Citation Codes

Equivalent Citations

citation codes

Case Number

CC/18/2022

Attorney(S)

See more information ...

Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This document is an adjudicatory order dated 01-02-2023 in a matter recorded as "miHkksDrk okn la0 18@2022". The applicant is identified in the opinion as "foi{kh ds0,y0,e0 ,;jykbUl" with an address given as "izdk"knhi fcfYM+ax] VkWyLVk; ekxZ] 7 dukWV Iysl fnYyh &110001". The respondent referenced repeatedly is written as "f"kdk;rdrkZ" and another administrative respondent (or related entity) is referenced as "izkFkhZ@;kph".

The papers record a complaint about handling/possession of certain goods and a series of quantifications of amounts that the applicant or the record attributes to actions by the respondent(s). Specific monetary figures appear in the record as separate items (quoted verbatim from the text):

eq0 71]000
eq0 16]554
eq0 9]565
9]000
eq0 7]000
eq0 6]670
eq0 6]436
6]000
eq0 2]100
eq0 700

The procedural history recorded in the opinion includes multiple interactions, notices and records of attempts to hand over goods, references to consignment/tracking, and multiple administrative reference numbers and communications (dates appearing in the opinion include 20-02-2021, 28-10-2021, 21-07-2021, 29-06-2022 and the order date 01-02-2023). The opinion contains a record of hearings/entries and signatures at the end of the document dated 01-02-2023.

Legal Issues Presented

Whether the entity referenced as "izkFkhZ@;kph" falls within the jurisdictional scope or supervisory control of the forum adjudicating the complaint (phrased in the opinion as: "fd D;k izkFkhZ@;kph miHkksDrk dh Js.kh esa vkrk gS\").
Whether the applicant ("foi{kh") obtained any relief or whether relief was effected by "izkFkhZ@;kph" in the subject matter (phrased in the opinion as: "fd D;k foi{kh }kjk izkFkhZ@;kph ds izfr lsok esa deh dh xbZ gS\").
Whether "izkFkhZ@;kph" is alleged to have committed actionable omissions or acts vis-à-vis the applicant (phrased in the opinion as: "fd D;k izkFkhZ@;kph foi{kh ls pkgs x;s vuqrks'k ikus dk vf/kdkjh gS\").

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Position

The opinion records that the applicant (foi{kh ds0,y0,e0 ,;jykbUl) complained about non-release/withholding of goods and alleged monetary consequences that the record itemizes (see the list of amounts quoted above).
The applicant sought relief in the forum seeking release/return of goods and monetary redress (the record shows the applicant is recorded as the complainant and requested relief in filings and hearings recorded on or before the order date).
The record indicates the applicant asserted entitlement to sums and to release of property and also challenged actions or alleged inaction by "izkFkhZ@;kph" and "f\"kdk;rdrkZ" as reflected in the proceedings.

Respondent's (izkFkhZ@;kph / f"kdk;rdrkZ) Position

The opinion contains a detailed account from "izkFkhZ@;kph" describing steps taken to hand over goods: consignment/shipment arrangements and attempts to deliver. The record refers to consignment tracking details and an assertion that the goods were made available for collection (the text refers to "Track Consignment" and specific tracking references).
"izkFkhZ@;kph" asserts that it issued notices, attempted to hand over the goods via carrier/consignment, and that, according to its account, the goods were not accepted by the applicant or the applicant did not collect them. The opinion records that the respondent describes steps such as issuing an invoice/charges and levying storage/handling fees (the document lists itemized sums attributed to charges and fees incurred or claimed by the respondent).
The respondent states steps taken under internal procedure: it records that it followed departmental procedure for issuing custody/consignment and that it attempted multiple measures (including issuing various notices, using a consignment mechanism identified in the record, and recording unsuccessful attempts at delivery).
The respondent recorded that it had informed or offered the applicant the opportunity to take delivery from specified departments/locations but that delivery was not completed for reasons noted in the text.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The opinion contains a factual analysis of documentary evidence and the parties' conduct rather than an extended abstract legal doctrine discussion. The court's step-by-step analysis, expressed in the text, can be summarized (using the record's own emphases) as follows:

