1. This Petition is filed by Mrs. Rizwana Anjum, Petitioner herein under Section 59 of the Companies Act, 2013 read with Rule 70 of NCLT Rules, 2016, seeking the following reliefs:—
(i) To declare the impugned transfer of 2250 shares of Rs. 100/- each made in favour of 2 Respondent as null and void.
(ii) Directions to bring back 2250 shares of Rs, 100/- each in favour of the Petitioner which were not shown in favour of petitioners and which were held by the Petitioner in addition to 2250 shares.
(iii) Directions to 1 Respondent Company to rectify the Register of Members with respect to 4500 shares in favour of Petitioner.
(iv) Directions to Registrar of Companies, 11 Respondent to invalidate the Annual Returns, Form No. 20B, Form MGT-7, Financial Statements, Form No. 23AC & Form 23 ACA and Form AOC-4 filed after 31.03.2004 to till date.
(v) An order for payment of costs for the present proceedings
(vi) To grant such other reliefs as this Tribunal may deem fit, just and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case and in the interest of justice.
2. The averments in the Petition are that the Respondent No. 1 Company i.e. M/s Hira Multi Construction Ventures Private Limited (CIN. U45209TG1998PTC029125) (herein referred to as the “Company”) has been incorporated on 26.03.1998 under the name and style of M/s Hira Management Consultants Private Limited under the provisions of Companies Act, 1956 and the name was subsequently changed to M/s Hira Multi Construction Ventures Private Limited on 13.03.2013 and fresh certificate of incorporation was issued by the Registrar of Companies, Hyderabad.
3. It is averred that the Company is into the business of construction and allied activities and the same are set out in the Memorandum of Association of the 1 Respondent Company.
4. The Petitioner i.e. Mrs Rizwana Anjum was allotted 2500 shares in the 1 Respondent Company and the same has been reflected in the Annual Return for the year 2003. In the year 2004, another 2250 shares were transferred in favour of the Petitioner from one Mr. Sujha Shareef through Board Resolution dated 16.10.2004, but the same has not been effected in the subsequent Annual Returns i.e. 2006, 2007 and 2008 filed with the Registrar of Companies, Hyderabad. To the utter shock of the Petitioner, the shareholding of the Petitioner is shown as NIL in the Annual Returns filed for the years 2009 to 2018.
5. The Petitioner states that she has neither sold her shares to anyone nor any consideration received for transfer of shares held by her and that no request was made to the 1 Respondent Company about her intention to sell shares. The same was done fraudulently to gain benefit and to have control over the management of the Company. However, she gained knowledge about the impugned transfer when 2250 of her shares was transferred to Ms. M. Ayesha Hadi Ali, the 2 Respondent herein and the remaining 2250 shares were not reflected in the Annual Returns filed with RoC.
6. It is contended that the 1 Respondent Company failed to follow any of the procedures and compliances of the Companies Act with regard to transfer of shares besides Articles 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24 & 25 of the Articles of Association of the Company.
“16 - Shares cannot be transferred except to a person agreed to by a majority of the Board of Directors as being a fit and proper person to hold such shares.
17 - Any person becoming entitled to any share in consequence of the death, lunacy, bankruptcy or insolvency of any member by lawful means other than by a transfer in accordance with these articles, may with other the consent of the Board of Directors (which it shall not be under any obligation to give) upon producing such evidence that he sustains the character in respect of which he proposes to act under these Articles or of his title as the Board of Directors shall require, either be registered as a member in respect of such shares or elect to have some person nominated by him and approved by the Board of Directors registered as a member in respect of such shares, provided nevertheless that if such person shall elect to have his nominee registered, he shall testify his election by executing in favour of his nominee an instrument of transfer in accordance with the provisions herein contained and until he does so, he shall not be free from any liability in respect of such shares.
18- Subject to the provisions of Articles 16 and 22 hereof, no share shall be transferred to any person so long as any person selected by the Directors is willing to purchase the same at its fair value.
19 - The person proposing to transfer any share (hereinafter called the proposing transferor) shall give notice in writing to the Company that he desires to transfer the same. Such notice may specify the sum he fixes as the sale value and shall constitute the company as his agent for transferring the shares to any member of the company or a person selected as aforesaid at the fair value to be ascertained as provided hereunder. The transfer notice may include several shares and in such case shall operate as if it were a separate notice in respect of each. The transfer notice shall not be revocable except with the sanction of the Board of Directors.
20 - If the Company shall, within the space of twenty eight days after being served with such notice, find a member or person selected as aforesaid, it shall give notice thereof to the proposing transferor and he shall be bound, upon payment of the fair value to transfer the shares to the purchasing member or members.
21- The Company shall, at its general meeting, determine the fair value of shares for this purpose and the said fair value shall be in force unless otherwise altered according to the procedure stated above.
22- If in case the proposing transferor, after having become bound as aforesaid, makes default in transferring the shares to the proposing transferee, the company may hold the purchase money in trust for the proposing transferor. The receipt of the Company of the purchase money shall be a good discharge to the purchasing member and after his name has been entered in the Register in purported exercise of the aforesaid power the validity of the proceedings shall not be questioned by any person.
23- If the Company does not within the space of 28 days after being served with a transfer notice, find a member or person selected as aforesaid willing to purchase the shares, and give notice in the manner aforesaid, the proposing transferor shall at any time within three calendar months thereafter be at liberty to sell and transfer the shares to any person and at any price. If no action has been taken by either party within that the entire proceedings shall be treated as cancelled and fresh notice and procedure as aforesaid should be followed once again in case the transfer is desired.
24- Subject to the provisions of Articles 16 and 22 hereof, the Board of Directors may refuse to register any transfer of a share:
(a) Where the share is not fully paid up:
(b) Where the company has lien on the share or
(c) Where the result of such registration would be to make the number of members exceed the limit set out in Article 2 above. But clause (c) of the Article shall not apply where the proposed transferee is already a member.
25- A fee not exceeding two rupee may be charged for each transfer, to be paid both the Registration thereof.
7. According to the Petitioner, the impugned transfer of shares is fraudulent and illegal, more so because the Directors and Shareholders failed to follow the procedure as laid down under Section 108 of the Companies Act, 1956.
8. It is averred that Petitioner vide letter dated 27.09.2019 had requested the 1 Respondent Company to get back the 4000 shares in her favour and rectify the Register of members as per provisions of 59 of Companies Act to which the Petitioner received reply dated 14.10.2019 from 1 Respondent which indicated that the Petitioner was allotted with 2250 shares and that the Petitioner herself sold 2250 shares to Ms. Ayesha Hadi, the 2 Respondent herein, which according to the Petitioner is false. Thus, submitting the Petitioner filed this petition under Section 59 of the Companies Act and further relied on Rule 70 of NCLT Rules, 2016.
9. The Petitioner furnished a copy of her letter dated 27.09.2019 to the Registrar of Companies, Hyderabad for remedial action on 14.10.2019 but of no avail. It is stated that the Annual Return filed with the Registrar of Companies for the year 2008-2009 reveals that Dr. Fakruddin Mohammed and others were the Directors of the 1 Respondent Company and that the Company never called for any Board Meeting to consider the requests of any shareholders regarding transfer of shares. The Company also failed to comply Article 21 of the Articles of Association with respect to issuance of notice for convening the General Meetings for determining the fair value of shares. The Petitioner asserts that the Company and the other Respondents have fraudulently transferred the shares to take control of the management of 1 Respondent Company.
10. It is alleged that though Dr. Fakruddin Mohammed has not resigned from the directorship of the Company, yet the 1 Respondent Company has filed Form No. 32 with Registrar of Companies by fraudulently annexing forged resignation letters along with Form No. 32 and further states that she is in the process of filing criminal cases for the fraudulent acts of the Respondent No. 2 and other Directors.
11. Respondents 1-10 has filed a common counter, inter-alia, contending that.
12. That the Petition deserves to be dismissed as the Petitioner has approached this Tribunal with unclean hands and without any cause of action.
13. The averments in the Petition do not fall within the ambit of Section 59 of the Companies Act, as such the same is not maintainable.
14. The Petitioner herself has as per rules and procedures transferred her shareholding to Respondent No. 2 for a valid consideration in the year 2009. The Petitioner having admitted that the alleged transfer of shares was effected by Respondent No. 2 without her knowledge in the year 2009, the present petition having been filed in the year 2019 i.e. after a delay of 10 years, is barred by limitation by virtue of section 433 of the Companies Act, read with Article 137 of the Limitation Act and that the record indicates that the Petitioner has not filed any application seeking condonation of the delay.
