ORAL JUDGMENT
1. The present appeal is directed against judgment and order of conviction dated 25.2.2004 passed by learned 2nd Ad hoc Additional Sessions Judge, Nagpur in Sessions Trial No.285 of 2002. By the impugned judgment, the appellant is convicted for the offences
.....2/-
1
2
punishable under Sections 489-B, 489-C, and 420 of the Indian Penal Code. Sentence for conviction under Section 489-B of the Indian Penal Code is, rigorous imprisonment for 7 years and payment of fine of Rs.5000/- and, in default of payment of the fine amount, rigorous imprisonment for 1 year. Sentence for conviction under Section 489-C of the Indian Penal Code is, rigorous imprisonment for 7 years and payment of fine of Rs.2000/- and, in default of payment of the fine amount, rigorous imprisonment for 6 months. So also, sentence for his conviction under Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code is, rigorous imprisonment for 5 years and is handed down payment of fine of Rs.2000/- and, in default of payment of the fine amount, rigorous imprisonment for 6 months.
2. Heard learned counsel Shri J.M. Gandhi for the appellant and learned Additional Public Prosecutor Shri V.A. Thakare for the State.
3. According to learned counsel Shri J.M. Gandhi for the
.....3/-
3
appellant, the prosecution has not proved its case beyond reasonable doubt against the appellant. He submitted that there is no evidence at all to establish mens rea on the part of the appellant for his conviction under Section 489-B of the Indian Penal Code. Similarly, he submitted that there is a doubt as to really whether any counterfeit note was seized from possession of the appellant and, therefore, he cannot be convicted for the offence punishable under Section 489-C of the Indian Penal Code. He submitted that evidences and contemporaneous documents, which are proved during the course of the Trial, failed to prove its case against the appellant beyond reasonable doubt and, therefore, the appellant needs to be acquitted. He relied on decisions in the cases of Umashankar vs. State of Chattisgarh, reported at 2001 CRI. L.J. 4696; Ashok Baburao Shinde vs. State of Maharashtra, reported at 2005(2) Mh.L.J. 63 , and Madan Lal Sarma vs. The State, reported at 1990 CRI L.J. 215 and prayed for acquittal.
4. Per contra, learned Additional Public Prosecutor Shri V.A.
.....4/-
4
Thakare for the State submitted that the appellant was found in possession of a counterfeit note. There is no reason to depose against the appellant by the prosecution witnesses. He supported the judgment of the Trial Court and prayed for dismissal of the appeal.
5. The law was set into motion by Sadhu Laxmanrao Bhoyar (PW1) by lodging his report dated 18.3.2002 (Exhibit 8). On the basis of the oral report, the Police Station Officer registered an offence vide Crime No.40/2002. The printed First Information Report (F.I.R.) is at Exhibit 9.
6. Initially, the offence was registered only against the appellant. During the course of his interrogation, as per evidence of Investigating Officer Sudam Purnaji Sahare (PW6), the appellant disclosed to him that a counterfeit note was given to him by Ashoksingh. Therefore, said Ashoksingh was also arrested under arrest panchanama (Exhibit 30).
.....5/-
5
7. The charge-sheet was filed against both the accused persons. The charge was framed against the appellant and co-accused Ashoksingh by learned Judge of the Court below.
8. In order to bring home the guilt of the accused persons, the prosecution has examined in all 6 witnesses and also relied upon various proved documents.
9. Learned Judge of the Court below, by the impugned judgment, though acquitted original accused No.2 Ashoksingh, convicted the appellant as observed in the opening paragraph of this judgment. Though accused No.2 Ashoksingh was acquitted by learned Judge of the Court below, no further appeal is carried by the State challenging his acquittal.
10. As per report (Exhibit 8), first informant Sadhu Laxmanrao Bhoyar (PW1), reported that he works in a 'Country-Liquor Shop' owned by one Deepak Jaisinghani since last 5-6 years. On 18.3.2002, as usual, at
.....6/-
6
10:00 O'clock, he opened the shop and was doing his business. Along with him, his brother Madhu Bhoyar (PW5) was also present. At 17:20 hours, the appellant came to the shop. He tendered a currency note of Rs.50/- and purchased country liquor worth Rs.8/- and consumed the same then and there and, thereafter, left the shop by taking Rs.42/- with him. The report states that after leaving of the appellant, it was noticed by Sadhu Bhoyar that the currency note of Rs.50/- is not a genuine one but it was a spurious one. The said fact was informed by him to his brother. At that time, the appellant again came to the shop and was tendering a currency note of Rs.50/- in the process of demanding country liquor worth Rs.8/-. That time, it was noticed by the first informant that the note in the hand of the appellant was like the note which was already tendered to him and, therefore, he was apprehended there and made a phone-call to the police station.
