DATE OF HEARING: 11.01.2021 DATE OF DECISION: 11.01.2021 Order Per: Honble Mr. P. Anjani Kumar Brief facts of the case are that the appellant, M/s. Prasad Corporation Ltd., is engaged in data processing services such as Computer Graphics, Digital Restoration and Reverse Telecine and they provide service to domestic as well as foreign customers. While the appellants paid Service Tax on the service rendered to domestic customers, they did not pay Service Tax on the M/s. Prasad Corporation Ltd., No. 28, Arunachalam Road, Saligramam, Chennai 600 093 : Appellant VERSUS The Commissioner of Service Tax, Chennai-II Commissionerate, Newry Towers, 3rd Floor, Plot No. 2054, I Block, II Avenue, Anna Nagar, Chennai 600 040 : Respondent Appeal. No.: ST/40844/2016-DB service rendered to foreign customers under the belief that it amounted to export of services. The Revenue considered the above service rendered by the appellant as Video Tape Production Service and issued periodical Show Cause Notices and confirmed the same. In the instant case, the demand of Rs. 45,77,295/ has been confirmed, for the period from 01.04.2010 to 31.03.2011, vide impugned Order No. 451/2015 (STA-II) dated 31.12.2015 passed by the Commissioner of Service Tax (Appeals-II), Chennai.
2. Learned Counsel for the appellant submits that the issue is no longer res integra being decided in appellants favour in their own case by this very Bench in 2018 (11) G.S.T.L. 104 (Tri. Chennai) and vide Final Order Nos. 43119 to 43121 of 2018 dated 17.12.2018. Tribunal held that the services rendered by the appellants to foreign clients would not fall under the ambit of Video Tape Production Service. He further submits that while appeal against CESTAT Final Order No. 42464 of 2017 dated 30.10.2017 is pending before the Honble High Court of Madras, other appeal against Final Order Nos. 43119 to 43121 of 2018 dated 17.12.2018 was dismissed on monetary limits and no stay however has been granted. 2.1 Learned Counsel for the appellant submits that the activities rendered by the appellant do not fall within the definition of Video Tape Production Service at all; though the appellants have rendered services, in relation to recorded media, such as cutting, imparting special effects, processing, etc., they have not rendered any service for any programme, event or function and they are also not involved in any post-production activity. Learned counsel further brings out the definitions of programme, event and function as follows:
i. Programme: The Concise English Oxford Dictionary, Tenth Edition defines the term programme as a planned series of Appeal. No.: ST/40844/2016-DB events a sheet or booklet detailing items or performers at an event Volume II of 23rd Edition of Taxmanns How to meet your Service Tax Obligations as released in August 2007 also refers to dictionary meanings of the term Programme. The relevant portion is extracted hereunder: The dictionary meaning of programme is a paper, booklet or like giving the outline of proceedings arranged for an entertainment, conference, course of study, etc. With relative details, the items of such proceedings, collectively, a plan of things to be done, T.V. or radio presentation produced for broadcast single or as one office series. In the present context the meaning arranged for an entertainment, conference, course of study, etc., appears to be more appropriate.
ii. Event: The Concise English Oxford Dictionary, Tenth Edition defines the term event as a thing that happens or takes place, a public or social event Volume II of 23rd Edition of Taxmanns How to meet your Service Tax Obligations as released in August 2007 also refers to dictionary meanings of the term event. It specifies: the word event means anything which happens, result, any incident or occurrence esp. a memorable one, contingency or possibility of occurrence, an item in a programme (of sports, etc.) An organised activity at a particular venue e.g. sales promotion, fund raising, etc.
iii. Function: The Concise English Oxford Dictionary, Tenth Edition defines the term function as a large or formal social event or ceremony Volume II of 23rd Edition of Taxmanns How to meet your Service Tax Obligations as released in August 2007 also refers to dictionary meanings of the term function. It specifies: the word function means an impressive, elaborate or formal ceremony or social gathering. The meaning formal ceremony or social gathering appears more appropriate in the present context. (Emphasis in original)
3. Per contra, Learned Authorized Representative for the Department reiterates the findings in the Order-in- Original and Order-in-Appeal and submits that though the appellant was not involved in the actual process of Appeal. No.: ST/40844/2016-DB recording any programme in magnetic tapes, the appellant undertakes services of restoration, giving special effects to inputs received via internet and tapes of old films; the definition of Video Tape Production Service includes services such as cutting, colouring, imparting special effects, adding or undertaking any post- production activity and therefore, Rule 3(ii) of the Export of Service Rules would be applicable and therefore, the service is covered by Section 65(105)(zi) of the Finance Act, 1994.
4. Heard both sides and perused the records of the case. We find that the issue before us has been dealt by this Bench in their own case vide orders cited supra. In 2018 (11) G.S.T.L. 104 (Tri. Chennai), it was held as under:
4. Heard both sides and have gone through the facts. It is clear that the services performed by the appellant definitely do not involve his recording of any programme, event or function. In fact, this aspect has been considered even by the adjudicating authority in para 5.3 of the order. The activities of services of Computer Graphics, Digital Restoration, and Reverse Telecine all involving activities on old feature films is definitely a post-production film activity inter alia, rendered for service recipients abroad as per their requirements. This being so, we are not able to fathom how the adjudicating authority, having stated that the appellants are not engaged in the recording of any programme etc. has concluded that services or restoration, giving special effects etc. on the old films would be a Video Tape Production. Ostensibly, the department and the adjudicating authority have been influenced by the second limb of the definition of Video Tape Production in Section 65(120) of the Act. The definitions have to be read in totality and part thereof cannot be picked up to justify that the activities performed in the instant case will come under Video Tape Production Services. That would like putting the cart before the horse. The statutory provisions relating Appeal. No.: ST/40844/2016-DB to taxation have to be construed literally without engraving any additional meaning thereto except in very rare cases where, the maxim of casus omissus would apply. This is certainly not one of those situations. The definition of Video Tape Production Service is very clear and does not offer any ambiguity.
5. Viewed in this light, the services provided by the appellants will certainly not fall under the ambit of Video Tape Production Services. The impugned order cannot then sustain and will have to be set aside, which we hereby do. Appeal is allowed with consequential benefits, if any, as per law.
5. We find that the ratio of the above judgement was followed in Final Order Nos. 43119 to 43121 of 2018 dated 17.12.2018. We find that no stay has been granted by the Honble High Court on the appeal filed by department. In view of the above, we find that nothing survives in the matter as we do not find any reason not to follow the ratio of these cases.
6. In view of the above, the appeal is allowed along with consequential benefit, if any, as per law. (Operative part of the order was pronounced in open court) Sd/- (SULEKHA BEEVI C.S.) MEMBER (JUDICIAL) Sd/- (P. ANJANI KUMAR) MEMBER (TECHNICAL)