1. Heard on admission.
2. The petitioner is holder of D-1 licence under M.P. Distillery Rules, 1995, and is engaged in the business of manufacturing the spirit.
3. The grievance raised by the petitioner is against non consideration for grant of CS-1 license under M.P. Country Spirit Rules, 1995.
4. A licence in form CS-1 for manufacturing, bottling and wholesale supply of country spirit is granted by the Excise Commissioner after approval of State Government as per stipulation under Rule 3 of the Rules of 1995.
5. Earlier, the petitioner had approached this Court vide writ petition No. 6525/2018 challenging the validity of sub-clause (i) of Clause 2 of the notification dated 03.02.2018 inviting tenders for supply of country spirit in sealed bottles in 51 districts of M.P. (The impugned clause stipulated that the tenderer must be licencee for manufacturing, bottling and wholesale supply of country spirit in the State of Madhya Pradesh.) The validity was upheld as the State Government was found competent to incorporate the said condition. As the petitioner was not possessing CS-1 license, he was not eligible to participate. In said writ petition i.e. W. P. No. 6525/2018, one of the grounds for challenge was that unless an area is allotted, the person cannot hold CS-1 licence. These contentions were negatived as the petitioner could not substantiate the same on the anvil of the stipulations contained in Section 18 of the Excise Act and the Country Spirit Rules, 1995. The petitioner misconstruing the observation to be a stipulation that irrespective of non grant of area, a person is entitled for the CS-1 licence filed an application for the grant of said licence which being turned down on the ground that petitioner was not participant in the tender process for the year 2018-19 has no right for grant of CS-1 licence, vide communication dated 26/7/2018. The impugned communication when is tested on the anvil of Rule 3 (1) of the M.P. Country Spirit Rules, 1995 which empowers the Excise Commissioner after approval by the State Government to grant licence in form CS-1 for manufacture, bottling and wholesale supply of country spirit for such area or areas as may be determined by him. Thus an area is an imperative pre-condition for CS-1 licence. However, it will not create a right in the Distillers like the petitioner to have an area as a matter of right.
6. In view whereof, the impugned communication cannot be faulted with nor the prayer for deleting clause 2 (i) of the tender notice dated 03.02.2018 can be acceded as its validity is already upheld in W.P. No. 6525/2018.
7. Contention that the fundamental right guaranteed under Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution is jeopardized is taken note of and rejected outright as it is well settled that trade in liquor is not a fundamental right. It is an exclusive privilege which is granted by the State. In this context, reference may be had of the decision in Nashirwar v. State of Madhya Pradesh, (1975) 1 SCC 29 : AIR 1975 SC 360. The Supreme Court held as under:—
“35. Trade in liquor has historically stood on a different footing from other trades. Restrictions which are not permissible in other trades are lawful and reasonable so far as the trade in liquor is concerned. That is why even prohibition of the trade in liquor is not only permissible but is also reasonable. The reasons are publicmorality, public interest and harmful and dangerous character of the liquor. The State possesses the right of complete control over all aspects of intoxicants, viz., manufacture, collection, sale and consumption. The State has exclusive right to manufacture and sell liquor and to sell the said right in order to raise revenue. That is the view of this Court in Bharucha's case, 1954 SCR 873 = (AIR 1954 SC 220) (supra) and Jaiswal's case, (1972) 3 SCR 784 = ((1972) 2 SCC 36 : AIR 1972 SC 1816 : 1972 Tax LR 2298) (supra). The nature of the trade is such that the State confers the right to vend liquor by farming out either in auction or on private treaty. Rental is the consideration for the privilege granted by the Government for manufacturing or vending liquor. Rental is neither a tax nor an excise duty. Rental is the consideration for the agreement for grant of privilege by the Government.”
