COMMON ORDER: (Per Hon'ble Dr.SA,J) Since the facts of the case in both these writ petitions are identical and since the crimes relied upon by the detaining authority for passing the detention orders impugned in both these writ petitions are similar, both these writ petitions are being taken up together and disposed of by this common order.
2. W.P.No.12321 of 2021 is filed by Hakeem Khan, who is the father of the detenu, namely, Salman Khan and W.P.No.12327 of 2021 is filed by Shaik Naseema, who is the wife of the detenu, namely, Syed Ayub. The petitioners herein filed the present Habeas Corpus petitions challenging the separate detention orders vide SB(I) No.15/PD-3/HYD/2021 and SB(I) No.14/PD- 3/HYD/2021 of even date, dated 04.03.2021, respectively, passed by the respondent No.2-Commissioner of Police, Hyderabad City, and the consequential confirmation orders vide G.O.Rt.Nos.1102 and 1101 of even date, dated 17.05.2021, respectively, passed by the respondent No.1-Principal Secretary to Government, General Administration (Spl. (Law & Order)) Department, Government of Telangana.
3. Heard Mr.M.A.Mujeeb, learned counsel for the petitioners in both these writ petitions and Mr.A.Manoj Kumar, learned Additional Government Pleader for Home representing the
1
learned Additional Advocate General appearing for the respondents in both these writ petitions and perused the record.
4. The case of the petitioners in both these writ petitions is that basing on four criminal cases registered against the detenus herein in the year 2020, i.e., Crime No.151 of 2020 of Humayun Nagar Police Station, Crime No.131 of 2020 of Nampally Police Station, Crime No.203 of 2020 of Bahadurpura Police Station and Crime No.214 of 2020 of Golconda Police Station, Hyderabad, the respondent No.2 passed the impugned detention orders of even date, dated 04.03.2021. According to the respondent No.2, previously, the detenu in W.P.No.12321 of 2021 was involved in as many as eleven cases and the detenu in W.P.No.12327 of 2010 was involved in as many as seven cases in the limits of Hyderabad Police Commissionerate. But, merely relying on four recent cases registered against the detenus in the year 2020, the detention orders were passed. According to the detaining authority, the detenus are 'White Collar Offenders', as they have been committing offences of cheating the gullible people to acquire easy and illegal money under the guise of helping the people suffering from various ailments for their treatment in an organized manner in the limits of Hyderabad Police Commissionerate and thus creating large scale fear and panic among the general public and thereby adversely affecting the public order. Subsequently, the impugned detention orders were confirmed by the Government, vide G.O.Rt.Nos.1102 and 1101 of even date, dated 17.05.2021, respectively.
2
5. Learned counsel for the petitioners would contend that the impugned detention orders have been passed in a mechanical manner and without application of mind. Already criminal law was set into motion against the detenus. Further, out of four crimes relied by the detaining authority, the detenus were granted conditional bails by the Courts concerned in three crimes. In fourth crime, i.e., Crime No.214 of 2020 of Golconda Police Station, the detenus were granted anticipatory bail by the Court concerned. Thereafter, the alleged detenus compromised the said offence with the complainant before Lok Adalat on 07.11.2020. The detenus have not violated the conditions of bail and they have not involved in any crime from the date of their release on bail till the date of passing of impugned detention orders. Under these circumstances, the apprehension of the detaining authority that since the detenus were granted bail in all the crimes, there is imminent possibility of the detenus committing similar offences, is misconceived. Further, the alleged crimes do not add up to "disturbing the public order" and they are confined within the ambit and scope of the word "law and order". Since the offences alleged are under the Indian Penal Code, the detenus can certainly be tried and convicted under the Penal Code. Thus, there was no need for the detaining authority to invoke the draconian preventive detention law against the detenus. Hence, the impugned orders tantamount to colourable exercise of power. The impugned orders are legally unsustainable and ultimately, prayed to allow the Writ Petitions, as prayed for.
3
6. On the other hand, the learned Additional Government Pleader for Home appearing for the respondents supported the impugned orders and submitted that the detenus are 'White Collar Offenders'. They are committing offences of cheating the gullible people in an organized manner to acquire easy and illegal money under the guise of helping the people suffering from various ailments for their treatment. The unlawful activities of the detenus created a large scale fear and panic among the general public and adversely affecting the public order. Since the detenus were granted bail in all crimes relied by the detaining authority, the apprehension of the detaining authority that there is imminent possibility of the detenus committing similar offences, is not misconceived. Therefore, the detaining authority was legally justified in passing the impugned detention orders. Further, the Advisory Board rendered its opinion that there is sufficient cause for detention of the detenus and on considering the same along with the entire material, the Government confirmed the impugned detention orders vide G.O.Rt.Nos.1102 and 1101 of even date, dated 17.05.2021, respectively. All the mandatory requirements were strictly followed by the detaining authority while passing the impugned detention orders. The impugned orders are legally sustainable and ultimately, prayed to dismiss the Writ Petitions.
7. In view of the submissions made by both the sides, the point that arises for determination in these Writ Petitions is:
4
"Whether the impugned detention orders vide SB(I) No.15/PD-3/HYD/2021 and SB(I) No.14/PD- 3/HYD/2021 of even date, dated 04.03.2021, respectively, passed by the respondent No.2 and the consequential confirmation orders vide G.O.Rt.Nos.1102 and 1101 of even date, dated 17.05.2021, respectively passed by the respondent No.1, are liable to be set aside?"
