Per : S.S GARG
Appeal No.E/26522/2013 has been filed by the assessee against impugned order No.34-37/2013 dt. 21/02/2013 passed by the Commissioner(Appeals). The Department has also filed two appeals against the impugned orders No.34-37/2013 dt. 21/03/2013 and No.60- 61/2013 dt. 07/03/2013. The issue involved in party's appeal is the demand of reversal of service credit taken on management consultancy service pertaining to the unit in the location of area based exemption. The
1
impugned order confirmed the demand vide OIA No.34-37/2013 dt. 21/02/2013. This OIA disposed of 4 appeals pertaining to two Orders-in- Original No.137 and 138/2011 both dt. 19/12/2011 (against which both party and Department filed appeals before the Commissioner(Appeals). Further on the similar issue, the Commissioner(Appeals) vide OIA No.60- 61/2013 dt. 07/03/2013 disposed of the appeal filed by the party and the Department against Order-in-Original No.136/2011 dt. 19/12/2011. Against the said Order-in-Appeal, both the Department and the party have filed the following appeals before the Tribunal.
| Sl. No. |
Appeal No. |
OIA Nos. |
Filed by |
Present position |
| 1. |
E/26512/2013 |
No.34-37/2013 |
Assessee |
Disposed of vide Final order No.22095- 22096/2015 dt. 29/10/2015 |
| 2. |
E/26515/2013 |
No.34-37/2013 |
Department |
Present appeal |
| 3. |
E/26522/2013 |
No.34-37/2013 |
Assessee |
Present appeal |
| 4. |
E/26513/2013 |
No.60-61/2013 |
Assessee |
Disposed of vide Final Order No.22095- 22096/2015 Dt. 29/10/2015 |
| 5. |
E/26598/2013 |
No.60-61/2013 |
Department |
Present appeal |
Out of the 5 appeals filed by the party and the Department as shown in the
table, two appeals of the party have been disposed vide Final Order dt.
29/10/2015 by the Tribunal. The remaining three appeals are being
disposed of by now as the same could not be disposed of earlier vide order
dt. 29/10/2015.
2
2. Briefly the facts of the case are that the appellant M/s. Fosroc Chemicals India (P) Ltd., engaged in the manufacture of admixatures, resin products and powder products falling under tariff heading 3824, 3408 and 3214 of CETA 1985. The registered office at Bangalore is having Input Service Distributor (ISD) registration under service tax for payment of service tax and distribute the credit to their various manufacturing units. The appellant is availing area based exemption under Notification No.50/2003 dt. 10/06/2003 in respect of their operations at the Rudrapur unit. During the course of audit of the records of ISD by the internal audit team, it was observed that the ISD had paid service tax on the payment made towards receiving Management Consultancy Service in terms of Section 65(105)(r) of the Finance Act, 1994. The ISD had distributed the entire service tax credit taken in respect of Management Consultancy Service which is commonly used for all the units of the ISD (including Rudrapur unit) without reversing the portion of the CENVAT credit which is attributable to their exemption unit at Rudrapur. As per Rule 7(b) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004, credit of service tax attributable to service used in a unit exclusively engaged in the manufacture of exempted goods or providing of exempted services shall not be distributed. On these allegation, show-cause notices were issued and after following the due process, Order-in-original dt. 19/12/2011 was passed. Aggrieved by the said order, assessee as well as the Department filed appeal before the Commissioner(Appeals) who disposed of all the appeals by the impugned order.
3
3. Heard both the parties and peruse records.
4. Learned consultant for the appellant submitted that the impugned orders are not sustainable in law as the same has been passed without properly considering the submissions of the appellant. He further submitted that Rule 7(b) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 would apply only if the services are exclusively utilized in a unit engaged in the manufacture of exempted goods. The services received by the Head Office are common services which are utilized in all the factories. They are not services which are exclusively utilized at Rudrapur and therefore he submitted that Rule 7(b) is not attracted to the facts of the case. He further submitted that there is no prohibition for an ISD to distribute credit of service tax paid on common input services to units which are paying excise duty to the exclusion of another unit. He also submitted that the show- cause notices proceeded on wrong interpretation to Rule 7(b) of CENVAT Credit Rules 2004. In support of this submission, he relied upon the decision of the Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka in the case of CCE Vs. ECOF Industries Pvt. Ltd. [2011(271) ELT 58 (Kar.)] wherein the Hon'ble High Court held that an Input service Distributor can distribute the credit of service tax to a unit of their choice and there is no requirement that the services received by the ISD should have actually been received in manufacturing unit. The learned consultant further submitted that the appellant has not committed an act of fraud, collusion, misrepresentation or willful misstatement with a view to evade service tax as the appellant was under a bona fide belief that it can distribute the service tax credit to units
4
at Kuluvanahalli and Ankleshwar. Under these circumstances, invocation of larger period of limitation is not tenable in view of the following decisions:-
i. Center for Development of Advance Computing Vs. CCE
[2002(141) ELT 6 (SC)]
ii. Gopal Zarda Udyog Vs. CCE [2005(188) ELT 251 (SC)]
5. He further submitted that the appellant distributed the credit of service tax to two units only on the basis of a bona fide interpretation of Rule 7(b). he further submitted that the issue being one of interpretation, larger period of limitation cannot be invoked. He also submitted that the various penalties under Section s76, 77 & 78 are not imposable as the conditions for imposing the said penalties are not present in the facts and circumstances of this case.
