AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 167(2) of Cr.P.C
  • Section 167(2) of the code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 457(2), 382, 411(2) and 414(2) of IPC
  • Section 167 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Sections 457(2), 380(2), 411 (2) and 414(2) of IPC.
  • Section 167 of Cr.P.C
  • Section 167 Cr.P.C.
  • Section 167(2) nor Article 21
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 167(2) of Cr.P.C
  • Section 167(2) of the code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 457(2), 382, 411(2) and 414(2) of IPC
  • Section 167 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Sections 457(2), 380(2), 411 (2) and 414(2) of IPC.
  • Section 167 of Cr.P.C
  • Section 167 Cr.P.C.
  • Section 167(2) nor Article 21
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Concise narrative based solely on the provided opinion.

The petitioner was arrested by the respondent police on 21.02.2020 in connection with Crime No. 495 (registered on 31.12.2015) for offences under Sections 457(2), 380(2), 411(2) and 414(2) of the Indian Penal Code, related to the theft of three idols from the Srinivasa Perumal Temple within the jurisdiction of Samayanallur Police Station, Madurai District. The petitioner filed an email petition for bail and the matter was heard via video conferencing because of the nationwide COVID-19 lockdown.

Investigation revealed seven persons were involved. After the arrest of A1, one idol was recovered from a relative of the petitioner (arrayed as A3) based on A1's confession; two idols remain unrecovered. Four accused (A1 to A4) have been secured while three accused are at large. The petitioner was in custody for 92 days at the time of hearing, and the police had not filed the final report. The petitioner sought bail, contending he is innocent, was falsely implicated, and is entitled to default bail under Section 167(2) Cr.P.C. because the investigation was not completed within the statutory period. The State opposed bail, citing incomplete recovery, pending investigation hampered by lockdown restrictions, and the petitioner's adverse antecedents.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to the benefit of Section 167(2) of the Criminal Procedure Code (i.e., default bail) given that the investigation and filing of the final report have not been completed.
  2. Whether the Supreme Court's suo motu order extending the period of limitation (SUO MOTU WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No.3/2020) applies to the time period prescribed under Section 167(2) Cr.P.C. for completion of investigation and filing of the final report.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner is innocent and falsely implicated; he and others were chosen as scapegoats in a long-pending idol theft investigation.
  • The original idol theft case was registered on 31.12.2015 (Crime No. 495 of 2015) and the petitioner was arrested only on 21.02.2020; he has been in custody for 92 days and the final report has not been filed.
  • Because the investigation has not been completed within the statutory period, the petitioner is entitled to default bail under Section 167(2) of the Cr.P.C.
  • The petitioner relied upon an order of this Court in Crl.O.P(MD) No. 5291 of 2020 (Settu v. The State, dated 08.05.2020) asserting that the Supreme Court's extension of limitation does not apply to Section 167 Cr.P.C.

Respondent/State's Arguments

  • Three idols of Hindu deities were stolen; of these, one idol was recovered via a confession of A1 from a relative (A3) of the petitioner; two idols remain unrecovered.
  • Investigation showed seven persons were involved; arrests have been made for A1 to A4 while three accused remain at large.
  • Investigation could not be completed within the statutory time because of the COVID-19 lockdown and restrictions on movement, which hindered access to witnesses and other investigative steps.
  • The petitioner has very bad antecedents and is accused in three other idol theft cases pending; there is a risk of absconding and reoffending if released on bail.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
SUO MOTU WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No(s).3/2020 IN RE: COGNIZANCE FOR EXTENSION OF LIMITATION (Supreme Court order dated 23.03.2020) The Supreme Court ordered that the period of limitation in all proceedings shall stand extended with effect from 15th March 2020 until further orders, invoking powers under Article 142 read with Article 141 of the Constitution, to obviate difficulties faced by litigants due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The Court treated this order as extending the period of limitation applicable to the filing of the final report and the time prescribed under Section 167(2) Cr.P.C., holding that the time prescribed for completing investigation is "eclipsed" by the Supreme Court's order and thus the petitioner cannot claim default bail on the basis of Section 167(2).
Crl.O.P(MD) No. 5291 of 2020 — Settu v. The State (Order dated 08.05.2020) This Court's earlier order (relied upon by the petitioner) took the position that the Supreme Court's extension of limitation would not apply to Section 167 Cr.P.C. The present Court rejected that interpretation, described the earlier order as misinterpreting the Supreme Court's order, and held that such an approach is contrary to the spirit of the Apex Court order and therefore non-est and without binding force.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by setting out the statutory scheme under Section 167 Cr.P.C., which contemplates completion of investigation within 60 or 90 days depending on the gravity of the offence and provides that failure to complete investigation within the prescribed period gives rise to a right to bail (commonly called "default bail"). The court acknowledged the Supreme Court's suo motu order of 23.03.2020 extending the period of limitation from 15 March 2020 until further orders, passed under Article 142 read with Article 141, and reproduced its terms.

