Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts

    M.P. Chothy v. Adv K N Anilkumar

    K.Abraham Mathew, J—Petitioner is a retired Class-I officer. He belongs to a Scheduled Caste. After his retirement he was enrolled as an advocate on the role of the Bar Council of Kerala. On 3.9.2012 he submitted an application to the Bar Association at Perumbavoor for membership. Respondents 1 to 8 were the office bearers of the association. After a few days, he knew that he would not be admitted as a member of the association. But he did not know the reason for it. In the order passed by the Disciplinary Committee of the Bar Council of Kerala which was initiated at the instance of a neighbour of the petitioner it was observed: "Another important fact to be considered is the Perumbavoor Bar Association not to admit him as a member of the association. This shows that Bar Association is also aware of the peculiar nature and character of the petitioner." The petitioner filed a complaint before the JFCM Court-I, Perumbavoor alleging that the refusal of the Bar Association, Perumbavoor to admit him as a member of the association amounted to the offene under Section 4(iii) of the Protection of Civil Rights Act. In the complaint, it is further alleged that respondents 1 to 8 compelled one Advocate K.M.Alias to relinquish the vakkalat of the petitioner, who was a party to an original suit. The petitioner alleges that this amounted to an offence under Section 6 r/w Section 10 of the Protection of Civil Rights Act. By the impugned order, the learned Magistrate dismissed the complaint. Its correctness is challenged.

    2. Heard the petitioner, who has appeared in person.

    3. In the observation made by the Disciplinary Committee of the Bar Council of Kerala which is quoted above the reason for the Bar Association''''''''s refusal to admit the petitioner as a member is not at all disclosed. There is no whisper that the Bar Association expressed any opinion about the character of the petitioner. It is the view of the Bar Council of Kerala that the Bar Association was aware of the ''''''''peculiar nature and character of the petitioner''''''''.

    4. It may be taken for granted that the Bar Association rejected the application of the petitioner on the ground of the ''''''''peculiar nature and character of the petitioner''''''''. The question is whether that would attract Section 4(iii) of the Protection of Civil Rights Act. The Section runs thus:

    ''''''''Whoever on the ground of "untouchability" enforces against any person any disability with regard to the practice of any profession or the carrying on any occupation, trade or business or employment in any job.''''''''

    The petitioner has no case that it is on the ground of ''''''''untouchability'''''''' the Bar Association refused to admit him as a member. But, on the other hand, his case is that it is because of the alleged ''''''''peculiar nature and character of the petitioner'''''''' the request was refused. I have no doubt that Section 4(iii) of the Protection of Civil Rights Act is not attracted by the allegations in the complaint. That apart, it is also doubtful whether the refusal of the Bar Association to give him membership amounts to enforcement of any disability with regard to the practice of profession of advocate.

    5. The next question is whether respondents 1 to 8 compelled Advocate K.M.Alias to relinquish the vakalat of the petitioner in a civil suit by which the petitioner was a party. There is no evidence to in support of the allegation. Advocate K.M.Alias was not examined as a witness in the enquiry under Section 202 Cr.P.C. Moreover, it is doubtful whether Section 6 of the Protection of Civil Rights Act is attracted. The Section provides:

    ''''''''Whoever on the ground of "untouchability" refuses to sell any goods or refuses to render any service to any person at the same time and place and on the same terms and conditions at or which such goods are sold or services are rendered to other persons in the ordinary course of business.''''''''

    6. The petitioner filed application for membership of the Bar Association on 3.9.2012. Admittedly, within a few days he knew that his request was turned down. On 13.6.2015 he knew that the Disciplinary Committee of the Bar Council of Kerala made the observation with regard to his ''''''''nature and character''''''''. In spite of all these he did not file a complaint even within a reasonable time. The complaint was filed only on 8.11.2016.

    7. For the reasons stated above, I hold that the learned Magistrate was fully justified in dismissing the complaint. No interference is called for.

    In the result, this Crl. Revision Petition is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M.P. Chothy v. Adv K N Anilkumar
    (Jun 12, 2018)