regime requiring an appellate body to decide appeals on merits rather than dismissing them merely because an appellant was absent.
  2. It then analysed Section 107 of the BGST Act. The Court highlighted sub-section (8) (opportunity of hearing), sub-section (9) (power to adjourn on sufficient cause, along with proviso limiting repeated adjournments), sub-section (10) (allowing consideration of grounds not originally pleaded in non-willful omission), and particularly sub-sections (11) and (12). The Court quoted sub-section (11) (power to pass such order as it thinks just and proper, confirming, modifying or annulling the decision appealed against) and sub-section (12) (requirement of a written order stating points for determination, decisions thereon and reasons).
  3. From the statutory text, the Court concluded that the Appellate Authority is mandated to make a substantive inquiry as necessary and to affirm, modify or annul the impugned decision with reasons; the exercise could not be a mere mechanical or formal action.
  4. The Court examined the impugned order. Although the Appellate Authority had extracted the grounds of appeal and the Assessing Officer's grounds, the operative portion of the order reflected dismissal because the appellant did not appear and reliance on the departmental representative's submissions. The impugned order recorded that the appellant had been given multiple opportunities, alleged intermittent filing of time petitions, failure to produce evidence and an intention to keep the matter pending, and therefore confirmed the lower order and dismissed the appeal.
  5. The Court found that there was "little consideration on merits" and that the Appellate Authority had failed to comply with the statutory mandate in Section 107 to conduct any further inquiry and to decide the appeal on merits with reasons. The Court characterized such summary dismissal for absence/non-prosecution as an abdication of the Appellate Authority's statutory powers.
  6. Given that the GST Tribunal (the statutory appellate forum beyond the Appellate Authority) had not been constituted, the Court noted there was no efficacious alternate remedy available at the moment. Relying on the State of H.P. v. Gujarat Ambuja Cement Ltd. principle, the Court held that invocation of Article 226 was permissible in the exceptional circumstances presented.
  7. On these bases, the Court concluded that the impugned appellate order must be set aside and the matter remitted for merits consideration. The Court therefore issued specific directions for restoration and re-hearing, while expressly reserving any observation on the merits of the appeal.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition was allowed. The Court set aside the impugned appellate order dated 15.02.2023 and directed restoration of the appeal to the Appellate Authority's files with specific directions for re-hearing and merits disposal.

Directives and immediate consequences for the parties (as ordered by the Court):

  • The Appellate Authority is directed to restore the appeal to its files.
  • The appellant shall appear before the Appellate Authority on 04.05.2023.
  • The Appellate Authority or its office shall fix a date of hearing on that day (taking due acknowledgment from the appellant). If the date is issued by the office, the Authority must proceed with the hearing on the date fixed.
  • The Appellate Authority is required to dispose of the appeal on merits within two months from the date of the last hearing.
  • The petitioner is directed to cooperate in the hearing. Even if the appellant or an authorised representative is absent on the hearing date, the Appellate Authority shall consider the appeal on merits and pass a speaking order stating points for determination, decisions thereon and reasons.

Implications regarding precedent and broader effect:

  • The Court's decision enforces the existing principle — drawn from prior authorities — that an appellate forum vested with statutory powers to decide appeals must generally decide them on the merits and not dispose of them mechanically for non-appearance.
  • The opinion did not purport to create a novel legal principle beyond the precedents it applied; instead it applied established authorities to the statutory provisions of the BGST Act and to the facts before it.
  • Because the GST Tribunal had not been constituted, the Court treated the situation as an exceptional circumstance warranting exercise of writ jurisdiction under Article 226 to prevent prejudice to the assessee.

Outcome in the case: The writ petition was allowed and the impugned appellate order set aside with directions for restoration and merits re-hearing in accordance with the statutory mandate.

    Purushottam Stores v. The State of Bihar

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA

    Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.4349 of 2023

    ====================================================== Purushottam Stores a proprietary concern having its place of business at Subash Chawk, Darbhanga through its present proprietor namely Deenanath Gami male aged about 43 years son of Late Mohan Gami resident of Shivaji Nagar, Basant Ganj, P.O. - Lal Bagh, District - Darbhanga, Bihar - 846004. ... ... Petitioner/s

    Versus

    1. The State of Bihar through the Commissioner, Department of State Taxes, Government of Bihar, Patna.

    2. The Additional Commissioner of State Taxes (Appeal) Darbhanga Division, Darbhanga.

    3. The Deputy Commissioner of State Taxes Darbhanga Circle, Darbhanga. (2020-2021)

    ... ... Respondent/s

    ======================================================

    Appearance :

    For the Petitioner/s : Mr.Gautam Kumar Kejriwal, Advocate For the Respondent/s : Mr.Vivek Prasad, GP 7 ======================================================

