AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Section 14 of the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (hereinafter referred to as the SARFAESI Act)
  • sec. 13 of SARFAESI Act and rules 8 and 9 of security enforcement rules 2002,
  • Section 13 of the SARFAESI Act and Rules 8 and 9 of the Security Enforcement Rules 2002
  • Section 14(1) of the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (the SARFAESI Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Section 14 of the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (hereinafter referred to as the SARFAESI Act)
  • sec. 13 of SARFAESI Act and rules 8 and 9 of security enforcement rules 2002,
  • Section 13 of the SARFAESI Act and Rules 8 and 9 of the Security Enforcement Rules 2002
  • Section 14(1) of the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (the SARFAESI Act
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Court's Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitions arise from actions taken by the 1st respondent, State Bank of India (“the respondent-bank”), pursuant to recovery proceedings under the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (SARFAESI Act). The guarantor for the loan (the petitioner's mother, 2nd respondent) had mortgaged property and, following default, the bank initiated SARFAESI proceedings. The Chief Judicial Magistrate, Rajamahendravaram, passed an order under Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act (dated 07/08/2018) directing physical possession of the scheduled property to be delivered to the bank.

The petitioner (the daughter of the guarantor) filed Writ Petition No. 38662 of 2018 under Article 226 alleging that the bank took possession of a specific 496 sq. yards portion of land (north-western corner of an overall property) that she claimed by deed of gift from her mother, and challenging the physical possession as illegal and contrary to Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act and principles of natural justice.

The guarantor (the mother) earlier filed Writ Petition No. 33083 of 2018 before the Hyderabad High Court against the same Section 14 order; that petition was dismissed by a Division Bench on 01/10/2018 after the bank produced an affidavit required under Section 14(1). A Division Bench of this Court later directed measurement of the land alleged to have been taken in excess of 1,924 sq. yards and ordered redelivery if excess belonged to the petitioner.

While these directions and other interim steps were pending, the petitioner filed a second writ petition (W.P. No. 3079 of 2019) challenging an auction notice dated 19/02/2019 (auction scheduled for 11/03/2019) and seeking interim relief restraining the bank from auctioning without separating/dividing the petitioner's claimed 496 sq. yards from the mortgaged property. The bank responded with a counter-affidavit and a map produced after survey and mapping, asserting the petitioner's land had not been touched and that the mortgaged property alone was being proceeded against.

Both writ petitions were heard together with consent of counsel; the Court reserved orders on 08/01/2020 and ultimately delivered the judgment dismissing both petitions and miscellaneous petitions, concluding the writs lacked merit.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent-bank, in taking physical possession under Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act, had proceeded beyond the mortgaged property (1,924 sq. yards) and thereby encroached upon the petitioner's claimed 496 sq. yards.
  2. Whether issuance of an auction notice (dated 19/02/2019) for the entire property without measuring or separating the petitioner's claimed portion rendered the auction unlawful or contrary to Sections 13 and 14 of the SARFAESI Act and Rules 8 and 9 of the Security Enforcement Rules, 2002.
  3. Whether interim relief (stay of auction or redelivery of possession) was warranted in the circumstances, particularly given the bank's assertions and the usual judicial reluctance to grant interim orders in financial recovery matters.
  4. Whether the High Court should entertain writ petitions under Article 226 in matters where effective statutory remedies (under the SARFAESI Act / DRTA mechanisms) are available — i.e., the question of maintainability of writ jurisdiction in the presence of an alternate remedy under the statute.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner (through her counsel) asserted that the bank had obtained physical possession of the petitioner's 496 sq. yards portion which had been gifted to her by her mother (the guarantor), and that such possession and the auction proceedings were illegal, arbitrary, violative of Sections 13 and 14 of the SARFAESI Act and Rules 8 and 9 of the Security Enforcement Rules, 2002, and also violated principles of natural justice and fundamental rights.
  • The petitioner argued that the Division Bench's interim direction dated 06/12/2018 for measurement of the land had not been complied with and that the bank issued an auction notice without separating the petitioner's alleged portion, thereby necessitating urgent interim relief (release of lock and key; redelivery; stay of the auction).
  • Relied on documents and photographs to show alleged possession by the bank of the gifted portion, and sought protection of peaceful possession over the 496 sq. yards area.