11. PW6 Investigating Officer Sudam Sahare corroborates that he received a phone-call from first informant Sadhu Bhoyar and,
.....7/-
7
thereafter, taking sanha entry (Exhibit 28) in station diary, he went to the liquor shop along with the staff. There, he made a search of the appellant in presence of panchas and one note of Rs.50/- was found in his shirt-pocket. The said was seized under seizure memo (Exhibit 15) in the presence of panchas i.e. Madhu Bhoyar (PW5) and Mayangraj Babu Nagwanshi (PW3). He also seized the note from Sadhu Bhoyar (PW1) by drawing a seizure panchanama (Exhibit 10). Both these notes were sent to the Reserve Bank of India under requisition (Exhibit 22). Suresh Pochanna Kodmalwar (PW4), who at the relevant time was working as Treasurer in the Reserve Bank of India, gave his opinion (Exhibit 23) to the effect that the currency notes sent to him are not genuine notes.
12. If evidences of PW1 Sadhu Bhoyar and PW5 Madhu Bhoyar are scrutinized, it appears that these two prosecution witnesses are making out altogether different case about the time of the incident, from what is reported in oral report (Exhibit 8).
As observed in Exhibit 8, oral report, it is reported by PW1
.....8/-
8
Sadhu Bhoyar, that at about 17:20 hours, the appellant came to the liquor shop where he was discharging his duties and purchased liquor worth Rs.8/- by tendering a spurious note worth Rs.50/-. However, before the Court on oath he states that the appellant came to his shop at about 11:10 a.m.. Even, PW5 Madhu Bhoyar, who was also working with PW1 Sadhu Bhoyar in the shop, states from the witness-box that at 11:30 a.m. his brother Sadhu Bhoyar (PW1) informed him that one note of Rs.50/- of different type is kept separate in cash box.
13. Thus, PW1 Sadhu Bhoyar departs himself in respect of the time of the incident as noted in the F.I.R.. Not only that, PW5 Madhu Bhoyar on oath deposed that at 11:30 a.m. his brother told him that different note is kept separately in the cash box. This particular note is seized under seizure panchanama (Exhibit 10). If the appellant is coming for the first time at 17:20 hours, as reported in the F.I.R., he cannot be connected to the note which was already available in the cash box at 11:30 a.m.. This particular aspect is totally missed by learned Judge of
.....9/-
9
the Court below while appreciating the prosecution evidences in its true perspective.
14. Though Exhibit 15 shows that another spurious note is seized from possession of the appellant, PW1 Sadhu Bhoyar and PW5 Madhu Bhoyar are blissfully silent in their evidences that in their presence a spurious note of Rs.50/- was seized from possession of the appellant. Though PW3 Mayangraj Nagwanshi confirms the recitals in Exhibit 15, in my view, on closure scrutiny of his evidence, it is really doubtful. As per Exhibit 15, only one spurious note was seized from the appellant. However, Mayangraj Nagwanshi (PW3) states that in his presence two notes denomination of Rs.50/- were seized from the appellant under seizure memo (Exhibit 15).
15. Further, according to F.I.R. (Exhibit 8), when on second occasion the appellant came and was in the process of tendering spurious one, he was caught hold. According to the F.I.R., at that particular point of time, the note was in his hand. If that be so, there
.....10/-
10
ought to have been 3 notes on record. However, only two spurious notes were sent to determine their genuineness to the Reserve Bank of India.
16. Treasurer, in the Reserve Bank of India, Suresh Kodmalwar (PW4) states that only the General Manager of the Government Printing Press at Nashik and at Dewas are qualified to give final opinion. Not only that, he asked the police department to obtain their final report. In spite of this fact, being known to the Investigating Officer, no such step was taken. Not only that, PW6 Investigating Officer Sudam Sahare admitted during the course of his evidence that though he received letter from the Reserve Bank of India to send notes either to Nashik or Dewas Currency Note Press, he did not send those notes either to Nashik or Dewas. Thus, final opinion about genuineness of those notes seized is not brought on record.