    CORAM: HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE

    and

    HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MADHURESH PRASAD

    ORAL JUDGMENT

    (Per: HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE) Date : 25-04-2023

    The petitioner, an assessee, under the Bihar Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, challenged the appellate order dated 15.02.2023 passed by the 3rdRespondent under Section 74 of the Act. The short ground, on which the challenge is raised, is that the Appellate Authority has dismissed the appeal for reason of non-prosecution of the same when even in the context of non-appearance of the appellant, the Appellate Authority was statutorily obliged to dispose of the appeal on

    1

    2/9

    merits. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner also relies on the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Commissioner of Income Tax, Madras vs. S.Chenniappa Mudaliar, Madurai;(1969)1SCC591.

    2. The learned Government Pleader, in support of the order, points out the grounds raised by the appellant having been dealt with by the Assessing Officer and reiterated by the Appellate Authority, in its order produced as Annexure-9. It is also pointed out that the appellant had consistently not appeared before the Appellate Authority in which circumstance, the said fact was also noticed by the Appellate Authority, which was an additional reason cited by the Appellate Authority to reject the appeal. It is pointed out that there is provided an appeal before the GST Tribunal and since the Tribunal has not yet been constituted, this Court in similar matters grants liberty to the assessee to approach the Tribunal as and when it is constituted and keeps in abeyance the recovery proceedings on deposit of 20% of the tax amount disputed. There is no cause for invocation of the extraordinary remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, is the compelling submission; but for the above limited relief.

    3. The appellate order dated 15.02.2023 is in an

    3/9

    appeal filed against the order dated 01.11.2021, produced by the petitioner which is at Annexure-9, the operative portion of which, in the vernacular, was translated to English and produced before us across the bar, with copy served on the learned State Counsel.

    4. Before we look at the order, we have carefully read the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court cited before us, which dealt with Sections 33 (4) and 66 of the Income Tax Act 1922 and Rule 24 of the Appellate Tribunal Rules, 1946. Rule 24 empowered the Appellate Tribunal, subject to the provisions of the Act, to regulate its own procedure and the procedure of Benches of the Tribunal in all matters arising out of the discharge of its functions, including the places at which the Benches shall hold their sittings. The Appellate Tribunal first had a set of rules which provided that the Tribunal shall determine the appeal on merits, notwithstanding the absence of the appellant and it was also empowered to restore an appeal which was disposed of without hearing the appellant. The substituted rules contained Rule 24A, which empowered the Tribunal to dismiss the appeal for default if the appellant does not appear on the day fixed for hearing and on any day to which the appeal is adjourned; without any provision for restoration of

    4/9

    the appeal dismissed for default.

    5. The Hon'ble Supreme Court found that the scheme of the Act, especially Section 33 (4) was to dispose of an appeal by making such orders as the Tribunal thinks fit, on the merits. The Hon'ble Supreme Court specifically emphasized the word 'thereon' in sub-section (4) of Section 33, which required the Tribunal to afford an opportunity of hearing to both parties and make such orders 'thereon' as it thinks fit. The word 'thereon', according to the Hon'ble Supreme Court, clearly indicated that the Tribunal ought to go into the correctness or otherwise or the points decided by the departmental authorities in the light of the submissions made by the appellant. 'This exercise can only be done by giving a decision on the merits on questions of fact and law and not by merely disposing of the appeal on the ground that the party concerned has failed to appear' (sic). The decisions in Hukumchand Mills Ltd. v. CIT; 63ITR 232, CIT v. Mtt. Ar. S. Ar. Arunachalam Chettiar; 23ITR 180 and CIT v. Scindia Steam Navigation Co. Ltd.; 42ITR 589, were also noticed, all of which, considering the very same provision held that there is a statutory mandate that the Appellate Tribunal dispose of the appeal on merits.

    5/9

    6. With the above principle in mind, we have looked at Section 107 of the BGST Act. Sub-section (8) of Section 107 requires the Appellate Authority to give an opportunity of hearing to the appellant and sub-section (9) also empowers the Appellate Authority to adjourn the hearing at the request of the appellant, if sufficient cause is shown for the prayer made. The proviso to sub-section (9) ensures that the Appellate Authority has sufficient powers to refuse such adjournment, if it has been granted three times previously. Sub- section(10) empowers the Appellate Authority to permit the appellant to argue any ground, not set forth in the grounds of appeal, if the omission was not willful or unreasonable. We specifically extract sub-section (11) and (12) of Section 107, without the two provisos under sub-section(11):-

    "(11) The Appellate Authority shall, after making such further inquiry as may be necessary, pass such order, as it thinks just and proper, confirming, modifying or annulling the decision or order appealed against but shall not refer the case back to the adjudicating authority that passed the said decision or order:

    xxx xxx

    xxx xxx

    (12) The order of the Appellate Authority disposing of the appeal shall be in writing and shall state the points for determination, the decision thereon and the reasons for such decision."

