AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2020 INSC 295
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2020 INSC 295
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Anil Padegaonkar was employed as an Aviation Officer (Job Group “A”) at the General Aviation Service Station, Air Force Station, Gwalior, operated by Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd. (BPCL). Two departmental charge-sheets were served on him:

  • 31 December 1993: Issued by the Deputy General Manager (Aviation) alleging negligence after fresh sand particles were found in all ten fuel tanks post his “C” shift.
  • 27 September 1994: Alleging unauthorised absence from duty on 13 August 1994.

After a domestic enquiry, the Enquiry Officer found him guilty. On 21 May 1997 the Director (Marketing) passed a common order ‘discharging’ him from service under Part III-B (2)(e) of the BPCL Conduct, Discipline and Appeal Rules, 1976; a departmental appeal was rejected on 5 October 1998.

The employee challenged the discharge in a writ petition. A Single Judge of the High Court held (i) the first charge-sheet was invalid because it was not issued by the Functional Director (assumed to be the disciplinary authority for “dismissal”), and (ii) the punishment for the second charge was disproportionate. Reinstatement was granted with liberty to BPCL to issue a fresh charge-sheet and withhold back wages pending the result. A writ appeal filed by BPCL resulted in a common order substantially affirming the Single Judge, prompting both sides to appeal to the Supreme Court. In the meantime, the employee reached superannuation in February 2018.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Deputy General Manager (Functional General Manager) was a competent disciplinary authority to issue the first charge-sheet when the eventual penalty imposed was “discharge” (not “dismissal”).
  2. Whether the High Court erred in treating the penalty as “dismissal”, thereby quashing the first charge-sheet and the consequential order of discharge.
  3. Whether the employee was entitled to reinstatement with back wages and whether BPCL could be permitted to issue a fresh charge-sheet after his superannuation.

Arguments of the Parties

Corporation's Arguments

  • The impugned order was one of discharge, not dismissal; therefore the Deputy General Manager, as Functional General Manager and head of the establishment, was competent under the Delegation of Authority Manual (15-12-1987) and Schedule I of the Rules to issue the charge-sheet.
  • The Delegation of Authority Manual was never withdrawn, notwithstanding the 1991 amendment to Rule 3(g); “competent authority” under Rule 3(h) includes the DGM.
  • The employee never objected to the DGM’s competence during the enquiry or departmental appeal; per H.V. Nirmala v. KSFC, jurisdictional objections must be raised at the first opportunity.
  • There was no procedural irregularity and no prejudice to the employee; proportionality of punishment depends on case-specific facts (S.R. Tewari v. Union of India).
  • Continuation of proceedings after superannuation is impracticable because the Rules contain no such provision.

Employee's Arguments

  • The Corporation itself treated the misconduct as “very serious” and followed the procedure for a major penalty; therefore the order amounts to dismissal, which could only be initiated by the Functional Director under Schedule I.
  • After the 1991 amendment, the 1987 Delegation of Authority Manual lost relevance; hence the DGM lacked jurisdiction. A charge-sheet issued without authority renders proceedings non-est (Union of India v. B.V. Gopinath).
  • Once the proceedings are vitiated, reinstatement with full back wages is the norm (Coal India Ltd. v. Ananta Saha).
  • The dismissal for leaving duty one hour early was grossly disproportionate (Dev Singh v. Punjab Tourism Development Corporation Ltd.).
  • The High Court therefore correctly quashed the discharge and should not have allowed fresh proceedings or denied back wages.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
H.V. Nirmala v. Karnataka State Financial Corporation, (2008) 7 SCC 639 Jurisdictional objections must be raised at the earliest opportunity. Cited in BPCL’s argument; the judgment does not record an independent analysis of this precedent.
S.R. Tewari v. Union of India, (2013) 6 SCC 602 No fixed yardstick for proportionality of punishment; depends on facts. Cited in BPCL’s argument; not expressly analysed in the Court’s reasoning.
Union of India v. B.V. Gopinath, (2014) 1 SCC 351 Charge-sheet issued without authority renders proceedings void. Cited in employee’s argument; Court distinguished the factual premise and found the charge-sheet valid.
Chairman-cum-Managing Director, Coal India Ltd. v. Ananta Saha, (2011) 5 SCC 142 When disciplinary proceedings are vitiated, back wages normally follow reinstatement. Cited in employee’s argument on back wages; the Court held the proceedings were not vitiated, so the precedent was inapplicable.
Dev Singh v. Punjab Tourism Development Corporation Ltd., (2003) 8 SCC 9 Punishment must be proportionate to misconduct. Cited in employee’s argument; the Court found the discharge proportionate and did not apply the precedent.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court emphasised that:

  1. The impugned penalty was expressly labelled “discharge” under Part III-B (2)(e), distinct from “dismissal” under Part III-B (2)(f); the Rules themselves recognise the two as separate major penalties with different consequences.
  2. Under Schedule I read with Rule 3(e), (g) and (h), the Functional General Manager (here, the Deputy General Manager) is the disciplinary authority for all major penalties except dismissal. The Delegation of Authority Manual dated 15-12-1987, never withdrawn or superseded, confirmed this competence.
  3. Part III-F(23) uses “Disciplinary Authority or Competent Authority” interchangeably, reinforcing that the DGM’s authority flows from both the Schedule and the delegated powers.
  4. The employee did not question the DGM’s competence during the enquiry or departmental appeal. Nonetheless, treating the objection as one of jurisdiction, the Court independently verified and upheld the DGM’s authority.
  5. The High Court mis-directed itself by assuming the penalty amounted to dismissal and, on that mistaken premise, required the charge-sheet to emanate from the Functional Director. Once it is accepted that the penalty was discharge, the charge-sheet stood on firm legal footing.
  6. Because the first charge-sheet was valid, and both charges were proved after a fair enquiry, the order of discharge required no interference. Consequently, the High Court’s directions granting reinstatement, liberty to issue a fresh charge-sheet, and postponement of back-wage consideration were unsustainable.
  7. Given the employee’s superannuation (February 2018) and the legality of the original discharge, the Court found further proceedings or reliefs academic.

Holding and Implications

The appeal filed by BPCL is ALLOWED, and the cross-appeal filed by the employee is DISMISSED. The Supreme Court restores the original order of discharge dated 21 May 1997 and sets aside all contrary directions issued by the High Court, including reinstatement, liberty to issue a fresh charge-sheet, and any consequential reliefs. No costs are awarded.

Implications are confined to the parties: the employee remains discharged without back wages or reinstatement, and BPCL faces no obligation to recommence disciplinary proceedings. The judgment turns on interpretation of the corporation’s internal rules and does not announce a new legal principle of general application.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited And Others (S) v. Anil Padegaonkar (S).

    REPORTABLE

    IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

    CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

    CIVIL APPEAL NO(s). 9778 OF 2010

    BHARAT PETROLEUM CORPORATION

    LIMITED AND OTHERS ...APPELLANT(S)

    VERSUS

    ANIL PADEGAONKAR ...RESPONDENT(S)

    WITH

    CIVIL APPEAL NO(s). 9779 OF 2010

    ANIL PADEGAONKAR ...APPELLANT(S)

    VERSUS

    BHARAT PETROLEUM CORPORATION

    LIMITED AND OTHERS ...RESPONDENT(S)

    JUDGMENT

    NAVIN SINHA, J.

    The two appeals have been preferred by the appellant- Corporation and the respondent-employee respectively, to the extent that they are aggrieved by the common order in a writ appeal preferred by the Corporation. They have thus been heard together and are being disposed by a common order.

    1

    2. The Corporation is aggrieved to the extent the impugned order sets aside the order of punishment on the ground that the charge-sheet had not been issued by the disciplinary authority. The employee is aggrieved by the grant of liberty to the Corporation for issuance of fresh charge-sheet, and denial of back wages while granting reinstatement. In the interregnum, the employee has attained the age of superannuation in February

    2018.

    3. A charge-sheet was issued to the employee on 31.12.1993 by the Deputy General Manager (Aviation) (hereinafter referred to as "the DGM") while he was working on the post of Aviation Officer at the General Aviation Service Station, Gwalior, in the management cadre in Job Group "A". It was alleged that fresh sand particles had been found in the all 10 fuel tanks after his duty hours in the 'C' shift ended while the earlier inspection during the 'B' shift had found it to be free of dirt and water except for minor traces of water in tank nos. 3 and 9. While the departmental proceedings were pending, a fresh charge-sheet

    2

    was issued to the employee on 27.09.1994 with regard to absence from duty on 13.08.1994. The employee was therefore charged with having acted in a manner prejudicial to the interests of the Corporation and negligence in the performance of duty including malingering or slowing down of work under Clause 6 & 10 of Part III-A of the Bharat Petroleum Limited Conduct, Discipline and Appeal Rules for Management Staff, 1976 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Rules'). Pursuant to a domestic inquiry, the inquiry officer returned a finding of guilt on 06.01.1995. The employee was furnished a copy of the report and after consideration of his reply, the Director (Marketing) under Part III-B (2)(f) of the Rules by a common order dated 21.05.1997 'discharged' the employee from service. The departmental appeal under the Rules was rejected by a reasoned order by the Chairman on 05.10.1998.