Respondent-Bank's Arguments

  • The respondent-bank denied taking possession of the petitioner's 496 sq. yards. It maintained that it had proceeded only against the mortgaged property, and that the petitioner's land had not been touched.
  • The bank produced a counter-affidavit and a map prepared after survey and mapping (survey report dated 23/05/2019), asserting the petitioner's property was north-west of the mortgaged property and was not included in the bank's possession or the auction proceedings.
  • The bank contended that the petitioner was using writ jurisdiction to delay legitimate recovery proceedings, and raised a preliminary objection on maintainability: the petitioner had a statutory remedy (under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act and recourse to Debts Recovery Tribunal) and the High Court should not ordinarily entertain Article 226 petitions where an effective statutory remedy exists.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Punjab National Bank v. Imperial Gift House (2001) 6 SCC 569 That SARFAESI and similar statutes provide a special, fast-track procedure for recovery and a hierarchical appeal mechanism; courts should refrain from exercising Article 226/227 jurisdiction where an alternative statutory remedy is available, to avoid derailing the statutory scheme. The Court relied on this principle to emphasise that writ jurisdiction should not be used to circumvent statutory remedies in recovery matters and that the petitioner should not frustrate the statutory process by invoking Article 226.
United Bank of India v. Satyawati Tondon (2010) 8 SCC 110 The High Court will ordinarily not entertain Article 226 petitions where effective remedies exist under a statute, especially in recovery matters; litigants must exhaust statutory remedies and High Courts should exercise discretion with caution in such cases. The Court relied on these observations to reinforce the point that the petitioner had statutory remedies available (e.g., under Section 17 / DRT) and that interference via writ jurisdiction in SARFAESI matters should be sparing.
Authorized Officer, State Bank of Travancore v. Mathew K.C (2018) 3 SCC 85 Courts should apply settled law in financial matters; grant of ex parte interim orders in financial recovery cases can have deleterious effects because loans involve public money; urgency to avoid blocking public funds and liquidity. The Court invoked this authority to justify reluctance to pass interim injunctions in financial disputes and to require strict satisfaction of the ingredients for interim relief (in particular, irreparable loss), thereby supporting the refusal to grant interim protection to the petitioner.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded by closely examining the factual matrix, documentary record and the parties' pleadings and affidavits. The principal steps of reasoning (as stated in the opinion) are:

  1. Identity and standing: The petitioner is the daughter of the guarantor (2nd respondent) and claimed a 496 sq. yards portion said to have been gifted by her mother.
  2. Chronology of proceedings: The bank instituted SARFAESI proceedings after the loan went NPA (loan and interest figures and demand notice dated 09/07/2014 were recorded). The bank obtained an order under Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act directing physical possession (Crl.M.P. No. 240 of 2018; order dated 07/08/2018 or 08/08/2018 in places).
  3. Earlier challenge by guarantor: The guarantor (mother) had earlier challenged the Section 14 order in W.P. No. 33083 of 2018 which was dismissed by the Division Bench on 01/10/2018 after the bank produced the affidavit required under the first proviso to Section 14(1), and an OTS proposal had been given which the guarantor did not accept.
  4. Division Bench interim direction: A Division Bench of the High Court had directed measurement of the land and ordered that if any excess beyond 1,924 sq. yards was found to belong to the petitioner it should be redelivered prior to delivery of auctioned land to any successful bidder. That direction informed subsequent proceedings.
  5. Bank's factual denial and survey: The bank filed a detailed counter-affidavit in W.P. No. 3079 of 2019, asserting the bank had not proceeded against the petitioner's property and had conducted survey and demarcation in compliance with the Division Bench order; a surveyor's report and map (dated 23/05/2019) were placed on record showing the petitioner's land was north-west to the mortgaged property and had not been included in the bank's possession.
  6. Petitioner's failure to controvert: The Court noted that no reply to the bank's counter-affidavit was filed, and at the hearing the petitioner only sought to orally dispute the bank's stand. The Court treated the bank's on-oath statement as admitted in the absence of contrary evidence.
  7. Maintainability and statutory remedies: The Court highlighted that once proceedings are initiated under the SARFAESI Act, normally writ jurisdiction is not the appropriate remedy where statutory alternatives exist (e.g., Section 17 appeals to the Debts Recovery Tribunal). The Court relied on binding precedents emphasizing judicial restraint in recovery matters.
  8. Reluctance to grant interim orders in financial matters: Applying precedent and principle, the Court emphasised that interim relief in financial recovery disputes should be sparingly granted; one of the key ingredients for interim relief — irreparable loss — was not satisfactorily demonstrated by the petitioner. The Court observed the public interest implications of blocking loan recovery and liquidity concerns noted in authority.
  9. Conclusion on merits: Given the bank's sworn assertions, the survey/map on record, the prior dismissal of the guarantor's writ, the Division Bench's measurement direction (and the bank's compliance by conducting survey) and the petitioner's lack of adequate rebuttal or demonstration of irreparable harm, the Court concluded the writ petitions lacked merits and constituted misuse of process.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: Both writ petitions (W.P. No. 38662 of 2018 and W.P. No. 3079 of 2019) are dismissed.