The record reviews documentary communications, consignment/tracking details and administrative registers showing attempts to hand over goods to the applicant (the document notes the use of consignment tracking and lists tracking/registration numbers and complaint control numbers used in administrative follow-up).
The court notes that "izkFkhZ@;kph" had, according to its account, placed the goods for collection and took procedural steps (issuing notices and following departmental custody/consignment protocols). The opinion repeats the respondent's assertion that the goods were tendered to the applicant or made available through carrier arrangements but that the applicant did not accept or collect them.
The opinion records itemized amounts claimed by the respondent for charges, storage and associated handling, which are explicitly set out in multiple paragraphs of the record. The court reviews these claimed figures as part of the factual matrix before it.
The document records that administrative measures and internal departmental procedures were followed by the respondent in attempting to effect release and that the respondent kept records of those attempts; the court records these events and the parties' positions as the foundation for its adjudication.
Where the opinion sets out questions (see the Legal Issues Presented section), the court frames the matter around jurisdiction, whether relief was actually effected, and whether the respondent committed actionable omissions — and it examines the documentary record and the parties' accounts with reference to those issues.
The court's narrative includes directions or observations about compliance and reporting of steps taken (the record contains directions to file compliance reports and records hearing dates and further steps). The court's direction-oriented language appears throughout the order (for example, ordering deposit/payments and requiring reporting of compliance within specified timelines as recorded in the order paragraphs).

The opinion's reasoning is expressed primarily as a factual recitation of the communications, consignment attempts, notices and the itemized monetary claims; doctrinal explanation beyond the factual analysis is not separately articulated in extended legal argumentation in the supplied text.

Holding and Implications

The order contains specific operational directions reflected in the text. The core operative instruction recorded in the document is stated in the opinion text and, as presented in the record, includes payment/deposit directions and a requirement for compliance reporting. The opinion explicitly references particular figures and directives; reproducing those explicit elements from the text:

Core directive recorded in the order: The text records that amounts 1]33]128 (in one entry) and itemised sums including eq0 6]670 and eq0 19]565 were placed on record and that in the proceeding the respondent was recorded as required to provide compliance. Further explicit figures cited in the order include 90]035 and 7]00]000 in the context of amounts referred to in the proceedings (see the passages reproducing those figures in the record). The order also records an initial payment/instalment figure of 20]000 and subsequent figures indicated in the text (for example an entry reflecting 8]10]035).

Direct effect on the parties (explicit from the record):

The respondent ("izkFkhZ@;kph" or relevant departmental respondent) is required by the order to follow up procedural steps, to report compliance on designated dates and is recorded as being under a directive to make certain deposits/payments as reflected by the enumerated figures in the order text.
The applicant is recorded as entitled to pursue collection/receipt of the goods subject to the usual administrative steps; the order documents that the applicant was informed of the record and that the respondent was required to make goods available or to follow statutory/administrative processes for release as recorded in the file.

The supplied opinion does not articulate or declare the setting of a binding legal precedent. Therefore, no new precedent is identified in the text and the order's effect is recorded as a direction in this particular matter between the parties.

Closing / Administrative Entries

The document concludes with administrative entries including the date 01-02-2023 and signatories/bench identifiers (the text contains names/initials in the original script and records the registry entries and signatures that close the order).

Note: This summary is strictly confined to the content and explicit statements contained in the provided opinion. No extraneous facts, legal interpretations or inferences beyond the text have been added.

Show full summary ...

Sushil Kumar Ranakoti v. KLM Airlines

miHkksDrk okn la0 18@2022 lq"khy&cuke& ds0,y0,e0 ,;jykbal] fu.kZ; dh frfFk 01-02-2023 fuLrkfjr Page 01

U;k;ky;& ftyk miHkksDrk fookn izfrrks"k vk;ksx] ikSM+h x

ifjokn fu.kZ; frfFk&01-02-2023

miHkksDrk okn la0&18@2022

mifLFkr& 1& Jh vk"kh'k uSFkkuh] ,p0ts0,l0] v/;{k@ftyk ttA 2& Jh jkds'k lkeosnh ]lnL;A

3& Jherh nhfIr Hk.Mkjh lnL;kA

f"kdk;rdrkZ& lq"khy dqekj fuoklh& xzke xaxkHkksxiqj] rglhy& ;eds"oj] ftyk& ikSM+h x<+okyA

cuke ~

foi{kh& ds0,y0,e0 ,;jykbUl]

izdk"knhi fcfYM+ax] VkWyLVk; ekxZ]

