Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2021 INSC 31
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 25(1-B)(a) of the Arms Act
  • Section 3(1)(xii) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989
  • Section 376, 376(2)(a) of the Penal Code, 1860
  • Article 32 of the Constitution
  • Section 228-A IPC which has been inserted in the Penal Code by Amendment Act 43 of 1983
  • Section 357-A of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2021 INSC 31
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 25(1-B)(a) of the Arms Act
  • Section 3(1)(xii) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989
  • Section 376, 376(2)(a) of the Penal Code, 1860
  • Article 32 of the Constitution
  • Section 228-A IPC which has been inserted in the Penal Code by Amendment Act 43 of 1983
  • Section 357-A of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a Scheduled Tribe woman born on 24-12-1984, was abducted in 1998 and later married to the abductor, Basant Yadav, with whom she had a son. After obtaining a divorce and losing custody of the child, she alleges that on 08-06-2002 she was gang-raped (Case No. 162 of 2002), resulting in the conviction of one accused, Mohd. Ali, for 10 years’ rigorous imprisonment. The petitioner subsequently filed multiple FIRs—including against high-ranking police officers—under Section 376 IPC and provisions of the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act. Some cases ended in acquittal; others remain pending. She also faces one criminal case under the Arms Act.

Claiming social ostracism after her identity was revealed by the media, and asserting homelessness, lack of income, and educational deprivation for her three children, she filed the present writ petition under Article 32 of the Constitution. On 29-11-2019 the Supreme Court issued notice, called for status reports, and directed interim police protection. Affidavits and additional documents were later exchanged between the petitioner and the State of Jharkhand.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State is constitutionally obliged to rehabilitate and protect a rape victim by providing security, housing, and free education for her minor children.
  2. Whether the disclosure of the petitioner’s identity by the media violates Section 228-A IPC and the guidelines in Nipun Saxena v. Union of India.
  3. What further relief, if any, is warranted when statutory victim-compensation under the Jharkhand Victim Compensation Scheme, 2012 (as amended in 2016) has already been granted.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • Social stigma arising from her status as a rape victim has left her without family or community support, employment, or housing.
  • Her identity was unlawfully publicised, aggravating discrimination and making it impossible to secure rental accommodation.
  • She lacks resources to educate her three children and seeks State intervention for their schooling and her own rehabilitation.

State of Jharkhand’s Arguments

  • The petitioner has lodged numerous rape allegations, some of which resulted in acquittals; she also faces a pending Arms Act case.
  • Security measures are already in place: since 02-10-2019 one armed lady constable, and an additional guard after 06-01-2020. The police seek permission to review security periodically.
  • The petitioner has vacated several rented accommodations following disputes with landlords; her difficulties are thus partly self-created.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Nipun Saxena v. Union of India, (2019) 2 SCC 703 Victim’s identity must not be disclosed; rape victims face social ostracism; media restrictions under Section 228-A IPC. Quoted to emphasise societal discrimination and to reinforce the statutory bar on publishing the petitioner’s identity.
Padma v. State of Jharkhand, 2015 SCC OnLine Jhar 5499 State’s willingness (recorded in High Court) to provide free education to the petitioner’s children. Relied upon to direct the Deputy Commissioner, Ranchi to ensure free education in government institutions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Recognising the undisputed fact that the petitioner is a rape victim—evidenced by the 2014 conviction of Mohd. Ali—the Court observed that rape survivors suffer both psychological trauma and social exclusion. Drawing on Nipun Saxena, it reiterated that the media is statutorily barred under Section 228-A IPC from revealing a rape victim’s identity.

The Court noted that the petitioner had already received Rs 1,00,000 compensation under the Jharkhand Victim Compensation Scheme, 2012. However, additional support was required. Regarding education, the Court referred to the State’s earlier commitment in the Padma case and accepted the State’s submission that free schooling up to 14 years is available. It therefore tasked the Deputy Commissioner, Ranchi with ensuring admission of the two minor children to government schools.

On housing, the Court acknowledged existing Central and State schemes (e.g., Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana) and directed the Deputy Commissioner to consider the petitioner for allotment. For personal security, the Court credited the State’s current deployment but ordered periodic review by the Senior Superintendent of Police to adjust protection as necessary.