Consequential orders: As a direct consequence of the dismissal, miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, in these writ petitions are also dismissed.

Implications and reasoning behind the holding:

  • The Court rejected the petitioner's claim because the respondent-bank on oath denied proceeding against the petitioner's specific portion and placed a survey/map on record showing segregation of the petitioner's land; the petitioner did not effectively rebut this factual position.
  • The Court emphasised that when a statutory remedy exists (here, under the SARFAESI Act and via DRT), the High Court should exercise writ jurisdiction with restraint in recovery matters, following Supreme Court precedent cited in the opinion.
  • The Court declined to grant interim orders in financial recovery matters absent a clear showing of irreparable loss, and invoked precedent warning against ex parte or ad hoc interim relief that could impair banks' ability to recover public funds lent in a fiduciary capacity.
  • No new legal principle or precedent was declared by the Court; the decision applied existing authorities and the statutory framework to the facts before it. The direct practical effect is dismissal of the petitions and dismissal of any related miscellaneous applications; the bank may proceed in accordance with the SARFAESI procedure subject to compliance with the earlier direction for measurement, as reflected in the record and the bank's survey.

This summary is confined strictly to the content and reasoning contained in the provided opinion and does not add facts or inferences beyond that text.

    Ch. Uma Maheshwari v. State Bank Of India, Rep. By Its Chief Manager/Authorized Officer And Another

    Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue a writ, order or direction, more particularly, one in the nature of Writ of Mandamus by declaring the action of the respondent no. 1 in obtaining Physical Possession of the petitioners site with Mangalore titled shed existing therein i.e., an extent of 496 sq.yds existing towards the north western corner of Ac.0-50 cents with an old tiled house bearing Door No. 16-25-8/1, in TS No. 1965/5/6, Sambamurthy Nagar, Near ESI Hospital, Kakinada, East Godavari District, in pursuance of Orders dt.07-08-2018 passed in CRLMP. No. 240/2018, by The Court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, East Godavari, Rajamahendravaram, obtained against the 2 respondent and others, as illegal, arbitrary, in violation of Sec. 14 of SARFAESI Act and in violation of the fundamental rights of the petitioner and Principles of Natural Justice, by consequently directing the 1 respondent by releasing the lock and key and to handover the property of the petitioner i.e., an extent of 496 sq.yds existing towards the north western corner of Ac.0-50 cents with an old tiled house bearing Door No. 16-25-8/1, in TS No. 1965/5/6, Sambamurthy Nagar, Near ESI Hospital, Kakinada, East Godavari District.

    IA NO: 1 OF 2018

    Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to Grant Interim Orders of Direction, directing the 1 respondent by releasing the lock and key and to handover the property of the petitioner i.e., an extent of 496 sq.yds existing towards the north western corner of Ac.0-50 cents with an old tiled house bearing Door No. 16-25-8/1, in TS No. 1965/5/6, Sambamurthy Nagar, Near ESI Hospital, Kakinada, East Godavari District.

    Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue a writ, order or direction, more particularly, one in the nature of writ of mandamus by declaring the action of the respondent no. 1 in issuing auction notice dated 19-02-2019 for the auction to be held on 11-03-2019 over the property all part and parcel of 1924 sq. yards of residential site located at Dr. No. 16-25-8/1 with T.S. No. 1965/5/6, Sambamurthy Nagar, Kakinada, belonging to Smt. M. Rajeswari vide sale deed no. 7278/1981, dated 20-08-1981 without measuring the total land and separating the petitioners property i.e., an extent of 496 sq. yards existing towards the north western corner of Ac. 0-50 cents with an old titled house bearing Dr. No. 16-25-8/1, in TS No. 1965/5/6 sambamurthy nagar, near ESI Hospital, Kakinada, E.G. District still holding possession of the petitioners property along with 2 respondents property, though directed by the Honourable court as per interim order dated 06-12-2018 in I.A. No. 1 of 2018 in W.P. 38662 of 2018 filed by the petitioner as. illegal, arbitrrary, in violation of sec. 13 of SARFAESI Act and rules 8 and 9 of security enforcement rules 2002, and in violation of the fundamental rights of the petitioner and principles of natural justice, by consequently directing the 1 respondent not to hold auction either on 11-03-2019 or any other date without separating/dividing the petitioners property i.e., an extent of 496 sq. yards existing towards the north western corner of Ac. 0.50 cents with an old titled house bearing Dr. No. 16-25-8/1, in T.S. No. 1965/5/6, sambamurthy nagar, near ESI Hospital, Kakinada, E.G. District.

    IA NO: 1 OF 2019

    Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to grant interim orders of stay of all further proceedings of the actuion to be held on 11-03-2019 by the 1 respondent pursuant to the auction notification dated 19-02-2019 over the property all part and parcel of 1924 sq. yards of residential site located at Dr. No. 16-25-8/1 with T.S. No. 1965/5/6 sambamurthy nagar, kakinada, belonging to Smt. M. Rajeswari vide sale deed no. 7278/1981 dated 20-08-1981 pending disposal of writ petition

    The Order of the Court was delivered by

    Rakesh Kumar, J.:— Since in both the Writ Petitions the parties, and the reliefs sought for, are almost similar, both these Writ Petitions, with the consent of learned counsel for parties, were taken up together and are being disposed of by this common order.

    2. The petitioner, who is none else but the daughter of guarantor of the secured properties, regarding which, initially, order under Section 14 of the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the SARFAESI Act’) was passed, had filed a Writ Petition vide W.P. No. 38662 of 2018 under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying to declare the action of 1 respondent-State Bank of India/secured creditor in obtaining physical possession of petitioner's site with mangalore tiled roof shed existing therein i.e., an extent of 496 square yards existing towards the north western corner of Ac.0.50 cents with an old tiled house bearing Door No. 16-25-8/1 in T.S. No. 1965/5/6, Sambamurthy Nagar, near ESI Hospital, Kakinada, East Godavari district. The petitioner has asserted that the respondent-bank had taken possession pursuant to the order, dated 07.08.2018, passed in Crl.M.P. No. 240 of 2018, by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, East Godavari at Rajamahendravaram. The said order was passed under Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act. Prior to filing of the instant Writ Petition by the petitioner, her mother viz., Mandapati Rajeswari, who is 2 respondent herein, had filed a Writ Petition vide No. 33083 of 2018 in the High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad for the State of Telangana and the State of Andhra Pradesh against the very same order, which was passed under Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act, in which initially an order of status-quo was passed. However, finally, after finding that the respondent-bank had produced affidavit, which was filed in terms of Section 14(1) of the SARFAESI Act, a Division Bench of the High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad for the State of Telangana and the State of Andhra Pradesh by order, dated 01.10.2018, dismissed the said Writ Petition. It appears that after dismissal of the said Writ Petition, on 01.10.2018, which was filed by the mother of the petitioner, who is 2 respondent herein, the petitioner filed the present Writ Petition i.e., W.P. No. 38662 of 2018 only on 25.10.2018 claiming as if the 1 respondent-bank was taking possession of her land to the extent of 496 square yards, which fell to her share as per deed of gift prepared by her mother, 2 respondent herein. On 26.10.2018, a Division Bench of the High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad while granting time to learned standing counsel for the respondent-bank, had observed as follows:

    “………………………………

    The only point to be considered if at all, is as to whether the possession notice and the order under Section 14 of the Securitization Act were confined only to the land of the extent of 1924 square yards and as to whether the possession is sought to be taken on a larger extent than what was mortgaged to the Bank.”