15. That on 02.01.2009, the Petitioner vide her letter dated 02.01.2009 had expressed her intention to transfer her 2250 shares in the Respondent No. 1 Company to the 2 Respondent for a total consideration of Rs. 2,25,000/- and consequently she signed the Share Transfer Form in favour of the 2 Respondent and the said transaction was consented in the General Body Meeting held on 02.01.2009 and on furnishing the Share Certificate a valid entry in the Register of Members/Share Ledger of the Respondent No. 1 Company was made according to the Articles of Association and the Rules and the original share certificate was handed over to the 2 Respondent. The same has been reflected in the Annual Returns of the Company for the Annual year 2009-2010 and the Petitioner had not objected to it at any point earlier.
16. That since the Petitioner has raked up serious charge of fraud, conspiracy and forgery in the petition this Tribunal under the provisions of Section 59 of the Companies Act has only summary jurisdiction and that the Petitioner has to approach appropriate forum for the remedy.
17. Though the Petitioner claim that the shares were transferred without her knowledge, she had failed to produce a copy of the Share Certificate which was initially issued to her for the shares she claimed to hold.
18. That the Respondent Company deny having transferred 2250 shares to the Petitioner without her knowledge as alleged in the year 2004 as the record do not indicate any such transfer in favour of the Petitioner.
19. The Respondents deny the averments as stated in para 6.4 of the Petition and submits that the procedure enumerated under Section 108 of the Act was adhered to for effecting the transfer of shares and the Petitioner is trying to stall the development process.
20. The Respondents contend that the Petitioner failed to comply with the provisions of Rule 70 of NCLT Rules and the petition suffers from technical infirmities.
21. That Dr. Fakhruddin Mohammed and Mr. Waheeduddin Azmi have resigned as Directors wef 22.03.2010 and Form 32 was accordingly submitted to ROC. At no point did the Petitioner object to the alleged fraud in the last 10 years. It is averred that the Company has complied with all the provisions of the Companies Act with regard to transfer of shares and as such the instant petition is not maintainable for the reasons stated supra.
22. The Petitioner filed rejoinder to the counter, reiterating the averments in the Petitioner, and stated as under : -
23. That the Petitioner never had neither any intention to sell her shares to a third party nor informed the 1 Respondent Company with regard to the same and contends that it has been done fraudulently.
24. The Petitioner had neither signed any transfer deed with regard to transfer of shares to the 2 Respondent nor received any consideration.
25. The Petitioner being a shareholder has not received notice of AGM, EOGM and that the Respondents violated Section 171 & 172 of the Companies Act, 1956 and Section 101 of the Companies Act, 2013.
26. The Petitioner reiterates that she gained knowledge about transfer of shares only after verification of the Annual Return filed with Respondent No. 11 for the year 2018-2019, as such the cause of action is well within the limitation period. Further it is stated that the Petition is maintainable on the ground that the alleged offence committed by the Respondents is from the year 2009 and continued till 2019 and as such the limitation with regard to the offence is continuing die in diem under Section 111A of the Companies Act, 1956 as well as under Section 59 of the Companies Act, 2013. To buttress her case on the maintainability aspect, she has relied on the following judgments:—
(i) Hon'ble NCLAT in Company Appeal (AT) No. 334 of 2018 wherein the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of “Shashi Prakash Khemka v. NEPC Micon was referred to.
“NCLT would now clearly have jurisdiction to deal with rectification and all questions including incidental and peripheral questions raised with regard to rectification for the purpose of deciding legality of the rectification. What could earlier be looked into to see if prima facie made out can now be considered if proved to justify rectification even if it was to be said to be complicated question.
(ii) Hon'ble NCLT in the case of “Chalasani Udaya Sankar v. Lexus Technologies Private Limited, wherein it is held as under:—
“….limitation is a question of fact and law. Therefore, it needs to be examined at the final hearing of the case after parties file all their documents”.
27. In response to the contention raised by the Respondents that the Petitioner herself expressed her intention vide letter dated 02.01.2009 to transfer her 2250 shares in the Company to Respondent No. 2 for a total consideration of Rs. 2,25,000/- which transaction is approved in the General Body Meeting held on 02.01.2009, the Petitioner submits that the Respondent have only placed on record a sheet indicating share ledger “Register of Members and Share Ledger” as Exhibit-19 (Page 19 of their counter) which according to the Petitioner has no authenticity at all and was an afterthought after issuance of notice by the Petitioner. Further the Respondents have failed to place on record the letter dated 02.01.2009 purported to have signed by the Petitioner indicating her intention to transfer the shares in favour of the 2 Respondent.
28. In support of her averment that this Tribunal has the jurisdiction to entertain the Petition, the Petitioner has relied on Section 430 of the Companies Act, 2013. The Petitioner further relied on the Hon'ble NCLAT, New Delhi judgment in the matter of MAIF Investments, wherein it is held as under:—
The effect of the aforesaid provision is that in matters in respect of which power has been conferred on the NCLT, the jurisdiction of the civil court is completely barred,
It is not in dispute that were a dispute to arise today, the civil suit remedy would be completely barred and the power would be vested with the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) under Section 59 of the said Act, we are conscious of the fact that in the present case, the cause of action has arisen at a stage prior to this enactment. However, we are of
the view that relegating the parties to civil suit now would not be the appropriate remedy, especially considering the matter in which Section 430 of the Act is widely worded.
We are thus of the opinion that in view of the subsequent developments, the appropriate course of action would be to relegate the appellants to remedy before the NCLT under the Companies Act, 2013.
29. The Petitioner further reiterates that despite requesting Respondent 2 to 10 several times, the Respondent No. 1 company has failed to hand over the share certificates to the Petitioner except showing a copy of the Annual Returns prior to the year 2009.
30. The Respondents filed additional counter, inter-alia, contending as under:
31. As per the Register of Members and Shares Ledger, 9880 shares of Rs. 100 each were issued to 25 shareholders on 08.08.1999. Subsequently on 10.08.1999 additional shares of 56200 were allotted to 28 shareholders and the total paid up capital as on 10.08.1999 stood at Rs. 66,10,000/- divided into 66,100 shares of Rs. 100 each.
32. The Company has consolidated the multiple share certificates of each shareholder by issuing one new share certificate stating the total no. of shares held by each shareholder with the new share distinctive numbers.
33. In the year 2006, all the shareholders decided to sell off the company and distribute the sale proceeds among themselves as per their shareholding and a buyer was approached in Financial Year 2006-2007 but as the negotiations failed, the shareholders offered to purchase the shares of other shareholders and a decision was reached. Consequently, Respondent No. 3 and his family members offered to purchase the shares of other shareholders and take over the Company. As a result, the following Directors resigned from the Company on 29.03.2007.
(i) Mr. Shaikh Salim Zubedi.
(ii) Mr. Mohammed Abdul Azeem
(iii) Mr. Mohammed Farooq
(iv) Mr. Mohammed Abdul Khadeer
(v) Mr. Mohammed Rafiuddin
(vi) Mr. Mohammed Mustafa Khan
34. It is stated that on January 2, 2009, 25 shareholders sold their shares and transferred their shares to the other 3 shareholders and 5 of their family members.
35. It is further submitted that on June 22, 2010 there was internal transfer of shares between the 8 shareholders and to one new shareholder.
36. That the company was incorporated on March 26, 1998 with the following persons as the first Directors of the Company:
i). Mr. Shaik Salim Zubedi
ii). Dr. Fakhruddin Mohammad
iii). Mr. Mohammed Abdul Azeem
iv). Mr. Mohammed Farooq
v). Mr. Mohammed Abdul Khadeer
vi). Mr. Waheeduddin Azmi
vii). Mr. Rafeeq Ahmed
viii). Mr. Habeeb Abdul Razzaq Baghdadi
37. It is stated that out of the above first Directors, Mr. Rafeeq Ahmed resigned on 11.02.1998. Mr. Mohammed Rafiuddin and Mr. Mohammed Mustafa Khan were appointed as Directors of the Company on August 16, 1998.
38. The Petitioner submitted that further, the below mentioned 6 Directors have resigned on March 23, 2007:
i). Mr. Shaik Salim Zubedi
ii). Mr. Mohammed Abdul Khadeer
iii). Mr. Mohammed Rafiuddin
iv). Mr. Mohammed Mustafa Khan
v). Mr. Mohammed Abdul Azeem
vi). Mr. Mohammed Farooq
39. It is also stated that Mrs. Khatija Begum and Mr. Mohammed Hadi Ali were appointed as Directors on February 1, 2007 and March 23, 2007 respectively and they have resigned on December 29, 2016 and June 8, 2019 respectively. The company had filed the Form 32/DIR 12 for the changes in Directors with MCA. 5.9. That Mr. Habeeb Umer was appointed as Director on May 7, 2015 and presently he along with Mr. Habeeb Abdul Razzaq Hadi Ali Albaghdadi are the Directors of the company.
