Loading..
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Acts
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — High Court of Delhi (Anup Jairam Bhambhani, J.) — 07 April 2022 (Judgment released 25.04.2022)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Juki India Private Limited, filed a petition under Section 11 of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 seeking appointment of a sole arbitrator to adjudicate disputes said to have arisen with the respondent, M/s Capital Apparels Technology Private Limited, under a Distribution Agreement dated 01.07.2010 and later renewals/amendments, the most recent being a Distribution Agreement dated 01.01.2021 (covering 01.01.2021 to 31.12.2021).

The petitioner relied on arbitration clauses appearing as clause 10(e) in the 01.07.2010 agreement and clause 13 in the 01.01.2021 agreement. The parties also executed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) dated 31.12.2020 in which the respondent purportedly admitted dues and undertook to pay about Rs. 4.53 crore; the petitioner alleges the respondent failed to honour the MoU. Demand notices (dated 23.09.2020 and 07.08.2021) and an invocation notice (dated 27.09.2021) were sent by the petitioner proposing two former judges as sole arbitrator; the respondent disputed the demands, made a counter-claim and declined to concur in the proposed arbitrator names.

Notice was issued on 30.11.2021. The respondent's written reply (18.01.2022) challenged the territorial jurisdiction of the Delhi High Court, contended non-arbitrability of the disputes, asserted that the 01.07.2010 distribution agreement was novated by subsequent agreements and MoUs (including MoUs dated 28.05.2018 and 31.12.2020) and argued that the MoUs—having no arbitration clause—precluded invocation of arbitration.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether this Court (the Delhi High Court) has territorial jurisdiction to entertain the Section 11 petition when the distribution agreements and arbitration clauses are silent as to the seat/venue/territorial jurisdiction.
  2. Whether there exists a subsisting arbitration agreement between the parties enforceable under Section 11 of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 (i.e., whether clauses 10(e) and 13 constitute an arbitration agreement capable of reference).
  3. Whether the disputes arising out of or touching the MoU dated 31.12.2020 fall within the scope of the arbitration clauses in the distribution agreements and are therefore arbitrable.
  4. Whether the execution of subsequent MoUs (including 28.05.2018 and 31.12.2020) novates or displaces the arbitration agreement contained in the earlier distribution agreements.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments (as advanced by Mr. Dhruv Wahi)

  • The distribution agreements (01.07.2010 and 01.01.2021) contain arbitration clauses (clause 10(e) and clause 13 respectively) but do not specify the place/seat or territorial jurisdiction; therefore the Court competent under Section 11 should be determined by reference to the statutory provisions (Section 2(1)(e) of A&C Act read with Sections 16–20 CPC).
  • There is an admitted acknowledgment of dues in the MoU dated 31.12.2020 by which the respondent undertook to pay about Rs. 4.53 crore; that MoU has not been complied with and disputes remain unresolved.
  • Several invoices claimed by the petitioner were raised in New Delhi and the respondent has a registered office within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court; reliance on Section 20 CPC (sub-sections (a) and (c)) supports jurisdiction of this Court to entertain the petition.
  • Where the seat is not designated by the parties, the Court before which a Section 11 petition is filed (as defined in the A&C Act read with CPC provisions) is competent to deal with the appointment of an arbitrator; thus the Delhi High Court is competent in the present matter.

Respondent’s Arguments (as advanced by Mr. Navodaya Singh Rajpurohit)

  • The distribution agreements and their arbitration clauses are silent as to territorial jurisdiction; the respondent argued that this factor militates against the present petition being maintainable before this Court.
  • The disputes between the parties culminated in the execution of two MoUs (28.05.2018 and 31.12.2020); the distribution agreements have been novated by subsequent agreements and, in any event, the MoUs do not contain arbitration clauses—therefore there is no subsisting arbitration agreement and the petition should be dismissed.
  • The respondent also challenged the arbitrability of the disputes and disputed the petitioner’s claims and quantum, having also filed a counter-claim.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Aarka Sports Management Pvt. Ltd. v. Kalsi Buildcon Pvt. Ltd., (2020) SCC OnLine Del 2077 Summarised principles: (i) Section 20(1) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act permits parties to determine the seat of arbitration; (ii) if the seat is determined the Court of that place has exclusive jurisdiction; (iii) if the parties have not determined the seat, the Arbitral Tribunal may determine it under Section 20(2); (iv) if no seat is agreed, the competent Court for a Section 11 application is the Court as defined in Section 2(1)(e) of the A&C Act read with Sections 16–20 CPC. The Court relied on these principles to conclude that, absent a chosen seat/venue in the agreements, territorial jurisdiction for the Section 11 petition should be determined by reference to Section 2(1)(e) of the A&C Act and relevant provisions of the CPC; applying those principles and the factual position (registered office in Delhi and invoices raised in Delhi) the Court held it had territorial jurisdiction to entertain the petition.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a focused examination of the pleadings, documents on record (particularly the distribution agreements dated 01.07.2010 and 01.01.2021) and the parties' submissions.