    3. By subsequent order, a Division Bench of the High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad, on 06.12.2018, had further observed as follows:

    “Despite the matter undergoing two adjournments after Sri. K.B. Ramanna Dora, learned standing counsel for the first respondent bank, was asked to get instructions, we find that no instructions are forthcoming and Sri. Kiran Kumar, learned counsel, representing Sri. K.B. Ramanna Dora, learned standing counsel, again seeks an adjournment to get instructions.

    Sri. P. Rajesh Babu, learned counsel for the petitioner, would state that having taken possession of the petitioner's property in addition to the mortgaged property, the first respondent is now in the process of selling the same by way of a public auction and irreparable injustice would be caused to the petitioner if her property is also delivered to the auction purchaser.

    In that view of the matter, there shall be a direction to the first respondent to undertake measurement of the land that has been taken possession of and in the event it is found to be in excess of 1924 square yards as set out in the auction sale notice issued by the bank, the excess extent, if found to be belonging to the petitioner, shall be redelivered to her. This exercise shall be undertaken prior to the delivery of the auctioned land to the successful bidder, if any.”

    4. Even before compliance of the order, dated 06.12.2018, regarding measurement of the land in question, the petitioner, during pendency of the present Writ Petition, filed another Writ Petition i.e., W.P. No. 3079 of 2019 on 07.03.2019, in which on 08.03.2019, while directing for issuance of personal notice by registered post with acknowledgment due and to post the matter on 22.03.2019, a Division Bench of this Court i.e., High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Amaravati observed as follows:

    “……………………………

    The sale if any conducted shall not be confirmed or third party interest created by the respondents, for a period of three weeks from today.”

    5. Despite receipt of service report, the Writ Petition was not listed and thereafter on 02.01.2020, W.P. No. 3079 of 2019 was listed and adjourned. Finally, on 08.01.2020, W.P. No. 3079 of 2019 was listed side by side of W.P. No. 38662 of 2018. In W.P. No. 3079 of 2019, the petitioner has prayed to declare the action of 1 respondent in issuing auction notice, dated 19.02.2019, which was scheduled to be held on 11.03.2019 over the property “all part and parcel of 1924 sq. yards of residential site located at Door No. 16-25-8/1 with T.S. No. 1965/5/6, Sambamurthy Nagar, Kakinada, belonging to Smt. M. Rajeswari vide sale deed No. 7278/1981, dt.20.08.1981”, without measuring the total land and separating the petitioner's property i.e., an extent of 496 sq. yards existing towards north western corner of Ac.0.50 cents with an old tiled house bearing Door No. 16-25-8/1, in TS No. 1965/5/6, Sambamurthy Nagar, near ESI Hospital, Kakinada, East Godavari district, still holding possession of the petitioner's property along with 2 respondent's property, though directed by this Hon'ble Court as per interim order dt.06.12.2018 in I.A. No. 1 of 2018 in W.P. No. 38662 of 2018 filed by the petitioner, as illegal, arbitrary, in violation of Section 13 of the SARFAESI Act and Rules 8 and 9 of the Security Enforcement Rules 2002 and in violation of the fundamental rights of the petitioner and principles of natural justice, consequently prayed for directing the 1 respondent not to hold auction either on 11.03.2019 or any other date without separating/dividing the petitioner's property i.e., an extent of 496 sq. yards existing towards north western corner of Ac.0.50 cents with an old tiled house bearing Door No. 16-25-8/1 in TS No. 1965/5/6/, Sambamurthy Nagar, near ESI Hospital, Kakinada, East Godavari district, ancillary and for other incidental reliefs.

    6. Sri. P. Rajesh Babu, learned counsel for the petitioner, has taken us to number of documents including some of the photographs in Writ Petitions with a view to persuade the Court as if the land which was gifted to her by 2 respondent i.e., her mother/guarantor was being taken possession by the respondent-bank. Learned counsel submits that the action of the respondent-bank was completely illegal and as such he further argued that since direction given by a Division Bench in W.P. No. 38662 of 2018 regarding measurement of the land was not carried out and auction notice was issued, the petitioner was constrained to file W.P. No. 3079 of 2019. Accordingly, learned counsel for the petitioner has prayed for granting relief which has been sought for in both the Writ Petitions and not to disturb her peaceful possession over the land measuring 496 square yards.

