Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 307, 448, 147, 148, 506 read with 149 of IPC.
  • Sections 106, 107, 108(1) (i) and 110(e) and (g) of Cr.P.C. C. Persons
  • sections 59 and 70 of the Hyderabad City Police Act
  • Sections 106, 107, 108(c) and 110(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Act No.2 of 1974); (c) persons
  • Section 3, clause 12, of the Towns Nuisances Act; (d) persons
  • Section 75 of the Madras City Police Act
  • Sections 447, 427 and 506 read with 34 IPC.
  • section 3, clause 12, of the AP Towns Nuisances Act. D. Persons
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 307, 448, 147, 148, 506 read with 149 of IPC.
  • Sections 106, 107, 108(1) (i) and 110(e) and (g) of Cr.P.C. C. Persons
  • sections 59 and 70 of the Hyderabad City Police Act
  • Sections 106, 107, 108(c) and 110(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Act No.2 of 1974); (c) persons
  • Section 3, clause 12, of the Towns Nuisances Act; (d) persons
  • Section 75 of the Madras City Police Act
  • Sections 447, 427 and 506 read with 34 IPC.
  • section 3, clause 12, of the AP Towns Nuisances Act. D. Persons
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion: Writ Petition No.22980 of 2020 (High Court for the State of Telangana, Hyderabad)

Factual and Procedural Background

This writ petition was filed by Mansoor Shah Khan and three others seeking a declaration that the respondents' action in opening Rowdy Sheet Nos.1284, 1285, 1286 and 1287/RS/ACP-BH/2019 dated 11.12.2019 and continuing the same against the petitioners was illegal, and for a consequential direction to the respondents to close those rowdy sheets and not call the petitioners to the police station.

There are four petitioners. According to the petitioners, they were involved in two police matters: Crime No.331 of 2015 (Banjara Hills Police Station) — charges under Sections 447, 427 and 506 read with 34 IPC; charge-sheeted and taken on file as C.C. No.650 of 2017; proceedings ended in acquittal by judgment dated 22.02.2018, which attained finality as no appeal was filed.

Crime No.926 of 2019 (Banjara Hills Police Station) — offences under Sections 307, 448, 147, 148, 506 read with 149 IPC; charge-sheeted and pending as PRC No.307 of 2020.

Petitioners alleged that rowdy sheets were opened and continued against them without following the procedure in the A.P. Police Manual and contrary to legal principles, and that the police have been calling and harassing them at the police station. Respondents (through the Station House Officer and Government Pleader for Home) contended the rowdy sheets were opened with ACP permission and are continued in public interest and under Standing Orders, to curb unlawful activities; respondents also denied the alleged harassment.

