Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Orissa Pension Rules, 1977
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Orissa Pension Rules, 1977
Smart Summary

Court Opinion — Structured Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner challenged an order dated 11.06.2009 of the State Administrative Tribunal, Cuttack Bench, in O.A. No. 1513 (C) of 2009, seeking directions for release of pension, gratuity and retirement benefits. This High Court disposed of the writ petition on 24.01.2014 directing that the petitioner be treated as notionally regularized at least one day prior to superannuation, that his pension be fixed in accordance with rules and arrear pension be paid by the end of March 2014, with regular monthly pension thereafter.

The State challenged that order before the Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 10690 of 2017. The Supreme Court, by its judgment dated 01.04.2019, remitted the matter to the High Court to decide the case afresh on merits within six months. The matter was reheard in this Court.

Background facts specific to the petitioner: he initially worked as a Night Watchman from 15.11.1965 to 31.12.1969, then remained absent, and later tendered a joining report accepted on 02.04.1991. A District Consumer Forum order directed acceptance of the joining report from April 1991 and payment of salary; subsequent proceedings resulted in acceptance of joining effective 16.11.1995. The petitioner retired on 31.08.2002. The authorities denied gratuity and pension on the ground that he had not worked for ten years; the petitioner claimed entitlement based on counting earlier and later periods of service and claimed at least five years in work-charged establishment entitling him to pensionary benefits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner, a work-charged employee with service periods before and after an absence, is entitled to pension, gratuity and other retirement benefits by treating him as notionally regularized/absorbed into regular establishment for the purpose of pension computation.
  2. Whether, in view of settled decisions and government/memorandum resolutions, a work-charged employee can be notionally absorbed/regularized (including by creating a supernumerary post for at least one day) to entitle the employee to pensionary benefits despite non-availability of a vacancy.
  3. Whether the earlier direction of this Court dated 24.01.2014 should be given effect to, in view of the Supreme Court's remand dated 01.04.2019.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner relied on prior Tribunal and High Court decisions (including O.A. No. 70(8) of 1997, O.A. No. 622 of 1999 and W.P.(C) No. 8666 of 2004) and a cited decision State of Orissa v. Chaitanya Gouda and five others to assert entitlement to absorption/regularization from the time he completed five years of continuous service and consequential notional fixation of pay for pension computation.
  • The petitioner contended that he had completed more than five years in work-charged establishment (when counting relevant periods) and therefore was entitled to pension and other retirement benefits; alternatively he argued that counting service from 1991 would exceed ten years and entitle him to pension/gratuity under OCS (Pension) Rules, 1992.
  • The petitioner submitted that he had repeatedly represented for being brought over to regular establishment and relied on specific State resolutions/circulars (Finance Department resolution dated 22.01.1965, Works Department letter dated 25.05.1997 and Circular dated 27.09.1980) in support of his claim for regularization and pensionary benefits.

Opposite Parties' Arguments (State / Additional Government Advocate)

