ORAL ORDER
(PER : HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE AKIL KURESHI)
1. This petition is filed by a judicial officer challenging initiation of departmental inquiry, being Inquiry No.7 of 2012 (hereinafter to be referred as "said inquiry"). She has prayed that the said inquiry be quashed.
2. Brief facts are as under:
Petitioner was appointed as Civil Judge & JMFC and upon completion of training, she was posted as Civil Judge-cum-JMFC, Junagadh and took charge on 11.3.2005. According to the petitioner, she was facing hostile service conditions and discriminations being a
Page 1 of 15
lady judicial officer. On 15.7.2011, she was placed under suspension. Subsequently, Departmental Inquiry No.3 of 2011 was instituted in which several charges were levelled. On 17.11.2011, her suspension was revoked. She was posted at Vadodara. However, on 03.09.2012, she was transferred from Vadodara to Deesa under Banaskantha district. According to the petitioner, though she was entitled to allotment of residential quarter of specified category, no such quarter was allotted to her at Deesa. Instead, she was assigned a room in Government Guest House where conditions were not suitable for stay. From 1.11.2012 to 19.11.2012, petitioner was on leave during Diwali holidays. Even after she returned, she was not allotted a staff quarter at Deesa, or even a room in Government Guest House. The petitioner therefore wrote to the District Judge, Banaskantha and requested that Collector, Bansakantha be asked to make arrangements for her stay at Deesa or, in the alternative, to permit her to commute between Palanpur and Deesa. According to the petitioner, neither of these requests were granted. On 30.11.2012, petitioner came to be placed under suspension again. Her headquarter was shifted to Vadodara. On 26.2.2013, a chargesheet was issued instituting said Departmental Inquiry No.7 of 2012. This chargesheet contained following charges:
"I. While you had requested for allotment of judicial quarter at Deesa, you were informed by the office of the District Court, Banaskantha at Palanpur, vie their letter dated 11.10.2012 that, Judicial Quarters are not available at Deesa, hence, the same cannot
Page 2 of 15
be allotted to you. Therefore, you yourself have to make arrangement of your accommodation by hiring private accommodation and District Judge and Collector are not involved in the process of hiring such a accommodation as per the Resolution dated 24.7.1995 of Government of Gujarat, Legal Department, No.R.A.C./1093/3235/D/Part-2. However, instead of hiring private accommodation, you have purposefully with a oblique and ulterior motive, on 20.11.2012 at about 6.05 p.m. sent a fax letter to the Principal District Judge, Palanpur, and made three irrelevant demands in in discourteous manner, I.e.(i) to permit you to pass night on pavement, (ii) to permit you to commute from Palanpur to Deesa on daily basis with T.A./D.A.till appropriate arrangement for your accommodation is made and (iii) to make arrangement for requisitioning suitable accommodation for you through the Collector and insisted the Principal District Judge, Banaskantha at Palanapur, for requisition of private accommodation by the Collector. Thereby, you have shown insubordination towards your Head of the Department.
The aforesaid act of yours, if proved, would amount to a misconduct, the conduct unbecoming of a Judicial officer, and violation of provisions contained in Rule 3 (1) and 3A(a) of the Gujarat Civil Service (Conduct) Rules, 1971.
II.
That, on 20.11.2012, at abut 7.00 p.m., all Judicial Officers of Deesa came to Palanpur for courtesyh visit to exchange New Year Greetings and you had also come with them. Thereafter, all Judicial Officers went to Judges colony at Palanpur to meet other Judicial Officers, but, while returning, it has come to their notice that, you were still in District Court compound by keeping grudge against the Principal District Judge, Palanpur, and therefore at about 9.30 p.m. all of them came to you in District Court compound and you were too much rigid to leave District Court compound, Palanpur, and after much persuasions, you agreed to go to Deesa. Thus, you had created unnecessary controversy and problems before the Judicial Officers. Being a Judicial officer, you were bound to maintain the dignity and
Page 3 of 15
decorum of the Judiciary. By committing such act, you has spoiled the image of the Judiciary as well as the Head of the Department I.e. Principal District Judge, Palanapur.