6. On the other hand, the learned AR submitted that out of the 5 appeals shown in the table above, this Tribunal vide its Final Order No.22095-22096/2015 dt. 29/10/2015 disposed of the appeals at Sl.No.1 pertaining to Order-in-Appeal No.34-37/2013 and Sl.No.4 pertaining to Order-in-Appeal No.60-61/2013. She further submitted that appeals at Sl.No.2 & 3 pertains to the impugned order No.34/-37/2013 and appeal covered under this Order-in-Appeal has already been disposed of vide Final Order No.22095-22096/2015 dt. 29/10/2015. She also submitted that appeal at Sl.No.5 pertains to Order-in-Appeal No.60-61/2013 which has already been disposed of vide Final order No.22-95-22096/2015 dt.
5
29/10/2015. She further submitted that the impugned order relates to the appeals which have already been considered and Final orders have already been passed. She also submitted that the decision of the Tribunal disposing of two appeals vide order dt. 29/10/2015 have not been appealed against by the assessee and it has attained finality. She also submitted that in the present appeals, there is nothing new for this Tribunal to be considered since these appeals also against the same impugned order already decided by the Hon'ble Tribunal vide its order dt. 29/10/2015. She further submitted that the two Departmental appeals related to non-demand of the demand on the plant and non-imposition of penalty on the plant whereas the impugned order has confirmed demand against ISD. She further prayed that the present appeals should also be decided in the light of the Final orders earlier passed by the Tribunal dt. 29/10/2015.
7. After considering the submissions of both the parties and perusal of material on record as well as the judgment of this Tribunal in the appellant's own case whereby the Tribunal vide order dt. 29/10/2015 disposed of two appeals against the same impugned order. Further I find that in the order dt. 29/10/2015, this Tribunal has considered all the submissions of the assessee which have been raised in the present appeals also by the assessee as well as by the Department. Further I also find that the issues which are before this Tribunal in the present appeals have already been considered in the earlier appeals decided by the Tribunal and therefore I find nothing new to be considered in the present appeals. It is also a fact that the assessee has not challenged the order of
6
the Tribunal dt. 29/10/2015 vide which the Tribunal has disposed of two appeals of the appellant/assessee. Therefore by following the judicial discipline, I dispose of the appeal of the assessee on the same terms and condition vide which the earlier appeals were disposed of. Here it is pertinent to reproduce the relevant findings contained in para 6 to 9 of the said decision of Tribunal.
6. However, I find no force in the above plea of the appellant. In terms of Rule 7(b), the service tax attributable to service used in a unit 'exclusively' engaged in the manufacture of exempted goods is not available. The expression
'exclusively' appearing in the said Rule relates to the unit and not to the service tax. The unit has to be exclusively engaged in the manufacture of exempted goods meaning thereby that if service tax stands utilized in a unit which is manufacturing exempted as also dutiable goods, the said Rule will have no application. The expression "exclusively" is not associated with the word
"service tax" as suggested by the learned advocate. It is well settled law of interpretation that where the words of a particular provision is unambiguous, no extraneous words can be introduced or taken out or can be allowed to switch places. As such, the expression "exclusively" cannot be associated with the service tax availed by a unit manufacturing exempted goods. As such, I find no justification in the appellant's contention.
Inasmuch as the said Rule debars taking of credit attributable to service tax used in a unit exclusively engaged in the manufacture of exempted goods and inasmuch as the Rudrapur unit is admittedly engaged in the manufacture of only exempted goods, I am of the view that the credit of service tax in respect of services used in the said Rudrapur unit is not available to the appellant's ISD. The order of the lower authorities to that extent, disallowing proportionate credit is upheld.
7. As regards the penalty, learned Chartered Accountant Shri Ramasubramanian has drawn my attention to the provisions of Rule 15 of Cenvat Credit Rules under which penalty stands imposed. The period involved in the present appeals is April, 2006 to April, 2010. The penalties stand imposed in terms of Rule 15(3) of the Cenvat Credit Rules. By drawing my attention to the said Rule, learned advocate submits that prior to 17-2-2010, the Rule read as under :-
"Confiscation and penalty. — (1) If any person, takes Cenvat credit in respect of input or capital goods wrongly or in contravention of any of the provisions of these rules in respect of any input or capital goods, then, all such goods shall be liable to confiscation and such person, shall be liable to a penalty not exceeding the duty on the excisable goods in respect of which any contravention has been committed, or two thousand rupees, whichever is greater.