Finally, recognising ongoing legal complexities, it authorised the District Legal Services Authority, Ranchi to extend further legal assistance upon representation by the petitioner.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF – The writ petition was allowed in part and closed with specific mandatory directions:

  • The Deputy Commissioner, Ranchi must secure free education for the petitioner’s minor children until they reach 14 years of age.
  • The Deputy Commissioner must examine the petitioner’s eligibility for government housing under Central or State schemes.
  • The Senior Superintendent of Police, Ranchi shall periodically review and adjust police protection for the petitioner.
  • The District Legal Services Authority, Ranchi shall provide further legal aid if requested.

Implications are confined to the parties: the petitioner gains enforceable directives for education, housing consideration, continued security, and legal aid. The judgment reiterates but does not expand existing precedent on victim confidentiality; no new legal doctrine was created.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    X v. State Of Jharkhand And Others

    Ashok Bhushan, J.— This writ petition has been filed by a rape victim invoking the jurisdiction of this Court under Article 32 of the Constitution.

    2. This Court entertained the writ petition and while issuing notice on 29-11-2020 2019 SCC OnLine SC 1944 passed the following order: (State of Jharkhand case 2019 SCC OnLine SC 1944, SCC OnLine SC paras 1-5)

    “1. Issue notice.
    2. Mr Tapesh Kumar Singh, learned Standing Counsel for the State of Jharkhand, accepts notice on behalf of the respondent State.
    3. Let the respondent State file an affidavit giving details of all proceedings initiated by the petitioner or against her and the status of those proceedings.
    4. We, however, observe that Respondent 3 Home Secretary shall also ensure that the police authorities concerned are instructed to ensure protection of the petitioner.
    5. List after four weeks.”

    3. A counter-affidavit has been filed on behalf of the State of Jharkhand to which rejoinder has also been filed by the petitioner. The petitioner has also filed certain additional documents.

    4. From the pleadings of the parties the following facts emerged: the petitioner claims to be a Scheduled Tribe in the State of Jharkhand. The petitioner was born on 24-12-1984. On 31-3-1998, the petitioner was taken away by one Basant Yadav. The petitioner's father, Rajender Badaik, lodged a complaint. Basant Yadav was apprehended on 2-4-1998. The father of the petitioner and police of the police station concerned got the marriage of the petitioner solemnised with Basant Yadav. After one year of the marriage, one son was born, named Manish Yadav. The petitioner filed a complaint as well as case for maintenance against her husband, Basant Yadav.

    5. The petitioner obtained divorce from Basant Yadav and the custody of son was given to Basant Yadav. On 8-6-2002, the petitioner went to Dultonganj on asking of Basant Yadav to meet her son on which date she was raped by one Mohd. Ali and three other accused. Case No. 162 of 2002 under Sections 376/34 read with Section 3(1)(xi) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 was registered in which accused, Mohd. Ali was apprehended and put on trial.

    6. The petitioner lodged an FIR against the Dy. Inspector General of Police on 2-8-2005 under Sections 376, 376(2)(a) of the Penal Code, 1860 and Section 3(1)(xii) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 on which on 3-8-2005 Case No. 304 of 2005 was registered. The petitioner also lodged an FIR against an Inspector General of Police on which Sessions Trial No. 257 of 2006 was registered. Certain other criminal cases were got registered by the petitioner against different persons, some of which were filed under Section 376 IPC. In Sessions Trial No. 11 of 2006, the accused Mohd. Ali was convicted on 15-2-2014 with 10 years' RI.

    7. In the FIR lodged against Dy. Inspector General of Police final report was submitted which was accepted by the court on 6-8-2007. Insofar as FIR lodged against Inspector General of Police, the Sessions Judge acquitted the Inspector General of Police by judgment and order dated 23-12-2017 against which criminal appeal has been filed in the High Court of Jharkhand. A criminal case was also lodged against the petitioner.

    8. The petitioner's case in the writ petition is that she being the rape victim, whose identity was disclosed by the media and after knowing that the petitioner is a rape victim, no one is ready to give her accommodation even on rent. The petitioner in the writ petition invoked jurisdiction of this Court in the matter of rehabilitation of the petitioner. The petitioner also prays for direction to the respondent to protect the petitioner and her children's life. The petitioner after divorce from her first husband got married to one Rajesh Kujur with whom a son was also born. The petitioner has also lodged criminal case being No. 56 of 2004 against her husband Rajesh Kujur which resulted in acquittal.

    9. The petitioner has also filed a copy of the legal notice dated 9-8-2019 which was sent by the landlord of the petitioner asking the petitioner to vacate the premises on the ground of non-payment of rent. The petitioner sent a letter dated 5-12-2019 stating that the landlord had sealed the house on 4-12-2019.

