ORAL ORDER
Heard learned advocate Mr.Jaimin Dave for the petitioner, learned Assistant Government Pleader Mr.Manan Mehta for respondent Nos.1 and 2, and learned senior advocate Mr.Anshin Desai assisted by learned advocate Mr.Parth Bhatt appearing on caveat on behalf of respondent No.3.
2. The challenge in the present petition is directed against order dated 28thDecember, 2017 passed by the Secretary, Revenue Department (Appeals), Ahmedabad - respondent No.1 herein. Thereby the revisional authority dismissed Revision Application No.112 of 2017 preferred by the petitioner herein, and maintain order dated 20th March, 2017 of the Collector, Ahmedabad.
Page 1 of 12
2.1 The Collector had in turn upheld order of the Deputy Collector, Daskroi Prant, dated 18thMarch, 2015 whereby confirmed was the certification of Mutation Entry No.8219 in the revenue records and it was observed that decision which may be rendered in Special Civil Suit No.917 of 2011 shall bind the parties.
3. The dispute dealt with by the revenue authorities pertained to Mutation Entry No.8219. The Entry was in respect of land bearing Block No.484 situated at Bopal, Taluka Daskroi, which was made in the revenue records pursuant to the sale deed executed in favour of respondent No.3 herein. The petitioner objected to the Entry by preferring Appeal No.41 of 2012 before the Deputy Collector which came to be dismissed on 18thMarch, 2015. The Revision Application filed thereagainst was dismissed by the Collector on 20thMarch, 2017. It was thereafter that the Revision Application was filed before the Special Secretary ending up with the impugned order.
3.1 The registered sale deed was executed by respondent No.4 Association on 30thOctober, 2010 in respect of the land property in favour of respondent No.3 herein. The present petitioner and one Nalinbhai Vadilal Mehta stood aggrieved and raised objections to the Mutation Entry recorded pursuant to the said sale transaction. The Mamlatdar, Daskroi treated the Entry as disputed to register Takrari Case No.110 of
2011.
3.2 The petitioner claimed that he was member of
Page 2 of 12
respondent No.4 Devpuri Owners Association - the vendor in the transaction, a non-trading association, whereas said Nalinbhai putforth that his capacity was that of the President of respondent No.4 - Association. Their case was that the Secretary and other office bearers of the Association colluded with respondent No.3 to sell off the land to respondent No.3 without knowledge and intimation. It was the objection that they were maintaining share and interest in the property and that they were kept in dark about the transaction despite they had holding of abovesaid status in the aforesaid non-trading corporation. It was their case that by forging their signatures, the sale was fraudulently executed.
3.3 Seeking to answer the objections, the case of the rival side was that said Nalinbhai Mehta had resigned from the Association on 18thAugust, 1998 and took away his share contribution from the Association, that the Secretary of the said Association was authorised by Resolution No.3 and thus effected the sale competently; it was stated the petitioner herein was an ex-member of the Association, who had already ceased to be the member on 18thAugust, 1998. The Mamlatdar, Daskroi, overruled the objections and passed order dated 09th December, 2011 certifying the Mutation Entry.
3.4 In order to maintain the sequence of narration of events, it has to be noted at this stage that while the Mamlatdar passed order on 09th December, 2011 rejecting the objections, in
Page 3 of 12
September, 2011, the petitioner herein instituted Special Civil Suit No.917 of 2011 before the Court of Principal Senior Civil Judge, Ahmedabad, wherein respondent Nos.3 and 4 herein are the defendants. In the said suit, it was pleaded that respondent No.4 - Devpuri Owners Association was a non-trading corporation which had ceased in its existence when the sale deed was executed, as the Non-Trading Corporation Act was repealed, that the plaintiffs were the members and had interest in the property, that the Chairman and Secretary of the Association acted collusively to execute the sale deed illegally. This suit is pending.
3.5 Coming back to the orders passed by the revenue authorities, the order of the Mamlatdar dated 19thDecember, 2011 was challenged before the Deputy Collector by the petitioner by filing Appeal No.41 of 2012 under Rule 108(5) of the Gujarat Revenue Rules. The Deputy Collector dismissed the appeal and upheld the certification of the Mutation Entry, and observed in his order that outcome of the aforementioned Special Civil Suit No.917 of 2011 would be binding to the parties. Thereafter Revision Application No.430 of 2015 was filed before the Collector which was dismissed on 25thMarch, 2017. The Collector also observed making the Entry subject to the suit. It was against the said order of the Collector that the Revision Application came to be filed before the Secretary, Revenue Department - respondent No.1 herein, to culminate into the impugned order.