Although the Supreme Court's order did not explicitly mention police investigation, the court reasoned that the Apex Court invoked extraordinary constitutional powers to obviate difficulties caused by the pandemic and intended the extension to be understood holistically. The court emphasized the practical effects of the nationwide lockdown: restrictions on movement, curtailed access to witnesses, administrative and judicial functions hampered, and investigative agencies rendered unable to complete investigations or file final reports through normal physical channels. The court found these effects beyond the investigators' control.

On this basis, the court held that it would be pedantic and contrary to the spirit of the Supreme Court's order to read the order narrowly so as to exclude police investigations or the filing of final reports. The court treated the Apex Court's order as an equitable and binding directive that extends limitation periods generally, and therefore as eclipsing the time prescribed under Section 167(2) Cr.P.C. The court observed that accused persons and investigating agencies must be treated at par in these extraordinary circumstances and that permitting accused persons to claim default bail where delay in investigation is attributable to pandemic restrictions would amount to taking undue advantage of the situation.

The court also addressed and rejected the earlier High Court order in Crl.O.P(MD) No. 5291 of 2020 (Settu), concluding that that order misinterpreted the Supreme Court's directive and was inconsistent with the Apex Court's invocation of Article 142; accordingly, it was characterized as non-est and without binding force for the present matter.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The bail petition is DISMISSED.

Implications (as stated in the opinion)

  • The Court held that the Supreme Court's order extending the period of limitation (w.e.f. 15th March 2020 until further orders) applies to the time for completing investigation under Section 167(2) Cr.P.C.; thus, the statutory period for completion of investigation is effectively "eclipsed" for the duration of the extension.
  • As a direct effect, the petitioner cannot claim release on default bail under Section 167(2) Cr.P.C. where the delay in completing the investigation and filing the final report is attributable to the COVID-19 lockdown and attendant restrictions.
  • The Court rejected the contrary view taken in Crl.O.P(MD) No. 5291 of 2020 in Settu v. The State, describing that order as misinterpretation of the Supreme Court order and as having no binding force in this context.
  • No statement was made in the opinion that a new legal precedent beyond this interpretation is being set in a manner different from the Supreme Court's directive; the direct consequence described is the dismissal of the present bail petition and the court's interpretation that the Supreme Court's extension covers the time prescribed under Section 167(2) Cr.P.C.

    S. Kasi Petitioner/Accused No. 3 v. State, Through The Inspector Of Police /Complainant.

    PRAYER:- For Bail in Crime No. 495 of 2020 on the file of the respondent Police.

    The Order of the Court was delivered by

    G. Jayachandran, J.:— The petitioner herein was arrested by the respondent police on 21.02.2020 for the alleged offence under Sections 457(2), 380(2), 411 (2) and 414(2) of IPC.

    2. The petitioner herein is now before this Court seeking bail. In view of the national wide lock down, to avoid physical contacts and to maintain social distancing courts are function through virtual mode. The petitioner has filed his petition petition through E-mail and same is heard through video conferencing.

    3. The learned counsel for the petitioner would urge this Court for grant of bail on the ground that the petitioner is innocent and falsely implicated in this case. The respondent to give quitus to the long pending idol theft case under investigation without any progress for nearly 5 years have choosen this petitioner and others as scapegoats. According to the learned counsel for the petitioner the case of idol theft was registered by the respondent police on 31.12.2015 under Section 457(2), 382, 411(2) and 414(2) of IPC in Crime No. 495 of 2015. After 4 years the petitioner was arrested on 21.02.2020. The petitioner is in custody for the past 92 days. The respondent police has not filed the final report. Hence the petitioner is entitled for bail by default as contemplated under Section 167(2) of Cr.P.C.

    4. Per contra, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for the State would submit that three idols of Hindu God and Goddess were stolen from the Srinivasa Perumal Temple within the jurisdiction of Samayanallur Police Station, Madurai District. The Case was registered on 31.12.2015. Investigation revealed that seven persons were involved in this case. After the arrest of A1, based on the confession given by A1 out of three idols stolen one was recovered from the relative of this petitioner who is arrayed as A3. Two more idols are yet to be recovered. Police could able to secure A-1 to A-4. Three more accused are still at large. Inview of the lockdown clamped by the Government, the investigation could not be completed within the time prescribed under the statute. The investigating officer is handicapped with the restrictions imposed by the State which included free movement and access to witnesses for recording their statements. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor would further submit that the petitioner is carrying very bad antecedent. He is accused of idol theft in 3 more cases and still pending. If the petitioner is released on bail, there is possibility of absconding as well as recurrence of similar crime.

