AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Section 482 of Cr.P.C.
  • Sections 326, 307, 302, 420 of IPC r/w 34 of IPC.
  • Sections 420, 326, 307 and 302 of IPC
  • Sections 420, 302 r/w 109 of IPC,
  • Sections 174 Cr.P.C., @ 326, 307, 302, 420 of IPC r/w 34 of IPC,
  • Section 161(3) of Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 174 of Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 161 of Cr.P.C.,
  • Sections 420, 302 of IPC r/w 109 of IPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Section 482 of Cr.P.C.
  • Sections 326, 307, 302, 420 of IPC r/w 34 of IPC.
  • Sections 420, 326, 307 and 302 of IPC
  • Sections 420, 302 r/w 109 of IPC,
  • Sections 174 Cr.P.C., @ 326, 307, 302, 420 of IPC r/w 34 of IPC,
  • Section 161(3) of Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 174 of Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 161 of Cr.P.C.,
  • Sections 420, 302 of IPC r/w 109 of IPC
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, arrayed as Accused No. 2, filed a Criminal Original Petition under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. seeking quashing of the charge sheet in P.R.C. No. 250 of 2019, pending committal before the X Metropolitan Magistrate, Egmore, Chennai. [1][2]

The prosecution case arose from allegations that the petitioner introduced the first accused to the deceased, who was promised employment in return for ₹4,00,000. The first accused allegedly administered poisonous powder mixed with religious prasadam to the deceased and the second respondent; the deceased died in hospital, while the second respondent survived. [3][4]

The case was initially registered under Section 174 of the Cr.P.C. and was subsequently altered to offences under Sections 326, 307, 302 and 420 read with Section 34 of the IPC. Following investigation, a charge sheet was filed against the first accused under Sections 420, 326, 307 and 302 of the IPC, and against the petitioner under Sections 420 and 302 read with Section 109 of the IPC. [5]

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the materials on record disclosed the ingredients of cheating and abetment of the offences under Sections 420 and 302 read with Section 109 of the IPC against the petitioner. [6][7]
  2. Whether the proceedings against the petitioner should be quashed under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. [1][8]

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The FIR contained no reference to the petitioner's participation in the crime. [6]
  • The money was paid to the first accused, who called the victims to the place of occurrence and administered the poisonous prasadam. [6]
  • The petitioner was implicated only on the basis of the second respondent's statement under Section 161 of the Cr.P.C., which alleged merely that she introduced the first accused to the deceased. [6]
  • No witness other than the second respondent attributed any overt act to the petitioner, and there was no evidence of instigation, aiding or conspiracy necessary to attract Section 109 of the IPC. [6][7]
  • The entire proceedings against the petitioner should therefore be quashed. [7]

Second Respondent's Arguments

  • The petitioner introduced the first accused to the deceased, after which the deceased and the second respondent paid ₹4,00,000 on the promise of employment. [3]
  • The first accused later called them to collect an appointment order and gave them powdered religious prasadam, which the deceased swallowed. He became unconscious and subsequently died, while the second respondent survived after receiving treatment. [3]
  • The petitioner's introduction of the first accused constituted a specific overt act, and her conduct attracted Sections 420 and 109 of the IPC. [8]
  • Because the case involved an offence under Section 302 of the IPC, the quashing petition should be dismissed. [8]

Prosecution's Arguments

  • The second respondent's statement clearly supported the offences alleged against the petitioner. [5]
  • The petitioner and the first accused allegedly cheated the victim of ₹4,00,000 and administered poison to the deceased and the second respondent. [5]
  • The proceedings should not be quashed because the case involved the death of the deceased and an offence under Section 302 of the IPC. [5]

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted that the FIR contained no allegation of any overt act by the petitioner beyond introducing the first accused to the deceased. [9]

The Court treated the second respondent's later statement under Section 161(3) of the Cr.P.C. as an improvement, observing that it was the only material implicating the petitioner. [9]

No other witness corroborated the allegation against the petitioner. The Court also found no evidence or material showing instigation, aiding or other conduct sufficient to attract Section 109 of the IPC. [10]

The evidence instead indicated that the first accused alone stole sodium cyanide from a laboratory, mixed it with the prasadam and administered it to the victims. This account was supported by the statement of a Senior Analyst and other witnesses. [11]

Accordingly, the Court concluded that the ingredients of Sections 420 and 302 read with Section 109 of the IPC were not established against the petitioner and that there was no reasonable possibility of her conviction on the available material. [11]

