Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India challenges the order dated 22.06.2021 passed in Civil Suit No. 01-B/2021 by the Criminal Court District-Raipur, Chhattisgarh, which closed the opportunity of the petitioner/defendants to file a written statement. The petitioner received summons on 6 January 2021, and the time for filing the written statement was extended to 120 days, expiring on 06.05.2021. The case was listed for hearing on 15.04.2021 and 22.06.2021. The petitioner contended that no last opportunity was given to file the written statement and that the court was closed on 06.05.2021 due to COVID-19 lockdown measures.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the impugned order closing the opportunity to file a written statement after expiry of 120 days under Order VIII Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) as incorporated in the Commercial Courts Act was valid.
  2. Whether the Supreme Court's Suo-motu Writ (Civil) No. 03 of 2020, which excluded the lockdown period from limitation calculations, applies to the time for filing written statements.
  3. Whether the petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India is maintainable given the appeal provisions under Section 13(1)(A) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner argued that the lockdown period should be excluded from the limitation period for filing the written statement, relying on the Supreme Court’s Suo-motu Writ (Civil) No. 03 of 2020.
  • On 22.06.2021, the petitioner sought time to file the written statement on medical grounds as the counsel was in quarantine, but the trial court did not consider this prayer.
  • Reliance was placed on Supreme Court judgments including S.S. Group Pvt. Ltd. v. Aaditiya J. Garg, Kailash v. Nanhku, and S.C.G. Contracts (India) Private Limited v. K.S. Chamankar Infrastructure Private Limited, which granted liberty to defendants to file written statements beyond prescribed timeframes under certain circumstances.
  • The petitioner contended that the appeal provisions under Section 13(1)(A) of the Commercial Courts Act allow for appeals only from orders enumerated under Order 43 of CPC and Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, and thus this petition under Article 227 is maintainable.
  • Reliance was also placed on New India Assurance Company Limited v. Hilli Multipurpose Cold Storage Private Limited to support the applicability of the extension of limitation period due to the pandemic.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The respondent opposed the petition, arguing that the petition under Article 227 is not maintainable since Section 13(1)(A) of the Commercial Courts Act provides for appeal to the Commercial Appellate Division of the High Court against orders of the Commercial Court.
  • The respondent submitted that the impugned order is appealable under Order 43 of CPC and thus cannot be challenged by a single judge under Article 227.
  • It was argued that the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, does not permit condonation of delay beyond the prescribed 120 days for filing written statements.
  • The respondent distinguished the cited Supreme Court judgments, emphasizing that the opportunity granted in S.C.G. Contracts (India) Private Limited was a singular incident and not a binding precedent applicable to this case.
  • Reliance was placed on the Supreme Court decision in Sagufa Ahmed v. Upper Assam Polywood Products Private Limited, which clarified that the Suo-motu order on limitation extension applies only to initiation of proceedings and not to condonation of delay in filing written statements.
  • The respondent maintained that the petitioner had sufficient time to file the written statement and the grounds for delay were baseless, and condoning the delay would frustrate the object of the Act, 2015.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Suo-motu Writ (Civil) No. 03 of 2020 (Supreme Court) Exclusion of lockdown period (15.03.2020 to 14.03.2021) from limitation calculations. The court held that this order applies to limitation for initiating proceedings but not to condonation of delay for filing written statements.
S.S. Group Pvt. Ltd. v. Aaditiya J. Garg (2020 SCC OnLine SC 1050) Extension or liberty to file written statements beyond prescribed time in exceptional circumstances. Referenced by petitioner, but the court noted this was a singular incident and not a binding precedent.
Kailash v. Nanhku (2005) 4 SCC 480 General principles related to limitation and filing of written statements. Referenced in support of petitioner's arguments.
S.C.G. Contracts (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. K.S. Chamankar Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. (2019) 12 SCC 210 Time for filing written statement is mandatory and cannot be extended beyond prescribed period under the Act. The court relied on this decision to affirm that the right to file written statement stands forfeited after expiry of time.
Sagufa Ahmed v. Upper Assam Polywood Products Pvt. Ltd. (2021) 2 SCC 317 Extension of limitation period does not equate to condonation of delay for filing pleadings. The court applied this principle to reject the petitioner's claim that the lockdown period extension applies to filing written statements.
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Hilli Multipurpose Cold Storage Pvt. Ltd. (2020) 5 SCC 757 Extension of limitation period during pandemic. Referenced by petitioner; the court noted it but held that it does not permit extension of time beyond statutory limits for filing written statements.
Oku Tech Pvt. Ltd. v. Sangeet Agarwal (Delhi HC, 2016) Mandatory nature of amended Order VIII Rule 1 CPC regarding filing written statements. Cited to support that non-filing of written statement within prescribed time results in forfeiture of right.
Maja Cosmetics v. Oasis Commercial (P) Ltd. (Delhi HC) Similar to Oku Tech, reinforcing mandatory compliance with Order VIII Rule 1 CPC. Used to reinforce the principle of mandatory time limits for filing written statements.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first examined the maintainability of the petition under Article 227, concluding that the impugned order closing the opportunity to file the written statement is not appealable under Section 13(1)(A) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, as it is not an order enumerated under Order 43 of CPC or Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act. Hence, the petition is maintainable.

