AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petitions, transfer petition and connected applications before the Supreme Court concerned the conduct of Class X and Class XII Board examinations administered by the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) and the Council for the Indian School Certificate Examinations (ICSE) for the academic year 2019-2020. The examinations had been rescheduled for 1 July – 15 July 2020 because of the COVID-19 pandemic. Multiple petitions sought directions on whether these examinations should proceed, be postponed, or be cancelled and replaced by an alternative evaluation scheme. On 26 June 2020, a Bench comprising A.M. Khanwilkar, Dinesh Maheshwari and Sanjiv Khanna, JJ., heard the matters together and delivered the present order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the CBSE should be permitted to cancel the remaining Class X and Class XII examinations scheduled for 1 July – 15 July 2020 and publish results on the basis of an alternative assessment scheme.
  2. Whether similar relief should be extended to the ICSE, including the option of future examinations for performance improvement, and how its distinct assessment methodology would be accommodated.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined a draft notification placed on record by the CBSE cancelling the pending examinations and detailing an assessment scheme based on students’ prior performance. After considering “suggestions given by the counsel appearing for the concerned parties,” the Bench found “no difficulty in permitting the CBSE to issue the said notification forthwith.”

Key elements accepted by the Court include:

  • Cancellation of all pending CBSE Class X and XII papers scheduled between 1 July and 15 July 2020.
  • Declaration of results by 15 July 2020 using the assessment methodology devised by a competent CBSE committee (best-performance averaging and internal assessment parameters).
  • An optional examination for Class XII students in cancelled subjects, to be conducted when conditions are “conducive,” with marks obtained therein treated as final for those who choose to appear.
  • No further examination for Class X students; their assessment-scheme result will be final.

Regarding the ICSE, its counsel informed the Court that the Board would issue a “similar notification” cancelling remaining papers, adopt its own assessment methodology (to be published within one week), and may provide an option for students of both Classes X and XII to sit for the cancelled subjects later. The Court recorded these assurances and noted that all other stipulations in the CBSE draft were acceptable to ICSE “in principle.”

Given the consensus and the Boards’ undertakings, the Court concluded that all petitions across India concerning the 2019-2020 CBSE and ICSE examinations would be governed by this order and “deemed to be disposed of.” The Bench expressly limited the order’s scope to the examination-conduct issue and left unrelated questions open.

Holding and Implications

ORDER: All writ petitions, transfer petition and pending applications are DISPOSED OF in terms of the CBSE draft notification (approved by the Court) and the parallel assurances given by the ICSE.

Implications:

  • CBSE and ICSE examinations scheduled for 1 July – 15 July 2020 are officially cancelled.
  • Both Boards will declare results on the basis of their respective assessment schemes; CBSE must do so by 15 July 2020.
  • Optional future examinations for performance improvement are sanctioned (mandatory for CBSE Class XII and potentially for ICSE Classes X and XII).
  • All existing and future litigation on this specific examination issue is resolved by, and subject to, the present order; no broader legal precedent on other COVID-19 educational challenges is set.

    Amit Bathla And Others Petitioner(S) v. Central Board Of Secondary Education And Another (S).

    1. The core issue involved in these matters is about conducting examinations for classes X and XII of the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) and the Indian Certificate of Secondary Education (ICSE) respectively.

    2. As regards CBSE examinations, the CBSE has presented a draft notification for our consideration.

    3. After perusing the same and taking into account the suggestions given by the counsel appearing for the concerned parties, we see no difficulty in permitting the CBSE to issue the said notification forthwith. The draft notification reads thus:

    NOTIFICATION

    Keeping in view the requests received from various State Governments and the changed circumstances as on date, following has been decided:—

    1. Examinations for classes X and XII which were scheduled from 1 July to 15, 2020 stand cancelled.

    2. Assessment of the performance of students in the cancelled examinations will be done based on the assessment scheme as suggested by competent committee of the CBSE for declaration of result for both class-X and class-XII. The said scheme is mentioned in Para-7 below.

    3. Results based upon the aforesaid assessment scheme will be declared by 15 July, 2020 so that candidates can apply and seek admissions in Higher Education Institutions in India and abroad, based thereon.