    7. Sri. K.B. Ramanna Dora, learned counsel for the respondent-bank, has opposed both the Writ Petitions and argued that the respondent-bank has never taken possession of petitioner's land. The property which was mortgaged by 2 respondent as a guarantor is only subject matter in the SARFAESI proceedings. According to him, the petitioner has filed these Writ Petitions with a view to unnecessarily delay the action taken by the respondent-bank under the SARFAESI Act. He further argued that in compliance of the order passed in W.P. No. 38662 of 2018, the land in question was got measured in the presence of petitioner and a map was also prepared and the land allotted to the petitioner through deed of gift has not been touched. Copy of map has also been brought on record along with the counter-affidavit.

    8. Besides hearing learned counsel for both the parties, we have minutely examined the material available on record. In W.P. No. 3079 of 2019, the respondent-bank has filed a detailed counter-affidavit.

    9. After hearing learned counsel for both the parties, orders were reserved on 08.01.2020.

    10. Before proceeding further, it would be apt to notice as to how the land in question was mortgaged by 2 respondent, mother of the petitioner, as guarantor for the loan to the secured creditor i.e., respondent-bank. The respondent-bank had sanctioned loan of Rs. 5,0067,521/- and claimed interest and since, in the said loan, 2 respondent, mother of the petitioner, stood as guarantor, vide Account Nos. 62114315401 and 62114641151, all the loan documents were executed in favour of the respondent-bank for fetching loan. Since even after utilization and availing credit facility from the respondent-bank, the borrower failed to repay the loan amount as per the agreement, the loan account became Non Performing Asset and declared as NPA. Accordingly, the respondent-bank initiated recovery proceedings under the provisions of SARFAESI Act and issued demand notice on 09.07.2014 to repay the outstanding loan of Rs. 5,00,67,521/- as on 07.07.2014. The said amount was to be paid as per the notice within a period of 60 days from the date of receipt of notice with further intimation that failure to make payment may constrain the respondent-bank to take action under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act. Despite the borrower after noticing failed to pay the amount within the prescribed period, the respondent-bank filed petition before the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Rajahmundry for taking one or more measurements as prescribed under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act. As on the date i.e., 15.07.2018, the total recoverable amount had come to Rs. 8,03,91,084/- only. After filing of the aforesaid petition by the respondent-bank, it was numbered as Crl.M.P. No. 240 of 2018. The said petition was filed before the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate along with all the relevant documents. Thereafter, on 08.08.2018, learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, by exercising power under Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act, appointed an Advocate Commissioner to take physical possession of the schedule property from the borrower/guarantor and to deliver the same to the secured creditor/respondent-bank. After the order dated 08.08.2018 passed by learned Chief Judicial Magistrate in Crl.M.P. No. 240 of 2018, the guarantor/2 respondent, who is the mother of the petitioner, filed Writ Petition vide W.P. No. 33083 of 2018 in the High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad for the State of Telangana and the State of Andhra Pradesh. Initially, in the said matter, status-quo order was passed. However, finally, by an order, dated 01.10.2018, W.P. No. 33083 of 2018 stood dismissed. It would be apt herein to quote the order, dated 01.10.2018, passed in W.P. No. 33083 of 2018, which has been brought on record in W.P. No. 38662 of 2018:

    “THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE RAMESH RANGANATHAN

    THE HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE KONGARA VIJAYA LAKSHMI

    WRIT PETITION No. 33083 OF 2018

    ORDER: (Per the Hon'ble Sri. Justice Ramesh Ranganathan)

    Heard Sri. P. Rajesh Babu, learned counsel for the petitioner, and Sri. K.B. Ramanna Dora, learned counsel for the respondent-Bank and, with their consent, the Writ Petition is disposed of at the stage of admission.

    The proceedings under challenge in this Writ Petition is the order passed by the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Rajamahendravaram, in Crl.M.P. No. 240 of 2018 dated 07.08.2018 directing physical possession of the subject property to be delivered to the first respondent-Bank.