On merits, the court considered the provisions of Order VIII Rule 1 CPC as incorporated in the Commercial Courts Act, which mandates that after expiry of the prescribed period (120 days), the right to file a written statement is forfeited. The court relied on the Supreme Court’s decision in S.C.G. Contracts (India) Pvt. Ltd. which emphasized the mandatory nature of this time limit.

The court analyzed the petitioner’s reliance on the Supreme Court’s Suo-motu Writ (Civil) No. 03 of 2020, which excludes the lockdown period from limitation calculations. It held that this order applies only to the limitation period for initiating proceedings, not to condonation of delay in filing written statements. This position was supported by the Supreme Court’s ruling in Sagufa Ahmed.

The court observed that the petitioner had not filed any written statement till date, despite the expiry of the prescribed and extended time. The petitioner’s prayer for further extension was effectively a request for condonation of delay, which is not permissible under the statutory provisions.

Accordingly, the court found no error in the trial court’s rejection of the petitioner’s prayer to file the written statement beyond the prescribed period.

Holding and Implications

The petition under Article 227 is dismissed at the motion stage, and the impugned order closing the opportunity to file the written statement is upheld.

The direct effect of this decision is that the petitioner is not permitted to file the written statement after the expiry of the prescribed period of 120 days under the Commercial Courts Act and the Civil Procedure Code. The court clarified that the Supreme Court’s extension of limitation period due to the COVID-19 lockdown does not apply to condonation of delay for filing written statements. No new precedent was set beyond affirming the mandatory nature of the statutory time limits and the non-appealability of the impugned order under the relevant provisions.

    Prakash Corporates, Through Its Partner Namely Shailesh Kumar Goyal v. Dee Vee Projects Limited, Through Its Director .

    Rajendra Chandra Singh Samant, J.:— This petition under Article 227 of Constitution of India has been brought being aggrieved by the order dated 22.06.2021 passed in Civil Suit No. 01-B/2021, by the Criminal Court District-Raipur, C.G., by which the opportunity of the petitioner/defendants for filing written statement was closed.

    2. It is submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the respondent has filed a Civil Suit in No. 01-B/2021 before the Criminal Court Raipur, C.G. The petitioner/defendant received the summons on 6 January, 2021. The time for filing written statement was extended for 120 days which got expired on 06.05.2021. The case was listed on 15.04.2021 and on that date the case was fixed for arguments on the application under Section 10 read with Section 151 of C.P.C. and application under Order 38 Rule 5 read with Section 151 of C.P.C., on 22.06.2021. No last opportunity was given by the Commercial Court to the petitioner for filing of written statement and on 06.05.2021, the Court was closed due to the imposition of lock-down in corona pandemic control measure.