Step 1 — Jurisdictional analysis: The arbitration clauses in both distribution agreements did not designate a seat/venue or specify courts' territorial jurisdiction. Relying on the summarised principles in Aarka Sports (supra) and statutory provisions (Section 2(1)(e) of the A&C Act and Section 20 CPC), the Court considered the question which Court is competent to entertain a Section 11 petition where the parties have not chosen a seat. Applying those principles to the facts (the respondent's registered office being in Delhi and prima facie some invoices having been raised in Delhi), the Court concluded that the Delhi High Court has territorial jurisdiction to entertain the petition.

Step 2 — Existence and scope of arbitration agreement: The Court observed that clause 10(e) of the 01.07.2010 distribution agreement and clause 13 of the 01.01.2021 distribution agreement explicitly provide that "Every dispute, difference, or question ... touching or arising out of or in respect of this agreement (deed) or the subject matter thereof shall be referred to the arbitrator to be appointed by JIN and the decision of the arbitrator shall be final and binding on the parties." On that basis, the Court held that the parties had agreed to refer inter se disputes under those distribution agreements to arbitration under the A&C Act.

Step 3 — Effect of the MoU(s): Although the respondent contended that the MoU dated 31.12.2020 (and another MoU dated 28.05.2018) did not contain arbitration clauses and therefore ousted arbitration, the Court analysed the relationship between the MoU and the underlying distribution agreements. The Court noted that the 31.12.2020 MoU was founded upon business transactions conducted by the parties inter alia under the parent distribution agreement (01.07.2010). The Court reasoned that the subject matter of the MoU falls within the language used in the arbitration clauses ("... dispute ... touching or arising out of or in respect of this agreement ... or the subject matter thereof") and therefore the disputes recorded in and arising from the MoU are within the scope of the arbitration agreement contained in the distribution agreements.

Step 4 — Arbitrability: The Court recorded that, prima facie, none of the disputes sought to be raised appear to be non-arbitrable.

On the above basis, the Court concluded that the petitioner was entitled to relief under Section 11 and that the petition should be allowed.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition under Section 11 of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 is allowed and disposed of.

Immediate consequences and directions given by the Court:

  • The disputes between the parties are referred to arbitration under the aegis of the Delhi International Arbitration Centre (DIAC), New Delhi.
  • The arbitration is to be conducted in accordance with the rules and regulations of DIAC, including arbitrator's fees and arbitration costs as provided under those rules.
  • The Court directed that a copy of the order be sent to learned counsel for the parties and to the Director, DIAC for information and compliance.
  • Pending applications, if any, were also disposed of.

Broader implications: The opinion applies existing law (as summarized in Aarka Sports) to determine territorial jurisdiction where the arbitration clauses are silent on seat/venue. The judgment does not purport to set any new legal precedent beyond applying those principles to the facts; its direct effect is to compel reference of the parties' disputes to arbitration under DIAC and to confirm the Court's territorial competence in the circumstances described.

This summary is prepared strictly from the content of the provided opinion and does not add facts or infer matters not contained in the judgment.

    JUKI INDIA PRIVATE LIMTED v. M/S CAPITAL APPARELS TECHNOLOGY PRIVATE LIMITED

    $~S-5 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI th Date of decision: 07 April, 2022

    + ARB.P. 1151/2021

    JUKI INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED ..... Petitioner Through: Mr. Dhruv Wahi with Mr. Paras Joshi, Advocates.

    versus

    M/S CAPITAL APPARELS TECHNOLOGY PRIVATE LIMITED ..... Respondent

    Through: Mr. Navodaya Singh Rajpurohit, Advocate.

    CORAM:

    HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANUP JAIRAM BHAMBHANI J U D G M E N T (Judgment released on 25.04.2022)

    ANUP JAIRAM BHAMBHANI J. (ORAL) By way of the present petition under section 11 of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act 1996 („A&C Act"), the petitioner Juki India Private Limited, seeks appointment of an arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes that are stated to have arisen with the respondent M/s Capital Apparels Technology Private Limited, from Distribution Agreement dated 01.07.2010 as renewed, extended and/or amended from time-to-time, the most recent renewal being by way of

    Distribution Agreement dated 01.01.2021 covering the period from 01.01.2021 to 31.12.2021. Mr. Dhruv Wahi, learned counsel for the ARB.P. 1151/2021 Page 1 of 8

    1

    petitioner, has drawn attention to clause 10(e) of Distribution Agreement dated 01.07.2010 and to clause 13 of Distribution Agreement dated 01.01.2021, which contain the arbitration agreement between the parties.

