Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 14 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules. Pay
  • Rule 10 of the Rules
  • Rule 10 of the Central Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008
  • 6) Page 9 of 10 "...the interpretation of Rule 10 of the Rules
  • Rule 39 of the Gujarat Civil Services (Pay) Rules, 2002
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 39
  • 5) "...Rule 10 of the Rules,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 14 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules. Pay
  • Rule 10 of the Rules
  • Rule 10 of the Central Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008
  • 6) Page 9 of 10 "...the interpretation of Rule 10 of the Rules
  • Rule 39 of the Gujarat Civil Services (Pay) Rules, 2002
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 39
  • 5) "...Rule 10 of the Rules,
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary: STATE OF GUJARAT v. TAKHATSINH UDESINH SONGARA (Letters Patent Appeal No. 868 of 2021)

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a Letters Patent Appeal under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent Act challenging the order dated 11.8.2021 of a learned Single Judge which allowed a Special Civil Application filed by the petitioner (respondent No.1) and directed the respondents to grant the petitioner the benefit of one increment and to revise his pension accordingly.

Relevant factual matrix (as stated in the opinion):

  • The petitioner joined service under respondent No.2 as Chowpdar cum Driver on 19.2.1983 and was appointed as Driver with effect from 1.4.1987.
  • The petitioner's date of birth is 10.6.1960; he retired on 30.6.2020 on attaining superannuation.
  • The petitioner rendered service for the one-year period 1.7.2019 to 30.6.2020 and claimed entitlement to the annual increment for that period.
  • By communication dated 6.1.2021 the petitioner was refused the benefit of the notional increment falling due on 1.7.2020 on the ground that he had retired on 30.6.2020 and was not an employee on 1.7.2020.
  • The petitioner made a representation dated 31.7.2020 and produced examples where similarly situated employees retiring on 30th June had been granted increment; respondent No.2 made a proposal to respondent No.1 but ultimately benefit was denied as per the impugned communication.
  • The Single Judge allowed the petition concluding the rule had been misread and directed grant of benefit; the State filed this Letters Patent Appeal challenging that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a government servant who has completed the qualifying period of service (one full year of service prior to retirement) and whose annual increment "accrues" or "falls due" on 1st July but who retires on 30th June is entitled to the notional increment (for pensionary benefits) despite not being in service on the date the increment becomes payable?
  2. Whether the interpretation of the relevant rule (Rule 39 of the Gujarat Civil Services (Pay) Rules, 2002, and by analogy Rule 10 of the Central Civil Services rules considered in earlier decisions) permits grant of such notional increment for pensionary benefits when the qualifying service has been completed prior to retirement?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (State) Arguments

  • The learned Assistant Government Pleader relied on decisions of the Himachal Pradesh High Court (Hari Prakash and Others v. State of Himachal Pradesh) and decisions of the Rajasthan High Court (Safi Mohammad and Others v. State of Rajasthan; Ramji Lal Kulhari and Others v. State of Rajasthan) which took a contrary view and held that there is no entitlement to the increment where the increment becomes payable after retirement.
  • Implicit in those citations is the contention that the rule which fixes the date of increment (the proviso that the increment shall be admissible from the 1st of the month in which it accrues) precludes giving the increment to a person who is not in service on that date.

