AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    ANUPAM HARNATH GOYAL AND ANOTHER v. THE CITY AND INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LTD,

    906-wp-4012-2020 judg.odt

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

    BENCH AT AURANGABAD

    WRIT PETITION NO.4012 OF 2020

    1. Anupam Harnath Goyal Age. 79 years, Occu. Retired, R/o. 283, 284 "Premsar" CIDCO, Sector N.3, Aurangabad.

    2. Mrs. Kamal W/o Anupam Goyal, Age. 70 yrs, Occu. Homemaker, R/o. As above. ...Petitioners Versus

    The City and Industrial Development Corporation Ltd, (Through the Administrator) New Aurangabad Ofce,

    Udyog Bhawan,

    New Aurangabad - 431 003. ...Respondent …

    Mr. C.V. Dharurkar, Advocate for the Petitioners. Mr. N.S. Tekale, Advocate for the Respondent.

    ...

    CORAM : RAVINDRA V. GHUGE &

    S.G. MEHARE, J.J.

    DATED : 09th DECEMBER, 2021

    ORAL JUDGMENT (PER RAVINDRA V. GHUGE, J) :-

    1. Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith and heard fnally by consent of the parties, on 07.12.2021, 08.12.2021 and today.

    2. Petitioner no.1 is 80 years old. Petitioner no.2 is a 71 years old wife of petitioner no.1. Both the petitioners have put-forth prayer clause (B) as under:

    "B. By issuing a Writ of Mandamus or any other writ of like nature, the order passed by Respondent Administrator dated

    1/12

    28.08.2019 (Exhibit-N) whereby the Petitioners' request for De-amalgamation of their Plots 283 and 284 is rejected, may kindly be quashed and set aside and instead the respondent may kindly be directed to pass appropriate order permitting a De-amalgamation / Sub-Division of the Petitioners' Plots No.283 and 284 situated at Sector N.3 CIDCO, Aurangabad."

    3. The following factors are undisputed:-

    a) Plot no.283 was earlier leased in the name of the mother of petitioner no.1 and the lease deed was accordingly executed on 01.10.1981. Subsequently, the mother has gifted the said plot to her son, petitioner no.1.

    b) Another agreement to lease dated 01.10.1981 was executed between petitioner no.2 and the respondent - CIDCO for land ad- measuring 354 sq. mtrs.

    c) Since the petitioners are a married couple, both requested the CIDCO authorities for amalgamation of the two pieces of land which were subsequently granted plot nos.283 and 284.

    d) Both these two plots are situated in N-3 Sector.

    e) The General Development Control Regulations for Notifed Areas of 'New Towns' (as amended upto 9thJanuary, 2003) (hereinafter referred to as 'the Regulations') are placed on record.

    f) Both the plots purchased by these two petitioners fall in Category 8 under Table-3 found in Clause 13.4 - Size of Plots

    (13.4.1).

    g) Note no.5 below Table-3 indicates as under :-

    2/12

    "Plot categories of No.1 to 7 will not be permitted to be subdivided; if amalgamated, the open spaces shall be observed as per the amalgamated area; in case of plot category No.8 amalgamation and subdivision will be permitted provided the minimum area of any plot after subdivision shall not be less than 300 sq. m."

    h) The two plots post amalgamation (subsequently, these two plots were said to be a total of 627 sq. mtrs.) form a size of 654 sq. mtrs and therefore, as these two plots fall in Category 8 under Table-3, subdivision or de-amalgamation is permissible.

    4. The controversy that has arisen between the litigating sides is as regards de-amalgamation of two plots, 283 and 284. The petitioners were residing with their son and daughter in the house constructed in the amalgamated plots (284) within the prescribed limit of 6 years, from 1981. They had a car garage, a garden and place for play in plot no.283 along with the bungalow that was constructed as per their requirements. The built up area of the bungalow was about

    474.36 sq. mtrs. Such occupation of bungalow continued for more than 38 years. Building permission for the bungalow and the occupancy certifcate was also granted. In 2018, the petitioners sought permission to construct an additional home ad-measuring 75 sq. mtrs in the same amalgamated plot, albeit, the said new constructed house would be located on plot no.283 keeping in view that the earlier bungalow was constructed on plot no.284. Building permission was

    3/12

    granted and occupancy certifcate was also issued by CIDCO in 2019 with the rider introduced by the administrator of CIDCO that the petitioners would not be permitted to de-amalgamate / subdivide the amalgamated plots and if they intend to do so, plot no.283 will be considered to have been vacant without construction of a bungalow from 1981 onwards and after a passage of 6 years i.e. 1987 onwards, the petitioners would be liable for additional lease premium till the date of subdivision, which is approximately an amount of Rs.5,00,202/-.

