Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Mahendra Chawla, applied for the post of Constable Store Keeper (Male) in the Border Security Force (BSF) on 12 July 2022 and successfully cleared all examinations. He was called for a Medical Examination on 17 November 2022 but was declared unfit due to a tattoo on his right forearm. Subsequently, the petitioner removed the tattoo and obtained a certificate dated 18 November 2022 from a tattoo removal service. Despite this, upon being called for a Review Medical Examination, he was again declared unfit. The petitioner filed the present writ petition seeking a writ of mandamus or any other appropriate direction to declare him fit in the medical examination, to quash the report dated 18 November 2022 by the Medical Board, and to direct respondents to allow him to re-conduct the medical examination afresh.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner can claim appointment to the post of Constable Store Keeper in BSF despite having a tattoo removed after the recruitment process had commenced?
  2. Whether the provisions regarding tattoos as stipulated in the BSF recruitment advertisement can be waived or relaxed in the petitioner’s case?
  3. Whether the Court can issue directions contrary to the conditions laid down in the recruitment advertisement under Article 226 of the Constitution of India?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner belongs to a rural area where tattoos are customary and traditional.
  • The petitioner removed the tattoo immediately after being declared unfit and obtained a certificate of removal.
  • The tattoo was only 2 to 3 cm in size, and thus the petitioner should be considered fit and allowed to continue in the recruitment process.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The petitioner was declared unfit by the Medical Board due to the tattoo on the right forearm during the initial medical examination.
  • The petitioner appeared before the Review Committee after removal of the tattoo as per the Medical Board’s suggestion but was still declared unfit.
  • The recruitment advertisement clearly states that tattoos must be removed prior to appearing for the recruitment process and must have faded substantially to be treated as scars, which was not the case here.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the relevant provisions of the recruitment advertisement published by the Ministry of Home Affairs (Directorate General Border Security Force), specifically paragraph No.D(d) relating to medical standards for tattoos. The advertisement permits tattoos only if they depict religious symbols or figures and are located on traditional sites such as the inner left forearm or dorsum of the hands, with size restrictions. Crucially, it mandates that any tattoo removal must have been completed prior to participation in the recruitment process, and the tattoo must have faded substantially to be treated as a scar. The petitioner had a tattoo on the right forearm during the recruitment process, which was disallowed. Removal of the tattoo after the recruitment process commenced does not satisfy the advertisement’s conditions. The Court held that the petitioner’s attempt to cure the infirmity post facto could not override the clear terms of the advertisement. Therefore, the petitioner could not claim appointment based on tattoo removal after the recruitment process and the medical examination had taken place.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is summarily rejected.

The Court’s decision directly denies the petitioner’s claim for appointment based on tattoo removal post recruitment process. No directions contrary to the recruitment advertisement’s conditions are permissible under Article 226 of the Constitution. The ruling reinforces adherence to the specific medical standards and procedural requirements prescribed in recruitment advertisements for disciplined forces. No new precedent was established beyond affirming the binding nature of the stated recruitment conditions.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    MAHENDRA CHAWLA S/O GOPAL CHAWLA v. UNION OF INDIA

    C/SCA/24720/2022 ORDER DATED: 08/12/2022

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD

    R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 24720 of 2022

    ========================================================== MAHENDRA CHAWLA S/O GOPAL CHAWLA

    Versus

    UNION OF INDIA

    ========================================================== Appearance:

    MR CZ SANKHLA(3243) for the Petitioner(s) No. 1 for the Respondent(s) No. 1,2,3,4,5,6

    ==========================================================

    CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.S. SUPEHIA

    Date : 08/12/2022

    ORAL ORDER

    1. The writ petition has been filed for the following prayers:

    "6(B) YOUR LORDSHIPS be pleased to issue writ of mandamus and or any other appropriate writ, orders or directions to the Respondents herein to declare the Petition as FIT in Medical Examination as the Petitioner already undergone to Remove the Tattoo and further be pleased to declare the act of the Respondents as illegal, arbitrary and discriminatory against the petitioner.

    (C) YOUR LORDSHIPS be pleased to quash and set aside the Report dated 18/11/2022 issued by the Respondent no.6 and further direct the Respondent no.5 and 6 to allow the Petitioner to re-conduct Medical Examination afresh."