    2. Mr. Wahi, submits that no clause, covenant or provisions in the distribution agreements contains any reference to the place where the agreements were signed; nor does the opening part of the agreements recite to that effect. It is pointed-out that there is no clause in the agreement as regards „territorial jurisdiction" of courts for purposes of disputes arising from them; and even the arbitration provisions embedded in the agreements do not specify any „seat" or „venue" or jurisdiction otherwise, for arbitration proceedings.

    3. Mr. Wahi further submits that in admission of the dues owed by respondent to the petitioner, the parties signed a Memorandum of Understanding dated 31.12.2020 („MoU"), whereby the parties agreed to settle all past dues; and the respondent undertook to pay to the petitioner the outstanding sum of about Rs. 4.53 crore, in terms of the commitments comprised in the MoU. It is submitted however, that the respondent has not honoured the terms agreed to in the MoU; and their inter-se disputes remain unresolved.

    4. In this backdrop, the petitioner caused to be issued to the respondent demand notices dated 23.09.2020 and 07.08.2021; and subsequently also an invocation notice dated 27.09.2021, invoking the arbitral mechanism and calling upon the respondent to concur in the appointment of a sole arbitrator from amongst two former Hon"ble ARB.P. 1151/2021 Page 2 of 8

    2

    Judges of this court whose names were proposed in the notice. Vidé reply dated 11.10.2021 (erroneously mentioned as 11.10.2017) received from the respondent, in essence and substance, the respondent has disputed the demands; has made a counter-claim; and has also declined to concur in the appointment of any of the proposed names as sole arbitrator.

    5. Notice on this petition was issued on 30.11.2021, observing that the petitioner seeks reference of disputes only under distribution agreement dated 01.07.2010(erroneously recorded as 01.07.2020); consequent whereupon the respondent has filed reply dated 18.01.2022, inter-alia disputing the territorial jurisdiction of this court to entertain the present petition. The respondent has also contended that the disputes sought to be raised do not fall within the purview of the arbitration clause and are therefore non-arbitrable. The respondent has further submitted that distribution agreement dated 01.07.2010 stands novated by subsequent agreements; and cannot therefore be relied-upon for the purpose of raising disputes or for seeking reference to arbitration. It has been further urged that the disputes between the parties stand resolved and settled under two separate MoUs dated 28.05.2018 and 31.12.2020, pointing-out that none of the MoUs contain any arbitration clause; and that therefore the petitioner cannot invoke the arbitral remedy any longer.

    6. At this stage, it would be relevant to extract the arbitration clauses in distribution agreements dated 01.07.2010 and 01.01.2021:

    ARB.P. 1151/2021 Page 3 of 8

    3

    Agreement dtd 01.07.2010Agreement dtd 01.01.2021
    “10. Terms of Agreement … e. Arbitration Every dispute, difference, or question which may at any time arise between the parties hereto or touching or arising out of or in respect of this agreement (deed) or the subject matter thereof shall be referred to the arbitrator to be appointed by JIN and the decision of the arbitrator shall be final and binding on the parties.”“13. Arbitration Every dispute, difference, or question which may at any time arise between the parties hereto or touching or arising out of or in respect of this agreement (deed) or the subject matter thereof shall be referred to the arbitrator to be appointed by JIN and the decision of the arbitrator shall be final and binding on the parties.”

    7. In support of his contention, that absent any stipulation as to territorial

    jurisdiction in the distribution agreements, this court has territorial jurisdiction to entertain and decide the present petition, Mr. Wahi places reliance on the decision of this court in "Aarka Sports Management Pvt. Ltd. vs. Kalsi Buildcon Pvt. Ltd" reported as (2020) SCC OnLine Del 2077, in which decision, while summarizing the principles in that behalf, a Co-ordinate Bench of this court has held as under:

    "Summary of Principles

    "24. Section 20 (1) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act empowers the parties to determine the seat of arbitration. The parties are at liberty to choose a neutral seat of arbitration where neither the cause of action arose nor the parties reside or work and Sections 16 to 20 of the Code of Civil Procedure would not be attracted.

    "25. Once the seat is determined, the Court of that place shall have exclusive jurisdiction to deal with all matters relating to arbitration ARB.P. 1151/2021 Page 4 of 8

    4

    agreement between the parties.

    "26. If the parties have not determined the seat of arbitration, the seat of arbitration shall be determined by the Arbitral Tribunal under Section 20(2) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act.

