Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Maharashtra Regional Town Planning Act
  • subsection (2) or (4) of section 126
  • Section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 ('the said Act')
  • Section 127 of said Act 5
  • Section 154 of the MRTP Act, 1966
  • Section 127 of the MRTP Act. 4.2.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Maharashtra Regional Town Planning Act
  • subsection (2) or (4) of section 126
  • Section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 ('the said Act')
  • Section 127 of said Act 5
  • Section 154 of the MRTP Act, 1966
  • Section 127 of the MRTP Act. 4.2.
Smart Summary

High Court of Judicature at Bombay — Writ Petition No.205 of 2021 (Oral Order dated 9 April 2021)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Petitioner, Jayantilal Himmatlal Oswal, is the owner of land originally acquired by registered sale deed dated 17 October 1986 (Survey No. 21, Hissa No. 1B). The development plan of Lonavala Municipal Council, sanctioned on 28 February 1978, reserved 390 sq. metres of the Petitioner's land for a playground for a primary school and 204.53 sq. metres for a development plan road. A revised development plan sanctioned on 29 June 2005 (effective 27 August 2005) continued those reservations.

The Petitioner transferred 204.53 sq. metres to the Lonavala Municipal Council by registered deed dated 31 July 2006 (against grant of FSI). Subsequent transactions reduced the Petitioner's holding to 1683.46 sq. metres as of 10 November 2009.

Alleging that the Council failed to acquire the 390 sq. metres reserved for the playground for about 40 years, the Petitioner served a purchase notice on the Lonavala Municipal Council on 21 July 2018 under Section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning (MRTP) Act, 1966. The Petitioner waited the statutory period of two years (until 20/21 July 2020) but says the Council took no steps to commence acquisition. The Petitioner filed the present Writ Petition (in December 2020) seeking, inter alia, declarations that the reservation had lapsed and that the land was available to the Petitioner for development.

Respondent No.3 (Lonavala Municipal Council) filed an affidavit (23 March 2021) acknowledging service of the purchase notice and stating that the Council sought a six-month extension from the Court because the matter was pending before its General Body and the nationwide lockdown (from 24 March 2020) had prevented decision-making. The State issued a Government Resolution (G.R.) dated 4 June 2020 under Section 154 of the MRTP Act granting a nine-month extension for completion of development work, which the Council sought to rely upon; the Petitioner disputed its applicability to acquisition proceedings.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under Section 127 of the MRTP Act, the reservation of 390 sq. metres of the Petitioner’s land lapsed because the Planning/Development Authority did not acquire the land by agreement or commence acquisition within the statutory timeframe after service of the purchase notice dated 21 July 2018.
  2. Whether the G.R. dated 4 June 2020 (granting a nine-month extension under Section 154 of the MRTP Act for completion of development work) applies to or extends the statutory period prescribed in provisions pertaining to acquisition (i.e., whether the Council could claim relief from lapsing of reservation on that basis).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The development plan reserving the Petitioner's land was sanctioned in 1978 and the reservation continued in the revised plan effective 27 August 2005.
  • Because the land was not acquired within approximately 40 years, the Petitioner issued a purchase notice under Section 127(1) MRTP Act on 21 July 2018.
  • The Council failed to acquire the land or commence acquisition within the two-year statutory period following the purchase notice, so under Section 127 the reservation is deemed to have lapsed and the land released to the owner for development.
  • The Respondents failed to comply with sub‑section (2) of Section 127 which requires the Government to notify the lapsing in the Official Gazette, thus necessitating the Writ Petition.
  • The Petitioner submitted that the G.R. dated 4 June 2020 relates only to development/construction permissions and does not apply to acquisition matters; therefore the Council cannot claim benefit of that G.R. to avoid lapsing of reservation.

Respondent No.3 (Lonavala Municipal Council) — Affidavit / Submissions

  • Admitted service of the purchase notice dated 21 July 2018 under Section 127 MRTP Act.
  • Stated that because the Petitioner filed the Writ Petition in December 2020, the Council wrote (17 February 2021) to their Advocate requesting a six-month extension in view of the matter being pending before the General Body of the Council and the nationwide lockdown (from 24 March 2020) which hindered decision-making.
  • Suggested that the Court may give the benefit of the G.R. dated 4 June 2020 (which granted a nine-month extension under Section 154 MRTP Act for completion of development/work) to the Council, although the G.R. does not expressly include acquisition matters.