    The sole ground, on which the said order is subjected to challenge in this Writ Petition, is that an affidavit, as required under the first proviso to Section 14(1) of the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (“the SARFAESI Act” for brevity), was not filed by the respondent-Bank; and the certified copies furnished to the petitioner do not reflect an affidavit having been filed.

    When the matter came up earlier, Sri. K.B. Ramanna Dora, learned counsel for the respondent-Bank, sought time to obtain instructions. Today, the learned counsel for the respondent-Bank has placed before us a copy of the affidavit received by him by E-mail from the first respondent-Bank. The said affidavit is the affidavit filed in terms of the first proviso to Section 14(1) of the SARFAESI Act. A copy of the said affidavit has also been handed over to Sri. P. Rajesh Babu, learned counsel for the petitioner.

    Sri. K.B. Ramanna Dora, learned counsel for the respondent-Bank, would further state that, in terms of the OTS proposal made by the bank, the petitioner was given time till 30.09.2018 to make an offer for an OTS proposal; and no such offer has been received from the petitioner even as on date.

    As it is evident that an affidavit was filed by the first respondent-Bank, in support of the petition filed by them under Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act, the petitioner's complaint, of such an affidavit not having been filed, necessitates rejection.

    As this is the sole ground on which the proceedings of Magistrate, under Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act, is questioned, the Writ Petition is liable to be, and is accordingly, dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs. Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending shall stand dismissed.”

    11. On examination of order, dated 01.10.2018, quoted herein above, it appears that subsequently the borrower was offered OTS proposal also which was not acceded to by the borrower/guarantor. After the mother of the petitioner who was guarantor failed to get any relief from the High Court, the petitioner approached this Court with a plea as if the respondent-bank had also taken possession of the land which was allotted to her through deed of gift by the guarantor, mother of the petitioner i.e., 2 respondent. In W.P. No. 38662 of 2018 in Para No. 9 the petitioner has stated as if earlier W.P. No. 33083 of 2018 was disposed of whereas order dated 01.10.2018 supra makes it clear that the Writ Petition was dismissed.

    12. In the counter affidavit, which has been filed by the respondent-bank in W.P. No. 3097 of 2019, a categorical stand has been taken by the bank that the bank never proceeded against the petitioner's property. Further, in Para No. 7 of the counter-affidavit the bank has stated that pursuant to the interim order passed by this Court, the bank conducted survey and demarcated the lands mortgaged and the property belongs to the petitioner through survey and mapping solutions. As per the report of the Surveyor, dated 23.05.2019, the land was measured and as per the said drawing the property of the petitioner was on north western to the property mortgaged in favour of the bank. A specific stand has been taken in Para No. 7 that “the respondent-bank is not proceeding against the petitioner's property”. Along with the counter-affidavit the bank has brought on record the map prepared by the Surveyor, which is reproduced hereunder:

    13. A bare perusal of the sketch plan referred herein above as well as specific statement made by the respondent-bank, it is clear that the petitioner's land has not been touched by the respondent-bank. Even then, to the reasons best known to the petitioner, in same dispute, she has filed two Writ Petitions. In Writ Petition i.e., W.P. No. 38662 of 2018 a direction was issued regarding measurement of the land. However, during pendency of the said Writ Petition, the petitioner filed second Writ Petition vide W.P. No. 3079 of 2019. It is simply misuse of the process of the Court. Moreover, once a proceeding under the SARFAESI Act was initiated, in normal course, the petitioner was not required to invoke writ jurisdiction of this Court which is to be invoked in extraordinary circumstances particularly, in a dispute where an aggrieved party is having a statutory remedy. In the counter-affidavit also the respondent-bank has raised preliminary objection regarding maintainability of the Writ Petition since the petitioner was having remedy under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act to approach the Debts Recovery Tribunal. Time without number the Hon'ble Supreme Court has deprecated the action of the High Court in interfering in such a matter that too particularly in a dispute under the SARFAESI Act. Even prior to enactment of SARFAESI Act, in a dispute of recovery of debts to the banks and other financial institutions, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Punjab National Bank v. Imperial Gift House (2001) 6 SCC 569, has observed as follows at Para No. 6:

    “6. The Act has been enacted with a view to provide a special procedure for recovery of debts due to the banks and the financial institutions. There is a hierarchy of appeal provided in the Act. Namely, filing of an appeal under Section 20 and this fast-track procedure cannot be allowed to be derailed either by taking recourse to proceedings under Article 226 and 227 of the Constitution or by filing a civil suit, which is expressly barred. Even though a provision under an Act cannot expressly oust the jurisdiction of the court under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution, nevertheless, when there is an alternative remedy available, judicial prudence demands, that the Court refrains from exercising its jurisdiction under the said constitutional provisions. This was a case where the High Court should not have entertained the petition under Article 227 of the Constitution and should have directed the respondent to take recourse to the appeal mechanism provided by the Act.”

