JUDGMENT AND ORDER ( ORAL )
Heard Mr. D. R. Gogoi, learned counsel for the petitioners and Mr. B. Sarma, learned Additional Public Prosecutor, Assam for the opposite party No.1. Also heard Mr. S. C. Biswas, learned counsel for the opposite party No.2/informant.
2) By the judgment and order dated 08.06.2007, passed in G.R. Case No. 1703/2005 arising out of Tezpur Police Station Case No. 787/2005, the learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sonitpur, Tezpur convicted the petitioners under Sections 147/325 of the IPC and sentenced them to suffer Simple Imprisonment for two months under Section 147 IPC and also to suffer Simple Imprisonment for ten months with fine of Rs. 1,000/- each, in default of payment of fine to suffer Simple Imprisonment for further one month under Section 325 IPC, where both the sentences to run concurrently.
3) Against the same, the petitioners preferred an appeal being Criminal Appeal No. 23(S- 3)/2007 and the learned Additional Sessions Judge (FTC), Sonitpur, Tezpur by the judgment and order dated 15.05.2012 dismissed that appeal, upheld the judgment and order dated 08.06.2007, passed by the learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sonitpur, Tezpur in G.R. Case No. 1703/2005.
4) Being aggrieved with the same, the petitioners have preferred this criminal revision petition.
5) Prosecution's case, in short is that in the morning of 02.10.2005 around 6:30 am when a flock of hen entered into the house of the PW-3, informant/victim, namely, Sri Niranjan Das @ Mantu Das and spoiled his paddies, rice, dal etc., as well as some other crops, being annoyed with that while he chased those hens out, he also rebuked some persons and at that point of time, the petitioners armed with bamboo in their hands entered
2
into the house of the informant and assaulted him on various parts of his body including forehead and severely injured him and on intervention of their neighbours, Kajal Debnath, Dilip Kalita, Babul Debnath and Kamal Mudi, the victim was saved from the accused persons.
6) To prove the accusations, prosecution examined 8 witnesses on its behalf including the Medical Officer, who examined the victim as well as the concerned Police Officer, who investigated the case.
7) It is seen that PW.2, Dilip Kalita, neighbour of the victim and the accused persons was declared hostile by the prosecution. PW.3, Niranjan Das @ Mantu Das is the victim and informant of the case, PW.4, Alaka Debnath, neighbour of the victim, PW.5, Bimala Das is the mother of the victim, PW.6, Kajal Debnath another neighbour of the victim and brother of PW.1, Babul Debnath, PW.7, Dr. G. M. Das is the Medical Officer, who examined the victim and PW.8, Tilak Saharia is the concerned Investigating Officer of the case. It is seen that PWs. 4 and 6 did not see the incident, but they saw the victim lying on the ground with injuries on his person.
During his cross examination PW.8, Investigating Officer of the case stated that PW.3 the victim/informant as well as PW.5 did not state before him the names of the accused persons nor the said victim stated before him that those accused persons assaulted him with lathi. Said PW.8 also stated that mother of the victim, did not state before him that the victim was pulled out of his house and that accused Sudhan assaulted the victim by iron rod or gave blow on his forehead. It is only PW.1, a neighbour of the victim and an independent witness in his evidence deposed that as some flock of hen entered into the house of the informant/victim and spoiled his paddy and other crops, for which said victim/informant became agitated and while chasing those hens out from his house, he rebuked some persons and then, the accused persons came to the place of occurrence with sticks in their hand and an altercation took place between the victim/informant and the accused persons, in which the victim was beaten up by the accused persons. PW.1 stated that he then intervened between both the parties and saved the victim. In his cross examination, PW.1 stated that the sticks that were used by the accused persons in the incident were branches of some tree, which were about 3 feet long and that the incident occurred in the road, in front of the house of the
3
victim.
8) PW.7, the concerned Medical Officer who examined the victim on the date of the incident, deposed that he found the injuries of (i) tenderness of right hip joint and its X-ray showed fracture of neck and right femur and (ii) abrasion on the left side of forehead. He also deposed that the injury No. (i) was grievous whereas injury No. (ii) was simple. Said Doctor further deposed that the injuries were found to be fresh and caused by blunt object, within 0- 6 hours of his examining the victim.
9) The evidence led by the prosecution goes to show that all the accused persons were present at the place of occurrence during the time of the incident and also committed the offence of assault on the victim by sticks and blunt object.
