This matter is listed for admission today. Heard the learned counsel for the appellant.
2. The factual matrix of the case is that, the plaintiffs have filed a suit before the Trial Court seeking relief of partition in respect of suit schedule property contending that the suit schedule property is granted in favour of their father Late Ningachari. The defendants No.1 and 2, who are the brothers of the plaintiffs have sold the property along with their mother defendant No.3 in favour of defendant No.4, who is the appellant herein, contending that their father had died intestate leaving behind plaintiffs as well as defendant Nos. 1 to 3. The defendant Nos.1 to 3 are not having any absolute right but alienated the suit schedule property in favour of the defendants No.4 excluding the plaintiffs No.1 and 2. Hence, the registered sale deed executed by the defendant Nos.1 to 3 in favour of defendant No.4 is not binding upon the share of the plaintiffs. Hence, they have sought for the relief of partition and separate possession claiming 1/5th share each in the suit schedule property.
3. The defendant No.4 who is the appellant herein, also filed written statement contending that suit schedule property is sold in favour of him for family necessity and also plaintiffs have not included all other properties belongs to the family. The defendant No.4 also contended that, he is the bonafide purchaser of the suit schedule property for the valuable consideration. Hence, the Trial Court has framed the following issues based on the pleadings:
(i) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for 2/5th share in the suit schedule properties by metes and bounds?
(ii) Whether the defendant No.4 who is the appellant herein, is the bonafide purchaser of the suit schedule property?
(iii) Whether the defendant No.4 proves that plaintiffs are not entitled for share in the suit schedule property?
4. The Trial Court after considering both oral and documentary evidence allowed the suit and granted the relief as sought in the plaint, in coming to the conclusion that the sale deed executed by defendants No.1 to 3 in favour of defendant No.4 is not binding upon the share of the plaintiffs and it is also further ordered and decreed that, while drawing final decree, the suit schedule item No.1 as far as possible to be allotted to the share of defendants No.1 to 3.
5. Being aggrieved by the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court, the appellant herein has filed an appeal which is numbered as R.A No.25/2020. The First Appellant Court on re- appreciation of oral and documentary evidence framed the following points for consideration. Whether plaintiffs are entitled for legitimate share in the suit schedule properties as claimed? Whether the defendant No.4 proves that, he is a bonafide purchaser of item No.1 of the suit schedule property and his sale is to be protected under the law?
6. Having considered the materials available on record and also on re-appreciation of the materials available on record the First Appellant Court also dismissed the appeal.
7. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant herein vehemently contend that, the sale is for the family necessity and not considered the recitals of the documents of the sale deed, wherein it is mentioned the sale is made for family necessity. Learned counsel for the defendant / appellant also submits that, the appellant has purchased the property for valuable sale consideration and he is a bonafide purchaser of the suit schedule property. The counsel also brought to the notice the averments made in the plaint and contend that no allegations are made against defendants No.1 to 3 viz., two sons and widow of Ningachari, colluded with each other and illegally sold the property to defendant No.4. It is not their case that they committed fraud and suppressed their right and sold the property and they were having any bad vices while selling the property.
8. The learned counsel also brought to the notice of this Court that the defendant / appellant who had taken the defence that there are other properties are available which are not included in the suit and even the landed property was also not added in the plaint. Hence, on the threshhold, the plaint is sought to be rejected which is specifically pleaded in paragraph No.4(a) and also contend that failure to include other properties in the partition suit, itself amounts to suit for partial partition.
9. Learned counsel also brought to the notice of documents which have been exhibited as Exs.D4 to 6. The learned counsel in support of his contention also relied upon the judgment of ILR 1998 Kar 681, in the case of Sri Tukaram vs. Sambhaji and others, wherein this Court held that the suit for partial partition is not maintainable and the same is a substantial question of law. Even though the joint family owned number of properties, the Trial Court held that the suit is not maintainable, but First Appellant Court reversed the same and in second appeal held that suit for partial partition is not maintainable and restored the decree of the Trial Court.
10. The learned counsel for the appellant also relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in 1970(3) SCC 722, in the case of Smt.Rani and another vs. Smt.Santa Bala Deenath and others, and brought to the notice of this Court in paragraph No.11, wherein discussion was made with regard to the recital of the document.
11. The learned counsel for the appellant also relied upon the judgment reported in (1997) 9 SCC 701, in the case of Sunder Das and others vs. Gajananrao and others, wherein regarding the alienation of legal necessity if alienation by father as karta of joint Hindu family, father-karta legally entitled to alienate the property of the joint family and interest of minor member of the family for his own requirement unless it is shown that the transaction was tainted by any immoral or illegal purpose.
12. Learned counsel for the appellant also relied upon the judgment of the Apex Court in (2003) 6 SCC 595 in the case of Roop Kumar vs. Mohan Thedani, with regard to the Sections 91 and 92 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, with regard to documentary evidence prevails over the oral evidence.
