State of Meghalaya Vs. All Dimasa Students Union, Dima-Hasao District Committee & Ors (2019)8 SCC 177 In the said case, a bunch of orders passed by NGT had been challenged in Supreme Court. However, in the said judgement passed by Supreme Court, there is no reference and no discussion in respect of any bar to release of vehicles on superdari. Order dt. 7.5.2019 passed by Honble Supreme Court in In the said case, an order dated 10.1.2019 passed by NGT in
I.A. No. 22/2019 in O.A. No. 670/2018 had been challenged. The order dated 10.1.2019 is a short order vide which the ( 25 ) CRM-M-23190-2020 CRM-M-36757-2020 C.A. 1590/2019 Atul Chauhan vs. State of respondents had been directed by NGT to furnish information with regard to taking steps for recovery of damages for the illegal mining and for regulating the release of vehicles carrying illegally mined material on the pattern dealt with by Tribunal vide order dated 04.01.2019. The appeal challenging the same was dismissed by Honble Supreme Court in limene without there being any reference to facts. State of Madhya Pradesh vs. Uday Singh, 2019 AIR (SC) 1597 In Uday Singhs case it was held that jurisdiction under section
451 of the CrPC, 1973 was not available to the Magistrate, once the Authorised Officer initiated confiscation proceedings under Indian Forest Act 1927. The said case dealt with amended provisions of Indian Forest Act 1927 (as amended by State of Madhya Pradesh). As per amended provisions of Section 52(1), the officer effecting the seizure, upon being satisfied that a forest offence has been committed, is empowered to confiscate the forest produce together with the tools, vehicles, boats and articles used in its commission. The order of confiscation under Section 52(3) is subject to an appeal and a revision. Section 52C (as amended by State of Madhya Pradesh) stipulates that no Court, Tribunal or authority, other than an Authorised Officer, an Appellate Authority or Court of Sessions (in revision) shall have jurisdiction to pass orders with regard to possession, delivery, disposal or distribution of the property. State of West Bengal
v. Sujit Kumar Rana, (2004) 4 SCC 129 This Court in Sujit Kumar Ranas case held that once confiscation proceedings are initiated, the jurisdiction of the criminal court stands excluded. However, the provisions of the Act i.e. The Indian Forest Act 1927 were entirely different. Section 59A(3) of the Indian Forest Act (as amended by State of West Bengal) provides that if the authorised officer is satisfied that a forest offence has been committed, then irrespective of the fact whether a prosecution has been instituted or not, he may direct confiscation of the property used in committing the offence. Still further Section 59G(as amended by State of West Bengal) of the Act creates a bar on the jurisdiction of Court to make ( 26 ) CRM-M-23190-2020 CRM-M-36757-2020 orders with regard to the custody, possession, delivery, disposal or distribution of any property including vehicles seized under section 52 of the Act.
36. The aforesaid judgements reveal that while the former two judgements neither dealt with nor laid any law with respect to release of vehicles on superdari, the latter two judgements do deal with said aspect and have held that jurisdiction of Courts is barred but the said judgements were delivered while interpreting a different set of Rules where the Rules specifically ousted the jurisdiction of Courts. The said judgements can not be made applicable in instant case under Mining Rules 2012 where there is no such specific provision for ouster of jurisdiction.
37. Honble Supreme Court, while interpreting another set of Rules in (2008)
14 SCC 624: State of Madhya Pradesh & ors v. Madhukar Rao has taken a different view. In the said case the Honble Supreme Court considered the question as to whether a vehicle or vessel etc. seized under section 50(1)(c) of the Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972 can be released by Magistrate during the pendency of trial in exercise of powers under section
451 CrPC, 1973. After considering the provisions of Section 50(1)(c) of the Act and section 451 CrPC, it was concluded that there could be no bar on the power of the Court for exercise of powers under section 451 CrPC for interim release of the seized vehicles by the Judicial Magistrate.
38. From perusal of judgements rendered by Honble Supreme Court in Uday Singhs case(supra) and Sujit Kumar Ranas case(supra) and also Madhukar Raos case(supra), it is borne out that it is the specific provision of the Rules which holds the key to the question of there being any bar or ( 27 ) CRM-M-23190-2020 CRM-M-36757-2020 not to release of vehicle on superdari. The Mining Rules 2012, however, do not contain any such provision from which it could be inferred that jurisdiction of Courts is ousted or that there is any specific bar against release of a vehicle on superdari.
39. In Nongstoin PS & others Vs. State of Meghalaya 2019 CrLJ 4466, wherein release of truck, seized on account of carrying coal illegally, was being opposed on the strength of order passed by the NGT mandating release of seized vehicles only upon recovering damages to the extent of 50% of the showroom price of the vehicle, the Meghalya High Court, while relying upon Madhukar Raos case (supra) held that the order of NGT would not take away the power and jurisdiction of the Magistrate/Criminal Court to adjudicate on the issue of release of seized vehicles under section 451 CrPC.