The writ petition was allowed. The court directed the respondents to close the rowdy sheets maintained in the names of the petitioners on the file of Banjara Hills Police Station, Hyderabad, with no order as to costs; miscellaneous petitions, if any, were closed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the opening and continuation of Rowdy Sheet Nos.1284, 1285, 1286 and 1287/RS/ACP-BH/2019 dated 11.12.2019 against the petitioners was lawful and in accordance with the A.P. Police Manual and the principles laid down by the Supreme Court and this Court.
  2. Whether, having regard to the petitioners' criminal history (one past matter acquitted and one matter pending), the respondents were justified in maintaining and continuing the rowdy sheets and in calling the petitioners to the police station.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The rowdy sheets (Nos.1284–1287 dated 11.12.2019) were opened and are being continued without complying with the A.P. Police Manual and the legal principles laid down by the Supreme Court and this Court.
  • Of the two cases in which they were involved, one (C.C. No.650 of 2017 arising from Crime No.331 of 2015) ended in acquittal and attained finality; only PRC No.307 of 2020 (arising out of Crime No.926 of 2019) is pending, so they are not "habitual" offenders per the applicable tests.
  • Under the guise of rowdy sheets, the police have been calling them to the police station and harassing them (making them wait for hours).
  • They relied on prior decisions of this Court (including W.P. No.12845 of 2014 dated 27.09.2019 and W.P. No.15050 of 2020 dated 03.11.2020) to support their claim that the opening/continuation was impermissible.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents acknowledged the two cases but pointed out that C.C. No.650 of 2017 ended in acquittal and PRC No.307 of 2020 is pending.
  • Rowdy sheets were opened after obtaining permission from the Assistant Commissioner of Police, Banjara Hills Division, and are being continued to curb unlawful activities and protect public order in view of serious incidents (including three murders in the area).
  • The police relied on Standing Orders Nos.601 and 602(2) of the A.P. Police Manual and asserted there was no illegality or irregularity in opening the rowdy sheets.
  • Respondents denied that the petitioners were called to police station during odd hours and denied harassment; they asserted that patrolling was being done in the vicinity and that surveillance was necessary to prevent repetition of offenses.
  • Relied on a Madras High Court decision (G. Raman Alias Ramachandran) to contend that public interest in dissemination of law-and-order information can, in some circumstances, outweigh private reputation concerns.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kharak Singh v. The State of U.P., AIR 1963 SC 1295 Domiciliary visits at night under police surveillance declared unconstitutional; right to privacy implicated by history-sheet surveillance. Used to show that surveillance/domiciliary visits at night are constitutionally impermissible and to highlight privacy concerns with history/rowdy sheets.
Vijay Narain Singh v. State of Bihar, AIR 1984 SC 1334 'Habitually' means repeatedly or persistently — a thread of continuity; a single act does not make one 'habitual'. Applied to interpret the term 'habitually' in the A.P. Police Manual; court concluded a solitary or limited number of instances does not satisfy the habit requirement.
Dhanji Ram Sharma v. Superintendent of Police, North District, Delhi Police, AIR 1966 SC 1766 Condition precedent for opening a history sheet: the officer must have a reasonable belief based on reasonable grounds. Cited to emphasize that opening/retaining history/rowdy sheets requires a reasonable belief grounded in reasonable grounds by the police officer concerned.
Sunkara Satyanarayana v. State of Andhra Pradesh, 2000(1) ALD (Crl.) 117 (AP) Maintenance of history/rowdy sheets for long periods can violate right to privacy and other fundamental rights; administrative authorities should place reasons when challenged; better to have reasons recorded. Relied upon to underline that prolonged retention must be justified with recorded reasons and that privacy and fundamental rights may be impacted.
B. Satyanarayana Reddy v. State of Andhra Pradesh, 2004(1) ALD (Crl.) 387 (AP) 'Habitually commit/attempt/abet' indicates requirement that at least 'two or more cases' have been registered to characterize a habitual offender. Used to show that mere solitary involvement is insufficient and that multiple cases are required as a threshold for categorisation.
Majid Babu v. Government of A.P., 1987(2) ALT 904 Two instances may not be sufficient to describe a person as a 'habitual offender'; at least more than two instances should be present. Applied to support the proposition that involvement in two cases (one of which ended in acquittal here) does not satisfy the threshold for a 'habitual offender'.
Kamma Bapuji v. Station House Officer, Brahmasamudram, 1997 (6) ALD 583 Rowdy sheets cannot be opened casually or mechanically; two cases alone do not make a person a 'habitual offender'; acquittal in earlier cases is relevant. Cited to reject the contention that opening rowdy sheets during pendency (and ignoring acquittal later) makes the sheet valid; supports requirement of careful application of standards.
Puttagunta Pasi v. Commissioner of Police, Vijayawada, 1998 (3) ALT 55 (DB) Confirmed that rowdy sheets cannot be opened casually and that due care must be taken before designating a person as a rowdy; two cases alone insufficient. Relied on to reinforce the principle that police must exercise caution and not mechanically open rowdy sheets based on limited involvement in cases.
Mohammed Quadeer v. Commissioner of Police, Hyderabad, 1999(3) ALD 60 A.P. Police Standing Orders are not statutory; opening a rowdy sheet affects right to reputation under Article 21 and must be strictly construed. Applied to stress that standing orders do not themselves confer extraordinary powers and that opening a rowdy sheet must be strictly scrutinized due to consequences for fundamental rights.
Yerramsetti Venugopal Rao v. State of Andhra Pradesh and others, 2020(2) ALD (Crl.) 1048 (AP) History/rowdy sheet may be continued only if (i) activities are prejudicial to maintenance of public order or affecting peace and tranquility, or (ii) victims are not coming forward to give complaints due to threats. Adopted as the test for continuation; court found the counter lacked these grounds and therefore continuation could not be sustained.
G. Raman Alias Ramachandran v. The Superintendent Of Police, Karur District and others, 2013 Crl.LJ 2746 Police may have a right in public interest to disseminate law-and-order information; publication/display of a history-sheet subject may infringe identity/reputation but public interest can prevail. Noted as a precedent relied upon by the Government Pleader to justify rowdy-sheet dissemination in public interest; referenced in evaluating respondents' public interest claim.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the facts and the applicable administrative and judicial authorities step-by-step:

  1. Facts: The petitioners were involved in two criminal matters: one (C.C. No.650 of 2017 arising from Crime No.331 of 2015) ended in acquittal and attained finality; the other (PRC No.307 of 2020 arising from Crime No.926 of 2019) is pending. Thus, as of the hearing, only one case was pending against the petitioners.
  2. Applicable administrative law: The court extracted the relevant provisions of the A.P. Police Manual — Standing Order 601 (classification as rowdies and opening Rowdy Sheets), Standing Order 602 (period of retention of history sheets), and Standing Order 742 — noting the categories and procedural expectations for opening and retaining rowdy/history sheets.
  3. Judicial principles: The court surveyed Supreme Court and High Court decisions which establish that:
    • The term 'habitually' requires repeated or persistent conduct — a thread of continuity (Vijay Narain Singh).
    • A reasonable belief grounded in reasonable grounds is a condition precedent for opening a history sheet (Dhanji Ram Sharma).
    • Opening and retention of history/rowdy sheets may affect privacy and fundamental rights; the actions must be recorded, justified, and strictly construed (Kharak Singh; Sunkara Satyanarayana; Mohammed Quadeer).
    • Multiple instances/cases (more than two, per authorities cited such as Majid Babu) are required to characterize a person as a habitual offender; two cases alone are generally insufficient (B. Satyanarayana Reddy; Majid Babu; Kamma Bapuji; Puttagunta Pasi).
    • Continuation of a rowdy sheet is permissible only if specific conditions exist (activities prejudicial to public order or victims not coming forward due to threats) as set out in Yerramsetti Venugopal Rao.
  4. Application to present facts:
    • Given that one of the two alleged involvements ended in acquittal and that only one case is now pending, the court found that the requirement of involvement in at least more than two cases to infer habitual offending was not established on the facts before it.
    • The respondents' counter did not demonstrate the specific grounds required for continuation under the cited authority (Yerramsetti Venugopal Rao), namely activities prejudicial to public order or victims failing to come forward due to threats.
    • Consequently, the opening and continuation of the rowdy sheets against the petitioners was held to be contrary to the procedure in the A.P. Police Manual and to the cited judicial precedents.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is allowed. The respondents are directed to close the rowdy sheets being maintained in the names of the petitioners on the file of Banjara Hills Police Station, Hyderabad. There shall be no order as to costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The immediate and direct consequence is that Rowdy Sheet Nos.1284, 1285, 1286 and 1287/RS/ACP-BH/2019 maintained against the petitioners are to be closed by the respondents; miscellaneous petitions, if any, are closed; no costs awarded.
  • Broader implications: The court applied established principles from the Supreme Court and this Court regarding the narrow circumstances in which rowdy/history sheets may be opened or continued, the meaning of 'habitually', the need for reasonable grounds, and protection of privacy and reputation. The opinion enforces that administrative action under police standing orders must conform to judicially recognized thresholds and recorded reasoning. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond applying existing authorities to the facts at hand.

Order dated: 01-06-2021; K. Lakshman, J.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Mansoor Shah Khan v. The State of Telangana

    HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA

    AT HYDERABAD

    *****

    WRIT PETITION No.22980 OF 2020 Between:

    Mansoor Shah Khan and others. .. Petitioners

    Vs.

    The State of Telangana rep.by its Principal Secretary Home Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad and others. .. Respondents

    DATE OF JUDGMENT PRONOUNCED: 01.06.2021

    HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K. LAKSHMAN

    1 Whether Reporters of Local newspapers may be allowed to see the Yes/No Judgments?

    2 Whether the copies of judgment may be marked to Law Reporters/Journals Yes/No

    3 Whether Their Ladyship/Lordship wish to see the fair copy of the Yes/No Judgment?

    JUSTICE K. LAKSHMAN

    1

    2

    * THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K. LAKSHMAN

    + W.P. No.22980 of 2020 % Dated 01.06.2021 #Mansoor Shah Khan and others. ... Petitioners

    Vs.

