Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE ACT 1948
  • ARTICLE 42 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • ARTICLE 21 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Section 43 of the CCS (Leave) Rules,
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule H 30 or sub-rule (1) of Rule 31,
  • Rule 74 of the the Maharashtra Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1961,
  • sub- section i (1) of Section 2
  • sub-rule (1). (5) Maternity
  • provisions contained in Articles 38, 39, 42 and 43 ofthe Constitution of India and Sections 2 and 5 of theMaternity Benefit Act, 1961 as well as Article 11
  • Section 43 of the CCS (Leave) Rules, 1972,
  • Rule 43(1) of the CCS (Leave) Rules, 1972
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE ACT 1948
  • ARTICLE 42 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • ARTICLE 21 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Section 43 of the CCS (Leave) Rules,
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule H 30 or sub-rule (1) of Rule 31,
  • Rule 74 of the the Maharashtra Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1961,
  • sub- section i (1) of Section 2
  • sub-rule (1). (5) Maternity
  • provisions contained in Articles 38, 39, 42 and 43 ofthe Constitution of India and Sections 2 and 5 of theMaternity Benefit Act, 1961 as well as Article 11
  • Section 43 of the CCS (Leave) Rules, 1972,
  • Rule 43(1) of the CCS (Leave) Rules, 1972
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Dr. Pratiba Himral, employed as an Associate Professor on a contract basis at Shri Lal Bahadur Shastri Government Medical College, Mandi, adopted a female child on 11.03.2020, who was born on 25.02.2020. The petitioner filed the writ petition challenging the Notification dated 07.03.2012, which allegedly withdrew maternity leave benefits under Section 43 of the CCS (Leave) Rules, 1972. The petitioner sought quashing of the notification, direction to grant maternity leave and child care leave for the period from 13.06.2020 to 25.09.2020, payment of salary with interest for the recovery order dated 08.02.2021, and to treat the said period as service period. The matter proceeded before the High Court of Himachal Pradesh and was admitted for hearing.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner, having adopted a child shortly after its birth, is entitled to maternity leave of 180 days under Section 43 of the CCS (Leave) Rules, 1972.
  2. Whether the Notification dated 07.03.2012 withdrawing maternity leave benefits under the CCS (Leave) Rules is liable to be quashed.
  3. Whether the petitioner is entitled to child care leave and the treatment of the maternity leave period as service period.
  4. Whether the recovery order dated 08.02.2021 for denying maternity leave is illegal and liable to be set aside.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Lakshmi Kant Pandey (AIR 1984 SC 469) Right to life under Article 21 includes right to motherhood and the right of every child to full development. The Court relied on this precedent to affirm that maternity leave protects the dignity of motherhood and supports the child's development, reinforcing entitlement to maternity leave for adoptive or commissioning mothers.
Municipal Corporation of Delhi (AIR 2000 SC 1274) Female workers, including those on muster roll, are entitled to maternity benefits under the Maternity Benefit Act, 1961. The Court cited this case to emphasize that maternity benefits should be granted without discrimination, underscoring the social justice aspect of maternity leave.
Devshree Bandhe v. Chhattisgarh State Power Holding Company Limited (2017 Labour Industrial Cases 1506) Definition and scope of maternity includes biological and non-biological motherhood such as surrogacy. The Court used this precedent to support the interpretation that maternity leave should be available to commissioning mothers and those who become mothers through surrogacy or adoption.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the provisions of Section 43 of the CCS (Leave) Rules, 1972, which grants maternity leave of 180 days to female government servants with less than two surviving children. It noted that the purpose of maternity leave is to protect the dignity of motherhood and to foster the bond between mother and child. The Court referred to prior judgments, including those from the Delhi and Bombay High Courts, which recognized maternity leave entitlement for commissioning mothers and adoptive mothers, emphasizing that motherhood is not limited to biological birth but includes adoption and surrogacy.

The Court highlighted the constitutional protection under Articles 14 and 21, which guarantee equality and the right to life, encompassing the right to motherhood and child development. It found the respondents' refusal to grant maternity leave discriminatory and arbitrary, especially since the petitioner adopted the child when it was only 15 days old, thereby necessitating maternity leave for proper care and bonding.

The Court distinguished this case from others by clarifying that its judgment was rendered on the peculiar facts of the early adoption and did not address the constitutional validity of the impugned Notification dated 07.03.2012 withdrawing maternity leave benefits under the CCS (Leave) Rules.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the petition, quashed the recovery order dated 08.02.2021, and directed the respondents to grant maternity leave to the petitioner in accordance with Rule 43(1) of the CCS (Leave) Rules, 1972, treating the maternity leave period as service period. The Court also disposed of pending applications related to the matter.