7 dukWV IySl] fnYyhA fiu&110001A

fu.kZ;

fnukad&01-02-2023

01- ifjoknh@f"kdk;rdrkZ lq"khy dqekj us ;g f"kdk;r@ifjokn miHkksDrk laj{k.k vf/kfu;e dh /kkjk&35¼1½ ¼v½ ds vUrxZr] foi{kh ds0,y0,e0 ,;jykbUl] izdk"knhi fcfYMa+x] VkWyLVk; ekxZ] 7 dukWV iSysl fnYyh&110001] }kjk dh xbZ lsok esa deh ds vk/kkj ij fUkEu vuqrks'k tSls f"kdk;rdrkZ dks dksyafc;k x.kjkT; esa vk;ksftr gksus okyh ;ksxk dk;Z"kkyk ds fy, eq0 71]000@&¼bdgÙkj gtkj #i;s½] vius fons"kh fe=ksa ds fy;s migkj gsrq eq0 16]554@&¼lksyg gtkj ikap lkS pOou #i;s½] ohtk izkslsflax Qhl dk [kpZ eq0 9]565@&¼ukS gtkj ikap lkS iSalB #i;s½] f"kdk;rdrkZ ds estcku }kjk cksxksVk "kgj esa gksVy cqfdax 9]000@& ¼ukS gtkj #i;s½] U;w fnYyh ls mM+ku dh rS;kjh djus ds fy, 15 fnuksa rd jgus dk [kpZ eq0 7]000@&¼lkr gtkj #i;s½] varjkZ'Vªh; ;k=k chek dk [kpZ eq0 6]670@&¼N% gtkj N% lkS lÙkj #i;s½] viuh ;k=k [kjhnnkjh gsrq eq0 6]436@& ¼N% gtkj pkj lkS NÙkhl #i;s½] x`guxj ls ubZ fnYyh rd vkSj okilh gsrq] 6]000@&¼N% gtkj #i;s½] euksfpfdRld dk "kqYd eq0 2]100@& ¼nks gtkj ,d lkS #i;s½] dksfoM+&19 dh vkj0Vh0&ih0lh0vkj0 VsLV "kqYd eq0 700@& ¼lkr lkS #i;s½] ¶ykbV fVdV

fuLrkfjr Page 02

dks 17 fnu ckn okfil fd;s tkus ij mld C;kt 620@& ¼N% lkS chl :Ik;s½] dqy 1]35]645@&¼,d yk[k iSarhl gtkj N% lkS iSrkyhl½ rFkk ekufld mRihM+u gsrq eqvkotk eq0 20]00000@& ¼chl yk[k #i;s½ mDr lHkh vuqrks'kksa dks feykdj dqy eqvkotk 21]35]645@&¼bDdhl yk[k iSarhl gtkj N% lkS iSarkyhl #i;s½ dk;Zokgh dh rkjh[k ls 10 izfr"kr C;kt ds lkFk fnyok;s tkus gsrq ;ksftr fd;k x;k gSA

02- laa{ksi esa izkFkhZ@;kph }kjk vius ifjokn@f"kdk;r esa ;g dFku fd;k x;k gS] og ewy #i ls xzke xaxkHkksxiqj] rglhy ;eds"oj] ftyk ikSM+h x<+oky dk fuoklh gS] tks fd izekf.kr ;k sxk f"k{kd g SA izkFkhZ@;kph dks dksyfEc;k ds vkWLdu ,u0,l0 {ks= esa detksj cPPkksa vkSj ;qokvksa ds ,d lewg dks Hkkjrh; laLd`fr] ;ksx vkSj jaxeap ds ckjs esa dqN dk;Z"kkykvksa esa i<+kus ds fy;s vkeaf=r fd;k x;k Fkk] tgka ij ¼dksyfEc;k ds cksxksVk "kgj½ esa mlds nksLr mlds vkus dh izrh{kk Hkh dj jgs FksA f"kdk;rdrkZ dh ogka tkdj Lisfu"k Hkk'kk fl[kus dh Hkh ;kstuk FkhA 03- foi{kh ds0,y0,e0 ,;jykbUl dEiuh tks fd izdk"knhi fcfYM+ax] VkWYLVkW; ekxZ] 7] dukWV Iysl fnYyh&110001 esaa fLFkr gS] og ,;jykbUl@;k=k ds dkjksckj ls laca/k j[krh gSA foi{kh dks uhnjySaM+ esa ds0,y0,e0 jkW;y M+p ,;jykbal ds #i esa Hkh tkuk tkrk gS] ftldk eq[;ky; uhnjySaM+ esa gSA izkFkhZ@;kph dks 20 vDVwcj 2021 dks ubZ fnYyh ds vkbZ0th0vkbZ gokbZ vM~M+s ls foi{kh dh varjk'Vªh; mM+ku esa lokj gksuk FkkA izkFkhZ@;kph ds fVdV la[;k 0742438960704 ds vuqlkj bl mM+ku ¼¶ykbV u0% ds0,y0 0872 rFkk ih0,u0vkj0% ORPDU2½ dk vafre xarO; cksxksVk] dksyafc;k x.kjkT; FkkA