    $ The State of Telangana,

    Rep. by its Principal Secretary

    Home Department,

    Secretariat, Hyderabad

    and others. ..Respondents

    ! Counsel for the Petitioners: Ms.Valdimeer Khatoon ^ Counsel for the Respondents: Learned Government Pleader for Home, appearing for the respondents.

    >HEAD NOTE:

    ? Cases referred

    1. AIR 1963 SC 1295

    2.AIR 1984 SC 1334

    3. AIR 1966 SC 1766

    4.2000(1) ALD (Crl.) 117 (AP)

    5. 2004(1) ALD (Crl.) 387 (AP)

    6. 1987(2) ALT 904

    7. 1997 (6) ALD 583

    8. 1998(3) ALT 55 (DB)

    9..1999(3) ALD 60

    10. 2020(2) ALD (Crl.) 1048 (AP)

    11. 2013 Crl.LJ 2746

    3

    THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K. LAKSHMAN

    WRIT PETITION No.22980 of 2020

    ORDER:

    This writ petition is filed to declare the action of the respondents in opening Rowdy Sheet Nos.1284, 1285, 1286 and 1287/RS/ACP-BH/2019 dated 11.12.2019 and continuing the same against the petitioners as illegal and for a consequential direction to the respondents to close the rowdy sheets against the petitioners and not to call them to the police station.

    2. There are four petitioners in the present writ petition. According to them, they were involved in two cases i.e. Crime No.331 of 2015 pending on the file of Banjara Hills Police Station, Hyderabad for the offences under Sections 447, 427 and 506 read with 34 IPC. The police, after completion of investigation, filed a charge sheet against the petitioners herein for the aforesaid offences and the same was taken on file vide C.C.No.650 of 2017. The said proceedings in C.C.No.650 of 2017 ended in acquittal vide judgment dated 22.02.2018 passed by the learned II Special Magistrate, Hyderabad. No appeal is filed challenging the said judgment and therefore, the said judgment attained finality. The other case is Crime No.926 of 2019 pending on the file of Banjara Hills Police Station for the offences under Sections 307, 448, 147, 148, 506 read with 149 of IPC. The police, after completion of investigation, have filed a charge sheet vide PRC.No.307 of 2020. The same is pending.

    3. Ms. Vladimeer Khatoon, learned counsel for the petitioners, referring to the said proceedings, would submit that proceedings in C.C.No.650 of 2017 (arising out of Crime No.331 of 2015) ended in

    4

    acquittal by the learned Special Magistrate Court, Hyderabad. The said judgment attained finality. The petitioners herein are also accused in P.R.C.No.307 of 2020 (arising out of Crime No.926 of 2019) for the offences under Sections 307, 448, 147, 148, 506 read with 149 of IPC, which is pending. As on today, there is only one case pending against the petitioners herein. However, without considering the said fact and also the procedure laid down under the A.P.Police Manual, the respondents have issued the above said rowdy sheets against the petitioners herein and they are continuing the same which is arbitrary, illegal and also contrary to the principles laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court and this Court in catena of decisions. Learned counsel would further submit that under the guise of opening and continuation of rowdy sheets, the respondents/police are calling the petitioners to the police station and harassing them by making them to wait in the police station for hours together. With the said submissions, learned counsel for the petitioners sought a direction to the respondents to close the above said rowdy sheets opened against the petitioners on 11.12.2019. She has relied on the principles laid down by this Court in the judgments in WP.No.12845 of 2014 dated 27.09.2019 and W.P.No.15050 of 2020 dated 03.11.2020.

    4. On the other hand, learned Government Pleader for Home referring to the contents of the counter filed by respondent No.5 i.e Station House Officer, Banjara Hills Police Station, would submit that the petitioners were involved in Crime No.331 of 2015 and Crime No.926 of 2019 for the aforesaid offences. However, Crime No.331 of 2015 (arising out of C.C.No.650 of 2017) ended in acquittal. In Crime No.926 of 2019, the police after completion of investigation have filed

    5

    charge sheet against the petitioners herein vide PRC.No.307 of 2020. The same is pending.