    14. Yet again the Hon'ble Supreme Court in respect of a dispute under the SARFAESI Act, in United Bank of India v. Satyawati Tondon (2010) 8 SCC 110 observed as follows in Paragraph Nos. 43 and 55:

    “43. Unfortunately, the High Court overlooked the settled law that the High Court will ordinarily not entertain a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution if an effective remedy is available to the aggrieved person and that this Rule applies with greater rigour in matters involving recovery of taxes, cess, fees, other types of public money and the dues of banks and other financial institutions. In our view, while dealing with the petitions involving challenge to the action taken for recovery of the public dues, etc. the High Court must keep in mind that the legislations enacted by Parliament and State Legislatures for recovery of such dues are a code unto themselves inasmuch as they not only contain comprehensive procedure for recovery of the dues but also envisage constitution of quasi-judicial bodies for redressal of the grievance of any aggrieved person. Therefore, in all such cases, the High Court must insist that before availing remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution, a person must exhaust the remedies available under the relevant statute.

    55. It is a matter of serious concern that despite repeated pronouncement of this Court, the High Courts continue to ignore the availability of statutory remedies under the DRT Act and the SARFAESI Act and exercise jurisdiction under Article 226 for passing orders which have serious adverse impact on the right of banks and other financial institutions to recover their dues. We hope and trust that in future the High Courts will exercise their discretion in such matters with greater caution, care and circumspection.”

    15. Of course, in W.P. No. 3079 of 2019 an interim order was passed restraining the respondent-bank from confirming sale or creating third party interest which was only for a period of three (3) weeks but it was never existed. We are of the opinion that in financial matters, we may refrain from passing any interim order. We are of the opinion that if it is a dispute relating to finance one may not suffer any irreparable loss. It is settled law that for granting interim injunction, three ingredients are must. Amongst them establishing irreparable loss by a party claiming injunction/interim order is paramount. Recently, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Authorized Officer, State Bank of Travancore v. Mathew K.C (2018) 3 SCC 85 has observed as follows in Para No. 15:

    “15. It is the solemn duty of the court to apply the correct law without waiting for an objection to be raised by a party, especially when the law stands well settled. Any departure, if permissible, has to be for reasons discussed, of the case falling under a defined exception, duly discussed after noticing the relevant law. In financial matters grant of ex parte interim orders can have a deleterious effect and it is not sufficient to say that the aggrieved has the remedy to move for vacating the interim order. Loans by financial institutions are granted from public money generated at the taxpayer's expense. Such loan does not become the property of the person taking the loan, but retains its character of public money given in a fiduciary capacity as entrustment by the public. Timely repayment also ensures liquidity to facilitate loan to another in need, by circulation of the money and cannot be permitted to be blocked by frivolous litigation by those who can afford the luxury of the same.”

    16. Despite the fact that in the counter-affidavit a specific stand was taken by the respondent-bank that the bank was not proceeding against the petitioner's property and in Para No. 13 it has stated that the bank had no such intention to auction the whole property which is in excess of 1924 square yards, no reply to the counter-affidavit has been filed. However, at the time of hearing, learned counsel for the petitioner tried to orally dispute the said stand. Once on oath a specific stand has been taken by the bank that they are not proceeding against the petitioner's property, unless it is reverted the same shall be treated as admitted. Accordingly, in view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, there is no reason for passing any order in favour of the petitioner. We are of the opinion that these Writ Petitions have got no merits.

    17. Accordingly, both the Writ Petitions stand dismissed.

    18. As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, in these Writ Petitions shall stand dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ch. Uma Maheshwari v. State Bank Of India, Rep. By Its Chief Manager/Authorized Officer And Another
    (Jan 22, 2020)