    5. The learned advocate for the petitioners strenuously submits that the petitioners' two children, i.e. their son Asit Goyal is a nominee over plot no.283 and their daughter Piyuli Goyal (Jain) is a nominee of plot no.284. They desire a peaceful separation and handing over of the plots to their children to ensure a peaceful co- existence. Since this property is being divided into two shares for their two children, the old couple desires that there should be a peaceful partitioning in order to avoid any further complications after the couple has gone. It was with this object that they prayed for subdivision of the plots by their letter dated 29.08.2013, 30.10.2013, 09.12.2013 etc.

    6. The learned advocate further submits that there have been instances in CIDCO area where people have invested monies in multiple plots and after this was brought to light in Writ Petition No.2338 of 1999 before this Court, orders were passed by the Court mandating that in the entire CIDCO area, one person can have only one lease agreement with regard to one plot and no person shall be

    4/12

    entitled to have more than one plot registered in his name under the lease agreement. Such orders were passed taking into account that there were elements who had indulged in practically hoarding of plots and such plots were later on sold for a fortune to builders or other purchasers. The petitioners would not fall in the category of such elements as the petitioners had used the amalgamated plots for almost 40 years and though their children have taken education in USA, the petitioners have not sold either of the plots even for funding their education. This would establish the bonafdes of the petitioners and would indicate that there is no oblique or ulterior motive behind seeking the subdivision.

    7. The learned advocate for CIDCO has vehemently opposed this petition by contending that the amalgamation of two plots is a rare thing to be done, though such amalgamation is not prohibited. These were two plots which were in the names of the two petitioners individually and hence, there are two individual lease agreements and registrations. Though the petitioners happen to be a married couple, legally these two plots would stand in the names of two persons by virtue of the lease agreement. He, therefore, vehemently submits that once the administrator of CIDCO has placed the rider/condition on the petitioners that if they desire to construct a new home in plot no.283, they may proceed to do so, with the condition that they would not request for subdivision or de-amalgamation. He points out the construction permission granted to the petitioners to construct the

    5/12

    bungalow on plot no.283, vide communication dated 16.05.2018. Once such de-amalgamation is prohibited, the petitioners cannot pray for subdivision.

    8. The learned advocate for the petitioners points out an ofce note dated 20.04.2018 which is Exhibit-J at page 80 in the petition paper book, wherein the CIDCO authorities have admitted that in Writ Petition No.2338 of 1999 which was considered by this Court, it was erroneously informed to the High Court that plot no.283 was a vacant plot in the list of vacant plots submitted to the Court. The Chief Administrator of CIDCO has agreed with the ofce note as is visible from the remarks admitting that plot no.283 from the amalgamated plots, cannot be represented to be a vacant plot. The ofce note further indicates that the proposal for extension to develop the building on the amalgamated plot (i.e. 283) would be subject to the condition that no de-amalgamation shall be permitted. The learned advocate, therefore, contends that when the Regulations of the CIDCO authorities places the amalgamated plots in Category 8 under Table-3 and permit subdivision with the rider that the minimum size of the plot should be atleast 300 sq. mtrs, neither the ofce note nor the administrator of CIDCO can introduce a condition of prohibiting subdivision.

    9. We fnd from the Regulations that after a plot is handed over to a lessee by CIDCO-lessor, the lessee has to erect a construction, size of the construction being immaterial, on the said plot

    6/12

    by presenting a proper map, design and plan prepared by an architect. After such construction is erected in accordance with the specifcations approved post building permission, the CIDCO authorities inspect such construction and upon fnding it to be in tune with the permission granted, an occupancy certifcate is issued.

    10. For all purposes, the two plots i.e. 283 and 284 were amalgamated as is permissible by the Regulations and though the construction was erected on plot no.284 with the remainder area in plot no.283 having been utilized for garage, garden and playing place respectively, the occupancy certifcate granted by CIDCO would signify that CIDCO was not treating plot no.283 to be a vacant plot which, for all purposes, was standing in the name of petitioner no.1.

    11. There is no dispute that the frst bungalow constructed by the couple is positioned in plot no.284. Once the CIDCO authorities have permitted amalgamation and the construction of the bungalow on plot no.284 would not render plot no.283 a vacant plot, they did not levy additional lease premium on plot no.283 for a period of 40 years. So also, the ofce note indicates that the CIDCO authorities corrected their mistake of informing this Court in Writ Petition No.2338 of 1999 that plot no.283 is a vacant plot. With such correction, the CIDCO authorities agree that the two plots with the construction in 284 would not mean that 283 is a vacant plot.

    12. The learned advocate for the CIDCO authorities has

    7/12

    strenuously canvassed that, with subdivision of the amalgamated two plots, that plot on which there is no construction i.e. plot no.283, would amount to a vacant plot with retrospective efect. We are unable to persuade ourselves to agree to such a submission for reasons more than one. Firstly, when the building permission was granted for constructing the bungalow on plot no.284, the authorities were aware that plot no.283 exists in the name of petitioner no.1 and there is no construction on that plot. If they had any objection, they could have raised this demand after 6 years from 1981 and could have called upon petitioner no.1 to pay the additional lease premium.