The aforesaid act of yours, if proved, would amount to a misconduct, the conduct unbecoming of a Judicial Officer, and violation of provisions contained in Rule 3 (1)(iii) and 3A(a) of the Gujarat Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1971 as also the violation of the instructions contained in the Code of Conduct for the Judicial Officer.
III.
You were well aware of the Code of Conduct for the Judges wherein, it is specifically prescribed at Para 1 that, a Judge's official conduct should be free from impropriety and the appearance of impropriety, Judicial Officer should avoid infraction of law in his/her private affairs and his/her personal behaviour, not only upon the bench and in the performance of Judicial duties, but also in his everyday life, should be beyond reproach. However, after returning to Deesa from District Court, Palanpur, you put your threat of staying on pavement in reality and you passed entire night intervening between 20.11.2012 and 21.11.2012 in your car on road in front of the Court Complex of Deesa, and thereby, put entire judiciary in an embarrassing position. The aforesaid act of yours, if proved, would amount to a misconduct, the conduct of unbecoming of a Judicial Officer, and violation of provisions contained in Rule 3 (1) (iii) and 3A(a) of the Gujarat Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1971, as also the violation of the instructions contained in the Code of Conduct for the Judicial Officers.
IV
As your irrelevant demands I.e. (I) to permit you to pass snight on pavement, (ii) to permit you to commute from Palanpur to Deesa daily with TA/DA till appropriate arrangement for your accommodation is made and (iii) to make arrangement for requisitioning suitable accommodation for you through the Collector, contained in your letter dated 20.11.2012 were not accepted by the
Page 4 of 15
Principal District Judge, Palanpur, keeping grudge against the Principal District Judge, Palanapur, other Government Officers and the Hon'ble High Court, just to malign their image and also with a view to satisfy your false and irrelevant demands, you passed entire night intervening between 20.11.2012 and 21.11.2012 in your car on road in front of the Court Complex of Deesa and you had expressed your so called grievances against the Government, the District Judge, Palanpur and the High Court, before the Electronic and Print Media and you also made statement that the Hon'ble Gujarat High Court is against you and is harassing you and now the High Court will suspend you, which false statements were widely published in print and electronic media.
The aforesaid act of yours, if proved, would amount to a misconduct, the conduct unbecoming of a Judicial Officer, and also a violation of provisions contained in Rules 3 (1) (iii), 8 and 9 of Gujarat Civil Services (Conduct) Rules 1971 as also the violation of the instructions contained in the Code of Conduct for the Judicial Officer.
V
The members of subordinate judiciary are required to make their correspondence to Hon'ble High Court through proper channel I.e. the Principal District Judge, however, you have directly forwarded the letter dated 22.11.2012 addressed to the Registrar General, High Court of Gujarat, regarding your grievance against the conduct and behaviour of the Principal District Judge, Palanpur, the District Collector and Election Officer with a request to initiate contempt proceedings against them. Thus, you Ms.Asha Dave have committed gross misconduct by writing letter directly to the Registrar General of this High Court, instead of writing letter through the Principal District Judge of Banaskantha. This act of yours is discourteous and unbecoming of a judicial officer.
The aforesaid act of yours, if proved, would amount to a misconduct, the conduct unbecoming of a Judicial Officer, and violation of provisions contained in Rules 3 (1) (iii) and 3A(a) of Gujarat Civil
Page 5 of 15
Services (Conduct) Rules 1971 as also the violation of the instructions contained in the Code of Conduct for the Judicial Officer.