Respondent's (Petitioner's) Arguments

  • The petitioner contended that he rendered one full year of service (1.7.2019 to 30.6.2020) and thereby earned the annual increment; denial on the sole ground that the increment falls due on 1.7.2020 (a day after retirement) is a misreading of the rule.
  • The petitioner produced instances where similarly situated employees retiring on 30th June were granted the increment and relied on authorities (including P. Ayyamperumal and subsequent High Court decisions) holding that completion of the qualifying year gives a right to notional increment for pensionary benefits even if the date of increment falls on the day following retirement.
  • Counsel for respondent relied on several High Court decisions (Gopal Singh; Nand Vijay Singh; Yogendra Singh Bhadauria; AFR Arun Kumar Biswal) which interpreted analogous rules to grant the benefit where the qualifying service had been completed prior to retirement.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
P. Ayyamperumal v. The Registrar and Others (Madras High Court, W.P. No.15732 of 2017, decided 15.9.2017) Interpreted Rule 10 of the Central Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008 (similar to Rule 39 of Gujarat Rules) to hold that an employee who completed one full year of service prior to retirement must be treated as having earned the increment for pensionary benefits even though the increment falls due on the day after retirement. The Division Bench accepted the Madras High Court's interpretation as decisive; this court followed and relied upon P. Ayyamperumal as binding authority supporting grant of the notional increment.
Gopal Singh v. Union of India and Others (Delhi High Court, W.P. No.10509 of 2019, decided 23.1.2020) Explained that entitlement to increment depends on satisfactory service/good conduct for the qualifying period; increment accrues from the day following the period in which it is earned but entitlement crystallises on completion of the qualifying service and cannot be defeated merely because the pay-date falls on a day when the employee is not in service. The court accepted and relied on this reasoning to hold that denying an increment earned by completion of the qualifying period, merely because the increment becomes payable on the day after retirement, would be arbitrary; Gopal Singh was followed to support the petitioner's entitlement.
Nand Vijay Singh and Others v. Union of India and Others (Allahabad High Court, W.P. No.13299 of 2020, decided 29.6.2021) Applied the principle in P. Ayyamperumal (as described in the opinion) to hold entitlement where qualifying service had been completed before retirement. Relied upon by the respondent; the Division Bench treated such authorities as supportive of the view that the increment should be allowed.
Yogendra Singh Bhadauria and Others v. State of Madhya Pradesh (Madhya Pradesh High Court, decided 22.9.2020) Applied the principles in P. Ayyamperumal and similar authorities to hold entitlement to notional increment for pensionary benefits where qualifying service had been completed prior to retirement. Relying parties cited it; the court treated it as part of the line of supporting authorities.
AFR Arun Kumar Biswal v. State of Odisha and Another (Writ Petition No.17715 of 2020, decided 30.7.2021) Applied the same principle in favour of grant of increment where qualifying service had been completed. Referenced as supporting authority for the respondent's position; the court considered it among the consistent decisions accepting P. Ayyamperumal's interpretation.
Hari Prakash and Others v. State of Himachal Pradesh and Others (Himachal Pradesh High Court, Civil Writ Petition No.2503 of 2016, decided 6.11.2020) Held a contrary view that there is no entitlement to the increment where the date of payment falls after retirement. Relied on by the State (Appellant) in support of denying the increment; the Division Bench expressly declined to accept this contrary view.
Safi Mohammad and Others v. State of Rajasthan and Others (Rajasthan High Court, decided 1.12.2021) Held (as stated in the opinion) that there would be no entitlement to get the increment in the post-retirement scenario. Relied on by the State; the court noted this decision but did not adopt its conclusion.
Ramji Lal Kulhari and Others v. State of Rajasthan and Others (Rajasthan High Court, CWP No.85 of 2020 and group, decided 10.1.2022) Reached a conclusion similar to other Rajasthan decisions denying entitlement where the increment becomes payable after retirement. Cited by the State; the court recorded these as contrary authorities which it was unable to subscribe to.
Union of India v. Laxmanbhai Kalabhai Chavda (Division Bench of Gujarat High Court, Special Civil Application No.10751 of 2020, decided 27.1.2021) Considered Rule 10 and accepted the interpretation of the Madras High Court in P. Ayyamperumal that entitlement to increment should be recognized where qualifying service was completed though increment fell after retirement. The present Division Bench treated Laxmanbhai Chavda as binding precedent for co-ordinate Benches and explicitly followed it in reaching the same conclusion.
Special Leave Petition (Civil) Diary No.22283 of 2018 against P. Ayyamperumal (Supreme Court order dated 23.7.2018) The Supreme Court dismissed the Special Leave Petition against the Madras High Court decision (P. Ayyamperumal), effectively leaving the Madras decision intact. The Division Bench noted the dismissal of the SLP and treated it as reinforcing the authority of P. Ayyamperumal which supported the petitioner's entitlement; it formed part of the reasons for rejecting the contrary view.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Division Bench, speaking through Hon'ble Mr. Justice N.V. Anjaria, proceeded by reference to the relevant statutory/regulatory provision and the competing lines of judicial authorities.