DETAILS OF SHARES ISSUED/ALLOTTED ON AUGUST 8, 1999
Distincti ve No's S. NO. Name of the Shareholder Folio No From To No of Shares - Alotted on 08.08.1999 1 Shaik Salim Zubedi 1 21 520 500 2 Mohammed Abul Azeem 2 521 1020 500 3 Mohammed Rafiuddin 3 1021 1520 500 4 Dr. Fakhruddin Mohammed 4 1521 2510 990 5 Md. Waheeduddin Azmi 5 2511 3010 500 6 Mohammed Farroq 6 3011 3500 490 7 Habib Abdul Razaq Albaghdadi 7 3501 4000 500 8 Mohammed Khaza Muneruddin 8 4001 4500 500 9 Mohammed Abdul Khadeer 9 4501 5000 500 10 Mohammed Mustaffa Khan 10 5001 5500 500 11 Khatija Begum 11 5501 6000 500 12 Syed Ibrahim Ahmed 12 6001 6500 500 13 Mohammed Moizur Rahman 13 6501 7000 500 14 Mohammed Abdul Kareem 14 7001 7500 500 15 Habeeb Ali Baghdadi 15 7501 8000 500 16 Shuja Mohammed Sheriff 16 8001 8500 500 17 Rizwana Anjum 17 8501 8600 100 18 Huda Baghdadi 18 8601 9100 500 19 Dr. Mohammed Abdul Raheem 19 9101 9300 200 20 MST. Mohammed Abdul Raheem 20 9301 9400 100 21 Dr. Mohammed Iftekharuddin 21 9401 9500 100 22 Moin Ahmed 22 9501 9600 100 23 Lal Jan Basha 23 9601 9700 100 24 Rasheed Yar Khan 24 9701 9800 100 25 Dr. Yusuf Azman 25 9801 9900 100 TOTAL 9,880
DETAILS OF SHARES ISSUED/ALLOTTED ON AUGUST 10, 1999 TOTAL SHARES HELD ON AUGUST 10, 1999
Sl. No Name of the Shareholder No. of Shares allotted on 10.08.1999 No. of shares allotted on 08.08.1999 Subscrip tion shares TOTAL No. of shares allotted as on 10.08.1999 1 Shaik Salim Zubedi 3,000 500 3,500 2 Mohammed Abul Azeem 3,500 500 4,000 3 Mohammed Rabiuddin 3,200 500 3,700 4 Dr. Fakhruddin Mohammed 2,600 990 10 3,600 5 Md. Wahedduddin Azmi 3,500 500 4,000 6 Mohammed Farroq 2,500 490 10 3,000 7 Habib Abdul Razaq Albaghdadi 3,500 500 4,000 8 Mohammed Khaza Muneruddin 2,550 500 3,050 9 Mohammed Abdul Khadeer 3,200 500 3,700 10 Mohammed Mustaffa Khan 2,050 500 2,550 11 Khatija Begum 3,500 500 4,000 12 Syed Ibrahim Ahmed 2,000 500 2,500 13 Mohammed Moizur Rahman 3,500 500 4,000 14 Mohammed Abdul Kareem 1,750 500 2,250 15 Habeeb Ali Baghdadi 2,250 500 2,750 16 Shuja Mohammed Sheriff 1,750 500 2,250 17 Rizwana Anjum 2,150 100 2,250 18 Huda Baghdadi 1,500 500 2,000 19 Dr. Mohammed Abdul Raheem 1,800 200 2,000 20 MST. Mohammed Abdul Raheem 1,400 100 1,500 21 Dr. Mohammed Iftekharuddin 900 100 1,000 22 Moin Ahmed 900 100 1,000 23 Lal Jan Basha 400 100 500 24 Rasheed Yar Khan 900 100 1,000 25 Dr. Yusuf Azman 150 100 250 26 Dr. Md. Abdul Mateen 250 - 250 27 Md. Ziauddin Nayyar 500 - 500 28 Firasat Ali 1,000 - 1000 56,200 9,880 66,100
DETAILS OF CONSOLIDATION OF SHARE CERTIFICATES ON JUNE 1, 2004
S. No. Name of the Shareholder No. of shares 1 Shaik Salim Zubedi 3,500 2 Mohammed Abul Azeem 4,000 3 Mohammed Rafiuddin 3,700 4 Dr. Fakhruddin Mohammed 3,600 5 Md. Waheeduddin Azmi 4,000 6 Mohammed Farroq 3,000 7 Habib Abdul Razzaq Albaghdadi 4,000 8 Mohammed Khaza Munieruddin 3,050 9 Mohammed Abdul Khadeer 3,700 10 Mohammed Mustaffa Khan 2,550 11 Khatija Begum 4,000 12 Syed Ibrahim Ahmed 2,500 13 Mohammed Moizur Rahman 4,000 14 Mohammed Abdul Kareem 2,250 15 Habeeb Ali Baghdadi 2,750 16 Shuja Mohammed Sheriff 2,250 17 Rizwana Anjum 2,250 18 Huda Baghdadi 2,000 19 Dr. Mohammed Abdul Raheem 2,000 20 MST. Mohammed Abdul Raheem 1,500 21 Dr. Mohammed Iftekharuddin 1,000 22 Moin Ahmed 1,000 23 Lal Jan Basha 500 24 Rasheed Yar Khan 1,000 25 Dr. Yusuf Azman 250 26 Dr. Md. Abdul Mateen 250 27 Md. Ziauddin Nayyar 500 28 Firasat Ali 1,000 66,100
DETAILS OF TRANSFER OF SHARES ON JANUARY 2, 2009
S. No Name of the Shareholder No. of Shares TRANSFEROR 1 Habib Abdul Razzak Albaghdadi 3,700 Mohammed Rafiuddin 3,500 Shaik Salim Zubedi 4,000 Md. Waheeduddin Azmi 4,000 Own Shares 4,000 Mohammed Farroq 2 Khatija Begum 4,000 Own Shares 2,500 Syed Ibrahim Ahmed 3,700 Mohammed Abdul Khadeer 3,050 Mohammed Khaja Munenuddin 3 Huda Baghdadi/Huda Hadi Ali 2,000 Own Shares 3,600 Dr. Fakhruddin Mohammed 4,000 Mohammed Moizur Rahman 4 Habib Umer Hadi Ali 2000 Dr. Mohammed Abdul Raheem 1,500 MST. Mohammed Abdul Raheem 500 Mohammed Ziauddin Nayyar 1,000 Firasat Ali 5 Mohammed Hadi Ali 2,550 Mohammed Mustafa Khan 2,250 Mohammed Abdul Kareem 2,750 Habib Ali Baghdadi 2,250 Shuja Mohammed Shariff 6 Ameen Hadi Ali 1,000 Rasheed Yaar Khan 250 Dr. Yusuf Azam 250 Dr. Md. Abdul Mateen 7 Ms. M. Ayesha Hadi Ali 4,000 Mohammed Abdul Azeem 2,250 Mrs. Rizwana Anjum 8 Abdul Rahman Hadi Ali 1,000 Dr. Mohammed Iftekharuddin 1,000 Moin Ahmed 500 Lal Jan Basha 66,100
DETAILS OF TRANSFER OF SHARES ON JUNE 22, 2010 - (within the family members)
S. No Name of the Shareholder Total No. of Shares % HOLDING 1 Habib Abdul Razzak Albaghdadi 20,491 31% 2 Khatija Begum 13,220 20% 3 Mohammed Hadi Ali 4,627 7% 4 Huda Baghdadi/Huda Hadi Ali 4,627 7% 5 Ms. M Ayesha Hadi Ali 4,627 7% 6 Habib Umer Hadi Ali 4,627 7% 7 Abdul Rahman Hadi Ali 4,627 7% 8 Ameena Hadi Ali 4,627 7% 9 Habeeb Abdullah 4,627 7% 66,100 100%
40. It is contended that the Petitioner sold her shares for total sale consideration of Rs. 4,52,450/- on 08.08.2006 through chq No. 513330 and Rs. 50,000/- through Chq No. 513348 on 09.08.2006 in lieu of her 2250 shares but transferred them on 02.01.2009 by way of a transfer deed and the said documents are kept in the bank locker by the Respondent and is inaccessible as the Respondents are out of the Country in Riyadh and undertook to produce the same at a later date before this Tribunal, which fact is well within the knowledge of the Petitioner. The Respondents vehemently contend that since a plea of “fraud” has been taken by the Petitioner, the appropriate forum is civil court.
41. It is stated that the relief of cancellation of the sale deeds vis-à-vis, the Companies Act is not available as per Section 31 of the Specific Relief Act.
42. The Respondents are alleging collusion of M/s Kancharla Constructions Pvt Ltd who are the developers and has entered into the Development Agreement GPA as per the Registered Document No. 3600/2016 dated 29.04.2016, 4843/2016 and 6365/2016 dated 24.05.2016 and the said agreements were cancelled by issuing a notice dated 01.06.2018 by the Petitioner through her Advocate.