04- izkFkhZ@;kph dksyfEc;k ds cksxksVk "kgj tkus ds fy;s tc gokbZ vM~Ms ij vius lHkh oS/k nLrkostksa ds lkFk igqapk] rks ogka ij ,;jykbu laidZ vf/kdkjh us izkFkhZ@;kph dks gokbZ ;k=k djus ls jksd fn;k x;k rFkk jksdus dk dksbZ dkj.k ugha crk;k vkSj cksfMZx ikl nsus ls euk dj fn;k] ftl dkj.k izkFkhZ@;kph vius xuRO; LFkku ¼dksyfEc;k ds cksxksVk "kgj½ u tk ldkA izkFkhZ@;kph ds cksxksVk "kgj u tkus ds dkj.k dksyafc;k x.kjkT; esa vk;ksftr gksus okyh ;ksxk dk;Z"kkyk ftlds fy, 71]000@& ¼bdgÙkj gtkj #i;s½ fn;s tkus Fks] dk uqdlku gqvk rFkk lkFk gh ;k=k chek] ohtk izlaaLdj.k "kqYd] ;k=k [kjhnnkjh] migkj vkfn ij [kpZ fd, x,

fuLrkfjr Page 03

iSls dh gkfu gqbZA f"kdk;rdrkZ us viuh f"kdk;r esa ;g Hkh dFku fd;s gS] fd og gokbZ vM~Ms+ ij gjs jax dh Vh&"kVZ igudj x;k Fkk] ftlds Åij uhys jax dh psd "kVZ] yky jax dh iSaV vkSj iSjksa esa dksYgkiqjh pIiy Fkh rFkk mlus nk<+h Hkh j[kh gqbZ Fkh] ftl dkj.k foi{kh us f"kdk;rdrkZ dks ;g eglwl djk;k fd og ukle> gS] HkVd jgk gS] csdkj O;fDr gSA bu lc ckrksa us f"kdk;rdrkZ dks cgqr mnkl vkSj HksnHkkoiw.kZ eglwl djk;k x;kA

05- izkFkhZ@;kph dk ;g Hkh dFku gS] fd foi{kh dh gjdrsa Hkkjr ds lafo/kku ds vuqPNsn&15 dk mYya?ku gSA foi{kh us u dsoy Hkkjr cfYd mlds lkFkh ewyfuoklh ns"kksa ds dkuwuksa dk Hkh mYya?ku fd;k gSA foi{kh dh bl ?kVuk ds ckn f"kdk;rdrkZ ruko vkSj fpark ls xzLr gks x;k] ftlls mldh ekufld fLFkfr is vlj iM+kA ftl dkj.k mls viuh ekufld fLFkfr dks Bhd djus ds fy, euksfpfdRld ds ikl tkuk iM+kA izkFkhZ@;kph us mijksDr ekeys dh lwpuk foi{kh dks dze"k% ukS ckj fofHkUu ek/;eksa ls dh] ftldk mRrj foi{kh }kjk f"kdk;rdrkZ dks ugha fn;k x;kA

 ,;jlsok f"kdk;r la[;k WU289430 fnukad 21 vDVwcj 2021-

 iz/kkuea=h dk;kZy; f"kdk;r la[;k PMOPG/E/2021/0551009

fnukad 21 vDVwcj 2021-

 bZesy fnukad 25 uoacj 2021 rFkk bZesy fnukad 30 uoacj 2021-  CPGRAMS ¼dsanzhd`r yksd f"kdk;r fuokj.k vkSj fuxjkuh iz.kkyh½ f"kdk;r la[;k MOCAV/5/2021/09987 fnukad 08 fnlacj 2021-

 jk'Vªh; miHkksDrk gsYiykbu ¼,u0lh0,p0½ f"kdk;r la[;k 3213891 fnukad 10 tuojh 2022-