POINT:
8. In catena of cases, the Hon'ble Supreme Court had clearly opined that there is a vast difference between "law and order"
and "public order". The offences which are committed against a particular individual fall within the ambit of "law and order". It is only when the public at large is adversely affected by the criminal activities of a person, then such conduct of that person is said to disturb the public order. Moreover, individual cases can be dealt with by the criminal justice system. Therefore, there is no need for the detaining authority to invoke the draconian preventive detention laws against an individual. Hence, according to the Hon'ble Apex Court, the detaining authority should be wary of invoking the immense power under the Act.
9. In Ram Manohar Lohia v. State of Bihar1, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has, in fact, deprecated the invoking of the preventive law in order to tackle a law and order problem. It was observed that every breach of public peace and every violation of law may create a 'law and order' problem, but does not necessarily create a problem of 'public order'. The distinction
5
has to be borne in mind in view of what has been stated in the grounds of detention.
10. In Kanu Biswas v. State Of West Bengal . Bengal2, the Hon'ble Apex Court, while discussing the meaning of word 'public order,' held that the question whether a man has only committed a breach of 'law and order' or has acted in a manner likely to cause a disturbance of the 'public order', is a question of degree and extent of the reach of the act upon the Society.
11. In the instant cases, the detaining authority passed the impugned detention orders of even date dated 04.03.2021, basing on four aforesaid crimes registered against the detenus. We shall present them in a tabular form, the date of occurrence, the date of registration of FIRs, the offences complained of and their nature, such as bailable/non-bailable or cognizable/non- cognizable.
| Crime No. |
Date of Occurrence |
Date of registration of FIR |
Offences |
Nature |
| 151/2020 of Humayun Nagar PS |
20.07.2020 |
25.07.2020 |
Sections 420 & 406 r/w 149 of IPC |
Non-bailable/ cognizable |
| 131/2020 of Nampally PS |
19.07.2020 |
25.07.2020 |
Section 420 of IPC |
Non-bailable/ cognizable |
| 203/2020 of Bahadurpura PS |
04.05.2020 |
04.08.2020 |
Sections 406 & 420 of IPC |
Non-bailable/ cognizable |
| 214/2020 of Golconda PS |
20.08.2020 |
20.08.2020 |
406 & 420 of IPC |
Non-bailable/ cognizable |
214/2020 of
20.08.2020 20.08.2020 406 & 420 Non-bailable/ Golconda PS of IPC cognizable
12. A bare perusal of the impugned detention orders reveals that out of the four crimes relied by the detaining authority, the
1 AIR 1966 SC 740
6
detenus were granted conditional bails by the Courts concerned in three crimes, i.e., Crime No.151 of 2020 of Humayun Nagar Police Station, Crime No.131 of 2020 of Nampally Police Station and Crime No.203 of 2020 of Bahadurpura Police Station and released from jail. In fourth crime, i.e., Crime No.214 of 2020 of Golconda Police Station, the detenus were granted anticipatory bail by the Court concerned. Thereafter, the alleged detenus compromised the said offence with the complainant before Lok Adalat on 07.11.2020. The detenus have not violated the conditions of bail and they have not involved in any crime from the date of their release on bail till the date of passing of impugned detention orders. Under these circumstances, the apprehension of the detaining authority that since the detenus were granted bail in all the crimes, there is imminent possibility of the detenus committing similar offences which are detrimental to public order unless they are prevented from doing so by an appropriate order of detention, is highly misplaced. It is the bounden duty of the Police to inform the learned Public Prosecutor about the conduct of the detenus and to handover the entire case record available against the detenus. The police are supposed to be vigilant in collecting the whole data against the detenus and furnish the same to the Public Prosecutor/ Additional Public Prosecutor to defeat the bail application/s of the detenus. In the instant cases, since the detenus are released on bail, in the event if it is found that the detenus are involved in further crimes, the prosecution can apprise the same to the Court concerned and seek cancellation of bail. Moreover, the
7
criminal law was already set into motion against the detenus. Since the detenus have allegedly committed offences punishable under the Indian Penal Code, the said crimes can be effectively dealt with under the provisions of the Indian Penal Code. The detaining authority cannot be permitted to subvert, supplant or substitute the punitive law of land, by ready resort to preventive detention.
13. Here, it is apt to state that the true distinction between the areas of 'law and order' and 'public order' lies not merely in the nature or quality of the act, but in the degree and extent of its impact on the society. Acts which are similar in nature, but committed in different contexts and circumstances, might cause different reactions. In one case, it might affect specific individuals only, and therefore touches the problem of 'law and order' only, while in another, it might affect the public order. The words 'law and order' and 'public order' have well defined contours. Some infractions of law may lead to disturbance of law and order, but every infraction of law does not necessarily result in public disorder. In the instant cases, grave as the offences may be, in the given circumstances of the case, no inference of disturbance of public order can be drawn against the detenus. The subject cases can be tried under the normal criminal law and, if convicted, can certainly be punished by the Court of law. Thus, these cases do not fall within the ambit of the words "public order" or "disturbance of public order".
Instead, they fall within the scope of the words "law and order".
8
Hence, there was no need for the detaining authority to pass the impugned detention orders. Therefore, for the reasons stated above, the impugned orders are legally unsustainable.
14. In the result, both the Writ Petitions are allowed. The impugned detention orders vide SB(I) No.15/PD-3/HYD/2021, and SB(I) No.14/PD-3/HYD/2021, of even date, dated 04.03.2021, passed by the respondent No.2, and the consequential confirmation orders vide G.O.Rt.Nos.1102 and
9