43. That Arbitration Proceedings are pending before the Civil Courts vide CMA 61 & 62 of 2020 before the X Addl. Chief Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad. M/s. Kancharla Constructions (P) Ltd., has filed further cases with respect to the respondent No. 2 company as well, before this Hon'ble NCLT. The details of the cases pending are as follows:—
S. No Case No. Petitioner U/Section of Companies Act 1 CP No. 767/59/2019 Mr. Waheeduddin Azmi 59 2 CP No. 776/59/2019 Mohammed Abdul Azeem 59 3 CP No. 778/59/2019 Mrs. Rizwana Anjum 59 4 CP No. 786/59/2019 Mohd. Ziauddin Nayyar 59 5 CP No. 787/59/2019 Mohd. Abdul Raheem Abdul Azeem 59 6 CP No. 790/59/2019 Mohammed Abdul Kareem 59 7 CP No. 761/59/2019 Dr. Fakhruddin Mohammed 59 8 CP. No. 222/59/2020 Habeeb Ali Baghdadi 59
44. In response to para 4 (a) of the Rejoinder, the Respondents contends that although there is no written intimation to sell the shares, but there were telephonic calls between the parties.
45. In response to para 4 (b) to (k), the Respondents deny the averment of the Petitioner that she had no intention to sell the shares and that she has not signed on transfer deed.
46. The response to the Petitioner's contention that she has not received any notice of Annual General Meeting, EOGM at any point of time, the Respondents submit that the Petitioner was one of the Directors of the Company at relevant point of time and all the appropriate notices have been given to all the shareholders under the statutory compliance u/s. 171, 172 of Companies Act, 1956 and S. 101 of Companies Act, 2001.
47. The petitioner purposefully did not specify the date of knowledge in the para under reply. The date of knowledge put as 2019 is vague and bald of necessary particulars.
48. The Respondents contend that it is a baseless averment that the Petitioner gained knowledge about the transfer of shares from annual general returns filed in 2019 and disagree with the contention of the Petitioner that there is continuous cause of action and continuous die in diem and to state that the petition is within limitation is baseless.
49. The judgments cited by the counsel for the petitioner are not applicable to the present facts of the case.
50. In the light of the contest as above the points that emerge for consideration are:
(1) Whether it is true that the Petitioner never intended to transfer Petitioner's shares in favour of 2 Respondent and the transfer of Petitioner's shares in favour of the 2 respondent is illegal, fraudulent and contrary to the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956? If so, whether the petitioner is entitled for a declaration and direction to rectify the register of members and the other consequential reliefs as prayed?
(2) Whether the Company Petition is barred by Limitation?
51. We have heard Shri M.S. Prasad, learned senior counsel assisted by Shri Venkat Rami Reddy and Shri Parameswara Reddy, Advocates for the petitioner and Shri Jagadeesh Advocate for the 1 respondent, Shri S. Ravi, learned senior counsel assisted by Shri Sharad Sanghi, Advocate for respondents 2-10, perused the record and the case law.
Point 1.
Whether it is true that the Petitioner never intended to transfer Petitioner's equity shares in favour of 2nd Respondent and the transfer of Petitioner's shares in favour of the 2nd respondent is illegal, contrary to the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956 besides fraudulent? If so, whether the petitioner is entitled for a declaration and direction to rectify the register of members and the other consequential reliefs as prayed?
52. Learned senior counsel for the petitioner Shri. MS Prasad, submits that the above Company Petition has been filed by the Petitioner claiming, inter alia, that she was a shareholder of 1 respondent/Company having 2250 equity shares and without her consent and by playing fraud the 2 respondent herein, in the year 2009, got 2250 shares held by her transferred in her name, said illegal and fraudulent act of the 2 respondent in the year 2019.
53. Learned senior counsel further contends that that the respondents have falsely claimed that on 22.03.2010 Dr. Fakhruddin Mohammed has resigned as Director of the 1 respondent/Company and asserted that the said claim is false as he never resigned as director of the 1 respondent/company. It is also contended that the petitioner was unaware of Form-32 purportedly submitted to the Registrar of Companies and that the same is invalid and unenforceable.
54. According to the learned senior counsel for the Petitioners until the year 2019 the Petitioner was not at all aware of the fraudulent transfer of her shares in favour of 2 respondent and immediately upon coming to know about the same in the month of September i.e. on 27.09.2019 the Petitioner sent a letter to the 1 respondent asserting categorically that she never intended to sell her shares and the claim that she had sold 2250 equity shares to 2 respondent and executed Share Transfer Form dated 02.01.2009 besides the letter confirming the sale of his 2250 equity shares.
55. Ld. Sr counsel contended that Articles 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24 and 25 of the Articles of Association of the 1 respondent Company, which are mentioned below are completely violated by the respondents.
“16. Shares cannot be transferred except to a person agreed to by a majority of the Board of Directors as being a fit and proper person to hold such shares.
17. Any person becoming entitled to any share in consequence of the death, lunacy, bankruptcy or insolvency of any member by lawful means other than by a transfer in accordance with these articles, may with other the consent of the Board of Directors (which it shall not be under any obligation to give) upon producing such evidence that he sustains the character in respect of which he proposes to act under these Articles or of his title as the Board of Directors shall require, either be registered as a member in respect of such shares or elect to have some person nominated by him and approved by the Board of Directors registered as a member in respect of such shares, provided nevertheless that if such person shall elect to have his nominee registered, he shall testify his election by executing in favour of his nominee an instrument of transfer in accordance with the provisions herein contained and until he does so, he shall not be free from any liability in respect of such shares.
18. Subject to the provisions of Articles 16 and 22 hereof, no share shall be transferred to any person so long as any person selected by the Directors is willing to purchase the same at its fair value.
19. The person proposing to transfer any share (hereinafter called the proposing transferor) shall give notice in writing to the Company that he desires to transfer the same. Such notice may specify the sum he fixes as the sale value and shall constitute the company as his agent for transferring the shares to any member of the company or a person selected as aforesaid at the fair value to be ascertained as provided hereunder. The transfer notice may include several shares and, in such case, shall operate as if it were a separate notice in respect of each. The transfer notice shall not be revocable except with the sanction of the Board of Directors.
20. If the Company shall, within the space of twenty-eight days after being served with such notice, find a member or person selected as aforesaid, it shall give notice thereof to the proposing transferor and he shall be bound, upon payment of the fair value to transfer the shares to the purchasing member or members.
21. The Company shall, at its general meeting, determine the fair value of shares for this purpose and the said fair value shall be in force unless otherwise altered according to the procedure stated above.
22. If in case the proposing transferor, after having become bound as aforesaid, makes default in transferring the shares to the proposing transferee, the company may hold the purchase money in trust for the proposing transferor. The receipt of the Company of the purchase money shall be a good discharge to the purchasing member and after his name has been entered in the Register in purported exercise of the aforesaid power the validity of the proceedings shall not be questioned by any person.
23. If the Company does not within the space of 28 days after being served with a transfer notice, find a member or person selected as aforesaid willing to purchase the shares, and give notice in the manner aforesaid, the proposing transferor shall at any time within three calendar months thereafter be at liberty to sell and transfer the shares to any person and at any price. If no action has been taken by either party within that the entire proceedings shall be treated as cancelled and fresh notice and procedure as aforesaid should be followed once again in case the transfer is desired.
24. Subject to the provisions of Articles 16 to 22 hereof, the Board of Directors may refuse to register any transfer of a share:
a) Where the share is not fully paid up:
b) Where the company has lien on the share or
c) Where the result of such registration would be to make the number of members exceed the limit set out in Article 2 above. But clause (c) of the Article shall not apply where the proposed transferee is already a member”.
25. A fee not exceeding two rupees may be charged for each transfer, to be paid before the Registration thereof”.
56. The relevant sections 171, 172 of the Companies Act, 1956 and Section 101 of the Companies Act, 2001 are reproduced hereunder.
Section 171. Members' right to inspect
(1) The register kept under sub-section (1) of section 170,—
(a) shall be open for inspection during business hours and the members shall have a right to take extracts therefrom and copies thereof, on a request by the members, be provided to them free of cost within thirty days; and
(b) shall also be kept open for inspection at every annual general meeting of the company and shall be made accessible to any person attending the meeting.
(2) If any inspection as provided in clause (a) of sub-section (1) is refused, or if any copy required under that clause is not sent within thirty days from the date of receipt of such request, the Registrar shall on an application made to him order immediate inspection and supply of copies required thereunder.
Section 172 : Penalty.
*172. If a company is in default in complying with any of the provisions of this Chapter and for which no specific penalty or punishment is provided therein, the company and every officer of the company who is in default shall be liable to a penalty of fifty thousand rupees, and in case of continuing failure, with a further penalty of five hundred rupees for each day during which such failure continues, subject to a maximum of three lakh rupees in case of a company and one lakh rupees in case of an officer who is in default.
Section 101. Notice of meeting.