    5. Learned Government Pleader would further submit that the petitioners herein indulged in criminal trespass with mischief causing damage and threatening and attempt to murder case, thereby created terror in the minds of people and havoc in the area. To curb and curtail the unlawful activities in the vicinity of Banjara Hills Police Station, Hyderabad, after obtaining permission from the Assistant Commissioner of Police, Banjara Hills Division, Hyderabad, respective rowdy sheets have been opened vide Rowdy Sheet Nos.1284, 1285, 1286 and 1287/RS/ACP-BH/2019 dated 11.12.20219 and the same are being continued and renewed from time to time. Referring to Standing Order Nos.601 and 602(2) of the A.P.Police Manual, learned Government Pleader would submit that there is no illegality or irregularity in opening the rowdy sheets against the petitioners herein by respondent No.5. He would further submit that respondent No.5 never called the petitioners to police station during odd hours as alleged in the writ affidavit. The police were patrolling in the areas, including the area where the petitioners reside, since three murders were taken place in the said area. The petitioners are not innocents and they were involved in the above said two crimes. Unless and until a close watch is being maintained to curtail their unlawful activities in the vicinity of Banjara Hills Police Station, Hyderabad City, there is every chance that they may repeat the offences. Except continuation of rowdy sheets as per the Police Manual, respondent No.5 never harassed the petitioners as alleged in the writ affidavit. With the said submissions, learned Government Pleader sought to dismiss the present writ petition.

    6

    6. In view of the said rival submissions, it is opt to refer to the relevant clauses of the A.P. Police Manual. Maintenance of rowdy sheets is governed by Standing Order 601 of the A.P.Police Manual, Part-I, Volume II which reads as under:-

    "601. The following persons may be classified as rowdies and Rowdy Sheets (Form 80) may be opened for them under the orders of the SP/DCP and ACP/SDPO.

    A. Persons who habitually commit, attempt to commit or abet the commission of offences involving a breach of the peace, disturbance to public order and security. B. Persons bound over under Sections 106, 107, 108(1) (i) and 110(e) and (g) of Cr.P.C.

    C. Persons who have been convicted more than once in two consecutive years under sections 59 and 70 of the Hyderabad City Police Act or under section 3, clause 12, of the AP Towns Nuisances Act.

    D. Persons who habitually tease women and girls and pass indecent remarks.

    F. Persons who intimidate by threats or use of physical violence or other unlawful means to part with movable or immovable properties or in the habit of collecting money by extortion from shopkeepers, traders and other residents. G. Persons who incite and instigate communal/caste or political riots.

    H. Persons detained under the "AP Prevention of Dangerous Activities of Bootleggers, Dacoits, Drug Offenders, Goondas, Immoral Traffic Offenders and Land-Grabbers Act, 1986" for a period of 6 months or more.

    I. Persons who are convicted for offences under the Representatives of the Peoples' Act for rigging and carrying away ballot paper, Boxes and other

    polling material"'

    Likewise, the period of retention of history sheets of suspects/rowdies is governed by Standing Order 602, which reads as follows:-

    "602-1. History Sheets of suspects shall be maintained from the date of registration up to the end of December, after which the orders of a gazetted officer as to their discontinuance or retention for a further period shall be obtained.

    7

    2. Merely because a suspect/rowdy, having a history sheet, is not figuring as accused in the previous 5 years after the last case in which he was involved, it should not preclude the SP/DCP/CP to continue his history sheet if SP/DCP/CP is of the considered view that his activities are prejudicial to the maintenance of public order or one affecting peace and tranquillity in the area or the victims are not coming forward to give complaint against him on account of threat from him." Standing Order 742 of A.P. Police Standing Orders deals with the situation as to classification of rowdies and opening of rowdy sheets, which is extracted below:-

    "742. Rowdies:- (1) The following persons may be classified as rowdies and Rowdy Sheets (Form 88) may be opened for them under the order of the Superintendent of Police or Sub-divisional Officer:

    (a) persons who habitually commit, attempt to commit or abet the commission of, offences involving a breach of the peace;

    (b) persons bound over under Sections 106, 107, 108(c) and 110(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Act No.2 of 1974);

    (c) persons who have been convicted more than once in two consecutive years under Section 75 of the Madras City Police Act or under Section 3, clause 12, of the Towns Nuisances Act;

    (d) persons who habitually tease women and girls by passing indecent remarks or otherwise; and

    (e) in the case of rowdies residing in an area under one Police Station but are found to be frequently visiting the area under one or more other Police Stations their rowdy sheets can be maintained at all such Police Stations; (G.O. Ms. No. 656, Home (Police-D) Dept. Dt. 8-4-1971)

    (2) Instructions in Order 735 regarding discontinuance of History Sheets shall also apply to Rowdy Sheets."