8. In another Judgment reported as State of Punjab v. Devans Modern Breweries Ltd., (2004) 11 SCC 26, the Supreme Court has held as under:—
“45. A large number of decisions, as noticed hereinbefore, have been cited at the Bar for the proposition that by reason of grant of licence, the licensee is merely granted a permissive privilege subject to the degree of regulatory control as may be deemed necessary and appropriate having regard to the fact that nobody has any constitutional right to trade in liquor in view of its inherently pernicious and noxious nature. I may deal with some of the decisions cited at the Bar a little later but the principles which emerge from the various decisions of this Court and particularly by Constitution Benches of this Court are:
(i) Trade in liquor is against public morality and thus res extra commercium. No citizen has any fundamental right to carry on business in liquor. (See State of Bombay v. R.M.D. Chamarbaugwala, AIR 1957 SC 699) As there does not exist any right to carry on trade, Article 301 shall not apply.
(ii) Right to trade in liquor is a fundamental right within the meaning of Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution subject, of course, to the reasonable restrictions in terms of clause (6) of Article 19. (See Krishan Kumar v. State Of J.&K. ., AIR 1967 SC 1368)
(iii) Right of the State to deal exclusively in liquor is its own privilege. It does not matter as to whether such right is restricted while parting with privilege by reason of a statute in terms of Article 19(6) of the Constitution.
(iv)(a) The equality clause even in the matter of carrying on trade is not available. The right of the State to part with its privilege being a superior right, the inferior right of a citizen to carry on trade, shall give way to the State's superior right.
(b) The State while carrying on any trade or business itself cannot make any discrimination and its acts must be fair and reasonable. (See State of M.P. v. Nandlal Jaiswal, (1986) 4 SCC 566)
(v) The State's right is absolute when a complete prohibition is imposed and at that stage the State can part with its exclusive privilege in any manner it likes and it is also entitled to take any measures for having the best price. (See Har Shankar v. Dy. Excise & Taxation Commr., (1975) 1 SCC 737: (1975) 1 SCC 737 : AIR 1975 SC 1121)
46. In Khoday Distilleries Ltd. v. State Of Karnataka, (1995) 1 SCC 574 at SCC pp. 608-09, a Constitution Bench referred to some of the decisions as referred to hereinbefore and summed up its findings [paras 60(a), (b), (e), (f) & (g)]:
“60. (a) The rights protected by Article 19(1) are not absolute but qualified. The qualifications are stated in clauses (2) to (6) of Article 19. The fundamental rights guaranteed in Articles 19(1)(a) to (g) are, therefore, to be read along with the said qualifications. Even the rights guaranteed under the Constitutions of the other civilised countries are not absolute but are read subject to the implied limitations on them. Those implied limitations are made explicit by clauses (2) to (6) of Article 19 of our Constitution.
(b) The right to practise any profession or to carry on any occupation, trade or business does not extend to practising a profession or carrying on an occupation, trade or business which is inherently vicious and pernicious, and is condemned by all civilised societies. It does not entitle citizens to carry on trade or business in activities which are immoral and criminal and in articles or goods which are obnoxious and injurious to health, safety and welfare of the general public i.e. res extra commercium (outside commerce). There cannot be business in crime.
(e) For the same reason, the State can create a monopoly either in itself or in the agency created by it for the manufacture, possession, sale and distribution of the liquor as a beverage and also sell the licences to the citizens for the said purpose by charging fees. This can be done under Article 19(6) or even otherwise.
(f) For the same reason, again, the State can impose limitations and restrictions on the trade or business in potable liquor as a beverage which restrictions are in nature different from those imposed on the trade or business in legitimate activities and goods and articles which are res commercium. The restrictions and limitations on the trade or business in potable liquor can again be both under Article 19(6) or otherwise. The restrictions and limitations can extend to the State carrying on the trade or business itself to the exclusion of and elimination of others and/or to preserving to itself the right to sell licences to do trade or business in the same, to others.
(g) When the State permits trade or business in the potable liquor with or without limitation, the citizen has the right to carry on trade or business subject to the limitations, if any, and the State cannot make discrimination between the citizens who are qualified to carry on the trade or business.”
9. In view whereof, as no relief can be granted to the petitioner, petition fails and is dismissed. No costs.