    4. The employee assailed the orders in a writ petition. The learned Single Judge, with regard to the first charge-sheet, held that the punishment of 'dismissal' stood vitiated because the Functional Director alone was competent to issue the charge- sheet. The second charge-sheet though issued by the disciplinary

    3

    authority, required reconsideration as the punishment was held disproportionate to the charge, necessitating an order of remand. The Corporation was granted liberty in appeal to issue a fresh charge-sheet with regard to the first charge and to pass a lesser order of punishment with regard to the second charge. Though reinstatement was ordered, the question of back wages was left for consideration subject to the outcome of such fresh proceedings.

    5. Shri. J.P. Cama, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the Corporation, submitted that the employee was not 'dismissed' but 'discharged' from service. The DGM being the functional General Manager and Head of the Department, the highest officer on the spot, was fully competent under the manual for delegation of authority dated 15.12.1987 to issue charge-sheet for a punishment lesser than dismissal under serial 1(a) of Schedule I under Part III of the Rules. The manual for delegation of authority had never been withdrawn or superseded even after amendment of Rule 3(g) on 22.08.1991 with regard to the definition of Disciplinary Authority in the Rule. The

    4

    misconduct on the part of employee, considering his place of posting at an air force station was serious in nature. There was no infirmity in the conduct of the departmental proceedings. The employee had since reached the age of superannuation in February, 2018. Continuance of the proceedings under the Rules was an impossibility in absence of any provisions for the same.

    6. The employee did not take any objection in his reply to the charge-sheet or in the memo of appeal that the DGM was not competent to issue the same. Relying on H.V. Nirmala vs. Karnataka State Financial Corporation, (2008) 7 SCC 639, it was submitted that the objection with regard to the lack of jurisdiction ought to have been raised at the very first instance. The employee took this objection for the first time before the High Court in the writ petition. In any event the employee has failed to demonstrate any prejudice to him thereby, assuming though not admitting any lapse. Reliance was also placed on S.R. Tewari vs. Union of India and Another, (2013) 6 SCC 602, that there could be no standardised yardstick with regard to proportionality of punishment which would depend on the facts of each case.

    5

    7. Shri Puneet Jain, learned counsel for the employee, submitted that dismissal was a major punishment under Part III- B (2)(f) of the Rules. The Corporation themselves opined that the charges were very serious. The procedure followed was that for a major penalty. The mere use of the word 'discharge' in the order of punishment therefore could not be determinative. The High Court has committed no error in holding that the employee had been dismissed from service pursuant to a charge-sheet issued without jurisdiction. The view taken by the High Court that after amendment of the term disciplinary authority in Rule 3(g) by the Board of Directors on 22.08.1991, the manual for delegation of authorities dated 15.12.1987 had lost its relevance, does not call for any interference. The Functional Director alone was competent to issue charge-sheet for dismissal under Sr.1(b) of Schedule I under Part III of the Rules. The charge-sheet issued by the DGM has rightly been held to be without authority, thus vitiating the punishment. The Rules make a distinction between the disciplinary authority in Rule 3(g) and competent authority in Rule 3(h). Competent authority cannot be equated with

    6

    disciplinary authority. Reliance was placed on Union of India vs. B.V. Gopinath, (2014) 1 SCC 351, to submit that a charge- sheet not issued according to law rendered the entire proceedings non-est. The High Court, in the facts of the case ought not to have given liberty to issue fresh charge-sheet or deny back wages while directing reinstatement.

    8. The entire proceedings having been vitiated back wages ought to have been granted while directing reinstatement relying on Chairmen-cum-Managing Director, Coal India Limited and Others vs. Ananta Saha and Others, (2011) 5 SCC 142. With regard to the second charge-sheet, it was submitted that the punishment of dismissal for absence from place of duty one hour before duty hours got over was grossly disproportionate relying on Dev Singh vs. Punjab Tourism Development Corporation Limited and Another, (2003) 8 SCC 9.