VI
As your irrelevant demands as mentioned in your Fax-letter dated 20.11.2012 addressed to the District Judge, Banaskantha, were not satisfied, you, without any reasons and only with a view to take revenge and to malign the prestige and image of the Principal District Judge and other Government officers, in your letter dated 22.11.20121, addressed to the Registrar General, High Court of Gujarat, ventilated the false grievances against the behaviour and conduct of Principal District Judge, Palanpur, the District Collector, Palanpur and the Election Officer, Palanpur and you have requested to initiate contempt proceedings against them. This act of yours is quite derogatory and discourteous towards the Principal District Judge, Banaskantha at Palanpur.
The aforesaid act of yours, if proved, would amount to a misconduct, the conduct unbecoming of a Judicial Officer, and violation of provisions contained in Rule 3 (1) (iii) and 3A(a) of Gujarat Civil Services (Conduct) Rules 1971....."
3. The petitioner thereupon filed the present petition. In such petition, she had made multiple prayers. Besides the said chargesheet, she had also challenged validity of Departmental Inquiry No.11 of 2013 and yet another inquiry later on instituted and numbered as Departmental Inquiry No.1 of 2014. She had also challenged her suspension order.
4. On 27.4.2015, a Division Bench of this Court confined the petition to challenge only Departmental Inquiry No.7 of 2012 leaving it open for her to institute separate proceedings regarding the
Page 6 of 15
remaining grievances as can be seen from the following portion of the order:
"[4.0] Under the circumstances, present petition be restricted to challenging the departmental inquiry No.7/2012 (being oldest). Present petition with respect to other departmental inquiries being Departmental Inquiry Nos.11 of 2013 and 01 of 2014 and even with respect to challenging the order of suspension is not entertained. However, it is clarified that it will be open for the petitioner to file separate petitions challenging the aforesaid departmental inquiries and even the order of suspension on whatever the grounds which may be available to her under the law and as and when such separate independent
petitions/proceedings are initiated, the same be considered in accordance with law and on merits. As observed herein above, the present petition be restricted to challenging the departmental inquiry No.7/2012...."
5. Consequently, learned counsel for the petitioner has confined her submissions to legality of Departmental Inquiry No.7 of 2012. She has raised two-fold contentions. Firstly that this is a case of no evidence. Counsel took us to detailed material on record to submit that the chargesheet has been issued without any material on record to even, prima facie, suggest that the petitioner has committed any misconduct. Elaborating this contention, counsel submitted that what the petitioner required was a descent accommodation at Deesa. She was neither allotted a staff quarter though it was duty of the District Judge to do so, nor any arrangement was made for suitable accommodation in Government guest house. In absence of any facility for stay, her request for commutation between Palanpur to Deesa was required to be granted, which was also not done. It was,
Page 7 of 15
therefore, impossible for the petitioner to discharge her duties at Deesa. Her only choice was to spend the night in her vehicle. She cannot be said to have committed any misconduct in the process.
6. The second limb of the petitioner's challenge was that even if all allegations in the chargesheet are taken on face value, would not constitute "misconduct" as defined in Rule 3 (1) of the Gujarat Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1971 (hereinafter referred to as "the Conduct Rules"). Counsel invited our attention to each charge in detail to contend that the petitioner had not acted in a manner unbecoming of a judicial officer. She submitted that the petitioner had not directly corresponded with the High Court. The charge of making representation without routing it through proper channel was thus baseless. Counsel would contend that the petitioner had never contacted the media or created any unnecessary controversy, as alleged. She, therefore, requested that the chargesheet be quashed.
7. Having heard learned counsel for the petitioner and having perused the documents on record, we must realise that we are dealing with a challenge to a chargesheet at a stage where departmental inquiry is yet to be completed. Scope of judicial review at such a stage would be extremely narrow. We have already reproduced various charges levelled against the petitioner. Gist of these charges can be summarized as under:
Charge I:
Petitioner was conveyed that staff quarter at Deesa was not
Page 8 of 15
available and the same, therefore, cannot be allotted to her and she would have to make her own arrangements by hiring private accommodation. Despite this, petitioner, with ulterior motive, sent a fax letter to District Judge, Palanpur making demands in a discourteous manner to permit her to pass night on pavement, to permit her to commute from Palanpur on daily basis with TA/DA till appropriate arrangements are made and to make arrangements for suitable private accommodation through Collector. These were acts of insubordination and amounted to misconduct within the meaning of Rule 3(1) of the Conduct Rules.