    7. According to respondent No.5, the above said proceedings in C.C.No.650 of 2017 ended in acquittal and no appeal is filed against the said judgment and thus, the said judgment attained finality. At present, the proceedings in PRC.No.307 of 2020 alone are pending against all the four petitioners herein. As per Standing Order 601 of

    8

    the A.P. Police Manual, rowdy sheet can be maintained against persons who habitually commit, attempt to commit or abet the commission of offences involving a breach of peace, disturbance to public order and security.

    8. The Hon'ble Apex Court had an occasion to deal with the opening of history sheets, continuation of the same and also right to privacy in Kharak Singh v. The State Of U. P. & Others1. In the said case, rowdy sheet was opened against the petitioner therein and the same was continued. Under the guise of surveillance, the police started visiting the house of the petitioner therein against whom rowdy sheet was opened and pending during night hours and they used to torture him. The Hon'ble Apex Court declared the domiciliary visits at night hours as unconstitutional.

    9. In the case of Vijay Narain Singh v. State of Bihar2, a three Judge Bench of the Hon'ble Apex Court had an occasion to deal with the expression 'habitually' and held that the expression 'habitually' would mean 'repeatedly' or 'persistently' implying a thread of continuity, stringing together similar repetitive acts, and a single act or omission would not characterize an act as 'habitual'. The Hon'ble Apex Court was of the opinion that to qualify as a 'habit', a person must have grown accustomed to leading a life of crime, whereby it would be a force of habit, inherent or latent, in an individual with a criminal instinct, with a criminal disposition of mind, that makes him dangerous to society in general.

    1 AIR 1 963 SC 1 295

    2 AIR 1984 SC 1334

    9

    10. In another case of Dhanji Ram Sharma v. Superintendent of Police, North District, Delhi Police3, a three Judge Bench of the Hon'ble Apex Court held that the condition precedent for opening of a history sheet is that such person should be reasonably believed to be habitually addicted to crime or to be an aider or abettor of crime. In order to justify the opening of a history sheet, the Hon'ble Supreme Court opined that the police officer must have a reasonable belief based on reasonable grounds.

    11. In Sunkara Satyanarayana v. State of Andhra Pradesh4 a learned Single Judge was concerned with the maintenance of history sheets/rowdy sheets for considerably long periods of time and held that the same would not only violate the right of privacy but also other fundamental rights of such persons under Articles 14 and 19 of the Constitution of India. Orders for opening or retention of history sheets/rowdy sheets should be passed under administrative instructions and guidelines and if such orders are challenged, the competent authority has to place the reasons before the Court justifying the opening/retention of such history sheets/rowdy sheets. It would be better for the police officer concerned to record his own reasons for opening/retention of history sheets/rowdy sheets.

    12. In B. Satyanarayana Reddy v. State of Andhra Pradesh5, a Division Bench held that the expressions 'habitually commit', 'attempt to commit' and 'abet the commission' of offences indicate the requirement that atleast 'two or more cases' have bee been registered against the person concerned to characterize him as a person who habitually commits, attempts to or abets the commission of offences.

    3 AIR 1966 SC 1766

    4 2000(1) ALD (Crl.) 117 (AP)

    5 2004(1) ALD (Crl.) 387 (AP)

    10

    It was further held that involvement of a person in a solitary case would not be enough to classify such person as 'habitually' committing offences. With the said finding, the Division Bench held that solitary instance in which the appellant therein was alleged to be involved in could not constitute the basis to classify him as a 'rowdy.'

    13. In another case in Majid Babu v. Government of A.P.6, it was held that two instances of involvement in criminal cases would not make a person a 'habitual offender' and that atleast more than two instances should be present before a person can be described as a habitual offender.