  • The Additional Government Advocate supported the order passed by the Tribunal. He did not dispute the general settled position of law regarding regularization of work-charged employees, but the Tribunal's order was otherwise defended.
  • At least one contention advanced on behalf of the State (mentioned and rejected by the Court in a related order) was that a work-charged employee could not be brought into regular establishment if there were no vacancies; the Court treated that contention as unsustainable in view of existing law permitting creation of a supernumerary post for the purpose.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Civil Appeal No. 10690 of 2017 (Supreme Court judgment dated 01.04.2019) Supreme Court remitted the High Court's earlier order back to this Court for fresh decision on merits within six months. The High Court reheard the matter and directed the State to comply with this Court's earlier direction dated 24.01.2014 within two months; the Court stated that the Supreme Court remand was "answered accordingly."
W.P.(C) No. 8666 of 2004 (Judgment dated 06.05.2004) High Court direction to absorb work-charged employees in regular establishment from the time they completed five years' continuous service and grant pensionary benefits on notional fixation of pay (citing State of Orissa v. Chaitanya Gouda). The Court relied on that line of authority to support the petitioner's entitlement to pension/gratuity on notional regularization.
State of Orissa v. Chaitanya Gouda and five others (as cited) Principle permitting notional fixation of pay and absorption for pension computation where work-charged employees have qualifying continuous service. Referenced by the Court and relied upon in earlier High Court decisions that were applied to entitle work-charged employees to pensionary benefits.
Civil Appeal No. 5575 of 2007 (Apex Court confirmation dated 22.07.2015) Apex Court confirmed the High Court's order allowing absorption and pensionary benefits in the cited writ petition. The High Court noted that its earlier order was confirmed by the Apex Court, reinforcing the settled position favourable to work-charged employees.
S.L.P. No. 22498 of 2012 (Apex Court) — as to Narasu Pradhan After the Apex Court's order in the SLP, authorities created a supernumerary post to regularize service for sanctioning pension. The Court cited the Narasu Pradhan outcome as an example of authorities creating a supernumerary post to regularize a work-charged employee for pension purposes.
W.P.(C) No. 1534 of 2008 — State of Orissa and others v. Jyostna Rani Patnaik and others (Judgment dated 19.12.2016) Direction of the Tribunal to regularize the service by creating a supernumerary post (if necessary) was affirmed by the High Court. The Court relied on this decision to support the proposition that regularization by creating supernumerary posts is an accepted remedy to confer pensionary benefits.
OJC No. 12017 of 2000 (order dated 02.04.2018, also referenced decisions dated 16.04.2019) Re-iterated that Finance Dept. resolution dated 22.01.1965 and memorandum dated 06.03.1990 support absorption/pensionary benefits after five years; affirmed that absence of vacancy is not a bar because a supernumerary post can be created for at least one day. The Court quoted and relied on this order to reject the "no-vacancy" contention and to justify creation of a supernumerary post to enable pensionary benefits.
O.A. No. 2389 of 1997 (order dated 23.02.1999) and O.A. No. 1819 of 1996 (as referenced) Instances where the Tribunal disposed of similar disputes and adjudicated on extension of pensionary benefits to work-charged employees, including retirees. The Court cited these Tribunal decisions as part of a consistent line of authorities addressing extension of pensionary benefits to work-charged employees.
O.A. No. 70(8) of 1997 and O.A. No. 622 of 1999 (as referenced) Tribunal orders directing absorption in regular establishment from the time five years of continuous service were completed, and computation of pension by notional fixation of pay. The petitioner relied on these orders and the Court treated them as part of the established practice supporting the petitioner's claim.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the factual record and the established legal position regarding work-charged employees and pensionary benefits. It observed that:

  • There exists a consistent administrative and judicial approach (citing Finance Department resolutions/memoranda and a series of Tribunal and High Court decisions) that where a work-charged employee has completed the requisite period (commonly five years) of continuous service, the period can be counted towards pensionary benefits upon absorption into regular establishment.
  • The Court emphasised prior High Court and Apex Court decisions confirming the practice of notional absorption and notional fixation of pay for purposes of calculating pension and related retirement benefits.
  • The Court addressed and rejected the contention that absence of a vacant post prevents such absorption: it accepted the proposition, supported by precedents quoted in the opinion, that a supernumerary post can be created and an employee can be notionally brought over to the regular establishment even if no clear vacancy exists, including bringing the employee over for at least one day to qualify for pensionary benefits.
  • The Court noted the particular procedural history in this case — including the District Consumer Forum and State Consumer Commission orders that affected the recognition of the petitioner's joining date — and that the Tribunal had allowed continuity of service at least from 02.04.1991 and directed payment of gratuity, while leaving consideration of regularization to be examined; the petitioner contended that the Tribunal did not decide pension/retirement benefits fully.
  • The Court criticised the State authorities for repeated non-compliance with directions and for dragging employees into successive litigations despite settled law and administrative instructions (resolutions/circulars). The Court considered those actions unacceptable and misleading to the courts.

On that basis and in view of the prior authorities and administrative instructions, the Court concluded that the Supreme Court's remand (01.04.2019) should be answered by directing compliance with the High Court's earlier order of 24.01.2014 and by requiring the State to effect the necessary steps to grant pensionary benefits — including creating a supernumerary post if necessary — within a specified timeframe.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court answered the Supreme Court remand by directing that the State opposite parties shall comply with the direction given by this Court on 24.01.2014, and complete the required exercise within two months from the date of receipt of the copy of the order.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The State is ordered to give effect to this Court's earlier direction (notional regularization at least one day prior to superannuation, fixation of pension according to rules, payment of arrear pension and regular monthly pension thereafter) and to complete the compliance within two months; this includes, if necessary, creating a supernumerary post to bring the employee onto regular establishment for pensionary entitlement.
  • The Court relied on and applied existing administrative instructions and a line of Tribunal/High Court/Apex Court decisions; the order follows established precedent rather than announcing an unfamiliar legal principle. The opinion does not purport to create a novel precedent beyond applying and re-affirming the settled position described in the opinion.

Administrative note: The Court permitted the parties' counsel to use the soft copy of the order available on the High Court's website or printouts thereof for all purposes in the manner prescribed (Court's Notice No. 4587 dated 25.03.2020).

    chandra nandi v. state and ors

    1. This matter is taken up through video conferencing.

    2. Heard learned counsel for the parties.

    3. By way of this Writ Petition, the petitioner has challenged the order dated 11.06.2009 passed by the learned State Administrative Tribunal, Cuttack Bench, Cuttack in O.A. No. 1513 (C) of 2009. The petitioner has further prayed for a direction to the opposite parties to release the pension, gratuity and retrial benefits to the petitioner.