(2) In a case, where the Cenvat credit in respect of input or capital goods has been taken or utilised wrongly on account of fraud, wilful misstatement, collusion or suppression of facts, or contravention of any of the provisions of the Excise Act, or the rules made thereunder with intention to evade payment of duty, then, the manufacturer shall also be liable to pay penalty in terms of the provisions of section 11AC of the Excise Act.
(3) If any person takes Cenvat credit in respect of input services, wrongly or in contravention of any of the provisions of these rules in respect of any input service, then, such person, shall be liable to a penalty which may extend to an amount not exceeding two thousand rupees.
7
(4) In a case, where the Cenvat credit in respect of input services has been taken or utilised wrongly by reason of fraud, collusion, wilful misstatement, suppression of facts, or contravention of any of the provisions of the Finance Act, or of the rules made thereunder with intention to evade payment of service tax, then the provider of output service shall also be liable to pay penalty in terms of the provisions of section 78 of the Finance Act.
(5) Any order under sub-rule (1), sub-rule (2), sub-rule (3), or sub-rule (4) shall be issued by the Central Excise Officer following the principles of natural justice."
He submits that the said rules were amended with effect from 27-2-2010 and amended provisions read as under :-
"Confiscation and penalty. — (1) If any person, takes or utilises Cenvat credit in respect of input or capital goods or input services, wrongly or in contravention of any of the provisions of these rules, then, all such goods shall be liable to confiscation and such person, shall be liable to a penalty in terms of clause (a) or clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 11AC of the Excise Act or sub-section (1) section 76 of the Finance Act (32 of 1994), as the case may be
(2) In a case, where the Cenvat credit in respect of input or (2) capital goods or input services has been taken or utilised wrongly by reason of fraud, collusion or any wilful mis-statement or suppression of facts, or contravention of any of the provisions of the Excise Act, or of the rules made thereunder with intent to evade payment of duty, then, the manufacturer shall also be liable to pay penalty in terms of the provisions of [clause (c), clause (d) or clause (e) of sub- section (1) of section 11AC of the Excise Act.
(3) In a case, where the Cenvat credit in respect of input or capital goods or input services has been taken or utilised wrongly by reason of fraud, collusion or any wilful misstatement or suppression of facts, or contravention of any of the provisions of these rules or of the Finance Act or of the rules made thereunder with intent to evade payment of service tax, then, the provider of output service shall also be liable to pay penalty in terms of the provisions of section (1) of Any Section 78 of the Finance Act.
(4) Any order under sub-rule (1), sub-rule (2) or sub-rule (3) shall be issued by the Central Excise Officer following the principles of natural justice." He submits that a comparison of both the Rules would show that Rule 15(1)(2) apply only in respect of inputs and capital goods and it was Rule 15(3) which was invocable in the case of wrong availment of Cenvat credit of service tax. The said Rule provided maximum penalty of Rs. 2000/-. However, after the amendment, provisions of Rule 15(3) included the wrong availment of service tax in respect of input services. However, the assessee was to be imposed penalty only when the credit was availed wrongly by way of fraud collision or in wilful misstatement of suppression of facts. He submits that in the 1st case, the provisions of earlier Rule 15(3) which would apply, which provide for penalty for Rs. 2,000/- only and in the other case it is the amended provisions of Rule 15(3) which would apply, and submits that even the said amended provisions would not be invocable in their case inasmuch as the entire credit was availed on the basis of documents and by reflecting the same in the statutory records, there was no mala fide intention on their part so as to invoke the amended Rule 15(3).
8. On a careful consideration of the above submission of the learned advocate, I find that in Appeal No. 26512/2013, the entire period is prior to the amendment of Rule 15(3). If that be so, the penal provisions invokable against an assessee would be unamended Rule 15(3) which provided for penalty of Rs. 2,000/-. The said Rule simpliciter provided for penalty, on wrong availment of credit without there being any nexus with the mala fide intention. Inasmuch as the appellants have availed wrong Cenvat credit, I reduce the penalty to Rs. 2000/-.
8
9. In the second appeal, the amended provisions of Rule 15(3) would be applicable which provided for imposition of penalty in case of mala fide intention of the assessee. Admittedly, the appellants have availed the credit by reflecting the same in all the statutory records and the issue is also disputed issue of legal interpretation, I find no justifiable reason to impose penalty upon the assessee. Accordingly the penalty imposed in Appeal No. 26513/2013 is set aside.
8. As far as Department's appeals are concerned, I do not find any force in the grounds raised by the Department as the Department's appeals only relate to the non-imposition of penalty on the plant as well as on the ISD. Therefore I do not find any merit in the Department's appeals and the same are dismissed. As far as assessee's appeal is concerned, the same is disposed of on the same terms on which earlier two appeals were disposed of vide Final order dt. 29/10/2015.
(Pronounced on ………………………….)
S.S GARG
JUDICIAL MEMBER
Raja...
9