  1. The court examined Rule 39 of the Gujarat Civil Services (Pay) Rules, 2002 (specifically Rule 39(1) and its proviso that "the increment shall be admissible from the 1st of the month in which it accrues"). The Single Judge had held that the Rule was misread by the respondents in denying the increment.
  2. The court considered the factual position that the petitioner had completed one full year of service (1.7.2019 to 30.6.2020) and that the increment for that period "fell due" on 1.7.2020, the day after his retirement on 30.6.2020.
  3. The court surveyed the authorities. It accepted the reasoning in P. Ayyamperumal (Madras High Court) and Gopal Singh (Delhi High Court) and other supporting decisions which held that:
    • Increment is an entitlement that accrues on completion of the qualifying period (subject to good conduct) and the fact that the date of payment falls on the day after retirement is a fortuitous circumstance which should not defeat the crystallised right.
    • Reading the provision mechanically to deny an earned increment because the employee is not in service on the succeeding day would be arbitrary and would defeat the purpose of the scheme for progressive appointment.
  4. The court expressly rejected the converse view taken by certain High Courts (Himachal Pradesh and Rajasthan) which denied entitlement where the increment date falls after retirement. The Division Bench stated it was "unable to subscribe to the converse view" and found the reasoning of Madras and Delhi High Courts persuasive.
  5. The court noted that the Supreme Court had dismissed the Special Leave Petition against P. Ayyamperumal (order dated 23.7.2018), and that a Division Bench of this Court (Union of India v. Laxmanbhai Kalabhai Chavda) had already accepted the Madras interpretation; as a co-ordinate Bench this court considered itself bound by that view and followed it.
  6. Applying those principles to the facts, the court agreed with the Single Judge that the petitioner had earned one increment during the last year of service and that denial of benefit merely because the increment fell due on the day after retirement was a misreading of the Rule and impermissible.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Letters Patent Appeal is dismissed. The court affirmed the order of the Single Judge which had directed grant of one increment and revision of the petitioner's pension.

Direct consequences and directions:

  • The appeal was declared meritless and dismissed.
  • Notice was discharged and interim orders were vacated.
  • The directions issued by the Single Judge (paragraph No.12 of the Single Judge's order) regarding grant of benefits to the petitioner are to be implemented; the respondents are directed to grant the benefits within six weeks from the date of the Division Bench judgment.
  • In view of disposal of the main appeal, the pending Civil Application (for stay) is disposed of as not surviving.

Broader implications: The Division Bench expressly followed and applied the line of authority exemplified by P. Ayyamperumal and Gopal Singh and related decisions, and treated prior contrary High Court decisions as not persuasive. The court also relied on an earlier Division Bench decision of the Gujarat High Court (Laxmanbhai Chavda) and noted the dismissal of the SLP against P. Ayyamperumal by the Supreme Court. The decision therefore affirms the approach that a qualifying period of service completed prior to retirement gives an entitlement to the notional increment for pensionary benefits even if the increment becomes payable on the day following retirement.

Judges: Hon'ble Mr. Justice N.V. Anjaria and Hon'ble Mr. Justice Samir J. Dave. Judgment delivered per Hon'ble Mr. Justice N.V. Anjaria on 27/04/2022.