    4. This writ petition was disposed of on 24.1.2014 with a direction as follows:-

    "We therefore direct that the petitioner should be treated to have been regularized in service at least one day prior to his superannuation notionally and we further direct that calculating his entitlements, his pension amount shall be fixed by the opposite parties - State, in accordance with the rules and the arrear pension of the petitioner so calculated shall be paid to the petitioner by the end of March, 2014 and further the monthly payment of pension shall be made to the petitioner regularly thereafter."

    5. However, the above order was challenged by the State Opposite parties in Civil Appeal No. 10690 of 2017 and the Hon'ble Supreme Court vide its judgment dated 1.4.2019 remitted back the same to this Court for deciding the case afresh on merits within a period of six months and the matter was reheard.

    6. It appears that such an issue was earlier before this Court in W.P.(C) No. 8666 of 2004. In the said writ application the W.P.(C) No. 19550 of 2011 petitioner, who was a work charged employee had also challenged the order dated 04.08.2003 passed by Odisha Administrative Tribunal", Cuttack in O.A. No. 2782 (C) of 1997, wherein the Tribunal instead of giving any direction towards pensionary benefits directed the 'authorities to prepare proper scheme and consider the case of the petitioner for regularization and other consequential benefits.

    7. The said writ application was disposed of on 06.05.2004. In paragraph-4 of the said order, it has been observed as follows:-

    "In respect of work charged establishment the Government of Orissa vide Finance Department Office Memorandum No. 5483/F dated 6th March, 1990 decided that consequent upon absorption of work charged employees in the corresponding post created in regular establishment, the period of service rendered by him in work charged establishment, shall count towards pensionary benefits under the Orissa Pension Rules, 1977 subject to the condition that the employees so absorbed should have served continuously for a minimum period of five years in the work charged establishment. This decision was not followed by the subordinate authorities. Thus, the fate of the work charged employees who rendered a quite good years of service remained in dark, xxx xxx xxx."

    Accordingly the said writ application was allowed and direction was given to absorb the petitioner in any establishment post from the time he completed five years continuous service till the date he retired from' service and thereafter his pension and other pensionary benefits shall be granted on the basis of notional fixation of pay in regular establishment as has been granted to the applicants in O.A. No. 622 of 1999 and other bases as reflected in the said order of this Court. The order passed by this Court, was confirmed by the Apex Court in Civil Appeal No. 5575 of 2007 dated 22.07.2015.

    8. Such was the issue in case of one Narusu Pradhan, a work charged employee, wherein after the order passed by the Hon'ble Apex Court in S.L.P No. 22498 of 2012, the authorities passed an office order on 08.05.2013 by creating supernumerary post, regularized his service for the purpose of sanctioning pension.

    9. This Court had also occasion to deal with this issue again in W.P.(C) No. 1534 of 2008, i.e. in the case of State of Orissa and others v. Jyostna Rani Patnaik and others, wherein direction of the Tribunal to regularize the service of the applicant's husband by way of creating a supernumerary post, if necessary from the time he had completed 5 years of service as work-charged employee by bringing him over to regular establishment was challenged before this Court by the State authorities. The said case was disposed of vide judgment dated 19.12.2016, affirming the view expressed by the Tribunal.

    10. The brief facts of the present case is that the petitioner joined as a Night Watchman under Executive Engineer, Angul Irrigation Division with effect from 15.11.1965 and worked till 31.12.1969, after which he remained absent. He resumed the duty on 02.04.1991 by tendering his joining report which was duly accepted by the competent authority, i.e. the Executive Engineer, who directed the Assistant Executive Engineer, Derjang Irrigation Sub Division to engage him as a Night Watchman for watching the structure of Balaram Prasad Branch Canal including cross-regulator mentioning on his joining report that it was accepted. Since the opposite parties did not pay his salary, he filed CD. Case No. 71 of 1994 before the District Consumer Dispute Redressal Forum, which directed the authorities to accept his joining report with effect from April, 1991 and pay his salary. Thereafter the same was challenged before the State Consumer Dispute Redressal Commission and pursuant to the order passed, however, the opposite partied accepted his joining report with effect from 16.11.1995. While he was so continuing he retired on 31.08.2002 on attaining the age of superannuation. The opposite parties denied him the gratuity and retirement dues including pension on the plea that the petitioner has not worked for a period of ten years. The petitioner therefore, approached the Tribunal in O.A. No. 1513 (C) of 2004 submitting therein even if his period of service would be counted from 1965 to 1969 and thereafter from 1995 to 2002, since he has completed more than 5 years in work charged establishment he is entitled for pension and other recital benefits as per the settled position of law. However, he prayed that since he has been performing his duty from 1991, he has completed more than 10 years of service and as such is eligible for pension and gratuity as per OCS (Pension) Rules, 1992. The Tribunal observed that the continuity of service at least from 02.04.1991 till his retirement on 31.08.2002 may be allowed and due gratuity be paid to him as per rules. However as regards other benefits such as regularization claimed by him, the same be considered in the light of the existing O.A. According to the petitioner, nothing was decided by the learned Tribunal with regard to grant of pension and other retrial benefits. Hence he approached this Court in the present writ application.

