AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2019 INSC 1371
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order XLI Rule 17(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC for short).
  • itself.8. Order 41 Rule 17(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 17 of Order 41 of CPC.
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 17 of Order 41 CPC
  • Rule 17(1) of Order XLI of the CPC.12.
  • CPC (Amendment) Act 104 of 1976,
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 17
  • Order 41 Rule 17(1)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2019 INSC 1371
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order XLI Rule 17(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC for short).
  • itself.8. Order 41 Rule 17(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 17 of Order 41 of CPC.
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 17 of Order 41 CPC
  • Rule 17(1) of Order XLI of the CPC.12.
  • CPC (Amendment) Act 104 of 1976,
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 17
  • Order 41 Rule 17(1)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondents (plaintiffs) instituted Title Suit No. 10 of 2000 before the Civil Judge (Junior Division), Khowai, seeking (i) declaration of title, (ii) recovery of possession, and (iii) mesne profits. The Trial Court dismissed the suit on 19 August 2002.

On appeal (Appeal No. 2 of 2003), the Additional District Judge, West Tripura, Khowai, allowed the plaintiffs’ appeal on 30 June 2006, set aside the Trial Court’s decree, declared the plaintiffs owners of the suit land, and awarded them recovery of possession.

The defendants (appellants) filed Second Appeal No. 45 of 2006 before the Gauhati High Court. The matter was listed several times; when called on 21 January 2015, counsel for the appellants was absent and no adjournment request was made. The High Court decided the appeal on merits and dismissed it.

The defendants thereafter approached the Supreme Court, challenging the High Court’s course of deciding the second appeal on merits in their counsel’s absence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under Order XLI Rule 17(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, the High Court could dismiss a second appeal on merits when the appellant’s counsel was absent at the time of hearing.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • The High Court lacked authority to dispose of the appeal on merits in the absence of their counsel, as expressly prohibited by Order XLI Rule 17(1) CPC read with its Explanation.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The respondents supported the High Court’s judgment and urged its affirmation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Abdur Rahman v. Athifa Begum, (1996) 6 SCC 62 An appellate court cannot examine the merits of an appeal when the appellant is unrepresented at the hearing. Relied upon to underline that the High Court’s action in deciding the appeal on merits contravened settled law.
Ghanshyam Dass Gupta v. Makhan Lal, (2012) 8 SCC 745 Explanation to Order XLI Rule 17(1) CPC explicitly bars dismissal of an appeal on merits in the appellant’s absence. Cited to reinforce that legislative clarification introduced in 1976 leaves no discretion to decide on merits when the appellant is absent.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. The Court reproduced Order XLI Rule 17(1) CPC and its Explanation, emphasizing that while an appeal may be dismissed for default when the appellant is absent, the rule expressly forbids dismissal on merits.

2. The Explanation, inserted by the 1976 amendment, was designed to resolve conflicting High Court views and ensure an absent appellant is not denied an opportunity to be heard on merits.

3. Precedent from Abdur Rahman and Ghanshyam Dass Gupta reinforces this statutory mandate.

4. On the facts, the High Court noted prior adjournments but, upon the counsel’s absence on 21 January 2015, proceeded to decide the appeal on merits, which the Supreme Court found “clearly in contravention” of Order XLI Rule 17(1).

5. Consequently, the Supreme Court concluded that the High Court acted without jurisdiction in adjudicating the merits and that the judgment could not stand.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Supreme Court set aside the Gauhati High Court’s judgment and decree and remitted Second Appeal No. 45 of 2006 to the High Court for fresh disposal in accordance with law; the appeal before the Supreme Court was accordingly disposed of with no order as to costs.

Implications: The decision reaffirms the statutory bar against deciding an appeal on merits when the appellant is unrepresented, ensuring litigants retain the opportunity to be heard. It does not create new precedent but reinforces the mandatory nature of Order XLI Rule 17(1) CPC.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Prabodh Ch. Das And Another v. Mahamaya Das And Others

    S. Abdul Nazeer, J.:— Leave granted.

    2. The question for consideration in this appeal is whether the High Court is justified in dismissing the second appeal on merits in the absence of the learned counsel for the appellants.

    3. The appellants herein are the defendants in the suit T.S. 10 of 2000 on the file of the Civil Judge (Junior Division) Khowai and the respondents are the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs filed the said suit for a declaration of their title, recovery of possession and for mesne profits. The Trial Court dismissed the suit on 19.08.2002. Feeling aggrieved, the plaintiffs filed an Appeal No. 2 of 2003 before the Additional District Judge, West Tripura, Khowai. The District Judge allowed the appeal on 30.06.2006. The judgment and decree of the Trial Court was set aside and the plaintiffs were declared as owners of the suit land. Further, it was held that the plaintiffs are also entitled for recovery of possession of the suit property. This judgment of the First Appellate Court has been challenged by the defendants before the Guwahati High Court in R.S.A No. 45 of 2006.

