Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order 13, Rule 10 read with section 151, Civil Procedure Code, Order 7, Rule 14(3) read with section 151, Civil Procedure Code
  • Order 7, Rule 14(3), Civil Procedure Code and Order 13, Rule 10, Civil Procedure Code,
  • provisions contained in Order 7, Rule 14(1) or Order 7, Rule 14(2),
  • Order 13, Rule 10 read with section 151, Civil Procedure Code.
  • Order 1, Rule 10 read with section 151, Civil Procedure Code
  • provisions of Order 1, Rule 10(2), Civil Procedure Code
  • provisions of Order 7, Rule 14(2), Civil Procedure Code.
  • provisions of Order 7, Rule 14(3), Civil Procedure Code.
  • SECTION 11 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • ORDER 13 RULE 10 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Order 7, Rule 14(3), Civil Procedure Code
  • Order 1, Rule 10 read with section 151
  • ORDER 1 RULE 10 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • SECTION 151 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order 13, Rule 10 read with section 151, Civil Procedure Code, Order 7, Rule 14(3) read with section 151, Civil Procedure Code
  • Order 7, Rule 14(3), Civil Procedure Code and Order 13, Rule 10, Civil Procedure Code,
  • provisions contained in Order 7, Rule 14(1) or Order 7, Rule 14(2),
  • Order 13, Rule 10 read with section 151, Civil Procedure Code.
  • Order 1, Rule 10 read with section 151, Civil Procedure Code
  • provisions of Order 1, Rule 10(2), Civil Procedure Code
  • provisions of Order 7, Rule 14(2), Civil Procedure Code.
  • provisions of Order 7, Rule 14(3), Civil Procedure Code.
  • SECTION 11 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • ORDER 13 RULE 10 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Order 7, Rule 14(3), Civil Procedure Code
  • Order 1, Rule 10 read with section 151
  • ORDER 1 RULE 10 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • SECTION 151 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed a writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India challenging the order dated 24-11-2015 passed by the Vth Additional District Judge, Gwalior, in Civil Suit No. 67A/14. The impugned order dismissed three applications filed by the plaintiff: two applications made under Order 13, Rule 10 read with Section 151 and Order 7, Rule 14(3) read with Section 151 of the Civil Procedure Code, and one application under Order 1, Rule 10 read with Section 151 CPC.

The applications before the trial court were, in substance:

  • An application under Order 7, Rule 14(3) CPC to take certain documents on record (some of which were alleged to be illegible).
  • An application under Order 13, Rule 10 CPC to summon revenue records (mutation/case records) from the Revenue Authorities (including mutation case No. 668/69-70/A-6 and related records).
  • An application under Order 1, Rule 10 CPC to implead Piyush Thapak, alleged beneficiary of the will of Thakurdas (a deceased purchaser), as a party to the suit.

The trial court rejected these applications for reasons including illegibility of the documents, the absence of a Will of Thakurdas on record, and the proposition that survey/mutation entries do not themselves create title. The trial court also recorded that, on the question of title, the suit land had been declared to belong to defendant No. 1 (Gwalior Dairy Ltd.) in proceedings taken up to the Supreme Court.

The High Court, in this writ petition, examined those rejections and reached a partly favourable result for the petitioner: it set aside the trial court's rejection insofar as the Order 1, Rule 10 application to implead Piyush Thapak was concerned, but it did not interfere with the trial court's refusal to admit illegible documents under Order 7, Rule 14(3) and its refusal to call certain revenue records under Order 13, Rule 10.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court erred in rejecting the application under Order 1, Rule 10 CPC to implead Piyush Thapak (legal heir/beneficiary) as a necessary party.
  2. Whether the trial court properly refused leave under Order 7, Rule 14(3) CPC to admit certain documents which the plaintiff had tendered but which were allegedly illegible and not listed under the provisions of Order 7, Rule 14(1) or (2).
  3. Whether the trial court rightly refused to exercise its discretion under Order 13, Rule 10 CPC to call for Revenue records (mutation case records), given that the title to the suit land had been declared in favour of defendant No. 1 up to the Supreme Court.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (Plaintiff's) Arguments

