Date of Hearing : 03.11.2020 Date of Decision : 05.11.2020
Information Commissioner : Shri Y. K. Sinha Relevant facts emerging from appeal:
RTI application filed on : 23.09.2019 PIO replied on : 30.09.2019 First Appeal filed on : 03.10.2019 First Appellate Order on : 30.10.2019 2ndAppeal/complaint received on : 21.11.2019
Information sought and background of the case:
The Appellant filed an RTI application dated 23.09.2019seeking information on following point:-
Provide the Minutes of the Meeting for compliance with order of Hon"ble High Court of Delhi in LPA 50/2018 requesting the stakeholders to attend the hearing in the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, in the Room 343-A, Nirman Bhawan, Delhi on 20.09.2019 at 10 AM by Shri Rajeev Attri, Under Secretary to the Government of India.
The PIO, Under Secretary vide letter dated 30.09.2018 stated that no such minutes have been issued in this regard. The matter is sub judice. The hearing of stakeholders in the case was given by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare in compliance with the direction of Hon'ble High Court of Delhi. Dissatisfied with information received from the PIO, the Appellant filed a First Appeal dated 03.10.2019. The FAA vide order dated 30.10.2019 stated as follows:-
"Whereas, as per DoPT OM. No. No. 1/32/2013-IR dated 28.11.2013: „It is important to note that only such information can be supplied under the act which already exists and is held by the public authority or held under the control of the
1
public authority. The public information officer is not supposed to created information; or to interpret information; or to solve the problems raised by the applicants; or to furnish replies to hypothetical questions"" Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied, the Appellant approached the Commission with the instant Second Appeal.
Facts emerging in Course of Hearing:
A written submission has been received from CPIO and US vide letter dated 20.10.2020 wherein it was stated that vide letter dated 30.09.2019, reply was provided within the stipulated time limit as per the provisions of the RTI Act, 2005. Furthermore, as per DoPT OM No No.1./32/2013-IR dated 28.11.2013 only such information can be supplied which already exists and is held by the public authority or held under the control of the public authority. In order to ensure social distancing and prevent the spread of the pandemic, COVID-19, audio hearings were scheduled after giving prior notice to both the parties.
The Appellant participated in the hearing on being contacted on his telephone. Explaining that no satisfactory response was provided by the CPIO/ FAA, the Appellant stated that the information was sought in the larger public interest since it revolved around the issues of competence of persons other than registered medicine practitioners to sign laboratory reports. He also cited a catena of decisions of the Commission and the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi to submit that the mere fact that a matter was subjudice cannot be a ground for denying information under the RTI Act, 2005. Moreover, the Respondent did not claim an exemption u/s 8 (1) (h) of the RTI Act, 2005 in the instant matter. Thus, he prayed that the copy of minutes of the meeting with the stakeholders in compliance with order of Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in LPA 50/2018 be disclosed to him.
The Respondent is represented by Shri Rajeev Attri, Under Secretary and CPIO through audio conference. At the outset he stated that the information sought was not available since no minutes pertaining to the deliberations with stakeholders were recorded as discussions were carried out in compliance with the order of the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi on the basis of one to one hearings. On the basis of the deliberations with the associations/ stakeholders, the Clinical Establishment Rules were amended in 2020 allowing individuals having PhD in Medical Microbiology/ Medical Biochemistry to become authorised signatory to sign laboratory reports. It was however stated that the matter was still pending in the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi where the updated factual position would be intimated to the Court through their legal counsel. The Appellant desired that if the minutes of the meeting were not available then a copy of the submissions to be deposed before the Court be provided to him at this stage. The Respondent however vehemently objected to the request of the Appellant on the ground that the same violated the principles of Attorney- Client privilege and the stand of the Public Authority before the Hon'ble High Court could be appropriately contested by the Appellant as and when the hearing in the matter resumed.
2
Decision:
Keeping in view the facts of the case and the submissions made by both the parties, the Commission at the outset noted that as per the provisions of the RTI Act, 2005 only such information which is held and available on the record of the Public Authority can be provided. In its reply against the RTI application, the CPIO clearly mentioned that "no such minutes were issued in this regard". The reason for the above mentioned reply was further explained by the Respondent during the hearing which is self explanatory and appears reasonable to the Commission.