40. The legal position regarding application of section 451 Cr.P.C., being well settled, the question regarding release of a vehicle seized under provisions of MMDR or under the rules framed therein i.e. Mining Rules 2012, on superdari, or as regards there being any bar to such release also needs to be examined in context of the stage at which release of vehicle on superdari is sought. The following stages after seizure could be visualized:
(i) Immediately after seizure of vehicle but before any intimation regarding such seizure is sent to Court or before lodging of FIR/complaint by authorities concerned;
(ii) During the course of confiscation proceedings, whether or not any FIR is lodged. ( 28 ) CRM-M-23190-2020 CRM-M-36757-2020
(iii) After any intimation regarding seizure of vehicle is sent to Court or after lodging of FIR where investigation or trial is pending;
41. As far as stage (i) is concerned i.e. before any FIR is lodged or any intimation regarding seizure is sent to Court, the Court cannot be said to be seized of any matter pertaining to seizure of vehicle and as such resort cannot be had to provisions of section 451 Cr PC or 457 Cr PC. While an application for release of property in terms of section 451 could only be maintainable during the pendency of a trial, an application in terms of section 457 Cr.PC would be maintainable only if such seizure is reported to the Court by the authorities concerned. As regards stage (ii) and stage (iii), recourse to provisions of section 451 Cr PC and 457 Cr PC could be had provided there is nothing inconsistent to the said provisions in the Rules in question. The Mining Rules 2012, however, do not contain any such provision from which it could be inferred that jurisdiction of Courts is ousted or that there is any specific bar against release of a vehicle on superdari.
42. The powers conferred by section 451 and 457 of Cr PC cannot be ousted once the Court gets seized of the matter in respect of which superdari is sought. No doubt MMDR is a special Act and the provision of Special Act override any general provisions contained in Cr.P.C. but in MMDR Act there is no such provision ousting the jurisdiction of Courts to invoke provisions of section 451 or 457 of Cr PC at appropriate stage unlike some other special Acts where it has specifically been ousted. Following are some of the instances, wherein jurisdiction is specifically ousted: ( 29 ) CRM-M-23190-2020 CRM-M-36757-2020
(i) Indian Forest Act 1927 : Section 52C (as amended by State of Madhya Pradesh) stipulates that no Court, Tribunal or authority, other than an Authorised Officer, an Appellate Authority or Court of Sessions (in revision) shall have jurisdiction to pass orders with regard to possession, delivery, disposal or distribution of the property. Section 59G(as amended by State of West Bengal) of the Act creates a bar on the jurisdiction of Court to make orders with regard to the custody, possession, delivery, disposal or distribution of any property including vehicles seized under section 52 of the Act. Similar amendments have been made by other States as well.
(ii) Delhi Excise Act 2009: Section 61 of the Act puts an embargo on jurisdiction of Courts, and provides that no Court shall, notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in any other law for the time being in force, shall have jurisdiction to make any order with regard to any intoxicant, material, still, utensil, implement, apparatus or any receptacle, package, vessel, animal, cart, or other conveyance used in committing any offence, which is seized or detained under the Act.
43. The MMDR Act, unlike some other enactments, however, does not impose any absolute bar on moving an application on superdari. In these circumstances, the bar as referred to in order dated 26.7.2019 as modified in order dated 19.2.2020(Annexure R-1) thus, can only be relatable to a situation when the Court is not seized of the matter in any manner. In other words when there is neither any FIR/complaint nor any application filed by behalf of the respondent authorities for confiscation, the Illaqa Magistrate would not be competent to entertain any application for superdari but would be competent when any FIR/complaint is lodged or any application for confiscation is filed on behalf of the respondent authorities. Question no. (iii) is answered accordingly. ( 30 ) CRM-M-23190-2020 CRM-M-36757-2020
44. As an upshot of discussion made above, this Court is of the opinion that even if the Illaqa Magistrate may not be able to take cognizance of any offence under MMDR Act after expiry of 3 months in terms of Rule 106 and 115 of Mining Rules 2012, but the confiscation proceedings are independent proceedings and there is no such limitation provided for initiating the same and the only rider therein as per Rule 101(10) is that such proceedings can be initiated after expiry of one month of the imposition of penalty in case such penalty is not paid. Sitting over the matter for an unreasonable would be prejudicial to the owner inasmuch as not only the owner would be deprived of an opportunity to put forth his case against confiscation but he would remain deprived of use of his vehicle which rather would deteriorate on account of its disuse and vagaries of weather. The authorities, on their own certainly cannot confiscate the vehicle and as per Section 21(4A), it is only under the orders of the Court that the same can be confiscated and further disposed of. The respondent authorities should therefore take necessary steps for moving the Court concerned so as to seek permission to confiscate the vehicle in question after giving due opportunity to its owner/accused who may be able to successfully show that the same is not liable to be confiscated.
