Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order I Rule 10 of Page 4 of 8 the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order I Rule 10 of Page 4 of 8 the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners, third party applicants, filed a petition under Article 227 of the Constitution challenging the order dated 15th April, 2015 passed by the 16th Additional Senior Civil Judge, Surat, which rejected their application to be joined as parties in Special Civil Suit No.540 of 2013. The original plaintiffs (respondents Nos.1 and 2) instituted the suit against the original defendants (respondents Nos.3 and 4) for declaration, permanent injunction, and specific performance related to a sale agreement dated 5th February, 2012 concerning land at Village Umra, District Surat.

The petitioners claimed to have paid a substantial part of the sale consideration jointly with the plaintiffs for the suit land and sought to be impleaded as defendants in the suit. Their application to be joined as parties was opposed by both the original plaintiffs and defendants and was ultimately rejected by the trial court. The petitioners apprehended collusion between the original parties that might prejudice their rights. An agreement dated 15th May, 2013 between the petitioners and one of the plaintiffs recognized the petitioners' contribution towards the purchase consideration and their interest in the suit property.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioners, who claim to have contributed substantially towards the consideration for the suit property, are entitled to be joined as parties in the suit under Order I Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908?
  2. Whether the petitioners have a direct and legal interest in the subject matter of the suit sufficient to justify their impleadment as necessary and proper parties?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners contributed a substantial part of the sale consideration jointly with the plaintiffs for the purchase of the suit land.
  • They have an agreement with one of the plaintiffs recognizing their interest and contribution towards the property.
  • There is a valid apprehension that if the original parties collude or compromise, the petitioners' rights may be defeated.
  • They therefore seek to be impleaded as parties to protect their legal interest in the suit property.

Opposition by Original Plaintiffs and Defendants

  • The original plaintiffs and defendants opposed the impleadment application, contesting the petitioners' entitlement to be joined as parties.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Razia Begum v. Sahebzadi Anwar Begum [AIR 1958 SC 886] Parameters for applying Order I Rule 10 CPC for addition of parties; a party must have a direct interest (not merely commercial) in the subject matter. Confirmed that petitioners have a subsisting direct interest in the suit property, justifying impleadment.
Sumtibai v. Paras Finance Co. Regd. Partnership Firm Beawer (Raj.) [(2007) 10 SCC 82] Distinction between proper and necessary parties; a third party with semblance of title or interest must be impleaded. Distinguished from Kasturi case; held petitioners have more than a semblance of interest and thus are necessary and proper parties.
Kasturi v. Iyyamperumal [(2005) 6 SCC 733] Third party without any title or interest cannot be impleaded in a suit for specific performance. Clarified that this applies only where third party has no semblance of title; not applicable here as petitioners have legal interest.
Vinodkumar Mansukhlal Kanaiya v. Vasuben @ Vasantben Vinodlukar (Special Civil Application No.11516 of 2009) Joining a party does not prejudice plaintiffs; merits of right need not be examined at impleadment stage. Supported the view that petitioners should be joined without examining the merits of their claim at this stage.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the nature of the petitioners' interest in the suit property, particularly focusing on the agreement dated 15th May, 2013, which acknowledged the petitioners' contribution to the purchase consideration and their share in the property until repayment. The Court noted that the petitioners have a direct and legal interest in the suit property, which creates a lis between them and the plaintiffs.

Applying the principles from the cited precedents, the Court distinguished cases where third parties had no interest and emphasized that even a semblance of legal interest entitles a party to be impleaded. The Court held that the petitioners are necessary and proper parties because their presence is essential for an effective decree and to protect their rights. The Court also observed that the merits of the petitioners' claim need not be examined at this stage.

Accordingly, the Court concluded that the trial court erred in rejecting the petitioners' application for impleadment.

Holding and Implications

The impugned order dated 15th April, 2015 is set aside, the application Exh.19 is allowed, and the petitioners shall be joined as party defendants in Special Civil Suit No.540 of 2013.

The direct effect of this decision is that the petitioners, having demonstrated a legal interest in the suit property, will participate as parties in the ongoing litigation. No new precedent was established beyond the application of settled principles regarding impleadment of parties with a direct interest in the subject matter.

    MAHESHBHAI JIVRAJBHAI VAGHANI v. HIMATBHAI MANJIBHAI DAYANI

    C/SCA/8691/2015 CAV JUDGMENT

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD

    R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8691 of 2015

    FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:

    HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE N.V.ANJARIA

    ==========================================================

    1 Whether Reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment ? Yes

    2 To be referred to the Reporter or not ? Yes
    3 Whether their Lordships wish to see the fair copy of the judgment ? No

    4 Whether this case involves a substantial question of law as to the interpretation of the Constitution of India or any No

    order made thereunder ?