Charge II:
On 20.11.2011, all judicial officers of Deesa came to Palanapur on the occasion of New Year. Petitioner was also a part of the group. It was noticed that petitioner stayed back in the District Court compound and required much persuasion before she agreed to go back to Deesa. She had thus created unnecessary controversy.
Charge III:
Petitioner spent the entire night between 20.11.2012 and 21.11.2012 in her car which was parked in front of the Court complex at Deesa. Her conduct embarrassed the Judiciary. Her action was unbecoming of a judicial officer.
Page 9 of 15
Charge-IV:
She not only spent the entire night between 20.11.2012 and 21.11.2012 in her car on road in front of the Court complex at Deesa, she also expressed her grievance against the government, the District Judge, Palanapur and the High Court to electronic and print media further making a statement that Gujarat High Court is against her and is harassing her and she would now be placed under suspension. Her statement was widely published in media.
Charge V:
She directly addressed her letter dated 22.11.2012 to the Registrar General of the High Court regarding her grievance against the conduct and behaviour of Principal District Judge, Palanpur and other government officers, with a request to initiate contempt proceedings against them. Petitioner had committed gross misconduct by writing letter directly instead of routing it through Principal District Judge.
Charge-VI:
In her letter dated 22.11.2012 addressed to the Registrar General, Gujarat High Court, she had raised false grievance against the behaviour and conduct of Principal District Judge, Palanapur; Collector, Palanpur and Election Officer, Palanpur
Page 10 of 15
and she had requested to initiate contempt proceedings against them.
8. It can thus be seen that, under the said chargesheet, several allegations have been made against the petitioner of variousl acts or omissions. According to the chargesheet, these acts amounted to misconduct defined under Rule 3 of the Conduct Rules. Sub-rule (1) of Rule 3 of the Conduct Rules, inter alia, require that every government servant shall at all times maintain absolute integrity, maintain devotion to duty and do nothing which is unbecoming of a Government servant. Rule 3-A of the said Rules, inter alia, provides that no government servant shall in the performance of his official duties, act in a discourteous manner.
9. At this early stage, it is impossible for us to conclude that there is no evidence on record to drive home the charges levelled against the petitioner. Prima facie, allegations of alleged misconduct have been made against the petitioner, who is a judicial officer. The charges included impropriety and objectionable behaviour which would amount to acting in a manner unbecoming of a government servant. Such charges, inter alia, provide that the District Judge, not being able to allot official residence for want of availability, petitioner insisted that the District Judge asks the Collector to ensure procurement of private accommodation for her. According to the administration, this was not the duty of Principal District Judge and the petitioner could not have insisted for the same. When such
Page 11 of 15
request was not accepted, petitioner spent the night in her car in front of the Court building and this incident was widely published in print and electronic media. Whether the petitioner spoke to the media making her grievances public so that the entire event comes in full public view and whether the petitioner made certain statements before the media are issues which the disciplinary authority is required to go into at the time of conduct of the inquiry. At this premature stage, it will be improper on our part to do a fact finding inquiry and hold whether the charges are true or untrue, a task that is to be performed by the Inquiry Officer.
10. Equally, we are unable to accept the second limb of the contention that even if the charges are established, they do not amount to misconduct. As noted, Rules 3 and 3-A of the Conduct Rules include wide range of acts and omissions which would amount to "misconduct". What is precise scope of the expression "in any manner unbecoming of a government servant" is not possible to put in a straightjacket formula. By very nature of things, such expression is possible of flexibility and must be viewed in the background of the position that a government servant holds, kinds of duties and functions he or she is entrusted with and the allegation of impropriety or objectionable behaviour made against him or her. At any rate, as a judicial officer, the petitioner held a greater duty to carry herself with dignity in public, to act responsibly, reasonably and in a manner which would not, without reason or basis, tarnish the image of the
Page 12 of 15
judiciary or drag herself or the administration into needless controversy. However, these are only observations made to deal with the petitioner's contention that no misconduct is established even on admitted charges, and we do not intend to conclude this issue in the present litigation.