45. The following directions are thus issued to the respondents:
(i) The respondents are directed that in future all such cases where a vehicle is seized in terms of MMDR Act or Rules framed thereunder and the penalty imposed is not paid within a reasonable time, either the requisite steps, as per rules, shall be taken for prosecuting the accused or an appropriate application shall be filed for confiscation of the vehicle in terms of Rule 101(10). A period of 3 months can well be said to be a fairly reasonable time so as to enable the authorities concerned to take requisite steps in this direction. Once a ( 31 ) CRM-M-23190-2020 CRM-M-36757-2020 vehicle is ordered to be confiscated, further steps for auctioning the same may be taken immediately instead of retaining the vehicle in the police station where its condition is bound to deteriorate which would be a loss to the State as well as it will not be able to recover much amount from auction of the vehicle on account of deteriorated condition of the vehicle.
(ii) All those vehicles, including the vehicles of the petitioners in both the cases, which are presently lying seized by respondent authorities for more than three months, pursuant to inspection carried out in terms of Rule 101 of Mining Rules 2012, and in respect of which the authorities have neither lodged any FIR nor instituted any complaint in the Court and have not even initiated confiscation proceedings shall be dealt with under provisions of Rule 101(10) immediately. The Director, Department of Mines and Geology, Haryana shall ensure that the needful in this regard is done within two weeks from today.
(iii) Upon the respondent authorities either choosing to lodge a FIR/complaint or choosing to move an application under rule 101 (10) of Mining Rules 2012 for confiscation of vehicle, it shall be open to the Court concerned to entertain an application for release of the vehicle on superdari during the pendency of such proceedings if there is likelihood of delay in conclusion of such proceedings. The Court dealing with such application shall decide the same independently while considering all such pleas as may be raised by the parties. The Court concerned shall, however, endeavour to dispose of such applications at the earliest.
(iv) While considering release of vehicle on superdari, the Court may choose to impose any such strict conditions as deemed fit. The Court concerned may even direct the applicant to deposit in Court an amount equal to the penalty imposed by the authorities concerned or part thereof, in addition to any other condition.
46. Further, since some minor errors have been noticed in the Mining Rules 2012, which are there not only in the Rules published by private publishers ( 32 ) CRM-M-23190-2020 CRM-M-36757-2020 but are also present in copy of the notification which was furnished by the learned State counsel, the respondent authorities to consider the feasibility of having a relook at the Rules for carrying out necessary amendments, if deemed appropriate particularly in respect of the following issues which have been noticed :
(i) In Rule 101(5), in the existing rule the authorised officers/officials in charge of a check post are required to take action as provided under rule 104 in respect of any violation pertaining to transit pass or transport permit whereas the consequences for such violations such violations are in fact prescribed in rule 102 and not in 104;
(ii) Similarly in Rule 101(8) it is stated that a person found transporting any mineral in contravention of the provision of the rules would be liable for punishment under rule 105 whereas rule 105 does not prescribe any punishment and pertains to liability of all those persons who are In-charge and responsible to the company when an offence is stated to have been committed by company. Thus it needs to be clarified as to whether in terms of Rule 101(8), a person is to be penalized for illegal transportation or illegal mining and under which specific rule;
(iii) While Rule 101(7) refers to certain action to be taken under the rules, when it is found to be a case of under-weighment of the mineral being transported, however there is no specific rule dealing with the penalty to be imposed in case of under-weighment of mineral. It needs to be specified as to whether in a case where the mineral being transported is found to be excess of the quantity which is mentioned in transit pass, the same has to be taken to be a case of illegal transportation or as to whether a lesser penalty is to be provided;
(iv) There is an element of overlapping/duplicity as regards the provisions pertaining to cognizance inasmuch as there are two rules
i.e. Rule 106 and Rule 115, dealing with the same issue. Said rules read as follows: ( 33 ) CRM-M-23190-2020 CRM-M-36757-2020 RULE 106 RULE 115
106. Offences cognizable only on written complaint. No Court shall take cognizance of any offence punishable under these rules except upon a complaint in writing made by the Director or any other officer authorised by him to the police in this behalf within three months of the date on which said offence is alleged to have been committed.
115. Offences cognizable only on written complaint. No Court shall take cognizance of any offence punishable under these rules except upon a complaint in writing made by the Director or any other officer authorised by him in this behalf within three months of the date on which said offence is alleged to have been committed. The aforesaid two rules are identical but for the words to the police which exist in Rule 106 but are missing in Rule 115 though both are in respect of offences punishable under these rules. The said duplicity needs to be resolved.
(v) Since it has been informed that the department has taken initiatives for introducing e-governance processes which have led to a much more effective implementation of the Act particularly with the introduction of e-Ravaana transit passes/bills, the authorities shall continue with their endeavours of increasing e-governance in every sphere which may even be incorporated specifically and made a part of the rules.
47. Both the petitions stands disposed of accordingly with the aforesaid directions. However before parting with the judgement, this Court places on record its appreciation for the invaluable assistance rendered by both the learned counsel and also by Shri Parvesh Sharma, State Mining Engineer and Shri R.S. Thakran, Mining Engineer, Department of Mines and Geology, Haryana. ( GURVINDER SINGH GILL ) 04.02.2021 JUDGE (kamal) Whether reasoned / speaking? Yes / No Whether reportable? Yes / No