The judgment applies specifically to the facts where the petitioner adopted a child shortly after birth and does not set a broad precedent on the constitutional validity of the Notification dated 07.03.2012. The direct effect is the restoration of maternity leave and related benefits to the petitioner, reinforcing recognition of maternity leave rights for adoptive mothers under the CCS (Leave) Rules.

    DR. PRATIBA HIMRAL v. STATE OF HP AND ORS

    REPORTABLE

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA

    .

    ON THE 29th DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2021

    P

    BEFORE

    .

    HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TARLOK SINGH CHA &

    f

    U H HAN

    HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SATYEN VAIDYA CIVIL WRIT PETITION N t o. 16o75 of 2021Between:-

    DR. PRATIBA HIMRAL, Wr/O

    SHRI ASHWANI o RAJ SHAH, R/OTYPE-V, BLOCK A, SEuT NO.101,RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX SLBSGMCMANDI AT NERH CHOWK, DISTRICT MANDI, H C .P., PRESENTLY WORKINGAS ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR ON CONTRACT BASIS IN THE DEPARTMENTOF h MEDICINE AT SLBSGMC MANDIAT NERH CHOWK, DISTRICT g MANDI, H.P. .…..PETITIONER. i

    (BY SH. KARAN SINGH PARMAR,ADVOCATE)

    H AND 1.STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESHTHROUGH SECRETARY HEALTHTO THE GOVERNMENT OF H.P.,SHIMLA-2.

    2. DIRECTOR OF MEDICAL EDUCATION & RESEARCH IN SHIMLA-2.

    3. DIRECTOR HEALTH SERVICES,

    SHIMLA-2.

    1

    2

    4. PRINCIPAL SHRI LAL BAHADUR SHASTRI

    GOVERNMENT MEDICAL COLLEGE

    (SLBSGMC) MANDI AT NER CHOWK,

    DISTRICT MANDI, H.P. .…..RESPONDENTS..

    (SH. AJAY VAIDYA, SENIOR P

    ADDITIONAL ADVOCATE GENERAL,

    .

    FOR RESPONDENTS- 1 TO 4)

    H

    This petition coming on for adm ission after notice this day, Hon'ble Mr. Ju f s o tice Tarlok SinghChauhan, passed the following:

    O R D E R rt CMP No.1162 u 1 of 2021.

    For the r o easons stated in the application, theamendment as C prayed for, is allowed. Application standsdisposed of.

    h Amended writ petition is taken on record.

    ig

    CWP No. 1675 of 2021. H

    The instant petition has been filed for grant of the following substantive reliefs:- "i) That the Notification dated 07.03.2012(Annexure PA-1 substituted as Annexure P-7A may very kindly be quashed and set aside.

    ii) That the action of the respondents to deny maternity leave/Child Care Leave to the petitioner and order of recovery dated 08.02.2021 may be held illegal, wrong and respondents may be directed

    3

    to pay the petitioner the payment for the period of 13.06.2020 to 25.09.2020 with the interest rate of 9% Annum on the account of recoveries made with .

    all Consequential Benefits.

    P

    iii) That the respondents may very kind . ly be directed to treat the period from 13.06.2020 to 25.09.2020 as a Service Period. H

    iv) That the petitioner may also f b e held entitled for child care leave."

    o

    2. The undisputed facts t a re that the petitioner adopted a female child on 1 r 1.03.2020, who was born on

    25.02.2020.

    u

    3. Now, the o moot question is whether the petitioner can claim the benefit of maternity leave of 180 days in h terms o

    Cf Section 43 of the CCS (Leave) Rules, which is r g eproduced as under:- i

    "43. Maternity Leave: H

    (1) A female Government servant (including an apprentice) with less than two surviving children may be granted maternity leave by an authoritycompetent to grant leave for a period of 1 [180 days]from the date of its commencement.

    (2) During such period, she shall be paid leave salary equal to the pay drawn immediately before proceeding on leave.

    4

    NOTE:- In the case of a person to whom Employees' State Insurance Act, 1948 (34 of 1948), applies, the amount of leave salary payable under this rule shall be reduced by the amount of benefit payable under .

    the said Act for the corresponding period.