    10. In the counter-affidavit by the State, the State has given a tabular chart containing status of 7 criminal cases which were initiated by the petitioner. In para 7 one of the cases mentioned in the chart is the case filed against Mohd. Ali. Mohd. Ali was convicted on 15-2-2014 under Section 376(2)(g) IPC and Section 3(1)(xii) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989. In other criminal cases either the accused were acquitted or trial is pending in some cases. In two FIRs lodged by the petitioner, in the year 2018 under Section 354-A(ii) as well as under Sections 376, 448 and 506 IPC, respectively the investigation is said to be going on.

    11. The petitioner has appeared in person. Shri Tapesh Kumar Singh, learned counsel has appeared for the State of Jharkhand.

    12. The petitioner submits that due to the petitioner being rape victim she is not getting any help from family, friends or society. She, with three children, has no means of survival and she is not able to give education to her children. The administration, media and society has compelled the petitioner to lead a life with no security, no job and no shelter in future.

    13. Shri Tapesh Kumar, learned counsel appearing for the State submits that the petitioner has lodged various FIRs alleging rape against several persons. It is submitted that against the petitioner also an FIR was lodged at Palamau Sadar Police Case No. 194 of 2002 for the commission of the offences under Section 25(1-B)(a) of the Arms Act, on the basis of a written report submitted by the Assistant Sub-Inspector of Police in which charge-sheet has also been filed. It is submitted that since 2-10-2019 an armed Lady Constable, namely, Suman Surin has been deputed with the writ petitioner for her security.

    14. It is further submitted that the State has taken care of making security arrangement of the petitioner and in pursuance of the order dated 6-1-2020 another security personnel has been deputed with the writ petitioner. The learned counsel, however, submits that the police authority may be permitted to review the security from time to time to take appropriate measures in that regard. Shri Singh further submits that the petitioner is in the habit of making false allegations against several persons and officers. A complaint has recently been submitted making allegations of offences under Section 376 IPC. It is submitted that the petitioner has vacated the earlier accommodation of Subodh Thakur.

    15. We have heard the petitioner in person as well as the learned counsel appearing for the State.

    16. There can be no denial that the petitioner is a rape victim. Even if we do not take into consideration other criminal cases filed by the petitioner under Section 376 IPC, in Case No. 162 of 2002 where allegation of rape was made on 8-6-2002 the accused, Mohd. Ali has been convicted under Section 376(2)(g) IPC for 10 years' RI. The petitioner being a rape victim deserves treatment as rape victim by all the authorities.

    17. A rape victim suffers not only mental trauma but also discrimination from the society. We may refer to the judgment of this Court in Nipun Saxena v. Union of India (2019) 2 SCC 703, wherein the following observations were made by this Court:

    “12. A victim of rape will face hostile discrimination and social ostracisation in society. Such victim will find it difficult to get a job, will find it difficult to get married and will also find it difficult to get integrated in society like a normal human being.”

    18. The petitioner herself has brought on record few orders passed in Writ Petition (Cri.) No. 229 of 2014 (Padma v. State of Jharkhand) filed by the petitioner before the High Court of Jharkhand where in the order dated 12-9-2015 2015 SCC OnLine Jhar 5499/11-9-2015 statement on behalf of the counsel for the State was recorded by the High Court that the State is ready to provide free education to the children of the writ petitioner. Following is the statement recorded by the High Court on 12-9-2015 2015 SCC OnLine Jhar 5499/11-9-2015: (Padma case 2015 SCC OnLine Jhar 5499, SCC OnLine Jhar para 1)

    “1. Counsel for the State has submitted that the State is ready to provide free education to the children of the writ petitioner. If she will give her consent, her children shall be admitted in the Government Boarding School at Gumla and the expenses shall be borne by the Government.”

    19. The petitioner has two sons and one daughter. Manish Yadav appears to have been born after one year of the marriage which took place in the year 1998, eldest son, thus, as on date is major, two children of the petitioner are still minor.

    20. On an inquiry by the Court as to which authority is to ensure that the minor children of the petitioner are provided free education, the learned counsel submitted that it is Deputy Commissioner, Ranchi who can take appropriate measures to ensure that the minor children of the petitioner are provided free education. The learned counsel for the State has submitted that education up to the age of 14 years in the State of Jharkhand is free which is provided by the State. We, thus, are of the view that the Deputy Commissioner shall take appropriate steps to ensure that minor children of the petitioner are provided free education in any government institution at Ranchi.