Respondent No.1 (State of Maharashtra)

  • The Advocate appearing for the State submitted to the Orders of the Court (i.e., no substantive contest recorded in the opinion).

Table of Precedents Cited

The opinion refers to "case law relied upon by the Advocate for the Petitioner" but does not identify or cite any specific judicial precedents in the text of the provided opinion.

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the factual matrix and the relevant statutory provisions, focusing on Chapter VII of the MRTP Act (which deals with land acquisition) and, in particular, Section 127 (Lapsing of reservations). The Court reproduced Section 127 in full as it was central to resolution of the petition.

The Court noted the undisputed facts: the reservation arose under the final development plan that came into force on 28 February 1978, the reservation for 390 sq. metres continued under the revised plan effective 27 August 2005, and Respondent No.3 had not taken steps to acquire the reserved land for a prolonged period (about 40 years). The Petitioner served a purchase notice under Section 127(1) on 21 July 2018 and, according to the Petitioner, the Respondent did not commence acquisition within the statutory period of two years (i.e., by 21 July 2020).

On the point of the Government Resolution dated 4 June 2020, the Court analyzed its scope. The G.R. under Section 154 granted a nine-month extension for completion of development work and other stipulated work, expressly concerning permissions for development/construction. The Court found that the G.R. did not apply to acquisition matters under the MRTP Act. Consequently, the Council could not rely on that G.R. to avoid the legal consequences of failing to acquire or commence acquisition within the statutory period under Section 127.

The Court proceeded on the further alternative that even if the nine‑month extension under the G.R. were somehow applicable to acquisition matters, that extension in any event expired on 4 March 2021, and by that date Respondent No.3 still had not taken steps to acquire the Petitioner's 390 sq. metres.

On these bases the Court concluded that Respondent No.3 had failed both to acquire the land reserved under the final development plans and to commence acquisition within the period required after service of the purchase notice, resulting in the statutory lapsing of the reservation under Section 127(1). The Court therefore found that the reservation was deemed to have lapsed and the land released for the owner's use as otherwise permissible under the relevant plan.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Writ Petition is allowed in terms of prayer clauses (b) and (c) set out in the petition. The Court declared that the reservation in respect of 390 sq. metres of the Petitioner's land has lapsed under Section 127 of the MRTP Act and the land is released to the Petitioner for development as permissible under the plan. There shall be no order as to costs. The Writ Petition is accordingly disposed of.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The reservation of 390 sq. metres under the development/revised development plan has been held to have lapsed and the land is available to the Petitioner for development to the extent permitted by the applicable plan provisions.
  • The Respondent No.3 (Lonavala Municipal Council) cannot rely on the G.R. dated 4 June 2020 to avert the lapsing of reservation as the Court held that the G.R. does not cover acquisition matters; and, even on the Court’s hypothetical assumption, the extension would have lapsed prior to any acquisition steps being taken.
  • No order as to costs was made.

Broader implications: The opinion resolves the dispute between these parties on the specific statutory question of lapsing of reservation under Section 127 MRTP Act as applied to the facts before the Court. The provided opinion does not state that it establishes any new, general precedent beyond the application of Section 127 to the facts at hand, nor does it cite other judicial authorities in support.