    3. In the impugned order, the learned Commercial Court has held that according to the proviso under Order VIII Rule 1 of C.P.C. incorporated in Commercial Courts Act, after the expiry of 120 days from the date of service of summons, the right of defendants to file written statement stands forfeited and therefore, the opportunity of filing written statement by the petitioner was closed. It is submitted by the learned counsel for petitioner that on 22.06.2021, the petitioner filed application seeking time to file written statement on the medical ground as the learned counsel for the petitioner was in quarantine. The learned trial Court has not given any consideration on this prayer of the petitioner. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has in Suo-moto Writ (Civil) No.-03 of 2020 has ordered that while computing the period of limitation prescribed in general law and special Acts, the period between 15.03.2020 to 14.03.2021 shall stand excluded. On 27.04.2021, the suspension of limitation under general or special laws was further extended and the matter was listed for 19.07.2021. Hence, on the basis of this order of the Supreme Court, the limitation that has been counted without taking into consideration of the period of lock-down, is erroneous.

    4. Reliance has been placed on the judgment of Supreme Court in the case of S.S. Group Pvt. Ltd. v. Aaditiya J. Garg reported in 2020 SCC OnLine SC 1050 and the judgment of Supreme Court in Kailash v. Nanhku reported in (2005) 4 SCC 480. It is submitted that in the case of S.C.G. Contracts (India) Private Limited v. K.S. Chamankar Infrastructure Private Limited reported in (2019) 12 SCC 210. The Supreme Court granted liberty to the defendant and ordered that the written statement that was already produced to be taken on record. Therefore, it is prayed that this petition may be admitted and petitioner may be granted opportunity to file written statement in the Civil Suit before the Commercial Court.

    5. Shri Amrito Das, learned counsel for the respondent has appeared on caveat and he opposes the petition and the submissions made in that respect and submits that the present petition under Article 227 Constitution of India is not maintainable. Section 13(1)(A) of Commercial Courts Act Specifically provides that “Any person aggrieved by the judgment or order of a Commercial Court at the level of District Judge exercising original civil jurisdiction or, as the case may be, Commercial Division of a High Court may appeal to the Commercial Appellate Division of that High Court.” Therefore, the impugned order is appealable. Hence, in such a case, the appeal shall be maintainable against the impugned order, under Order 43 of C.P.C. and the same shall be heard by a Commercial Appellate Division Bench of the High Court. Therefore, there is no provision for hearing of such cases by a Single Judge. The amended provision of the C.P.C. filed under Section 16 of the Act, 2015 does not leave any scope of condonation of delay. It is submitted that in the case of S.C.G. Contracts (India) Private Limited (Supra), the Supreme Court is very clear on this point that the Commercial Court has no power to extend the time given beyond the period of 120 days. The opportunity that was given to the defendant in that case was a singular incident and does not lay down any precedent. Further, the defendant in that case had already filed the written statement in the present case, the petitioner has still not filed any written statement. In the case of Sagufa Ahmed v. Upper Assam Polywood Products Private Limited reported in (2021) 2 SCC 317, the Supreme Court has considered and it has been observed, that the order in Sou-moto is only for the purpose of extension of period of limitation and not to condone the delay. The time provided for filing of reply is prescribed period and therefore, this has to be not a limitation, which is not covered under the order of Suo-moto Writ (Civil) No. 03 of 2020.

    6. It is further submitted that the petitioner was granted sufficient time for filing of written statement and on the date fixed, the Courts was not closed. The grounds taken for non-submission of reply are baseless. On the last date, on which the case was fixed for hearing i.e. 22.06.2021, again the written statement was not filed and the limitation for filing written statement had already expired on 06.05.2021. It is submitted that if such delay in filing of written statement condoned, then the object of the Act, 2015 will be frustrated. Hence, the impugned order has been rightly passed. Therefore, it prayed that this petition may be dismissed at motion stage.

    7. In reply, it is submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the proviso of Section 13(1)(A) provides that an appeal shall lie from such orders passed by a Commercial Division of a Commercial Court that are specifically enumerated under Order 43 of C.P.C. as amended by this Act and Section 37 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act. There is a clear order of the Supreme Court in Sou-moto case extending the period of limitation.

    8. Reliance has been placed on the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of New India Assurance Company Limited v. Hilli Multipurpose Cold Storage Private Limited reported in (2020) 5 SCC 757. It is again submitted that the order in Suo-moto Writ Petition regarding extension of limitation is applicable in this case. Therefore, it is prayed that this petition may be allowed and relief be granted to the petitioner.

    9. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the documents present on record.

