AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2022 INSC 851
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 226
  • Article 32
  • Schedule X of the Constitution
  • Article 145(3) of the Constitution
  • Article 179(c)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2022 INSC 851
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 226
  • Article 32
  • Schedule X of the Constitution
  • Article 145(3) of the Constitution
  • Article 179(c)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Supreme Court heard a batch of petitions in which senior counsel for all sides were heard. The petitions concern disputes under Schedule X of the Constitution (anti-defection provisions) and challenge actions of the Speaker, the Deputy Speaker and the Governor in relation to disqualification proceedings. At this stage the Court did not decide the merits; instead, it considered whether the questions raised require determination by a larger Bench.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the issuance of a notice for removal of a Speaker restricts the Speaker from continuing with disqualification proceedings under the Tenth Schedule, as held in Nabam Rebia (2016).
  2. Whether a petition under Article 226 or Article 32 can directly seek a decision on a disqualification petition from the High Courts or the Supreme Court.
  3. Whether a court can hold that a member is “deemed” disqualified absent an explicit decision by the Speaker.
  4. What is the status of proceedings in the House during the pendency of disqualification petitions against members.
  5. If a Speaker’s decision on disqualification “relates back” to the date of the impugned act, what is the status of intervening House proceedings.
  6. What is the impact of the deletion of paragraph 3 of the Tenth Schedule.
  7. The scope of the Speaker’s power to determine the Whip and leader of the legislature party and its interplay with the Tenth Schedule.
  8. Whether intra-party decisions are amenable to judicial review and, if so, to what extent.
  9. The extent of the Governor’s discretion in inviting a person to form the Government and whether that discretion is judicially reviewable.
  10. The scope of the Election Commission of India’s power in determining a split within a political party.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Nabam Rebia & Bamang Felix v. Deputy Speaker, Arunachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly, (2016) 8 SCC 1 A Speaker should refrain from adjudicating disqualification petitions while a motion for his own removal is pending (harmonising Article 179(c) and Schedule X). The Court observed that the reasoning in Nabam Rebia appears contradictory and requires “gap-filling” to uphold constitutional morality, indicating the need for reconsideration by a larger Bench.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

After examining the record and hearing counsel, the Court identified that the petitions raise significant constitutional questions concerning the interface between the Tenth Schedule, the Speaker’s powers, the Governor’s discretion, and judicial review. It highlighted, in particular, that the principle laid down in Nabam Rebia—preventing a Speaker facing a removal motion from proceeding with disqualification matters—rests on reasoning that the present Bench finds contradictory and incomplete. Because clarification is necessary to preserve “constitutional harmony” and “constitutional morality,” the Court concluded that a larger Bench must revisit the issue.

In exercise of its power under Article 145(3), the Court therefore framed ten substantial questions of constitutional interpretation (listed above) and determined that the matters warrant reference to a five-judge Constitution Bench.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court directed that the papers be placed before the Hon’ble Chief Justice of India for constitution of an appropriate five-judge Bench to decide the enumerated constitutional questions.

Implications: No final adjudication on the merits of the disqualification disputes has yet been made. The immediate consequence is that further proceedings will occur before a Constitution Bench, which will have the opportunity to reconsider Nabam Rebia and clarify the powers of the Speaker, Governor and courts under the Tenth Schedule. No new binding precedent is set until the larger Bench renders its judgment.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    SUBHASH DESAI v. PRINCIPAL SECRETARY, GOVERNOR OF MAHARASHTRA

    1. We have heard learned senior counsels appearing on both sides and perusing the material available on record.

    2. This Court is of opinion that the present batch of petitions raise important constitutional questions relating to interpretation of Schedule X of the Constitution pertaining to disqualification, as well as the powers of the Speaker and the Governor and the power of judicial review thereof.

    3. At the outset, it may be necessary to highlight one particular question raised in these batch of matters relating to the power of the Speaker/Deputy Speaker to initiate disqualification proceedings, when proceedings for removal from the said office has been initiated against them. In Nabam Rebia & Bamang Felix v. Deputy Speaker, Arunachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly, (2016) 8 SCC 1, a Constitution bench of this Court held as follows:

    “193….We are, therefore, of the view that constitutional purpose and constitutional harmony would be maintained and preserved, if a Speaker refrains from adjudication of a petition for disqualification under the Tenth Schedule, whilst his own position, as the Speaker, is under challenge. This would also, allow the two provisions [Article 179(c) and the Tenth Schedule] to operate in their individual constitutional space, without encroaching on the other.”

    4. We may prima facie observe that the proposition of law laid down by the Constitution bench in Nebam Rebia (supra), stands on contradictory reasoning, which requires gap filling to uphold the constitutional morality. As such, this question needs a reference to a Constitution bench for the requisite gap filling exercise to be conducted.

    5. Further, these matters merit reference under Article 145(3) of the Constitution to a 5-Judge bench as they raise other substantial questions of law as to the interpretation of the Constitution, which are:

    a. Whether notice for removal of a Speaker restricts him from continuing with disqualification proceedings under Tenth Schedule of the Constitution, as held by this Court in Nebam Rebia (supra)?

    b. Whether a petition under Article 226 or Article 32 lies, inviting a decision on a disqualification petition by the High Courts or the Supreme Court, as the case may be?

    c. Can a Court hold that a member is “deemed” to be disqualified, by virtue of his/her actions, absent a decision by the Speaker?

    d. What is the status of proceedings in the House during the pendency of disqualification petitions against the members?

    e. If the decision of a Speaker that a member has incurred disqualification under the Tenth Schedule relates back to the date of the action complained of, then what is the status of proceedings that took place during the pendency of a disqualification petition?

    f. What is the impact of the removal of Paragraph 3 of the Tenth Schedule?

    g. What is the scope of the power of the Speaker to determine the Whip and the leader of the house legislature party? What is the interplay of the same with respect to the provisions of the Tenth Schedule?

    h. Are intra-party decisions amenable to judicial review? What is the scope of the same?

    i. What is the extent of discretion and power of the Governor to invite a person to form the Government, and whether the same is amenable to judicial review?

    j. What is the scope of the powers of the Election Commission of India with respect to determination of a split within a party?

    6. The papers may be placed before the Hon'ble the Chief Justice for appropriate orders, immediately.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    SUBHASH DESAI v. PRINCIPAL SECRETARY, GOVERNOR OF MAHARASHTRA
    (Aug 23, 2022)