    2. The petitioner applied for the post of Constable Store Keeper (Male) in Border Security Force (BSF) on 12.07.2022 and cleared all the examinations and thereafter, he was called for Medical Examination on 17.11.2022. It is the case of the petitioner that he has not been appointed in view of a tattoo on his right forearm. After

    Page 1 of 5

    such a report was made by the Medical Board declaring him unfit in view of the tattoo, he thereafter, got the tattoo removed and accordingly, also obtained certificate dated 18.11.2022 from one M/s.Jai Bhole Tattoo. The petitioner was called for Review Medical Examination however, he was declared unfit.

    3. Learned advocate appearing for the petitioner has submitted that the petitioner is a resident of rural village and there is custom and tradition in the rural areas to get the tattoo on the body and when his case was rejected on the ground of tattoo, he immediately got it removed. It is submitted that the respondents may accordingly, be directed to consider his case of appointment to the said post since tattoo was only 2/3 cm in size. Learned advocate on the contrary, has submitted that the petitioner has appeared before the Review Committee in view of the suggestion of the Medical Board to undergo the process of removal of tattoo and after he had removed the same immediately within a period of 4 days, he was examined by the Review Board.

    4. The petitioner is seeking appointment to the post of Constable Store Keeper in a Disciplined Force such as BSF. The norms are already published by the Ministry of Home Affairs (Directorate General Board Security Force) in the

    Page 2 of 5

    detailed advertisement. The provision with regard to tattoo has been mentioned in paragraph No.D(d), which reads as under:

    "(D) MEDICAL STANDARDS FOR THE POST OF SUB INSPR(TECH) & CONSTABLE(TECH)

    (d) TATTOO :-

    Content - Being a secular country, the religious sentiments of out countryman are to be respected and thus, tattoos depicting religious symbol of figures and the name, as followed in Indian Army are permitted.

    Location - Tattoos marked on traditional sites of the body like inner aspect of forearm but only left forearm, being non saluting limb or dorsum of the hands are to be allowed.

    Size - Size musy be less than ¼ of the particular part (Elbow or hand) of the body.

    In case of candidate has undergone removal of tattoo (s) prior to appearing for recruitment process and the same has faded substantially, this will be treated as a "scar" and not a tattoo. Such candidate will be permitted to undergo the entire selection process with approval of Presiding officer of the recruitment Board. Further, the scar resulting die to removal of tattoo will be reviewed by the Medical Board of officers during detailed Medical examination."

    5. In the advertisement, the location and size of tattoo are already mentioned. It is also mentioned that in case of a candidate, who has undergone removal process of tattoo "prior to appearing in the recruitment process" and the same has faded substantially, the same will be

    Page 3 of 5

    treated as a scar and not a tattoo and such candidate is permitted to undergo the entire selection process with the approval of Presiding Officer of the Recruitment Board and further, the scar, resulting due to removal of tattoo, will be reviewed by the Medical Officer during the detailed examination.

    6. Unquestionably, in the present case, the petitioner was already having tattoo, after he had undergone the recruitment process. As per the Review Examination Board, the tattoo was found on the right forearm of the petitioner depicting a heart and arrow with initials 'M' and he was declared unfit. Thus, the provision of the advertisement mandates that tattoo should have been removed prior to the recruitment process and the same must have faded substantially. Thus, the petitioner cannot claim appointment in the Disciplined Force, after removal of his tattoo, that too after undergoing the recruitment process.

    7. Thus, this Court does not find any illegality or infirmity in the order passed by the respondent authority denying his appointment as per the specific provision of paragraph No.D(d) of the advertisement. Infirmity cannot be subsequently cured in order to dilute the provision of the advertisement. The candidate, as

    Page 4 of 5

    per the provision as mentioned hereinabove, prior to participation in the recruitment process should have undergone the process of removal of tattoo resulting into its fading substantially and only such removal of tattoo can be treated as a scar and not tattoo.

    8. In the present case, the aforesaid provisions are absolutely violated and hence, the petitioner cannot claim appointment to the aforesaid post and this Court, while exercising discretion under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, cannot issue such directions, which are contrary to the conditions envisaged in the advertisement.

    9. The present writ petition is summarily rejected.

    Sd/-

    (A. S. SUPEHIA, J)

    NVMEWADA

    Page 5 of 5

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    MAHENDRA CHAWLA S/O GOPAL CHAWLA v. UNION OF INDIA
    (Dec 8, 2022)