Holding and Implications

The Criminal Original Petition was allowed, and the proceedings in P.R.C. No. 250 of 2019 were quashed insofar as the petitioner was concerned. [12]

The Magistrate was directed to complete the committal proceedings within four weeks, after which the trial Court was to proceed against the remaining accused on the merits and in accordance with law, without being influenced by the observations concerning the petitioner. [12]

The opinion discusses no broader implications; its direct effect was limited to terminating the proceedings against the petitioner, and no new precedent was set.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Bharathi v. State, Rep. By The Inspector Of Police And Another

    Prayer: Criminal Original Petition filed under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. praying to call for the records and quah the entire charge sheet as against the petitioner/accused No. 2, pending committal in PRC. No. 250 of 2019 on the file of the learned X Metropolitan Magistrate, Egmore, Chennai.

    The Order of the Court was delivered by

    G.K. Ilanthiraiyan, J.:— This petition has been filed to quash the proceeding in P.R.C. No. 250 of 2019 on the file of the learned X Metropolitan Magistrate, Egmore, Chennai, thereby taken cognizance for the offences under Sections 174 Cr.P.C., @ 326, 307, 302, 420 of IPC r/w 34 of IPC, as against the petitioner.

    2. The learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner would submit that there are two accused in which, the petitioner is arrayed as A2. He further submitted that the ingredients to attract the offence under Sections 420, 302 of IPC r/w 109 of IPC are not at all made out as against the petitioner. There is absolutely no reference about the participation of the petitioner in the said crime in the FIR. Even as per the complaint lodged by the second respondent, the money was given only to the first accused and he called the victims to the place of occurrence, where they were administered poison through Sridi Saibaba Prasadam in the form of powder. Further the petitioner has been implicated as an accused only on the statement of the second respondent recorded under Section 161 of Cr.P.C., stating that the petitioner only introduced the first accused to the deceased. On the said introduction, the first accused assured that he would get job, for which the deceased and the second respondent paid a sum of Rs. 4 lakhs. Except the statement of the second respondent herein, no witness has spoken about the overt-act of the petitioner herein.

    2.1. He further submitted that there is absolutely no material evidence is available to attract the offence under Sections 420, 302 of IPC r/w 109 of IPC as against the petitioner. The petitioner has been implicated as an accused for the offence under Section 109 of IPC. To attract the offence under Section 109 of IPC, there is no ingredient available as against the petitioner. There is absolutely no instigation, aiding or conspiracy with other accused persons. Therefore the petitioner has been falsely implicated as an accused and she is not at all punishable by any of the offence as alleged by the prosecution. Therefore, he prayed for quashment of the entire proceedings as against the petitioner.

    3. Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the second respondent would submit that the petitioner only introduced the first accused to the deceased viz., the husband of the second respondent. Thereafter, believing the words uttered by the first accused to get job for the deceased, they paid a sum of Rs. 4,00,000/- to the accused persons. On 23.09.2019, the first accused called the deceased and the second respondent for issuing appointment order at Plot No. 560, 8 Main Road, M.K.B. Nagar, Vayasarpadi, Chennai. They had met the first accused in the said address and he had given Sridi Saibaba temple prasadam. It was in the form of powder and both had the said prasadam. Immediately the second respondent spit it out and unfortunately her husband viz., the deceased swallowed the prasadam. Immediately, he fell down unconscious and he was taken to Stanley Hospital, where the treatment failed and he died. The second respondent also admitted in the said hospital for treatment and fortunately she survived.

    3.1. He further submitted that the petitioner is having specific overt-act and she only introduced the first accused and believing their words, the second respond and her husband paid a sum of Rs. 4,00,000/- to the first accused. Therefore the offence under Section 420 of IPC is clearly attracted. Further the petitioner abetted the first accused to commit the offence and therefore Section 109 of IPC is also attracted as against the petitioner. He further submitted that it is a case of 302 of IPC as such the quash petition is not at all maintainable and hence he sought for dismissal of the quash petition.