    21. The petitioner has also raised grievance regarding her identity which has been disclosed by the media. The petitioner has annexed certain materials along with writ petition and the additional documents. Section 228-A IPC which has been inserted in the Penal Code by Amendment Act 43 of 1983 with effect from 25-12-1983 makes disclosure of the identity of the victim as an offence. Section 228-A is as follows:

    “228-A. Disclosure of identity of the victim of certain offences, etc.—(1) Whoever prints or publishes the name or any matter which may make known the identity of any person against whom an offence under Section 376, Section 376-A, Section 376-B, Section 376-C or Section 376-D is alleged or found to have been committed (hereafter in this section referred to as the victim) shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years and shall also be liable to fine.
    (2) Nothing in sub-section (1) extends to any printing or publication of the name or any matter which may make known the identity of the victim if such printing or publication is—
    (a) by or under the order in writing of the officer-in-charge of the police station or the police officer making the investigation into such offence acting in good faith for the purposes of such investigation; or
    (b) by, or with the authorisation in writing of, the victim; or
    (c) where the victim is dead or minor or of unsound mind, by, or with the authorisation in writing of, the next of kin of the victim:
    Provided that no such authorisation shall be given by the next of kin to anybody other than the chairman or the secretary, by whatever name called, of any recognised welfare institution or organisation.
    Explanation.—For the purposes of this sub-section, “recognised welfare institution or organisation” means a social welfare institution or organisation recognised in this behalf by the Central or State Government.
    (3) Whoever prints or publishes any matter in relation to any proceeding before a court with respect to an offence referred to in sub-section (1) without the previous permission of such Court shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years and shall also be liable to fine.
    Explanation.—The printing or publication of the judgment of any High Court or the Supreme Court does not amount to an offence within the meaning of this section.”

    22. This Court in Nipun Saxena (2019) 2 SCC 703 has occasion to consider Section 228-A wherein this Court in para 50.1 has issued the following directions:

    “50.1. No person can print or publish in print, electronic, social media, etc. the name of the victim or even in a remote manner disclose any facts which can lead to the victim being identified and which should make her identity known to the public at large.”

    23. The law with regard to Section 228-A is well established, all including the media, both print and electronic have to follow the law.

    24. With regard to the payment of compensation to the petitioner as a rape victim, along with additional documents the petitioner has brought on record materials to indicate that the decision was taken by the District Legal Services Authority, Ranchi to pay compensation of Rs 1,00,000 by letter dated 6-3-2017. The letter of the Secretary, District Legal Services Authority, Ranchi has been brought on record by the petitioner herself. The grant of compensation has been considered under the Jharkhand Victim Compensation Scheme, 2012 as amended in 2016.

    25. There is a statutory scheme already enforced in the State of Jharkhand framed under Section 357-A of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, which provides procedure for grant of compensation. The petitioner had already made application to seek compensation under the above Scheme and payment of compensation has already been made.

    26. The next grievance which has been highlighted by the petitioner is the petitioner's inability to get any rented accommodation in Ranchi due to she being a rape victim. In the counter-affidavit filed by the State, it is clear that the petitioner has lived at several/different places but due to the dispute with the landlord she has to leave the premises. There are various Central as well as State schemes for providing residential accommodation to persons living below poverty line and other deserving cases, the Deputy Commissioner, Ranchi may consider the case of the petitioner for allotment of any housing accommodation under Prime Minister Awas Yojna or any other scheme of the Centre or the State.

    27. In view of the foregoing discussion, we dispose of this writ petition with the following directions:

    27.1. The Deputy Commissioner, Ranchi is directed to take measure to ensure that minor children of the petitioner are provided free education in any of the government institutions in District Ranchi where the petitioner is residing till they attain the age of 14 years.

    27.2. The Deputy Commissioner, Ranchi may also consider the case of the petitioner for providing house under Prime Minister Awas Yojna or any other Central or State scheme in which the petitioner could be provided accommodation.

    27.3. The Senior Superintendent of Police, Ranchi and other competent authority shall review the police security provided to the petitioner from time to time and take such measures as deemed fit and proper.

    27.4. The District Legal Services Authority, Ranchi on representation made by the petitioner shall render legal services to the petitioner as may be deemed fit to safeguard the interest of the petitioner.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    X v. State Of Jharkhand And Others
    (Jan 20, 2021)