>
ORDER
Per: V Nallasenapathy, Member (Technical)
1. This is a Miscellaneous Application filed under Section 60(5) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 ('Code') seeking for the following prayers:
a) To issue directions to resolution Professional to disclose the highest offer/bid by resolution Applicants in the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process of the Corporate Debtor.
b) To issue directions upon the Resolution Professional and the Committee of Creditors to conduct bidding process by way of Swiss Challenge Method so as to maximize the value of the assets of the Corporate Debtor.
c) To call for record of process documents, minutes and records of CoC meetings.
d) To direct the CoC to consider the Resolution Plan submitted by the Applicant and such revised offer as may be submitted by the Applicant upon disclosure of highest bid of competing Resolution Applicants.
e) Ad-interim and interim reliefs and other orders as the Tribunal deems fit.
2. The Applicant is one of the Resolution Applicants and Respondent No. 1 is the Resolution Professional of the Corporate Debtor.
3. On a Section 9 Petition filed by the Operational Creditor, the Corporate Debtor was put under Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process by an order of this Adjudicating Authority and R1 is the Resolution Professional. During the course of CIRP, R1 invited Expression of Interest from the Prospective Resolution Applicants.
4. The Applicant states that it had sent its Expression of Interest to the Respondent no. 1 vide letter dated 03.12.2019 along with ₹25,00,000/- as earnest money deposit.
5. Subsequently, the Applicant submitted its Resolution Plan to Respondent No. 1 on 15.01.2020 wherein the Applicant had made an offer of ₹12.25 Crores out of which 10% would be payable as Performance Bank Guarantee within 7 days from the date of approval of the of Resolution Plan by the CoC.
2
6. The Applicant submits that in Clause 1.7 of the Resolution Plan, the Applicant had categorically sought for an opportunity to match or better the highest bid of the competing Resolution Applicants. The same was reiterated by the Applicant in its letter dated 03.02.2020 and 12.02.2020. The relevant portion of Clause 1.7 of the Resolution Plan is as follows:
"… Further Resolution Applicant states to CoC to give an opportunity to RA to Bid more than other Applicant, in case anyone has bid for more than ₹12.25 crores to match his bid or outbid him."
7. Thereafter, the Applicant was invited to attend the 5thCoC meeting held on 13.02.2020 wherein the Applicant revised his offer from ₹12.25 Crores to ₹12.5 Crores. The Applicant submits that it had expressed its willingness to increase the said offer of Rs 12.5 Crores further, to match the highest bidder and the same was communicated to Respondent No. 1 vide letter dated 14.02.2020.
8. It is further submitted by the Applicant that the shortlisting of the highest bidders was not done in his presence and that the Respondent No. 1 failed to disclose the highest bid of the competing Resolution Applicants and thus no opportunity was provided to it to make an offer to match the highest bid.
9. The Applicant contends that the opportunity given to lower bidders to outbid the highest bid of the competing Resolution Applicants, which is also called the Swiss Challenge Method, was adopted in the CIRP of Ruchi Soya Industries Limited. He further contends that this process would serve in maximizing the value of assets and thus improve the value of CIRP of the Corporate Debtor.
10. To support his contentions, Applicant relied on an Order of the Hon'ble NCLT, Principal Bench, New Delhi in the case of Punjab National Bank Vs. Bhushan Steel & Powers Ltd. [CA (IB) 152/PB/2018 in CP(IB) 202/PB/2017] wherein it was held that neither the Resolution Professional nor the CoC can impose restrictions upon a Resolution Applicant by denying its legitimate right to participate in the bidding process and revise its offer till the bidding process is complete.
11. However, this Bench is of the view that the judgement cited supra may not be of any avail to the Applicant in view of the fact that the applicant was given an opportunity to present its plan before the CoC and further opportunity was given to improve its plan which it has exercised by
3
improving the offer from ₹12.25 crores to ₹12.5 crores. The Counsel for the Resolution Applicant (R1) and the CoC submitted that the improved offer is not the highest offer and there is a resolution applicant whose offer is more than the offer of Rs.12.5 Crores. It is further submitted that the highest offer of another Resolution Applicant was accepted by the CoC and the Resolution Plan was approved by the CoC in its meeting held on 13.02.2020 with requisite voting percentage.