    4. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor submitted that on the complaint lodged by the second respondent, the first respondent registered a case under Section 174 of Cr.P.C., and thereafter altered the offences under Sections 326, 307, 302, 420 of IPC r/w 34 of IPC. After completion of investigation, the first respondent filed charge sheet for the offences under Sections 420, 326, 307 and 302 of IPC as against the first accused and for the offences under Sections 420, 302 r/w 109 of IPC as against the second accused viz., the petitioner herein. To attract the said offences, the statement of the second respondent is clearly constitute those offences and hence the petitioner is liable to punish for those offences. Further he submitted that it is a case of 302 of IPC and there is no question of quashment of the entire proceedings, since the petitioner along with the first accused cheated the victim to the tune of Rs. 4,00,000/- and also administered poison to the deceased and the second respondent herein. Fortunately the second respondent survived and her husband died in the hospital. Therefore, he sought for dismissal of the quash petition.

    5. Heard Mr. K. Venkataramani, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner, Mr. G. Ganesh Kumar, learned counsel appearing for the second respondent and Mr. S. Karthikeyan, learned Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for the first respondent.

    6. There are totally two accused in which, the petitioner is arrayed as A2. The case of the prosecution is that the petitioner being the friend of the deceased introduced the first accused as he is working in the employment office, Guindy, Chennai. The first accused assured that he would get employment for the deceased. Believing the words, the deceased paid a sum of Rs. 4,00,000/- to the post of office assistant. On 29.09.2019, the deceased received a phone call from the first accused stating that the appointment order was ready and pleased to come and collect the appointment order at Door No. 560, 8 Main Road, M.K.B. Nagar, Vayasarpadi, Chennai. When the deceased and the second respondent visited the said address, they were given Sridi Saibaba temple prasadam in the form of powder by the first accused. The deceased has swallow it and fortunately the second respondent spit it out. Immediately the deceased fell down unconscious and the second respondent also had irritation on her tongue and throat and felling very gridiness. Immediately both were taken to the Stanley Hospital, where the husband of the second respondent died. Hence the charge.

    7. On perusal of FIR, there is no whisper about the overt-act as against the petitioner herein as if the petitioner only introduced the first accused to the deceased. Whereas, it is seen from the statement of the second respondent recorded under Section 161(3) of Cr.P.C., stating that the petitioner had acquainted with the deceased in the Xerox shop run by the deceased and she introduced the first accused to the deceased. On said introduction, the first accused assured to get employment to the post of office assistant to the deceased. Therefore, the second respondent statement is nothing but improved one and only to implicated the petitioner as an accused, the statement was prepared.

    8. That apart, to corroborate the statement of the second respondent herein, no one has spoken about the said allegations. Further to attract the offence under Section 109 of IPC, there is absolutely no evidence and material available in the records. Merely on the basis of the statement of the second respondent herein, the petitioner has been implicated as second accused. The learned Senior Counsel rightly pointed out that on the phone call received from the first accused, the deceased and her wife viz., the second respondent went to the place of the first accused, where the first accused had given Sridi Saibaba prasadam in the form of powder to the deceased and the second respondent. After swallowing the said powder, the deceased fell down and the second respondent spit it out. Immediately both were taken to hospital, where her husband died and fortunately the second respondent survived.

    9. On perusal of statement of witness it is seen that one Hamasavarthini Senior Analysts of food, Food Analysis Lab, Kings Institute, Guindy, stated that the first accused had stolen the Sodium Cyanide from the laboratory. The said Sodium Cyanide was added with the Sridi Saibaba prasadam and administered to the victim. It is also corroborated by other witnesses. Therefore, the first accused alone stolen the Sodium Cyanide from the laboratory and administered the deceased through Sridi Saibaba viputhi. As far as the petitioner is concerned, though the prosecution laid charge sheet for the offences under Sections 420, 302 r/w 109 of IPC, there is no ingredient or evidence or material to attract the said offence. Therefore, there is absolutely no possibility of convicting the petitioner for the above said offences and in order to met the ends of justices the entire charge sheet as against the petitioner is liable to be quashed.

    10. Accordingly, this Criminal Original Petition stands allowed and the proceedings in P.R.C. No. 250 of 2019 on the file of the learned X Metropolitan Magistrate, Egmore, Chennai, is hereby quashed insofar as the petitioner alone. The learned X Metropolitan Magistrate, Egmore, Chennai, is directed to complete the committal proceedings in P.R.C. No. 250 of 2019, within a period of four weeks from the date of the receipt of a copy of this Order. After committal, the trial Court is directed to proceed with the trial without any interference of any of the observation made by this Court as against the accused person and pass orders on merits and in accordance with law. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bharathi v. State, Rep. By The Inspector Of Police And Another
    (Aug 25, 2020)