(1) A general meeting of a company may be called by giving not less than clear twenty-one days' notice either in writing or through electronic mode in such manner as may be prescribed:
Provided that a general meeting may be called after giving shorter notice than that specified in this sub-section if consent, in writing or by electronic mode, is accorded thereto—
(i) in the case of an annual general meeting, by not less than ninty-five per cent. of the members entitled to vote thereat; and
(ii) in the case of any other general meeting, by members of the company—
(a) holding, if the company has a share capital, majority in number of members entitled to vote and who represent not less than ninety-five per cent. of such part of the paid-up share capital of the company as gives a right to vote at the meeting; or
(b) having, if the company has no share capital, not less than ninty-five per cent. of the total voting power exercisable at that meeting:
Provided further that where any member of a company is entitled to vote only on some resolution or resolutions to be moved at a meeting and not on the others, those members shall be taken into account for the purposes of this sub-section in respect of the former resolution or resolutions and not in respect of the latter.
57. Learned senior counsel submits that the petitioner never received any notice of Board/Annual General Meeting/EGM in the year 2009 or subsequent thereto. No Financial Statements were also received by the petitioner. According to the learned senior counsel the very transfer of shares is illegal and fraudulent as such the same is liable to be set aside and the register of shares of the 1 respondent be amended suitably.
58. Per contra, learned senior counsel for the 2 Respondent submitted that 2250 equity shares of the Petitioner were transferred as petitioner on 02.01.2009 expressed her intention vide letter dated 02.01.2009 to transfer her 2250 shares of first respondent company to the 2 respondent for a total consideration of Rs. 2,25,000/- and accordingly submitted a signed share transfer form marked as Exhibit-R3. Request so made by the petitioner has been approved by the general body in the meeting held on 02.09.2009 in which Resolution was passed, consequently the shares of the petitioner came to be transferred in favour of the 2 Respondent. Sale consideration has been paid vide cheque Nos. 513330 dated 08.08.2006 and Chq No. 513348 on 09.08.2006 and thereupon a valid entry to the said effect has been made in the share ledger, a copy of which also has been filed along with the counter. Therefore, the Petitioner having received sale consideration and has voluntarily sold her 2250 equity shares to the 2 respondent by executing Share Transfer Form marked as Exhibit R/3 is not entitled to question the transfer. The Annual Statements of 1 respondent/Company were uploaded on the website of Ministry from time to time. Placing reliance on the copy of extract of Register of Member and share ledger, the original share certificate folio No. 17 of the petitioner, the original share transfer form of the petitioner issued by the petitioner, Ld. Sr. Counsel submits that the mandatory requirement both in terms of Section 108 of Companies Act as well as the relevant provisions in the Articles of Association of the Company were complied with, hence the Petition is liable to be dismissed.
59. Ld. Counsel Shri Jagadeesh representing the 1 Respondent sailed with the submissions of the Ld. Sr. Counsel Shri S. Ravi.
60. At the outset it may be stated that the procedure of transfer of subject transfer of shares since covered under Section 108 of the Companies Act 1956, we hereby refer to the same which is as below:—
108. Transfer not to be registered except on production of instrument of transfer.
(1) A company shall not register a transfer of shares in, or debentures of, the company, unless a proper instrument of transfer duly stamped and executed by or on behalf of the transferor and by or on behalf of the transferee and specifying the name, address and occupation, if any, of the transferee, has been delivered to the company along with the certificate relating to the shares or debentures, or if no such certificate is in existence, along with the letter of allotment of the shares or debentures : Provided that where, on an application in writing made to the company by the transferee and bearing the stamp required for an instrument of transfer, it is proved to the satisfaction of the Board of directors that the instrument of transfer signed by or on behalf of the transferor and by or on behalf of the transferee has been lost, the company may register the transfer on such terms as to indemnity as the Board may think fit : Provided further that nothing in this section shall prejudice any power of the company to register as shareholder or debenture holder any person to whom the right to any shares in, or debentures of, the company has been transmitted by operation of law.
(1A) Every instrument of transfer of shares shall be in such form as may be prescribed, and-(a) every such form shall, before it is signed by or on behalf of the transferor and before any entry is made therein, be presented to the prescribed authority, being a personal ready in the service of the Government, who shall stamp or otherwise endorse thereon the date on which it is so presented, and
(b) every instrument of transfer in the prescribed form with the date of such presentation stamped or otherwise endorsed thereon shall, after it is executed by or on behalf of the transferor and the transferee and completed in all other respects, be delivered to the company,-(i) in the case of shares dealt in or quoted on a recognised stock exchange, at any time before the date on which the register of members is closed, in accordance with law, for the first time after the date of the presentation of the prescribed form to the prescribed authority under clause (a) or within twelve months] from the date of such presentation, whichever is latter;
(ii) in any other case, within two months from the date of such presentation.
(1B) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1A),- an instrument of transfer of shares, executed before the commencement of section 13 of the Companies (Amendment) Act, 1965, (31 of 1965) or executed after such commencement in a form other than the prescribed form, shall be accepted by a company,-(a) in the case of shares dealt in or quoted on a recognised stock exchange, at any time not later than the expiry of six months from such commencement or the date on which the register of members is closed, in accordance with law, for the first time after such commencement, whichever is later;
(b) in any other case, at any time not later than the expiry of six months from such commencement.
(1C) Nothing contained in sub-sections (1A) and (1B) shall apply to-(A) any share-(i) which is held by a company in any other body corporate in the name of a director or nominee in pursuance of sub-section (2), or as the case may be, sub-section (3), of section 49, or
(ii) which is held by a corporation, owned or controlled by the Central Government or a State Government, in any other body corporate in the name of a director or nominee, or
(iii) in respect of which a declaration has been made to the Public Trustee under section 153B, if-(1) the company or corporation, as the case may be, stamps or otherwise endorses, on the form of transfer in respect of such share, the date on which it decides that such share shall not be held in the name of the said director or nominee or, as the case may be, in the case of any share in respect of which any such declaration has been made to the Public Trustee, the Public Trustee stamps or otherwise endorses, on the form of transfer in respect of such share under his seal, the date on which the form is presented to him, and
(2) the instrument of transfer in such form, duly completed in all respects, is delivered to the-(a) body corporate in, whose share such company or corporation has made investment in the name of its director or nominee, or
(b) company in which such share is held in trust, within two months of the date so stamped or otherwise endorsed; or
(B) any share deposited by any person with-
(i) the State Bank of India, or
(ii) any scheduled bank, or
(iii) any banking company (other than a scheduled bank) or financial institution approved by the Central Government by notification in the Official Gazette (and any such approval may be accorded so as to be retrospective to any date not earlier than the 1 day of April, 1966), or
(iv) the Central Government or a State Government or any corporation owned or controlled by the Central Government or a State Government, by way of security for the repayment of any loan or ad-vance to, or for the performance of any obligation undertaken by, such person, if-(1) the bank, institution, Government or corporation, as the case may be, stamps or otherwise endorses on the form of transfer of such share-(a) the date on which such share is returned by it to the depositor, or
(b) in the case of failure on the part of the depositor to repay the loan or advance or to perform the obligation, the date on which such share is released for sale by such bank. institution, Government or Corporation, as the case may be, or
(c) where the bank, institution, Government or corporation, as the case may be, intends to get such share registered in its own name, the date on which the instrument of transfer relating to such share is executed by it; and
(2) the instrument of transfer in such form, duly completed in all respects, is delivered to the company within two months from the date so stamped or endorsed. Explanation.- Where any investment by a company or a corporation in the name of its director or nominee referred to in clause (A) (i) or clause (A) (ii), or any declaration referred to in clause (A) (iii), or any deposit referred to in clause (B), of this sub-section is made after the expiry of the period or date mentioned in clause (a) of sub-section (1B) or after the expiry of the period mentioned in clause (b) of that subsection, as the case may be, the form of transfer, in respect of the share which is the subject of such investment, declaration or deposit, means the prescribed form; or
(C) any share which is held in any company by the Central Government or a State Government in the name of its nominee, except that every instrument of transfer which is executed on or after the 1 day of October, 1966, in respect of any such share shall be in the prescribed form.]
(1D) Notwithstanding anything in sub-section (1A) or sub-section (1B) or sub-section (1C)], where in the opinion of the Central Government it is necessary so to do to avoid hardship in any case, that Government may on an application made to it in that behalf, extend the periods mentioned in those sub-sections by such further time as it may deem fit whether such application is made before or after the expiry of the periods aforesaid]; and the number of extensions granted hereunder and the period of each such extension shall be shown in the annual report laid before the Houses of Parliament under section 638.]
(2) In the case of a company having no share capital, sub-section (1) shall apply as if the references therein to shares were references instead to the interest of the member in the company.
(3) Nothing contained in this section shall apply to transfer of security effected by the transferor and the transferee both of whom are entered as beneficial owners in the records of a depository.