    14. In Kamma Bapuji v. Station House Officer, Brahmasamudram7, wherein the persons in whose names rowdy sheets were opened were involved in two cases but they were acquitted in both, it was sought to be contended on behalf of the police authorities that the rowdy sheets were opened during the pendency of the cases and that acquittal therein would be of no consequence thereafter. While dealing with the said facts of the said case, the learned Judge rejected the said contention and held that rowdy sheets could not be opened in a casual and mechanical manner and a person could not be dubbed a 'habitual offender' merely because he was involved in two criminal cases.

    15. In Puttagunta Pasi v. Commissioner of Police, Vijayawada8, a Division Bench confirmed the said principle holding that a rowdy sheet could not be opened against an individual in a casual and mechanical manner and due care and caution should be taken by the police before characterizing a person as a rowdy. The Division Bench

    6 1987(2) ALT 904

    7 1997 (6) ALD 583

    8 1998 (3) ALT 55 (DB)

    11

    expressed agreement with the view taken by the learned Single Judge in Kamma Bapuji's case (7 supra) that figuring as an accused in two crimes would not be sufficient to categorise a person as a 'habitual offender'.

    16. In Mohammed Quadeer v. Commissioner of Police, Hyderabad9, it was held that A.P.Police Standing Orders were not statutory in nature and were only a compilation of government orders issued from time to time and they therefore did not invest the police officers with any powers of arrest, detention, investigation of crimes etc. not specifically conferred under the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, or other enactments. As regards retention of a rowdy sheet, it was held that opening of a rowdy sheet against a citizen was undoubtedly fraught with serious consequences and the right to reputation under Article 21 of the Constitution could not be deprived except in accordance with the procedure established by law. The law which authorizes the police to open rowdy sheets and exercise surveillance would have to be very strictly construed.

    17. In Yerramsetti Venugopal Rao v. State of Andhra Pradesh and others10, a learned Single Judge of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Amaravathi referring to the above said provisions of the A.P.Police Manual and the principles laid down in the above said judgments held that history sheet of a rowdy can be continued (i) if his activities are prejudicial to the maintenance of public order or affecting peace and tranquility in the area; and (ii) the victims are not coming forward to give complaint against him on account of threat from him.

    9 19 9 9 (3) ALD 60

    10 2020(2) ALD (Crl.) 10 48 (AP)

    12

    18. In W.P.No.19194 of 2012 dated 24.08.2015, by referring to the above said provisions of the A.P. Police Manual and also the principles laid down in the aforesaid judgments, it was held that the requirement of involvement in atleast more than two cases for inferring that he was a habitual offender was not established. The opening of the rowdy sheet in the name of the petitioner therein was therefore tainted in law in its very inception. Therefore, continuation of the said rowdy sheet by the police authorities ignoring the law laid down by this Court as well as the Supreme Court cannot be sustained. Accordingly, with the said finding, the respondents therein were directed to close the rowdy sheet being maintained in the name of the petitioner therein.

    19. In another judgment in W.P.No.18364 of 2020 dated 03.12.2020, a learned Judge of this Court, after referring to the principle laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in Vijay Narain Singh's case (2 supra) and also referring to the Police Standing Orders supra, it was held that it is impermissible to the police to open a rowdy sheet if police are of the view that the petitioner is habitually committing offences/abetting commission of offence involving breach of peace, disturbance to the public order and security. In the said case, the petitioner has involved in five cases and he has been facing trial in the said cases Referring to the facts of the said case, it was held that it cannot be said that the action of the police in opening rowdy sheet amounts to abuse or misuse of power and authority, and cannot be said as one made in illegal exercise of power and without application of mind.

    13

    20. In W.P.No.12845 of 2014 dated 27.09.2019, wherein the petitioner has involved in only one case for the offence under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC and by relying on the principles laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court and this Court in catenae of decisions, it was held that opening of rowdy sheet and continuation of the same thereafter was in violation of the life and liberty as guaranteed to the petitioner therein under the provisions of the Constitution of India as well as contrary to the law laid down by this Court and the Hon'ble Apex Court.