Page 4 of 12
4. Learned advocate for the petitioner with his commendable clarity in the submissions, raised three main contentions. He firstly submitted that the seller - respondent No.4 Devpuri Owners Association which acted through its Chairman and Secretary - respondent Nos.4.1 and 4.2, was a non-trading association and that the Non-Trading Corporation Act was repealed with effect from 25thFebruary,2005. It was submitted that when sale transaction in favour of respondent No.3 by respondent No.4 was conveyed, the law having been repealed, respondent No.4 did not have its existence in eye of law to be clothed with the capacity to execute the sale deed. The second limb of the submission was that the sale was collusive and fraudulent and that the office bearers of respondent No.4 hobnobbed with the respondent No.3 to execute the sale transaction in which, it was submitted, the petitioners had their share. Thirdly it was submitted, without prejudice to the earlier two contentions, that though the civil suit was pending for setting aside the sale deed, the operative portion of the order of the revisional authority did not make any clarification that the Mutation Entry had to remain subject to the outcome of the civil suit.
4.1 As far as the contention that the sale deed was fraudulent and illegal, learned advocate for the petitioner in his submissions elaborated the same grounds on which Special Civil Suit No.917 of 2011 was founded. He submitted that when the sale deed was fraudulent, Mutation Entry could not have been made.
Page 5 of 12
He placed reliance on the observations of the Supreme Court in paragraph 14 of decision in Vishwa Vijay Bharati v. Fakhrul Hassan [(1976) 3 SCC 642], to submit that presumption of the correctness of the Entry can apply only when the sale transaction on which it is based is genuine and not forged or fraudulent.
4.2 In order to substantiate his contention about repeal of Non-Trading Corporation Act, learned advocate for the petitioner relied on certain observations in paragraph 2 of order dated 08th August, 2013 of this Court in Appeal From Order No.189 of 2013. Responding to the submission about repeal of 1959 Act, learned advocate for the petitioner relied on Section 2 of the Bombay Non- Trading Corporation (Gujarat Repeal) Act, 2005 to submit that according to the said Section, provision of Section 7 of the Bombay General Clauses Act, 1904 shall apply in relation to the repeal of the 1959 Act, whereafter drew attention of the Court to Section 7 of the General Clauses Act which deals with the effect of the repeal of any Act and in its sub- clause (c), it provides that when any enactment is repealed, unless a different intention appears, repeal shall not effect any right, privilege, obligation or liability acquire, accrued or incurred under the repealed enactment.
4.3 Learned senior counsel for the respondent No.3 further submitted that the sale transaction made in favour of respondent No.3 was preceded by a public
Page 6 of 12
notice in newspaper and a title-clearance certificate obtained for the same. He submitted that the civil suit is pending where legality and validity of the sale deed is the subject matter to be decided. It was further emphasised that the Mutation Entry was made on the basis of the registered sale transaction.
4.4 Learned senior advocate for the respondent No.3 relied decision of this Court in Chhimiben wd/o.Hirabhai Gopalbhai v. State of Gujarat [2006 (3) GLR 2455] in which case Mutation Entry was made on the basis of unprobated Will and civil suit challenging the Will was pending before the civil court. The Court held that when the suit was pending before the civil court, the revenue authority was not required to adjudicate the identical issue. He supported his submission further by pressing into service the decisions in Sitaram Sugars and Allied Industries Limited v. Baroda Central Co-operative Bank Limited [2016 (2) GLR 1102], in Hemant Kantibhai Patel v. State of Gujarat [2016 (3) GLH 65] and other judgments.
5. Having gone through the facts and the impugned order and having further considered the rival submissions, it has to be observed that any revenue Entry in the revenue records does serve only purpose of having fiscal value. Mutation Entry is reflection of record of the transaction in relation to any property taking place between the parties. The revenue Entries are for maintaining of record in the governmental books in respect of the transactions
Page 7 of 12
between the parties where the property rights are involved. They themselves do not reflect anything on the property rights or ownership instances of the parties to the transaction.
5.1 In Gandabhai Dalpabhai Patel v. State of Gujarat [2005 (2) GLR 1370] the Court observed that Entry in record of rights has only a presumptive value for the purpose of collection of revenue. It was ruled that in RTS proceedings the revisional authority cannot go into the question such as genuineness of power of attorney or right of the power of attorney to execute sale deed. In paragraph 8, it was held "the questions in relation to genuineness of Power of Attorney and/or authority, and whether the Power of Attorney holder can execute the sale-deed or not, are the questions which are required to be considered by a Civil Court and not in an R.T.S. Proceeding while mutating necessary entry in the record of rights which is only made for fiscal purpose and which does not confer any right, title or interest in favour of a person in whose favour entry is made."