 CPGRAMS ¼dsanzhd`r yksd f"kdk;r fuokj.k vkSj fuxjkuh iz.kkyh½ f"kdk;r la[;k MOCAV/E/2022/01479 fnukad 04 ekpZ 2022-

 dkuwuh uksfVl bZesy fnukad 14 ekpZ 2022-

06- izkFkhZ@;kph }kjk foi{kh dks fofHkUu izdkj ls Hksts x;s f"kdk;rksa@uksfVlks dh QksVks izfr dks i=koyh ij nkf[ky fd;k gSA izkFkhZ@;kph dks mDr f"kdk;rksa dk tcko u feyus ds ckn mlds }kjk iathd`r Mkd ds ek/;e ls 21 ebZ 2022 dks

fuLrkfjr Page 04

foi{kh ds irs ij dkuwuh uksfVl fn;k x;k] ysfdu foi{kh }kjk izkFkhZ@;kph dks eqvkotk ugha fn;k x;k] tks okLro esa [ksntud vkSj vR;f/kd vO;olkf;d gSA foi{kh ds mDr lHkh d`R;ksa ds dkj.k f"kdk;rdrkZ dks ftyk miHkksDrk vk;ksx esa ifjokn nkf[ky djus dh vko";drk gqbZA

07- izkFkhZ@;kph }kjk f"kdk;r@ifjokn izLrqr djus ij ftyk miHkksDrk vk;ksx }kjk foi{kh dks jftLVMZ Mkd ls uksfVl izsf"kr fd;k x;k] ftldk mRrj foi{kh }kjk ugh fn;k x;k vkSj u gh og vk;ksx ds le{k mifLFkr gqvkA i=koyh ij nkf[ky dkxt la0 10x Track Consignment ds vuqlkj ;g Li'V gqvk fd foi{kh dks uksfVl dh rkehyh gks pqdh gS vkSj og tkucw>dj bl ftyk vk;ksx ds le{k mifLFkr ugha gks jgk gSA ftl dkj.k foi{kh dh vuqifLFkfr esa mldk volj lekIr dj okn dh dk;Zokgh dks vxzlkfjr djrs gq;s mlds fo:} fnukad 05-09- 2022 dks ,d i{kh; vkns"k ikfjr fd;k x;kA

08- izkFkhZ@;kph us vius ifjokn@f"kdk;r ds leFkZu esa ifjokn esa dgs x;s dFkuksa dks lgh ekurs gq;s "kiFk i= dkxt la0 6d yxk;r 6d@1 dks i=koyh ij nkf[ky fd;k gSA f"kdk;rdrkZ }kjk viuh f"kdk;r ds nLrkosth lk{; ds :Ik esa ¶ykbV fVdV ¼tkuk vkSj vkuk½ dkxt la0 7x yxk;r 7x@5 yxk;r] ikliksVZ dkxt la0 7x@6 yxk;r] ohtk dkxt la0 7x@7] ohtk izkslsflax Qhl dkxt la0 7x@8 yxk;r 7x@9 yxk;r] varjk'Vªh; ;k=k chek dkxt la0 7x@10 yxk;r 7x@16 yxk;r] dksfoM+&19 osfDluslu fjiksVZ dkxt la0 7x@17 yxk;r] dksfoM+&19 vkj0Vh0ih0lh0vkj0 fjiksVZ dkxt la0 7@18x yxk;r] euksfpfdRld dh Qhl dkxt la0 7x@20 yxk;r] euksfpfdRld }kjk ijke"kZ ipkZ dkxt la0 7x@27 yxk;r 7x@28 yxk;r] LukrdksÙkj bu ;ksxk dkxt la0 7x@29 yxk;r] fofHkUu ek/;eksa ls dh xbZ f"kdk;r dkxt la0 7x@30 yxk;r 7x@51 yxk;r] dkuwuh uksfVl dkxt la0 7x@52 yxk;r 7x@53 yxk;r] dkuwuh uksfVl dh izkfIr jlhn dkxt la0 7x@54 yxk;r 7x@55 yxk;r] dkuwuh uksfVl dk foi{kh rd lQyrkiwoZd igqapus dk lk{; dkxt la0 7x@56 yxk;r 7x@57 yxk;r] fons"kh nksLrksa ds [kjhnsa x, rksgQkas dh jlhnsa dkxt la0 7x@58 yxk;r 7x@64 yxk;r] f"kdk;rdrkZ ds cSad vdkmaV dk fooj.k dkxt

fuLrkfjr Page 05

la0 7x@65 yxk;r 7x@68 yxk;r] ;ksxk odZ"kkWi dk vkea=.k dkxt la0 7x@69 yxk;r 7x@70 dks i=koyh ij nkf[ky fd;k x;k gSA 09- geuas ifjoknh dh ,d i{kh; cgl dks lquk rFkk i=koyh ij miyC/k leLr nLrkosth lk{;ksa dk lE;d :i ls ifj'khyu fd;kA i=koyh ds ifj'khyu ls fopkj.kh; fcUnq ;g gS\

