Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub-rule (2) of Rule 1 of Order 23 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • Order XXIII Sub-Rule (3) of Rule 1 CPC.8.
  • Order 23 Rule 1 of the CPC
  • Order 23 Rule 1
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub-rule (2) of Rule 1 of Order 23 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • Order XXIII Sub-Rule (3) of Rule 1 CPC.8.
  • Order 23 Rule 1 of the CPC
  • Order 23 Rule 1
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant filed a civil suit seeking partition, declaration, and permanent injunction. The trial court dismissed the suit on 8.5.2018 due to non-joinder of necessary parties and insufficient court fees. The appellant appealed, and during the pendency of the first appeal, filed an application to implead necessary parties. The first appellate court upheld the trial court's dismissal on 29.9.2019. Subsequently, the appellant filed a second appeal. During this appeal, the appellant filed an application under Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) seeking permission to withdraw the suit with liberty to file a fresh suit.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant can be permitted to withdraw the suit dismissed on grounds of formal defects such as non-joinder of necessary parties and insufficient court fees.
  2. Whether the dismissal of the suit on such formal grounds entitles the appellant to liberty to file a fresh suit.
  3. Whether the precedent allowing withdrawal of suits with liberty to file afresh applies to suits for partition of ancestral property.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The suit was dismissed on formal defects (non-joinder of necessary parties and insufficient court fees), not on merit.
  • The suit property is ancestral property, and the appellant seeks liberty to withdraw and file a fresh suit.
  • Relied on the precedent of Kunwar Bai wd/o Ram Prasad Keer v. Gangaram s/o Baliram Keer (C.R. No. 259/2012) supporting withdrawal with liberty to refile.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The matter has been decided on merit by both lower courts.
  • Liberty to withdraw and file a fresh suit should not be granted.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mst. Chhabili Dullaiya v. Lallu, 1965 M.P.L.J. Note 99 Order 23 Rule 1(2) CPC: Formal defects (such as non-joinder of necessary parties) justify allowing withdrawal of suit with liberty to file afresh. The Court applied this principle to hold that non-joinder of necessary parties in a partition suit is a formal defect warranting withdrawal with liberty to refile.
Ramrao Bhagwantrao v. Babu Appanna, 1939 SCC OnLine Bom 57 Definition of 'formal defect' includes mis-joinder or non-joinder of parties. Supported the broad and liberal interpretation of formal defects under Order 23 Rule 1 CPC.
R. Watson and Co. v. Collector of Zillah Rajshahye, 1869 SCC OnLine PC 30 Non-joinder of necessary parties as a formal defect causing suit to fail. Reinforced the principle that failure to join necessary parties is a formal defect allowing withdrawal.
Asian Assurance Co. v. Madholal, AIR 1950 Bom. 378 Non-joinder of parties as a formal defect under Order 23 Rule 1 CPC. Confirmed that suits failing due to non-joinder qualify for withdrawal with liberty to refile.
Vinod Kumar Gupta v. Ramadevi Shivhare, 2008 (2) M.P.L.J. 151 Distinguished on facts: suit not for partition but based on adverse possession. The Court held this precedent inapplicable to the present partition suit scenario.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the nature of the dismissal of the suit, noting it was based on formal defects—specifically, non-joinder of necessary parties and insufficient court fees—rather than merits. The Court referred to established precedents that interpret non-joinder as a formal defect under Order 23 Rule 1 CPC, which permits withdrawal of a suit with liberty to file afresh. The Court emphasized the wide and liberal meaning of ‘formal defect’ and underscored that in partition suits involving joint family property, all interested parties are necessary. The Court distinguished the cited precedent in Vinod Kumar Gupta v. Ramadevi Shivhare, noting that it did not concern a partition suit and thus was not applicable. Applying these principles, the Court found it appropriate to allow the appellant to withdraw the suit with liberty to file a fresh suit to address the formal defects.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the application under Order 23 Rule 1 CPC, permitting the appellant to withdraw the suit with liberty to file a fresh suit.

The direct consequence is that the appellant may initiate a fresh suit addressing the formal defects identified earlier. No order as to costs was made. The Court did not establish any new legal precedent but reaffirmed the settled principle that suits dismissed on formal defects such as non-joinder of necessary parties qualify for withdrawal with liberty to refile.

    Krishnagopal Saxena v. Purushottam Lal Saxena .

    Vandana Kasrekar, J.:— Heard the learned counsel for the parties on I.A. No. 227/2019, which is an application under Order 23 Rule 1 read with 151 of the C.P.C.

    2. The appellant has filed a civil suit for partition, declaration as well as permanent injunction. The said civil suit was dismissed by the trial Court by judgment and decree dated 8.5.2018 on the ground of non-joinder of necessary parties as well as in-sufficient court fees. Against the said judgment, the appellant has filed a first appeal and during the pendency of the first appeal, the appellant has filed an application for impleading necessary parties in the said civil suit. The first appellate court vide order dated 29.9.2019 has confirmed the order passed by the trial Court. Against which, the second appeal has been filed. During the pendency of the appeal, the appellant has filed an application under Order 23 Rule 1 of the CPC for permitting him to withdraw the suit with a liberty to file a fresh suit.