    21. Learned Government Pleader for Home, referring to the principle laid down by the Madras High Court in the case of G.Raman Alias Ramachandran v. The Superintendent Of Police, Karur District and others11 wherein it was held that in public interest, the Police has got a right to disseminate information, concerning law and order, and crime. Display or publication of a photograph of a History Sheeted Rowdy, may be contended to infringe upon a person's right, in so far as it affects his identity, reputation in the minds of others, but at the same time, public interest would prevail over private interest, would submit that respondent No.5 has rightly opened the rowdy sheets against the petitioners and is continuing the same in the interest of public. According to him, there is no illegality.

    22. In view of the law laid down by this Court and the Hon'ble Apex Court in the above said judgments, coming to the facts on hand, as discussed supra, admittedly, the petitioners herein were involved in the above said two cases. C.C.No.650 of 2017 (arising out of Crime No.331 of 2015) for offences under Sections 447, 427, 506 read with

    34 IPC ended in acquittal. No appeal was filed against the said

    11 2013 Crl.LJ 2746

    14

    judgment. Thus, the said judgment attained finality. Another case i.e PRC.No.307 of 2020 (arising out of Crime No.926 of 2019) for offences under Sections 307, 448, 147, 148, 506 read with 149 IPC is pending against the petitioners herein. Thus, as on today, only one case is pending against the petitioners herein. According to respondent No.5, to curb and curtail the unlawful activities of the petitioners herein in the vicinity of Banjara Hills Police Station, Hyderabad, after obtaining permission from the Assistant Commissioner of Police, Banjara Hills Division, Hyderabad, the above said rowdy sheets were opened against the petitioners herein and the same are being continued in view of public interest.

    23. As stated above, as per Standing Order 601 of the A.P. Police Manual, for opening and maintenance of rowdy sheet, a person against whom the same was issued should habitually commit, attempt to commit or abet the commission of offences involving a breach of peace, disturbance to public order and security. Further, as held by the Hon'ble Apex Court in Vijay Narain Singh's case (2 supra), the expression 'habitually' would mean 'repeatedly' or 'persistently' implying a thread of continuity, stringing together similar repetitive acts, and a single act or omission would not characterize an act as 'habitual'. The Hon'ble Apex Court was of the opinion that to qualify as a 'habit', a person must have grown accustomed to leading a life of crime, whereby it would be a force of habit, inherent or latent, in an individual with a criminal instinct, with a criminal disposition of mind, that makes him dangerous to society in general. In Majid Babu's case (6 supra), by referring to Standing Order No.742, it was held that two instances of involvement in criminal cases would not make a person a 'habitual offender' and

    15

    that atleast more than two instances should be present before a person can be described as a habitual offender. Rowdy sheet could not be opened against an individual in a casual and mechanical manner and due care and caution should be taken by the police before characterizing a person as a rowdy. Figuring as an accused in two cases would not be sufficient to characterize a person as a habitual offender.

    24. In view of the above said law laid down and in view of the above said discussion, the petitioners herein were involved in the above said two crimes. One crime has ended in acquittal. As on today, only one case i.e PRC.No.307 of 2020 is pending against the petitioners herein. Thus, the requirement of involvement of in atleast more than two cases for inferring that the petitioners were habitual offenders was not established. Thus opening of rowdy sheets in the name of the petitioners is therefore contrary to the procedure laid down under A.P. Police Manual and procedure laid down in the Judgments supra.

    25. As held in Yerramsetti Venugopal Rao's case (supra), rowdy sheet can be continued (i) if his activities are prejudicial to the maintenance of public order or affecting peace and tranquility in the area; and (ii) the victims are not coming forward to give complaint against him on account of threat from him. In the counter filed by respondent No.5, lacks the said grounds. Therefore, continuation of the said rowdy sheets by the police authorities ignoring the law laid down by this Court as well as the Hon'ble Apex Court in the judgments cited supra cannot be sustained.

    25. Therefore, the writ petition is allowed and the respondents are directed to close the rowdy sheets being maintained in the names of

    16

    the petitioners on the file of Banjara Hills Police Station, Hyderabad. There shall be no order as to costs.

    26. As a sequel, the miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand closed.

    __________________

    K. LAKSHMAN, J

    Date: 01-06-2021. Note: L.R.Copy to be marked.

    JSU

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mansoor Shah Khan v. The State of Telangana
    (Jun 1, 2021)