Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of CPC one Order 6 Rule 17 CPC and the other Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC
  • Order 7 Rule 14 and Order 6 Rule 17 read with 151 CPC.
  • Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC and Order 6 Rule 17 CPC
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Order 6 Rule 17 CPC cautions
  • Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC
  • Order 7 Rule 14 CPC
  • Order 6 Rule 17 CPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of CPC one Order 6 Rule 17 CPC and the other Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC
  • Order 7 Rule 14 and Order 6 Rule 17 read with 151 CPC.
  • Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC and Order 6 Rule 17 CPC
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Order 6 Rule 17 CPC cautions
  • Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC
  • Order 7 Rule 14 CPC
  • Order 6 Rule 17 CPC
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff filed a suit for permanent injunction claiming ownership and possession of a plot measuring 410 sq. yds., purchased from defendant No.2 through a registered sale deed dated 20-6-2008. The plaintiff alleged that defendant No.1 threatened to dispossess him, prompting the suit. The defendants filed a written statement denying the claims, and issues were framed on 30-3-2016. Subsequently, the plaintiff filed two applications: one on 21-9-2016 under Order 7 Rule 14 CPC to take certain documents on record, and another on 10-7-2017 under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC seeking amendment of the plaint. Both applications were opposed by the defendants and dismissed by the trial court on grounds of delay, lack of good cause, and procedural impropriety.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court erred in dismissing the plaintiff's application under Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC for taking additional documents on record after the plaint was filed.
  2. Whether the trial court properly exercised its discretion in rejecting the plaintiff's application for amendment of the plaint under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC after issues were framed.
  3. Whether a composite petition challenging two separate orders under different provisions of the CPC is maintainable under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The amendment sought was relevant to proving the plaintiff's case and should have been allowed in the interest of justice, especially since the suit was at the stage of plaintiff's evidence and no prejudice would be caused to the defendants.
  • The trial court was unduly influenced by the proviso to Order 6 Rule 17 CPC and failed to exercise its jurisdiction fairly for just adjudication.
  • Regarding the application under Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC, the plaintiff relied on the Supreme Court judgment in Chakreshwari Construction Private Limited Vs. Manohar Lal (2017) 5 SCC 212, asserting that the trial court has discretion to allow subsequent filing of documents.
  • The two documents sought to be admitted (sale deeds dated 5-9-1990 and 1-7-1997) were relevant to the issues before the trial court.
  • The trial court's refusal to exercise discretion was mechanical and contrary to justice; any delay could have been compensated by costs.

Defendants' Arguments

  • The defendants supported the trial court's order dismissing the applications and prayed for dismissal of the petition.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chakreshwari Construction Private Limited Vs. Manohar Lal, (2017) 5 SCC 212 Discretion of trial court under Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC to allow subsequent filing of documents in support of the plaint. The court acknowledged the precedent but found that the trial court rightly exercised its discretion to refuse leave due to lack of good cause and delay.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reasoned that the composite petition challenging two separate orders under distinct provisions of the CPC was not maintainable, as each dismissal constituted a separate cause of action. The trial court's orders were based on objective consideration of the record and statutory provisions. The proviso to Order 6 Rule 17 CPC aims to expedite civil dispute adjudication and prevent misuse of amendment rights to delay trials or harass opponents. The amendment sought was filed several months after issues were framed and related to facts already within the plaintiff's knowledge at suit inception. It was also not necessary for resolving the real controversy. Similarly, the plaintiff failed to provide good and reasonable grounds for belated filing of documents under Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC, which is an exception to the rule requiring documents to be filed with the plaint. The trial court correctly exercised discretion to deny leave, considering the documents could have been filed earlier and their relevance to the issues. The court found no illegality or perversity warranting interference under Article 227 of the Constitution.

Holding and Implications

The court DISMISSED the petition challenging the trial court's dismissal of the plaintiff's applications under Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC and Order 6 Rule 17 CPC.

The direct effect is the upholding of the trial court's discretion to refuse belated filing of documents and amendments to the plaint post framing of issues. No new precedent was established, and the decision reinforces the principle that amendments and additional documents must be timely and justified to prevent delay and harassment in civil proceedings.

    Haji Amin Siroha v. Dungarmal

    Alok Sharma, J. - The petitioner-plaintiff (hereafter ''''''''the plaintiff'''''''') is aggrieved of the order dated 14-2-2018 passed by Civil Judge Jhunjhunu in Suit No.14/2011 dismissing his applications under Order 7 Rule 14 and Order 6 Rule 17 read with 151 CPC.

    2. The facts of the case are that the plaintiff filed a suit for permanent injunction against the respondents-defendants (hereafter ''''''''the defendants'''''''') with the averment that he was owner of a plot admeasuring 410 sq. yds. being the suit property after having purchased the same from the defendant No.2 Vinod Kumar on 20- 6-2008 through registered sale deed on a consideration of Rs. 1,47,000/-. The plaintiff claimed possession of the plot in issue. It was stated that construction over the plot have been thereafter made.