    STATE OF GUJARAT v. TAKHATSINH UDESINH SONGARA

    C/LPA/868/2021 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 27/04/2022

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD

    R/LETTERS PATENT APPEAL NO. 868 of 2021 In R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 10308 of 2021 With

    CIVIL APPLICATION (FOR STAY) NO. 1 of 2021 In R/LETTERS PATENT APPEAL NO. 868 of 2021

    FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:

    HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N.V.ANJARIA

    and

    HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SAMIR J. DAVE

    ==========================================================

    1 Whether Reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment ? No
    2 3 To be referred to the Reporter or not ? Whether their Lordships wish to see the fair copy of the judgment ? No No
    4 Whether this case involves a substantial question of law as to the interpretation of the Constitution of India or any order made thereunder ? No

    ==========================================================

    STATE OF GUJARAT

    Versus

    TAKHATSINH UDESINH SONGARA

    ========================================================== Appearance:

    MR SAHIL TRIVEDI, AGP for the Appellant(s) No. 1 LAW OFFICER BRANCH(420) for the Respondent(s) No. 2 MR VAIBHAV A VYAS(2896) for the Respondent(s) No. 1 MS TRUSHA K PATEL(2434) for the Respondent(s) No. 2 ==========================================================

    CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N.V.ANJARIA

    and

    HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SAMIR J. DAVE

    Date :27/04/2022

    CAV JUDGMENT

    (PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N.V.ANJARIA)

    Heard learned Assistant Government Pleader Mr.Sahil

    Page 1 of 10

    Trivedi for the appellant- applicant, learned advocate Mr.Vaibhav Vyas for the respondent No.1 and learned advocate Ms.Trusha Patel for the respondent No.2.

    2. This Letters Patent Appeal under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent Act, is directed against order dated 11.8.2021 of learned Single Judge whereby the Special Civil Application filed by the petitioner- respondent No.1 herein came to be allowed. The respondents were directed to grant benefit of one increment to the petitioner and accordingly revise his pension.

    2.1 The petitioner prayed in his petition to set aside communication dated 6.1.2021. By the said communication the petitioner was refused to benefit of notional increment falling due on 1.7.2020 on the ground that the petitioner had retired with effect from 30.6.2020. It was stated in the said order that since the petitioner ceased to remain in employment he could not be considered as employee from 1stJuly, with effect from having retired a day prior, he acquires the status of pensioner and consequentially would not be entitled to the increment. The said communication dated 1.6.2021 was addressed to the Registrar General of the respondent No.1 by the under Secretary of the Legal Department of the State Government.

    3. The relevant facts to be noticed are that the petitioner joined his services under respondent No.2 as Chowpdar cum Driver on 19.2.1983. He was appointed as Driver with effect from 1.4.1987. As the date of birth of the petitioner was 10.6.1960, he retired on 30.6.2020, upon attaining the age of superannuation. The petitioner had rendered one full year of service from 1.7.2019 to 30.6.2020 in the said last year. It is his case that he was entitled to get benefit of annual increment for the said period of service. The increment for the said period of service, it was stated, falls due on

    1.7.2

    Page 2 of 10

    3.1 The petitioner made representation dated 31.7.2020 to respondent No.1 State requesting to release the increment, alongwith representation also produced by the petitioner were the instances where increment was granted to the similarly situated employees retiring on 30thJune. It is the averment of the petitioner that pursuant to the said representation, respondent No.2 made proposal to respondent No.1, however at the end of correspondence the benefit was denied as per the decision reflected in the impugned communication dated 6.1.2021.

    3.2 Learned Single Judge referred to Rule 39 of the Gujarat Civil Services (Pay) Rules, 2002 which provides for services which may be counted for increment. Rule 39(1) provides for release of increment on the first date of every month. The relevant part of Rule 39 is as under,

    "39. Service which counts for increment: The following provisions prescribe the conditions subject to which service counts for increments in a time-scale;-

    (I) Subject to the provisions of rules- 11,13,15,16,19,23,30 and 44 all periods of duty discharged in a post on a time-scale shall count for increments in that time-scale.