12. Further, we are of the view that the Swiss Challenge method (usually adopted for Govt tendering process to facilitate the awarding of contract in the second round of bidding to the highest bidder) as suggested by the applicant does not find any place in the IBBI (Insolvency Resolution Process for Corporate Persons) Regulations, 2016 ("CIRP Regulations"), as the CIRP Regulations provide the manner in which the Resolution Plan has to be approved. The applicant herein framed the rule on his own and contended that rule has to be followed by the CoC for approving the resolution plan, disregarding the CIRP Regulations. The method suggested by the applicant, on the guise of maximization of value of Corporate Debtor, is nothing but an auction sale of the Corporate Debtor, where the commercial wisdom of the CoC has to take a back seat. If this contention is accepted, the CIRP Regulations framed by the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India will virtually become otiose. Hence the contention that Swiss Challenge method has to be followed for approval of resolution by CoC is rejected.
13. The counsel for the Applicant during the course of argument submitted that they are ready with an offer of ₹1 crore more than the highest bid made by the highest offeror (successful resolution applicant) but we are not inclined to go against the commercial wisdom of CoC.
14. It is beneficial to refer the Judgment of Hon'ble NCLAT in the case of Binani Industries Limited Vs Bank of Baroda & Anr.1[C.A. (AT) No. 82 of 2018] wherein it was held that :
"It is not a sale. No one is selling or buying the 'Corporate Debtor' through a 'Resolution Plan'. It is resolution of the 'Corporate Debtor' as a going concern. One does not need a 'Resolution Plan' for selling the 'Corporate Debtor'. If it were a sale, one can put it on a trading platform. Whosoever pays the highest price would get it. There is no need for voting or application of mind for approving a 'Resolution Plan', as it will be sold at the highest price. One would
4
not need 'Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process', 'Interim Resolution Professional', 'Resolution Professional', interim finance, calm period, essential services, Committee of Creditors or 'Resolution Applicant' and detailed, regulated process for the purpose of sale. It is possible that under a 'Resolution Plan', certain rights in the 'Corporate Debtor', or assets and liabilities of the 'Corporate Debtor' are exchanged, but that is incidental. It is not an auction. Depending on the facts and circumstances of the 'Corporate Debtor', 'Resolution Applicant' may propose a 'Resolution Plan' that entails change of management, technology, product portfolio or marketing strategy; acquisition or disposal of assets, undertaking or business; modification of capital structure or leverage; infusion of additional resources in cash or kind over time; etc. Each plan has a different likelihood of turnaround depending on credibility and track record of 'Resolution Applicant' and feasibility and viability of a 'Resolution Plan' are not amenable to bidding or auction. It requires application of mind by the 'Financial Creditors' who understand the business well."
15. The Hon'ble NCLAT, in a recent decision on 5/3/20, in the case of Shrawan Kumar Agrawal Consortium and Ors. Vs. Rituraj Steel Private Limited and Ors.2, While deciding the issue whether the Adjudicating Authority has exceeded its jurisdiction in passing order for re-bidding, despite the approval of the Resolution Plan by CoC, with a vote share of 84.70% of votes, held as below:
"14. In the instant case, the Adjudicating Authority has overturned the decision of the CoC regarding approval of the Resolution Plan despite being approved by 84.70 percent of the vote share of the CoC, on the pretext of maximization of value of the corporate debtor. The provisions investing jurisdiction and authority in the NCLT has not made the commercial decision exercised by the CoC of not approving the resolution plan or rejecting the same, justiciable. In the circumstances as stated above, it is clear that the Adjudicating Authority cannot interfere with the commercial wisdom of CoC. The direction for rebidding for maximisation of the value of the corporate debtor also amounts to an interference in the business decision of the CoC, which is not permitted in law".
5
16. The ratio laid down in the above decisions are squarely applies to the facts of the case on hand. The reliance of the applicant on the judgment of Mumbai Bench of NCLT dt. 30.11.2018 in MA Nos. 692/2018 and 811/2018 in CP 1399/2017 in support of his contention for outbidding is no avail to the applicant in view of the Judgment of the Hon'ble NCLAT in the case of Shrawan Kumar Agrawal Consortium cited above. For the very same reason the reliance of the applicant on the judgment of NCLT, Kolkata Bench dated 02.05.2018 in CA Nos. 201,235,224,227,233 etc. of 2018 is of no avail to the applicant. Further the reliance of the applicant on the judgment of Mumbai Bench of NCLT dated 21.12.2018 in MA No. 1569/2019 in CP No. 197/2018 is distinguishable on the facts of the case on hand and the same is of no avail to the applicant.
17. Accordingly, this Application is dismissed. -Sd- -Sd-
V. Nallasenapathy Suchitra Kanuparthi Member (Technical) Member (Judicial)
6