10) The prosecution therefore, proved that the accused persons in a common object assaulted the victim/informant and injured him and thereby proved the ingredients of Section
147 IPC of committing riot.
11) By examining the Medical Officer and proving the medical reports including the X-ray of the victim, the prosecution proved that the victim had tenderness on his right hip joint, where his X-ray report reflected fracture on the neck on his right femur and abrasion on left side of his forehead.
12) Section 320 of the IPC relates to grievous hurt, Clause 7 of Section 320 stipulates fracture or dislocation of a bone or tooth as one of the ingredient of grievous hurt, whereas Section 325 of the IPC relates to punishment for voluntary causing grievous hurt. From the evidence of PW.1 as well as PW.7, the prosecution proved that the accused persons voluntarily caused grievous hurt to the victim/informant of the incident.
13) Mr. Gogoi, learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that all along the victim and the accused persons lived in the neighbourhood peacefully and that on the date of the incident, without any pre-meditation or any intention, in a sudden fight, the victim sustained the injuries noted above.
14) Mr. Gogoi for the petitioners further submitted that there was no animosity between the victim and the accused persons either prior to the incident or thereafter. Both Mr. B. Sarma, learned Additional Public Prosecutor as well as Mr. S. C. Biswas, learned counsel for
4
the victim/informant also admitted the fact that there was no hostility between the victim and the accused persons prior to the incident and that the incident occurred when the victim chased out the hens who spoiled his paddy and other crops, he rebuked some persons and at that stage the accused persons came to the place of occurrence stating that the said flock of hen belong to them and thereafter a commotion took place between the victim/informant and the accused persons in which the victim was beaten up by the accused persons.
15) Mr. Gogoi, learned counsel further submitted that since there is no enmity between the victim and the accused persons and they are living peacefully all along as neighbours to each other separated by a road, therefore, some leniency should be considered towards the conviction and punishment imposed upon the accused persons, converting the same to a fine.
16) Section 147 of the IPC relates to punishment for rioting and it reads as follows:--
"147. Punishment for rioting.— Whoever is guilty of rioting, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both."
17) Section 325 IPC relates to punishment for voluntary causing grievous hurt, which reads as follows:--
"325. Punishment for voluntarily causing grievous hurt.—Whoever, except in the case provided for by section 335, voluntarily causes grievous hurt, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to seven years, and shall also be liable to fine."
18) The punishment for commission of crime under Section 325 IPC prescribes imprisonment for 7 years and fine and compoundable by the person to whom hurt is caused with the permission of the Court.
19) Mr. Biswas, leaned counsel appearing for the victim/informant admitted the fact that both the victim and the accused persons are neighbours and prior to the incident noted above, they lived peacefully and no such untoward incident occurred between them nor there was any animosity between them and till date, both victim/informant as well as the accused persons are living peacefully in their neighbourhood/locality.
20) From the perusal of the record, the Court did not find any illegality with the impugned order of conviction and sentence dated 08.06.2007, passed in G.R. Case No.1703/2005 arising out of Tezpur Police Station Case No. 787/2005 passed by learned Additional Chief
5
Judicial Magistrate, Sonitpur, Tezpur convicting the accused persons under Sections 147/325 IPC and also with the appellate judgment dated 15.05.2012 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge (FTC), Sonitpur, Tezpur in Crl. Appl. No.23(S-3)/2007.
21) It is well settled that the idea behind compounding the offence is that the law is meant to do justice and not to force the parties for a protracted litigation, as there is no requirement for a mock trial, when the parties have settled their disputes and want to live peacefully. It is true that no such heinous crime can be compounded.
22) After hearing the learned counsels for the parties, considering the entire matter and on the submission of Mr. Biswas, learned counsel appearing for the victim, the punishment of Simple Imprisonment for two months under Section 147 IPC is hereby converted to a fine of Rs.2,500/- payable by the each of the accused persons under Section 147 IPC. Further, the punishment to suffer Simple Imprisonment for ten months with fine of Rs.1,000/- each under Section 325 IPC, imposed upon the accused petitioners under Section 325 IPC is hereby compounded with an exemplary cost of Rs. 2,500/- payable by each of the accused persons. The accused persons shall now deposit an amount of Rs. 5,000/- each as punishment under Sections 147/325 IPC before the learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sonitpur, Tezpur in said G.R. Case No. 1703/2005 on or before 31.03.2020.
23) On depositing the said fine Rs. 5,000/- each by the accused petitioners noted above, the learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sonitpur, Tezpur shall disburse the said amount to the respondent No.2, victim/informant, as victim compensation under Section 357 of the CrPC, on proper identification of the said victim.
24) With the above observation and direction this revision petition is allowed to the extent indicated above.
25) Registry shall return the LCRs along with copies of this judgment and order.
JUDGE
6