H
ig h Co ur t o f H
.P
.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH SHIMLA
CWP No. 221 of 2019.
Reserved on: 23 rd March, 2023. Date of Decision : 28 th March, 2023.
Mohan Singh Guleria ...Petitioner.
Versus State of H.P. & Ors. ....Respondents. Coram:
The Hon'ble Ms. Justice Sabina, Acting Chief Justice. The Hon'ble Mr. Justice Satyen Vaidya, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the Petitioner: Mr. T.S. Chauhan, Advocate.
For the Respondents: Mr. Anup Rattan, Advocate General with Mr. Rakesh Dhaulta, Additional
Advocate General.
Satyen Vidya, Judge.
By way of instant petition, the petitioner has prayed for following substantive reliefs:-
"(a). That the respondents especially respondent No.3 may be directed to register the sale certificate and enter mutation qua sale of the land in question in a time
1
. bound manner without insisting for affixation of stampduty. (b). That the respondent No.3 may be directed to perform his statutory duties in pursuance of Section 17(2)(xii) of the Registration Act. "
2. The undisputed facts of the case are that the petitioner was the highest bidder in an auction of immovable property conducted by the HDFC bank under the provisions of Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act 2002 (for short "SARFAESI Act"). The sale was confirmed in favour of the petitioner and a sale certificate dated 21.12.2017 was issued.
3. Respondents refused to register the sale certificate without payment of stamp duty as applicable to the registration of a sale deed.
4. The petitioner has approached this Court on the grounds that the refusal to register the sale certificate issued in his favour without deposit of stamp duty was illegal and against the provisions of Registration Act as also Stamp Act.
2
.5.This Court rejected the contention raised on behalf of the respondents and allowed the petition filed by the petitioner vide judgment dated 08.10.2020 in following terms:-
" 10. Despite the issue in question being squarely covered by the aforesaid judgement, which was rendered, as far back on 20.10.2016, we really fail to understand why after the pronouncement of the judgement, respondent No.1 did not issue necessary clarification on this subject to all concerned.
11. Had it been done, the petitioner would not have been compelled to indulge in otherwise avoidable and unwarranted litigation.
12. In normal circumstances, this would have been a fit case to impose heavy costs on the respondents, however, taking into consideration that this is the first lapse on the part of the respondents, we refrain from doing so.
13. In view of the aforesaid discussion, we find merit in this petition and the same is accordingly allowed. Respondent No.3 is directed to register sale deed and enter mutation qua sale of the land in question, that too, without insisting for affixation of stamp duty, within a period of four weeks.
14. In the meanwhile, respondent No.1 shall also issue necessary notification/circular/order clarifying the legal position in tune with the
3
. judgment rendered by this Court in Valley Iron case(supra)."
6. Later, respondents sought review of judgment dated 08.10.2020 passed by this Court by way of review petition No. 18 of 2021, which was allowed by the same bench vide order dated 25.08.2021 in following terms:-
"Heard. There is an error apparent on the face of the record inasmuch as issue in question has only been dealt with from the perspective of Indian Registration Act and not Indian Stamps Act. Therefore, the judgment dated 08.10.2019 passed by this Court in CWP No. 221/2019 is ordered to be recalled and the writ petition is restored to its original number."
7. The issue involved in the instant case is no more res integra in light of the exposition made in the judgment dated 11.11.2022 passed by Hon'ble Supreme Court in a bunch of Special Leave Petitions (Civil) with Petition for Special Leave Appeal (c) No. 16949 of 2022 as lead case, titled The Inspector General of Registration & Anr. vs. G. Madhurambal & Anr., which reads as under:-
4
. "Learned counsel for the petitioner(s) has made avaliant endeavor to persuade us to interfere with the impugned judgment(s) but not successfully. It
is logically so as this issue has been repeatedly
settled and if one may say, a consistent view
followed for the last 150 years. We may refer to
the judgments by the Madras High Court in the
Board of Revenue No.2 of 1875 (In Re: Case
Referred) dated 19.10.1875 opining that a
certificate of sale cannot be regarded as a
conveyance subject to stamp duty, by the
Allahabad High Court in Adit Ram v. Masarat-un-
Nissa Nissa (Manu/UP/0089/1883) opining that a
sale certificate is not an instrument of the kind
mentioned in clause (b) of Section 17 of Act III of
1877 and is not compulsorily registrable and this
Court's view in Esjaypee Impex Pvt. Ltd. v. Asst.
General Manager and Authorised Officer, Canara
Bank ((2021)11 SCC 537) opining that the
mandate of law in terms of Section 17(2)(xii) read
with Section 89(4) of the Registration Act, 1908
only required the Authorised Officer of the Bank
under the SARFAESI Act to hand over the duly
validated Sale Certificate to the Auction Purchase
with a copy forwarded to the Registering
Authorities to be filed in Book I as per Section 89
of the Registration Act and order of this Court in
M.A. No.19262/2021 in SLP(C) No.29752/2019
5
. dated 29.10.2021 opining that once a direction isissued for the duly validated certificate to be issued to the auction purchaser with a copy
forwarded to the registering authorities to be filed
in Book I as per Section 89 of the Registration Act,
it has the same effect as registration and obviates
the requirement of any further action."
8. Thus, the petition is allowed and respondent No.3 is directed to register the sale certificate dated 21.12.2017 (Annexure P-4) issued by HDFC Bank in favour of petitioner and enter the consequent mutation in favour of the petitioner without insisting for affixation of stamp duty. Respondents are also directed to refund the stamp duty, if any, already paid/deposited by the petitioner. The needful is directed to be done within four weeks. Petition is accordingly disposed of, so also, the pending applications, if any.
(Sabina) Acting Chief Justice (Satyen Vaidya) Judge
28th March, 2023. (jai)
6