    7. The specific statutory mandate is that after hearing the appellant, the Appellate Authority is to make further

    6/9

    enquiry, if found necessary and pass such orders as it thinks just and proper, confirming, modifying or annulling the decision or order appealed against. Such affirmation, modification or annulment shall not be an empty formality nor can it be mechanical, without the consideration of the grounds of appeal. We observe so, specifically when the Appellate Authority is empowered to refuse the prayer for adjournment made by an appellant, if on three prior occasions, such adjournment has been allowed, in which case also the Appellate Authority cannot absolve itself from the obligation to conduct such further enquiry as is mandated under sub-section (11) of Section 107. Sub-section (12), it has to be further emphasized, also requires the order of the Appellate Authority disposing of the appeal to be in writing and specifically stating the points for determination, the decision thereon and the reasons for such decision. When an appeal is dismissed for reason only of absence of the appellant or lack of effective prosecution, then the Tribunal should be found to have abdicated its powers and not followed the statutory mandate.

    8. It is in the teeth of the above interpretation of the provisions in the statute that the impugned order has to be examined specially in the light of the ground raised, of a

    7/9

    peremptory dismissal for non-prosecution or absence of a counsel. We see from the order that the Appellate Authority has extracted the grounds of appeal and the grounds on which the Assessing Officer has proceeded. The operative portion of the order reads as follows, as found in the translated copy produced across the bar, with a copy served on the learned Government Advocate:-

    "The departmental representative gave his attendance and apprised of the facts of this case and also requested to confirm the order passed by the court below. Whereas the appellant/tax payer remained absent today the date of hearing being 15.02.2023 and there is no action on his part.

    The submissions and arguments of the departmental representative have been heard by me. The grounds of appeal furnished by the appellant ear5lier have been perused. A serious consideration has been given to the same. The concerned appellant has been given several opportunities of hearing but there has been no action on his part towards disposal of this case. Earlier also the dates of hearing fixed in this case were 22.12.2021, 08.01.2022, 12.01.2023 and 15.02.2023 in ordder to afford opportunity to the appellant but the appellant intermittently filed time petitions. The matter is getting older. The appellant did not furnish the relevant evidence, documents, accounts etc nor did he appear and clarify this matter. This clearly shows that the appellant/taxpayer intends to keep this matter pending. In these circumstances, I do not find a need to interfere with the order passed by the lower court. The order passed by the lower court is confirmed.

    Consequently, matter is dismissed."

    9. There is little consideration on merits and due compliance of the requirement under Section 107 in the impugned order is totally absent. It is trite that in exceptional

    8/9

    circumstances, one of which is a clear abuse of process of law, the invocation of Article 226 Constitution of India, despite the existence of an efficacious alternate remedy is permissible as has been held in State of H.P & Ors. v. Gujarat Ambuja Cement Limited & Anr.; (2005) 6 SCC 499. Here is a case where the Appellate Authority failed to follow the mandate in the statute for disposal of an appeal, which has to be on merits, even if the assessee/appellant had failed to appear before the Authority. We also notice that there is no efficacious alternate remedy available as of now, against the appellate order, since the Tribunal, to which a further appeal is provided, has not been constituted. Leaving the Assessee/petitioner to the appellate remedy as and when the Tribunal is constituted, that too with a further direction to pay 20% of the disputed tax amount would unnecessarily prejudice the assessee.

    10. On the above reasoning, we deem it appropriate that the appellate order is set aside for the reasons stated above, without any observation on merit. We direct the Appellate Authority to restore the appeal to its files and the appellant shall appear before the authority on 04.05.2023. The Appellate Authority or its office shall fix a date of hearing on the said date, with due acknowledgment taken from the

    9/9

    appellant; if the date of hearing is issued from the office, proceed with the hearing on the date fixed and dispose of the appeal on merits within two months from the date of last hearing. We also direct the petitioner to cooperate in the hearing of the appeal and even if there is absence of the appellant or his authorized representative on the date of hearing, the Appellate Authority shall consider the appeal on merits and pass a speaking order. The writ petition stands allowed with the above direction.

    (K. Vinod Chandran, CJ) ( Madhuresh Prasad, J)

    Sujit/-

    AFR/NAFR AFR
    CAV DATE
    Uploading Date 29.04.2023
    Transmission Date

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Purushottam Stores v. The State of Bihar
    (Apr 25, 2023)