  • The trial court dismissed the three applications in a casual manner without properly appreciating the facts.
  • Because certain documents were illegible, the plaintiff filed an application under Order 13, Rule 10 CPC to call original records from Revenue Authorities and filed certified copies under Order 7, Rule 14(3) CPC.
  • Plaintiff contended it was necessary to implead Piyush Thapak (beneficiary of the Will of Thakurdas) as a party because Thakurdas died during the proceedings and Piyush Thapak inherited his estate.
  • Plaintiff asserted a stakeholder interest in the matter (being a shareholder of defendant No.1/Gwalior Dairy Ltd.), implying entitlement to pursue the applications seeking documents/records and proper parties.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Respondents pointed out that an earlier application under Section 151 CPC for impleading Piyush Thapak had been rejected, so a subsequent application under Order 1, Rule 10 read with Section 151 CPC was unjustified.
  • They contended that the second application was barred by Section 11 CPC (res judicata) because the earlier rejection precluded reconsideration of the same issue in the same suit.

Trial Court's Findings (as recited in the opinion)

  • The application to implead Piyush Thapak was rejected because no Will of Thakurdas was produced on record and the prayer appeared to be based on survey/mutation entries, which the trial court held do not create title.
  • The leave to admit certain documents under Order 7, Rule 14(3) CPC was refused because those documents were not legible and the plaintiff had not satisfactorily explained why legible copies were not produced or why they were not listed under Order 7, Rule 14(1) or (2).
  • The application under Order 13, Rule 10 CPC to call revenue records was dismissed because the trial court recorded that title in favour of defendant No. 1 had already been upheld up to the Supreme Court, and therefore no justification was shown for calling the Naib Tehsildar records.

Table of Precedents Cited

The opinion refers to prior adjudications concerning the title to the suit land that were taken up to higher courts. The following decisions are mentioned in the text and were applied factually by the court in its analysis.

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
High Court decision in Case No. 560/88 (order dated 12-5-1988) Establishment of title — decision that the suit land belonged to defendant No. 1 (Gwalior Dairy Ltd.) The court recorded that this High Court dismissal supported the conclusion that title had already been decided against the plaintiff; used as a factual basis to deny the need to call revenue record under Order 13, Rule 10 CPC.
Supreme Court dismissal of SLP No. 16052/88 Final adjudication on title — confirmation (by dismissal) of the earlier High Court decision The court relied on the fact that the Supreme Court had dismissed the SLP, reinforcing that the title of the land in favour of defendant No. 1 had been established up to the highest court; this weighed against calling Revenue records as unnecessary.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court addressed each category of application by reference to the relevant procedural provisions and the factual record as found by the trial court:

  1. Order 1, Rule 10 CPC (impleading a party): The court emphasized the scope of Order 1, Rule 10(2) CPC — at the stage of considering an application to add a party the court must determine whether a person's presence is necessary to enable the court to effectually and completely adjudicate all questions in the suit. The court observed that the question of whether title stood vested in Piyush Thapak was a substantive issue for adjudication on evidence at the trial stage and not a matter to be decided at the joinder stage. Because impleading concerns whether a person ought to be joined for complete adjudication, the court found that the application to implead Piyush Thapak deserved allowance and set aside the trial court's rejection of that application.
  2. Order 7, Rule 14(3) CPC (admission of documents when originals/copies are tendered): The court treated the Rule as conferring a discretionary but essential gatekeeping function. It held that Order 7, Rule 14(3) is not a hollow formality and that the trial court was entitled to refuse leave to admit documents that were illegible where the plaintiff had not explained why legible copies could not be produced or why the documents were not listed under Order 7, Rule 14(1) or (2). The court concluded that the trial court properly exercised discretion in refusing to admit illegible documents because the plaintiff failed to discharge the burden of justification.
  3. Order 13, Rule 10 CPC (calling for papers from other courts/records): The court restated that Order 13, Rule 10 vests discretionary power to send for papers and that a person seeking such relief must show by affidavit how the record is material to the suit. Here the trial court had recorded that title to the land had been conclusively declared in favour of defendant No. 1 by decisions up to the Supreme Court. Given that factual backdrop, the petitioner could not show that the revenue records were material in a manner that justified calling them. Consequently, the court found no fault in the trial court rejecting the application under Order 13, Rule 10 read with Section 151 CPC.

The court therefore proceeded on the basis that joinder under Order 1, Rule 10 focuses on the necessity for complete adjudication rather than on merits of title, whereas Orders 7 and 13 involve discretionary, procedural thresholds requiring adequate justification and proper compliance with formal requirements.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Petition partly allowed.