    3. The defendant No.1 Dungarmal threatened to dispossess him. That cause of action entailed filing of the suit. The defendants filed a written statement of denial on summons served and issues were framed on 30-3-2016.

    4. On 21-9-2016 the plaintiff filed an application under Order 7 Rule 14 CPC for taking on record certain documents purportedly to prove his case laid in the suit. He also filed another application on 10-7-2017 under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC for amendment of the plaint stating that the amendment sought would not change the nature of the suit. Both the applications were opposed by the defendants.

    5. The trial court considering the submissions of both the plaintiff and the defendant held that there was no good cause for belatedly seeking to bring on record the document which were not even referred to in the plaint. It held that issues having been framed and no proper explanation for the delay in filing the document under Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC being proferred by the plaintiff there was no good ground for exercising the court''''''''s discretion. In fact the trial court concluded that as the application had been filed to delay the trial in the suit, it was dismissed with costs of Rs. 200/-.

    6. The plaintiff''''''''s application for amendment of his plaint was also dismissed by the trial court on the ground that issues in the suit were framed on 30-3-2016 and only thereafter the application in issue was filed on 10-7-2017 without disclosing the date or the incident by which the new facts, sought to be amended, came to the knowledge of the plaintiff and whether such facts were not in the plaintiff''''''''s knowledge when the suit was filed.

    7. Counsel for the plaintiff submitted that the amendment sought to be brought on record were relevant to the plaintiff proving his case and the application ought to have been allowed in the interest of justice as the suit was only at the stage of plaintiff''''''''s evidence and no prejudice could be caused to the defendant. Counsel submitted that the trial court was overtly influenced by the proviso to Order 6 Rule 17 CPC without regard to the justice of the case. That was the trial court''''''''s failure to exercise its jurisdiction in the interest of a fair and just adjudication of the dispute before it.

    8. On the issue of rejection of the plaintiff''''''''s application under Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC counsel relied on the judgment in the case of Chakreshwari Construction Private Limited Vs. Manohar Lal, (2017) 5 SCC 212 and submitted that the trial court has the discretion to allow subsequent filing of documents in support of the plaint by resort to Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC. Counsel submitted that the two documents in issue in the application under Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC i.e. sale-deed dated 5-9-1990 by Panchayat Malsisar in favour Jagpal Singh son of Lakhu Singh and the sale deed dated 1- 7-1997 by Niranjan in favour of Dungarmal were relevant to the issues before the trial court. Yet the trial court again failed to reasonably exercise its discretion and allow the application. The defendants could have been compensated for the delay/ inconvenience to be caused by costs. Counsel submitted that the mechanical refusal to exercise the discretion by the trial court is not in consonance with the justice and hence warrants correction by the court in the exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction.

    9. Mr. Brij Bhushan Ojha, counsel for defendants supported the impugned order passed by the trial court and prayed for dismissal of the petition.

    10. Heard. Considered.

    11. I am of the considered view that a composite petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India challenging two orders on two wholly separate and distinct provisions of CPC one Order 6 Rule 17 CPC and the other Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC is not maintainable. Each of the application''''''''s dismissal constituted a separate cause of action. The petition is therefore liable to be dismissed on this ground alone. Besides, even otherwise, the order of the trial court both on the application under Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC and Order 6 Rule 17 CPC passed in its discretion is well considered and founded on objective consideration of the material on record and extant statutory provisions. The proviso to Order 6 Rule 17 CPC cautions against amendment of pleadings subsequent to framing of issues.

    12. There is a public purpose thereto i.e. expedited adjudication of civil disputes and at the same time exclusion of mischief, by a litigating party, of delaying trial and corresponding harassment to the opposite party. In the instant case the amendment to the plaint was sought several months after the issues were framed on 30-3-2016. Further the amendment sought related to facts which were well within the plaintiff''''''''s knowledge when the suit was filed. Even otherwise the amendment sought was not necessary for determining the real questions in controversy raised in the plaint as the trial court has recorded and counsel for the plaintiff has failed to otherwise establish. Similarly the plaintiff did not set out any good and reasonable ground for the trial court to exercise its discretion in allowing belated filing of documents in support of his plaint which the plaintiff did not even aver in his pleadings. Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC is an exception to the rule of procedure that the plaintiff file documents in support of his case at the outset along with the plaint itself. The exception under Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC can be invoked only with the leave of the trial court. That leave of the court is discretionary. Facts on which the leave of the court is sought under Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC are therefore relevant. Where the trial court finds that the documents in issue could have been earlier filed for reason of being in the knowledge of the plaintiff, or with due diligence could have been in his knowledge or delay in seeking to bring documents on record was unexplained or the documents in issue were irrelevant to the issue/s for adjudication before the court, it can refuse to exercise its discretion and deny leave to take such documents on record. That is what the trial court has done in dismissing the plaintiff''''''''s application under Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC.

    13. In the over all facts of the case, I find no illegality and perversity in the impugned order passed by the trial court to warrant interference therewith under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.

    14. I find no force in the petition. Dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Haji Amin Siroha v. Dungarmal
    (Aug 10, 2018)