Source: Oral order of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay (Coram: S.J. Kathawalla & Surendra P. Tavade, JJ.), dated 9 April 2021, as provided in the supplied opinion text.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Jayantilal Himmatlal Oswal v. State Of Maharashtra, Through Its Urban Development Department And Others

    PA-Nitin Jagtap 1 / 10 34-WP-205-2021.doc

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

    CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

    WRIT PETITION NO.205 OF 2021

    Jayantilal Himmatlal Oswal, ) Age : 64 years, Occupation : Business, ) R/of House No. 56/2, F-Ward, Lonawala, ) Taluka - Maval, District - Pune )…Petitioner Versus

    1. The State of Maharashtra, ) Through its Urban Development Department, ) Mantralaya, Mumbai )

    2.Director of Town Planning, ) State of Maharashtra, Ofce at Commissioner of Pune,) Pune )

    3.Lonawala Municipal Council, ) Through its Chief Ofcer, Lonawala, ) Taluka - Maval, District - Pune )...Respondents

    Mr.U.B.Nighot for the Petitioner. Mr.S.B.Kalel, AGP for the State. Mr.A.A.Garge for Respondent No. 3.

    1

    CORAM : S.J. KATHAWALLA, &

    SURENDRA P. TAVADE, JJ.

    DATE : 9TH APRIL, 2021

    (THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING)

    ORAL ORDER (PER S.J.KATHAWALLA, J.) :

    1. The Petitioner is the owner of land more particularly set out / described hereinafter. Respondent No.1 is the State of Maharashtra, Respondent No.2 is the Director of Town Planning Authority and Respondent No. 3 is the Lonavala Municipal Council.

    2. The Petitioner has fled the above Writ Petition inter alia seeking the following reliefs :

    "(b) That by an appropriate writ, order and or direction it is declared that the reservation, designation or allotment provided under the development plan and revised development plan of Respondent No. 3 - Lonavala Municipal Council in respect of 390 Sq. Mtrs. Land from Survey No. 21, Hissa 1 B, Lonavala within the jurisdiction of Lonavala Municipal Council is lapsed and said land is available to Petitioner for the purpose of development or otherwise, as is permissible;

    (c) That by an appropriate writ, order and or direction it is declared that the said reserved land i.e., 390 Sq. Mtrs. Land

    2

    from Survey No. 21, Hissa 1 B, Lonavala, within jurisdiction of Lonavala Municipal Council has been de-reserved under the provisions of Maharashtra Regional Town Planning Act as per the purchase notice dated 21.7.2018 for want of valid steps by Lonavala Municipal Council.;"

    3. The facts and circumstances giving rise to the present petition are in brief set out hereunder :

    3.1. Under a registered sale deed dated 17thOctober, 1986, the Petitioner and his brother purchased a plot of land ad-measuring 1945.46 Sq. Mtrs. bearing Survey No. 21, Hissa No. 1B alongwith a bungalow standing thereon, bearing municipal house No. 92, ward - G ('the said Land').

    3.2. The development plan of the Lonavala Municipal Council was sanctioned by the Government of Maharashtra vide G.R. No. TPS/1876/940 dated 28thFebruary, 1978.

    3.3. By the said development plan, 390 Sq. Mtrs. and 204.53 Sq. Mtrs. from and out of the said land came to be reserved for the purpose of Play Ground for Primary School and for the purpose of development plan road, respectively.

    3.4. Thereafter, the Development Plan underwent revision. However, as per the revised Development Plan sanctioned vide G.R. No. TPS. 1896/751/CR - 82/A/96/UD/ dated 29thJune, 2005, and which came into force on 27thAugust, 2005 the above reservations were continued.

    3

    3.5. In the year 2006 the Petitioner and his brother transferred an area of

    204. 53 Sq. Mtrs. from their land in favour of Respondent No. 3 - Lonavala Municipal Council by executing a registered deed of transfer dated 31stJuly, 2006 against grant of FSI. Therefore, the ownership of the Petitioner and his brother was reduced to 1740.95 Sq. Mtrs. from the original holding i.e. 1945.46 Sq. Mtrs.

    3.6. By a release deed dated 30thMarch, 2009 the brother of the Petitioner released and relinquished his share in the said land ad-measuring 1740.95 Sq. Mtrs. in favour of the Petitioner and the Petitioner became the absolute owner in respect of the said area ad-measuring 1740.95 Sq. Mtrs.

    3.7. Out of his land ad-measuring 1704.93 Sq. Mtrs. the Petitioner by a sale deed dated 10thNovember, 2009, sold 57.49 Sq. Mtrs. of land to Shri Pradeep Ramkishore Gupta. The Petitioner therefore, on and from 10thNovember, 2009, till date holds / owns the said land ad-measuring 1683.46 Sq. Mtrs. in place of the original 1945.46 Sq. Mtrs.