Direct effects on the parties:

  • The application under Order 1, Rule 10 CPC to implead Piyush Thapak as the legal heir of Thakurdas is allowed; the trial court's order rejecting that application is set aside and the necessary party may be impleaded in the suit in place of Thakurdas.
  • The trial court's rejections of the other two applications — the leave under Order 7, Rule 14(3) CPC to admit certain illegible documents, and the application under Order 13, Rule 10 CPC to call Revenue records — are upheld; the High Court found no interference with those rulings was warranted.

Broader implications:

The opinion does not announce a new broader legal principle beyond its application of settled procedural rules: it reinforces that (a) Order 1, Rule 10 CPC is concerned with necessary joinder for complete adjudication and does not require pre-adjudication of substantive title questions; (b) Order 7, Rule 14(3) CPC admission of documents is discretionary and contingent on compliance and adequate explanation for legibility/production; and (c) Order 13, Rule 10 CPC requires a showing that the called-for record is material, especially where title has previously been adjudicated up to higher courts. The decision thus affects only the parties before the court and does not purport to create a new precedent beyond applying these procedural principles.

Petition partly allowed.

    Ashok Choudhary v. Gwalior Dairy Ltd. And Others

    Petitioner has filed this writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India being aggrieved by the order dated 24-11-2015 passed by Vth Additional District Judge Gwalior in Civil Suit No. 67A/14 whereby, three applications filed by the plaintiff under the provisions of Order 13, Rule 10 read with section 151, Civil Procedure Code, Order 7, Rule 14(3) read with section 151, Civil Procedure Code and one under Order 1, Rule 10 read with section 151, Civil Procedure Code have been rejected.

    2. It is petitioner's contention that the first application under Order 7, Rule 14(3), Civil Procedure Code was filed for taking certain documents on record. Since, those documents were not legible, therefore, another application under Order 13, Rule 10, Civil Procedure Code was filed to summon records of such cases from the Revenue Authorities, certified copies of which were filed by the plaintiff under the provisions of Order 7, Rule 14(3), Civil Procedure Code. It is also submitted that plaintiff had filed an application under Order 1, Rule 10, Civil Procedure Code to implead the beneficiary of the will of Thakurdas s/o Manpal Choudhary namely Piyush Thapak s/o Kailash Narayan as a party.

    3. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that these three applications have been dismissed by the trial Court in a very casual manner without appreciating the facts in the correct perspective and also without taking cognizance of the fact that petitioner/plaintiff is the share holder of defendant No. 1/Gwalior Dairy Ltd. and once the documents were not readable, then application under Order 13, Rule 10 read with section 151, Civil Procedure Code was filed to call the original record and therefore these applications should have been allowed. It is also submitted that since defendant No. 3 Thakur Das was one of the purchasers of the disputed land and he died during the pendency of the proceedings, therefore, it was necessary to bring his legal heir Piyush Thapak on record as Piyush Thapak had inherited estate of said Thakur Das.

    4. As far as the application under Order 1, Rule 10, Civil Procedure Code is concerned, the trial Court has recorded a finding that the plaintiff had earlier filed an application which was dismissed by the Court on the ground that no Will of Thakurdas was produced on record. The trial Court has held that this prayer has been made to implead Piyush Thapak as a party on the basis of certain surveys which have been filed on record, but it is settled principle of law that such survey entries do not create any right and therefore on the basis of survey entries whereby name of Piyush Thapak was mutated in relation to certain properties, he cannot be directed to be impleaded as a party and therefore application under Order 1, Rule 10, Civil Procedure Code has been rejected.

    5. Learned counsel for the respondents on the other hand submits that since earlier application under section 151, Civil Procedure Code for impleading said Piyush Thapak was rejected, therefore, there was no justification for moving another application under Order 1, Rule 10 read with section 151 and such second application was hit by provisions of section 11 of Civil Procedure Code inasmuch as the principle of res judicata will be applicable between the two proceedings in the same suit.

    6. As far as this objection of learned counsel for the respondents is concerned, this objection was not taken before the trial Court and trial Court has merely rejected this application on two counts namely Will was not produced on record and secondly the survey entries which reflect mutation of name of Piyush Thapak cannot be treated to have created any title in favour of such Piyush Thapak.