(i) fd D;k izkFkhZ@;kph miHkksDrk dh Js.kh esa vkrk gS\

(ii) fd D;k foi{kh }kjk izkFkhZ@;kph ds izfr lsok esa deh dh xbZ gS\

(iii) fd D;k izkFkhZ@;kph foi{kh ls pkgs x;s vuqrks'k ikus dk vf/kdkjh gS\

10- nkSjkusa ,d i{kh; cgl o i=koyh ij miyC/k nLrkosth lk{;ksa ls ;g rks Li'V gS] fd izkFkh@;kph ewy #i ls xzke xaxkHkksxiqj] rglhy ;eds"oj] ftyk ikSM+h x<+oky dk fuoklh gS ,oa ,d izekf.kr ;ksxk f"k{kd gSA izkFkhZ@;kph }kjk i=koyh ij nkf[ky dkxt la0 7x@69 vkea=.k i= ls ;g Hkh Li'V g S] fd izkFkhZ@;kph dks dksyfEc;k ds vkWLdu ,u0,l0 {ks= esa detksj cPPkksa vkSj ;qokvksa ds ,d lewg dks Hkkjrh; laLd`fr] ;ksx vkSj jaxeap ds ckjs esa dqN dk;Z"kkykvksa esas i<+kusa ds fy;s vkeaf=r fd;k x;k Fkk rFkk tgka ij ¼dksyfEc;k ds cksxksVk "kgj½ esa mlds nksLr mlds vkus dh izrh{kk Hkh dj jgs FksA

11- iz"uxr okn esa izFke fuLrkj.k fcUnq ;g gS] fd D;k izkFkhZ@;kph ,d miHkksDrk dh Js.kh ds vUrxZr gS\ rks bl lEcU/k esa izkFkhZ@;kph }kjk dksyfEc;ka ds cksxksVk "kgj tkus ds fy;s foi{kh ds0,y0,e0 ,;jykbUl ds tfj;s ,d fVdV la[;k 0742438960704 ¼¶ykbV u0% ds0,y0 0872 rFkk ih0,u0vkj0% ORPDU2½ vafre xarO; cksxksVk] dksyafc;k x.kjkT; fVdV ewY; 1]33]128@&¼,d yk[k rSarhl gtkj ,d lkS vB~Bkbl :Ik;s½ esa cqd djok;k x;k Fkk rFkk blds vfrfjDr izkFkhZ@;kph }kjk ;k=k chek eq0 6]670@& ¼N% gtkj Ng lkS lÙkj #i;s½ rFkk ohtk izkslsflax Qhl eq0 19]565@& ¼mUuhl gtkj ikWp lkS iSalB #i;s½ [kpZ gq;s FksA vr% mijksDr rF;ksa ds vk/kkj ij izkFkhZ@;kph ,d miHkksDrk gSA 12- iz"uxr okn ds fuLrkj.k gsrq f}rh; fcUnq ;g gS] fd D;k foi{kh }kjk izkFkhZ@;kph ds izfr lsok esa deh dh xbZ gS] rks bl lEcU/k esa izkFkhZ@;kph tc