61. A bare perusal of the above provision discloses that a company shall not register transfer of shares or debentures of the company, unless a proper instrument of transfer duly stamped and executed by or on behalf of the transferor and by or on behalf of the transferee and specifying the name, address and occupation, if any, of the transferee, has been delivered to the company along with certificate relating to the shares or debentures, or if no such certificate is in existence, along with the letter of allotment of the shares or debentures. Therefore, in order to have valid transfer of shares or debentures, an instrument of transfer shall be a proper instrument and duly stamped. Insofar as the case on hand is concerned the Petitioner apart from pleading breach of the mandatory requirements under the Company's Act, as well as under the Articles of Association of the Company in so far as the same relating to transfer of equity shares, the Petitioner denied even intention to transfer her shares and vehemently contended that she has neither handed over her shares certificates nor executed Share Transfer Form and also denied having signed Exhibit R/3-Share Transfer Form besides the undated letter in favour of 2 respondent, which contentions however were denied out rightly by the respondents. Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Mannalal Khetan v. Kedearnath Khetan, (1977) 2 SCC 424, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court had categorically held that the provisions of section 108 of the Companies Act, 1956 are mandatory, therefore, it needs to be seen whether transfer of shares of the Petitioner as done was legal and is in accordance with the above provision law.
62. Here it is pertinent to state that though the Ld. Sr. Counsel for the Petitioner during the course of his oral submissions disputed Exhibit R-3 on the ground that Ex. R-3 was not stamped at all as such the same is per se, void and inadmissible. However, learned senior counsel for 2 respondent contended that Ex. R-3 is only insufficiently stamped and therefore, steps were taken for payment of the deficit stamp duty, as such it cannot be said that the document is not stamped. In our considered view the submissions as made by the learned senior counsels insofar as the same relates to the admissibility of Ex R-3 in evidence is concerned, is wholly unsustainable and untenable, inasmuch as when Exhibit R-3 was tendered to PW-1 during her cross-examination, objection on any ground much less on the ground of non-payment/deficit payment of stamp duty on Exhibit R-3 has been raised by the Petitioner. Thus, the said document was marked without objection. So much so, Exhibit R-3 having been marked without any objection including objection as to payment of stamp duty, it is not open for either side to comment on/object to, on the admissibility of Exhibit R-3. However, we make it clear that as mere marking of a document will not dispense with proof of the contents of the said document, it is essential to see whether Exhibit R-3 has been proved or not. Needless to say, that the party relying on the document shall establish its proof when the said document is not admitted by the opposite side.
63. The respondents in support of their plea that the transfer of shares of the Petitioner has been affected pursuant to the request of the petitioner, while strongly contending that the provisions of law have been complied with relied on the following documents.
1. A copy of extract of Register of Member and share ledger
2. The original share certificate folio No. 17 of the petitioner.
3. The original share transfer form of the petitioner
4. A photo copy of the bank statement showing entries of clearance of two cheques.
64. A perusal of the same discloses that the 2 cheques bearing nos. 513330 and 513348 of a sum of Rs. 4,52,450/- and Rs. 50,000/- have been cleared on 08.08.2006 and 09.08.2006 respectively. According to the Ld. Senior Counsel for the Respondent, these entries stand as proof of payments of sale consideration in respect of transfer of 2250 shares of the Petitioner.
65. The Respondents in support of their plea that the shares of Petitioner were duly transferred in favour of 2 Respondent, have relied on the following documents
(i) Copy of Extract of the Register of Members and Share Ledger.
(ii) Copy of cash receipt dated 27.07.2006
(iii) Copy of cash receipt dated 01.08.2006
(iv) Copy of cash receipt dated 11.08.2006
(v) Copy of cash Receipt dated 17.11.2006
(vi) Copy of Cash Receipt dated 05.01.2007
66. Here, it is pertinent to refer to the cross examination of the Petitioner where under Question No. 12 & 14 the Petitioner was asked as under:—
Q.12. Under two cheques No. 513330 and 513348 on 09.08.2006 have you received any amount of Rs. 4,52,450/- and Rs. 50,000/- respectively/
Ans, Under the said cheques No. 513330 and 513348 I have not received any amount. It is not true to say that I have received an amount of Rs. 4,52,450/- and Rs. 50,000/- under respective cheques drawn on Central Bnk of India dated 08.08.2006.
Q.14. Can you produce bank statement of your account for the dates 08.08.2006 and 09.08.2006?
Ans : 08.08.2006 and 09.08.2006 bank statement is old dates to be produced. But the aforementioned amount might have come to the account but I do not know the source. It is not true to say that I received the sale consideration towards sale of my shares amounting to Rs. 4,52,450/- and Rs. 50,000/- respectively and it is not true to say that on receipt of the same I have handed over the original certificate along with signed transfer shares to the purchaser and it is not true to say that anything I stated is false.
67. That apart it is pertinent to note that even as per the Respondents, the purported resolution for share transfer was passed on 02.09.2009, on the date when the Petitioner said to have requested for transfer of his shares. Therefore, the transfer, if any, can be validly effected post 02.09.2009, whereas the disputed cheques have been realized by 08.08.2006 and 09.08.2006 itself. So much so, it cannot be such that the cheques bearing nos. cheques No. 513330 and 513348 were in respect of sale consideration for the shares of the petitioner.
68. In the above backdrop, the burden in on the 2 Respondent to establish before this Tribunal that the two cheques that are stated to have been issued to the Petitioners were in respect of the consideration for sale of 2250 equity shares of the Petitioner. However, Respondent No. 2 has not chosen to take any steps. Here, it is pertinent to refer to the reply notice got issued by the Respondents to the Petitioner dated 14.10.2019 wherein there is no whisper of payment of consideration made and the amount of consideration stated to have been made by the 2 Respondent to the Petitioner. Thus, the payment of consideration for the alleged transfer of shares under Exhibit R 3 is not established.
69. Now it is to be seen whether the instrument of transfer namely, Ex R 3, relied on by the respondents is a proper instrument or not. Needless to say, that a proper instrument contemplated under section 108 of the Companies Act 1956, means an instrument which has the compliance of all the legal requirements. The procedure of transfer of shares of 1 respondent Company is governed both by Articles of Association of a Company, supra, as well by the provisions of the Companies Act.
70. The petitioner had specifically pleaded that her verification of the annual returns for the year 2017-2018 done in the month of September 2019, revealed that for the year 2009 onwards the shareholding of the petitioner has been shown as nil, even though the petitioner never intended nor informed the first respondent company of her intention to sell her shares, sold her 2250 shares to any one at any point of time, received any consideration from any one for the alleged sale transfer of her shares, executed any share transfer form and the fraud played by the 2 respondent with the active support of the rest of the respondents. According to the Petitioner immediately upon coming to know above the fraudulent transfer of her shares the petitioner claims that the undated letter has been issued to the respondents demanding, cancellation of entries in the registers showing her as NIL shareholder and to restore her original shareholding in the 1 respondent Company.
71. The Petitioner further pleaded that the petitioner was not given/served of any notice of the meetings of the Board of Directors if any held approving the transfer of shares of the petitioner even though it is mandatory in terms of Article-16 of Articles of Association to serve notice on the Petitioner who also is one of the Directors of the 1 respondent Company (indisputable till 2008), for the purported Board meeting where transfer of petitioner's shares was purported to be in the agenda.
72. The above contentions are simply refuted by the respondents stating that “shares were transferred as petitioner expressed her intention vide letter dated 02.01.2009 to transfer her 2250 shares of the first respondent company to the 2 respondent for a total consideration of Rs. 2,25,000 and accordingly submitted and signed the share transfer form marked as Exhibit-R3 in favour of 2 Respondent. Request so made by the petitioner has been approved by the general body meeting held on 02.09.2009 in which Board Resolution was passed, consequently the shares of the petitioner came to be transferred in favour of the 2 Respondent for valid consideration and a valid entry to that effect has been made in the share ledger. The copy of which have been filed along with the counter”.
73. The record such as notice of meeting of the Board meeting supposed to have been held for considering the transfer of shares of the Petitioner, the purported bard resolution dated 02.09.2009 accepting the request of the petitioner for transfer of her equity shares are not produced. The only document produced was the photocopy of the share extract of Register of Member and share ledger. Even the share register was not produced. In the absence of any record showing the due compliance of the procedure contemplated under the Article of the Company and the provisos of the Companies Act, no credence can be given to the photocopy of the share extract of Register of Member and share ledger especially in the absence of the original or a true copy of the same being produced. Moreover, in the reply dated 14.10.2019, sent in response to the petitioner's letter dated 28.09.2019 even though the respondents asserted that full sale consideration in respect of 2250 shared transferred to the 2 respondent has been paid by the 2 Respondent to the applicant, failed to mention the date on which Board Meeting was held, whether notice of the said meeting has been given to the petitioner the date, the mode, and the quantum of sale consideration paid to the Applicant by the 2 Respondent.