    4. However, for Class-XII, CBSE will conduct an optional examination in the subjects whose examinations were scheduled to be conducted from 1 July to 15 July, 2020 as soon as conditions are conducive, as assessed and decided by the Central Government. Candidates whose results will be declared based on the assessment scheme will be allowed to appear in these optional examinations to improve their performance, if they wish so. However, the marks obtained by a candidate in these optional examinations will be treated as final for those who have opted to take these examinations.

    5. For candidates in Class X, no further examinations will be conducted and the result declared by CBSE on the basis of assessment scheme will be treated as final.

    6. For class-XII, the result declared by the CBSE under Sl. No. (2) above will be considered as final unless the students opt for Sl. No. (4) above.

    7. Assessment Scheme:—

    (a) For the students of both classes-X and XII, who have completed all their examinations, their results will be declared based on their performance in the examinations.

    (b) For students who have appeared in the examinations in more than 3 subjects, the average of the marks obtained in best three performing subjects will be awarded in the subjects whose examinations have not been conducted.

    (c) For students who have appeared in the examinations in only 3 subjects, the average of the marks obtained in the best two performing subjects will be awarded in the subjects whose examinations have not been conducted.

    (d) There are very few students of class-XII, mainly from Delhi, who have appeared in the examinations in only 1 or 2 subjects. Their results will be declared based on performance in the appeared subjects and performance in internal/practical project assessment. These students will also be allowed to appear in the optional examinations conducted by CBSE to improve their performance, if they desire to do so. Result of these students will also be declared along with other students.

    4. Resultantly, all these petitions pertaining to CBSE examinations pending in this Court or any other Court shall be deemed to be disposed of in terms of the proposed notification to be issued by the CBSE.

    5. Accordingly, if any other petition is pending in this Court or any other Court concerning the subject of conducting examinations for Classes X and XII by the CBSE scheduled from 1 July, 2020 to 15 July, 2020, the same will be governed by this order and the notification approved by this Court.

    6. As regards ICSE, the counsel appearing for the said Board, on instructions, stated that ISCE in principle would issue similar notification with additional aspects referred to in the affidavit filed by them. To wit, paragraph 6 of the affidavit reads thus:

    “6. In the light of the aforesaid, the Respondent has taken the following decisions with regard to the ICSE (Class 10) and ISC (Class 12) Year 2020 Examinations:

    i) The remaining papers in the ICSE and ISC Year 2020 Examinations as scheduled from 1 July to 14 July 2020 as per press release/notification dated 22.05.2020 shall stand cancelled.

    ii) Results of all the candidates for the remaining papers in the ICSE and ISC Year 2020 Examinations will be declared as per methodology decided and adopted by Respondent i.e. CISCE.

    iii) If the situation is deemed conducive, in the near future, CISCE may give an option to candidates to write any or all of the remaining papers of the ICSE/ISC Year 2020 Examinations at a later date whereby the marks so obtained by the candidate in that written examination(s) shall be considered as their final marks.”

    7. Two aspects have been highlighted during the hearing by the counsel for the ICSE, as follows:

    (i) ICSE may consider of conducting optional examination for Class X as well and abide by the same terms as regards the optional examination regarding Class XII referred to in the draft notification of CBSE, reproduced above.

    (ii) The Assessment Scheme of ICSE is different, which would be notified within one week from today on the website of the ICSE.

    8. Rest of the stipulations in the draft notification of CBSE, referred to above, are acceptable to ICSE in principle, which would be reflected in the proposed notification to be issued by the ICSE in that behalf.

    9. In terms of this order, all proceedings/petitions pertaining to the subject matter of conducting examinations for classes X and XII by ICSE for Academic Year 2019-2020 pending in this Court or any other Court shall be governed by this order and deemed to be disposed of accordingly.

    10. We make it clear that this order does not deal with any other issue which may arise for consideration in some other proceedings pending before the High court or this Court except the subject matter of conducting examinations for classes X and XII for Academic Year 2019-2020 by the CBSE and ICSE respectively.