    4. It is evident from the materials on record that the appeal was listed for hearing several times. When the matter was taken up for hearing on 21.01.2015, learned counsel for the appellants/defendants was not present to argue the matter and no request was made on his behalf. Therefore, the High Court proceeded to decide the appeal on merits itself. After consideration of the materials on record, the High Court dismissed the appeal on merits.

    5. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties.

    6. The only contention raised by the learned counsel for the appellants is that the High Court was not justified in dismissing the appeal on merits in the absence of the learned counsel for the appellants. In support of his contention, learned counsel has pressed into service the provisions of Order XLI Rule 17(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (‘CPC’ for short). On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents has supported the judgment of the High Court.

    7. It is not disputed that the matter was listed for hearing on 21.01.2015 on which date learned counsel for the appellants was not present in the Court to argue the matter and no request was made on his behalf. Therefore, the High Court proceeded to decide the appeal on merits itself.

    8. Order 41 Rule 17(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure is as under:

    “R.17. Dismissal of appeal for appellant's default.-(1) Where on the day fixed, or on any other day to which the hearing may be adjourned, the appellant does not appear when the appeal is called on for hearing, the Court may make an order that the appeal be dismissed.

    Ins. by CPC (Amendment) Act 104 of 1976, (w.e.f. 1-2-1977)[Explanation.- Nothing in this sub-rule shall be construed as empowering the Court to dismiss the appeal on the merits.]”

    9. Explanation to sub-rule (1) of Rule 17 was added by Act 104 of 1976. Prior to 1976 conflicting views were expressed by different High Courts in the country as to the purport and meaning of sub-rule (1) of Rule 17 of Order 41 of CPC. Therefore, the explanation was introduced w.e.f 01.02.1977, to clarify the law by making an express provision that where the appellant does not appear, the Court has no power to dismiss the appeal on merits. Thus, Order 41 Rule 17(1) read with its explanation makes it explicit that the Court cannot dismiss the appeal on merits where the appellant remains absent on the date fixed for hearing. In other words, if the appellant does not appear, the Court may if it deems fit dismiss the appeal for default of appearance but it does not have the power to dismiss the appeal on merits.

    10. This position has been clarified by this Court in Abdur Rahman v. Athifa Begum, (1996) 6 SCC 62 wherein it was held that High Court cannot go into the merits of the case when there was non-appearance of the appellant. In Ghanshyam Dass Gupta v. Makhan Lal., (2012) 8 SCC 745 this Court has reiterated the legal position as under:

    “Prior to 1976, conflicting views were expressed by the different High Courts in the country as to the purport and meaning of sub-rule (1) of Rule 17 of Order 41 CPC. Some High Courts had taken the view that it was open to the appellate court to consider the appeal on merits, even though there was no appearance on behalf of the appellant at the time of hearing. Some High Courts had taken the view that the High Court cannot decide the matter on merits, but could only dismiss the appeal for the appellant's default. Conflicting views raised by the various High Courts gave rise to more litigation. The legislature, therefore, in its wisdom, felt that it should clarify the position beyond doubt. Consequently, the Explanation to sub-rule (1) of Rule 17 of Order 41 CPC was added by Act 104 of 1976, making it explicit that nothing in sub-rule (1) of Rule 17 of Order 41 CPC should be construed as empowering the appellate court to dismiss the appeal on merits where the appellant remained absent or left unrepresented on the day fixed for hearing the appeal. The reason for introduction of such an Explanation is due to the fact that it gives an opportunity to the appellant to convince the appellate court that there was sufficient cause for non-appearance. Such an opportunity is lost, if the courts decide the appeal on merits in absence of the counsel for the appellant.”

    11. Coming to the facts of the present case, the Court has decided the appeal on merits after noticing “…. On this date a request for adjournment was made on behalf of Mr. Lodh when the matter was adjourned to 18.12.2014 and on 18.12.2014 Mr. Choudhury made a request for adjournment. Today Mr. Choudhury is not even present to argue the matter and no request has been made on his behalf. I, therefore, proceed to decide the appeal on merits itself.” This order has been made clearly in contravention of Rule 17(1) of Order XLI of the CPC.

    12. Therefore, we set aside the impugned judgment and decree of the High Court and remit the matter to the High Court for fresh disposal in accordance with law. Appeal is disposed of accordingly. However, there will be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Prabodh Ch. Das And Another v. Mahamaya Das And Others
    (Dec 13, 2019)