    ==========================================================

    MAHESHBHAI JIVRAJBHAI VAGHANI

    Versus

    HIMATBHAI MANJIBHAI DAYANI

    ========================================================== Appearance:

    MR P P MAJMUDAR(5284) for the PETITIONER(s) No. 1,2 DECEASED LITIGANT(100) for the RESPONDENT(s) No. 1 DS AFF.NOT FILED (N)(11) for the RESPONDENT(s) No. 1.4 MR. KRUNAL K MODI(7321) for the RESPONDENT(s) No. 1.1,1.2,1.3,2 NOTICE SERVED BY DS(5) for the RESPONDENT(s) No. 3,4 ==========================================================

    CORAM: HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE N.V.ANJARIA

    Date : 31/07/2018

    CAV JUDGMENT

    Heard learned advocate Mr.Shashvat shukla for learned advocate Mr.P.P. Majmudar for the petitioners and learned advocate Mr.Krunal Modi for the respondents.

    Page 1 of 8

    2. The present petition filed under Article 227 of the Constitution is filed by the petitioners-the third party applicants in which the petitioners have challenged order dated 15thApril, 2015 passed by learned 16thAdditional Senior Civil Judge, Surat below Exh.19 in Special Civil Suit No.540 of 2013. Thereby the application of the petitioners to be joined as parties in the proceedings of the aforesaid suit came to be rejected.

    3. The attendant facts may be noted. The respondent Nos.1 and 2-the original plaintiffs instituted Special Civil Suit No.540 of 2013 against respondent Nos.3 and 4-the original defendants. The suit was for declaration, permanent injunction and the relief for specific performance. In the said suit instituted on 22ndOctober, 2013, the case of the plaintiffs was inter alia that the defendants had executed the sale agreement dated 05thFebruary, 2012 in favour of the plaintiffs and had accepted part of sale consideration with regard to the suit land bearing Block No.43 situated at Village Umra, District Surat. It was alleged that the defendants failed to perform their part of contract. Application Exh.5 was also filed in the said suit.

    3.1 The present petitioners who want to be impleaded as party defendants in the suit, are the persons who have paid substantial part of the consideration along with the plaintiffs in respect of purchase of the very land bearing Block No.43 at Umra. In the agreement to sell dated 05thFebruary,

    Page 2 of 8

    2012, this third party applicants were shown to be the contributors of the amount of consideration. An agreement in this regard was also entered into by the applicants, which is adverted to for its details in the subsequent paragraphs.

    3.2 The petitioners filed application Exh.19 to pray before the court below to permit them to be joined as parties. It was the case and the apprehension by the petitioners expressed in the said application that if the original plaintiffs and the original defendants colluded with each other to arrive at a compromise, it would defeat the rights of the petitioners. The application to be joined as parties filed by the petitioners came to be contested by the original plaintiffs by filing reply at Exh.30. The original defendants also opposed the prayer by filing reply at Exh.34. The prayer of the petitioners came to be rejected as per the impugned order and they were not allowed to be joined as parties.

    4. Looking at the status of the petitioners - third party applicants who claimed to be interested in the subject matter and the outcome of the suit, their interest in the subject matter land is discernible from agreement dated 15thMay, 2013. This agreement is executed between the petitioners herein on one hand and one of the original plaintiffs Himmatbhai on the other hand. It is provided in the said agreement that the suit land was agreed to be purchased by the petitioners as well as the plaintiffs for a consideration of Rs.01,58,21,000/-

    Page 3 of 8

    per Vigha and that the present petitioners had paid towards the said consideration Rs.01,09,15,488/-. Towards this total amount, part of the amount to the tune of Rs.58.00 lakhs has been paid to them and for the rest of the amount, as the agreement stipulates, the petitioners would have share in the land property transacted under agreement to sell dated 05th February, 2012. It is provided in the agreement that thus in the suit property, petitioners have their share until the amount contributed by them is paid back to them for which certain conditions are mentioned in the agreement.

    4.1 From the aforesaid agreement between the plaintiff No.1 and the petitioners, it is revealed that the petitioners are the contributors in the consideration paid towards the purchase of the suit land. In that way, they acquire direct interest in the suit property. Agreement dated 15thMay, 2013 can be said to be creating a lis for the petitioners in respect of the suit subject matter and the suit controversy. The case of the petitioners was that if the original plaintiffs and the original defendants hobnobbed with one another, their interest would be duped, for, they have paid substantial part of the consideration, could be said to be valid apprehension. In any view, clear interest of the petitioners in the suit was shown.