17. The F.I.R. is registered at 17:35 hours. There is no explanation from the prosecution as to why immediately the factum of receipt of the spurious notes was not informed to the police and they
.....11/-
11
made a wait till return of the appellant to purchase liquor by using spurious note on second occasion.
18. In order to sustain the conviction under Section 489-C of the Indian Penal Code, the possession of the spurious note, together with that said note was intended to be used, is required to be proved.
19. In the present case, Exhibit 10, seizure panchanama, shows that the spurious note was seized not from the appellant but from possession of the first informant. Secondly, insofar as the note seized under Exhibit 15 is concerned, the evidence of the prosecution is not inspiring confidence in view of the evidences of PW1 Sadhu Bhoyar and PW5 Madhu Bhoyar who are blissfully silent that in their presence the note was seized from the possession of the appellant. Except these two notes, no other currency note was seized from the appellant even after taking a search of the appellant.
In that view of the matter, the conviction of the appellant
.....12/-
12
under Section 489-C of the Indian Penal Code is unsustainable.
20. Insofar as conviction under Section 489-B of the Indian Penal Code is concerned, the burden is on the prosecution to prove that at the time when the appellant was passing the currency note, he knew that it was a forged one. Mere possession of it by him would not shift the burden on the appellant to prove his innocence regarding the possession of the forged note. In that behalf, the Honourable Apex Court, in the case of Umashankar vs. State of Chattisgarh cited supra in paragraph No.8 of the judgment, rules as under:
"A perusal of the provisions, extracted above, shows that mens rea of offences under Sections 489-B and 489-C is, "knowing or having reason to believe the currency-notes or bank-notes are forged or counterfeit". Without the afore-mentioned mens rea selling, buying or receiving from another person or otherwise trafficking in or using as genuine forged or counterfeit currency-notes or bank-notes, is not enough to constitute offence under Section 489-B of
.....13/-
13
I.P.C. So also possessing or even intending to use any forged or counterfeit currency-notes or bank-notes is not sufficient to make out a case under Section 489-C in the absence of the mens rea, noted above. No material is brought on record by the prosecution to show that the appellant had the requisite mens rea. The High Court, however, completely missed this aspect. The learned trial judge on the basis of the evidence of P.W. 2, P.W. 4 and P.W. 7 that they were able to make out that currency note alleged to have been given to P.W. 4, was fake "presumed" such a mens rea. On the date of the incident the appellant was said to be 18 years old student. On the facts of this case the presumption drawn by the trial court is not warranted under Section 4 of the Evidence Act. Further it is also not shown that any specific question with regard to the currency-notes being fake or counterfeit was put to the appellant in his examination under Section 313 of Criminal Procedure Code. On these facts we have no option but to hold that the charges framed under Sections 489-B and 489-C are not proved. We, therefore, set aside the
.....14/-
14
conviction and sentence passed on the appellant under Sections 489-B and 489-C of I.P.C. and acquit him of the said charges [see: M. Mammutti v. State Of Karnataka ., AIR 1979 SC 1705]."
21. Further, from Exhibit 32, prosecution document, shows that after arrest of the appellant, he disclosed that the note was given to him by co-accused Ashoksingh and, therefore, this Ashoksingh's house was searched and nothing was found in the same. There is no evidence brought on record by the prosecution to show that at the time of taking note from Ashoksingh, it was made known to the appellant that the note is a spurious and it cannot be circulated as valid tender for purchase of any item or commodity.
22. In that view of the matter, in my view, the present prosecution case is groping in pitch dark. It only raises a suspicion. A suspicion, however, strong it may, cannot be a ground for conviction unless the case against the accused is proved beyond reasonable doubt. In the present case, right from the time of the occurrence, there is a
.....15/-
15
doubt in the prosecution case. Therefore, benefit is required to be extended in favour of the appellant. Consequently, I pass the following order:
ORDER
(a) The criminal appeal is allowed.
(b) Judgment and order of conviction dated 25.2.2004 passed by learned 2nd Ad hoc Additional Sessions Judge, Nagpur in Sessions Trial No.285 of 2002 is hereby set aside.
(c) The appellant is acquitted of the offences punishable under Sections 489-B, 489-C and 420 of the Indian Penal Code.
(d) The Bail Bonds of the appellant stand cancelled.
JUDGE
!! BRW !!
...../-