    9. We have considered the submissions on behalf of the parties. The employee was posted at the Air Force Station

    7

    Gwalior. There can be no two opinions that the nature of his duties had an inherent seriousness. Two charge-sheets were issued to him and departmental proceedings were conducted. The employee was given full opportunity of defence. A finding of guilt was arrived at by the enquiry officer with regard to both the charges. The employee in his departmental appeal raised no issues of procedural irregularity with consequent prejudice. A common order of punishment of 'discharge' from service dated 21.05.1997 followed under Part III B (2)(e) of the Rules. No order of 'dismissal' was passed under Part III-B (2)(f) of the Rules. If the Corporation was of the opinion that 'dismissal' was the appropriate punishment in the facts of the case nothing prevented it from stating so. The High Court fell in a serious error by opining that the employee had been 'dismissed' from service and on that premise arrived at the conclusion that the charge- sheet was incompetent in absence of it having been issued by the Functional Director who was the disciplinary authority under Sr. 1 (b) of Schedule I under Part III of the Rules for dismissal.

    8

    10. Part-III B (2) of the Rules provides for major penalties which includes inter alia removal from service which shall not be a disqualification for future employment and dismissal from service which shall ordinarily be a disqualification from future employment. The Rules therefore themselves recognise them as different punishments with varying severity. Though the word 'discharge' does not find reference under the Rules, nonetheless in service jurisprudence, removal and/or discharge are synonymous leading to a termination or end of service but without the punitive consequences of dismissal entailing loss of past services, affecting future employment and debarring retiral benefits. There is no dispute that consequent to the impugned order of 'discharge', the employee has been paid his dues.

    11. The employee either in his reply to the charges or in the departmental appeal rightly raised no issues with regard to lack of competence in the DGM to issue the charge-sheet. Sr. 1 (a) of Schedule I, to be read with Part III of the Rules, provides that with regard to Job Group 'A' the Functional General Manager was the disciplinary authority for all other penalties except that of

    9

    dismissal. The Functional Director was the disciplinary authority for punishment of dismissal only. The employee for the first time raised the issue in the writ petition that the charge-sheet had been issued by other than the disciplinary authority. If the employee had raised the issue either in his reply to the memo of charges or in appeal perhaps the Corporation could have addressed the issue better. Nonetheless, since a fundamental issue of jurisdiction has been raised, we shall proceed to examine the issue.

    12. Rule 3(e) defines a Functional Manager as the Manager in- charge of a function. Rule 3(g) defines Disciplinary Authority as specified in Schedule I competent to impose penalties under the Rules. Competent Authority has been defined in Rule 3(h) to mean any authority empowered by the Board of Directors or the Chairman by any general or special rule or order to discharge the function or use the powers specified in the rule or order. Under Schedule I, the Functional General Manager was the disciplinary authority for punishment lesser than dismissal and the Functional director was the disciplinary authority for punishment

    10

    of dismissal. We are of the considered opinion that the term Competent Authority will include a disciplinary authority so authorised in the manner prescribed in 3(h) under the delegation of authority manual dated 15.12.1987. Under Part III-F(1) of the Rules dealing with procedure for imposing major penalties, the disciplinary authority has been described to include an authority as specified in Schedule I. It includes both a Functional manager and Functional Director. Part-III-F(23) provides as follows:

    "(23) If the Disciplinary Authority or the Competent Authority having regard to its findings on all or any of the charges is of the opinion that any of the penalties specified in Rule "B" should be imposed on the Management Staff it shall, notwithstanding anything contained in Rule "G", make an order imposing such penalty"

    13. The fact that the words 'Disciplinary Authority or Competent Authority' have been used interchangeably in Part III- F leaves no doubt in our mind that the delegation of authority manual had never been recalled or superseded. It is the specific case of the Corporation that the manual for delegation of authority issued on 15.12.1987 had never been withdrawn and

    11

    the Corporation had all along in all other cases also acted on basis of the same and that no charge-sheet for a punishment lesser than dismissal had ever been issued by the Functional Director. The DGM was therefore fully competent under the manual also to both suspend and issue charge-sheet. The High Court itself reasoned that had the penalty been other than dismissal, the Functional Manager would have been competent to issue the charge-sheet. The High Court having posed unto itself the wrong question of dismissal from service, naturally arrived at an erroneous conclusion.

    14. In view of our conclusion that the first charge-sheet had been issued by an authority competent to do so, the order of discharge calls for no interference. The direction for issuance of fresh charge-sheet is therefore held to be unsustainable and is set aside. The direction for reinstatement and grant of back wages including any proportionality of punishment under the second charge therefore becomes academic and needs no consideration.

    12

    15. The appeal preferred by the appellant-Corporation is allowed and that preferred by the respondent-employee is dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.

    …………...................J.

    [ASHOK BHUSHAN]

    …………...................J.

    [NAVIN SINHA]

    NEW DELHI

    MARCH 17, 2020

    13

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited And Others (S) v. Anil Padegaonkar (S).
    (Mar 17, 2020)