Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2020 INSC 177
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Articles 129 and 142 of the Constitution of India
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2020 INSC 177
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Articles 129 and 142 of the Constitution of India
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The matter before the Supreme Court arose on contempt petitions alleging non-compliance with the directions issued by a Constitution Bench in Public Interest Foundation v. Union of India (2019) 3 SCC 224. That earlier judgment had mandated disclosure of criminal antecedents of electoral candidates. The present Bench, upon examining documents and hearing counsel, noted a continued and significant rise in the number of Members of Parliament with pending criminal cases—24% in 2004, 30% in 2009, 34% in 2014, and 43% in 2019—and an absence of explanation from political parties for fielding such candidates. Acting under Articles 129 and 142 of the Constitution, the Court proceeded to issue further directions intended to secure compliance with its previous orders.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether political parties have complied with the disclosure obligations concerning candidates’ criminal cases as mandated in Public Interest Foundation v. Union of India.
  2. What further measures are necessary to enforce the Court’s earlier directions and curb the increasing criminalisation of politics.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Public Interest Foundation v. Union of India (2019) 3 SCC 224 Mandatory disclosure by candidates and political parties of pending criminal cases and wide publicity of such information. The Court found disregard of these directions and, invoking its contempt jurisdiction, reinforced and expanded the disclosure obligations.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by acknowledging its prior recognition of “the increasing criminalisation of politics” and the corresponding “information gap” faced by voters. Noting empirical data from the last four general elections showing a steady rise in MPs with pending criminal cases, the Bench concluded that earlier directions had not been adequately implemented. It observed that political parties offered no substantive justification for nominating individuals with criminal antecedents.

To address continued non-compliance, the Court exercised powers under Articles 129 and 142 of the Constitution and laid down a series of mandatory steps:

  • Political parties must upload, on their websites, detailed particulars of each selected candidate’s pending criminal cases and specifically state the reasons for the candidate’s selection, referencing qualifications, achievements and merit rather than mere electoral “winnability” (Direction 4.1 & 4.2).
  • The same information must be published in at least one local vernacular newspaper, one national newspaper, and on the party’s official social-media platforms (Direction 4.3).
  • Publication must occur within 48 hours of selection or at least two weeks prior to the first nomination-filing date, whichever is earlier (Direction 4.4).
  • A compliance report must be filed with the Election Commission within 72 hours of candidate selection (Direction 4.5).
  • The Election Commission is required to inform the Supreme Court of any non-compliance so that contempt proceedings can ensue (Direction 4.6).

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF WITH DIRECTIONS.

The contempt petitions were disposed of after issuing the above mandatory directions designed to ensure fuller disclosure of criminal cases involving electoral candidates and to hold political parties accountable for non-compliance through potential contempt proceedings. The decision directly affects all political parties by imposing stringent timelines and reporting duties but does not establish a new legal precedent beyond reinforcing and elaborating upon the existing obligations set out in Public Interest Foundation.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Rambabu Singh Thakur v. Sunil Arora And Others

    Rohinton Fali Nariman, J.— This contempt petition raises grave issues regarding the criminalisation of politics in India and brings to our attention a disregard of the directions of a Constitution Bench of this Court in Public Interest Foundation v. Union of India (2019) 3 SCC 224.

    2. In this judgment, this Court was cognizant of the increasing criminalisation of politics in India and the lack of information about such criminalisation amongst the citizenry. In order to remedy this information gap, this Court issued the following directions: (Public Interest Foundation case (2019) 3 SCC 224)

    “116. Keeping the aforesaid in view, we think it appropriate to issue the following directions which are in accord with the decisions of this Court:
    116.1. Each contesting candidate shall fill up the form as provided by the Election Commission and the form must contain all the particulars as required therein.
    116.2. It shall state, in bold letters, with regard to the criminal cases pending against the candidate.
    116.3. If a candidate is contesting an election on the ticket of a particular party, he/she is required to inform the party about the criminal cases pending against him/her.
    116.4. The political party concerned shall be obligated to put up on its website the aforesaid information pertaining to candidates having criminal antecedents.
    116.5. The candidate as well as the political party concerned shall issue a declaration in the widely circulated newspapers in the locality about the antecedents of the candidate and also give wide publicity in the electronic media. When we say wide publicity, we mean that the same shall be done at least thrice after filing of the nomination papers.”

    3. On a perusal of the documents placed on record and after submissions of counsel, it appears that over the last four General Elections, there has been an alarming increase in the incidence of criminals in politics. In 2004, 24% of the Members of Parliament had criminal cases pending against them; in 2009, that went up to 30%; in 2014 to 34%; and in 2019 as many as 43% of MPs had criminal cases pending against them.

    4. We have also noted that the political parties offer no explanation as to why candidates with pending criminal cases are selected as candidates in the first place. We therefore issue the following directions in exercise of our constitutional powers under Articles 129 and 142 of the Constitution of India:

    4.1. It shall be mandatory for political parties [at the Central and State election level] to upload on their website detailed information regarding individuals with pending criminal cases (including the nature of the offences, and relevant particulars such as whether charges have been framed, the court concerned, the case number, etc.) who have been selected as candidates, along with the reasons for such selection, as also as to why other individuals without criminal antecedents could not be selected as candidates.

    4.2. The reasons as to selection shall be with reference to the qualifications, achievements and merit of the candidate concerned, and not mere “winnability” at the polls.

    4.3. This information shall also be published in:

    (a) One local vernacular newspaper and one national newspaper;
    (b) On the official social media platforms of the political party, including Facebook & Twitter.

    4.4. These details shall be published within 48 hours of the selection of the candidate or not less than two weeks before the first date for filing of nominations, whichever is earlier.

    4.5. The political party concerned shall then submit a report of compliance with these directions with the Election Commission within 72 hours of the selection of the said candidate.

    4.6. If a political party fails to submit such compliance report with the Election Commission, the Election Commission shall bring such non-compliance by the political party concerned to the notice of the Supreme Court as being in contempt of this Court's orders/directions.

    5. With these directions, these contempt petitions are accordingly disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rambabu Singh Thakur v. Sunil Arora And Others
    (Feb 13, 2020)