    10. Considered on the point of the maintainability. Section 13(1)(A) of Commercial Courts Act, 2015 (hereinafter referred to as the Act, 2015) provides as follows:

    “13. Appeals from decrees of Commercial Courts and Commercial Divisions:—

    (1A) : Any person aggrieved by the judgment or order of a Commercial Court at the level of District Judge exercising original civil jurisdiction or, as the case may be, Commercial Division of a High Court may appeal to the Commercial Appellate Division of that High Court within a period of sixty days from the date of the judgment or order”

    11. Although, the proviso mentions that appeal shall lie from such orders, which are specifically enumerated under Order 43 of C.P.C. as amended by the Act. The schedule Section 16 of Act, 2015 does not show any amendment in Order 43 of C.P.C. In such a case, the existing provision under Order 43 of C.P.C. has to be construed and taken into consideration. The order 43 Rule 1 of C.P.C. provides for appealable orders, in which the order passed by any Court under Order 8 Rule 1 of C.P.C. is not included. Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 also does not provide for appeal from such order, by which the opportunity for filing written statement is closed by the Court. Hence, on this basis, it can be held that the impugned order is not an appealable order, according to the provisions of Section 13 of the Act, 2015, therefore, the petition under Article 227 Constitution of India is maintainable.

    12. Considered on the submissions. The view of the Supreme Court in the case of S.C.G. Contracts (India) Private Limited (Supra) is very clear that the right to file written statement stands forfeited after the time prescribed for filing of written statement and the time extended according to the provisions contained in the enactment. Although, the case was under the provisions of the Consumer Protection Act and the time for filing of written statement had expired after the completion of prescribed period and the period that was extended according to the provision in the Act, the Supreme Court then held in paragraph 10:—

    “(10) Several High Court judgments on the amended Order VIII Rule 1 have now held that given the consequence of non-filing of written statement, the amended provisions of the CPC will have to be held to be mandatory. See Oku Tech Private Limited v. Sangeet Agarwal by a learned Single Judge of the Delhi High Court dated 11.08.2016 in CS (OS) No. 3390 of 2015 as followed by several other judgments including a judgment of the Delhi High Court in Maja Cosmetics v. Oasis Commercial (P) Ltd.”

    13. The Supreme Court ordered that the written statement filed by the appellant be taken on record. The judgment of Supreme Court in New India Insurance Company Ltd. (Supra) had been referred to in the judgment asked in S.S. Group Pvt. Ltd. (Supra).

    14. In the case of Shagufta Ahmed (Supra), it is held in paragraph 17:—

    “But we do not think that the appellants can take refuge under the above order in Cognizance for Extension of Limitation, In re. What was extended by the above order of this Court was only “the period of limitation” and not the period upto which delay can be condoned in exercise of discretion conferred by the statute. The above order passed by this Court was intended to benefit vigilant litigants who were prevented due to the pandemic and the lockdown, from initiating proceedings within the period of limitation prescribed by general or special law. It is needless to point out that the law of limitation finds its root in two latin maxims, one of which is vigilantibus et Non dormientibus Jura subveniunt which means that the law will assist only those who are vigilant about their rights and not those who sleep over them.”

    15. Taking into consideration the view settled by the Supreme Court and the applicability of the order of Supreme Court in Suo-moto Writ (Civil) No. 03 of 2020, the glaring fact present in this case is this, that the petitioners have till date not filed any written statement, the prescribed time for filing written statement and the time which can be extended by the Court both have expired. The case was fixed for hearing on 22.06.2021 even on that date, the petitioner was not ready and prepared to file the written statement, therefore, it appears to be a case in which the petitioner is making a prayer for extension of limitation. No Court can grant any extension of limitation against the provisions of the enactment under which the case is being considered and heard. Further, it is not a case of condonation of delay as the written statement is still not filed. Hence, I am of this view that the learned Commercial Court has not committed any error in rejecting the prayer made by the petitioner for granting time to file written statement. Accordingly, no substance is found to be present in this petition, hence, this petition is dismissed at motion stage.

    16. Accordingly, this petition is disposed off.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Prakash Corporates, ... v. Dee Vee Projects Lim...
    (Jul 9, 2021)