    P

    2 [(3) Maternity leave not exceeding 45 days . may also be granted to a female Government servant (irrespective of the number of survivi H ng children) during the entire service of that fe f ma le Government servant in case of miscarria ge o including abortion onproduction of medical ce t rtificate as laid down in Rule19:

    Provided that u the r maternity leave granted andavailed of o before the commencement of the CCS(Leave) Amendment Rules, 1995, shall not be takeninto C account for the purpose of this sub-rule.](4 ) (a) Maternity leave may be combined with leave h of any other kind.

    ig

    (b) Notwithstanding the requirement of production ofmedical certificate contained in sub-rule (1) of Rule H

    30 or sub-rule (1) of Rule 31, leave of the kind due and admissible (including commuted leave for a period not exceeding 60 days and leave not due)upto a maximum of 1 [two years] may, if applied for,be granted in continuation of maternity leave granted under sub-rule (1).

    (5) Maternity leave shall not be debited against the leave account."

    5

    4. Somewhat an identical issue came up before this Court in CWP No. 4509 of 2020, titled Sushma Devi

    .

    versus State of Himachal Pradesh and others, deci P ded on 04.03.2021, regarding entitlement of matern H ity lea.ve tosurrogacy parents and while dealing with th is issue, the question of maternity leave to the adopti f ve mother was

    also considered in para-8 of the t jud gm o ent, referred supra,which reads as under:-

    "8. Once, the u resp r ondents admit that the minorchild is that of the petitioner, then she is entitled tothe leave a o kin to the persons, who are granted leavein te C rms of the rules (ibid). The purpose of the saidru les is for proper bonding between the child andparents. Even, in the case of adoption, the adoptive h mother does not give birth to the child, yet the g

    necessity of bonding of the mother with the adopted i

    child has been recognized by the CentralGovernment."

    H5.This issue has been considered in detail by the learned Single Judge of theDelhi High Court inRamaPandey versus Union of India and others 2015 Labour Industrial Cases 3921 wherein it was held that the

    commissioning mother's entitlement to maternity leave

    6

    cannot be denied only on the ground that she did not bear the child.

    .

    6. A Division Bench of the Bombay High Cour P t in

    Dr. Mrs. Hema Vijay Menon versus

    H State. ofMaharashtra and others AIR 2015 Bomb ay 231 while following the aforesaid judgment observed a f s under:

    "7. On hearing the learned co o unsel for the parties, it appears that the Join r t D t ire ctor of Higher Education,Nagpur, was not justified in refusing maternity leaveto the petitio u ner. According to Oxford EnglishDictionary o , maternity means- motherhood. Maternitymeans the period during pregnancy and shortly afterthe C child's birth. If Maternity means motherhood, itw ould not be proper to distinguish between a naturaland biological mother and a mother who has h begotten a child through surrogacy or has adopted a g

    child from the date of his/ her birth. The object of i

    maternity leave is to protect the dignity ofmotherhood by providing for full and healthy

    H

    maintenance of the woman and her child. Maternity leave is intended to achieve the object of ensuring social justice to women. Motherhood and childhoodboth require special attention. Not only are the health issues of the mother and the child considered

    while providing for maternity leave but the leave is

    provided for creating a bond of affection between

    the two. It is said that being a mother is one of the

    most rewarding jobs on the earth and also one of the

    7

    most challenging. To distinguish between a mother who begets a child through surrogacy and a natural mother who gives birth to a child, would result in .

    insulting womanhood and the intention of a wom P an to bring up a child begotten through s H urroga . cy, asher own. A commissioning mother like the petitionerwould have the same rights and obligations towards the child as the natural mother. M f ot herhood never

    ends on the birth of the ch ild o and a commissioningmother like the petitioner cannot be refused paidmaternity leave. A woman cannot be discriminated, as far as maternity b r entefits are concerned, only onthe ground that she has obtained the baby through

    surrogacy. Thou u gh the petitioner did not give birth to

    the child, the child was placed in the secured hands

    of th C e petiotioner as soon as it was born. A newly bornch ild cannot be left at the mercy of others. A h maternity leave to the commissioning mother likethe petitioner would be necessary. A newly born child

    ig

    needs rearing andthat is themost crucial periodduring which thechild requires thecare andH

    attention of hismother. There is atremendous amount of learning that takes place in the first year of the baby's life, the baby learns a lot too. Also, thebond of affection has to be developed. A mother, asalready stated hereinabove, would include a commissioning mother or a mother securing a child

    through surrogacy. Any other interpretation would

    result in frustrating the object of providing maternity

    leave to a mother, who has begotten the child.