74. Needless to say, that the disputed transfer of equity shares is in respect of M/s Hira Multi Ventures Private Limited, and not in respect of Greenscape Mega Resorts. So much so payment of Rs. 25,00,000/- as above was not in respect of transfer of shares of the petitioner held in 1 respondent/Company. No other proof of payment of sale consideration has been filed. That apart in the counter filed by Respondents No. 1-10, it has been specifically pleaded that “that the petitioner sold 2250 shares to 2nd Respondent for a total consideration of Rs. 2,25,000”, whereas the above photocopy of the receipt above, states that a sum of Rs. 25 lakhs has been paid under two different cheques of Rs. 10,00,000.00 and Rs. 15,00,000.00 each. Thus, there is no nexus between the pleading and the documents placed in proof of pleading, and plea that sale consideration in respect of 2250 equity shares of the Petitioner remain unestablished. Needless to say, that shares which are considered as movable property under the Transfer of Property Act, sale of shares without payment of consideration is void. Reliance, in this regard can be placed on the ruling in Kewal Krishan v. Rajesh Kumar etc, (Civil Appeal Nos. 6989-6992 of 2021) wherein at para 15, it is held as under
If a sale deed in respect of an immovable property is executed without payment of price and if it does not provide for the payment of price at a future date, it is not a sale at all in the eyes of law. It is of no legal effect. Therefore, such a sale will be void. It will not effect the transfer of the immovable property.
75. However, relying on the ruling of Hon'ble Supreme Court of India “Vidhyadhar v. Manikrao (1999) 3 SCC 573, wherein Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that “Price constitutes of the Transfer of sale or promised or part paid and part payment indicate that actual payment of the whole price at the time of execution of the sale is not, a sin qua non, to the completion of the sale. Even if the price of the sale is paid but the document execution is thereafter registered, for the property of more than 100 sale would be complete.” Ld. Counsel for 1 Respondent contended that the plea that the sale of equity shares of the Petitioner was without sale consideration hence the sale is void is unsustainable.
76. We have carefully perused the above ruling wherein it was held that price which is otherwise called as consideration, constitutes an essential ingredient of transaction of sale. Therefore, at the outset it can be said that payment of consideration for sale of shares is being an essential ingredient for a valid sale, it is imperative for the respondents to establish the same even as per the ruling supra. However, unlike the facts in re, Vidyadhar, supra, the plea of the Respondents herein is that, “that the petitioner sold 2250 shares to 2nd Respondent for a total consideration of Rs. 2,25,000”, and in proof of payment of the said sale consideration the respondents relied on the photo copy of bank statement. So much so, it is not the case of the respondents herein that only a part sale consideration was paid and the document has been registered.
77. Thus, it is as clear as crystal that financial statements that were uploaded post transfer of shares of the Petitioner were in nothing but the outcome of violation of section 108 of the Companies Act, Articles of Association of the 1 respondent and suppression of non-payment of sale considering for the shares purportedly sold to the 2 respondent hence we have no hesitation to hold that the respondents indulged fraud and perpetuating fraudulent acts. Thought in a dispute of this nature the role Company being that of a ‘Guardian of the rights of the members’, besides to assist the Tribunal by placing the required information in resolving the disputes among the members of the Company, strangely the 1 respondent played a very actively sailed with the remaining respondents. More over at the behest of the 1 respondent this Tribunal allowed cross examination of Pw1. The respondents though got marked Exhibits R 1 to R 3 nothing worth denting the case of the Petitioner has been elicited. The 1 respondent also sought for sending the disputed signatures of the Petitioners for expert opinion and the same was rejected by this Tribunal. In view of our finding that the share transfer itself is fraudulent and illegal we not find any necessity to invoke Section 74 of Indian Evidence Act.
78. Hon'ble Apex Court, in re, Somathi devi v. Mahendra Viswakarma SLP(CIVIL) NO. 3506/2019 dated September 15, 2021, held that,
“It is well known that fraud vitiates every solemn act”. The finding rendered by the Trial Court that the gift deed was brought about by practicing fraud and undue influence is unassailable.”, the court observed while allowing the appeal and restoring the Trial Court judgment.
In the above ruling Hon'ble Supreme Court referred to the judgment in re State of A.P. v. T. Suryachandra Rao [(2005) 6 SCC 149] it was observed as follows:
“fraud” is meant an intention to deceive; whether it is from any expectation of advantage to the party himself or from the ill will towards the other is immaterial. The expression “fraud” involves two elements, deceit and injury to the person deceived. Injury is something other than economic loss, that is, deprivation of property, whether movable or immovable or of money and it will include and any harm whatever caused to any person in body, mind, reputation or such others. In short, it is a non-economic or non-pecuniary loss. A benefit or advantage to the deceiver, will almost always call loss or detriment to the deceived. Even in those rare cases where there is a benefit or advantage to the deceiver, but no corresponding loss to the deceived, the second condition is satisfied.”
“Fraud” as is well known vitiates every solemn act. Fraud and justice never dwell together. Fraud is a conduct either by letter or words, which includes the other person or authority to take a definite determinative stand as a response to the conduct of the former either by words or letter. It is also well settled that misrepresentation itself amounts to fraud. Indeed, innocent misrepresentation may also give reason to claim relief against fraud. A fraudulent misrepresentation is called deceit and consists in leading a man into damage by willfully or recklessly causing him to believe and act on falsehood. It is a fraud in law if a party makes representations, which he knows to be false, and injury enures therefrom although the motive from which the representations proceeded may not have been bad. An act of fraud on court is always viewed seriously. A collusion or conspiracy with a view to deprive the rights of the others in relation to a property would render the transaction void ab initio. Fraud and deception are synonymous. Although in a given case a deception may not amount to fraud, fraud is anathema to all equitable principles and any affair tainted with fraud cannot be perpetuated or saved by the application of any equitable doctrine including res judicata. (See Ram Chandra Singh v. Savitri Devi ((2003) 8 SCC 319)”
(emphasis supplied)
Therefore, in view of our discussion as above we hereby declare that the transfer of the Petitioner's 2250 equity shares in favour of 2 Respondent as illegal, contrary to the Articles of Association of the 1 respondent, provisions of the Companies Act, 1956 besides fraudulent, consequently we direct rectification the register of members accordingly. Point is answered accordingly.
Point 2.
Whether the Company Petition is barred by limitation?
79. According to the learned senior counsel for the Petitioners until the year 2019 the petitioner Mrs. Rizwana Anjum was not at all aware of the fraudulent transfer of her shares in favour of 2 respondent and immediately upon coming to know about the same on 27.09.2019 sent a letter to the 1 respondent asserting categorically that she never intended to sell her shares and the claim that she had sold 2250 equity shares to 2 respondent and executed Share Transfer Form dated 02.01.2009, besides letter confirming the sale of her 2250 equity shares. Learned senior counsel submits that the petitioner never received any notice of Board/Annual General Meeting/EGM in the year 2009 or subsequent thereto. No Financial Statements were also received by the petitioner. According to the learned senior counsel cause of action for the present application claimed to have arisen during the year 2009 since the so-called transfer apart from illegal is fraudulent, the date of knowledge of the fraud played by the 2 respondent plays crucial role while computing the starting point of limitation, if any, in the case on hand. In this context, the learned senior counsel would submit that the petitioner could know the said transfer of shares in the month of September 2019, only after verification of the Annual Return filed with respondent no. 11 for the year 2018-2019, therefore, the limitation, if any, in filing the present petition shall be calculated from September 2019 and the present application having been filed on 27.11.2019 is well within the period of limitation.
80. Learned senior counsel further submitted that the applicant had not received any notice of the Meetings of the Board of Directors/EGM or AGM after 2006. According to the learned senior counsel since the very transfer of shares being fraudulent, it is continuous, the question of limitation does not arise. Learned senior counsel contended that ‘fraud vitiates every Solemn Act’, and since the 2 respondent has played fraud in getting the petitioners' shares transferred in favour of the 2 respondent, the limitation, if any in the case on hand shall begin to run only from the date when the petitioner came to know about the fraud in terms of section 17 of the Limitation Act, 1963.
81. Learned senior counsel relied on the following rulings:
OK Augaste v. OFS Industries, (2009) 149 Comp Cas 20, held that “illegal allotment of shares amounts to continuous act of oppression causing prejudice to the interest of the members, the act of oppression being continuous till it is remedied or brought to an end the petition cannot be dismissed on the ground of delay.”
Further at para 43 of the Judgment, it is held that “it is settled law that illegal allotment of shares amounts to continuous act of oppression causing prejudice to the interests of members. The act of oppression being continuous till it is remedied or brought to an end, the petition cannot be dismissed at the threshold on account of unproved case of delay or laches.