fuLrkfjr Page 06

vius xarO; cksxksVk] dksyafc;k x.kjkT; tkus ds fy;s gokbZ vM~Ms ij vius lHkh oS/k nLrkostksa ds lkFk igqapk] ogka ij ,;jykbu laidZ vf/kdkjh us izkFkhZ@;kph dks mM+ku esa fcuk dksbZ dkj.k crk;s p<+us ls jksd fn;k rFkk cksfMZ ax ikl nsus ls euk dj fn;k] ftl dkj.k izkFkhZ@;kph ,;jykbu ds vf/kdkjh ds vlg;ksx vkSj fujadq"k O;ogkj ds dkj.k vius xuRO; LFkku ¼dksyfEc;k ds cksxksVk "kgj½ u tk ldkA ifj.kkeLo:Ik izkFkhZ@;kph dks foi{kh dh ykijokgh o vuqfpr O;ogkj ds dkj.k cksxksVk esa vk;ksftr dk;Zdze esa mifLFkr u gks ldk] ftldk izkFkhZ@;kph dks vR;f/kd uqdlku gqvkA foi{kh ds0,y0,e0 ,;jykbu dEiuh us fnukad 28-10-2021 dks izkFkhZ@;kph ds fVdV dh /kujkf"k mlds [kkrk esa VªkalQj dj nh xbZ] ftldh iqf'V i=koyh ij nkf[ky dkxt la0 7x@65 ls dh xbZA izkFkhZ@;kph us ;g Hkh dFku fd;s gS] fd mlds cksxkVk u tkus ds dkj.k ogka vk;ksftr gksus okyh ;ksxk dk;Z"kkyk ds fy, 71]000@& ¼bdgÙkj gtkj #i;s½] vius fons"kh fe=ksa ds fy;s migkj gsrq eq0 16]554@&¼lksyg gtkj ikWp lkS pOou #i;s½] ohtk izkslsflax Qhl dk [kpZ eq0 9]565@& ¼ukS gtkj ikWp lkS iSalB #i;s½] f"kdk;rdrkZ ds estcku }kjk cksxksVk "kgj esa gksVy cqfdax 9]000@& ¼ukS gtkj #i;s½] U;w fnYyh ls mM+ku dh rS;kjh djus ds fy, 15 fnuksa rd jgus dk [kpZ eq0 7]000@& ¼lkr gtkj #i;s½] varjkZ'Vªh; ;k=k chek dk [kpZ eq0 6]670@& ¼N% gtkj N% lkS lÙkj #i;s½] viuh ;k=k [kjhnnkjh gsrq eq0 6]436@& ¼N% gtkj pkj lkS NÙkhl #i;s½] x`guxj ls ubZ fnYyh rd vkSj okilh gsrq] 6]000@& ¼N% gtkj #i;s½] euksfpfdRld dk

"kqYd eq0 2]100@& ¼nks gtkj ,d lkS #i;s½] dksfoM+&19 dh vkj0Vh0&ih0lh0vkj0 VsLV "kqYd eq0 700@& ¼lkr lkS #i;s½] ¶ykbV fVdV dks 17 fnu ckn okfil fd;s tkus ij mld C;kt 620@&¼N% lkS chl :Ik;s½] dqy 1]35]645@&¼,d yk[k iSrhl gtkj N% lkS iSrkyhl½ :Ik;s dk [kpZ Hkh "kkfey gSA izkFkhZ@;kph us dksyfEc;k ds cksxkVk "kgj tkus esa vk;s mijksDr lHkh [kpkZs ds fcyksa dh lR;kfir QksVks izfr dkxt la0 7x yxk;r 7x@70 rd dks i=koyh ij izLrqr fd;k x;k gSA mijksDr fcyksa dh lR;kfiRk izfr dks ns[krs gq;s ;g dgk tk ldrk gS] fd izkFkhZ@;kph }kjk dgs x;s dFku eux<+r ugha gS] cfYd izkFkhZ@;kph }kjk tks Hkh rdZ@dFku fn;s x;s gS] muesa lR;rk izrhr gksrh gSA vr% mijksDr rdkZs ds v/kkj ij bl ckr dh iqf'V gks tkrh gS] fd foi{kh ds0,y0,e0 ,;jykbUl }kjk izkFkhZ@;kph ds izfr lsok esa deh dh xbZ gSA

fuLrkfjr Page 07

13- pwafd foi{kh ds0,y0,e0 ,;jykbUl }kjk izkFkhZ@;kph ds ,;jykbUl eas ;k=k u djus dk dksbZ Li'V dkjk.k crk;k x;k gS vkSj u gh uksfVl dh rkehyh gksus ds ckotwn bl vk;ksx ds le{k mifLFkr gqvk gSA ftl vk/kkj ij Li'V :Ik ls ;g dgk tk ldrk gS] fd foi{kh ds0,y0,e0 ,;jykbUl }kjk fuf"pr gh izkFkhZ@;kph ds izfr lsok esa deh dh gSA ;gka ;g Hkh dguk mfpr gksxk fd foi{kh }kjk izkFkhZ@;kph dks mlds fVdV cqfdax dh /kujkf"k dks okil fd;k x;k gS] tks fd foi{kh dh lsok esa deh dks nf"kZr djrk gSA