    3.8. According to the Petitioner, for the past 40 years i.e. from the year 1978 to 2018, the Respondent No.3 - Lonavala Municipal Council failed to acquire the said land which was kept under reservation for the purpose of Play Ground for Primary School.

    3.9. The Petitioner therefore, issued a purchase notice dated 21stJuly, 2018 under Section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 ('the said Act') to the Respondent No.3 and requested the Respondent No. 3 - Lonavala

    4

    Municipal Council to take appropriate steps for acquisition of the said land of the Petitioner.

    3.10. After serving the purchase notice on the Respondent No. 3 - Lonavala Municipal Council on 21stJuly, 2018 under Section 127 of the said Act, the Petitioner waited for the statutory period of two years i.e. till 20thJuly, 2020, during which no steps in regard to the acquisition of the said land were taken by the Respondent No.3 - Council.

    3.11. The Petitioner is therefore, compelled to fle the above Writ Petition seeking reliefs set out in paragraph 2 hereinabove.

    4. Smt. Suvarna Ogale - acting chief ofcer of Respondent No.3 - Lonavala Municipal Council, has fled an Afdavit dated 23rdMarch, 2021 on behalf of Respondent No.3 stating as under :

    4.1. It is true that the Petitioner had on 21stJuly, 2018 served a purchase notice on the Respondent No. 3 - Council under Section 127 of the MRTP Act.

    4.2. Since the Petitioner fled the above Writ Petition in December 2020, Respondent No. 3 wrote a letter dated 17thFebruary, 2021 to their Advocate and requested him to seek an extension of 6 months from the Court on the ground that the issue is pending before the General Body of the Lonavala Municipal Council and since a nationwide lockdown was declared from 24thMarch, 2020 no decision could be taken.

    4.3. In the present matter, the purchase notice under Section 127 of said Act

    5

    was issued on 21stJuly, 2018 and the statutory period of 2 years expired on 21stJuly, 2020 i.e. during the Pandemic.

    4.4. The State of Maharashtra has issued a G.R. dated 4 thJune, 2020 under Section 154 of the MRTP Act, 1966 by which extension of 9 months has been granted for completion of development work and other stipulated work. Though the acquisition matters are not included in the said G.R., the Court may give beneft of the said G.R. dated 4thJune, 2020 to the present Respondent No. 3 - Council.

    5. The learned Advocate for the Petitioner took us through the facts in the present Petition which are already set out in paragraph 3 hereinabove. He pointed out that the development plan under which the said land belonging to the Petitioner was reserved, was sanctioned on 28thFebruary, 1978. Since the said land was not acquired within 40 years from the date on which the development plan came into force, the Petitioner served a statutory notice dated 21stJuly, 2018 under Section 127(1) of the said Act, to the Respondent No.3 - Council. Respondent No.3 admittedly failed to acquire the said land within the statutory period of two years. In the circumstances, as provided under Section 127 of the Act, the reservation of the said land is deemed to have been lapsed and the said land stood released from the reservation and became available to the owner/Petitioner for the purpose of development. However, the Respondents failed to comply with the mandate provided in sub-Section 2 of Section 127 of the Act i.e. issuing a Notifcation in the ofcial gazette notifying the lapsing of the reservation of the said land, thereby compelling the Petitioner to fle the above

    6

    Writ Petition seeking the reliefs set out in paragraph 2 hereinabove. It is also submitted that admittedly the extension granted by the Government by G.R. dated 4 th June, 2020 pertains to the development work and other stipulated work required to be carried out by the Applicants and does not apply to matters pertaining to acquisition. Therefore, the question of this Court granting the beneft of the extension to the Respondent No. 3 - Council does not arise. It is submitted that even otherwise the said extension admittedly came to an end on 4thMarch, 2021.