    "27. If the parties have not agreed on the seat of the arbitration, the Court competent to entertain an application under Section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act would be the "Court" as defined in Section 2(1) (e) of the Act read with Sections 16 to 20 of the Code of Civil Procedure." (emphasis in original)

    8. Mr. Wahi submits that since in the present case the distribution agreements are completely silent as to the „seat" or „venue" of arbitration and as to the „territorial jurisdiction" of courts in relation to the arbitration agreement, the petitioner"s case would be covered by the principle summarised in para 27as extracted above, namely, that the territorial jurisdiction would lie with a court as defined in section 2(1)(e) of the A&C Act, that is to say the „principal civil court of original jurisdiction" which would be competent to decide the questions forming subject matter of the arbitration if the same had been subject matter of a civil suit.

    9. Furthermore, attention is drawn to the provisions of section 20 of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908 („CPC'), to say that in the present case, since the registered office of the defendant is situate within the territorial jurisdiction of this court in Delhi; and that at least some of the invoices which are claimed to be due and payable by the respondent were raised at New Delhi, this court would be competent to entertain and decide the present petition. On this point, Mr. Wahi ARB.P. 1151/2021 Page 5 of 8

    5

    draws attention to section 20(a) and (c) of the CPC which read as under :

    "20. Other suits to be instituted where defendants reside or cause of action arises.—Subject to the limitations aforesaid, every suit shall be instituted in a Court within the local limits of whose jurisdiction—

    (a) the defendant, or each of the defendants where there are more than one, at the time of the commencement of the suit, actually and voluntarily resides, or carries on business, or personally works for gain; or

    * * * * *

    (c) the cause of action, wholly or in part, arises. * * * * * " 10. On the other hand, Mr. Navodaya Singh Rajpurohit, learned counsel for the respondent, has argued that for one, the arbitration clauses contained in the distribution agreements are completely silent as to „territorial jurisdiction". Besides it is urged that since the disputes between the parties culminated in the signing of two MoUs, the distribution agreements are of no consequence now; and the petitioner"s claims can at best be said to arise from the MoUs, which do not contain any arbitration clause. Accordingly, it is argued that there is no subsisting arbitration agreement between the parties and the present petition deserves to be dismissed.

    11. Upon a conspectus of the averments contained in the petition and in the reply; the documents placed on record, in particular distribution agreements dated 01.07.2010 and 01.01.2021, upon which reliance is placed; keeping in view the existence of the arbitration agreements contained in clauses 10(e) and 13 respectively of the said distribution agreements; as also the decision of the Co-ordinate Bench of this ARB.P. 1151/2021 Page 6 of 8

    6

    court in Aarka Sports Management (supra) read with section 2(1)(i) of the A&C Act and section 20 of the CPC, this court is of the following opinion :

    i. Since the respondent has its registered office in Delhi within the territorial jurisdiction of this court; and some of the amounts claimed by the petitioner are due against invoices that have prima-facie been raised in Delhi, this court has territorial jurisdiction to entertain and decide the present petition;

    ii. Clause 10(e) of the parent distribution agreement dated 01.07.2010 and clause 13 of the latest distribution agreement dated 01.01.2021 clearly record that the parties have agreed to refer their inter-se disputes arising from the distribution agreements to arbitration by a sole arbitrator under the provisions of the A&C Act;

    iii. A perusal of MoU dated 31.12.2020 also shows that certain monies were owed by the respondent to the petitioner against invoices raised, which monies are claimed to be due till date;

    iv. Although it has been contended on behalf of the respondent that MoU dated 31.12.2020 does not contain an arbitration clause, and therefore, the disputes cannot be referred to arbitration, this court sees no merit in that contention, since MoU dated 31.12.2020 is itself founded upon the business transactions conducted by the parties inter-alia under distribution agreement dated 01.07.2010; ARB.P. 1151/2021 Page 7 of 8

    7

    and the subject matter of the MoU is therefore itself part of a " ... dispute, difference, or question which may at any time arise between the parties hereto or touching or arising out of or in respect of this agreement (deed) or the subject matter thereof ..." as contemplated in the arbitration agreement contained in the distribution agreements;

    v. This court is also satisfied that prima-facie none of the disputes that are sought to be raised appear to be non- arbitrable.

    12. In view thereof, this court is to persuade to allow the present petition.

    13. Accordingly, as requested jointly by the parties, the disputes between them are referred to arbitration under the aegis of the Delhi International Arbitration Centre (DIAC), New Delhi; for the arbitration to be conducted in accordance with the rules and regulations of the said institution, including arbitrator"s fee and arbitration costs as provided thereunder.

    14. A copy of this order be sent to learned counsel for the parties.

    15. A copy of this order be also sent to the Director, DIAC for information and compliance.

    16. The petition is allowed in the above terms and disposed of accordingly.

    17. Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.

    ANUP JAIRAM BHAMBHANI, J

    APRIL 7, 2022/ds

    ARB.P. 1151/2021 Page 8 of 8

    8

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    JUKI INDIA PRIVATE LIMTED v. M/S CAPITAL APPARELS TECHNOLOGY PRIVATE LIMITED
    (Apr 7, 2022)