As regards the request of the Appellant during the hearing to provide a copy of the deposition/ submissions to be made by the Respondent before the Hon'ble High Court, the Commission is satisfied that the same falls in the category of privileged communication between Client and Attorney that is exempted u/s 8 (1) (e) of the RTI Act, 2005. In a catena of judgments, the Supreme Court has reiterated that a lawyer/ attorney acts in a fiduciary capacity with his client. Reference can be made to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Central Board of Secondary Education & Anr. vs. Aditya Bandopadhyay &Ors., (2011) 8 SCC 497 wherein it was held as under:
41. In a philosophical and very wide sense, examining bodies can be said to act in a fiduciary capacity, with reference to students who participate in an examination, as a government does while governing its citizens or as the present generation does with reference to the future generation while preserving the environment. But the words 'information available to a person in his fiduciary relationship' are used in Section 8(1)(e) of RTI Act in its normal and well recognized sense, that is to refer to persons who act in a fiduciary capacity, with reference to a specific beneficiary or beneficiaries who are to be expected to be protected or benefited by the actions of the fiduciary - a trustee with reference to the beneficiary of the trust, a guardian with reference to a minor/physically/infirm/mentally challenged, a parent with reference to a child, a lawyer or a chartered accountant with reference to a client, a doctor or nurse with reference to a patient, an agent with reference to a principal, a partner with reference to another partner, a director of a company with reference to a share-holder, an executor with reference to a legatee, a receiver with reference to the parties to a lis, an employer with reference to the confidential information relating to the employee, and an employee with reference to business dealings/transaction of the employer. We do not find that kind of fiduciary relationship between the examining body and the examinee, with reference to the evaluated answer-books, that come into the custody of the examining body" Similarly, in the judgment of Reserve Bank of India & Ors vs. Jayantilal N. Mistry & Ors., (2016) 3 SCC 525 the Supreme Court while dealing with the defence of RBI that it was in the fiduciary relationship with the Bank noted as follows:- "
"55. The Advanced Law Lexicon, 3rd Edition, 2005, defines fiduciary relationship as "a relationship in which one person is under a duty to act for the benefit of the other on the matters within the scope of the fiduciary relationship. Fiduciary relationship usually arise in one of the four situations (1) when one person places trust in the faithful integrity of another, who as a result gains superiority or influence over the first, (2) when one person assumes control and responsibility
3
over another, (3) when one person has a duty to act or give advice to another on matters falling within the scope of the relationship, or (4) when there is specific relationship that has traditionally be recognized as involving fiduciary duties, as with a lawyer and a client, or a stockbroker and a customer. xxx
57. The term fiduciary relationship has been well discussed by this Court in the case of Central Board of Secondary Education and Anr. v. Aditya Bandopadhyay and Ors. (supra). In the said decision, their Lordships referred various authorities to ascertain the meaning of the term fiduciary relationship and observed thus:
20.1) Black's Law Dictionary (7th Edition, Page 640) defines 'fiduciary relationship' thus: A relationship in which one person is under a duty to act for the benefit of the other on matters within the scope of the relationship. Fiduciary relationships-such as trustee beneficiary, guardian-ward, agent-principal, and attorney client-require the highest duty of care. Fiduciary relationships usually arise in one of four situations: (1) when one person places trust in the faithful integrity of another, who as a result gains superiority or influence over the first, (2) when one person assumes control and responsibility over another, (3) when one person has a duty to act for or give advice to another on matters falling within the scope of the relationship, or (4) when there is a specific relationship that has traditionally been recognized as involving fiduciary duties, as with a lawyer and a client or a stockbroker and a customer."
Nonetheless, the Commission observed that reference made by the CPIO in his reply regarding the matter being sub judice was erroneous. It is a settled position of law that a matter being sub judice is no ground for denying information under the RTI Act, 2005 unless disclosure of information is explicitly barred by a Court of Law.
With the above observations, the instant matter stands disposed off accordingly.
Y. K. Sinha (वाई. के. नसन्द्हा)
Information Commissioner (सूचना आयुक्त) Authenticated true copy
(अभिप्रमाभितसत्याभितप्रभत)
Ram Parkash Grover (राम प्रकाश ग्रोवर) Dy. Registrar (उप-पंजीयक)
011-26180514
4