11. In case of Union of India v. A.N.Saxena reported in AIR 1992 SC 1233, the Supreme Court set aside the order of CAT granting stay of disciplinary proceedings against income tax officer observing that charges were extremely serious and, if proved, would establish misconduct and misbehaviour. The Supreme Court criticized the manner in which without assigning reasons stay was granted against further inquiry. Argument that the delinquent was performing judicial or quasi-judicial function in making assessment order and even if his actions were wrong no disciplinary proceedings could be initiated was rejected. The Court observed as under:
"6. In the first place, we cannot, but confess our astonishment at the impugned order passed by the tribunal. In a case like this the tribunal, we feel, should have been very careful before granting stay in a disciplinary proceeding at an interlocutory stage.The imputations made against the respondent were extremely serious and the facts alleged, if proved, would have established misconduct and misbehaviour. It is surprising that without even a counter being filed, at an interim stage, the tribunal without giving any reasons and without apparently considering whether the memorandum of charges deserved to be enquired into or not, granted a stay of disciplinary proceedings as it has done. If the disciplinary proceedings in such serious matters are stayed so lightly as the tribunal appears to have done, it would be extremely difficult to bring any wrong-doer to book.
Page 13 of 15
We have, therefore, no hesitation in setting aside the impugned order of the tribunal and we direct that the disciplinary proceedings against the respondent in terms of the chargesheet dated March 13, 1989 shall be proceeded with according to law. In fact, we would suggest that disciplinary proceedings should be proceeded with as early as possible and with utmost zeal.
7. It was urged before us by learned Counsel for the respondent that as the respondent was performing judicial or quasijudicial functions in making the -assessment orders in question even if his actions were wrong they could be corrected in an appeal or in revision and no disciplinary proceedings could be taken regarding such actions.
8 .In our view, an argument that no disciplinary action can be taken in regard to actions taken or purported to be done in the course of judicial or quasi-judicial proceectings is not correct.It is true that when an officer is performing judicial or quasi-judicial functions disciplinary proceedings regarding any of his actions in the course of such proceedings should be taken only after great caution and a close scrutiny of his actions and only if the circumstances so warrant. The initiation of such proceedings, it is true, is likely to shake the confidence of the public in the officer concerned and also if lightly taken likely to undermine his independence. Hence the need for extreme care and caution before initiation of disciplinary proceedings against an officer performing judicial or quasijudicial functions in respect of his actions in the discharge or purported to discharge his functions. But it is not as if such action cannot be taken at all. Where the actions of such an officer indicate culpability, namely, a desire to oblige himself or unduly favour one of the parties or an improper motive there is no reason why disciplinary action should not be taken....."
12. In case of Noratanmal Chouraria v M.R.Murli reported in 2004 AIR SCW 2894, in the context of allegation of misconduct by an advocate, it was observed that:
Page 14 of 15
"7. Misconduct, inter alia, envisages breach of discipline, although it would not be possible to lay down exhaustively as to what would constitute misconduct and indiscipline, which, however, is wide enough to include wrongful omission or commission whether done or omitted to be done intentionally or unintentionally. It means, improper behaviour, intentional wrongdoing or deliberate violation of a rule of standard of behaviour....".
13. Seen from the limited scope of the writ petition at the stage where disciplinary proceedings are yet to be completed and the inquiry instituted against the petitioner is still going on, neither of the two contentions can be accepted.
In the result, the writ petition is dismissed.
(AKIL KURESHI, J.)
(MOHINDER PAL, J.)
KMGThilake)
Page 15 of 15