13. Having heard the learned counsel for the appellant and learned counsel for the respondents and also on perusal of the materials available on record, it is not in dispute that property is granted in favour of Ningachari and appellant also not disputing the said fact and also not disputed the fact Ningachari who is the original owner died intestate. Hence, it is clear that the property is the separated property of the said Ningachari and it is the self acquired property of the said Ningachari and plaintiffs have approached the Court for the grant of relief of partition and also contend that he died intestate. The appellants herein though disputed the plaintiffs are not legal representatives of Late Ninagachari but have not seriously disputed the relationship between the parties.
14. The main contention that sale was made for the family necessity and also learned counsel brought to the notice of this Court particularly in para No.3 of its sale deed. On perusal of the sale deed it is mentioned that vendors have sold this property in order to purchase an alternative property on behalf of their minor children. When such being the case, first of all this is not the joint family property and this is the self acquired property of the Ningachari, who got the property during his life time and he died intestate. When he died intestate, the daughters and also sons and wife are entitled for equal share but the fact that sale was made by the wife and sons and excluded the plaintiffs herein. No doubt in the judgments referred supra, if the sale is made by the karta, for the family necessity that can be considered but in the case on hand sale is made not by karta but the wife and sons of the original owner. The property which has been granted in favour their father and the sale is only for the purpose of purchasing of alternative property, excluding the plaintiffs herein and not for family necessity as contended by the appellant counsel.
15. Having considered the material on record succession opens to the plaintiffs under section 8 of Hindu Succession Act and the same is not also disputed by the learned counsel for the appellant and only main contention that other properties have not been included in the suit. On perusal of the plaint, two items of the suit property are included in the plaint. It is not the case of the other defendants No.1 and 2, that they have excluded the other properties of the family. The defence is taken by the purchaser contending that in collusion with the plaintiffs and defendants they have filed this present suit in view of escalation of property value. In order to substantiate the said contention no material has been placed before the Trial Court. It is an admitted fact that the property belongs to the father and he died intestate. In view of section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, the plaintiffs are also entitled for share in the property and they have been excluded while selling the property. The Trial Court also taken note of the fact that defendant / appellant has not verified that who were all legal representatives of the said Ningachari while purchasing the property. Hence, the very contention that he was a bonafide purchaser of the suit schedule item No.1 of property cannot be accepted.
16. The Trial Court has taken note of the interest of the defendant No.4/ appellant herein while decreeing the suit and while passing decree, made it specific that the share of the defendants No.1 to 3 could be allotted to the defendant No.4/ appellant. The specific order is made that while drawing final decree, the suit schedule property item No.1 as far as possible to be allotted to the share of defendants No.1 to 3 wherein the interest of this appellant also protected.
17. The First Appellant Court also on re-appreciation of the question of fact and question of law taken note of the fact that the property is left by the father Ningachari and which is self acquired property of the father who died intestate and succession open to the parties under section 8 of Hindu succession Act. It is also taken note of the admissions elicited from the mouth of D.W. 1 in the cross examination and in paragraph No.39 in detail discussed the evidence available on record and taken note of the sale was made in the year 1997. When the sale is not made by the karta of the family and excluded the rights accrued to the plaintiffs on account of death of the father and even other sons and wife of deceased are not having exclusive right in the suit schedule property, but they have executed the sale deed excluding the plaintiffs. The Trial Court rightly comes to the conclusion that sale is made by the defendants No.1 to 3 is not binding on the plaintiffs. I do not find any error committed by both the Courts in coming to the conclusion that the plaintiffs are having share in the suit schedule property and sold in favour of the appellant herein. Other contention of the learned counsel for the appellant is that the Trial Court and also First Appellant Court committed an error in considering only oral evidence excluding the documentary evidence. I have already pointed that in the documentary evidence the recitals only with regard to sale of property for purchase of other alternative property and hence, it is not for family necessity, when such being the facts and circumstances of the case, the very contention of the learned counsel for the appellant cannot be accepted.
18. Admittedly, the suit schedule property is belongs to Late Ningachari and he died intestate and immediately on account of the death of said Ningachari, the plaintiffs and defendants No.1 to 3 have succeeded the estate of deceased Ningachari and while selling excluded the plaintiffs and executed sale deed. I do not find any merit in the appeal to invoke Section
100 of CPC to frame any substantial question of law with regard to Section 92 of the Indian Evidence Act as contended by the appellant counsel and hence, I do not find any force in the contention of the learned counsel for the appellant and both the Courts appreciated both oral and documentary evidence and not committed any error and in the absence of any perversity and substantial question of law, it is not a fit case to admit the second appeal.
19. In view of the discussions made above, I pass the following: ORDER
(i) The appeal is dismissed. Sd/- JUDGE