    7. As far as these two aspects are concerned, this Court is of the opinion that at the stage of an application under Order 1, Rule 10, Civil Procedure Code the Court is only required to see that name of any person who ought to have been joined whether as plaintiff or defendant or whose presence before the Court may be necessary in order to enable the Court to effectually and completely adjudicate upon and settle all the questions involved in the suit be added. Thus, the provisions of Order 1, Rule 10(2), Civil Procedure Code can be resorted to even without application of either party. Thus the issue of vesting of the title in favour of such Piyush Thapak is an issue to be decided on adjudication of the case and appreciation of the evidence which was not the stage while considering application under Order 1, Rule 10, Civil Procedure Code. Therefore, this application deserves to be allowed and is allowed and to this extent order of the trial Court is set aside.

    8. As far as application under Order 7, Rule 14(3), Civil Procedure Code is concerned, same has been partially rejected in respect of those documents which was not readable namely certified copies of the statements of Chandrakant, Suresh, Anand and Prakash. Similarly application which was filed for mutation and certified copy of Khasra panchshala. It was always open to the petitioner to have obtained readable copies of the documents and to produce them before the trial Court. Since the plaintiff has failed to discharge this burden and this Court has already held that provisions under Order 7, Rule 14(3), Civil Procedure Code is not a hollow formality but the rule of the Court is essential, therefore, the Court was very much within its right to exercise his discretion in refusing such leave on the ground that such documents were not readable. No explanation has been given as to why legible copies could not be produced and what prevented the plaintiff from filing it earlier at the time of filing of this suit and why such documents were not mentioned in the list to be produced under the provisions of Order 7, Rule 14(2), Civil Procedure Code. Therefore, in absence of such documents being entered into in terms of the provisions contained in Order 7, Rule 14(1) or Order 7, Rule 14(2), the Court was required to exercise its jurisdiction and discretion while granting leave. This Court is of the opinion that leave could not have been granted for admitting illegible documents and therefore that has been rightly discarded.

    9. As far as application under Order 13, Rule 10, Civil Procedure Code is concerned, petitioner requested the Court to call for the mutation case No. 668/69-70/A-6 in which statements of defendants No. 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 were recorded. Learned trial Court has recorded that the said case was decided by the Naib Tehsildar on 16-7-1975 and the suit land was recorded as that of the defendant No. 1/company as Bhumiswami. Thereafter the then manager of defendant No. 1 Omprakash Sharma wanted to manipulate such order and include his name in which regard case No. 01/B/121/83-84 was registered in which defendant Nos. 4 to 8 were party and finally Collector, Gwalior had passed order dated 10-11-1987 treating the land to be that of company i.e. Gwalior Dairy Ltd. Against this order, petition was filed before the High Court which was registered as case No. 560/88 which was dismissed by the High Court vide order dated 12-5-1988. Thereafter, SLP No. 16052/88 was filed which was dismissed by the Supreme Court. Thus, it is apparent that this issue that the suit land belongs to defendant No. 1/Gwalior Dairy Ltd has already been decided up to the level of Supreme Court. Therefore, in the light of this fact that land has been declared to be that of defendant No. 1 up to the Supreme Court, no justification was shown by the plaintiff to call for the Revenue record from the Court of Naib Tehsildar and accordingly the said application was dismissed as no justification could be furnished for calling of such record.

    10. Order 13, Rule 10, Civil Procedure Code vests the Court with discretion to send for papers from its own record or from other Courts. Such discretion has been bestowed upon the Court to do complete justice between the parties and the person making such application is required to show on affidavit that how the record is material to the suit in which the application is made. In the present case, since such justification could not be given by the plaintiff to show that the record is material to the suit specially when the trial Court has recorded a finding that the title of defendant No. 1 has been established up to the Supreme Court, there is no fault, shortcoming or imperfection in rejecting the application under Order 13, Rule 10 read with section 151, Civil Procedure Code. Thus, this petition is partly allowed. It is directed that application under Order 1, Rule 10, Civil Procedure Code is allowed and the necessary party may be impleaded in the suit in place of Thakurdas as his legal heir. Order of the trial Court in regard to other two applications; under Order 7, Rule 14(3), Civil Procedure Code and Order 13, Rule 10, Civil Procedure Code, does not call for any interference and to that extent the petition is dismissed.

    Petition partly allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ashok Choudhary v. Gwalior Dairy Ltd. And Others
    (Nov 13, 2017)