    5. Heard the learned Counsels on either side. On considering the antecedent of the accused, crime alleged, abscondance of few more accused persons and non-recovery of the remaining stolen property this court finds that the petitioner does not deserve bail at this juncture.

    6. However, in view of the covid-19 lockdown and the order passed by the Hon'ble Supreme court extending the limitation, a unique and peculiar legal issue stares at the Court whether the petitioner is entitle to avail the benefit of Section 167(2) of Cr.P.C?.

    7. Taking note of the Covid-19 situation and realising the gravity of the pandemic, the Hon'ble Supreme Court on 23/03/2020 in a suomotu writ petition (SUO MOTU WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No(s).3/2020 IN RE : COGNIZANCE FOR EXTENSION OF LIMITATION) passed order extending the period of limitation to obviate the difficulties faced by the litigants who are supposed to personally come to the court and file their petition/application/suits/in all other proceedings until further orders. For the sake of proper appreciation, the relevant portion of the Supreme court order is extracted below:

    “This Court has taken Suo Motu cognizance of the situation arising out of the challenge faced by the country on account of Covid-19 Virus and resultant difficulties that may be faced by litigants across the country in filing their petitions/applications/suits/appeals/all other proceedings within the period of limitation prescribed under the general law of limitation or under Special Laws (both Central and/or State).

    To obviate such difficulties and to ensure that lawyers/litigants do not have to come physically to file such proceedings in respective Courts/Tribunals across the country including this Court, it is hereby ordered that a period of limitation in all such proceedings, irrespective of the limitation prescribed under the general law or Special Laws whether condonable or not shall stand extended w.e.f. 15th March 2020 till further order/s to be passed by this Court in present proceedings.

    We are exercising this power under Article 142 read with Article 141 of the Constitution of India and declare that this order is a binding order within the meaning of Article 141 on all Courts/Tribunals and authorities.

    This order may be brought to the notice of all High Courts for being communicated to all subordinate Courts/Tribunals within their respective jurisdiction. Issue notice to all the Registrars General of the High Courts, returnable in four weeks.”

    8. No doubt in the above order the Honourable Supreme Court has not specifically mentioned that police investigation should also be covered by the said order. However, the Apex Court while invoking its extraordinary power conferred in Article 142 of the Constitution during an extraordinary circumstances has clearly expressed his intention and reason for passing such order. The order has been passed to obviate the difficulties faced by the litigants across the country in filing their petitions/applications/suits/appeals/all other proceedings(emphasis added). Therefore it is appropriate for any prudent person to appreciate the order of the Honourable Apex Court in a holistic perspective. The pandemic situation, total nationwide lockdown, restrictions on movement, fear of death looming large paralysing the routine function of the administration including judiciary were the reason for issuing such order. The Honourable Supreme Court to render complete justice has invoked Article 142 and passed this order. No courts below obliterate the intention of the Supreme Court by offering pedantic interpretation. Oblivious of the provisions of law and spirit behind such laws.

    9. Section 167 of Cr.P.C envisages completion of investigation within the period of 60 days or 90 days, as the case may be, depending upon the gravity of the offence and the extent of punishment. If the investigation not completed within period prescribed, the person accused of the offence is entitled for bail as if he has committed bailable offence. Thereafter the Provisions of Chapter XXXIII of the Code will apply. In other words, Section 167 of the Code of Criminal Procedure mandates the investigating agency to complete the investigation within the time prescribed. If they fail to complete the investigation, statutory right blossom to the person in custody to seek release from prison on bail as matter of right.

    10. This provision in common parlance among the respected members of the bar and bench aptly called as ‘default bail’. The reason, when there is default on the part of investigation right of bail gets accrues to the person detained. Now with this understanding of Section 167(2) of Cr.P.C, and in the light of the order passed by the Apex Court extending limitation to render complete justice to the litigants the submission of the learned counsel for the petitioner has to be examined.

    11. Currently, the State has restricted free movement of the Public. The Law Enforcing Agencies are directed to ensure complete lock down. Access to places restricted either partially or absolutely. Government mechineries has almost come to stand still. Courts gates are locked. Public access is prohibited. All judicial proceedings are conducted through video conference. Administration wings of the Court yet to resume the physical functioning. In such a circumstances, the wings of the investigating agency are clipped; their legs are tied. They are unable to conduct the investigation and complete the same. Even if they complete the investigation, courts are not open to receive it. This is not their fault. Covid-19 situation is the cause for not completing the investigating within the time fixed under the Statute.