    For the purpose of arriving at the date of next increment in that timescale, the total of all such periods as to do not count for increment in that time-scale shall be added to the normal dates of increment.

    Provided that the increment shall be admissible from the 1st of the month in which it accrues."

    3.3 Learned Single Judge held noticing the facts of the case and the aforesaid Rule, held that the Rule was misread and misinterpreted in denying the increment to the petitioner, to observe, (Para 8)

    "The proviso to sub-rule (1) of Rule 39 stipulates

    Page 3 of 10

    that the increment shall be admissible from the 1st of the month, in which, it accrues. The petitioner has been denied the benefits of the increment for the services which he rendered prior to his retirement i.e. from 01.07.2019 to 30.06.2020 on the ground that the same accrued on 01.07.2020. The respondents have indubitably misread and misinterpreted the rule since it is not the case of the petitioner that he is claiming increment of one year after the date of retirement. The petitioner has become entitled for one increment during one year of service in the time pay-scale prior to his retirement and only because the same has accrued on 1st of every month, such benefits could not be denied by applying the rule prospectively resulting into wiping out the entire service of one year, which he has rendered in a particular time-scale. "

    3.4. While holding as above, learned Single Judge relied on the decision of the Madras High Court in P.Ayyamperumal Vs. The Registrar and Others being Writ Petition No.15732 of 2017 decided on 15.9.2017. The Madras High Court dealt with and interpreted Rule 10 of the Central Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008 which is similar. In that case, the petitioner had retired as Additional Director General, Chennai on 30.6.2013 on attaining the age of superannuation. After the Sixth Pay Commission the Central Government fixed 1stJuly to be the date of increment for all employees by amending Rule 10 of the Rules. This amendment resulted into denial of the benefit of the last increment. Though petitioner has completed full year of service on 1.7.2012 to 30.6.2013 and had retired on 30.6.2013, in view of the provisions and rules, that increment would be given only on 1.7.2013, the petitioner was treated not eligible to earn the increment. 3.4.1 The Madras High Court considered it to be a decisive circumstance that employee had completed full year of service for which the increment had become due, observing as under, (para 7)

    "The petitioner herein had completed one full year service as on 30.06.2013, but the increment fell

    Page 4 of 10

    due on 01.07.2013, on which date he was not in service. In view of the above judgment of this Court, naturally he has to be treated as having completed one full year of service, though the date of increment falls on the next day of his retirement. Applying the said judgment to the present case, the writ petition is allowed and the impugned order passed by the first respondent- Tribunal dated 21.03.2017 is quashed. The petitioner shall be given one notional increment for the period from 01.07.2012 to 30.06.2013, as he has completed one full year of service, though his increment fell on 01.07.2013, for the purpose of pensionary benefits and not for any other purpose. No costs."

    4. Learned Assistant Government Pleader relied on the decision of the Himachal Pradesh High Court in Hari Prakash and Others Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh and Others being Civil Writ Petition No.2503 of 2016 decided on 6.11.2020, further on the decision of the Rajasthan High Court in Safi Mohammad and Others Vs. State of Rajasthan and Others decided on 1.12.2021 and next also of the Rajasthan High Court in Ramji Lal Kulhari and Others Vs. State of Rajasthan and Others being Civil Writ Petition No.85 of 2020 and group of petitions decided on 10.1.2022 to submit that in the said decisions, the High Courts had taken a contrary view holding that there would occur no entitlement to get the increment.

    4.1 On the other hand, learned advocate for the respondent relied on the decisions in Gopal Singh Vs. Union of India and Others being Writ Petition No.10509 of 2019 decided by Delhi High Court on 23.1.2020, in Nand Vijay Singh and Others Vs. Union of India and Others being Writ Petition No.13299 of 2020 of Allahabad High Court decided on 29.6.2021, in Yogendra Singh Bhadauria and Others Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh of High Court of Madhya Pradesh decided on 22.9.2020, in AFR Arun Kumar Biswal Vs. State of Odisha and Another being Writ

    Page 5 of 10

    Petition No.17715 of 2020 decided on 30.7.2021. In all the above decisions P.Ayyamperumal (supra) has been considered and relied on to hold that the employee would be entitled to the benefit of increment on 1stJuly even though he had retired on 30thJune.