    13. The learned advocate for CIDCO submits that till amalgamation, plot no.283 would not have a separate existence. Such submission is in tune with the Regulations. As the two plots were amalgamated and construction was erected on plot no.284, legally plot no.283 did not have an independent existence, thereby meaning that the said plot could not have been treated as an independent or stand alone plot so as to impose additional lease premium on the said plot. Logically and legally, the day the subdivision is permitted, plot no.283 will have it's independent stand alone existence and from the date of such subdivision, in our view, would be the starting point of the limitation of 6 years for erecting a construction. In this situation, such subdivision cannot be held to have a retrospective efect from the date there was an amalgamation, lest, it would amount to wiping out the entire beneft and tenure of the amalgamation period which would be

    8/12

    prejudicial to the interest of the petitioners and such interpretation would be dehors the rules.

    14. In the light of the above, we conclude and especially in the backdrop of the CIDCO authorities sanctioning amalgamation, sanctioning building permission and granting occupancy certifcate, the subdivision of plots falling in Category 8 under Table-3 will not have a retrospective efect for the purposes of levying additional lease premium.

    15. In the backdrop of the above interpretation, the case of the petitioners stands on a better footing, in the sense that today, after getting building permission for the approved design of the bungalow on plot no.283, such a bungalow has been erected and occupancy certifcate has also been granted on 13.05.2019. If in future subdivision is permitted, plot no.283 and 284 will both have to be segregated from each other and, therefore, from the date of such subdivision, both will have an independent existence as stand alone plots. On these premises, there are already two constructions standing in plot no.283 as well as in plot no.284. The question of levying additional lease premium would therefore not arise.

    16. This leaves us with the last issue as to whether subdivision can be permitted in the above fact situation. As recorded above, the Regulations permit subdivision in the backdrop of amalgamation with regard to plots falling in Category 8 under Table-3.

    9/12

    These Regulations have the force of law unless challenged and found to be ultra virus the rules. The question, therefore, is as to whether the ofce note by an ofcer of CIDCO or whether a condition written in handwriting below the letter granting construction permission on 16.05.2018 under the signature of the Assistant Engineer, Building Permission Department of CIDCO, can over ride the Regulations. This requires no debate as it is a settled principle of law that a provision or a regulation having a force of law cannot be nullifed or neutralized by any ofce circular or a remark of an ofcer including the remark of the administrator of CIDCO.

    17. This Court in Writ Petition No.2755 of 2020 fled by Kathoba Deo Shikshan Prasarak Mandal Vs. The State of Maharashtra and Others vide judgment dated 16.11.2021 has observed in paragraph nos.23 to 25 as under:

    "23. In DDA and others (supra), the Honourable Apex Court dealt with the signifcance of a communication or an executive instruction in confict with a statute or a statutory rule and concluded in para 30 as under :

    "30. It is not a case where a confict has arisen between a statute or a statutory rule on the one hand and an executive instruction, on the other. Only in a case where a confict arises between a statute and an executive instruction, indisputably, the former will prevail over the latter. The lessor under the deed of lease is to fx the market value. It could do it areawise or plotwise. Once it does it areawise which being fnal and binding, it cannot resile therefrom at a later stage and take a stand that in a particular case it will fx the market value on the basis of the price disclosed in the agreement of sale."

    24. In Union of India and others vs. Somsundaram Viswanath

    10/12

    (supra), the Honourable Apex Court concluded in paragraph 6 that executive instructions in confict with the statutory provisions and the rules made under the proviso to article 309, would lose their signifcance and would not have a binding efect.

    25. In Punjab Water Supply and Sewerage Board (supra), the Honourable Apex Court concluded that a policy decision of the State Government adopted by means of the circular/letter would be void. Any departmental letter or executive instructions would not prevail over statutory rules and constitutional provisions."

    18. As such, to deal with a case of mischief or fraud which may be played by a plot holder/lessee, the CIDCO authorities may make a provision in the Regulations for dealing with such cases diferently so as to refuse the permission of subdivision or charge additional lease premium. We are making this observation since we are aware that there have been several irregularities in CIDCO committed by the lessee which were exposed in Writ Petition No.2338 of 1999 before this Court.

    19. In view of the above, this petition is allowed in terms of prayer clause (B). We direct the respondent to issue the order of subdivision / de-amalgamation in the light of Note-5 below Table-3 under clause 13.4.1 of the Regulations, to the petitioners.

    20. To safeguard the interest of the lessee as well as the lessor and considering various orders passed by this Court in Writ Petition No.2338 of 1999, we deem it appropriate to direct that the CIDCO authorities, may introduce rules or regulations to deal with cases of mischief or fraud committed by lessee of amalgamated plots

    11/12

    while seeking subdivision.

    21. Rule is made absolute in the above terms.

    (S.G. MEHARE. J.) (RAVINDRA V. GHUGE, J.)

    Mujaheed//

    12/12

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    ANUPAM HARNATH GOYAL AND ANOTHER v. THE CITY AND INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LTD,
    (Dec 9, 2021)