6. Adverting to the facts of the present case, in light of the above well settled principles, the whole objection against Mutation Entry No.8219 is that the sale deed on the basis of which the same was entered into the revenue records was tainted with illegality and was collusive and further that the vendors did not have legal capacity and/or right to execute the sale in favour of respondent No.3. Now as
Page 8 of 12
seen above, this very issue whether the sale deed is valid or not, is a subject matter of adjudication in the Special Civil Suit No.917 of 2011. Further, all the contentions which are sought to be raised to question the transaction of sale in favour of respondent No.3, are the contentions raised in the pleadings of the civil suit. They would be tried on evidence in the trial of the suit. It is not in the domain of the revenue authorities to go into such questions. Nor on the basis of the projected contentions about illegality of the sale deed on whatever ground, the Mutation Entry could be agitated, more particularly as it was based on registered sale transaction.
6.1 When the Mutation Entry in question was made in the revenue record with the backing of the registered sale transaction, recording thereof was obligatory. It was not to be an error in any view. It is trite that whenever a registered transaction takes place, it ought to be reflected in form of Mutation Entry and the transaction shall form part of the revenue records as based on the registered document. It is not only the registered sale deed but any registered document that could become basis for validly making the Mutation Entry. This is statutorily contemplated by virtue of Second Proviso to Section 135-C of the Bombay Land Revenue Code, when it says that, any person acquiring a right by virtue of a registered document shall be exempted from the obligation to report to the designated officer.
Page 9 of 12
6.2 The principle that the designated officer is enjoined in law to make the Mutation Entry when the basis shown is a registered sale transaction, is underlined and reiterated in Jhaverbhai Savjibhai Patel through P.O.A. Holder Ashok J. Patel v. Kanchaben Nathubhai Patel [2005 (3) GLR 2233]. In
Balvantrai Ambaram Patel v. State of Gujarat being
Special Civil Application No.5464 of 2014 decided on 08thMay, 2014 this Court in paragraph 6 stated that in all cases of claims for mutation based on a registered document, the competent officer has to be entered the name of the claimant-owner-right holder. The authority cannot insist for observing the requirements of Section 135-D apriori and on that basis declined to enter the name in the revenue records. The designated officer in charge of the said function has no jurisdiction to disregard the legal effect of the registered document, and he cannot be permitted to do so even indirectly. It was emphasised that once the petitioner purchased the land in question by virtue of registered sale deed, he is entitled to have his name mutated in the revenue records.
6.3 In Dudhiben Muljibhai Patel v. State of Gujarat being Special Civil Application No.758 of 1997, decided on 26thFebruary, 2016 the principle of requirement of exercise of powers by the authorities within reasonable time was reiterated, to observe that it is trite principle that an entry in the revenue record has to follow to be mutated when the transaction is by a registered document. It was held
Page 10 of 12
that question of following procedure of Section 135D of the Bombay Land Revenue Code would not arise when a transaction is by a registered deed. Such transaction cannot be disputed by the revenue authority unless the competent civil court annuls the same.
6.4 Dealing with the last contention of the petitioner that in the operative part of the order of the revisional authority, it is not mentioned that the Entry in question would remain subject to outcome of the civil suit, this submission was based on realism in law. It is true that the Entry which has only fiscal value, will always remain subject to the outcome of the decision in the civil proceedings before the civil court where the parties would seek to establish civil titular rights. While countenancing this submission, it has to be however noticed that the Deputy Collector and the Collector both while dismissing respective Appeal and the Revision before them, observed on this score that the Mutation Entry shall remain subject to outcome of the pending Civil Suit No.917 of 2011. Though the revisional authority has not expressly observed the same fact when it confirm orders of the revenue authorities below, the observations made by the Deputy Collector and Collector deemed to have been continued and the order of the revisional authority would be read accordingly only.
6.5 Notwithstanding this, it is observed, clarified and directed that Mutation Entry No.8219
Page 11 of 12
shall remain subject to the decision which may be rendered in the civil proceedings in form of Special Civil Suit No.917 of 2011. Though the orders of the revenue authorities and the revisional authority are upheld by this judgment, the aforesaid observations and directions shall continue to operate.
7. For the discussion preceded and the reasons recorded, however subject to the aforesaid limited observations and qualifications stated, the challenge in this petition to the order of the revisional authority is devoid of merits and was not liable to be entertained. The petition is dismissed accordingly.
(N.V.ANJARIA, J)
Anup
Page 12 of 12