    12. Therefore taking note of the situation The Hon'ble Supreme Court has passed the order dated 23.03.2020 extracted above. The order came to be passed to do complete justice to the litigants who face difficulty in presenting their documents related to the proceedings. Any attempt to misread the order or to interpret the order contrary to the spirit of this order will cause injustice. Inspite of the Apex Court order extending the period of limitation in all proceedings where litigants face difficulties to be present physically, if one say it is not applicable to filing of final report on completion of investigation, he just mock the Apex Court order and nothing less.

    13. Violators of law cannot take undue advantage of the extra ordinary situation and enjoy the liberty while the entire nation is under lock down and crippled from carrying on their normal activities.

    14. The lockdown announced by the Government is akin to proclamation of emergency. Under Article 352 of the Constitution, in case of external aggression National Emergency can be proclaimed by the President. Presently we face aggression not by human agencies, but by micro-organs. Like wise when the nation face threat to the credit or financial stability under Article 360 Financial emergency can be declared. If emergency is declared, under Article 358 the rights under Article 19 gets suspended. The right to live guaranteed under Article 21 is subject restriction. Presently, though the state is not passing through emergency duly proclaimed, whole nation has accepted the restrictions for well being of mankind. At this juncture, myopic reading of Section 167 of Cr.P.C conveniently ignoring the spirit behind the order by the Apex Court invoking its power under Article 142 of the constitution will amount to judicial indiscipline.

    15. The spirit behind the order of the Apex Court is to do complete justice. Conscious to the fact that there are several legislations prescribing limitation, the Honourable Supreme Court has generally stated the period of limitation prescribed under general law of limitation or under special laws shall be extended until further order. Therefore it is needless to mention that the limitation under Section 167 for investigation also get extended.

    16. The learned counsel for the petitioner relying upon the order passed by this Court in Crl.O.P(MD) No. 5291 of 2020 in Settu v. The State rep. by the Inspector of Police, Vallam Police Station, Thanjavur District, dated 08.05.2020 insisted that the extension of period envisaged in the Apex court order will not apply to Section 167 Cr.P.C.

    17. This Court had the privilege of reading the said order. It is hight of ignorance to expect the investigation agency to complete the investigation and file final report in the Court within time prescribed after closing down the gates and prohibiting the access. After imposing restrictions on their movements and chiding them, “executive must exhibit nimble footwork and not hide behind judicial order. Only little children hide behind the saree end (paalu) of their mothers” is uncharitable.

    18. The learned judge has mis-interpreted the Apex Court Order dated 23/03/2020. The clarification order dated 06/05/2020 no way dilute or restrict the scope and extend of the earlier order. Since the order relied by the learned counsel for the petitioner is contrary to the spirit of the Honourable Supreme Court order issued in exercise to the power of Article 142 it is non-est and has no binding force.

    19. In any given situation, a person accused of the offence and the investigation agency has to be treated at par under law. Order passed by the Supreme Court invoking Article 142 of the constitution is an equitable order. After putting fetters on the investigating agency upon their right of movement causing delay in completing investigation, the person accused of the offence cannot take undue advantage of the situation and seek default bail. The liberty enshrined under Article 21 is subject to restrictions. The order of the Apex Court is Law binding on all courts. The petitioner's life and liberty is restricted only by due process of law and procedure established under law. Neither Section 167(2) nor Article 21 give unfettered right to the person accused of an offence. In an extraordinary situation, the Apex Court has passed the order invoking its extraordinary power under Article 142 extending the period of limitation prescribed in the general law of limitation and other special laws. The Supreme Court order eclipses all provisions prescribing period of limitation until further orders. Undoubtedly, it eclipses the time prescribed under Section 167(2) of the code of Criminal Procedure also.

    20. In this case, the petitioner is arrested for the theft of three idols in the temple. One idol has been recovered based on the confession of the co-accused and two idols are yet to be recovered. Out of seven accused four have been arrested and three more are at large. In view of the order passed by the Honourable Supreme Court extending the limitation, the time prescribed for completing investigation under Section 167(2) gets eclipsed. The petitioner cannot harp on the limitation prescribed under Section 167(2) of Cr.P.C and pray release on bail.

    21. Hence the bail petition is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    S. Kasi Petitioner/Accused No. 3 v. State, Through The Inspector Of Police /Complainant.
    (May 11, 2020)