    8

    8. As rightly pointed out on behalf of the petitioner, there is nothing in Rule 74 of the the Maharashtra Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1961, which would .

    disentitle a woman, who has attained motherh P ood through the surrogacy procedure to maternity . leave. Rule 74 provides for maternity leave H to a femalegovernment employee. We do not find anything in Rule 74 which disentitles the petiti f one r to maternity

    leave, like any other female government servant,

    only because she has attaine o d motherhood through

    the route of surrogac r y proc edure. It is worthwhile tonote that by the Govternment Resolution dated28.07.1995, ma u ternity leave is not only provided to anatural mo o ther but is also provided to an adoptivemother, who adopts a child on its birth. The onlyreas C on for refusing maternity leave to the petitioneris that there is nothing in the Government h Resolution, dated 28.07.1995 for providing maternityleave to the mother who begets the child through

    ig

    surrogacy. If theGovernment Resolution, dated28.07.1995 provides maternity leave to an adoptive H

    mother, it is difficult to gauge why maternity leave should be refused to the mother, who secures the child through surrogacy. In our view, there cannot beany distinction whatsoever between an adoptivemother that adopts a child and a mother that begets a child through a surrogate mother, after implanting

    an embryo in the womb of the surrogate mother. In

    our view, the case of the mother who begets a child

    through surrogacy procedure, by implanting an

    embryo created by using either the eggs or sperm of

    9

    the intended parents in the womb of the surrogate mother, would stand on a better footing than the case of an adoptive mother. At least, there cannot be .

    any distinction between the two. Right to life un P der Article 21 of the Constitution of India include . s the right to motherhood and also the right of every child to full development. If the govern f me nt H can providematernity leave to an adoptive mother, it is difficult to digest the refusal on the p o art of the Governmentto provide maternity leav t e to a mother who begets achild through the surrogacy procedure. We do notfind any propriety in the action on the part of the Joint Director u of Hrigher Education, Nagpur, ofrejecting t o he claim of the petitioner for maternityleave. The action of the respondent Nos. 1 to 3 isclea C rly arbitrary, discriminatory and violative of thepr ovisions of Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of h India. It is useful to refer to the unreported judgmentof the Delhi High Court in the case of Rama Pande

    ig vs.Union ofIndia, andrelied on by thelearnedcounsel for the petitioner, in this regard." H 7. Similar reiteration of law can be found in the judgment rendered by the learned Single Judge of the Chhattisgarh High Court in Devshree Bandhe versus

    Chhattisgarh State Power Holding Company Limited and others 2017 Labour Industrial Cases 1506 wherein it was held as under:

    10

    "22.According to Shorter Oxford English Dictionary (Fifth Edition), "maternity" means (1) the quality or condition of being a mother; motherhood and (2) P the .qualities or conduct characteristic of a mother; motherliness. According to other Oxford E . nglish

    Dictionaries, "maternity" means motherh H ood. 23. According to Black's Law Dictionary (Eighth Edition), "maternity" means the sta f te or condition of

    being a mother, espec iall o y a biological one;motherhood.

    24. Maternity means r th t e period during pregnancyand shortly afte u r the child's birth. If maternity meansmotherhood, it would not be proper to distinguishbetween o a natural and biological mother and amother who has begotten a child through surrogacy. Th e C object of maternity leave is to protect thedignity of motherhood by providing for full and h healthy maintenance of the woman and her child. g

    Maternity leave is intended to achieve the object of i

    ensuring social justice to women. Motherhood andchildhood both require special attention. Not only are H

    the health issues of the mother and the child considered while providing for maternity leave but the leave is provided for creating a bond of affectionbetween the two.

    25. Right to life under Article 21 of the Constitution of India includes the right to motherhood and also the right of every child to full development.

    26. The Supreme Court in Lakshmi Kant Pandey (AIR 1984 SC 469) (supra) while expanding the scope of

    11

    right to life held that right to life includes the right to motherhood and also the right of every child to full development, and observed as under: - .

    "6. ... Children are a "supremely impor P tant national asset" and the future well-being . of the nation depends on how its children grow and develop. The great poet Milton put it admirably when he said: "Child sho f ws t H he man asmorning shows the day" and th e Study Teamon Social Welfare said m o uch to the same effectwhen it observed that "the physical and mentalhealth of the nation is determined largely bythe manner in which it is shaped in the early stages". The child is a soul with a being, a

    nature and cap r acit t ies of its own, who must behelped to u find them, to grow into theirmaturity, into fulness of physical and vitalenerg o y and the utmost breadth, depth andheight of its emotional, intellectual andspiritual being; otherwise there cannot be a C healthy growth of the nation. ..." 27 . In Municipal Corporation of Delhi (AIR 2000 SC h 1274, paras 30 and 35) (supra), the question beforethe Supreme Court was whether female workers

    ig

    working in muster roll in the Corporation are entitledfor maternity benefit at par with regular employees H

    under theprovisions of theMaternity Benefit Act, 1961. The Supreme Court noticed the constitutional provisions contained in Articles 38, 39, 42 and 43 ofthe Constitution of India and Sections 2 and 5 of theMaternity Benefit Act, 1961 as well as Article 11 of the "Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of

    Discrimination against Women" adopted by the

    United Nations on 18-12-1979 and held that female

    workers working in muster roll are entitled to all

    12

    benefits conceived under the Maternity Benefit Act, 1961. It was observed as under: - .