    5. The Delhi High Court in Gopal Singh (supra) taking same view as that of Madras High Court in P.Ayyamperumal (supra) explained that the entitlement of government servant to receive the increment, though may not be a matter of course, but is dependent upon good conduct of the central government servant and that he earns increment on the basis of his good conduct for specified period. (Para 20)

    "Payment of salary and increment to a central government servant is regulated by the provisions of F.R., CSR and Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules. Pay defined in F.R. 9(21) means the amount drawn monthly by a central government servant and includes the increment. A plain composite reading of applicable provisions leaves no ambiguity that annual increment is given to a government servant to enable him to discharge duties of the post and that pay and allowances are also attached to the post. Article 43 of the CSR defines progressive appointment to mean an appointment wherein the pay is progressive, subject to good behaviour of an officer. It connotes that pay rises, by periodical increments from a minimum to a maximum. The increment in case of progressive appointment is specified in Article 151 of the CSR to mean that increment accrues from the date following that on which it is earned. The scheme, taken cumulatively, clearly suggests that appointment of a central government servant is a progressive appointment and periodical increment in pay from a minimum to maximum is part of the pay structure. Article 151 of CSR contemplates that increment accrues from the day following which it is earned. This increment is not a matter of course but is dependent upon good conduct of the central government servant. It is, therefore, apparent that central government employee earns increment on the basis of his good conduct for specified period i.e. a year in case of annual

    Page 6 of 10

    increment. Increment in pay is thus an integral part of progressive appointment and accrues from the day following which it is earned. "

    5.1 It was stated that where a government servant observes good conduct for entire year before increment accrues, it is logical and normal that he earns the increment. Dealing with the situation where the government servant has retired on 30thJune and the increment is payable on 1stJuly, the High Court stated thus, (Para 23)

    "Annual increment though is attached to the post & becomes payable on a day following which it is earned but the day on which increment accrues or becomes payable is not conclusive or determinative. In the statutory scheme governing progressive appointment increment becomes due for the services rendered over a year by the government servant subject to his good behaviour. The pay of a central government servant rises, by periodical increments, from a minimum to the maximum in the prescribed scale. The entitlement to receive increment therefore crystallises when the government servant completes requisite length of service with good conduct and becomes payable on the succeeding day. "

    5.1.1 It was further observed by the Delhi High Court that denial of the entitlement to receive benefit when is crystallized in law could be arbitrary if it is denied unless there is valid reason. Though the increment was earned for past period it is denied on the ground that on the date when the increment becoming payable the government servant was not holding the post as he had retired, such has to be viewed to be not the valid ground to deny the increment. The High Court observed that 'the concept of day following which the increment is earned has otherwise no purpose to achieve'. It was stated, (Para 24)

    "In isolation of the purpose it serves the fixation of day succeeding the date of entitlement has no intelligible differentia nor any object is to be

    Page 7 of 10

    achieved by it. The central government servant retiring on 30th June has already completed a year of service and the increment has been earned provided his conduct was good. It would thus be wholly arbitrary if the increment earned by the central government employee on the basis of his good conduct for a year is denied only on the ground that he was not in employment on the succeeding day when increment became payable. "

    5.1.2 The retirement of the government servant on the day prior to the increment becoming payable is only fortuitous circumstance, it was rightly expressed, (Para 24)