82. Per contra, learned senior counsel for the 2 respondent at the outset would contend that the application as filed is hopelessly barred by limitation. As such the same is liable to be dismissed. In this regard the learned senior counsel contends that the applicant having received sale consideration has voluntarily sold her 2250 equity shares to the 2 respondent by executing Share Transfer Form marked as Exhibit R/3. The Annual Statements of 1 respondent/Company were uploaded on the website of Ministry from time to time. According to the learned senior counsel the petitioner being a Director of the Company till 2010 cannot plead ignorance of the fact that her shareholding was shown as NIL by the year 2010 itself, consequent to sale of her 2250 equity shares in favour of 2 respondent. In this context learned senior counsel submits that the transfer of the shares, as above, in favour of the 2 respondent has been displayed in Website of the 1 respondent/Company ever since the year 2009. Therefore, according to the Ld. Sr. Counsel, when the information regarding the shareholding of the Petitioner has been in public domain ever since 2009 it is not open to the petitioner under law to contend that the petitioner was unaware of transfer of his shares in favour of the 2 respondent till 2019. So much so the present petition having been filed after lapse of nearly 11 years is hopelessly barred by limitation. Ld. Counsels representing the 1 Respondents sailed with the submissions of the Ld. Sr. Counsel.
83. Needless to say, that whether nor not the opposite party raises the plea of limitation, it is incumbent on the part of the applicant to establish that the reliefs sought for are not barred by limitation. Thus, the burden is on the applicant to establish that the reliefs sought for in the present application are not barred by limitation. Since the Petitioner vehemently relied on section 17 of the Limitation Act, in order to contend that the present Petition is not barred by Limitation, reliance of which has been strongly opposed by the respondents, it would be proper to refer to section 17 of Limitation Act which is as below.
“17. Effect of fraud or mistake. —
(1) Where, in the case of any suit or application for which a period of limitation is prescribed by this Act,—
(a) the suit or application is based upon the fraud of the defendant or respondent or his agent; or (Emphasis supplied)
(b) the knowledge of the right or title on which a suit or application is founded is concealed by the fraud of any such person as aforesaid; or
(c) the suit or application is for relief from the consequences of a mistake; or
(d) where any document necessary to establish the right of the plaintiff or applicant has been fraudulently concealed from him, the period of limitation shall not begin to run until the plaintiff or applicant has discovered the fraud or the mistake or could, with reasonable diligence, have discovered it; or in the case of a concealed document, until the plaintiff or the applicant first had the means of producing the concealed document or compelling its production:
(Emphasis supplied)
Provided that nothing in this section shall enable any suit to be instituted or application to be made to recover or enforce any charge against, or set aside any transaction affecting, any property which—
(i) in the case of fraud, has been purchased for valuable consideration by a person who was not a party to the fraud and did not at the time of the purchase know, or have reason to believe, that any fraud had been committed, or
(ii) in the case of mistake, has been purchased for valuable consideration subsequently to the transaction in which the mistake was made, by a person who did not know, or have reason to believe, that the mistake had been made, or
(iii) in the case of a concealed document, has been purchased for valuable consideration by a person who was not a party to the concealment and, did not at the time of purchase know, or have reason to believe, that the document had been concealed.
(2) Where a judgment-debtor has, by fraud or force, prevented the execution of a decree or order within the period of limitation, the court may, on the application of the judgment-creditor made after the expiry of the said period extend the period for execution of the decree or order : Provided that such application is made within one year from the date of the discovery of the fraud or the cessation of force, as the case may be.”
84. A perusal of subsection 1(a) & (d) of the above provision discloses that when an application is based upon the fraud of the defendant or respondent the period of limitation shall not begin to run until the plaintiff or applicant has discovered the fraud or could, with reasonable diligence, have discovered it. Since the plea of the applicant that he came to know about the fraud and illegality in transfer of his equity share held by him in the 1 respondent Company, in September 2019 when he had perused the Annual Returns of the 1 respondent for the Year 2017-2018, has been denied outrightly by the respondents as false and baseless, the burden lies on the Petitioner to establish that despite reasonable diligence the petitioner could not discover the fraud purportedly played by the respondents. Since the Learned senior counsel for 2 respondent contends that the applicant being a director of 1 respondent/Company till 2010 cannot plead that she was unaware of the changes in the shareholding pattern of 1 respondent/Company, especially when the said information has been put in public domain by 2009 itself, and if the said plea is accepted the application may have to be dismissed as barred by limitation, since uploading the financial statements of the 1 respondent even by the year 2010 is not in dispute, it is imperative for us to examine whether in matters based upon fraud of the respondent, mere uploading of the Financial Statements of the Company in the Public website would be conclusive proof of ‘discovery of fraud’ by the suitor and the limitation shall not begin to run from the date when the financial statements were so up loaded, even while the entries in the Financial Statements of the Company, are found to be in violation of Articles of Association of the Company and the provisions of the Company's Act.
85. Here it is pertinent to refer to Section 108 of Companies Act, 1956, which says that a Company shall not register a transfer of shares or debentures of, the company, unless a proper instrument of transfer duly stamped and executed by or on behalf of the transferor and by or on behalf of the transferee and specifying the name, address and occupation, if any, of the transferee, has been delivered to the company along with certificate relating to the shares or debentures, or if no such certificate is in existence, along with the letter of allotment of the shares or debentures. Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, in re, Mannalal Khetan, supra, held that of Section 108 of Companies Act, 1956 is mandatory. Therefore, in order to have valid transfer of shares or debentures, an instrument of transfer shall be duly stamped and executed by or on behalf of the transferor at the first instance, lest the transfer can be held to be valid. Insofar as the case on hand is concerned the applicant apart from pleading fraud and contending noncompliance of mandatory statutory provisions by the respondents also denied even intention to transfer her shares and vehemently contended that she has neither handed over her shares certificates nor executed Share Transfer Form, also denied having signed Exhibit R/3-Share Transfer Form besides the undated letter in favour of 2 respondent, which contentions however were denied out rightly by the respondents.
86. Under the Point 1, supra, we have, inter alia, discussed the rival contentions as regards the plea of “fraud” in transfer of sharers in favour of the 2 respondent and categorically held that the respondents have failed in establishing the due compliance of the mandatory requirements under the Company's Act as well as under the Articles of Association of the Company, besides that the transfer of equity shares of the Petitioner as fraudulent. Therefore, in order to avoid repetition, we hereby observe that our discussion made and findings arrived as regards ‘fraud’ therein, be read as part and parcel of the discussion under this Point.
87. In the above back drop, when fraud and illegality in the transfer of the shares of the petitioner has been established, the financial statements of the 1 respondent which are in public domain were nothing but result of suppression, failure of statutory compliances, non-payment of sale consideration and fraud. As “fraud” as is well known “vitiates every solemn act”, the question before us now is can the starting point for computing the period of limitation for the purpose of Section 17 of Limitation Act, be the date of uploading the transaction in the Website tainted with illegality and fraud or the date on which the ‘victim’ of the said fraudulent act actually comes to know of the fraud committed by the opposite party?
88. Hon'ble Apex Court, in re, Sonamati Devi & Ors v. Mahendra Vishwakarma & Ors in Civil Appeal No. 5717 of 2021 held that,
“It is well known that fraud vitiates every solemn act. The finding rendered by the Trial Court that the gift deed was brought about by practicing fraud and undue influence is unassailable.”, the court observed while allowing the appeal and restoring the Trial Court judgment.
89. Reliance in this regard can also be placed on the ruling of NCLAT, in the matter of Dhanajya v. Tulhi bhavani Cold Storage, 2019 SCC OnLine NCLAT 434, wherein it has been held that;
“while each filing of statutory compliance supressing material facts in this regard to the majority holding of the respondent no. 2 ..on this part that fraudulent would continue cause against of action to competent even after AGM was held the company petition in the period of limitation in as much as Company petition was filed on 19.09.2006. Though acknowledgement cant be to 2nd Respondent as he has no notice of AGM and it was only 02/2016 he claims to gain acknowledge on the mis conduct part of the appellant though the letter and annual report for the year ending 3/2016 available with ROC.
90. In OK Augaste v. OFS Industries, (2009) 149 Comp Cas 20, it was held that.
“That illegal allotment of shares amounts to continuous act of oppression causing prejudice to the interest of the members, the act of oppression being continuous till it is remedied or brought to an end the petition cannot be dismissed on the ground of delay”
91. In view of the above legal position and by taking the factual matrix of this case into consideration, we hold that the date to be reckoned for the purpose of computing the starting point of limitation in this case is the date on which the Petitioner came to know of the fraud played by the respondents, i.e. September 2019 and not the date on which the financial statements of the respondent were uploaded. We are therefore, of the firm view that the present Petition having been filed within three years of coming to know about the fraud played by the respondents is not barred by limitation.
Point is answered accordingly.
92. Therefore, in light of our discussion as above we hereby declare that transfer of 2250 equity shares held by the Petitioner/Mrs Rizwana Anjum in favour of the 2 respondent as illegal, fraudulent and void under law, and as a corollary, we hereby set aside the said transfer in favour of the 2 respondent. The respondent is hereby directed to rectify the records of the 1 respondent in line with observations/directions in this Order, within a reasonable period.
93. We therefore, accordingly allow the Company Petition No. 778/59/HDB/2019. Since main Company Petition is disposed of, all pending IAs in this CP stands closed.