    6. The learned Advocate appearing for the Respondent No. 1 - State has submitted to the Orders of this Court.

    7. The learned Advocate appearing for the Respondent No. 3 has reiterated what is stated in the afdavit fled on behalf of the Respondent No. 3 - Council the contents of which are already set out in paragraph 4 hereinabove.

    8. We have perused the Writ Petition as well as the afdavits fled by the parties. We have considered the facts of the present case, the submissions made by the learned Advocates for the parties and the case law relied upon by the Advocate for the Petitioner.

    9. Chapter VII of the MRTP Act deals with "Land Acquisition". Section 125 of the MRTP Act deals with "Compulsory acquisition of land needed for purpose of regional plan, development plan or town planning etc." Section 126 of the MRTP Act deals with "Acquisition of land required for public purposes specifed in plans."

    Section 127 of the MRTP Act pertains to "Lapsing of reservations". Section 127 of the

    7

    MRTP Act is relevant for deciding the issues raised in the present Writ Petition and is therefore reproduced hereunder :

    "127. Lapsing of reservations [(1) If any land reserved, allotted or designated for any purpose specifed in any plan under this Act is not acquired by agreement within ten years from the date on which a fnal Regional plan, or fnal Development Plan comes into force [or if a declaration under subsection (2) or (4) of section 126 is not published in the Ofcial Gazette within such period, the owner or any person interested in the land may serve notice, alongwith the documents showing his title or interest in the said land, on the Planning Authority, the Development Authority or, as the case may be, the Appropriate Authority to that efect ; and if within twelve months] from the date of the service of such notice, the land is not acquired or no steps as aforesaid are commenced for its acquisition, the reservation, allotment or designation shall be deemed to have lapsed, and thereupon, the land shall be deemed to be released from such reservation, allotment or designation and shall become available to the owner for the purpose of development as otherwise,

    8

    permissible in the case of adjacent land under the relevant plan.

    (2) On lapsing of reservation, allocation or designation of any land under sub-section (1), the Government shall notify the same, by an order published in the Ofcial Gazette.]"

    10. The Respondent No. 3 has not denied that the Respondent No.3 has not taken any steps for acquisition of the said land for a period of 40 years i.e. from 28 th February, 1978 when the development plan of the Lonavala Municipal Council was sanctioned and under which 390 Sq. Mtrs. of the Petitioner's Land was reserved for the purpose of Play Ground for Primary School and which reservation continued even under the revised development plan which came into force on 27thAugust, 2005. Though the Petitioner issued a purchase notice on 21stJuly, 2018, the Respondent No.3 failed to take any steps towards commencement of the acquisition. By the G.R. dated 4thJune, 2020 issued by the State of Maharashtra under Section 154 of the MRTP Act, an extension of 9 months is granted only in respect of the permissions granted for development / construction work without recovering from the Applicants any tax or interest with regard to the extended period, and does not apply to the period prescribed in the provisions pertaining to acquisition. Therefore, the question of this Court granting beneft of the G.R. dated 4thJune, 2020 to the Respondent No. 3 - Council, does not arise. In any event, even if it is assumed that the extension of 9

    9

    months granted under the said G.R. dated 4thJune, 2020 applied to matters pertaining to acquisition, the said extension has lapsed on 4thMarch, 2021 by which time the Respondent No. 3 - Council has not taken any steps to acquire the Petitioner's land ad-measuring 390 Sq. Mtrs.

    11. We are therefore, convinced that in the instant case, the Lonavala Municipal Council not only failed to acquire the land of the Petitioner reserved under the fnal development plan, which came into force from 28thFebruary, 1978 and the revised development plan which came into force on 27thAugust, 2005, but also failed to take steps towards commencement of the acquisition within two years from the date of receipt of the purchase notice, resulting in lapsing of the said reservation.

    12. For the above reasons we allow the Writ Petition in terms of prayer clauses (b) and (c) reproduced in paragraph 2 hereinabove. However, there shall be no Order as to costs.

    13. The Writ Petition is accordingly disposed of.

    (SURENDRA P. TAVADE, J. ) ( S.J. KATHAWALLA, J. )

    10

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jayantilal Himmatlal... v. State Of Maharashtra...
    (Apr 9, 2021)