    5. In Razia Begum v. Sahebzadi Anwar Begum [AIR 1958 SC 886], the Supreme Court held, while laying down the parameters for applying Order I Rule 10 of

    Page 4 of 8

    the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 for addition of the parties, inter alia that in a suit relating to property in order that a person may be added as a party, he should have a direct interest as distinguished from a commercial interest in the subject matter of litigation. In the facts of the present case, it could not be gainsaid that there was a subsisting interest of the petitioners in the subject matter and their claim for joining has a basis of assertion of legal right for imleadment.

    5.1 If the party seeking to be impleaded himself has direct concern and interest in the subject matter and in the outcome of the proceedings, he ought to have been joined as party. It is well settled that necessary party is one without whose presence effective decree cannot be passed, whereas the proper party is one whose presence would facilitate the Court to pass decree.

    5.2 In Sumtibai v. Paras Finance Co. Regd. Partnership Firm Beawer (Raj.) [(2007) 10 SCC 82] the Court inter alia examined the concept of proper and necessary party. In that case opposing the impleadment, the decision of the Apex Court in Kasturi v. Iyyamperumal [(2005) 6 SCC 733] was relied on by the respondent to submit that it was held in that case that in a suit for specific performance of a contract for sale of property, a stranger or a third party to the property cannot be added as defendant in the suit.

    5.3 Sumatibai (supra) subtly distinguished

    Page 5 of 8

    Kasturi (supra) wherein it was observed that Kasturi (supra) was a decision which was to be understood to mean that a third party cannot be impleaded in a suit for specific performance if he has no semblance of title in the property in dispute. It was observed that a busybody or interloper with no semblance of title cannot be impleaded since such impleadment would protract the proceedings. In Sumatibai (supra), the registered sale deed dated 12thAugust, 1960 by which the property was purchased, showed that the shop in dispute was sold in favour of not only one Kapoor Chand but also his sons. It prima facie appeared clear that the purchaser of the property in dispute was not only Kapoor Chand but also his sons, therefore it was held that it could not be said that sons of Kapoor Chand have no semblance of title or interest and that they are mere busybodies. The Court held that where a third party showed some semblance of title or interest in the property in dispute, such third party ought to have been impleaded.

    5.4 In yet another decision in Vinodkumar Mansukhlal Kanaiya v. Vasuben @ Vasantben Vinodlukar Kanaiya being Special Civil Application No.11516 of 2009 decided by this Court on 02ndApril, 2014, it was observed that mere joining a party to the suit proceedings itself would not prejudice to the case of the plaintiffs. It was observed that merits of the right or enforceability of the right of the party seeking to be impleaded was not required to be examined at that stage.

    Page 6 of 8

    6. Swiftly re-visiting with the facts of the present case, as noted above, there was an agreement between the petitioners-third party and plaintiffs in respect of the very property which became subject matter of the suit. The present petitioners were the contributors in consideration payable who had agreed to purchase the very property by parting with substantial amount towards consideration. There was an understanding reached between them and the plaintiffs in the said agreement agreed that plaintiffs would return the money else they would acquire proportionate share in the property, as they had paid towards consideration along with the plaintiffs.

    6.1 The nature of the document and the nature of rights flowing for the petitioners therefrom could be said to be creating a lis between the petitioners and the plaintiffs. In a suit relating to the very property which was subject matter of the aforesaid agreement between the petitioners and the plaintiffs, it could hardly be denied that the petitioners have interest, much more than a semblance of interest in the suit property. Even a semblance of legal interest would entitle a party to be impleaded. The petitioners, therefore, have to be held as necessary and proper party, entitled to be joined in the proceedings of the suit, for, they can be well said to be interested in the suit proceedings.

    7. In light of the foregoing discussion and reasons, impugned order dated 15thApril, 2015 passed

    Page 7 of 8

    by learned 16thAdditional Senior Civil Judge, Surat, below application Exh.19 in Special Civil Suit No.540 of 2013 is hereby set aside. The application Exh.19 stands granted and the third party applicants shall stand joined as party defendants in the Special Civil Suit No.540 of 2013.

    The petition is allowed.

    (N.V.ANJARIA, J)

    Anup

    Page 8 of 8

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    MAHESHBHAI JIVRAJBHAI VAGHANI v. HIMATBHAI MANJIBHAI DAYANI
    (Jul 31, 2018)