    3. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the suit was dismissed by both the courts below on the ground of formal defect and had found that the suit property is an ancestral property and therefore, he prays that, the application be allowed. He further relied on the judgment dated 24.1.2013, passed by this Court in the case of Kunwar Bai wd/o Ram Prasad Keer v. Gangaram s/o Baliram Keer (C.R. No. 259/2012).

    4. Learned counsel for the respondents opposes the prayer and submits that the matter has been decided on merit by both the courts below and therefore, liberty may not be granted to the appellant to file a fresh civil suit.

    5. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

    6. In the present case, the appellant has filed a civil suit for partition, declaration as well as permanent injunction. The said civil suit was dismissed by the trial court on the ground of non-joinder of necessary parties as well as in-sufficient court fees. That, this Court in the case of Mst. Chhabili Dullaiya v. Lallu decided on 8.12.1964 passed in Second Appeal No. 218/1965: reported in 1965 M.P.L.J. Note 99, has held as under:—

    “This is a second appeal arising out of a suit for partition filed by respondent No. 1 Lallu against the widow and daughter of one Ajuddhi Jadiya, who, is alleged, was his father's cousin. Hiralal who was his cousin (once removed) was also joined as a party defendant. It appears from the genealogy filed with the plaint that one Udho has three sons: Pragi, Mathura and Patami. Hiralal is one of the grandsons of Pragi, the other two being: Punnu and Ramprasad. Lallu belongs to the branch of Mathura. But there is another son of Mathura, named Nandi, and this Nandi has also a son, named Dipchand. Similarly, the branch Patami is represented by his son Ajuddhi, whose wife and daughter have been joined as party defendants to the suit. There is no explanation on record, even though a specific objection in this behalf was taken, why the other members of the family, who are alive, have not been joined as party defendants to this partition suit. As belonging to the branch of Udho, they all would have an interest in joint family property.

    During the course of argument, it transpires that the suit must fail by reason of the non-joinder of necessary parties to this suit for partition. The learned counsel for the respondent-plaintiff then prayed leave to withdraw his suit with liberty to bring a fresh on the same cause of action, namely, for a partition of the joint family property belonging to the joint family of which Lallu, Hiralal and Ajuddhi, amongst others, are members.

    3. Under sub-rule (2) of Rule 1 of Order 23 of the Code of Civil Procedure, where the Court is satisfied that a suit must fail by reason of some formal defect, it may, on such terms as it thinks fit, grant the plaintiff permission to withdraw from such suit with liberty to institute a fresh suit in respect of the subject-matter of such suit. The expression ‘formal defect’ must be given a wide and liberal meaning:

    See Ramrao Bhagwantrao v. Babu Appanna, 1939 SCC OnLine Bom 57 : I.L.R. 1940 Bom. 299 (F.B.); and it is settled law that a mis-joinder or a non-joinder of parties is a formal defect within the meaning of this rule, if by reason of such mis-joinder or non-joinder, the suit must fail:

    See R. Watson and Co. v. Collector of Zillah Rajshahye, 1869 SCC OnLine PC 30 : 13 Moo Ind. App. 160 (170) and Asian Assurance Co. v. Madholal, 1950 SCC OnLine Bom 22 : AIR 1950 Bom. 378. In the instant case, this being a suit for partition of joint family property, all persons interested in that property were necessary parties to the suit and in their absence the suit was bound to fail. Consequently, their non-joinder was a formal defect by reason of which the suit was bound to fail.

    4. In the result, in my opinion, this is a fit case in which the plaintiff can be allowed to withdraw the suit with liberty to institute a fresh suit in respect of the subject-matter covered by it.

    5. Necessary permission is, therefore, granted to the plaintiff. There shall be no order as to costs.

    7. That case was also a suit for partition and the plaintiff of that suit, prayed for withdrawal of the suit with a liberty to bring a fresh suit for partition. This Court in the said decision held that the expression ‘formal defect’ must be given a wide liberal meaning and it was further held that the mis-joinder or non-joinder of the parties is a formal defect within the meaning of Order XXIII Sub-Rule (3) of Rule 1 CPC.

    8. Learned counsel for the respondents has relied on the judgment passed by this Court in the case of Vinod Kumar Gupta v. Ramadevi Shivhare: reported in 2008 (2) M.P.L.J. 151. However, this judgment would not be applicable in the present case, as the suit in the case of Vinod Gupta was not for a partition and it was preferred on the ground of adverse possession and the cause of action for seeking partition of joint property is a recurring cause of action, therefore, there is no bar in filing an application to withdraw the suit with liberty to file afresh.

    9. In the light of the aforesaid, I allow the application (I.A. No. 227/2019) and also set aside the impugned order passed by the trial Court. The appellant is permitted to withdraw the suit with liberty to file a fresh suit, in accordance with rule.

    10. With the aforesaid, the present appeal stands disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Krishnagopal Saxena v. Purushottam Lal Saxena .
    (Jul 5, 2019)