    11. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that in similar matter bearing O.A. No. 70(8) of 1997 in case of Duryodhan Mohanty and others and O.A. No. 622 of 1999, in which same point of law was under challenge and the learned Tribunal was pleased to allow the O.A and directed that the applicants shall be absorbed in any establishment posts from the time they completed five years of continuous service till the date when they retired from service. After such absorption, their pension and other pensionary benefits shall be computed on the bass of notional fixation of pay on the regular establishment by adding annual increments which fell due. The said common order passed by the Tribunal was challenged by the petitioner before this Court in W.P.(C) No. 8666 of 2004. Vide judgment dated 6.5.2004, this Court allowed the said Writ Petition by citing a decision in the case of (State of Orissa v. Chaitanya Gouda and five others), with the observation/direction as quoted above. Therefore, the petitioner is entitled to the benefit of pension, gratuity and other retrial benefits. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the petitioner has submitted several representations to be brought over to regular establishment entitling him to claim pension and pensionary benefits, but his grievance has not been redressed, even through the Finance Department has issued specific resolutions in this regard on 22.01.1965 and also the Works Department in his letter dated 25.05.1997 and Circular dated 27.09.1980 for regularization of services of such employees.

    12. Learned Additional Government Advocate, however advanced his argument in support of the order passed by the Tribunal, though he has not disputed the aforementioned settled position of law with regard to regularization of the work charged employees.

    13. It was also brought to the notice of this Court about the order dated 02.04.2018 passed in OJC No. 12017 of 2000, wherein it has been observed/directed as follow:-

    Having heard learned counsel for the parties and on perusal of the record, more particularly the order impugned herein, it appears that the Government in Finance Department vide resolution dated 22.01.1965 decided for absorption of such employees to regular establishment after completion of five years in the Work Charged Establishment. Subsequently vide memorandum dated 06.03.1990, Finance Department has also extended the pensionary benefit to work charged employees. Learned Tribunal in O.A. No. 2389 of 1997 vide order dated 23.02.1999 has already disposed of a case of similar nature. Even learned Tribunal has gone on to adjudicate one dispute in O.A. No. 1819 of 1996 regarding extension of pensionary benefit to such work charged employees, who have already retired. The plea of Additional Government Advocate to the effect that the opposite party could not have been brought over to regular establishment, as there was no vacancy, is not sustainable in law, as it has already been held in a catena of decisions that even if there is no clear vacancy, a work charged employee can be brought over to regular establishment for at least one day by creating a supernumerary post to make him entitled for pensionary benefit.

    In view of the above, we modify the order of learned Tribunal to the extent that the opposite party shall be brought over to the regular establishment for at least one day by creating a supernumerary post, if necessary and accordingly, he shall be extended with the pensionary benefit as would be admissible to him. The entire exercise shall be completed within a period of two months hence.

    14. It was also contended that relying on such decision, may other writ petitions, such as OJC No. 12017 of 2000 (decided on 16.04.2019), W.P.(C) No. 12017 of 2000 (decided on 16.04.2019) have also been disposed of.

    15. While dealing with the matter, this Court deprecates the action of the state-opposite parties. The state-opposite parties have not fair enough to comply the directions given by the Hon'ble Apex as indicated above and has only dragging such employees into multiple litigations. The state-authorities are also misleading this Court as well the Hon'ble Apex Court on each and every occasions in case of such types of work-charged employees, inspite of law settled in this regard and as well as specific circulars/resolutions/orders have been passed by the State Authorities in terms of the direction of this Court.

    16. In view of the reasoning given in the aforementioned paragraphs, the order dated 01.04.2019 passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 10690 of 2017 is answered accordingly. The State opposite parties are directed to comply the direction given by this Court on 24.01.2014 within a period of two months from the date of receipt of the copy of the order.

    Learned counsel for the parties may utilize the soft copy of this order available in the High Court's website or print out thereof at par with certified copies in the manner prescribed, vide Court's Notice No. 4587 dated 25.03.2020.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    chandra nandi v. state and ors
    (Feb 3, 2021)