    "33. ... To become a mother is the most natural phenomenon in the life of a woman. Whatever is needed to facilitate the birth of child tPo a woman who is in service, the emp H loyer h.as tobe considerate and sympathetic towards herand must realise the physical f diffi culties whicha working woman would face in performing herduties at the work place while carrying a babyin the womb or while rea o ring up the child afterbirth. ..."

    38. These prin r cipl t es which are contained inArticle 11, reproduced above, have to be readinto the contract of service between theMunicipal u Corporation of Delhi and the womenemployees (muster roll); and so read theseempl o oyees immediately become entitled to allthe benefits conceived under the MaternityBenefit Act, 1961. We conclude our discussion C by providing that the direction issued by the Industrial Tribunal shall be complied with bythe Municipal Corporation of Delhi by h

    approaching the State Government as also theCentral Government for issuing necessary g

    notification under the proviso to sub- section i

    (1) of Section 2 of the Maternity Benefit Act,1961, if it has not already been issued. In themeantime, the benefits under the Act shall be H

    provided to the women (muster roll) employees of the Corporation who have been working with them on daily wages." 8. Article 42 of the Constitution of India reads asunder:

    "42. Provision for just and humane conditions of work and maternity relief:- The State shall make provision for securing just and humane conditions of work and for maternity relief."

    13

    9. It was long felt that the working women were unable to depute their time towards their children due to .

    exigencies of service. Hence, the concept of grant of . cPhild care leave was introduced to ensure the w e H lfare of thechild so as to enable the mother to avail f child care leavewhenever she feels that the child ne ed o s the care. This is intune with the international cov t enants and treaties towhich India is a signatory.

    r

    10. As rightly held u by the Bombay High Court, the object of the mater o nity leave is to protect the dignity ofmotherhood by providing for full and healthy maintenance to the woma n C and her child. Maternity leave is intended to

    achieve h the object of ensuring social justice to women.

    iMog therhood and childhood both require special attention. H11.Not only are the health issues of the mother and the child considered while providing for maternity leave, but the leave is provided for creating a bond of affectionbetween the two. To distinguish between a mother who begets a child through adoption and a natural mother, who

    gives birth to a child, would result in insulting womanhood

    and the intention of a woman to bring up a child begotten

    14

    through adoption. Motherhood never ends on the birth of the child and a commissioning mother cannot be refused

    .

    paid maternity leave. A woman cannot be discriminated P , as far as maternity benefits are concerned, only on the g.round that she has obtained the baby through adop tio H n. A newly born child cannot be left at the mercy of ot f hers as it needs rearing and that is the most crucia t l p er o iod during which thechild requires care and atte r ntion of his mother. Thetremendous amount of learning that takes place in the first year of the baby's lif o e, th u e baby learns a lot too. A bond ofaffection has also to be developed.

    12. In vi C ew of the aforesaid discussion, we find meritin this h petition and the same is accordingly allowed andord g er of recovery dated 08.02.2021 (Annexure P-7) isq i uashed. The respondents are directed to sanction/grant

    H maternity leave to the petitioner in terms of Rule 43(1) of the CCS (Leave) Rules, 1972 and treat the same as serviceperiod. Pending application, if any, also stands disposed of.

    13. However, before parting, we make it clear that this judgment is being rendered in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, more particularly, in the background that the child that was adopted on 11.03.2020,

    15

    was born on 25.02.2020 i.e. only 15 days old at the time of adoption. It is for this reason that we have not gone into

    .

    the constitutional validity of the Notification . da P ted07.03.2012 (Annexure PA-1) whereby the benefits of Section 43 of the CCS (Leave) Rules, 1972, have bee f n wit H hdrawn. (Ta rl o ok Singh Chauhan) Judge r t (Satyen Vaidya) Judge

    29th September, 2021.

    (krt)

    u

    C

    o

    ig h

    H

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    DR. PRATIBA HIMRAL v. STATE OF HP AND ORS
    (Sep 29, 2021)