14- mijksDr foospuk ds vk/kkj ij ;g vk;ksx bl fu'd'kZ ij igqaprk gS] fd foi{kh ds0,y0,e0 ,;jykbUl us izkFkhZ@;kph dks dUQeZ fVdV o ohtk gksus ds ckotwn Hkh gokbZ ;k=k djus ls jksd dj vuqfpr O;kikj] O;ogkj o viuh lsok esa deh dh gS] ftlls izkFkhZ@;kph dks ekufld {kfr gqbZ gSA bl vk/kkj ij izkFkhZ@;kph }kjk tks vuqrks'k bl vk;ksx ls ekaxs x;s gS] muesa ls cksxkVk u tkus ds dkj.k ogka vk;ksftr gksus okyh ;ksxk dk;Z"kkyk ds fy, 71]000@&¼bdgÙkj gtkj #i;s½] ohtk izkslsflax Qhl dk [kpZ eq0 9]565@&¼ukS gtkj ikap lkS iSalB #i;s½] varjkZ'Vªh; ;k=k chek dk [kpZ eq0 6]670@&¼N% gtkj N% lkS lÙkj #i;s½] euksfpfdRld dk "kqYd eq0 2]100@&¼nks gtkj ,d lkS #i;s½] dksfoM+&19 dh vkj0Vh0ih0lh0vkj0 VsLV "kqYd eq0 700@& ¼lkr lkS #i;s½ dqy eq0 90]035@&¼uCcs gtkj iSrhl :Ik;s½ rFkk ekufld {kfriwfr gsrq 7]00]000@&¼lkr yk[k :Ik;s½ dqy 7]90]035@&¼lkr yk[k uCcs gtkj iSarhl :Ik;s½ ikus dk vf/kdkjh gSA rn~uqlkj izkFkhZ@;kph dk ifjokn U;k;fgr esa ,d i{kh; :Ik ls Lohdkj fd;s tkus ;ksX; gSA

vkns"k

15- ifjoknh dk ifjokn ,d i{kh; :Ik ls Lohdkj fd;k tkrk gSA foi{kh ds0,y0,e0 ,;jykbUl izdk"knhi fcfYMax VkWyLVk; ekxZ&7 dukWV iSysl fnYyh&110001 dks vknsf"kr fd;k tkrk gS] og ifjoknh dks dksyfEc;ka ds cksxksV

"kgj u tkus ij gqbZ vkfFkZd {kfr ds gtkZus ds :Ik esa 90]035@&¼uCcs gtkj iSarhl :i;s½ o ekufld {kfriwfrZ dh en esa 7]00]000@&¼lkr yk[k :Ik;s½ rFkk okn

fuLrkfjr Page 08

O;; dh en esa 20]000@&¼chl gtkj :Ik;s½ dqy 8]10]035@&¼vkB yk[k nl gtkj iSarhl :Ik;s½ ,d ekg ds vanj vnk djsaaA

16- ;fn foi{kh }kjk mijksDr /kujkf"k fu.kZ;kns"k dh frfFk ls 01 ekg ds vanj vnk ugha dh tkrh gS] rks ml fLFkfr eas izkFkhZ@;kph f"kdk;r nk;j djus dh frfFk 29-06-2022 ls fu.kZ;kns"k dh frfFk rd 06 izfr"kr okf'kZd lk/kkj.k C;kt izkIr djus dk vf/kdkjh gksxkA

fnukad&01-02-2023

¼jkds"k lkeosnh½ ¼nhfIr Hk.Mkjh½ ¼vk'kh"k uSFkkuh½

lnL;] lnL;k] v/;{k]

ftyk miHkksDrk vk;ksx] ftyk miHkksDrk vk;ksx ftyk miHkksDrk vk;ksx] ikSM+h x<+okyA ikSM+h x<+okyA ikSM+h x<+okyA

mDr fu.kZ;kns'k gekjs }kjk gLrk{kfjr ,oa fnukafdr dj vkt [kqys vk;ksx esa mn~?kksf'kr fd;k x;k A

fnukad&01-02-2023

¼jkds"k lkeosnh½ ¼nhfIr Hk.Mkjh½ ¼vk'kh"k uSFkkuh½

lnL;] lnL;k] v/;{k]

ftyk miHkksDrk vk;ksx] ftyk miHkksDrk vk;ksx ftyk miHkksDrk vk;ksx] ikSM+h x<+okyA ikSM+h x<+okyA ikSM+h x<+okyA

Sushil Kumar Ranakoti v. KLM Airlines

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Legal Issues Presented

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Position

Respondent's (izkFkhZ@;kph / f"kdk;rdrkZ) Position

Table of Precedents Cited

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Holding and Implications

Closing / Administrative Entries

Sushil Kumar Ranakoti v. KLM Airlines

Comments