    "In the case of a government servant retiring on 30th of June the next day on which increment falls due/becomes payable looses significance and must give way to the right of the government servant to receive increment due to satisfactory services of a year so that the scheme is not construed in a manner that if offends the spirit of reasonableness enshrined in Article 14 of the Constitution of India. The scheme for payment of increment would have to be read as whole and one part of Article 151 of CSR cannot be read in isolation so as to frustrate the other part particularly when the other part creates right in the central government servant to receive increment. This would ensure that scheme of progressive appointment remains intact and the rights earned by a government servant remains protected and are not denied due to a fortuitous circumstance. "

    5.2 The view taken by the Madras High Court in P.Ayyamperumal (supra) and by Delhi High Court in Gopal Singh (supra) and other High Courts as above, holding that the government servant is entitled to increment becoming payable on 1stJuly, even though he has retired on 30thJune, is required to be accepted. This court is in concurrence with the view taken in the aforesaid decisions by the Madras High Court and the Delhi High Court and the reasons supplied therein. This court is unable to subscribe to the converse view taken by High Courts of Himachal

    Page 8 of 10

    Pradesh and Rajasthan.

    5.3 Furthermore the Supreme Court has dismissed the Special Leave Petition (Civil) Dairy No.22283 of 2018 against the decision of the Madras High Court in P.Ayyamperumal (supra) as per the order dated 23.7.2018.

    5.4 Besides above, the Division Bench of this court in Union of India Vs. Laxmanbhai Kalabhai Chavda being Special Civil Application No.10751 of 2020 decided on 27.1.2021, dealing with the same issue accepted the interpretation of the Rule 10 made by the High Court of Madras High Court in P.Ayyamperumal (supra). The Division Bench of this court dealt with the legality of the order of the Central Administrative Tribunal which had granted the benefit. In that learned standing counsel could not dispute the judgment of the Madras High Court in P.Ayyamperumal (supra) confirmed by the Apex Court in the Special Leave Petition as above.

    5.4.1 In Laxmanbhai Chavda (supra), the Division Bench of this court observed that reading of Rule 10 of the Rules would make it clear that the government servant is entitled to the increment becoming payable on 1stJuly. (Para 5)

    "...Rule 10 of the Rules, which speaks of uniform date of annual increment, which is 1st July of every year. It says that the employees completing six months and above in the revised pay structure as on 1st July, will be eligible to be granted the increment. The first increment, after fixation of pay as per the said Rules is on 1.1.2006 in the revised pay structure which shall need to be granted on 1.7.2006 for those employees for whom the date of next increment was between 1.7.2006 to 1.1.2007."

    5.4.2 It was further stated, (Para 6)

    Page 9 of 10

    "...the interpretation of Rule 10 of the Rules made by High Court of Madras in W.P. No.15372/2017, where the Court held from the factual details that the employee before it since had completed one full year service as on 30.6.2013, i.e. the date of which he was superannuated, but the increment fell due on 1.7.2013, on which date he was not in services and therefore, it interpreted that he shall have to be treated as having completed one full year of service, though the date of increment fell on the next day of his retirement. Accordingly, the court had allowed the petition and directed that the petitioner before the High Court of Madras be given one notional increment for the period from 1.7.2012 to 30.6.2013, on his having completed one full year of service."

    5.5 As a Co-ordinate Bench, we are bound by the aforesaid view taken in Laxmanbhai Chavda (supra), and stand in agreement with the same.

    6. For the aforesaid reasons and the discussion, the present challenge to the order of the learned Single Judge in this Letters Patent Appeal stands meritless.

    7. The present Letters Patent Appeal is dismissed. Notice is discharged. Interim orders stand vacated. The directions issued in paragraph No.12 of the order of learned Single Judge regarding grant of benefits to the petitioner- respondent herein, the same shall be granted within six weeks from today and the direction shall be complied with.

    In view of disposal of the main appeal, the Civil Application will not survive. Accordingly, it is disposed of.

    (N.V.ANJARIA, J)

    (SAMIR J. DAVE,J)

    Manshi

    Page 10 of 10

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    STATE OF GUJARAT v. TAKHATSINH UDESINH SONGARA
    (Apr 27, 2022)