    11. The writ petitions, transfer petition and pending applications shall stand disposed of in the above terms.

    SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

    RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS

    Writ Petition(s) (Civil) No(s). 566/2020

    Amit Bathla and Others … Petitioner(s)
    Versus
    Central Board of Secondary education and Another … Respondent(s)

    (FOR ADMISSION IA No. 54475/2020 - EXEMPTION FROM FILING AFFIDAVIT IA No. 54492/2020 - EXEMPTION FROM PAYING COURT FEE, IA No. 57064/2020 - INTERVENTION/IMPLEADMENT, IA No. 54473/2020 - STAY APPLICATION)

    W.P.(C) No. 584/2020 (X)

    IA No. 56068/2020 - EX-PARTE STAY

    IA No. 56070/2020 - EXEMPTION FROM FILING AFFIDAVIT)

    W.P.(C) No. 590/2020 (X)

    IA No. 56835/2020 - EXEMPTION FROM FILING AFFIDAVIT)

    W.P.(C) No. 596/2020 (PIL-W)

    IA No. 56973/2020 - EXEMPTION FROM FILING AFFIDAVIT)

    W.P.(C) No. 583/2020 (X)

    FOR ADMISSION and IA No. 56005/2020-EXEMPTION FROM FILING AFFIDAVIT

    Transfer Petition(s)(C) No(s).674/2020 (XVI-A)

    (FOR ADMISSION and IA No. 57356/2020-EX-PARTE STAY and IA No. 57357/2020-EXEMPTION FROM FILING AFFIDAVIT

    Date : 26-06-2020 These matters were called on for hearing today.

    (Before A.M. Khanwilkar, Dinesh Maheshwari and Sanjiv Khanna, JJ.)

    For Petitioner(s) Mr. Rishi Malhotra, AOR

    Mr. Ajay Bhargava, Adv.

    Ms. Vanita Bhargava, AOR

    Ms. Trishala Trivedi, Adv.

    Mr. Sandeep Jindal, AOR

    Mr. Siddharth, In-person

    Mr. Rajat Sabu, Adv.

    Mr. Mriganga Dutta, Adv.

    Mr. P.S. Sudheer, AOR

    Ms. Shruti Jose, Adv.

    Mr. Jaideep Gupta, Sr. Adv.

    Mr. Kunal Chatterji, AOR

    Mr. Shoumendu Mukherji, Adv.

    Ms. Maitrayee Banerjee, Adv.

    Mr. Pravar Veer Misra, Adv.

    Mr. Vageesh Sharma, Adv.

    For Respondent(s) Mr. Tushar Mehta, S.G.

    Mr. Rupesh Kumar, AOR

    Mr. Rajeev Sharma, Adv.

    Ms. Neelam Sharma, Adv.

    Ms. Pankhuri Shrivastava, Adv.

    Mr. Tushar Mehta, S.G.

    Mr. Gurmeet Singh Makker, AOR

    Mr. Kanu Agrawal, Adv.

    Mr. Rajat Nair, Adv.

    Mr. Rupesh Kumar, AOR

    Mr. Rajeev Sharma, Adv.

    Ms. Neelam Sharma, Adv.

    Ms. Pankhuri Shrivastava, Adv.

    Mr. Jaideep Gupta, Sr. Adv.

    Mr. Kunal Chatterji, AOR

    Mr. Shoumendu Mukherji, Adv.

    Ms. Maitrayee Banerjee, Adv.

    Mr. Pravar Veer Misra, Adv.

    Mr. Vageesh Sharma, Adv.

    Mr. Mathews J. Nedumpara, Adv.

    Ms. Manju Jetley, AOR

    Mr. Rahul G. Tanwani, Adv.

    Mr. Anantha Narayana M.G., AOR

    Mr. Yuvraj P. Narvankar, Adv.

    Mr. Anand Dilip Landge, AOR

    UPON hearing the counsel the Court made the following

    12. The writ petitions, transfer petition and pending applications are disposed of in terms of the signed order.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Amit Bathla And Others Petitioner(S) v. Central Board Of Secondary Education And Another (S).
    (Jun 26, 2020)